Pod Insights Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger Ask The Compound Part One About this episode I recently joined Ask The Compound with Ben Carlson and Duncan Hill to discuss reducing concentrated holdings, gold as an investment, utilizing Roth conversions, the argument for traditional contributions as opposed to Roth, and much more! Have a money question? Email us here Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE YouTube: @jillonmoney Instagram: @jillonmoney Twitter: @jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 You know, gang, I was once a small business owner and running a small business comes with plenty of challenges, but managing your numbers shouldn't be one of them. That's where Xero, that's X-E-R-O, comes in. A financial management platform designed to take the overwhelming tasks out of your daily operations. You don't need multiple tools and spreadsheets to get a clear view of your cash flow. Xero connects your accounting, payments, payroll, and analytics all in one place using automated workflows that can save you hours of busy work. Instead of getting buried in complicated details, you get intuitive visual dashboards, forecasts, and smart insights that help you make confident decisions.
0:42 Speaker 00 While most software tries to sound smart, Xero is built to make you feel smart by turning complex financial tasks into simple routines. Over 5 million customers worldwide trust it to keep their operations moving. From a 2024 survey, 91% of customers across the U.S., U.K., and Australia agreed that Xero is easy to use. Stay ahead of what's coming in, what's going out, and what's next so you can spend less time on paperwork and more time growing your business. Learn more at X E R O dot com. You know that feeling when a vehicle doesn't just show up but genuinely takes over the space around it? That's what it's like to sit behind the wheel of Range Rover Sport.
1:25 Speaker 00 It brings a pure visceral presence to the road, engineered with sleek lines, dramatic proportions, and an unmistakable attitude. But as impressive as it looks, driving it is where things get truly interesting. Advanced all-wheel steering gives this muscular machine the nimble turning circle of a small hatchback, while the dynamic air suspension reads the road ahead to keep you planted through every sharp corner. Inside, the cabin feels like a private sanctuary. You're wrapped in 22-way massage seats as natural light floods in through the panoramic glass roof, while a 29-speaker Meridian Signature Sound System uses active noise cancellation right in the headrest to block out the rest of the world.
2:08 Speaker 00 Touchscreen navigation keeps your favorite features just taps away, letting you focus entirely on the drive itself. It's dynamic, purposeful, and tailored for those who accept zero compromises on the open road. Explore the full Range Rover Sport lineup at LandRoverUSA.com.
2:31 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Jill on Money Show. It's Saturday, November 16th, and we are here trying to help you make better financial choices, or maybe at least more considered choices. And if you've got a question, or something's going on in your life, why don't you give us a holler? Go to jillonthemoney.com and click the Contact Us button. If you'd like to join us live, just check the box and Mark will do everything else. So this weekend, we're doing something fun. We're doing sort of a crossover. It's like when two different characters on different shows end up swapping places. You know, one of those kind of switcheroo situations. And the switcheroo for this weekend is that I was on Ask the Compound with Ben Carlson and Duncan Hill. Now, the Compound is that link to our YouTube show, Jill on
3:16 Speaker 00 Money Powered by the Compound. The Compound has a vast number of shows. A lot of them are more investment oriented, but Ask the Compound is sort of like our program, just with different characters. So this weekend, we're going to air my most recent visit with Ask the Compound. And you'll hear Duncan start by reading a question, and then Ben and I end up coming in. Today, we're discussing one of our favorite topics.
3:39 Speaker 01 Many finance people advocate for Roth assets with statements like "all Roth all the time." Looking at you, Jill on Money. However, isn't there also a strong case for traditional IRAs due to the standard deduction? It seems like there's a solid argument for both Roth and traditional contributions. I never hear anyone bring up the standard deduction argument. Seems like a way to get traditional dollars completely tax-free in retirement.
4:02 Speaker 02 Listen, if you ask for someone by name for this show, we will bring them out like a genie in a bottle. Bring her in here. Jill on Money is here.
4:10 Speaker 01 Hey, Jill.
4:11 Speaker 02 Are you an "all Roth all the time" kind of person, Jill?
4:13 Speaker 00 A lot, a lot I am. Because I love the certainty of knowing what my tax liability is. And, you know, I'm an Ed Slott aficionada. And I really love-
4:25 Speaker 02 Bill Sweet, that's like Bill Sweet's hero. He loved that guy.
4:28 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, he's great. And, you know, I, okay, yes, there are certain cases where it can work out. But I love the certainty of knowing what my tax liability is.
4:39 Speaker 00 And that's really the issue. And by the way, tax rates are so low right now, the certainty of paying the tax today versus what I think could be rising tax rates in the future makes me say, okay, I'm going to amend it for our, for our listener, for our viewer. And that is all Roth, most, most, most of the time with a few little cases outside. What do you think, Ben?
5:06 Speaker 02 I do, I mean, I'm a convert to the Roth, you know, Bill Sweet has talked me into this too. I, I, we finally opened a Roth 401k at Ritholtz a couple of years ago. I of course made the change to that. I still don't understand that, like, I put Roth dollars in, but my match from the company is in traditional.
5:20 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's weird. That's kind of bizarre. Well, I can talk to management about that.
5:24 Speaker 02 I know they're, yeah, those guys. I do like the idea of some tax diversification. Cause I think for young people, I, I feel like some people, the spreadsheet warriors will ask us, well, what if I just go into traditional? And then I, I take my tax return and I save the difference and invest it. And most people aren't going to do that, right? You're, you're going to spend your tax return on something else. So you're not really going to do that. So I, I probably filled up the traditional bucket when I was younger and I've worked on filling up the Roth bucket more recently. So I like the fact that I have a little diversification.
5:53 Speaker 00 You know what, but I, but I also can say this, that, you know, I'm at the other end. I'm probably the oldest person here by, you know, two decades, at least, maybe three. And I think that a lot of the listeners to Jill on money and also a lot of my cohort, the problem we have is that we've already saved so much money pre-tax that the problem continues to compound. And the, the issue is if you've got, you know, if you're 38 years old and you got a million dollars in traditional, that problem is only getting worse. And those required minimum distributions, they're nasty. Because that pushes you into different tax brackets than you thought. It changes your, your Medicare payments. It's just like a lot of stuff that is
6:35 Speaker 00 out of your control later in life. And I'm a control freak when it comes to my money. So that's why I think I lean Roth in so many cases.
6:43 Speaker 02 Right. Most, most people are probably like you, or they have more traditional IRA assets than they do Roth. And balancing it out with more Roth assets makes more sense.
6:51 Speaker 01 When I've heard some people talk about splitting it up for your 401k, doing some traditional, some Roth, I mean, is there? Much reason to do that?
7:00 Speaker 00 I mean, it depends. I mean, if you are, I guess that if you're really uncertain and you want to like, play both sides, I just don't see a huge downside of being mostly Roth, especially if you've, if you've got time. Because I think that the idea that money is going to grow without any taxation ever, is pretty appealing to me.
7:20 Speaker 02 All Roth, most of the time. Most, most, most of the times.
7:23 Speaker 01 That one was from Zachary, so.
7:25 Speaker 02 Next question.
7:25 Speaker 01 Um, next, we have a question that came in on Twitter, I think. Why would anyone recommend a target date fund? My 2055 underperformed the S and P 500 over the past one, five, and 10 years, and has higher expenses. What am I missing? I feel like this is very targeted to you, Ben.
7:41 Speaker 02 It is a targeted question about a target date fund. Listen, this is like going to the buffet and asking, where's my filet? Right? When you go to a buffet, you're gonna get like some decent food. It's okay. You're not gonna get the best option. Here's, throw up a chart, John. Uh, this is, this is the S and P 500 versus a Vanguard 2055 fund. And you can see the S and P over the, this is over the last five years, is, is outperforming by quite a wide margin. It's outperforming like 40%. But this fund has not only a total stock market index fund for the US, it also has international stocks, it has international bonds, and it has US bonds. It's pretty equity heavy still. I think it's like a 90-10 fund, but it's underperformed because it's more diversified. So, you could always invest in the rearview mirror and say, well,
8:25 Speaker 02 why would I invest in anything else besides the thing that did the best? But I, I think that's a little harder to do going forward than it is in the past.
8:31 Speaker 00 You know, I also think that there has to be a recognition that for some people just like, starting out with something, we want people to just start. It's like, okay, if that is the, the gateway drug to investing, then I'm okay with it. I think the bigger problem that you find is that a lot of people will have a target date fund and then have like four other funds in their retirement accounts. Like, either just start with your target date fund, or just say, all right, put in an index fund and an index bond fund and go to sleep at night. It's fine. But I think that if we're just saying, what is the, the easiest step to start, that's not the worst one.
9:08 Speaker 02 Yeah, if you want to have all your money in the US stock market, the S and P 500, I'm sure you'll be, go have at it. But I do agree that this target date fund is a wonderful step forward for people who just look at their 401k lineup and go, "Ah, I don't know what to do." And a lot of that money in the past would end up in a stable value fund. And it would never get the stock market or never get diversified exposure. So the great thing about target date funds is it's professionally managed, it rebalances automatically for you. They handle all the diversification in one spot. Like, it's a great starting point. I agree. People will poke holes in it and say, "Well, there's this problem and that problem." But it's, guess what? It's better than most of the alternatives.
9:42 Speaker 00 Right.
9:43 Speaker 02 So it could be better, yes. It also could be way, way worse.
9:45 Speaker 00 I will, I also want to just remind everybody, and I know Ben knows this, there are some plans where the target date fund is so dumb, expensive, that you, it's like a head scratcher. It's like, "You guys have to be thieves on that." Like, that's, we're just trying to get people to start. Like, that's not where you should have the thievery. Save that for your emerging market fund.
10:04 Speaker 02 And good thing, most 401k plans, if you want to do it on your own, and you still want to be diversified, there's usually a button you can click that says "rebalances formally annually, automatically." And then you do it and you take yourself into the equation, you don't need to do it. So if you want to be more diversified, you can create your own set of funds. Or if you just want to have it in one US stock market fund and you're okay with that, sure. But just know where you're getting yourself into. We're comparing apples and oranges here. It's not the same thing.
10:26 Speaker 01 Up next, we have a question about gold, which is a common one these days. What's the story with gold these days? My understanding is that in times of peril, gold is where people go. In the most perilous times of the last five years, I feel like the price of gold really didn't do anything. It wasn't the hedge that most people believe it to be. Can you thread the story of the stock market, interest rates, and gold? Is gold no longer a good hedge against market turbulence? Is Dunkin' trading levered gold futures? Make it make sense. Is there a levered gold ETF?
10:56 Speaker 02 I'm sure if it existed, it would be in your portfolio.
11:00 Speaker 01 It's possible.
11:02 Speaker 02 Good use of the word peril here. I don't use that word enough. Uh, my, my instant reaction here is markets don't always make sense. So Jill, I have a series of stock charts I want to run through and then I want to get your,
11:11 Speaker 00 Okay.
11:11 Speaker 02 take on these.
11:12 Speaker 00 Let me put my glasses on for this. Get going.
11:14 Speaker 02 So the first one John throwed up here, this just shows the one year return for stocks in the S and P 500 and gold. They're both up roughly 40%. The stock market is up 43% over the last 12 months. I updated this this morning. Gold is up 38%, call it. This is the history of gold versus the S and P 500 rolling 12 months returns going back to 1970, which is effectively when we got off like the Nixon, got off the gold standard. You can see that these things move in, they don't always move in lockstep with one another. Usually they're way out of whack with one another. And I actually had to cut this chart off because returns were so high in the seventies and eighties. The, the best 12 month return for gold since 1970 was like 180% in the, in early 1980s, late 1970s. The best 12 month return for stocks, I think is 60%.
11:58 Speaker 02 So you can see this doesn't happen very often where they're both moving up. In fact, I found one other instance in November of 1980 where both stocks and gold were up 35, 40%ish at the same time. Happened one time in, in this past 55 years or whatever. So it's, it's very rare to see what were happening, happening this year happen. So all right, one more, John. This is gold and stocks, annual returns by decade. Seventies, gold crushed the stock market. 1990s, 1980s, stock market crushed gold. Two lost decades for gold in a row. Then you had a lost decade for the stocks in the 2000s and gold did well. 2010s, gold performed poorly again, stocks do well.
12:37 Speaker 02 This decade so far, halfway through the decade-ish, we're looking at stocks and gold both up quite a bit. So both double digit annual returns. That has never happened in the past six decades. So this is, this is kind of uncharted territory here. And my whole thinking is that stuff that has never happened in the markets tends to happen all the time and kind of get used to it. But I think my big takeaway here, my like zen philosophy about investing is that sometimes the reason doesn't matter, right? Because you could say, well, gold's an inflation hedge. Sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't. Gold does well when real interest rates are low because gold doesn't pay any cash flows. But this year, real interest rates are going up and gold's going up. And so I think if you try to pigeonhole yourself into some
13:20 Speaker 02 sort of if-then framework about the market has to work like this, if this happened, that happens, the markets don't work like that.
13:26 Speaker 00 And as the former gold trader that I was, because I did get my start on the Commodities Exchange of New York and I did-
13:34 Speaker 02 So you were trading gold futures?
13:35 Speaker 00 I traded gold options, so options on the futures. I was in the gold ring.
13:40 Speaker 01 So like on Trading Places, you were down there, I think I asked you this before, but you're just open outcry, shouting?
13:45 Speaker 00 Yes, that's me. That was me. And they were like, oh, she's 5'11", she knows how to handle herself. Perfect. Not big enough to be in the crude oil pit, but big enough to be in the gold pit. And I was, again, I wasn't trading futures, I was trading the options on futures. And you know what's fascinating to me is that forever, remember, I started trading in 1987, so I wasn't even in the heyday of gold. But when I got to the COMEX, there was like that haze of like, oh, remember when? And you could see that already it was, hate for the pun, losing its luster in many respects. It was seen as the, you know, essentially not just a hedge against inflation, it was the Armageddon trade. It was the if everything
14:27 Speaker 00 goes to hell in a handbasket, you want to own gold. And my first lesson with that was in October of 1987, when the stock market crashed and, you know, everybody was really nervous and they said, oh, everyone go home long, gold. And I screwed up my calculation and I went home flat. And my boss chewed me out in front of everybody and saying, I told you to go home long, I told you to go home long. And the next morning, gold opened limit down, down 25 bucks, because there was so many margin calls in the stock market-
14:58 Speaker 02 People were selling whatever else was doing okay.
15:00 Speaker 00 Exactly.
15:01 Speaker 02 I never thought about, I never looked at what gold did in the 87 crash, so it actually fell down the next day.
15:04 Speaker 00 Yeah, it fell down the next day, limit down. And so here's what I can tell everybody about gold. I agree with you, Ben. Nobody really knows. I heard Josh articulate a view recently that I thought that kind of made sense, which is, you know, maybe it's not so much an Armageddon against market disaster, but about global insecurity. So that if you are a country and you're worried about sanctions, or you're worried about trade wars, that gold is not something that anybody can look at from the Treasury Department and say, ah, we're locking you out of your account. So there is something to be said for some sovereign nations buying gold. The other thing is, there's just a lot of money on
15:45 Speaker 00 the sidelines being thrown at ideas. And if gold is an idea, and crypto is an idea, and everybody just wants a little idea that's somewhat different, fine. As somebody who was a gold trader, what I can tell you is actively trading gold is a recipe for disaster, unless you really know what you're doing. And if you want to have some small position in gold, like 2%, 3%, go at it. I don't own any. I'm the woman who was a gold trader. I don't own any gold.
16:08 Speaker 02 But it's the kind of thing where I look at it, if you're holding it as a diversifier in your portfolio, you hold it come hell or high water.
16:14 Speaker 00 You bet.
16:15 Speaker 02 You don't try to get in and out. You hold it, you rebalance into the pain.
16:17 Speaker 00 Yep.
16:17 Speaker 02 You take some money off and it's doing well like this year. That's how it works and helps your portfolio over time. Because it is, it's a volatile asset, and you want to trade around and rebalance it. But that's the thing, is not trying to jump in and out.
16:28 Speaker 00 Yeah, I agree 100%. If you'd like to see more of our YouTube show, Jill on Money Powered by The Compound, you can just go to our website, jillonthemoney, and click through and check out all the great content that The Compound creates. If you've got a question for us, just click the Contact Us button on the website and we'll get your note. Come on the air, it's so much fun, and Mark will do all the work to get you there. You can subscribe to us on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. Please leave us a rating and review wherever you listen. As always, we ask that you try to lift someone up. Change your work, change your wealth, change your life. Thank you for listening. We'll talk to you tomorrow.
17:09 Speaker 03 Greetings from Breeze Airways, your hometown carrier for non-stop flights from Richmond to Sarasota, Bradenton, and more. Your getaway to Florida's west coast is closer than you think. Breeze makes it easy to snag a getaway with non-stop lights, flexible change policies, and a seriously nice onboard experience. Enjoy premium seating with Breeze Ascent, plus high-speed Wi-Fi and tasty snacks. Book today at flybreeze.com. Breeze Airways, seriously nice. In partnership with Visit Sarasota.
Next Ask The Compound Part Two Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated