Pod Insights Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger Am I on Track at 39 Years Old? About this episode I'm 39 years old and have been with my employer for 15 years and plan to retire with them. Am I on track for a retirement around age 59? Have a money question? Email us here Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE YouTube: @jillonmoney Instagram: @jillonmoney Twitter: @jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:03 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Jill on Money Show. It's Thursday, May 8th, and we are here helping you make better, sometimes less bad, financial decisions. If there's something going on in your life, if you're thinking about an early retirement, if you're weighing two different job offers, if you're trying to figure out how to finance your kid's education, if you are seeking to sell or buy a home, anything that touches your money, get in touch with us. Go to jillonthemoney.com, click the Contact Us button, and write us a note. And if you'd like to join us on the air live, all you need to do is check the box, and we will do everything else. When I say we, I mean Mark will. I don't do anything. On
0:45 Speaker 00 our website, all of our content is living right there. Podcasts, meaning this one and Money Watch, our second podcast, and that Money Watch podcast is really great for those of you who want to brush up on some of your fundamentals, or someone in your life who would like to learn more about the financial process and how it impacts them throughout their lives. Money Watch is our second podcast. We've got a radio show, we've got a blog, videos, resources, and of course, the free weekly newsletter, which comes out every single Friday. So, check that out. It is all at jillonthemoney.com. Okay, let's do some emails. We are starting with Dan, who has, it says SPIA. Now, Mark, you know, I
1:26 Speaker 00 have to actually do this here. So, this is a single, premium, immediate, annuity, joint life with period certain using the pension payout. Boy, that's like a lot of words, right? Period certain means the money has to come out over a certain period of time, and I don't know what the pension payout is, so I'm going to see what this is. Here we go from Dan. Hello, Jill and Mark. Since 2024, I've listened to your podcast daily while commuting, and I'm also one of your subscribers. I appreciate all the direct, even indirect advice you give to your listeners. My question is related to a pension. Okay, here we go. I have a private pension, meaning this is not some government pension.
2:09 Speaker 00 It does not have a cost of living adjustment. The fixed pension amount, $5,000 a month with a 100% spousal benefit. It starts in January 2027, or $1.1 million in a pension payout in August of 2026. The company offered a monthly pension plan, which is essentially a single premium immediate annuity for life, either with no cash refund or for a period certain. I always like period certain, gang, which means the money has to be paid out to you or whoever your beneficiary is over that period. Most of the people who retired took the pension payout and invest
2:52 Speaker 00 or bought some annuity with better options from another insurance company. I am leaning towards taking the payout and would buy a better policy with a 20-year period certain or just invest the pension payout. I'd like your thoughts on better ideas. I will be 62 years old when I retire. My wife is eight years younger than I am. We need $12,000 a month in income. I plan to take social security at 70, which would be $4,500 a month, and my wife will start at 62. That would be $2,000 a month. Okay, we have retirement assets of IRA 401K, about $2.2 million, and Roth a brokerage, which is about $800,000.
3:32 Speaker 00 I mean, you have a lot of money and you have plenty of money to basically sustain you. I think the question is how you feel about having a fixed amount of money that comes to you over that 20-year period. And I tell you what I would do. I am not the kind of person who wants an annuity product. I would take the money, I would invest it, and I would make it much simpler. That said, if that is something that is really scary to you, the other opportunity would be to go talk to somebody who is a certified financial planner, someone who's a fiduciary, someone who could really walk you through what the choices are.
4:14 Speaker 00 Because my fear is that once you get into this annuity contract, you know, it's not a ton of money, but it's enough. Thank you very much. $1.1 million. I don't know if I'd want it tied up in a product. I think I might want control over it. But if you wanted to get some help, you could certainly go to letsmakeaplan.org, or you can go to the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors, napfa.org, and someone could help you really understand the cost of doing it one way versus another. I, again, lean towards not having a annuity, because I just think that's, you know, you've lost the money once it goes in. But if you're
4:56 Speaker 00 really freaked out about this, I get it. Okay. Next is from Austin, who writes, "Super duper appreciate your show, and I've learned a lot from it. Thanks so much for your work." Okay. "I'm 30 years old. My wife is 32 years old. No kids. We live in Texas. We own a home worth $275,000. Ah, they've got a big mortgage, Mark, $258,000, 6.99%." So they must have just gotten it. Vanguard retirement accounts include Roth, $25,000. Wife's Roth, $6,000. Rollover IRA, hers, $3,000. "I have a pension through my work as a clergy person. I'm not even sure how it
5:37 Speaker 00 works or its eventual value. I assume the longer I work in my denomination, the better the payout that it will become. I've got term life of $500,000. Question, does it make sense for us to hire a financial advisor?" Hmm. I'm going to say no right now, but here's the extra piece of it. "We have a family friend who we trust, who works at a big box retirement company. If we decide to sign on with him, a 1% fee. I'm not a huge fan of that. From your show, I think your general advice is to just invest in the market, S&P 500, total stock market ETFs." That's true, and maybe even a bond ETF also. "Is that the best way to go? Is it ever worth paying
6:19 Speaker 00 somebody to get a better return?" That's the first question. The answer is, that is not. Worth it because those advisors will not get you a better return. Okay. But what they could do is give you customized financial advice. That's the only reason I would pay a fee if I were getting ongoing, real financial planning advice. But in your case, to be honest with you, you guys are so young, you're just starting out. Mark, would you just clarify this and tell Austin whether or not to hire the good friend, who will soon become his bad friend?
6:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, I don't, not yet. I don't think they need it yet. I think they're probably, just based on what I'm reading, they're doing what they should be doing. They're investing in total stock market ETFs. They're young, they can take a lot of risk. I'm fine with that.
7:07 Speaker 00 Yep.
7:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, I don't see the need right now.
7:09 Speaker 00 Me neither. And by the way, one thing we will say, and Mark has done this himself, is you've got a 6.99% mortgage. Keep an eye on those interest rates. See if there is something you may want to do going forward if rates change. Maybe we can get you a refi, but that's the only thing that I would look at right now. So hopefully, if you want some more information about the pension, you can get, find out from work, we'll happily hold your hand through that. Do what you're doing. I say no to the financial advisor. Okay, I like this, it's like the Young Show. Matthew is 39 years old. He's married, he's got a six-year-old and a three-year-old. And here's the question. I've been with my employer for 15 years and I plan to retire with them. Oh my God, isn't that amazing? Very old-fashioned notion.
7:53 Speaker 00 Like, I'm gonna retire with these people. My wife took, I almost read this as my wife took off, like left me, but it's not that. She took off a few years when we were living out west to spend time with our kids. She started working part-time and I worked for a great company, good benefits. Okay, so Matthew's been contributing 17% since he started working with them. And check this out. He puts in 3%, they match 7%, and then he puts in another 7%. So he puts in 10, they match 7. Okay, we are also an employee-owned company, ESOP, and I've been in the stock program since day one. And an employee stock ownership plan is a very interesting plan. Very few places have it.
8:34 Speaker 00 But the majority of that plan is a traditional 401k and ESOP. They've recently added a Roth option. He rolled over some of his pre-tax money, not all. He started contributing 10% to the Roth and the company match of seven will go to the pre-tax. I started a 529 for one of the kids and then an in-state prepaid plan with the idea that one might stay in state, the other might go out of state. All right. You ready for these numbers, Mark? I just want to say one more time, these folks are 39 years old. Okay? Here we go. Traditional 401k, $588,000. Roth and Roth 401k, $100,000.
9:20 Speaker 00 Brokerage, $16,500. ESOP, $415,000. Cash, $40,000 and 529 of $25,000. So they're doing incredibly well and they got a couple, they own a home and they've got some equity in that home, a couple hundred thousand dollars of equity. Okay. Here are the questions. Mark, you're, I'm going to say the, I'm going to, I'm going to read the question. You're going to give the answer. Question, should I combine my investments into a single provider instead of having them both at Fidelity for work and then Vanguard for personal? What do you think, Mark?
9:53 Speaker 01 No, that's, that's fine. I mean, you really can't control who your employer uses. Uh, if you want to use Vanguard for your personal accounts, that's fine. I mean, one day you might roll all of your work stuff into your Vanguard anyway. So I have no problem with that.
10:04 Speaker 00 I don't either. Okay. Next, is 10% Roth contribution a good idea? Is it enough? Should I do more? What do you think for that, Matthews wants to know?
10:13 Speaker 01 If you can do more, do more. I think the goal should be to max it out.
10:16 Speaker 00 Absolutely. Not that I plan on retiring early, but I, but could I be on track to retire at 59? Um, I'm going to answer that. This completely depends. I would not even look at this right now. This is so, it's 20 years from now. Let's get your, you know, I get it. You want to see if you can change careers? Eh, I think you're probably on track to be able to do that, but if you really want those opportunities, just keep doing what you're doing. All right. Now, Mark, what else should they be doing with the extra funds? He says, I recently started to contribute $150 per week to my cash savings, $50 a week to my brokerage. Is it necessary?
10:52 Speaker 01 I mean, if I look at this whole thing, the one area of potential weakness is probably the 529 plans. I see one, I see one for 25,000. They have two kids. So if there's extra cash flow, that's probably where I would focus.
11:05 Speaker 00 Well, wait a second. I'm going to free up a little more cash flow with this next question.
11:11 Speaker 00 Matthew has a mortgage, okay? And the interest rate is 4.3%. He says, we bought the home in 22. We like it. We don't love it. He has been paying an extra, wait for it, $1,500 a month. And he wants to pay this down in five years. Okay, he said, the idea is to pay this down ASAP, then take 500 to 600,000, use a down payment for our forever home. Not saying I would use the full amount. Would like the option if we find our forever home. Is this a good idea or crazy? I'm not going to say crazy, but Mark, can you talk about why you wouldn't pay down a mortgage if you thought you were gonna actually?
11:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, yeah, if you think you're gonna be moving. I mean, why, I understand you want to build up your equity, but I just don't see the rationale behind it. And it's 4.3%.
11:57 Speaker 00 I would say that is not crazy, but I don't think that's a good idea. So now, let's go back to your other question. You have not just $1,500 per month. You have, you have $1,700 a month. So number one is, I think, I think there's three things to do with $1,700 a month. Beef up the 529, max out your retirement, and whatever is left, put in the brokerage account.
12:20 Speaker 01 It's more, it's more like 2,000 a month because he's doing 150 per week through his cash.
12:23 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah. Oh, my God, I missed that. Okay, so, um, 24, yeah.
12:27 Speaker 01 2,300.
12:28 Speaker 00 $2,300 a month. Number one, max out your retirement account. Number two, put more money in your 529. Number three, brokerage. That's it. Don't worry.
12:38 Speaker 01 I don't, I, yeah, I agree. That's obviously what he should do, but Matthew is, he's hell bent on getting rid of that mortgage. I don't know.
12:44 Speaker 00 Well, I want him to come on the air and talk to us. We'll talk you through it. Especially, Matthew, dude, if you're going to actually be thinking about selling the house, the money you invest in five, six, seven, eight years, you find that forever home, you have the money to do it. So don't get it tied up in that mortgage. Uh-uh. I'd say no way. All right, that's it. That is the program. If you are looking at paying down your mortgage, especially like in that situation, you know, it not always the best idea. I know there's this emotional part that people feel. Let us walk you through some of the math and at least give you a, an alternative to consider. So go to the website, jillonthemoney.com, click the contact us button. Let us know if you want to come on the air. This is where we can really talk through stuff.
13:29 Speaker 00 We'll change your name. Don't worry. It's all good. You can find all of our content on the website. You can subscribe to this program on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. Please leave us a rating and review wherever you listen. Put your hands metaphorically on someone's back, will you? Come on, someone needs a little pat on the back. Change your work, change your wealth, change your life. Thank you for listening. We'll talk to you tomorrow.
14:03 Speaker 02 The business world is moving faster than ever. And when change hits, we need to learn in real time. On Rapid Response, you'll hear candid conversations with CEOs and leaders making tough calls about AI, human talent, responsibility, and the bottom line, how they navigate uncertainty, pressure, and high stakes moments. I'm Bob Safian, former editor in chief of Fast Company, and I'll be your host as each episode breaks down what you need to know right now. You can find Rapid Response wherever you get your podcasts.
14:47 Speaker 03 The world is changing faster than most career advice can keep up with. It's true. Industries are shifting, jobs are disappearing, and new ones are just showing up that didn't exist five years ago, five minutes ago, whatever. I am Suzy Welch, and on Becoming You, we talk about how to find the work that genuinely calls you and actually pays you what you want to be paid, even in today's marketplace. When you find that intersection, the possibilities are bigger than you think. Listen to Becoming You wherever you get your podcasts.
Previous Did I Pull the Plug Too Soon? Next Retirement and Pension Options Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated