Pod Insights Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger 39 and Want to Retire About this episode Can we stop saving for retirement and basically let about $2,100,000 and our rental home values grow without contributing more? Have a money question? Email us here Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE Subscribe to Jill on Money Newsletter YouTube: @jillonmoney Instagram: @jillonmoney Twitter: @jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:03 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Jill on Money Show. It's Friday, May 30th. And hey, gang, it really does feel like this is now officially, we're getting into it, like, end of May. It's almost a half year behind us, five months behind us, seven months to go, and time sort of marches on. But has your financial life paused to take a moment of reflection? Are you wondering what is the next best financial move for you? Are you trying to figure out how you are going to navigate the next seven months? The next seven years, 17 years, whatever it is, whatever your time horizon is? If you're listening to this program, you know that we talk about money, but we really
0:44 Speaker 00 are focused on you and your lives. And that is why we encourage you to get in touch with us, because your money is not your life, I promise you. But what it does is it allows you to make different choices at different times in your life. And so, we encourage you to get in touch with us by going to jillonthemoney.com, click the Contact Us button, which is in the upper right-hand corner. When you click on that, a form will pop up. Write us a note. Now, that's the email we receive. And we love to get your emails. It's fantastic. I think our inbox is like 400 million thousand, or something like that. Very bulging. But we also like to talk to you, because this allows us to ask a lot of nosy follow-up questions. And, you know, listen, I'm a financial planner
1:28 Speaker 00 at heart. I'm a numbers person, but I'm a voyeur. So I like to hear your stories. Same with Mark. We love to hear what is behind the question. Sometimes, we can get to that more easily by talking to you through the computer. So, get in touch with us, write us the note. And if you want to join us live, check the box. Mark will do everything else. Now, very exciting.
1:51 Speaker 00 Next week is our second webinar of 2025. That webinar will be with Mike Quincy, the Consumer Reports auto expert. He will be joining us next Thursday, June 5th at 7 Eastern Time. You can only join if you are a subscriber to Jill on Money Live. Mark, I noticed that in the New York Times recently, they're talking about like, maybe EVs are kind of not going to actually be the thing anymore. I don't know. I kind of wanted it to be the thing. Maybe Mike will tell us and he'll help us understand what's going on in the car and truck market with all the tariffs. He'll help us understand what are the best cars to look at if you're thinking about getting something for your kid, your adult children. And he's just great and he's a lot
2:33 Speaker 00 of fun. And so I hope you join us Thursday, June 5th. But here's your asterisk. You've got to be a member of Jill on Money Live. That's our subscription service. And that will cost you 45 bucks for the next 12 months. Mike will be your first webinar. You'll have the back catalog of all of our previous webinars. You'll get three more after that. So we do them quarterly. It's so much fun. So check that out. There's also a bunch of bonus audio and video content that is behind the paywall. Jill on Money Live is the name of the service. Okay, so, hey, Mark, we got some emails here. So let's get started with Greg. He says, this is a subject, you know, of course, this sort of makes me want to smack them, but I'm going to be nice because it says 39 and want
3:16 Speaker 00 to quote retire. 39. I never thought about retirement when I was 39. I'll tell you that much, but that's just me. All right. Greg says, my wife and I are both turning 40 this summer. She's a full-time teacher. She makes $90,000 and has incredibly cheap health benefits. She also has a 403B and a pension that starts at age 55. Oh, my goodness. They've got $2.5 million in a brokerage account. They're only 40? Come on. $560,000 in Roths and $685,000 in traditional IRAs. More than three? Oh, my God, they've got 3.5 million bucks in. Savings already. Is this, come on, Mark, are you, um, this does not seem like a real question.
4:02 Speaker 00 I feel like this is a folk question. They have 13 rental properties and he's 40, come on.
4:08 Speaker 01 If he's got the time to come up with a, a folk question like this, then I don't know.
4:12 Speaker 00 This is ridiculous. I don't even want to answer him. Okay. He's got 13 rental properties, 3.75 million, they owe 2 and a half million, 6%. He wants to pay down a million or a million and a half on the credit line from the brokerage account and live on his wife's salary and the rental income so he can quit his stressful job. That takes away from his precious years with his three and five year old boys. But he won't be able to save anymore. Can he stop contributing to retirement and coast? They want to live on 12 grand a month. Okay, Mark. 12 grand a month, let's presume right now, um, they've got, they're going to take, let's lop off. He's only going to pay down a million, so he's going to take, let's just say that of the 2 and a half million in brokerage, it'll leave him a million in the brokerage, is what he's going to have, a million in brokerage, 560 in Roths, 685 in traditional IRAs.
4:55 Speaker 00 So that's the basis of what they have. They'll have rental income. Um, her pension will be $3,500 a month. Let, boy, she's nice letting him coast, huh? Social Security, he gives us the thing, how do we plan for the 27 years? My wife is happy working as a teacher. I can reduce our rental home expenses if I have time to do things myself. So here's a question. Can we stop saving and basically let a little over $2 million in rental home vows grow without contributing more? What do you think, Mark?
5:25 Speaker 01 Did he, did he say what the rental income is?
5:27 Speaker 00 Nope, he did not.
5:29 Speaker 01 I, I mean, I'm going to assume it's obviously enough, but if, if that's the case, then yeah, he could probably do it, but he didn't tell us that.
5:34 Speaker 00 Yeah, you left out one big piece, Greg. I feel like this is someone who's completely punking us. I really don't believe this is a real question.
5:42 Speaker 01 Oh, I don't think so at all.
5:43 Speaker 00 You don't?
5:44 Speaker 01 No.
5:44 Speaker 00 How does a 40 year old have all this money?
5:46 Speaker 01 I don't know, maybe they inherited some of it, I don't know.
5:49 Speaker 00 It seems very strange. That's all I can say. Maybe he's like, maybe someone died and left them rental properties. I don't know, but 13 rental homes and they're worth 3, uh, 3.75 million total. What kind of rental homes are these?
6:04 Speaker 00 It's like that a lot, right? When you think about it. I don't know where he lives. Get back in touch with us, Greg. We'll get you on the air. We'll anonymize you. I don't believe you, but Mark does. I just kind of know why. Okay. Paul says, I've listened to your show a few times. What do you mean a few times, Paul? Listen to it every time. I appreciate how clearly you explain things. Okay. I'm 59 and a half years old and I'm trying to rebuild after some major life changes. I had a long time career as a professional musician, but when the pandemic hit, everything changed. Remember, Mark, we did talk, we talked to a couple of musicians during that time. Anyway, Paul went through a rough divorce and he started over, starting from scratch, essentially.
6:45 Speaker 00 He says, these days I work as a truck driver for a wine distributor in New Jersey. I also play part time in a wedding band. Yearly income is about 70 to 85,000 plus 10 or 15,000 from my music gigs. Right now, I have $61,000 in an E-Trade brokerage account, $5,500 in Fidelity, $20,000 in savings, a $25,000 balance on a home equity line of credit. Oh, my gosh. These lines of credit have gotten so expensive. His is 8.75%. $7,500 on a 0% interest credit card from recent dental work. A roof that will likely need replacing soon, 10 to 20,000.
7:30 Speaker 00 A home that's fully paid off. Okay. I've heard a Roth could be a smart move at this stage, but I'm not sure how it works or whether I can convert my current E-Trade or Fidelity brokerage accounts into Roth IRAs without selling everything first. Can you help me understand if that's possible and whether it makes sense for someone in my position? Thank you so much for your time and everything you share on the show. It's really helpful. Well, all right, Paul. I'm going to guess that the money that you have in the E-Trade account and the Fidelity account, that those two accounts are not retirement accounts. Okay, so let's just say they're straight up brokerage accounts, meaning they've already been taxed. So a couple of things. If you want to do something with the money in those accounts, you would be, you would have to sell and then take the money to do something else.
8:13 Speaker 00 Now, it might be a very good idea for you to sell because given your tax bracket, you know, you're probably not going to pay a lot in capital gains, you know, maybe 15%, but I would say that maybe what you should consider doing is taking some of the money in that E-Trade brokerage account, maybe half of it, I would say, and I would first pay down the $25,000 balance on the home equity line of credit. Let's lock in an 8.75% no-risk return. That sounds like a good idea to me. So maybe you've got to sell half of the account. I'm a little bit worried about potentially doing much more than that. At this point, are you planning? Are you able to make sure that this credit card of $7,500 will get paid off?
8:58 Speaker 00 Because if you're not sure that that's going to happen within a year and that the interest rate is going to go up, we may need to think about tackling that as well. The roof, hmm, you could pay that. You could like, you could basically blow out of the whole brokerage account, essentially, pay the tax that's due, clean up your balance sheet, meaning pay off your home equity line of credit, pay off that interest from the credit card as soon as the 0% is up, make sure that the roof is paid for without any additional debt, and then you can start a Roth IRA, which is essentially taking an after-tax dollar, like you have in your brokerage account, putting it into an account, and investing that for the future. Now, you are 59 and 1/2 already, so this is a very good, you know, way to start saving money.
9:40 Speaker 00 It grows, it grows, it grows, it grows, and then maybe later in life, maybe in 15 or 20 years, whenever you're done, when you take that money out of the Roth, there will be no tax due. So the difference between a Roth and a traditional is that with a Roth, you've already paid the tax that's due, you pay no tax on the way out. With a traditional, you don't pay the tax upfront, you wait until you take it out later in when you're withdrawing your money from your retirement account, that's when you pay the tax that's due. Uh, Michael writes, accidentally contributed to a Roth when I probably shouldn't have, uh-oh. Uh, I'm a co-owner of a two-person member-managed LLC. All of our compensation comes from distributions, and we have it as K1 income. I received my K1 very late this
10:23 Speaker 00 This year, so I had to file an extension. I then contributed the max to this year's Roths, my wife's and mine, without realizing I made more than I thought last year. That put me over the Roth IRA limit. How screwed am I? You, Michael, are not the first person to have this problem. Don't worry. So you just have to recharacterize the money. You have to contact the place where you made the Roth contribution and say exactly what you just wrote to us. They'll take the money out. You have to submit a form to the IRS and tell them that you've done this. But don't worry, people, this happens all the time. This is also why we really encourage people not to make their contributions until they get their final tax documents. So I mean, I guess it's a good problem. You made more than the limit, right? So, not bad. Okay.
11:08 Speaker 00 Tracy writes, hello Jill, I have four kids in their twenties. Two of them took my advice and they actually took financial literacy classes in high school. And the other two have not. Guess what? Mom was right. Isn't she always right? And they now need more information about saving mortgages, retirement. Can you recommend an online class or podcast for the just beginning young adults? Right now, neither of these two are making a lot, but they need to learn right now how to handle their money well. I am afraid they will take advice from TikTok. Many thanks, Tracy. What do you think about that, Mark? Who's the Getting to Know You early stage podcasts?
11:45 Speaker 01 Isn't that Money Watch?
11:46 Speaker 00 That is a very good idea. So, okay, first of all, we have a second podcast. It's called Money Watch. We release it on Saturdays and Sundays, and that is what we're trying to do. We try to go back to basics a bit, and that would be a great idea to start. What about my friend Jack Otter's book? I wonder if it's still in print? Hmm. Who is that nice woman who did the book for newbies?
12:09 Speaker 01 Erin Lowry?
12:09 Speaker 00 Yes. Erin Lowry wrote a book called Broke Millennial, so that's pretty good.
12:17 Speaker 00 What about Jack Otter's book? Worth It, Not Worth It. That's the name of it.
12:21 Speaker 01 Erin Lowry has a whole series built around that Broke Millennial. It's not just one book anymore. It's like three or four.
12:26 Speaker 00 All right. Check it out. She's a good writer also, and I like her. So try that out. Let us know how it works. Okay. This email is from Anonymous and he needs help settling a debate and so he says I am a pilot and I work for a large private aviation company. A group of about 50 of us started this company at the same time. We've got a large group text with lots of opinions. The way our 401k is structured is we get a 66% match, holy moly, on the total contribution up to the maximum. However, for cash flow reasons during the year, they only match 66% on the first 20% withholding. Then they do a catch-up contribution in the following year, February. Okay, my coworker made the point,
13:10 Speaker 00 we should not quote, "front-load our contributions in any given year," i.e. max out contributions as early as possible because we're leaving money on the table until that catch-up and it spreads the risk out in a bad year. My counter is it's not so simple. The best time invest is yesterday and the second best time is today. Without having done the math, my primary point being it's better to get as much money in the market as early as possible and I don't care if it's a down year because I'm investing on a 20 to 30-year time scale and he's 38 years old. What do you think, Mark? Assuming returns that are whatever they are historically, better all at once, do the wait, I tend to think just get the money invested and stop overthinking it.
13:48 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, there's been plenty of proof out there. I remember doing this when I was going through the CFP coursework, but yeah, the math will prove to you that it's better to get the money in, you know, say January 1st versus September 15.
14:00 Speaker 00 Even if it's a bad year, by the way, because then there's years where they're bad years. So just get the money to work and stop overthinking it. What do you guys do? Fly your plane. Stop worrying about when to put your 401k to work.
14:10 Speaker 01 I hope they're not texting while they're flying.
14:12 Speaker 00 No texting while flying. Come on. Oh, my God, what goes on in those cockpits? We don't even know. Pay attention, all of you guys. All right. Thank you so much, gang, for listening. That is our Friday episode and on Fridays, you know, we like to thank everybody who makes it all possible, which is number one, you guys make this show possible. Thank you so much. You can subscribe to us on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. You can also subscribe to Money Watch on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. Our music is composed by Joel Good. Mark Teller is our executive producer and king of all things web. We are distributed by Odyssey. Try to lift someone up. Someone would need a little boost from you today. Change your work, change your wealth, change your life. Thank you for listening.
14:57 Speaker 00 We'll talk to you on Monday.
Previous Retired and Have a New Mortgage Next Worried About Portfolio Construction Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated