Pod Insights The Investor's Podcast (We Study Billionaires) - The Investor’s Podcast Network TIP778: How My Thinking About Investing Evolved in 2025 w/ Kyle Grieve About this episode Kyle discusses the most important investing lessons he learned in 2025. IN THIS EPISODE YOU’LL LEARN: 00:00:00 - Intro 00:03:01 - Why “strong convictions, weakly held” is one of the most powerful default frameworks 00:09:05 - Why customer loyalty is an underappreciated signal of long-term business quality 00:13:42 - Sleuthing a business 00:17:15 - Why reflecting on your own emotions is essential 00:23:35 - Why intelligent investing always involves incomplete information 00:31:17 - Intentional inactivity 00:37:09 - How understanding company culture helps identify true long-term compounders 00:42:25 - Why founders matter 00:53:56 - Focusing on fragility and downside risk 00:59:01 - Why incentive structures are one of the most critical drivers of business performance Disclaimer: Slight discrepancies in the timestamps may occur due to podcast platform differences. BOOKS AND RESOURCES Join the exclusive TIP Mastermind Community to engage in meaningful stock investing discussions with Stig, Clay, Kyle, and the other community members. Learn how to join us in Omaha for the Berkshire meeting here. Buy The Compounders. Listen to MI310: A Serial Acquirer Deep Dive. Follow Kyle on X and LinkedIn. Related books mentioned in the podcast. Ad-free episodes on our Premium Feed. NEW TO THE SHOW? Get smarter about valuing businesses in just a few minutes each week through our newsletter, The Intrinsic Value Newsletter. Follow our official social media accounts: X | LinkedIn | Instagram | Facebook | TikTok. Browse through all our episodes here. Try our tool for picking stock winners and managing our portfolios: TIP Finance Tool. Enjoy exclusive perks from our favorite Apps and Services. Learn how to better start, manage, and grow your business with the best business podcasts. SPONSORS Support our free podcast by supporting our sponsors: HardBlock Human Rights Foundation Simple Mining Netsuite Shopify Plus500 Vanta Masterworks Fundrise References to any third-party products, services, or advertisers do not constitute endorsements, and The Investor’s Podcast Network is not responsible for any claims made by them. Support our show by becoming a premium member! https://theinvestorspodcastnetwork.supportingcast.fm Support our show by becoming a premium member! https://theinvestorspodcastnetwork.supportingcast.fm Support our show by becoming a premium member! https://theinvestorspodcastnetwork.supportingcast.fm Support our show by becoming a premium member! https://theinvestorspodcastnetwork.supportingcast.fm Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices Support our show by becoming a premium member! https://theinvestorspodcastnetwork.supportingcast.fm
Transcript 13,238 words · 4 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 You're listening to TIP.
0:03 Speaker 01 This past year has been a predictably unusual one for me in the markets. Between the tariff tantrum and the AI scare, many of the companies that I own have really been put through the wringer. But after spending hours each day researching investing, I've learned a lot and taken the time to reflect on which of those lessons have really helped me evolve the most in 2025. This episode, like all my previous episodes, won't bother at all guessing with what will happen in 2026. It's about what I've learned that has directly impacted how I think and how I strategize. Now, when reflecting on some of the biggest mistakes I've ever made in my investing career, I realized that two of them didn't really stem from poor analysis. They came from fairly simple psychological errors. It's easy to learn about investing and assume that we'll all act rationally, but the reality is far from it.
0:48 Speaker 01 This episode was an excellent exercise for forcing me to confront where my thinking was too rigid, too emotional, or even too optimistic. One of my biggest thinking shifts was realizing that being confident and being flexible can actually coexist. A more uncomfortable realization was the biggest threat to my portfolio isn't interest rates, geopolitical unrest, or AI, but me and my imperfect thinking. I also share my thoughts on fragility of compounding and the steps that I've taken to protect myself so the compounding engine can just continue working. This episode is packed with how I've turned this thinking into usable tools to help me improve as an investor. And the reason I think these tools work is that nearly all of them have been cloned from the legendary investors I get the privilege of studying daily.
1:33 Speaker 01 I'll walk you through updates to my strategy around things like position sizing, how I wait for investments to play out, and how I say no. So if you've ever felt the urge to act when nothing needed to be done, or felt extreme confidence right before proven wrong, this episode is just for you because I feel your pain. This episode will help you learn from my mistakes and give you a few ways to think differently about your own investing. Let's jump right in to what I learned in 2025.
2:01 Speaker 00 Since 2014 and through more than 180 million downloads, we've studied the financial markets and read the books that influence self-made billionaires the most. We keep you informed and prepared for the unexpected. Now for your host, Kyle Grieve.
2:24 Speaker 01 Welcome to the Investors Podcast. I'm your host Kyle Grieve and today I'm happy to discuss my nine biggest learnings from my last year, specifically from this podcast. So the podcast game is just super interesting for me because you know, it's a job where I get to share these incredible lessons with you every episode, but then I can also, you know, pick and choose which of these strategies and meta models that I personally learned from that, you know, the world's greatest investors or minds are using on a regular basis. So today, I'm going to go over some of the strategic shifts that I've learned from spending thousands of hours researching the world's greatest investors, companies and fascinating books that I've shared with you in 2025. So let's jump right in and discuss the concept of flexible
3:07 Speaker 01 conviction. So on the face of it, flexible and conviction are two words that seem very, very strange to put next to each other. Don't you think? Flexible means being able to bend, adapt, or change easily without breaking. And conviction refers to a firmly held belief or strong confidence in an idea, principle, or decision. But here's the thing, conviction works very well under specific circumstances such as things like position sizing, but it can also lead to many errors in my thinking. If I have too much conviction in an idea, it makes me do things such as size positions too large, maintain conviction in an idea where maybe the thesis is deteriorating, or exposing myself to increased risk. And these three things
3:50 Speaker 01 add up to me losing money or having reduced returns, which is an area of investing that I'd obviously love to protect myself as much as possible. But don't get me wrong, conviction 100% matters and it matters a lot. But what I really learned this year, especially from someone like Anthony Bolton, was that conviction must be re-earned at very regular intervals. So what I used to focus on was strong convictions strongly held. When I looked at a business that I owned such as Alibaba, I think I followed this framework. I'd get an idea in my head, I'd gain conviction. And then I didn't think that I allowed myself to be very flexible until unfortunately it was just too late. While I thought that Alibaba was a great business, it was taking an approach to growth that just wasn't optimal for creating shareholder value in my view.
4:35 Speaker 01 I could have come to that conclusion a lot earlier had I allowed myself to adjust my conviction levels rather than stubbornly holding on to them as I did with Alibaba. Now Anthony Bolton warns us that beliefs can really calcify when new uncertainties appear. And this directly explains what I think happened to me with my Alibaba investment. The calcification of beliefs and conviction is a very perilous thing. And if you allow thoughts in your heads to calcify just too much, you rapidly increase the risk of making bad decisions because you become blinded by new facts that counter your existing beliefs. But this year, I came across a quote that profoundly changed just how I view conviction. And that was simply, "Strong convictions, weakly held."
5:17 Speaker 01 This is where the flexible part of flexible conviction comes into play. You can think of this as kind of a way to test the calcification of your ideas. There are a few ways that I do this now. So the first is to use what I call conviction ranking. This is a journal entry that I make pretty much every month in which I determine whether any new information that I've learned is either strengthening or weakening my conviction. And you can really do this however you want. You can give it a letter grade, you can have a number, a percent. I personally use percentages, but it really makes no difference. The reason this is so effective is that it shows whether you are gaining or losing conviction in your ideas. In my last entry from November 24th of 2025, I noticed a few highlights. I had one business where my conviction levels dropped a little more compared to some of
6:00 Speaker 01 my others, and then I had a few positions that gained a few more than others. Now, I'm not going to name either of these positions, but I can tell you that for one of the businesses where my conviction actually kind of decreased a little bit, there were a couple of reasons here that I can share. So the first is that the last two quarters have been pretty ho-hum. Had I known the business would probably slow down as much as it has, I would have delayed buying it since this is kind of one of my inflection point businesses. But I still actually have enough conviction in the position that a lot of the new spending that's causing this contraction in margins, et cetera, is going into money that can probably improve the business over the short to medium term. So that's money that's going into things like SG&A and research and development, which I think will probably end up helping the company.
6:43 Speaker 01 So my plan here is just to kind of wait and see what happens over the next year or so. There are some specific contracts to do with this business that are completely outside of their control. And once they get awarded to their customers, then their customers will begin shopping with businesses that the company I'm discussing sells. So there are specific contracts that are completely outside of their control that should actually end up helping this company once they're announced. Now, as for the position where my conviction went up, my conviction simply increased because the business has been going through some of these temporary headwinds. And this quarter really showed to me that a lot of these tailwinds that the market was very, very fearful of. And I wasn't very, very fearful. You know, I held my position and even added to it. But it was a position where I felt like I
7:25 Speaker 01 wanted to see how they were going to deal with them. And again, that's kind of a short term problem, but I felt that they dealt with them very, very well. And now that those problems are mainly behind them, there's probably going to be a re-acceleration to its growth and intrinsic value. And so the next few quarters should further reinforce my conviction that things are moving in the direction that I'm hoping for, which is to continue moving up. So one key to this test is to ensure that your conviction in an idea is coming from the fundamentals of a business and not from your emotional state about a company's share price movement. So when I look at where I increase conviction, I see stocks that have actually fallen in price. For instance, Lumine and Topicus have both decreased substantially in price, but my conviction in them just really hasn't faltered
8:08 Speaker 01 at all. This helps determine my actions as I then know that they're very good candidates for me to probably add capital to and increase my position size. So this conviction ranking really helps me be more decisive, but maybe less delusional. If there's a business where my conviction levels have dropped, you know, in half, there's probably a really good chance that I shouldn't be adding to that position, even if there's a corresponding drop in the share price. Just because a stock's price drops doesn't mean that that's a valid opportunity to invest in it. You need to look at things like the fundamentals of the business and decide if the market is correct or incorrect on its current perception. And my conviction ranking helps me make that independent decision that are not tied to the market. Now, it's essential to never get married to an idea or fall in love with one.
8:52 Speaker 01 As I've said, conviction is really just a test. And the businesses that stay in my portfolio will tend to be the ones where my conviction levels are improving over time. These improvements generally come from very strong fundamentals such as higher growth metrics, higher margins, greater capital efficiency, or maybe even more robust validation of capital allocation decisions. Now, I know that I've constantly tried to test myself to see where I could be wrong. And while this can obviously hurt the ego, a degree of humility in investing is much, much more valuable than having a high IQ. Another way a business can improve its fundamentals is through a less discussed strategy, which is strengthening customer loyalty. This is another area that I've spent more and more time thinking about after researching my episode on the book, Hidden Monopolies.
9:35 Speaker 01 Instead of focusing purely on traditional competitive advantages that businesses have, such as being a low-cost provider, economies of scale, network effects, and IP modes, I start to look more and more at the relationships that a business has with its customers. If a company is, you know, top of mind in their customers' minds, and customers just can't see a reason to switch to a different business, then you have a business that has a very, very strong mode. So yes, you can think of hidden monopolies as a type of switching costs. But as I outlined in that episode, there are many, many ways that a business can improve its customer loyalty, and it doesn't have to be explicitly tied to monetary reasons. My favorite case study from the book showed how a business with very obvious scale economies could still actually end up losing to a competitor who was able to improve customer loyalty.
10:19 Speaker 01 The story highlighted Nokia, which was once the absolute king of mobile devices, and it had exceptional scale benefits as well, which seemed to be undisruptable by newcomers such as Apple. But Apple built more and more customer loyalty over time, which eventually led to Nokia's loss of its mobile device dominance. Now, the beautiful part about customer loyalty is that it combines fundamentals such as intangibles with tangible results. For instance, if consumers spend a small amount of money on a product, they might not see any reason to switch as they satisfy the satisficing heuristic. This is an advantage that you generally won't see on a business's public presentation. But when you dig a little deeper and look at the thought processes that a customer makes in relation to a product,
11:05 Speaker 01 you will see these types of relationships. And businesses that have these relationships, such as, you know, a Netflix, saw substantial increases in their intrinsic value, specifically because customers didn't see a need to jump to a competitor. Now, as a quick side note here, I actually don't believe Netflix's score in this area is going to increase over time. It's probably going to decrease over time. But five to 10 years ago, it was a very, very significant advantage for them. Now, when you have customer loyalty, you don't need to spend as much time on customer acquisition. You can simply enrich the customer experience and keep customers happy, who will continue doing business with you. That saves a ton of money on things such as customer acquisition costs, which can then be diverted elsewhere. The other bonus of having high scores in customer loyalty is that the business becomes much, much more predictable.
11:51 Speaker 01 If a business has to fight, you know, tooth and nail to get every single new customer, it's going to have to spend a lot of money. And you have limited certainty whether those customers will actually stick and stay inside of that business. If you know a business already has a very sticky customer base, then chances are it'll have the same customers five to 10 years from now with greater certainty. This is why software businesses with switching modes trade at such high valuations. Investors tend to have high confidence that these businesses will increase their annual recurring revenue, and those are highly valuable. So what I like to look for are the hidden monopolies. This is where businesses have maybe improved their customer relationships, but the market doesn't quite understand how those relationships have improved. In those cases, you can truly get some incredible returns because once the market finds out,
12:36 Speaker 01 there's a great chance that you'll get a rerating in that business's multiple. Now, similar to conviction testing, I like to audit my businesses to observe their customer loyalty metrics. I try to do this now on probably a yearly basis, so I can see if there's any large scale changes that I need to focus on. Additionally, I can look at what other companies are doing and see whether my business is maybe cloning some of their best practices to help improve customer loyalty, or if they're just getting miles and miles further ahead in their own abilities to improve customer loyalty. So one business that I can talk freely About here is Aritzia. I've done my customer loyalty analysis on the business. And I concluded that they just don't have a very high customer loyalty grade. And that's actually okay. I think most retail businesses will not get the highest grade using this exact framework.
13:22 Speaker 01 But it was still valuable to really go through each one of these 20 line items to see where Aritzia scored somewhat strongly. Now, I didn't score it very highly in any one area. But it had some medium scores and things like satisficing, personal relationship costs and exclusivity. Now I can see whether these metrics move up or down as the business continues to scale, which will help me determine whether they are improving customer loyalty. Now, finding customer loyalty is great, especially when you decide to sleuth the business. I covered sleuthing in a lot more detail and I've already mentioned that hidden monopolies often requires quite a bit of digging just to find the hidden monopoly. And some of the aspects that I covered regarding sleuthing can become very, very helpful.
14:02 Speaker 01 So the problem with some businesses that I know I own is that I'm not a personal consumer of that business. So if I was to analyze a business such as Apple, it's pretty easy. You know, my house is littered with Apple products. I'm writing this episode on a MacBook Pro. I'm listening to podcasts on my iPhone. I got an Apple TV right next to me when I want to watch a show. But there are many businesses that are in my portfolio that I have zero ability to put myself in the customer's shoes, simply because they just serve markets or have products that I'm not going to shop for and nor will I probably ever shop for. This is where speaking with other people about their experience is so valuable. As well as why getting, you know, kind of boots on the ground is so important.
14:42 Speaker 01 If you have people like family, friends or acquaintances who work in industries that use products of the businesses that you're looking at, that can be a highly, highly important person to talk to. And in that case, you definitely should try and find out more about the relationship between that customer and the company, because you can unveil some incredible insights. For instance, I don't have a ton of experience with, you know, vertical market software businesses. So I have to go and depend on information from others who do use these types of products. So for instance, my stepdad works at a post office in Canada, and they recently switched to a new software for processing payment. And he said it was an absolute pain in the ass to learn. He had to spend weeks learning the latest software and teaching it to others at his location. So he didn't decide whether Canada Post would switch.
15:24 Speaker 01 I think if it had been up to him, he would probably have decided that he did not want to switch because he knew that there would be a lot of time and energy that would be spent in learning this new piece of software. So this, you know, little piece of information really helps me understand the switching costs that are involved with a lot of these vertical market software businesses I own, such as Topicus and Lumin. Now, one of the favorite episodes I did in 2025 was on the psychology of human misjudgment that was outlined by Charlie Munger. So making that episode was great for me personally because I can more closely examine the psychological biases that I personally have succumbed to in the past. And if you ask me when I started investing, what's the greatest risk to investing? I probably would have said things such as leverage, maybe lack of a moat or poor capital allocation. It would have been something that seemed clean and rational.
16:10 Speaker 01 But the honest answer to that, which I didn't really start to understand until I gained more and more experience, is probably a lot messier and irrational. And that's at the biggest risk in investing is myself. There are two investments that I made from two completely different worlds that I think have helped me understand this at a much deeper level. So for the first trade, we need to go back to 2017. So Bitcoin had shot up from 3,000 to 20,000 in just a few months. And every altcoin with, you know, a website seemed to double nearly in a couple of hours. It was in an environment that was really easy to fool yourself into thinking that you were smart. I quadrupled my capital in months, and I felt like I had found something that was truly special and life-changing. So I built what many temporary successful people do. I built my edge.
16:52 Speaker 01 Looking back, there wasn't much science about it, but it felt scientific to me at the time. I looked at things like Ichimoku clouds and other indicators that I didn't really understand all that well. I took screenshots that I focused on trends and specifically on the short term. But when the market rapidly turned against me, I didn't really adjust or take any time to step back and look a little more closely at what I was doing. Instead, I just doubled down and told myself things would probably go up, but I need to just wait it out. Much like Isaac Newton, who added to his South Sea Company bet once it popped, I made the mistake of thinking my crypto wouldn't go down for too much longer. So this mistake showed me that my system was more or less built around a narrative that justified a lot of the emotional biases that I was exhibiting. And as Spinoza said,
17:36 Speaker 01 emotion makes us pursue the worst while seeing the better. A few months later, 97% of my crypto net worth completely evaporated. And that didn't happen because Bitcoin was a scam, but because I fell victim to things such as a loving tendency, reward, super response tendency, and doubt avoidance. It was unfortunately the perfect storm of misjudgments, a negative Lollapalooza effect. The second trade took place recently in the last quarter of 2024. I'd evolved a lot since my days as a crypto speculator. I thought I had a much better framework and structures in place to help protect my downside, but the danger of emotional reasoning is always around the corner. When I first bought a business called Simply Solventless, a Canadian cannabis company, I did quite a bit of work. I did scuttlebutt,
18:20 Speaker 01 management interviews, due diligence, I spoke with other investors and people involved in the cannabis industry, and I liked the industry consolidation story that Simply Solventless was a part of. And I liked the price, I liked the upside, and maybe I liked it a little too much, which was probably the beginning of my mistake. When you like something too much, it's like putting on beer goggles. You're looking at an unclear picture, but it appears to you to be in 4K. When a significant acquisition they made fell through, the stock dropped very sharply. But looking back, my first instinct wasn't caution, which it maybe should have been, it was excitement and a view towards opportunity. I wrote in my journal after buying more shares that, quote, "This might be a mistake. I like the price shot, but there's a lot of uncertainty in the idea because of the
19:04 Speaker 01 unknowns with the material adverse condition." Now after that event came things like accounting changes. Then there were revenue recognition adjustments and these added more and more to the uncertainty with the business. But then a switch kind of changed in my mind. What if I've been wrong on this business the entire time and I was simply just allowing my emotions to cloud my judgment? I promptly sold the whole position at unfortunate considerable loss, the largest percentage loss that I've ever had.
19:30 Speaker 02 Let's take a quick break and hear from today's sponsors.
19:33 Speaker 03 Early in my career, I was shipping away at student loans and it felt like it would never end. I'd make a payment, check the balance and it barely moved. What finally changed my mindset was seeing a real finish line, a date I could actually circle on the calendar. That's what Monarch's debt pay down simulator gives you. It uses your real balances and payments to show your exact debt free date. Then you can run different scenarios side by side, like adding an extra hundred dollars a month and instantly see how much sooner you'd be done. Watching that timeline shrink is really motivating and you're the one in control of the plan. Plus a quick check in on your phone or laptop tells you exactly where your money stands.
20:14 Speaker 03 It's so important to manage your finances and I believe Monarch can help you in doing so. Write your own money story with Monarch. Use code WSB at monarch.com to get your first year of Monarch Core half off at just $50. That's 50% off your first year at monarch.com with code WSB. Interested in futures trading and looking for a place to get started? With plus 500 futures, you can explore some of the world's most active markets, all from one easy to use platform. Trade futures on popular assets like the S and P 500, NASDAQ, oil, gold, Bitcoin, Forex and more. Whether markets are moving in crypto, commodities or indices, there's always something to follow.
20:59 Speaker 03 Plus 500 futures is designed to make trading straightforward. The platform you can access wherever you are, right from your phone. And you can get started with a minimum deposit of just $10. Not ready to trade with real funds? Try the free unlimited demo account first and explore the platform without putting real money at risk. Backed by Nearly 20 years of experience and trust by millions of customers worldwide. Plus 500 gives you the tools to stay connected to the futures markets. Visit us dot plus 500 dot com to learn more. Trading in futures involves risk of loss and is not suitable for everyone. Not all applicants will qualify. Plus 500, it's trading with a plus. You don't need me to tell you that rent and mortgages are only getting more expensive.
21:43 Speaker 03 That's why Built created three credit cards designed to offer the richest rewards on rent, mortgage, and everything else you spend on. Whether you rent or own, you can earn up to 1.25 X points on every housing payment without the transaction fee, no matter where you live. Points can be redeemed for flights, hotels, Lyft rides, a future housing payment, and much more. Turn one of the most unavoidable payments in your life into the most rewarding. Find the card that's right for you and apply at joinbuilt.com slash T I P. That's J O I N B I L T dot com slash T I P. Use our link so they know we sent you.
22:27 Speaker 03 Terms apply, subject to approval and eligibility. Built cards are issued by Column N A, member FDIC pursuant to license from Mastercard International, Incorporated.
22:37 Speaker 01 All right, back to the show. Now, after reflecting on these two investments, I realized something quite profound. Unmanaged emotions never disappear, they just evolve. Emotions get smarter, more articulate, and even better at concealing themselves. After reading more and more on Spinoza, I came to a clear realization regarding emotions. Humans, myself included, are completely bound by emotions. And we do not clearly understand our own emotions enough to prevent them from distorting decision making. Or put simply, we're just wired wrong. So the lesson here is on risk. In academia, risk is measured by such factors as volatility, price, and beta. But in reality, risk is how our emotions play tricks on us, distorting our perception.
23:20 Speaker 01 The second lesson is on the power of loving or liking bias. This bias binds you to a more painful reality. It masks flaws that would have given you pause. And the more attached you become to a hypothesis, the less likely that new valid data will change your mind. And third, the market will punish psychological weakness at alarmingly fast rates. Bad analysis might mean your investment goes nowhere for several years if you buy it with a large enough margin of safety. But bad psychology can cost you instantly, just like it did on my crypto adventure. Now, the biggest tool for combounding your emotions is to acknowledge that they're there and to see which decisions that you're making now come from rational or emotional thinking. Only then can you triumph over the adverse effects of emotions.
24:04 Speaker 01 Now, while emotions will have the biggest impact on our investing, we still need to make sure that we are putting the right businesses inside of our portfolio to at least, you know, set us up with the best chance to succeed. And to do that, we need to embrace another concept I learned from Anthony Bolton. Now, I'd love to share a story here about when I was overwhelmed by another investor's expertise. So a few years ago, I invested in Micron, a business that manufactures silicon chips. I remember reading analysis deep into the night from this one guy on Seeking Alpha, and I was constantly, you know, just in awe at this guy's ability to understand Micron and its industry. He knew how Micron was doing versus competitors, how far Micron was ahead in terms of microchip size compared to Chinese competitors, the direction of pricing, which customers had excess inventory,
24:49 Speaker 01 and other just mind-boggling factoids that I hadn't even thought were material to my thesis. I felt a little out of my league. I thought to myself that I needed to get to this level if I ever wanted to feel like I had an edge. But the more I researched, the more I realized that that goal was entirely out of reach. Not only did I not have the time or really inclination to learn as much as this guy, but I also had 10 other positions to understand deeply as well, plus a full-time job and a family. Now, as I began thinking more and more about it, I realized that it was impossible to make that a goal to strive for because unless I could spend, you know, 40-plus hours per week researching semiconductors, chances are that I would never become as knowledgeable as this guy. Second, two different investors. We'll call them Deep Diver Dave and Sufficient Generalist Steve.
25:35 Speaker 01 So Deep Diver Dave absolutely loves detail. He invests in maybe just one thing a year and he knows everything there is to know about the industry. Someone like Shelby Davis comes to mind here, an investor who only really invested in insurance and knew all the key players and developments inside of that one industry. Now, Deep Diver Dave reads everything about the industry, every news article, every 10K, analyst reports, industry reports and journals, and feels the need to know more than literally anybody on the planet about the industry that he's digging into. But something dangerous has happened to Deep Diver Dave, taking this exact approach. Where he once had several winners, he's now experiencing many large losers that have erased a ton of the returns that he's had over the past five years. And this is because he's become a little too overconfident in his
26:17 Speaker 01 information. And because he feels he spent so much time and effort understanding this one industry, he's paralyzed to move somewhere else, keeping his capital in some pretty mediocre investments. Now we look at Sufficient Generalist Steve. He's obviously a generalist. And while he doesn't know nearly as much about one industry as Deep Diver Dave, he's perfectly fine with that because he focuses on information that he needs to know to make investments that will bear adequate returns. So you could say he focuses specifically on material variables and skips the immaterial ones. Steve knows that there's only so much time in a day and he's very, very picky about where he spends his time as he realizes that there's an opportunity cost to everything that he does. So this means that Steve has to live with incomplete information at
27:00 Speaker 01 times. But he's okay with that as long as the incomplete information is unlikely to harm his investments. He still does a ton of the research that someone like Deep Diver Dave would do, but he takes a more direct approach, focusing only on the information that he needs to make an investment or take a pass. So sometimes he'll even speak with experts on an industry or a business just to get, you know, key insights that he wants from that person who probably has a lot more knowledge than he'll ever have. Anthony Bolton himself is an excellent example of this investor archetype. Now Bolton's insight crystallizes the difference between Dave and Steve. The question that Bolton would pose to us investors is, what kind of edge do we get from spending, say, 40 hours on a company versus only 20?
27:42 Speaker 01 And if we know more than 99% of the average investor after spending 20 hours, what does 40 hours get us? 99.5%? Does that actually make a difference in our investing process? If I knew Micron was good, cheap, and had good growth potential, did it really matter what small adjustments competitors were making? That probably wouldn't really affect Micron's business. The more I thought about it, the more I came to the conclusion that, you know, depth is not the same as clarity. Depth is a great way to spend time and unfortunately even waste it. When you are thinking about clarity and time in general, you must focus on where your time is best spent and not on wasting time trying to get a negligible edge versus other investors. So now we get back to that Micron example. Once I realized that all the time spent researching all this extra stuff was unnecessary,
28:27 Speaker 01 it led to a potent insight. I began to see that information isn't always better. What matters is knowing what actually matters and acting on it at the right time. So even today, I still wrestle with this problem. It's so easy to spend another five to 10 hours on a business I might already own to just learn a little bit more about it or learn about a specific aspect of it. But I have to ask myself, you know, will this make a difference to me in the long term? I generally have an excellent idea of what KPIs that I'm looking for in all of my businesses. And as long as I'm staying on top of the developments inside of that company that directly affect those KPIs, I'm in pretty good shape. But if I spend too much time needlessly deepening my knowledge, I'm simply taking time away from putting that into better things.
29:10 Speaker 01 So what I learned from Bolton was that the edge regarding information isn't from knowing everything. It's from understanding and focusing only on what matters the most and to gently remind yourself to stop once you know enough. So now, when I'm looking at a business's quarterly, I'm not scrambling to spend five, 10, or 20 hours needlessly trying to understand some low-impact nuance that may subtly affect the company. I focus on my KPIs, their current state, what's moving them, and what's likely to happen over the near, medium, and long term. It's my simple way of telling myself that I know enough already. Now, I remember waking up on April 2 of 2025, opening up my Yahoo Finance app, rubbing my eyes and seeing just a sea of red. And this wasn't just a small drop.
29:52 Speaker 01 I remember some sizable, you know, minus 5% or greater drops that day, not too long after the market had opened. But you know, I was pretty calm. I've been through situations like this before. After doing some reading, I saw what all the fuss was about, the US tariff news. I had text messages and direct messages from other investor friends who were checking in and talking about all the carnage that was going on in the market that day. Many investors were panic selling, predicting that other investors would sell. They reasoned that they would just do it first, so they would lose less. For me, it was just another wild day in the market. Now reflecting on this day got me thinking, what if the hardest part of investing isn't in the analysis, but in the waiting part? So let me explain a little more. I recently did an episode about something called intentional inactivity. Now, in that episode, I discussed a really, really good story.
30:38 Speaker 01 So it was about this gentleman named Fabius, who was a Roman emperor in general. And so the story goes, he basically did nothing as his enemy attacked him. Basically, he knew that his enemy was trying to lure him out to have a conventional battle. Now, instead of fighting a fight that he knew that he would probably lose, he simply did not move his troops out onto the battlefield. Now, to the lay Roman, this might have looked like he was frozen and afraid. But to Fabius, he was just coiling. You see, intentional inactivity can easily look like incompetence until it starts to work. And Fabius was simply biding time, allowing his army's numbers to swell as more and more soldiers were called to the front. Now, once he knew he had the edge, he met his enemy on the open battlefield and he defeated him. Now, back to April 2nd. While the average investor may have looked at my inactivity as incompetence,
31:22 Speaker 01 I too was practicing intentional inactivity. I sold zero stocks in the month of April because many of my businesses were just simply well-positioned, I thought, to deal with tariffs. And I felt that many countries would begin bargaining to reduce tariffs. Sure, there might be a hit to the margins of some of my businesses, but it was nothing that would really break my thesis. And besides, why sell companies that I didn't think lost that much intrinsic value when their share prices were being beaten to a pulp? But I also realized, like all humans, that I'm wired to want to do something under stress. I just noticed that I don't really get stressed about my investing during the exact same times as probably the normal investor. I get more stressed out when a business that I own shows weakness in its fundamentals.
32:05 Speaker 01 So my wiring for doing something in these situations is an Area that I know I need to work on. Like Fabius, I needed to focus on controlled disengagement and patience during these times to avoid coming to the wrong conclusion. So intentional inactivity isn't just about emotional discipline. It's also about structural advantage. When I did my episode about systems and mental models, I began to create some very interesting connections with Fabius. When I thought more and more about feedback loops, I realized that compounding is like a contained machine. When you open the door, you let heat escape and it takes a lot of time to heat back up. Now, these minor interruptions have very high costs. So any small adjustment that I could make to my portfolio,
32:47 Speaker 01 such as, you know, trimming or what other people do like sectional rotations or panic selling, obviously create a drag on compounding. So in this sense, inactivity isn't laziness or incompetence at all. It's really a form of engineering. So I realized that my portfolio was most likely to compound when I touched it the least. So if you got a chance to look at Buffett's best investing decisions, it wasn't some sort of, you know, brilliant trade or financial engineering with the use of heavy amounts of leverage. They were simply able to find great businesses and hold them. Investors tend to admire Buffett because he's very smart, and I also believe this to be true. But his true superpower is his ability to just sit still. Charlie Munger said, "Never interrupt compounding unnecessarily." And Buffett was a master at it.
33:32 Speaker 01 The irony in Buffett and Munger's success stories was that they resulted from doing as little as possible for the longest possible time. So one regret that I had from the tariff tantrum was that I didn't deploy enough capital when the market was showing weakness. Well, it's easy to blame that on maybe a lack of courage on my part to deploy, you know, cash that I had during a downturn. When I actually look back at my portfolio, that problem wasn't really a problem because I just didn't have cash to deploy then. So if I wanted to add to a position, the only strategy that I could have used was to just sell a current position that was probably going to be trading at a loss. So when I look back at that event today, I feel a deep sense of regret that I just couldn't buy more of the businesses that I thought deserved a larger weighting in my portfolio.
34:13 Speaker 01 So one possible strategy that I've been kind of formulating and tinkering with is to just add cash from my job each month based on my savings, but then to put a restriction on, you know, how often I'm actually buying new stocks or adding to current positions. I still haven't figured out exactly how this would look like, but I'd really like to start taking advantage of situations like the tariff tantrum in April, or, you know, the AI scare that we just had in October and November, all in 2025. So my temptation to act takes the form of deploying money from my brokerage account immediately into the best possible situation in my portfolio or into a new idea. But that's probably not the way to take advantage of intentional inactivity. Fabius and Buffett would disapprove. My compounding machine might be letting the hot air out using this strategy rather than,
34:57 Speaker 01 you know, maybe being more selective about where I pick and choose my spots to get the compounding engine even hotter. So the two big lessons here are that I initially felt that action on a monthly basis, such as keeping my cash allocation as close to zero, made me feel productive, you know? It allowed me to continue building positions, but at a cost. And that cost is that, you know, weighting is what produces the most remarkable results. So instead of deploying capital throughout the year, maybe I should have deployed the lion's share of it when the market decided it temporarily did not like stocks. Had I done that, there's no doubt in my mind that my returns this year would have been much, much better. So that was my lesson from April. I underestimated the strength of patience as a part of my compounding engine. But inside the companies I invested in, the compounding engine looks much, much different.
35:42 Speaker 01 It's not just patience, you know, it's people. And this year, I saw something in the Netflix story, the Amazon story, then again, in the nine case study that I outlined in the book, The Compounders. And it was so consistent and predictive that it was really hard to ignore. So let me take you into that story because it's added another lens through which I analyze businesses today. Now, when I think about what makes businesses such as Netflix, Amazon, Bergman and Beving, Constellation Software, or HEICO so great, I also think about how these companies can survive highly competitive industries. After all, they all certainly have very, very big advantages, but they just can't rest in their laurels because a competitor is probably waiting right around the corner to eat their lunch. And the magic fairy dust that connects
36:24 Speaker 01 all these businesses is culture. Culture is often visible long before a stock price appreciates for decades, so let's discuss exactly why that is. So in 2001, Netflix had a significant issue. The tech bubble had just popped, and funding for tech-focused businesses was drying up faster than the Mojave Desert. They just fired 33% of their workforce, and their founder, Reed Hastings, felt sick to his stomach about it. But oddly enough, a few weeks after firing these poorer performers, he observed something very, very strange and unexpected. Productivity rapidly increased. Hastings realized that these poor performers were dragging down the excellence of the outperformers that were already inside of Netflix. And this became the bedrock of his principal talent density. The other
37:08 Speaker 01 two bedrocks: candor, be open, blunt, and have quick feedback loops to avoid complacency. And the final one was a reduction in control. When you remove rules, you empower your employees to make great decisions without wasting time seeking approvals. These three principles gave me my first clue that a culture helps predict behavior, and behavior helps predict compounding. Before founding Amazon, Jeff Bezos worked at DE Shaw, an elite quantitative hedge fund. But DE Shaw was fascinating because he wasn't just recruiting these traditional finance types. They were actually recruiting people like mathematicians, computer scientists, physicists, and generalists who had these kinds of unusual problem-solving capabilities. Their interview process was famously very quirky and probing. It was built around some
37:52 Speaker 01 open-ended analytical puzzles rather than focusing solely on the applicant's resume. You know, they'd ask questions that seemed quite odd, such as, how many fax machines are there in the United States? Now, as a result of these experiences with Shaw, Bezos cloned many of Shaw's hiring practices when he started at Amazon. And embedded into Amazon's culture was his unique hiring operating system. They had a concept called the bar-raiser program, and this was a single person in the hiring process who had the power to veto any hire. This prevented the culture from being diluted by mediocrity, and it ensured that Amazon kept raising the bar on new hires. They also focused on two themes that were heavily emphasized in the compounders, which were decentralization and long-termism.
38:34 Speaker 01 Amazon fostered this mental model that Bezos called the two pizza teams. Any team working on a project should be small enough that it can be fed with two pizzas. That meant that teams stayed small and efficient. If you could get the same output from a two-pizza team, why bother with a 10-pizza team? Bezos was also fond of his day-one philosophy, which showed that he thought Amazon still had a very, very long way to go in its maturation. This allowed him to take some long-term bets that maybe were a drag on the business in the short term, but had potentially very, very large effects years down the road. Amazon was my second confirmation on the power of culture, and it showed that high-talent, autonomous cultures behave very differently under stress. They remain resilient and even can improve their abilities while the average corporation just simply fails.
39:17 Speaker 01 Amazon showed me that high-quality, scalable decision-making was a key to the compounding process. Then we move on to the compounders. So, these were boring businesses like Haiko, which manufactures third-party plane parts, yet has quietly destroyed the market's return for decades. Across all nine of these case studies, the DNA was very similar to Netflix and Amazon. The businesses used small teams and empowered them to make decisions. They optimized the incentive system to keep employees accountable and to make them feel like owners of the business. They also had employees who just loved what they did and helped carry the culture forward for these winners for the next generation. The companies outlined in the compounders had a kind of cultural feedback loop. Good culture attracts high-caliber talent. Good talent makes high-quality decisions.
40:02 Speaker 01 Better decisions compound at higher rates and with lower risk. And compounding reinforces culture. And culture continues to attract top talent. It's a reinforcing feedback loop, the kind of feedback loops that I'm always searching for inside of a business. Now, let's complete the circle and connect these three stories. Netflix showed this, you know, high level of cultural innovation by emphasizing things like talent, candor, and responsibility. Amazon showed how important it was to improve the quality of its talent and give them more decision-making autonomy. The compounder showed that creating compounding feedback loops based on culture improved and extended a business's runway, which helped allow it to compound for decades. The key here is that culture is the upstream indicator to search for in businesses that can compound for decades.
40:47 Speaker 01 The financial results are the downstream outcome of that strong culture. And once you see this, it really becomes impossible to unsee it. So how did these insights affect how I analyze companies? By emphasizing company culture when I speak to management. I'll also see where businesses are using things such as centralization versus decentralization and, you know, which direction that they're moving towards. I also pay special attention to the candor that management exhibits to ensure that they are highlighting both wins and losses. I also try to ask questions that cover longer timeframes. Maybe I'll ask something such as if all things go well, where do you see yourself in three years? And see if they have a quick answer, or if they just haven't really given it much thought. All these learnings weren't just a nice idea to just ponder, you know? They have become a genuine filter and checklist item that I can add to my toolbox to help
41:32 Speaker 01 separate good from bad investments, as well as sharpen or dull my conviction in current positions. Now that I understand the compounding engine inside of a business, I'll continue to find ways to identify cultural aspects as quickly and accurately as possible to just keep my own compounding engine going. Now, while businesses like Netflix and Amazon were founder-led, I've actually challenged the whole founder's effect this year. So doing my company DNA episodes actually showed me one of the greatest strengths of founders. Now, do founders matter? Of course they do, but I think not necessarily for the reason that most investors assume. Great companies don't just survive purely because they have a founder at the helm. They survive because founders left behind a codified DNA that outlives them.
42:15 Speaker 01 So when you look at businesses like Netflix, Amazon, McDonald's, and Home Depot, these were four businesses that I researched quite in-depth this year. And even though they're no longer founder-led, these businesses continue to generate significant cash flow and remain very, very relevant today. Now, why is that? So when Bernie Marcus first came up with the idea of Home Depot, it wasn't just to replicate what he'd already done at his former job. He wanted to recreate the do-it-yourself experience for his customers to make it the best possible experience. Bernie Marcus and Arthur Blank were just obsessed with service and empowerment.
42:47 Speaker 02 Let's take a quick break and hear from today's sponsors.
42:50 Speaker 03 You know that sinking feeling when a meeting ends, everyone's nodding along and two days later, you realize that nobody wrote down who was doing what. That's why I use Granola. Granola is an AI-powered notepad that makes your meeting notes useful. It captures what happens in your meetings and it turns it into clean, structured notes with decisions and action items pulled out and made easy to find. On days with back-to-back calls like guest prep and team check-ins, community calls, I used to spend the gaps cleaning up messy notes and trying to remember who owned what. Now I stay in the conversation and weeks later, everything is searchable in one place. Once you try it on a first meeting, it's hard to go without. You can
43:34 Speaker 03 try it totally free. Head to granola.ai/wsb. That's granola.ai/wsb to get your time back. Go to granola.ai/wsb and try it on your next call. Interested in futures trading and looking for a place to get started? With Plus500 Futures, you can explore some of the world's most active markets, all from one easy-to-use platform. Trade futures on popular assets like the S&P 500, Nasdaq, oil, gold, Bitcoin, Forex, and more. Whether markets are moving in crypto, commodities, or indices, there's always something to follow. Plus500 Futures is designed to make trading straightforward. The platform you can access wherever you are, right from your phone. And you can get started with a minimum deposit of just
44:19 Speaker 03 $10. Not ready to trade with real funds? Try the free unlimited demo account first and explore the platform without putting real money at risk. Backed by nearly 20 years of experience and trust by millions of customers worldwide, Plus500 gives you the tools to stay connected to the futures markets. Visit us.plus500.com to learn more. Trading in futures involves risk of loss and is not suitable for everyone. Not all applicants will qualify. Plus500, it's trading with a plus. This September, I was in New York for the Intrinsic Value Conference. The talks were great, but what I kept thinking about is what happened around them. On Friday night, about 20 of us crowded around a long table at a family-style Italian spot near Times Square.
45:04 Speaker 03 Saturday, we did it again. And Sunday morning, a group of us were still debating Socrates over breakfast before everyone headed home. Many of the people at those tables had only known each other from our calls in the Mastermind community. That is the community I host with Kyle Grieve and Daniel Manca. Each week, we get together on live calls to dig into markets and individual businesses. We bring in fund managers, operators, and authors as guest speakers. And a few times a year, like New York this fall and Omaha every spring, we meet in person. If you want to think in decades alongside people who do the same, apply for free at theinvestorspodcast.com/mastermind. If your application stands out, I'll be the one to reach out to you personally.
45:50 Speaker 03 All right, back to the show.
45:52 Speaker 01 Home Depot associates were taught to run towards customers and to go to their way to serve them as best as possible, rather than what some of their competitors were doing, which was running away from customers and trying to keep distance. Bernie and Arthur eventually left the management of the company to their predecessors. And yet, when you looked at the culture that they created, it hasn't really changed that much since they started the business in Atlanta. Home Depot's orange-blooded DNA has replicated itself from just four locations at inception all the way up to about 2,347 locations today. McDonald's offers a very unique way of looking at culture. Ray Kroc wasn't even the founder of McDonald's, but he really defined its DNA. The business was founded by the McDonald's brothers. But where Kroc's principal value came wasn't really scaling the systems, products, and
46:35 Speaker 01 services that McDonald's is so well-known for today. Kroc employed the right people to help set up these systems and make it a core part of McDonald's operations. So what were some of these systems? First was a standardization of operations, making sure that a burger in California tastes the same as a burger in Illinois. And Kroc knew that customers wanted food quickly, not in 20 minutes. So he created the systems inside of each McDonald's so that McDonald's could pump out its products. Product at a very quick pace while maintaining quality. He also made sure that locations were clean and were desirable places to, you know, go quickly eat a meal. And he made sure that all of these procedures were replicable, not only in the US, but all over the entire world. And the ironic part, the man who wasn't the founder created one of the most durable founder DNA of any business today.
47:20 Speaker 01 Next was Coca-Cola. So in terms of DNA, Coke has outlived literally dozens of CEOs as the business was founded all the way back in 1886. So Coke has survived numerous leadership transitions, wars, and even globalization. Now where Roberto Goizetta came into play wasn't so much in creating Coke's DNA, but in strengthening the DNA that it already had. Instead of diversifying Coke's focus into non-Coke related areas such as media, shrimp, and wine, Goizetta ensured Coke stayed focused on what it's known best for, Coca-Cola. And even he actually made a massive mistake with New Coke, but he was able to overcome it due to the strength of Coca-Cola's brand. Goizetta was hyper-focused on brand dominance, expanding distribution, and bringing Coca-Cola to every corner of the earth.
48:03 Speaker 01 He designed Coca-Cola to focus on generating cash, running efficient operations by incentivizing things like profits, and relentlessly pursuing consistency. Coca-Cola is strong proof that a business with exceptional DNA can compound across multiple eras and compound at even higher rates once it has the right person under management focusing on the right things. And it also shows that a business even as great as Coca-Cola can be misled by wrong management for a time. Now Bezos, who I've already discussed today regarding the bar razor program, the day one mentality, and the two pizza teams brought his own unique flair and experience with him when he created Amazon. But it wasn't just those things that drove him to engineer Amazon's DNA. I would say that similar to Ray Kroc and Bernie Marcus,
48:46 Speaker 01 Bezos was just obsessed with his customers and with delighting them at every possible opportunity. And another vital aspect of Amazon's DNA that was passed on from Bezos was this high-velocity decision-making. So in his 2015 letter to shareholders, he wrote, "Speed matters in business. Many decisions are reversible and do not need extensive study." So he split decision-making into two types. So there are type-one decisions, which had these kind of one-way doors, and there are type-two decisions, which had two-way doors. A type-one decision was high stakes, hard to reverse, and required a slow and deliberate thinking process. Type-two decisions were low stakes, reversible, and should be made pretty quickly. Bezos felt the biggest mistake that companies make
49:27 Speaker 01 is to treat type-two decisions like type-one decisions. This wasted time and energy that could have been better spent elsewhere. This is why Amazon tested out many choices that just didn't end up working, such as their attempt at a mobile via the Amazon Fire Phone. Now, similar to many compounders, which Amazon clearly has been, Bezos also focused on decentralization. Bezos designed the company to be this kind of loosely coupled but tightly-aligned company. Amazon can be thought of as kind of a conglomerate of thousands of small startups glued together by a shared culture. And Amazon has flourished even after Bezos has stepped down as CEO, showing that a well-developed system can outlive even the most legendary founder. Now, there are four lasting DNA traits I think were repeated among all four of these exceptional businesses. The first: customer obsession. Home Depot
50:12 Speaker 01 displayed customer obsession by making sure that its customers left the store with exactly what they wanted and at unbeatable prices. Amazon focused its efforts on delighting customers rather than just focusing on the competition. And McDonald's focused on consistency as it already had an exceptional brand. Number two is service ethos. McDonald's relied on its speed and predictability. Home Depot made sure all of its employees, even if they weren't consumer-facing, knew how the business worked at the floor level. Number three is operational discipline. Coke focused on its global distribution network to ensure that customers could easily access its product, no matter where they traveled in the world. McDonald's had their hamburger university, where they educated their staff in detail on the inner workings of McDonald's functions. And fourth here is aligned incentives. Coke,
50:55 Speaker 01 under Goy Suetta, focused on profits over growth. Bernie Marcus and Arthur Blank made sure every Home Depot employee felt Like a business owner, which is why they went out of their way to end up helping customers. And McDonald's made sure that they serve their franchisees as best as possible to help set them up for success. That's the founder DNA framework. A good founder makes themselves just non-essential to the running of a business. That's the mark of a truly legendary founder. Because once the business is able to copy their DNA, the company is just set up to survive no matter what obstacles come its way. So you could say the best founders don't build companies, they create cultures that can survive them. Now, we've discussed a lot here about culture and company DNA, which helps businesses survive across multiple eras.
51:37 Speaker 01 But at my heart, you know, I'm an investor and I also want to focus on things like survival. If I hope to achieve financial freedom, I need to make sure that I actually reach the finish line. So let's say I want to make it to the finish line with as few war wounds as possible. Well, in that scenario, I've come to realize that I need to place probably less emphasis on the upside and even more emphasis on downside protection in order to maintain durability. So the interesting thing about compounding is that, yes, it's very, very powerful, but it's shockingly fragile as well. One single bad decision, excess leverage, poor portfolio management, or emotional overconfidence can easily erase years of great decision-making. Whereas I used to think of downside protection as being overly defensive.
52:18 Speaker 01 I now see that as a vital part of keeping the compounding engine running in an uncertain and unknown world. It's no surprise that I've underestimated the fragility of compounding. Humans have always underestimated fragility. And against the gods, I discussed risk in a lot of detail. And through history, new people have picked up the flag to try to better understand risk and how to quantify it. As time has passed from gambling with sheep bones to gambling on sports. We have learned that risk has some sort of structure, but it's definitely not intuitive. Humans want to believe that the world is stable, but in reality, it's probabilistic. And progress comes from taming randomness. We can never entirely avoid it, simply because randomness will never stop breaking things. And investing is no different. Outlier events will dominate our results, both to the upside and to the downside.
53:03 Speaker 01 So what exactly do we need to do in order to make sure that we're not blowing up our portfolio? We focus on the key lessons of Seth Klarman, the margin of safety. So Klarmann understood that in investing, there are two types of investors. The speculator, who relies on stories, momentum, and short-term narratives to justify their investments. And then you have the investors, those who focus on things like durability, cash flow, and buying assets for more than they're worth. While it's easy to think of the margin of safety as being a purely analytical tool, it's really a psychological tool first and an analytical tool second. The margin of safety is protection from our own misjudgment, which happens a lot more often than even I'd like to admit. It's humility which helps determine the proper position sizing. It's in refusing to pay for a business that's priced for perfection.
53:47 Speaker 01 And lastly, it's in designing a process that assumes that you will be wrong, but can still survive when you swing and miss. So when I invested in crypto, I had no margin of safety. I used leverage, which I thought was a multiplier of returns. But in reality, it just multiplied my own fragility. I also had too much emotional reasoning that I allowed myself to masquerade as in-depth analysis. So the margin of safety essentially serves to reduce fragility, a concept that I've taken embarrassingly long time to understand. Now, one investor who helped me understand this better was John Neff, because he emphasized specifically earnings power under adverse conditions. He was intentionally looking at how businesses would grow when everything was just going to crap. And this meant that in the case of things going decently or well, that was just pure upside.
54:31 Speaker 01 Now, this matters more than ever in current times. Interest rates have climbed, and they're unstable. Inflation has been rampant. Geopolitical risks are evident around the world and even in our backyards. Supply chains have been disrupted by onshoring. The number of unknown unknowns is falling kind of this exponential arc. Now, I've been pretty good at finding investments that haven't gone to zero. Only one business I've ever owned is no longer on the market, and that's because it was bought out at a premium. Every other business still has ongoing operations. But I must admit that I bought some companies that I thought could perform well in adverse conditions, but then when those conditions arose, they just didn't perform as well as I'd hoped for. Alibaba was a great example, where I thought the business would perform well, but they had several headwinds that I didn't weigh heavily enough, and therefore I was heavily disappointed as a shareholder.
55:15 Speaker 01 This year, I saw how businesses would react to many of the issues that I listed previously. Businesses like Lumine and Topicus, which specialize in vertical market software companies, continue just kind of chugging along because they have very little inventory and are therefore unaffected by tariffs. They also don't need to worry about moving their manufacturing or switching suppliers to avoid tariffs or really geopolitical tensions. These are businesses that have very low levels of fragility. While businesses like Lumin or Topicus aren't exactly the sexy kind of AI plays that seem to be dominating the markets today, they are the types of businesses that are much less likely to be killed. Those are the businesses that I love the most. So these stories tell me three things. One, risk is much older than markets. Two, fragility is an underappreciated attribute of the margin of safety.
56:00 Speaker 01 And three, durability under stress separates the winners from the losers. When I combine these three things, I was able to develop a much more robust downside protection system. So how have I integrated this into my investing this year? There are a few ways. If I'm looking at the more analytical angle, it's simply by increasing the probabilities of my bare thesis. Instead of using low numbers like 10%, which is unrealistic, I might now default to 33%. And my inflection point businesses, I use an even higher number, maybe closer to 40%. Doing this helps me take into account just how a company will perform under adverse conditions, and it builds right into my evaluation and analysis. Another way to think about this is in the multiples that I use at terminal value. When I look at the price of businesses today, it's very obvious that investors are projecting
56:44 Speaker 01 the present into the future. The S and P 500 trades at around a 28x multiple. This means that many investors are pricing in future growth and enthusiasm, and that's only under solid conditions. What happens in a downturn? Do all these businesses continue growing at historic rates? Are investors likely to hold them once they see a cut in profits? This is why I focused on multiples that are better aligned with a business's average rather than those that the market is focused on just maybe over the past year. After spending time thinking about fragility and downside protection, I realized that much of it doesn't come from macro shocks or competitive threats. It comes from people making key decisions within a business. And more specifically, it results directly from the incentives that guide people's behavior within a company.
57:28 Speaker 01 If culture shapes how a company operates, incentives help determine why they operate in very specific ways. Munger once said, "I think I've been in the top 5% of my age cohort all my adult life in understanding the power of incentives, and yet I've always underestimated that power." And never a year passes, but I get some surprise that pushes my limit a little further. I felt like I've been studying incentives for years, but in 2025, I really made it a much higher priority. And like Munger, I feel like I always underestimate its power. The problematic part about incentives is that they don't shout from the rooftops about how important they really are. They're subtle, but they create predictable patterns. Researching them this year has reinforced the idea that if you want long-term alignment between shareholders and management,
58:11 Speaker 01 you really need incentive structures that support it. Incentives help shape the conditions under which key management and capital allocators make very, very key decisions. In my opinion, the best incentive structure that I've ever seen is Constellation Software's, which is why I hold positions in both of its spinoffs. The incentive structure for the spinoffs was nearly identical to Constellation's. Now, the key here is the structure of these incentive systems. So managers at various levels receive cash as part of their incentives. But this cash is used very unusually. So instead of going straight to the employees' bank accounts, a portion of the cash, usually around 75%, is used to buy shares in their own company on the open market. And to make things even better, the shares are then held in escrow for three to five years. So how exactly do they unlock this bonus?
58:56 Speaker 01 Well, it's tied to things like return on capital thresholds. There are no short-term bonuses tied to things like revenue or stock prices to try to make a quick headline-grabbing deal to just to juice your bonus. The system incentivizes things like cost discipline, capital allocation efficiency, and long-term thinking. Now, the outcomes of this system help shape the behavior of Constellation's managers and capital allocators. Managers think like owners because they literally become owners under the incentive system. If a new deal comes onto their desk and the hurdle rates aren't correct, they simply know they can just walk away from that deal and let another sucker accept the terms. Since Constellation is a forever home for vertical market software businesses, it creates this positive reputation as well for many of its acquisition targets. People who are selling to them know that they can trust
59:41 Speaker 01 that Constellation will treat their business respectfully if they sell to them rather than to someone else. Now, this exact system helped clarify which is what strong alignment looks like to me: patience, discipline, and an owner-operator-focused mindset. The system is so good that it's also spread to other VMS businesses outside of the constellation. ...universe such as Computer Modeling Group. Now, today I've discussed one of Seth Carmen's central teachings on the margin of safety, but he also had some really, really excellent insights in his book on the power and abuse of incentives on Wall Street. And even though the book was published in 1991, there really isn't anything that he said that still is not relevant today regarding the narratives on Wall Street. So his point was that there's just too many participants along the investing value chain where people are incentivized to promote certain activities which they probably shouldn't be.
1:00:26 Speaker 01 And these are things such as promoting, trading, selling narratives to earn commissions, and closing deals no matter what the terms are just to earn a bonus based on that deal. Now, the system that these people are in are not designed to really protect investor capital whatsoever. They're really just designed to increase the profits for their employer and themselves. Now, it's not even necessarily malicious, they're just following the behavior that is guided by their incentive system. Now, while I have no real ties to Wall Street in terms of my money as I manage it all myself, the situation is still very fascinating. It has helped me to see just how powerful incentives are and how they affect the people around me. For instance, my mom has a registered retirement income fund, which is basically just an annuity up in Canada. She wanted me to take a look at it once, and I saw what she was getting out of it
1:01:10 Speaker 01 and the fees that were being charged to her. We were both pretty outraged at how much the fees the manager of the annuity was taking for themselves. And my mom hadn't even actually realized it until I pointed it out to her. They were making a fee that nearly matched my mom's monthly payments, just crazy. So what her annuity manager was doing is to collect a bunch of cash from my mom and invest it into something that just generates income. Then, when she reached a certain age, which she's already reached, they would pay her with the principal and interest that was accrued. But they're making money on the principal that they invested and on the annuity that they pay her today. The managers are most likely part of some sort of large bank or institution, so they're interested in maximizing their own profits for the bank and themselves and not in the best interest of my mom. Now, I couldn't leave this part on incentives without mentioning the impact that Charlie Munger has had on my thinking of it.
1:01:55 Speaker 01 Incentives are deeply intertwined with how we behave. But what Munger taught investors from his talk on psychological misjudgments is that incentives also change perception. Yes, incentives obviously cause people to do weird things. But they also cause people to rationalize very specific behavior that they might otherwise be appalled at. When your behavior determines how much money you make, you will twist reality to justify what you are doing. I can't tell you, you know, how many shows or movies I've watched over the years where you see some drug dealer who's justifying what they do because they say, if I don't do it, someone else will. This is them just justifying what they are doing, even though it's very apparent that it's not a good thing. Now, obviously, this is an extreme case, but I think you get the gist. Now, the terrifying part about incentive caused bias is that it's stronger and much
1:02:40 Speaker 01 more pervasive than people admit. It can even cause honest and intelligent people to do very weird things. So let's look at an otherwise normal business like Wells Fargo, the US bank. So in 2016, they had a scandal that went public, but the misbehavior that had been happening was from many years prior. So what was happening was that Wells Fargo set these uber aggressive sales targets for their employees. They needed to hit eight products per customer. So employees were paid and promoted based on the number of accounts that they opened, and managers were evaluated based on sales team growth. So you had a system in which both parties worked together. And unfortunately, their system was broken. Thousands of employees, many of whom were hardworking, honest, and normal people, began
1:03:21 Speaker 01 opening millions of fake accounts for customers, 3.5 million accounts to be exact. These people weren't unethical by nature, but they justified their actions based on the incentive structure that they followed. That is incentive caused bias. So when it comes to incentives, there are three areas which these stories really teach us to focus on. The first is that aligned incentives create owner-like behavior, which is what we want to see from the businesses that we invest in. Second, misaligned incentives predict short-termism and unnecessary activity. And third, incentives shape our perceptions, decision-making, and culture. After meditating on this over the years, I've examined how it's impacted how I analyze businesses and invest. When I'm speaking to management teams, I always try to emphasize the incentives of
1:04:04 Speaker 01 managers, lower-level management, and salespeople. This helps me see if employees are incentivized to create shareholder value or just to pad their own pockets. When I'm speaking with management, I'm also actively listening to just how they discuss them. Talking about how well they're going to do next quarter or in the next five to 10 years. How focused are they on cost discipline? I pay very close attention to compensation structures as well. And these can easily be found in a company's filings. I pay special attention to whether they have long term or short term incentive KPIs. And whether they help align or misalign management and shareholders. I've also spent time thinking about my own incentives regarding my own stock portfolio. So my goal is to double my capital every five years. And that means I am technically incentivized to take risks to achieve that lofty goal.
1:04:49 Speaker 01 So I think that's why risk has become so significant to me. I have to play this delicate game of finding great opportunities with the right upside. But also, you know, can't go to zero or hopefully not even go close to zero. Hopefully they can't go down 50%. I want my pie and to eat it too. So when I used to analyze companies, I didn't place enough emphasis on the proxy or circular. Now it's one of the first things I do as I want to make sure a business has shareholders best interest in mind. Or else there's just no real reason to continue researching it. So while incentives can be boring, like many long term compounders, they have outsized effects when done right. When your investments are being managed by people whose behavior is set up specifically to benefit all the parties involved. You just tip the odds in your favor of that investment being a good one. And that is something that we can all strive for. Thanks for spending time with me today.
1:05:34 Speaker 01 If you'd like to continue the conversation, please follow me on Twitter at rational MR KTS. Or connect with me on LinkedIn, just search for Kyle Grieve. I'm always open to feedback, so please feel free to share how I can make this podcast even better for you. Thanks for listening and see you next time.
1:05:50 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to TIP. Follow we study billionaires on your favorite podcast app. And visit the investors podcast.com for show notes and educational resources. This podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and does not provide financial, investment, tax or legal advice. The content is impersonal and does not consider your objectives, financial situation or needs. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal and past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Listeners should do their own research and consult a qualified professional before making any financial decisions. Nothing on this show is a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell any security or other financial product. Hosts, guests and the Investors Podcast Network may hold positions in securities discussed and may change those positions at any time without notice.
1:06:33 Speaker 00 References to any third-party products, services or advertisers do not constitute endorsements and the Investors Podcast Network is not responsible for any claims made by them. Copyright by the Investors Podcast Network. All rights reserved.
Previous TECH010: The Real Robotics Timeline w/ Ken Goldberg (Tech Podcast) Next TIP779: Richer, Wiser, Happier Q4 2025 w/ Stig Brodersen & William Green Page updated November 6, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated