Pod Insights If You're Listening Will the US and Iran make a deal (again)? About this episode In the midst of bluffs, empty threats and broken promises, Trump has struggled to find any leverage over the Iranian regime he has declared war on, so why is he so confident he can make a better deal than Obama did back in 2015?
Follow If You're Listening on the ABC Listen app https://radio.abc.net.au/help/apps.
Check out our series on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDTPrMoGHssAfgMMS3L5LpLNFMNp1U_Nq
Transcript 3,798 words · 20 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:08 Speaker 01 Hello, I'm Annabelle Crabbe. Now, I wouldn't say I'm a hoarder exactly, but I do hang on to things. It's not just you and me. Australia's oldest library is crammed with stuff that isn't books. Terrible paintings, old menus, human hair. Is this history or hoarding? Come and have a rummage through the story of us, told by our stuff. Search for the History or Hoarding podcast on ABC Listen or wherever you get your podcasts.
0:37 Speaker 02 This podcast was produced on the lands of the Uabakal and Gadigal people. If you happen to be wandering through just the right corridor of the Waldorf Astoria Hotel in New York City on the 18th of September 2013, you would have seen quite a bizarre sight. Two high-ranking American diplomats desperately trying to rip a framed photograph off the wall. The officials were these two men.
1:06 Speaker 03 Bill Burns is someone who has worked on the Iran issue for several years. Jake Sullivan is someone who is really widely respected at the White House and at the State Department.
1:15 Speaker 02 They would later go on to become CIA Director and National Security Advisor in the Biden administration. But at this particular moment, their main concern was getting this picture off the wall. Outside, the streets of New York were filled with protests against the Iranian regime.
1:38 Speaker 02 They were there to denounce the new president of Iran, Hassan Rouhani.
1:42 Speaker 04 This man Rouhani has an enormous amount of blood on his hands. There is no chance that the regime is going to give up its quest for nuclear weapons.
1:50 Speaker 02 But secretly, there at the Waldorf Astoria, Burns and Sullivan were set to meet with Rouhani's advisers and try and convince them to do just that, to get the Iranian regime to give up its quest for nuclear weapons. The trouble was, just as the advisers arrived, the Americans realised that on the wall outside their meeting room was a giant photograph of the last Shah of Iran visiting the Waldorf in the 1970s. A giant image of the man the Iranian regime hated more than any other person on earth, the man they had overthrown in 1979.
2:30 Speaker 02 Seeing his picture next to the meeting room could seriously offend them. Burns and Sullivan, in a panic, began tugging at the frame, only to find that it had been bolted to the wall. The relevant question here is: why did they care? Why were they worried about offending the Iranians? It's certainly not something that the Trump administration is worried about, as they attempt to find a way to extricate themselves from the war they gleefully joined in February of this year.
3:03 Speaker 05 They're animals, and we have to stop them and we can't let them have a nuclear weapon.
3:15 Speaker 02 Back in 2013, Burns and Sullivan were able to strike a deal with the Iranian regime that, in terms of substance, is probably pretty similar to the deal the Trump administration will be trying to get Iran to agree to this time. So today, I want to take a look at the similarities and differences between what happened in 2013 and what's happening now. I think it's going to tell us a lot about how difficult the process of finding peace will be in the next few weeks and months. I'm Matt Bevan, and this is If You're Listening.
3:54 Speaker 02 Okay, for a lot of this story, we're going to be talking about William Burns, one of these two guys who were trying to rip that picture off the wall that day in the Waldorf Astoria in New York. Burns is like an archetypal diplomat, softly spoken. He's got grey hair and a little moustache, educated at Oxford.
4:14 Speaker 06 I took the written exam for the Foreign Service at our old embassy in London, the same week as our diplomats in Tehran were taken hostage.
4:26 Speaker 02 That incident, the storming of the American Embassy in Tehran in 1979, ended diplomatic relations between the US and Iran. Over the next three decades of Burns's career, the two countries only spoke through intermediaries, like schoolchildren having an argument. Switzerland, can you tell Iran that we're very mad at them? Pakistan, can you please tell the US that we don't care? And also that they have Western decadent cooties? When two countries don't have diplomatic relations, trust is very difficult to build. And it was rendered even more difficult because throughout the George W. Bush administration and into the first term of the Obama administration,
5:07 Speaker 02 Iran was building up its capacity to enrich uranium, a process which could lead to Iran having nuclear weapons. The Americans really wanted Iran to stop doing that, so they imposed trade sanctions to increase the economic pressure on Iran.
5:25 Speaker 07 A significant regime of sanctions that will indicate to them how isolated they are from the international community as a whole.
5:34 Speaker 02 These sanctions seriously restricted Iran's ability to export oil, which was bad news for Iran because exporting oil is the way that Iran makes its money. And so the impacts rippled through the entire country.
5:50 Speaker 06 This is not a profession about talking nicely to people. You've got to build up leverage.
5:57 Speaker 02 The problem was that without diplomatic relations between Iran and the US, there was no way for the two countries to actually negotiate. Even if the US could find someone to talk to, how could they trust that that person was really in a position to strike a deal? But that started to shift in 2009, when something interesting happened.
6:18 Speaker 06 Some of you may remember the incident where there were three young American hikers. Who were on the Iraqi-Iran border, not the place I would have chosen to hike.
6:28 Speaker 02 Three American hikers accidentally wandered into Iran.
6:33 Speaker 08 The backpackers crossed the poorly marked border by mistake.
6:36 Speaker 02 Unfortunately for the hikers, one does not simply walk into Iran, or at least, one does not do it without getting arrested.
6:43 Speaker 08 Shane Bauer, Joshua Fatale, and Sarah Short have been held for three weeks. They entered Iran from Iraq without authorization July 31st.
6:51 Speaker 02 The usual intermediaries were unable to convince Iran to release these hikers. But fortunately, a new player entered the chat.
7:01 Speaker 09 This is Oman, a small but rich oil-producing country in the Middle East.
7:06 Speaker 02 Oman is a bit of an enigma of a country. At the time, it was ruled by Sultan Kabuz, who was a bit of an enigma himself.
7:16 Speaker 10 His Majesty Sultan Kabuz bin Said al-Sayed, graduate of Sandhurst, absolute ruler of his people, and fan of Gilbert and Sullivan.
7:28 Speaker 02 On top of being a modernizer and diplomat, he was a patron of classical music, employing a royal orchestra, playing the flute himself, and building venues for classical music across the country.
7:41 Speaker 09 Two of his palaces have maybe up there in the top 10 concert halls in the world.
7:46 Speaker 02 Everyone was a fan of Sultan Kabuz, largely because his geopolitical strategy was to be incredibly friendly.
7:52 Speaker 04 Oman never cut off diplomatic relations with any government in the world. He used his friends of all, enemies of no one, foreign policy to position Muscat as a very important diplomatic bridge.
8:10 Speaker 02 And it was this friendly foreign policy position that saw Oman successfully get these American hikers released, when all other countries had failed. We will always be grateful to His Majesty, Sultan Kabuz bin Said of Oman, for his work to secure our release. This made a big impression on the Americans.
8:29 Speaker 06 The Omanis proved very resourceful in helping us to obtain their release. So that's how they established their credibility.
8:37 Speaker 02 So when Sultan Kabuz called and said that he might be able to convince the Iranians to meet secretly with American diplomats to discuss their nuclear weapons program, the Americans were very interested.
8:51 Speaker 06 I vividly remember the first trip we made to Oman in an unmarked US government aircraft, leaving Andrews Air Force Base outside Washington. Seventeen-hour flight to Oman.
9:02 Speaker 02 Burns and his colleague Jake Sullivan were sent to head up the negotiations, partially because they weren't well-known. Burns says that President Obama sent them on their way with some important advice.
9:14 Speaker 06 Well, you guys know what we need to do. I trust you, so don't screw it up. It may have actually been a little bit more colorful than "don't screw it up."
9:22 Speaker 02 Both sides thought that public negotiations would turn into a political circus, which is why they were very keen to do things in private.
9:30 Speaker 06 I don't think we would have gotten very far if we had done this in the glare of publicity.
9:36 Speaker 02 They wanted to see if they could reach common ground before anyone found out about it. So when Burns and Sullivan landed in Oman, they got straight to business.
9:46 Speaker 06 We meet in this vacated Omani military officers retreat right on the Arabian Sea. The temperature outside was about 120 degrees Fahrenheit, so there wasn't much to do other than talk to the Iranians.
10:00 Speaker 02 The man they were meeting was Abbas Al-Araki, a prominent spokesperson for the Iranian Foreign Ministry, who was publicly hopeful that discussions with the West might lead to a solution.
10:11 Speaker 11 I think what we need is goodwill and a real willingness and determination to resolve these differences and to bridge these differences.
10:21 Speaker 02 Like Burns, Araki was educated in England, so his ability to negotiate with the Americans in English made the whole process much easier.
10:31 Speaker 11 I believe a solution is at our reach. What we need is only good faith.
10:36 Speaker 02 They had several secret meetings in Oman, followed by more secret meetings in New York during the UN General Assembly in September 2013.
10:44 Speaker 07 I do believe that if we can resolve the issue of Iran's nuclear program... That can serve as a major step down a long road towards a different relationship.
10:56 Speaker 02 Despite their progress, Burns and Sullivan couldn't get Barack Obama and Iran's president, Hassan Rouhani, into the same room together.
11:04 Speaker 00 This lunch might have offered the opportunity, but President Rouhani didn't show.
11:09 Speaker 02 But someone who seemed like he was important gave Sullivan Rouhani's phone number. Sullivan says he set up a call between Rouhani and Obama, but realised as the phone was ringing that it might not actually be Rouhani's number. He had just been given it by some random Iranian guy.
11:30 Speaker 12 And I have a thought. Have I just connected the president to like a Canadian shock jock or some random other person? Or is this actually the president of Iran?
11:39 Speaker 02 Thankfully for Sullivan, it was the real guy.
11:42 Speaker 07 Just now I spoke on the phone with President Rouhani of the Islamic Republic of Iran.
11:47 Speaker 02 Throughout this years-long, involved and occasionally bizarre process, the US and Iran built up enough trust to be able to find a way to work together. And in 2015, after two years of good faith negotiations, the two nations finally came to an agreement.
12:04 Speaker 00 Iran agreed to limit its disputed nuclear programme in exchange for some relief from tough sanctions.
12:13 Speaker 02 Well, there was actually one more caveat. The deal apparently couldn't be signed until after the Iranian delegation went on a Sound of Music sing-along bus tour across Austria.
12:28 Speaker 12 Which involved like the bus like playing the songs from the Sound of Music while they drove around to like the key sites from the movie. So I was asking these guys, I mean, Sound of Music, really? It's huge in Iran, huge. So all these kind of hard-bitten old Iranian diplomats and frankly, regime functionaries are going off to do their Sound of Music escapade.
12:49 Speaker 02 They got there in the end, and Iran said so long, farewell, al vie de zen, good night, to most of their nuclear enrichment capacity.
12:57 Speaker 13 This moment has been a long time coming, and we have worked very hard to get here.
13:03 Speaker 14 I believe this is a historic moment, and it is an important achievement for all of us.
13:09 Speaker 02 So what did this deal mean for Iran's nuclear programme?
13:13 Speaker 02 Okay, I'm gonna need to shorthand a little bit of nuclear physics here for you so that we can get back to the geopolitics. It won't take long, this ain't a nuclear physics podcast. The uranium you dig out of the ground is useless unless you enrich it, which basically involves turning it into a gas and spinning it in centrifuges. The longer it spins, the more powerful and scary it becomes.
13:38 Speaker 15 They could enrich to weapons-grade uranium, which would be sufficient for producing a nuclear weapon.
13:43 Speaker 02 The way we measure the power of the centrifuges is with a standard unit called separative work units, or SWUs. In 2013, Iran had a capacity of about 14,000 SWUs per year, which is minuscule. Not even enough to power a single nuclear power plant reactor. To put that in perspective, other nuclear-armed countries have SWU capacities of several million each. But 14,000 SWUs is enough for one particular thing. It means that the timeline for Iran being able to produce a nuclear weapon, if they were to decide to do so, is significantly shorter.
14:26 Speaker 02 The more SWUs they have, the shorter the timeline becomes.
14:30 Speaker 16 The US President Barack Obama believes Iran is about a year away from building a nuclear bomb.
14:36 Speaker 02 Iran could be just six months away from achieving the 90% level needed to make a bomb. World leaders talk about weeks and months, but really what they're talking about is SWUs. Iran has this many SWUs, and that means they could enrich enough uranium to build a bomb... Within three months.
14:53 Speaker 17 Only a few months, possibly a few weeks.
14:55 Speaker 02 So, the 10-year deal struck between Obama and Rouhani was mainly about pushing that timeline out by cutting Iran's SWUs to around 4,000. Secondly, Iran had to get rid of 98% of the uranium they had already enriched. And thirdly... Before sanctions are lifted, there must be proof of compliance with the International Atomic Energy Agency, given unrestricted access to nuclear sites. IAEA inspectors were allowed to basically sticky beak wherever centrifuges were being operated or stored.
15:30 Speaker 02 In exchange for this, sanctions on Iranian oil exports would be relaxed.
15:35 Speaker 07 This deal demonstrates that American diplomacy can bring about real and meaningful change. Change that makes our country and the world safer and more secure.
15:44 Speaker 02 Now, as you may be aware, there were some critics of this deal, and one of them was particularly vocal.
15:52 Speaker 18 I've been doing deals for a long time. I've been making lots of wonderful deals, great deals. That's what I do. Never, ever, ever in my life have I seen any transaction so incompetently negotiated as our deal with Iran.
16:11 Speaker 02 From the moment the deal was signed, presidential candidate Donald Trump said incorrectly that the deal simply amounted to a transfer of cash from America to Iran.
16:21 Speaker 18 So, they rip us off, they take our money, they make us look like fools, and now they're back to being who they really are. They don't want Israel to survive.
16:34 Speaker 02 Speaking of Israel, another particularly vocal critic of the deal was the Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
16:40 Speaker 17 By not dismantling Iran's nuclear programme, in a decade this deal will give an unreformed, unrepentant, and far richer terrorist regime the capacity to produce many nuclear bombs. What a stunning historic mistake.
16:56 Speaker 02 The core of Netanyahu's problem was that the agreement treated the Iranian regime as a legitimate government, something that the US and Israel had refused to do for more than three decades.
17:09 Speaker 17 This deal will treat Iran like a normal country, even if it remains a dark theocracy that conquers its neighbours, sponsors terrorism worldwide, and chants "Death to Israel, death to America."
17:24 Speaker 02 Even a perfect deal would not have satisfied Netanyahu. And, as everyone involved readily admitted, the deal was not perfect.
17:35 Speaker 14 We are reaching an agreement that is not perfect for anybody, but it is what we could accomplish.
17:42 Speaker 06 I mean, I've never met the perfect trade agreement or the perfect diplomatic agreement. Perfect is rarely on the diplomatic menu.
17:50 Speaker 02 The deal was basically just a pause button for Iran's nuclear enrichment programme. It didn't dismantle it, it froze it in kind of a weird state. 4,000 SWUs of capacity is way too much for medical research purposes, but way too little for a nuclear power station. Plus, Iran still had thousands more centrifuges sitting in storage, ready to be spun up whenever the deal expired. The deal didn't do anything to prevent Iran from doing all the other things the rest of the world would rather they not do, in particular, funding terrorist groups like Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis. And with the sanctions lifted and oil revenue flowing in,
18:35 Speaker 02 Iran had much more capacity to do just that. But according to Berns, Sullivan and Obama, this deal was better than nothing. The problem was, a lot of people didn't agree with that assessment. And one of those people became the president.
18:54 Speaker 05 We have terminated a terrible, terrible deal that should have never, ever been made. And we will be putting on, among the strongest sanctions that we've ever put on a country.
19:11 Speaker 17 Israel fully supports President Trump's bold decision today to reject the disastrous nuclear deal with the terrorist regime in Tehran.
19:20 Speaker 02 Trump withdrew from the deal in 2018. And within two years, Iran had dusted off those centrifuges in storage and had 15,000 SWUs of enrichment capacity spinning, more than there had been before the deal was struck. Iran blocked IAEA inspectors and rushed to expand its enrichment capacity and stockpile of enriched uranium. By mid 2025, Iran had 35,000 SWUs, more than double their previous capacity. By June 2025, Iran had 440 kilograms of enriched uranium and the capacity to turn
20:01 Speaker 02 that into roughly 10 nuclear weapons in around about a week. It was very clear that American leverage over Iran was decreasing and those
20:15 Speaker 05 strongest sanctions that we've ever put on a country.
20:20 Speaker 02 Were losing their effect because Iran began covertly selling its oil to China. It was clear that something needed to be done before the situation got out of hand. So our old friend Abbas Al-Arargchi was invited to travel back to Oman to talk with the Trump administration about a new nuclear deal. This wasn't his first rodeo. You might remember him from such nuclear negotiations as the Obama administration was back in 2015. He was the guy at the Waldorf Astoria ignoring the picture of the Shah. He was also in Vienna, although I can't tell if he actually went on the Sound of Music bus tour. Arargchi had climbed the mountain of Iran's Foreign Ministry and was now in charge of it.
21:05 Speaker 02 And so he was Iran's best person to negotiate another deal. He started meeting with Donald Trump's representatives, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner in Oman. But partway through that process
21:19 Speaker 05 Iran's key nuclear enrichment facilities have been completely and totally obliterated.
21:24 Speaker 02 US and Israeli jets flew into Iran and bombed the enrichment facilities that Arargchi had spent more than a decade negotiating over. He was stunned.
21:34 Speaker 11 They had perhaps this plan and they just needed negotiations perhaps to cover it up. We don't know how we can trust them anymore. What they did was in fact a betrayal to diplomacy.
21:52 Speaker 02 Despite this setback, negotiations continued. And in late February 2026, Aragchi was sitting at the negotiation table with Steve Whitkoff and Jared Kushner again in Switzerland when...
22:06 Speaker 05 We have hit hundreds of targets in Iran, including Revolutionary Guard facilities. Americans will never have to face a radical, bloodthirsty terrorist regime armed with nuclear weapons and lots of threats.
22:23 Speaker 02 And yet the talks somehow continued. Aragchi has been continuing to meet with Trump's representatives to try and negotiate an end to the war. But despite multiple rounds, there's one big sticking point.
22:37 Speaker 19 Both sides appear to remain at odds over Iran's nuclear programme and stockpile of enriched uranium.
22:44 Speaker 02 In short, a long-term deal like the one Aragchi struck with Burns and Sullivan in 2015 seems very unlikely.
22:59 Speaker 02 Finding a way for two enemies to come to a deal is a delicate dance. It's about assessing leverage, finding common ground and building some kind of trust. For Aragchi, Burns and Sullivan, this was a delicate, years-long process. The Americans built up economic pressure, then promised to release that pressure in exchange for Iran agreeing to their demands. The Iranians built centrifuges, then promised to turn them off in exchange for sanctions relief. Both sides carefully assessed the trustworthiness of their counterparts and came to an agreement. The first time Aragchi sat across the table from Americans, they were career diplomats
23:42 Speaker 02 who had spent decades building the qualifications, experience and credibility required to be able to negotiate on behalf of Barack Obama. This time, he's sitting across the table from Donald Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner, Trump's golfing buddy Steve Witkoff, and Vice President JD Vance, who seems to be under a witch's curse, which makes every public appearance he makes an embarrassing disaster. There is no attempt whatsoever to build trust or rapport. There's no hijinks or Sound of Music sing-along bus tours. In fact, it's the exact opposite. The hills are alive with the sound of airstrikes.
24:23 Speaker 02 Trump killed Iran's leader, bombed their military and destroyed their navy in the midst of nuclear negotiations. Then, he threatened attacks on civilian infrastructure if Iran doesn't accept his demands. Yet Trump has struggled to find any actual leverage over the regime he has declared war on. Iran, meanwhile, has blocked the Strait of Hormuz and triggered a global energy crisis, expertly displaying their extraordinary leverage over the entire global economy. Even if both sides can agree to some kind of peace deal, neither has any trust that the other side will honour it. Iran will assume that the US will return one day to attempt again to topple the Islamic
25:08 Speaker 02 regime. The US will assume that Iran will just secretly restart their nuclear programme. Perhaps a deal will have been struck by the time you started listening to this episode, but now you're at the end of it, it's worth checking whether that deal is still in place.
25:31 Speaker 02 If You're Listening is written by me, Matt Bevan. Supervising producer is Cara Jensen-McKinnon. It's produced by Adair Shepherd and Pat Sunderland. On Tuesday, we're bringing you something special, part of our show that we did at the Newcastle Writers' Festival last month. It's a story I told about the radioactive incident at my high school, which led to my first ever appearance on live radio. I'm not being hyperbolic, by the way, there really was a radioactive incident at my high school when I was 14 years old. That's coming up on Tuesday. I'll catch you then.
Previous When will Australia run out of fuel? Next How not to cover a radioactive incident Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated