Pod Insights If You're Listening Will anything stop Palantir? About this episode The shadowy U. S. tech company Palantir has had a meteoric rise from complete obscurity to transforming the nature of surveillance forever. Pivotal to that rise is its unorthodox CEO, the philosophising tech-entrepreneur Alex Karp.
As Palantir integrates itself into systems in every facet of life, from Australian supermarkets to the controversial U. S. ICE raids, Alex Karp provides justifications and bold mission statements for his company, citing a laser-focus on maintaining U. S. hegemony across the world. In doing so, he believes Palantir prevents the rise of undemocratic, far-right movements. But is there any line that Palantir won’t cross to assert U. S. superiority? And could they be in danger of undermining the democracy they claim to defend?
Follow If You're Listening on the ABC Listen app https://radio.abc.net.au/help/apps.
Check out our series on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDTPrMoGHssAfgMMS3L5LpLNFMNp1U_Nq
Follow If You're Listening on the ABC Listen app https://radio.abc.net.au/help/apps.
Check out our series on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDTPrMoGHssAfgMMS3L5LpLNFMNp1U_Nq
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:07 Speaker 01 Prices shift, petrol jumps, shares fall, a company cuts jobs and suddenly the business story is everyone's story.
0:16 Speaker 02 I'm Alan Coler.
0:17 Speaker 01 And I'm Carrington Clark. From Monday to Thursday on ABC Business Daily, we break down the biggest stories in business, finance and the economy and why they matter.
0:27 Speaker 02 Then on Fridays, I'll go deeper on that's business, the people making decisions, taking risks and shaping where the economy goes next.
0:35 Speaker 01 Find it all in the ABC Business Daily feed, on ABC Listen or wherever you get your podcasts.
0:42 Speaker 03 This podcast was produced on the lands of the Uwabikal and Gadigal people. There's a strange story about Alex Karp, the CEO of data analytics company Palantir. Well, almost every story about Alex Karp is strange, but I'm going to tell you this one. Back in 2016, Karp was interviewing a young British man named Louis, who was applying for a position at Palantir. As Louis sat down in Karp's office, Karp began to recite this infamous historic speech.
1:13 Speaker 04 All the cotton mills of India, the cotton mills of Japan, the cotton mills of China have been created by British money.
1:22 Speaker 03 This is Oswald Mosley, the most famous British fascist of all time, giving a speech encouraging the British government to stay out of World War Two and let the Nazis do whatever they wanted.
1:38 Speaker 03 Now, it may seem odd for the CEO of a tech company to start reciting a famous fascist speech during a job interview, but to Louis, the interviewee, it was particularly mortifying. That's because Louis's full name was Louis Mosley. Oswald Mosley, the man who gave this speech, was his grandfather. Louis was applying for this job at Palantir because despite the fact that he wasn't a fascist and disagreed strongly with his grandfather's politics, mere association with a man once voted the worst Britain of the 20th century was enough to close a lot of professional doors for him in the UK.
2:24 Speaker 03 Alex Karp recited several minutes of the speech from memory. Then he got up from his desk and started doing Tai Chi moves. He keeps Tai Chi swords in his office for this kind of thing. Then he walked out of the room without saying goodbye. So, did Louis get the job?
2:42 Speaker 05 And we are joined now in the studio by the head of Palantir in the UK, Louis Mosley.
2:48 Speaker 03 Yep, of course he did. Now, even on the scale of Silicon Valley CEOs, that's a pretty odd sequence of events. It's one of many odd stories about Alex Karp that have come out recently. According to his biography, he decapitates cupcakes and only eats the icing. He speaks German for at least half of every day. He's obsessed with Nordic skiing and often films his quarterly revenue statements while on skis on the side of a mountain.
3:18 Speaker 06 One of the reasons I do this video on cross-country skiing is it's a very similar analogy. You train and train and train and then you get to enjoy the splendor of gliding across the snow. In many ways, that's what Palantir did in the last year.
3:35 Speaker 03 We've been living in the world of Alex Karp for a couple of weeks now, looking at his company, Palantir, its history and what it actually does. Last week, our landing point was basically that Palantir has created software that is genuinely useful for organisations which need to deal with lots of different data sources. Palantir breaks down silos and brings genuine efficiencies, things like intelligence gathering, supply chain logistics, military operations. While lots of people are concerned that Palantir is basically Big Brother from Orwell's 1984, it's no more inherently sinister than Microsoft PowerPoint or Gmail. But the difference may be in its leadership.
4:27 Speaker 03 So who is Alex Karp? What's his deal? And what happens when governments and institutions hand someone with this particular flavour of personality, an incredible amount of power and influence? I'm Matt Bevan, and this is If You're Listening.
4:54 Speaker 03 There's a reason I started with that story about Oswald Mosley, because it's an example of how nothing is as simple as it seems with Alex Karp. He isn't able to quote fascist rhetoric at length because he's a fan of Oswald Mosley. It's because he spent a big chunk of his life studying fascism. Karp was raised in a left-wing Jewish household, and in the mid 1990s, he moved to the German city of Frankfurt to get his PhD in philosophy.
5:26 Speaker 03 Frankfurt is not as random a place as it may seem for an American Jew who did not speak German, like Alex Karp, to study. It's the location of the incredibly dominant Frankfurt School of philosophical thought.
5:40 Speaker 07 The ideas of Marcuse and the Frankfurt School have come to dominate some of the social science departments in various countries in Europe, and through them to have a continued and very important influence on the young.
5:53 Speaker 03 Philosopher Herbert Marcuse and the other big thinkers of the Frankfurt School were primarily left-wing German Jews, who actually did most of their early work in exile, having fled the Nazis.
6:05 Speaker 07 And by the mid 30s, the key figures had all settled in the United States.
6:09 Speaker 03 They spent their careers trying to figure out how the most technologically advanced, educated and developed country on earth elected Adolf Hitler as Chancellor, and then devolved into barbarism and collapsed entirely in less than 15 years.
6:27 Speaker 04 What actually has gone wrong in Western civilization? That at the very height of technical progress, we see at the same time the opposite as far as human progress is concerned. Dehumanization, brutalization.
6:45 Speaker 03 They wanted to try and stop it from happening again. The school's basic conclusion was that fascism was a by-product of technological and scientific advances. Modernization leads to bureaucracy, and that leads to treating humans as administrative units rather than people. And that led to totalitarianism and genocide.
7:08 Speaker 04 In other words, with the progress of civilization, we will have a progress in destructiveness. And it seems to me no hypo-
7:17 Speaker 03 Can better explain what happens today than that. The relentless pursuit of progress and cultural dominance leads to dehumanisation, which leads to catastrophe.
7:35 Speaker 03 Alex Karp spent years marinating in the teachings of the Frankfurt School, learning German so he could contribute to discussions and so that he could speak to German people about their lived experience. And one family in particular made a lasting impression.
7:51 Speaker 06 I know a family in a small village that were super nice to me and like took care of me and gave me a coat, like really decent, wonderful, old school family. And I talked to the father and I was like, I asked him and he was like, look, we were all Nazis.
8:08 Speaker 03 Karp said that they were no longer Nazis when he met them, but he was deeply interested in why their ideology shifted.
8:15 Speaker 06 These people became Democrats and built the German society. My estimation is they were in no way, you know, national socialists anymore.
8:24 Speaker 03 And he came to a conclusion that was quite different from what his mentors and professors in the Frankfurt School thought.
8:30 Speaker 06 And one of the most important things I learned from them was, you know, it was the fact that America and American ways of thinking made them healthier and wealthier and happier that changed how they saw the world much more than anything else.
8:44 Speaker 03 This was a revelation for Alex Karp. American thinking cures fascism. According to Karp, when Germany was defeated and occupied by the United States, the former Nazis became healthier and wealthier and happier, and that's what made them not want to be Nazis anymore. It was through these conversations that Karp determined that the cure of fascism isn't addressing the way that progress reduces humans to administrative units like the Frankfurt School suggests. It's cured by being more American. He doesn't see these ideas as being contradictory. In fact, he thinks the Frankfurt School has updated its thinking recently to align more with his ideas.
9:28 Speaker 06 I was particularly interested in the second phase of the Frankfurt School. The modern version of it is actually neo-Contine and pro-American.
9:35 Speaker 03 Now, it's worth pausing here to make an important point.
9:42 Speaker 03 Most historians would disagree that being more American is what cured Nazism in post-war Germany. Post-war Europe wasn't prosperous just because of American cultural dominance. It was prosperous because, thanks to the post-war alliance system, Europe went more than 25 minutes without destroying itself for the first time in about 500 years. The story of those 500 years was an endless cycle of great powers challenging each other for dominance, followed by catastrophic war. After World War II, Western Europe entered an unprecedented period of peace and economic cooperation, with a strong focus on promoting human rights. For Alex Karp, though, that was only possible because of American dominance.
10:27 Speaker 06 I'm very culturally specific in a way that maybe, you know, not everyone is. I think the chance of world survival goes up as America becomes stronger and more dominant.
10:37 Speaker 03 He thinks that overwhelming American military power will cause a lasting global period of peace.
10:45 Speaker 06 The obvious solution to war is to have the West having the strongest, most precise, deadly weapons possible, so that we can minimise unnecessary innocent deaths. And by the way, the primary way you minimise these deaths is you're so strong no one attacks you.
11:05 Speaker 03 He's ignoring the fact that this was the perspective of every empire that ever existed: Caesar, Napoleon, the British Empire, Emperor Palpatine. They all believed that if they became powerful enough, nobody would ever challenge them, right up until their empire all came crashing down. Karp's sure that it won't happen this time, though, and has dedicated two decades of his life to building one of the most powerful companies in the world, which explicitly aims to increase American military intelligence and corporate dominance through data processing.
11:43 Speaker 04 Really what it is, is creating a unified view.
11:48 Speaker 04 Over lots of disparate data sources, which don't otherwise make sense together.
11:52 Speaker 03 Karp spent years of his life reading theory about fascism and totalitarianism. He learned German so he could read about it in its native language. He thought about it a bunch and then bent his ideology into a shape that would allow him to lead a company that reduces everything from information to resources to humans to administrative units.
12:16 Speaker 06 Or, put simply, our product is used on occasion to kill people.
12:20 Speaker 03 In the last three years, Palantir has added AI to the mix, and the company has gone into hyperdrive, providing services to corporate, law enforcement and military clients in America and in US-allied countries. And Alex Karp thinks that it's all working great. In fact, better than working, he explicitly says that Palantir has played a role in stopping fascism and far-right politics in Europe.
12:47 Speaker 06 If you don't find the terrorists, you're going to have goose stepping in the streets. And I got yelled at all over the world for saying, "Our product, Palantir, has played an enormous role in Europe in stopping the far-right." Because if you protect data and stop terrorism, you get mainstream parties. If you don't protect terrorism, you get far-right people.
13:09 Speaker 03 Karp said that in February 2023, while Joe Biden was the US president. At the time, the clear policy of the US government was to support moderate political parties in Europe and support Ukraine in its fight against Russia. Palantir was very happy to help with both those things. But then something happened which challenged Western dominance more than anything had in years.
13:35 Speaker 03 On October 7th, 2023, Hamas attacked Israel, killing more than 1,000 people. A week later, Karp took out a full-page ad in The New York Times, a black page with white text and five words: "Palantir stands with Israel."
13:53 Speaker 03 On Palantir's earnings call soon afterwards, he announced the company's position on the increasingly fragile state of the world.
14:01 Speaker 06 There is no such thing anymore of being on all sides. Palantir only supplies its products to Western allies. We've never supplied our products to enemies. We proudly support the US government. I am proud that we are supporting Israel in every way we can.
14:14 Speaker 03 According to Karp's biography, the attack on Israel played a role in convincing him that Donald Trump would likely return to the US presidency. October 7th put terrorism back on the front page and made Americans feel their way of life was under threat. And as Karp says.
14:31 Speaker 06 If you protect data and stop terrorism, you get mainstream parties. If you don't protect the terrorism, you get far-right people.
14:40 Speaker 03 As a result, Karp began adjusting his worldview to fit whatever Trump's America might need from Palantir. America was about to become more right-wing, but it was still crucial for Palantir to ensure American dominance over the rest of the world. So Palantir was ready to help with whatever President Trump might need. And what he needed was this.
15:03 Speaker 06 Under President Trump's leadership, we are looking to set a goal of a minimum of 3,000 arrests for ICE every day, and President Trump is going to keep pushing to get that number up higher.
15:18 Speaker 03 Palantir has been working with the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement Agency, ICE, since 2016. But their cooperation stepped up a gear after Donald Trump's second inauguration, when they signed a contract to provide a product they called Elite.
15:33 Speaker 07 So it is a map interface, and an ICE official will simply draw a circle or a square onto that map. And all of these small pins will appear. They'll then click onto one of those pins, and that will be a specific person, or in ICE's sort of vernacular, a target. That'll be their name, date of birth, a photo if they have it, the address and the address confidence score.
15:57 Speaker 03 This is Palantir doing what Palantir does best. Last week, we illustrated it using marbles in jars. Lots of different bits of information gathered by different parts of the government, which previously had been impossible to find and connect with each other. With Elite, ICE could get marbles of information from, say, the Department of Motor Vehicles files, police reports, and subpoenaed social media data like location history and private messages, and build a fluid web of intelligence and surveillance.
16:30 Speaker 07 It seems to be a tool that brings together data from all of these usually separate places and sources, and brings it into a sort of all-in-one, single tool that ICE can use to find neighborhoods, to raid, maybe write up target lists, and eventually supervisors to approve those lists and send people out into the field.
16:50 Speaker 03 For ICE investigators, what once required weeks of cross-checking siloed systems could now be done in hours or less. Does that mean that people's right to privacy is being abused? Well, Karp thinks not.
17:03 Speaker 06 When people are worried about surveillance, of course, there are huge dangers there. But you will have far fewer rights if America's not in the lead.
17:14 Speaker 03 Now, look, you could basically use that kind of thinking to justify pretty much anything. But it's interesting to think about this idea in the context of Alex Karp's background. How do you think he feels about his company being used by masked men to round up large numbers of people and pull them into unmarked vans?
17:36 Speaker 04 I'm asking you just as a person, on a sort of a moral basis, as a human, when you see young people, mothers and fathers and families getting ripped apart with the masks on, with the ICE folks, what do you think of that?
17:50 Speaker 06 Again, of course, but at this point, you're abusing empathy. Because I, of course, don't like that. No one likes that. No American... This is the fairest, least bigoted, most open-minded culture in the world.
18:04 Speaker 03 And yet.
18:09 Speaker 05 ICE has pulled people from street corners, their homes. Even US citizens have been caught up in the chaos.
18:18 Speaker 03 Despite Palantir's effectiveness in ramping up ICE's capacity, setting quotas for deportations has led to a lot of mistakes.
18:25 Speaker 05 Since October, courts have found more than 4,000 immigrants were detained illegally.
18:31 Speaker 03 Many of the people arrested by ICE are being denied their constitutional rights.
18:36 Speaker 05 A majority of the people that are detained have no criminal history and no basis for their detention. They can be transferred out of state at ICE's whim.
18:42 Speaker 03 The number of people being arrested on the streets of American cities and towns has increased by a factor of 11. People, including American citizens, have been wrongfully deported. But as Karp says, this is what the American people voted for.
18:57 Speaker 06 And I personally think that US people, meaning citizens, have to decide by their vote what our immigration policy is going to be.
19:07 Speaker 03 And therefore, to limit the US government's access to Palantir's technology would be undemocratic.
19:15 Speaker 03 Last year, business journalist Andrew Ross Sorkin asked Karp a pointed question.
19:20 Speaker 06 You wrote your college thesis on fascism. There's a view, and I'm curious where you land. Do you think that President Trump is a fascist? Of course not. I think that's stupid, honestly. And you know what, again, you can go all day on this stuff. It's honestly idiotic. I grew up, half my life, in Germany. I spent time with actual fascists. I went and talked to lots of former Nazis. This is like, we have a democratic society, and, you know, he won in a landslide.
19:53 Speaker 03 Hmm.
19:57 Speaker 03 The key question is, does Alex Karp have a red line when it comes to Palantir's operations? Is there any request that a democratically-elected president could make which he would refuse? That question has very much come to the forefront after something that happened in January this year with the AI company Anthropic and their chatbot Claude.
20:20 Speaker 07 The US military has been pretty keen to get unrestricted access to Claude's abilities. Anthropic wasn't exactly comfortable with this. Worried about Claude being used for surveillance and to develop weapons.
20:33 Speaker 03 What Anthropic was particularly concerned about was Claude being used to spy on American citizens and create fully autonomous weapons.
20:41 Speaker 07 Leading to Anthropic's CEO deciding they wouldn't cooperate with the Pentagon.
20:46 Speaker 03 The Pentagon's position here is simple. Anthropic is a defence contractor. They are providing a service to the US military. And the US military thinks it should have the right to use that service however it wants. Its other defence contractors, the ones who make tanks, fighter jets, ships and missiles, don't get a say in how those things are used. Lockheed Martin can't say, actually, you can't use our F-35 fighter jet to bomb Iran. So what makes Anthropic different? Why should they get to decide what the democratically elected US government can use their service for? Anthropic's position is, well, we can't tell you what to do, but we also don't have to give you access to our product.
21:25 Speaker 04 I think that there's no issue in Anthropic taking a stance, you know, in fact, that that should be applauded. There's no requirement for them to sell to the federal government.
21:34 Speaker 03 Anthropic drew a red line and said, we will not help you spy on American citizens or hand over control of deadly weapons to AI. The US government said, well, in that case, we'll find someone who will. Like Anthropic's biggest competitor, OpenAI.
21:52 Speaker 07 OpenAI, by the way, is the company the US government has just made their new AI provider.
21:57 Speaker 03 The question that's hanging over OpenAI and indeed Palantir is, what is your red line? Does Alex Karp have one? In November last year, he indicated that Palantir might have one.
22:10 Speaker 06 You're asking, does our product allow for civil rights abuses and will I intervene? Yeah. Our product is the hardest in the world to violate. Will I intervene? Yes.
22:20 Speaker 03 But he doesn't think he's ever going to have to.
22:22 Speaker 06 It is the hardest product to misuse, to to take away the rights of human beings that's ever been built.
22:27 Speaker 03 And yet, it is at its very core, a system that reduces humans to administrative units, to dots on a map who can be killed by drones or scooped up by masked federal agents. Alex Karp, of all people, must know that there is a threat that that system will be abused by an authoritarian government. He says he'll intervene to stop that happening. But that relies on him identifying when his system is being abused. The trouble is, according to Karp, America is the solution to the world's problems. And so long as it continues to be a democracy, whoever runs America gets to decide what America's all about.
23:11 Speaker 03 So what right does he, or any private citizen, have to stand in the way?
23:24 Speaker 03 This episode of If You're Listening was written by me, Matt Bevan, and Cara Jensen-McKinnon. Cara is also our supervising producer. It's produced by Adair Shepherd and Pat Sunderland. I'll see you next week.
Previous The FBI dug a tunnel under the Russian embassy Next What is Palantir doing in Australia? Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated