Pod Insights If You're Listening We were warned about the Strait of Hormuz About this episode While governments scramble to find a way around the Strait of Hormuz, a pipeline sits half-finished in the desert that would have solved the problem. So why was it never completed?
Follow If You're Listening on the ABC Listen app https://radio.abc.net.au/help/apps.
Check out our series on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDTPrMoGHssAfgMMS3L5LpLNFMNp1U_Nq
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:08 Speaker 01 I'm Carrington Clark.
0:09 Speaker 02 And I'm Alan Coler.
0:10 Speaker 01 In 2026, business, big and small, is moving at a rapid pace. And ABC Business Daily is here to help you cut through the noise and spin, Monday to Thursday.
0:21 Speaker 02 And on Friday, I sit down with business leaders, founders, creators, change makers, and those in the know to ask them how they see the world, because that's business.
0:31 Speaker 01 All in the ABC Business Daily feed, on ABC Listen or wherever you get your podcasts.
0:37 Speaker 03 This podcast was produced on the lands of the Uwabakal and Gadigal people. In the middle of the deserts of Baluchistan, just next to the border between Iran and Pakistan, there's a mysterious little puddle of brown water, about 50 metres across. If you were to stand in the puddle up to your ankles and face west, you'd see a dead straight line of disturbed earth travelling hundreds of kilometres off over the horizon. So what is this straight line and puddle in the middle of the desert? Well, it's this.
1:14 Speaker 04 Pakistan and Iran have agreed to finalise plans for a gas pipeline project as soon as possible to meet Pakistan's energy requirements.
1:23 Speaker 03 For decades, Iran has been trying to build a pipeline to sell its gas to its eastern neighbours.
1:30 Speaker 05 It would run 2,615 kilometres from Iran to India through Pakistan.
1:36 Speaker 03 After more than a decade of negotiation and planning, Iran was confident it was going to happen.
1:41 Speaker 04 Iranian Foreign Minister Manouchi Mottaki said the two sides are committed to the project and would not allow any person or group to sabotage it.
1:50 Speaker 03 And so they built their bit of it.
1:52 Speaker 06 The work on the Iranian side is almost complete.
1:54 Speaker 03 Trouble was, Pakistan and India never built their bit. The result is a 1,000-kilometre pipeline capable of delivering enormous quantities of gas to that puddle in the Makran Desert, a few hundred metres from the Pakistani border. On the Pakistani side of the border, there are abandoned construction sites, gas terminals that were never built because the gas never actually arrived.
2:23 Speaker 03 Right now, I'm betting that Pakistan and India are seriously regretting not building their half. Because since the Strait of Hormuz has been closed, their fuel reserves are running dangerously low.
2:36 Speaker 07 Pakistan is bracing for an energy crunch. In India, a shortage of LPG has forced some kitchens to turn to firewood.
2:43 Speaker 03 Things are so bad in Pakistan that the government has taken measures to prevent people from driving to conserve fuel. Closing schools for two weeks. They have also ordered 50% of non-essential services staff to work from home. Pakistan relies on natural gas for more than a quarter of its energy supply, and it's at risk of running out of it before the end of April. If the pipeline was operating, it would allow Pakistan to bypass the current blockage of the Strait of Hormuz and access gas directly from the source. But they can't. And now, it's too late. As fuel prices continue to grow around the world, there's a lot of chat about ideas for
3:25 Speaker 03 infrastructure that could bypass the Strait of Hormuz. Ideas like this. A massive canal cutting through the mountains of Oman's Musun Dam Peninsula, allowing ships to bypass the strait entirely. Former US Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich, now a Fox News contributor, suggested a fast way to build this canal would be to use thermonuclear weapons to clear the terrain. Wow. Okay. The fascinating reality is, though, that over the last few decades, there have actually been a lot of projects proposed which could have solved the problem without the use of nuclear weapons. Almost none of those projects have been successful because something keeps getting in the way.
4:09 Speaker 03 I'll give you a hint. It starts with US and ends with A.
4:22 Speaker 03 So, what's going on here? We're in the midst of an entirely man-made energy crisis that is being blamed on Donald Trump, Benjamin Netanyahu and the Iranian government. While they might be to blame for the current situation, they aren't the ones who stopped all the previous attempts to mitigate it. Who did? And why? I'm Matt Bevan, and this is If You're Listening. The first and only time in post-World War II history that an American naval ship has been hit by missile fire was 39 years ago, in the Persian Gulf.
5:06 Speaker 03 The USS Stark was patrolling 75 miles north-east of Bahrain when the missiles slammed home. There was a huge fire aboard and many casualties too. The missiles had been launched from a nearby jet.
5:20 Speaker 05 The French-made Exocet missile was fired from 16 kilometres away, skimming low over the water and entering the hull through crew quarters below the bridge superstructure.
5:29 Speaker 03 The USS Stark had been in the Gulf protecting oil and gas tankers as the Iran-Iraq war entered its seventh year. They're trying to deter Iran from attacking the oil exports of countries which support its enemy in the Gulf War, Iraq. America was on Iraq's side of that particular conflict. An Iranian attack on an American frigate would be a significant escalation, but the missiles weren't fired by Iran. It was, the Americans believe, all a dreadful mistake. Iraqi planes fired the missiles at the wrong target.
6:05 Speaker 05 The Iraqi president Saddam Hussein sent a message to President Reagan saying the attack was accidental.
6:11 Speaker 03 Reagan accepted Saddam's explanation for the strike, which killed 37 American sailors. But he also put the US Navy on high alert.
6:20 Speaker 05 Tonight, on Mr Reagan's Orders, American ships in the Persian Gulf...
6:24 Speaker 04 are ready to fire if approached by any foreign ship or aircraft.
6:27 Speaker 03 A year later, that order led to tragedy.
6:31 Speaker 05 We believe that the cruiser USS Finnsands, protecting itself from what was concluded to be a hostile aircraft, shot down an Iranian airliner over the Straits of Hormuz.
6:41 Speaker 03 An identification error led to an American ship shooting an Iranian passenger aircraft out of the sky.
6:48 Speaker 05 The US government deeply regrets this incident.
6:52 Speaker 03 Two hundred and ninety people on board the airliner were killed.
6:56 Speaker 04 At Dubai Airport, relatives of the victims learned of the tragedy while waiting for the Airbus to arrive.
7:02 Speaker 03 It was a chaotic period in the Persian Gulf and in the Strait of Hormuz, which connects the Gulf to the rest of the ocean. While the strait wasn't closed to all traffic like it is now, tankers were being set on fire frequently by Iran and Iraq. There was a lot of disruption. In the mid eighties, the amount of oil coming through the Strait of Hormuz had dropped to around fifty percent of what it had been before the Iran-Iraq war started. The Gulf was an unstable and dangerous place to get a quarter of the world's oil from. There were thirty-seven dead American sailors and two hundred and ninety dead Iranian air travelers to prove it.
7:44 Speaker 03 In Washington, they were very aware of the situation.
7:48 Speaker 04 The unimpeded flow of oil through the Strait of Hormuz is of vital US interest. It's critical to the economic health of the Western world.
7:57 Speaker 03 We cannot allow Iran or anybody else to cut off the flow of oil through the Straits of Hormuz. The US was in the process of developing its own domestic oil supply, so it wouldn't need to buy oil from the Gulf. But even with their own supply, they wouldn't be totally insulated from the impact of global oil shocks.
8:17 Speaker 05 The world oil market is one market, and should Persian Gulf oil supplies be disrupted, the oil prices will rise for everyone.
8:25 Speaker 03 The resulting economic impacts would fall on the United States as well as on all oil-consuming nations, regardless of their sources of supply at the time. They were extremely aware forty years ago that a complete closure of the Straits of Hormuz by Iran would be catastrophic for the global economy and would be extremely complicated to fix. So, what were they going to do to stop it? Well, Plan A was to start building up US military capacity in the region to extraordinary levels, hoping to deter Iran from trying to close the strait. Plan B, well, obviously, Plan B would be to find a way to decrease the global economy's
9:09 Speaker 03 reliance on shipping traffic travelling through one very narrow waterway that can easily be held hostage by a hostile regime. In 1990, when the Iran-Iraq war and the subsequent Gulf War were over, about 20% of the global oil supply was going through the Straits of Hormuz. That was 36 years ago, and as of March 2026, when the strait was extremely predictably closed...
9:37 Speaker 00 About 20% of the world's oil and gas passes through the Strait of Hormuz.
9:42 Speaker 03 It appears that Plan B is "hope that Plan A works". The question is, why? Why has so little been done to deal with this obvious problem?
9:57 Speaker 03 Well, here's the thing. It's not because nobody thought of it. A lot of smart people have had a lot of good ideas for bypassing the strait, and they've been trying to get them operational for decades. Back in 1997, for instance, in the midst of the chaos in the Persian Gulf, an extremely nervous-looking German energy expert named Michael Renner explained that because Iran was blocking their oil tankers from getting through the strait, Iraq was finding ways of getting around the problem.
10:29 Speaker 04 It was compelled to construct a number of pipelines going through Saudi territory, Turkish territory, and also it is using overland routes, again, through Turkey and also through Jordan.
10:42 Speaker 03 When he says "overland routes", he means using big trucks to transport the oil, you know, like in Mad Max: Fury Road.
10:49 Speaker 04 New pipeline capacity has also been constructed by Saudi Arabia. And together the two countries will have a capacity of about six and a half million barrels per day by the end of this decade.
11:02 Speaker 03 So during the 1980s, the Saudis and Iraqis had built pipelines which would carry their oil to the port of Yambu on the Red Sea with a large enough capacity to carry a sizable chunk of the region's daily output.
11:16 Speaker 04 So in other words, two thirds of these exports no longer have to go through the Strait of Hormuz.
11:23 Speaker 03 Which worked well for a while. But in the years since, production in the Gulf has nearly tripled and the pipelines have only marginally increased their maximum capacity. Additionally, the port of Yambu, where the pipes deliver the oil, doesn't have the infrastructure to load it all onto ships. The pipelines can carry seven million barrels of oil a day. The port can only handle three or four million. The lack of capacity isn't because of any technical constraint. They just never bothered to build it. Why? Well, it would cost a lot of money, you see, and apparently nobody really thought that was worth it.
12:06 Speaker 03 They made a bet that Iran would never close the strait. A bet they have now lost. The thing is, a pipeline directly across Saudi Arabia is the best option for bypassing the Strait of Hormuz, purely because it would only have to run through one country. Because exporting oil across land borders can lead to problems when two countries disagree on something. Turkey has shut off Iraqi oil exports through its pipeline to the Mediterranean. And oil pipelines made easy targets for insurgent attacks after the US invasion of Iraq, for instance.
12:42 Speaker 05 It's believed the fire was started by a bomb exploded next to the pipeline by saboteurs.
12:48 Speaker 03 A proposal to build a pipeline linking the Iraqi oil fields to the Jordanian port of Akaba on the Red Sea sat in limbo for decades because it would mean that the pipeline ran within walking distance of the Israeli border. Opponents in Iraq argued that it will just mean that their oil ends up in Israel. Others were concerned that if the oil doesn't end up in Israel, the Israeli government will just attack the pipeline.
13:17 Speaker 03 So you can't bypass the Strait of Hormuz from Iraq to the Red Sea because of politics, and you can't bypass Hormuz across Saudi Arabia totally because of a lack of investment. If every pipeline capable of carrying oil around the Strait was running absolutely flat chat and just dumping oil directly onto ships, which is technically impossible, you still can't get even a third of the Gulf's oil loaded. But what about gas?
13:51 Speaker 03 Well, back in the 90s, Iran and Pakistan had a bright idea to build a gas pipeline.
13:57 Speaker 06 Pakistan and Iran have agreed to finalize plans for a gas pipeline project as soon as possible to meet Pakistan's energy requirements.
14:06 Speaker 03 The gas pipeline was set to deliver up to 5.2 billion cubic feet of natural gas per day from Iran into Pakistan. When it was first proposed in 1989, that was about five times more than Pakistan even needed. So planners looped India into the scheme as well.
14:24 Speaker 06 Pakistan's Foreign Minister is pressing India to move ahead quickly on a proposed $7 billion US dollar gas pipeline from Iran.
14:32 Speaker 03 Now, things were off to a rocky start because Pakistan and India are not exactly on the friendliest of terms. So the plan was a bit fraught from the get-go.
14:42 Speaker 06 Progress has been held up due to bickering over prices and Indian fears over the pipeline's security.
14:49 Speaker 03 But the project really came off the rails in 2005, when one very prominent critic emerged. You know the guy.
14:56 Speaker 06 The United States fears the pipeline will weaken efforts to isolate Iran of its disputed nuclear programme.
15:03 Speaker 03 The US had started a sanctions programme to try and squeeze Iran economically until they agreed to give up their nuclear weapons. By 2008, the US had managed to convince India to pull out of the deal by offering them a better one.
15:17 Speaker 06 The United States and India have agreed to begin plans to construct six nuclear plants to help the South Asian nation meet its energy needs.
15:25 Speaker 03 With India out, Pakistan was the only potential customer left. They seemed very keen, so keen that in 2013, the Pakistanis and Iranians held a ceremony near the border where they welded a few bits of pipe together to show that the project was going ahead. And well... It definitely half went ahead.
15:46 Speaker 06 Work on the Iran part is almost complete. Construction on the Pakistan side will now begin.
15:51 Speaker 03 It turns out the pipes being welded together were just props. But the ceremony was enough to get the US riled up and threaten Pakistan with sanctions.
16:00 Speaker 07 We have serious concerns if this project actually goes forward. The Iran sanctions act would be triggered. We've been straight up with the Pakistanis about these concerns.
16:09 Speaker 03 The US was concerned that if Iran had too many external revenue streams, the sanctions would have less of an impact.
16:16 Speaker 06 Washington's concerned it will also enable Iran to sell more gas and undermine US sanctions.
16:23 Speaker 03 The Obama administration had its reasons for trying to isolate Iran from the global energy market. But the ultimate failure of that strategy is now contributing to the current crisis. The Pakistanis never officially tore up the deal. They just kind of never got around to building their bit. Iran tried to force them to by pointing out that they had signed contracts. Pakistan still didn't build it. And as a result, the pipeline still ends at that little puddle in the middle of the desert.
16:58 Speaker 03 In the last few weeks, the US President Donald Trump has been saying that because the US produces its own oil and gas domestically, it's not their problem that the Strait of Hormuz is closed.
17:09 Speaker 05 You know, we don't use the strait. We don't, the United States, we don't need it.
17:14 Speaker 03 The thing is, when it comes to the global economy, that kind of doesn't matter. Why? Well, do you remember that clip from the US congressional hearing back in the 80s? This one.
17:24 Speaker 06 The world oil market is one market. And should Persian Gulf oil supplies be disrupted, the oil prices will rise for everyone. The resulting economic impacts would fall on the United States as well as on all oil consuming nations.
17:38 Speaker 03 Regardless of their sources of supply at the time. The global oil and gas market seems big and complicated, but it's not really. There are producers and there are consumers. There's a million different ways the products get from the producers to the consumers, but it's all one market. If Pakistan can't get gas from the Gulf, either through the Strait of Hormuz or from the Puddle Pipeline, they'll bid against the rest of the world to find other sources of gas. That bidding process will drive up the price of that gas. When the Strait of Hormuz closed, stranding all that oil and gas in the Gulf, it meant that the entire world had to start bidding for the stuff that wasn't stranded.
18:23 Speaker 03 Anything that gets in the way of these products being transported from the producers to the consumers is going to affect all consumers. Every bit of oil and gas that can escape the Gulf, no matter where it's going, helps bring down prices. But we can't get it out of there. All the opportunities in the past to avoid a crisis like this were either mothballed due to inertia or blocked by the US. As a result, Pakistan might run out of gas within days, which would see the country grind to a halt. Other countries are similarly desperate. Here in Australia, we probably won't run out of fuel, but it might become extraordinarily expensive.
19:07 Speaker 03 Donald Trump says he knew about the threat to the Strait of Hormuz before he started this. He says everyone knew. That might be the case. But the people who knew didn't actually do anything to prepare for it if it ever happened. They only had forty years.
19:32 Speaker 03 If You're Listening is written by me, Matt Peven. Supervising producer is Cara Jensen-McKinnon. It's produced by Adair Shepherd and Pat Sunderland. This Sunday afternoon, Adair, Pat and I will be appearing at the Newcastle Writers Festival. There are a few tickets left, but if you can't be there, we will be recording it for the podcast. You will hear it at some point in the future. On Tuesday, though, we are going to be taking a closer look at the bombing of the USS Stark by Iraqi forces in 1987. Because the more you investigate this story, the stranger it is. I'll catch you then.
Previous Why Iran is building their own internet Next When Iraq accidentally bombed a U.S. warship Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated