Pod Insights If You're Listening NEOM: The world's dumbest megaproject About this episode The massive infrastructure project NEOM sits in the Saudi Arabian desert, and the jewel in its crown is The Line, a futuristic city which looks insane. The AI-generated ads depict a car-free city, for 9 million people housed between two mirrors, stretching along the desert. Despite promises of millions of residents by 2030, the project has been scaled back by 98 per cent. The Line will be more like a dot. So what the hell happened? And was it all just a scam?
This episode was originally broadcast in September 2024
Follow If You're Listening on the ABC Listen app https://radio.abc.net.au/help/apps.
Check out our series on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDTPrMoGHssAfgMMS3L5LpLNFMNp1U_Nq
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:09 Speaker 01 Hi, I'm Patricia Carvallis, the host of Politics Now, the ABC's podcast unpacking the latest political news when it happens. Every weekday you'll hear me and the sharpest political minds at the ABC.
0:22 Speaker 02 Me, Jacob Greba.
0:23 Speaker 03 Me, Raf Epstein.
0:24 Speaker 02 Me, Fodi Alon. Me, David Spears.
0:26 Speaker 04 And me, Frank Kelly, for the party room every Thursday.
0:30 Speaker 01 So join me for Politics Now, download and follow on the ABC Listen app.
0:36 Speaker 05 This podcast was produced on the lands of the Uwabakal and Gadigal people. G'day, Matt Bevan here. The If You're Listening team is on summer holidays, which means we're hopefully sitting poolside and not thinking about the news. Ha ha. So here's an episode from the archives. If you're like me, you've seen a lot of ads on social media for something called NEOM.
0:58 Speaker 06 What is NEOM? This is NEOM.
1:03 Speaker 05 NEOM is a massive infrastructure project in the Saudi Arabian desert. And the jewel in its crown is the line, a futuristic city which looks insane.
1:15 Speaker 06 A 500 metre high, 200 metre wide, 170 kilometre long city in the shape of, well, a line.
1:22 Speaker 05 The AI-generated ads depict a car-free city for nine million people housed in a 200 metre space between two mirrors stretching along the desert. There are no roads.
1:37 Speaker 06 And everything its nine million residents could ever need within a five-minute walk.
1:42 Speaker 05 There's a service layer below which supplies the buildings and under that layer are trains. Nearby is the rest of NEOM. There's a floating business park in the shape of an octagon.
1:57 Speaker 05 There's an island resort in the Red Sea. There's also a ski resort in the middle of the desert. They're planning to make snow. It's the biggest construction project in modern history and all aimed at shifting the centre of international business in the Middle East from Dubai to Saudi Arabia.
2:18 Speaker 06 Or here, to be more precise, in the north-west of Saudi Arabia.
2:22 Speaker 05 Except it's not here.
2:29 Speaker 05 Despite promises of millions of residents by 2030, the project has been scaled back by 98%. The line will be more like a dot. So what the hell happened? And was it all just a big scam? I'm Matt Bevan, and this is If You're Listening.
2:55 Speaker 05 NEOM is the brainchild of the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia, a man who is more complicated than he seems. There's really two versions of him. One is Mohammed bin Salman al-Saud, the traditionally dressed heir to the throne in the ultra-conservative Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. And then there's MBS, the nickname he goes by when he's dressed in jeans and a blazer and meeting with Silicon Valley businessmen.
3:28 Speaker 05 In 2018, he was being MBS, travelling the world and making it clear that he wanted to be a major player in the future of the global economy. He used Saudi government money to make big investments in big tech companies like Uber, Boeing, Facebook and Disney, hoping that the bets would prove to be winners both financially and for his reputation. You see, Saudi Arabia has a problem, a pretty obvious one really. And that is that there is almost nothing in it at all. For most of the last 1,000 years, only a small population of nomadic Bedouin tribes
4:09 Speaker 05 lived there, in one of the hottest, driest places on earth.
4:14 Speaker 07 There is a biblical curse on the Middle East, that the land shall be desolate and the rivers shall run like oil.
4:20 Speaker 05 But then, all that changed. Since oil money started flowing into Saudi Arabia, its population has gone up enormously. But Mohammed bin Salman knows that oil money isn't forever and will likely start to dry up soon after he inherits a country with 20 times the population of the one that his grandfather ruled over. So ever since he became heir to the throne in 2017, the business prince has been trying to plan ahead.
4:54 Speaker 05 And that's how he came up with his big idea. Four months into his tenure, he held an event in the Saudi capital Riyadh called "The Future Investment Initiative". All sorts of global business figures were there, but he was the headliner.
5:10 Speaker 07 Let me introduce the vision behind that growth story. Please welcome to the stage, ladies and gentlemen, His Royal Highness, Prince Mohammed bin Salman.
5:22 Speaker 05 And his big announcement, the project that could save Saudi Arabia and make it the economic capital of the region, was NEOM.
5:30 Speaker 03 A roadmap for the future of civilization. We see a new way, a new era. We see NEOM.
5:39 Speaker 05 The thing about this video was, it was actually really quite familiar.
5:49 Speaker 05 You see, the idea of a brand new city has been tried before, a few times in fact, like King Abdullah Economic City.
5:58 Speaker 03 Imagine a city, a unique partnership between government and the private sector. At the crossroads between east and west.
6:06 Speaker 05 This was launched in 2005 by the former Saudi king.
6:10 Speaker 03 A new world city for Saudi Arabia, a new Saudi Arabian city for the world.
6:16 Speaker 05 It looks a lot like NEOM, but this is a completely different project with basically the same marketing.
6:23 Speaker 03 King Abdullah Economic City, our story is only just beginning.
6:31 Speaker 05 But after 13 years, that story still hasn't really begun. Only 7,000 people were living in King Abdullah Economic City.
6:42 Speaker 05 Despite having high-speed rail connections to three of the country's biggest cities, it's still just a small town, less than 1% of its projected size. A government official told The Financial Times that "The marketing was amazing, but the whole concept behind it was flawed because the economic base was never there."
7:05 Speaker 05 There are cities like this all over the Middle East. Ghost towns, dreams of paradise, cooked up by oil-rich kings and dictators. In Turkey, there's a city built of 732 identical castles, all of which look like the Disney logo. It has been abandoned. In Iran, there are a number of cities surrounding the capital Tehran with completed towers standing empty. The issue is usually that there are not enough jobs to sustain a population. Creating a city out of nothing does work sometimes. Just take Australia's capital city, Canberra. The industry there is the Australian federal government,
7:48 Speaker 05 which creates a lot of jobs in the public service. But even then, Canberra's founders thought it would rival London in size. A hundred years on, London is still 22 times bigger than Canberra. NEOM has no industries, or, um, water. But that's only the start of its problems.
8:15 Speaker 05 At a basic level, building anything in Saudi Arabia has been a tricky thing in the last six years. When MBS first came to power and started spruiking his business-minded vision for the future and minor human rights reforms, there was initial excitement. It caused a surge in foreign investment. But then, investors got cold feet after he started locking up his political opponents.
8:41 Speaker 02 Dozens of princes and senior officials were detained in Riyadh's Ritz-Carlton in November as part of a purge against graft and disloyalty.
8:50 Speaker 05 And killing dissident journalists.
8:52 Speaker 03 Jamal Khashoggi was murdered just minutes after he walked into Saudi Arabia's consulate in Istanbul in October 2018.
9:00 Speaker 05 For two years after MBS allegedly ordered the murder of a Washington Post journalist, foreign investment in Saudi Arabia ground to a halt.
9:09 Speaker 04 Since the gruesome murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi, its international reputation has been low.
9:15 Speaker 05 It's only now that things are starting to warm up again. But the other, much bigger problem with NEOM is that just because the ideas behind it are exciting and different, doesn't mean that they're good. Bloomberg reporter Vivian Nierem spent six months looking into the project and told the ABC that the ideas are literally based on science fiction.
9:37 Speaker 00 Quite a lot of the ideas that they're working on are drawn from and inspired by literal science fiction works, you know, whether it be films or, or books, you know, or TV series. So there are architects and designers and scholars who are basically, you know, sent to draw inspiration from science fiction.
9:57 Speaker 05 She says that some of the stuff in the plan is, well...
10:00 Speaker 00 There's even an urban spaceport, sort of like a place that spacecrafts could land.
10:05 Speaker 05 I'm going to be very generous now and pretend that NEOM has enough investment and that it isn't total sci-fi fantasy. So let me paint you a picture of what it would be like to live there.
10:21 Speaker 05 Shops, workplaces, friends, family, all of them will be either above you, below you, or up to 170 kilometres away, up the line. Basically, this means that you have to rely on lifts and trains to transport you literally anywhere you want to go, all somehow run by AI.
10:40 Speaker 04 What if we replace outdated urban services with new services driven by artificial intelligence?
10:46 Speaker 05 I am personally a huge fan of public transport and trains specifically, but this idea is very much not good. Because humans are like the king in a game of chess, great at going short distances in any direction. We don't like travelling far and we don't really like climbing. But the line breaks all of those principles, not to mention the fact that the trains may be fast, but you will have to stop extremely frequently. You'll also spend a huge amount of time queuing for lifts and standing in lifts that also stop very frequently. Or you can take the stairs. It'll only take 3,000 stairs to get
11:29 Speaker 05 from the bottom to the top of the city. This thing, remember, is significantly taller than the Eiffel Tower. The wonderful futuristic city would very quickly start to feel like some kind of Star Wars-themed dystopian prison planet.
11:46 Speaker 05 Building a city in a long, straight line just doesn't make any practical sense. And we know this because the line isn't a totally new idea. It's been tried before in Spain. The Ciudad Lineal, or Line City, was 400 metres across, based around a central boulevard with a tram running down the middle, and was built on the outskirts of Madrid. And guess what? The line part of the Line City has disappeared. They started with a narrow line, but then almost immediately, the city expanded and it's now completely surrounded by development.
12:26 Speaker 05 Okay, back to NEOM. Back in April, Bloomberg reported that "The line is going to be slightly less than 170 kilometres long. It's going to be about 2.4 kilometres long, which is 98% shorter." Investment, even from Saudi sources, is drying up. The project managers are now considering borrowing money to keep construction going. All of this adds insult to injury for the several thousand local people who have been forcibly removed from their homes to make way for construction of the line. But politically, the person most affected by this is MBS.
13:06 Speaker 04 The Saudi government is trying to build an economy less dependent on oil, reform its reputation and attract international investment. It needs projects like NEOM to succeed.
13:19 Speaker 05 I think it's clear what's happened here. At the age of 32, MBS became the de facto ruler of a country with enormous but limited wealth, and tried to build a future for it using ideas that were straight out of science fiction. Simultaneously, he purged anyone who posed a threat to him, leaving him with only yes men. Then he threw the ideas out into the world, offering big contracts to international companies who wanted to help him. Now, these companies don't care if the idea is good. The project's Western consultants, designers, architects, marketing gurus, advertising executives, voiceover artists and animators get paid by the hour.
14:03 Speaker 05 Why would you not want to work for Neon, apart from like, ethics lol? It's a bucket of money with only very vague outcomes way off in the future. We started this episode by asking whether this is a scam or not, and I think it is. But it's not us who's being scammed, it's not the people building it either. It's MBS. They are hiring now, if you're interested.
Previous What's the deal with fluoride? Next Trump’s playbook for Nicolás Maduro and Venezuela Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated