Pod Insights If You're Listening Matt's producers present the weirdest tales from the basement About this episode From engineers with god complexes to elite athletes prone to being struck by lightning, Matt’s producers Pat and Adair bring the strangest stories that haven’t made it into a story of If You’re Listening.
You can listen to Matt Bevan's episode of Conversations here https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/conversations/matt-bevan-if-youre-listening-history-butterfly-effect/106606980
Follow If You're Listening on the ABC Listen app https://radio.abc.net.au/help/apps.
Check out our series on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDTPrMoGHssAfgMMS3L5LpLNFMNp1U_Nq
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:08 Speaker 01 What's on the mind of the country's biggest, most influential and most innovative business leaders, founders and creators?
0:14 Speaker 02 You're in a very pessimistic place, Alan.
0:17 Speaker 01 You get to find out every Friday with me, Alan Kohler, as I sit down with the people influencing the markets, the economy and the ideas shaping our world.
0:25 Speaker 02 I gauge regularly enthusiastically with the tech sector and some of these big players in AI.
0:32 Speaker 01 Find That's Business with Alan Kohler on the ABC Business Daily Feed on ABC Listen or wherever you get your podcasts.
0:38 Speaker 03 This podcast was produced on the lands of the Uabakal and Gadigal people.
0:49 Speaker 03 G'day, Matt Bevan here, this is If You're Listening. Today, the second part of the Newcastle Writers' Festival live show that we did last month. In case you missed the first part, this was all about me and my producers Pat Sunderland and Adair Shepherd, sharing the stories we couldn't find time for in the show's regular schedule. I shared my story last week and this time it's Pat and Adair's turn. They came up with some very strange stories that I think you'll love.
1:21 Speaker 04 So I want to give you guys a bit of context to start this story. This is a story that came at the start of the year when the Black Swan series was airing. And sort of ironically, we were trying to predict what the most newsy story would be once we returned to regular programming. And as sort of quaint as the idea seems now, for a time, we thought that was going to be the US and Greenland. We thought that was going to be the first thing we're going to have to address. And then Trump sort of went, oh, never mind, I don't want it.
1:49 Speaker 03 Do you guys remember Greenland?
1:50 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:52 Speaker 03 I was actually thinking, you know, we've got these extra production resources, maybe we could go to Greenland. Then I found out how long it takes to fly to Greenland and I'm glad that, you know, we moved on from that.
2:03 Speaker 04 Exactly. But for a little time there, I was researching Greenland and looking into the history of US-Greeneeland relationships, the times in the past that the US has tried to buy Greenland. And I came across this image. This is a hypothetical map of the United States. You might notice it includes Greenland. If you're a real map expert, you might also notice that it includes Canada.
2:28 Speaker 04 It also includes Mexico, all of Central America, and Cuba, and a big chunk of South America as well.
2:35 Speaker 03 And all of the West Indies.
2:36 Speaker 04 Oh yeah, they're getting all of it. Anything that could conceivably described as America adjacent.
2:43 Speaker 03 I like that they've done a dotted line around the edge because they want half of the Pacific Ocean as well.
2:48 Speaker 04 Yeah. Look, they're not greedy, just half.
2:51 Speaker 03 Yep.
2:51 Speaker 04 So what this is, is the technate of America, and it was the proposal of a political and social movement in America. They're called Technocracy. So I want to set the scene for you guys. Imagine it's the 1930s, right? We've just had World War I, the Great Depression is happening, everyone is unsatisfied with the way that society is being run.
3:10 Speaker 03 Imagine.
3:11 Speaker 04 I know, why would you? And so there's plenty of pitches for how we should do things differently. People are pitching communism, socialism, futurism, fascism, all of it. And then you're walking past a newsagent and you see this political magazine.
3:26 Speaker 03 Here, Pat is showing the cover of the 1933 Technocrats magazine depicting a very intimidating giant robot marching on Capitol Hill, holding thunderbolts in its hand.
3:38 Speaker 04 How's this for an advertisement for your political party?
3:42 Speaker 03 Oh yeah.
3:43 Speaker 00 Yeah.
3:43 Speaker 04 That is how to say, I mean, if Karl Marx had put King Kong on the front of Das Kapital, we'd all be speaking Russian or German right now. Like, this is how you advertise. This is the first edition of the Technocrats magazine.
3:57 Speaker 03 Sorry, to be clear, they were advocating for this?
4:00 Speaker 04 They're kind of saying, "We can be the giant robot, holding thunderbolts, walking onto Capitol Hill." So Technocrats, in a modern sense, means any form of government where you put someone with technological expertise in charge, like an economist in charge of a country going through a financial crisis. But what this party, Technocracy, believed is that all of society's problems were because we were not running it efficiently enough. And so, society needs to be run more like a factory, more like an assembly line, and so you should put engineers in charge. Electrical engineers, technical engineers. They shouldn't be elected, they should just be put in charge to build giant robots that will make us all live happier lives, for some reason.
4:41 Speaker 03 So how many people are on board with this idea so far?
4:43 Speaker 04 Yeah.
4:45 Speaker 04 And can I say, they're pitching a universal basic income of $20,000 a year. At that time, that was $450,000. That was their pitch, they knew how to sell. Now, every movement needs a charismatic leader. And the leader of technocracy in New York in the 1930s was a guy called Howard C. Scott. This fellow.
5:07 Speaker 00 That's great, sir.
5:07 Speaker 04 He looks pretty cool. Now, he became the leader of technocracy for a few main reasons. Firstly, he had all these accreditations. He had so many doctorates in engineering. He had all the stuff backing up his cred as an engineer. His second reason was that he knew how to make the idea more interesting politically. He could get other engineers on board, and he introduced like a doomsday element to this political theory. Basically, if you don't put engineers in charge, we're gonna have millions of people out of work. We're gonna have wars, we're gonna have famine. You need to put engineers in charge. The third and most important reason why everyone liked him, which you can't get from this image, is that he was six foot five.
5:50 Speaker 04 In 1933, that's like being 13 foot tall today. This guy was the giant robot from the cover of the magazine, alright?
5:59 Speaker 03 I see the resemblance.
6:00 Speaker 04 Yeah.
6:00 Speaker 03 Instead of lightning bulbs, he's got a cigarette in his hand.
6:02 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, and a cool hat.
6:04 Speaker 03 Yeah, rad.
6:05 Speaker 04 So, under Howard Scott's leadership, technocracy really took off. Engineers started to gather. The New York Times wrote a bunch of periodicals about it, and membership was increasing. It was really starting to catch on. The only issue was that as it got more popular, more and more critics of the movement appeared. People who said, "You don't seem to be very specific about any of the solutions you're offering", stuff like that. So Howard came up with a plan. He would hold a massive speech at the Hotel Pierre in New York. He would invite hundreds of people to this speech, naysayers, supporters, journalists, engineers, everyone. And he would broadcast it nationwide. And this speech was going to really sell the idea of technocracy.
6:49 Speaker 04 He was gonna prove why it was important, why it was essential. He gave this speech, and this is the headline from the New York Times the next day. "400 Leaders Hear Technocracy Plea: Howard Scott Leaves Bankers Skeptical on New Solution, 'Bewildering' One Says."
7:05 Speaker 04 He bombed, he tanked it. How could they be skeptical of such a large man? I know, he could easily crush them, I don't understand. I have some quotes here from the New York Times. "Most hearers were disappointed with what they regarded as a confused presentation. Older women who were present said they did not feel any wiser, but were a great deal gloomier."
7:32 Speaker 04 My favorite was, uh, there was a comedian in attendance, Will Rogers. He was a famous silent film star and a social satirist. And his quote in the Times was that technocracy was gonna have the same shelf life as miniature golf. Which he meant as a burn, but we've still got miniature golf, right? That was way more popular than he was giving it credit, we love miniature golf. This speech has been cited by a number of historians looking into this movement as the key moment that sort of killed technocracy. He did the speech that badly. The other factor was that journalists started to look into Howard Scott after this speech and discovered he never went to university.
8:14 Speaker 04 He didn't even graduate from high school. His engineering experience was a little bit of combat engineering in World War I and he ran a floor wax company. Which, you know, maybe you can call yourself an engineer, but you can't lead a political party whose whole point is, "Let's be the smartest engineers and let's rule the world." So this was essentially the death of technocracy as a legitimate political movement. But Howard Scott had one trick left up his sleeve. After World War II, everyone was sad about the way things were being run again because we had just had another awful war. Howard Scott by this time had moved all of his most loyal followers from New York, where everyone was making fun of him, to Los Angeles, where everyone was like, "Cool, and who cares?"
8:56 Speaker 04 And he decided to launch one massive last burst of publicity. He called it Operation Columbia.
9:07 Speaker 05 It is suggested that we travel US Highway 99 from Los Angeles to Vancouver. On the way back, we could travel Coast Highway 101, making lecture stops at all major cities en route.
9:18 Speaker 04 So the idea was that we're gonna lead a massive speaking tour. They were gonna get all the technocrats into a massive motorcade of cars. And they were gonna drive all the way up the coast and all the way back down, giving speeches, holding rallies, and drumming up interest in technocracy. Which seems like a fairly good idea, right? That's how you spread word of mouth. The only issue is that, post-World War II, Howard Scott had become quite invested in the aesthetic of the Nazis. Oh no! Everyone in his organization wore these gray suits. They painted all their cars gunmetal gray. They put their weird pseudo-religious political logos on the side of the cars.
9:59 Speaker 04 And they would lead these massive motorcades without any announcement of what was going on. All the way up the coast. I don't wanna make the obvious comparison, but this is two years after the end of World War II. The Nazis are as recent to these people as Wicked Part 1 is to us. It's still very much part of the conversation. I wanna show you the end of this propaganda film they put out. And just think to yourself, does this give you hope about the future? Or does it give you bad vibes?
10:28 Speaker 00 From dawn till dusk, they are working for technocracy. Let's roll in the tech mate on the wheels of an official gray car. Salute and happy landings!
10:45 Speaker 04 I did not add this music, ladies and gentlemen. This is the music they... That's the music they put to their own propaganda film! It's an incredibly bad vibe! So unsurprisingly, Operation Columbia was another tremendous failure. The media response ranged from ridicule to, "Who the hell are these new Nazis?" And it was essentially the final death knell for the movement. New membership slowed to a trickle. Howard Scott died in 1970. There are still some technocrats around. They call themselves Technocracy Incorporated. But they barely do not exist anymore. I went onto their official website, it is abandoned. And that's what I thought was the end of the story.
11:29 Speaker 04 But there is one important legacy that technocrats still have today. While all this was happening in the US, there was a sister movement in Canada. Technocracy had a really big moment at the same time. And that was led by a chiropractor called Joshua Haldeman. Does this man look familiar to anyone in the crowd? No. No.
11:49 Speaker 00 No.
11:50 Speaker 04 What if I would compare him to this man?
11:52 Speaker 03 Here Pat shows a picture of Elon Musk.
11:55 Speaker 04 Oh god. Joshua Haldeman, the chiropractor, a man who fervently believed in the idea that engineers should rule the world, is the maternal grandfather of Elon Musk. Luckily, Elon Musk shows no sign of following in his grandfather's belief that engineers should rule the world, but he does believe that they should rule a world.
12:20 Speaker 06 Yeah, anyway, this is like an incredible thing to have like this amazing city on Mars. And it's also an opportunity for the Martians to rethink how they want civilization to be. So you can maybe rethink like what kind of form of government do you want?
12:35 Speaker 04 And that's my presentation on technocracy. Thank you very much.
12:39 Speaker 07 Oh my god.
12:45 Speaker 07 That was incredible. I've got to say, I don't feel wiser, but I do feel gloomier after that presentation.
12:51 Speaker 04 Exactly.
12:52 Speaker 07 Mine's a bit different. I kind of came across this story a few weeks ago because I've been very into the Asia Cup. I went to the final. Can I get a cheer for Tilly's? Yeah. Um, today, I'm going to be talking about a man who's a real champion of women's football. This is someone who's been promoting the women's game since the 90s, and that is...
13:16 Speaker 03 Here Adair shows a picture of former Supreme Leader of North Korea, Kim Jong-il.
13:21 Speaker 07 Oh. Yeah. So, yeah, you might have been surprised to see the People's Republic of Korea at the Asia Cup, but they have a long history with women's soccer. And Kim has been championing it since before there was the first Women's World Cup, because the first men's FIFA World Cup was in 1930. But the first women's one wasn't until 1991. And about five years before that, when they'd kind of decided that the women's game was going to grow, before he had become the leader, before he'd succeeded his father in the mid-eighties, he took over the management of the athletics and sport departments in North Korea. And he really saw a real potential in women's football. And he announced that they'd establish eighteen teams.
14:05 Speaker 07 He put programs into schools and into villages. He really invested in soccer. And it wasn't long before it paid off. They were like insanely dominant. Like, they were so incredible at women's soccer. They, from 2001 to 2008, they won three Asia Cup titles. And they reached the quarterfinals in the FIFA World Cup. And they were ranked fifth in the world throughout this time. And also, it was incredibly popular, like, the attendance was crazy. The Tillys played a match in North Korea, one of the first home games that North Korea ever played, in 1998. And fifty-eight thousand people were watching. They may have been forced to be there, but I think it still counts, you know?
14:48 Speaker 07 And this is like consistently tens of thousands of people watching these games. It was massive. They'd be recognized on the street. Like, this is a time that women's football here was not a big deal, but it was, these guys were celebrities. Yeah, Kim Jong-il was not only a champion of women's sports, he was also a champion of the arts. In North Korea, they make one drama every year. And in 2011, the drama that they made was called Our Women's Football Team. I couldn't understand any of it. Also, what's the point of a TV show about women's soccer without a single lesbian in it? So, there's no point. There were some weird plotlines as well, like... Players being too individualistic and being scolded for it. It was a very interesting vibe. Um, here's a clip, since the title's still going.
15:34 Speaker 03 So, the scene Adair plays here shows a couple of North Korean women's soccer players walking past some kids playing basketball. One of the soccer players picks up the basketball and kicks it with her foot straight through the hoop. Everyone cheers.
15:51 Speaker 07 They're lesbians, but come on.
15:52 Speaker 03 Yeah.
15:53 Speaker 07 Come on.
15:54 Speaker 03 She's so demure after having done it. I would be like, ugh!
15:59 Speaker 07 But actually, around this time, um, things started to change for the North Korean women's football team.
16:05 Speaker 03 Oh, okay.
16:06 Speaker 07 Um, yeah, so firstly, in 2010, you might know this, but, uh, after consecutive wins at the Asia Cup, the Tillys beat them in the Asia Cup final in 2010. And I think that was the start of the end. I think Sam Kerr undid it all.
16:21 Speaker 03 Yeah.
16:21 Speaker 07 Because, a year later, at the 2011 FIFA World Cup, North Korea didn't play very well in their first round against the US. And at the press conference afterwards, I want you to guess what the coach blamed the loss for.
16:36 Speaker 03 Capitalism.
16:37 Speaker 07 Yeah.
16:39 Speaker 03 Lesbianism?
16:40 Speaker 07 Yeah. Close. He said that they were struck by lightning.
16:46 Speaker 03 Ah, of course, yeah.
16:49 Speaker 07 Yeah.
16:50 Speaker 03 That always throws you off your game.
16:51 Speaker 07 Yeah. And this was kind of only the start. Basically, he said that a month earlier, they'd been struck by lightning at a training game. Five players had been struck by lightning.
17:01 Speaker 03 I feel like that should, like, if stories are the way that they are in comic books, that should make them more powerful. Yeah.
17:08 Speaker 07 Yeah, but they were playing very well. But that was just the beginning, because a few weeks later, five of them tested positive for steroids.
17:16 Speaker 03 Ah.
17:17 Speaker 07 Yeah.
17:18 Speaker 03 I thought you were gonna say tested positive for 5,000 volts.
17:23 Speaker 07 Well, it's not far off because the explanation they gave, so FIFA said that the substance they found had never been discovered before. And the North Koreans, they explained it by saying that it was a traditional medicine from the glands of a musk deer. So that's what, that's this animal.
17:40 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah. You can tell that animal's good at soccer.
17:44 Speaker 03 Does that animal have fangs?
17:45 Speaker 07 Yeah.
17:46 Speaker 03 Is that a vampire deer?
17:47 Speaker 07 Yeah. I'm confused about where the gland is. Some of them said that the gland is near the fangs and some of them said it's in the butt, but I'm not sure. So the reason that they had taken this substance was to treat the lightning strike. Yeah.
18:04 Speaker 04 Nothing kills what else you.
18:06 Speaker 03 We thought it was anti-lightning medicine. That's great.
18:10 Speaker 07 Um, so FIFA for some reason didn't believe this explanation. I don't know why. And it was a big scandal. It was one of the biggest doping scandals ever at a like major FIFA event. They were fined $400,000 and they were banned from the next World Cup. And this ban, like it wasn't just a hiccup.
18:31 Speaker 07 After 2011, they hadn't played in a tournament for 15 years. This really wiped them out. And this Asia Cup was the first time they had played in 15 years. And it was meant to be their comeback. And of course they were knocked out in the quarterfinals by the Matildas.
18:48 Speaker 03 I feel like you've been telling this story for like 10 minutes and I'm already on North Korea's side. Like, you said they got wiped out by the Matildas. I was like, damn it.
19:00 Speaker 07 This isn't the end of the story because while the North Korean women's team has been AWOL for 15 years, the youth teams have been absolutely dominating because it runs in the family. Another champion of women's sport is Kim Jong-un. And he has established this soccer school called the Pyongyang International Soccer School. I don't think there's any international players in it, but it's international. Um, and the biggest stadium in the world is also in North Korea. And he's just put a bunch of money into soccer, basically. And because there are sanctions on North Korea, these players can't play overseas. They only play with each other from seven years old. And like the Tillys are off playing with all different teams. They're not playing together as much.
19:45 Speaker 07 These, they play together incredibly and the under 17s.
19:51 Speaker 07 Um, team are like so incredibly dominant, there are conspiracy theories about it. They have won um four under seventeen's World Cups, which is twice as many as any other team. The last one, uh, the twenty twenty five one, they only conceded three goals in the entire tournament and scored twenty five. And that's the most goals ever scored in the history of the tournament.
20:14 Speaker 03 Okay.
20:15 Speaker 07 Um, they are just so insanely dominant and there's all these conspiracies that they're actually older than they are to try and explain it. So there's like a new golden generation. The North Korean women's soccer team is gonna be insane in the next few years. Watch out for North Korea, basically. We saw.
20:35 Speaker 03 This is the most cheerful context that watch out for North Korea has ever been said.
20:41 Speaker 03 This is the most feel good to watch out for North Korea story.
20:45 Speaker 07 These sixteen year olds in a few years might be, it might be a whole team of Sam Kers.
20:49 Speaker 03 Pending lightning strikes, of course.
20:51 Speaker 07 Of course.
20:52 Speaker 03 And the population of the Musk deer. Yeah, with Korea. Very good. Adair, thank you very much.
21:05 Speaker 03 Thanks to Pat and Adair for coming along. It was a fantastic show. If you want to hear my story, it's in our podcast feed from last week. You can also hear more stories in my interview with Richard Fidler on Conversations last Wednesday. We'll put a link in the show notes today. There was an issue with how it was published initially in the convo's feed, but it's all fixed now. On Thursday, we're gonna be taking a look at Palantir, the forebodingly named tech company that is getting involved in everything from government surveillance to airstrike targeting to the supply chain for your local supermarket. I'll see you then.
Previous The unexpected loser of the Iran war Next How did Palantir get so powerful? Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated