Pod Insights If You're Listening Making sense of Trump’s attack on Iran About this episode Matt and Kara answer your questions about the the unfolding situation in the Middle East.
Who are the contenders for new leadership, how will this attack impact the global oil trade and does Donald Trump actually have a master plan?
Follow If You're Listening on the ABC Listen app https://radio.abc.net.au/help/apps.
Check out our series on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDTPrMoGHssAfgMMS3L5LpLNFMNp1U_Nq
Transcript 4,282 words · 12 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:08 Speaker 00 Hey there, I'm Dominique Baynes, host of a new podcast I'm super excited to share with you. It's called Expanse: The Nanup Four, about the mysterious vanishing of four people two decades ago and their world of cults and hidden identities. Stick around after this episode of If You're Listening to hear a teaser of what you can expect when episode one drops on March 3rd.
0:32 Speaker 01 This podcast was produced on the lands of the Uwabakal and Gadigal people.
0:43 Speaker 01 G'day, Matt Bevan here, this is If You're Listening. Well, it's been an interesting weekend.
0:48 Speaker 02 A short time ago, the United States military began major combat operations in Iran.
0:56 Speaker 03 The Israeli-US joint strikes began in broad daylight, hitting multiple Iranian cities, including the capital. In Iran, people celebrated near the Ayatollah's destroyed compound as news spread of the 86-year-old dictator's death from Israeli and US bombs.
1:12 Speaker 04 The strikes have been met with fierce retaliation from the regime, launching missiles and drones at countries across the Middle East.
1:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, a bit going on. It's ironically perfect timing for us. We've just completed our three episodes on Jeffrey Epstein and we're intending to do a number of episodes on Iran. And Donald Trump delivered an extraordinary amount of information on our doorstep that we are going to be filtering into an Iran series that will be rolling out from Thursday here on the podcast and on Saturday on YouTube and TV. There's a lot to talk about and Cara Jensen-McKinnon is here with me. G'day Cara.
1:55 Speaker 00 Hello, we've got a lot to say.
2:02 Speaker 01 Yes, I've got a lot of hot takes, but I want to hear first from you. Where were you when your phone started blowing up with this information?
2:09 Speaker 05 Oh my God. So I was in a great space because I was in the mosh at the Sydney Olympic Park for Bad Bunny.
2:18 Speaker 01 Nice.
2:18 Speaker 05 Who was performing on Saturday night.
2:25 Speaker 05 So I was right in the middle. A lot of people around me, I'm trying to get a good spot, vying for a perfect position. My phone starts buzzing and I'm thinking it's people commenting on videos that I'm posting, but it's actually several notifications coming through from The Guardian, from Reuters, from New York Times, from BBC, all of the subscriptions that I have, telling me that Israel and then the United States have launched a coordinated bombing campaign on Iran.
2:55 Speaker 06 We begin with breaking news this evening. Israel has launched airstrikes against Iran.
3:01 Speaker 05 Absolutely not the sort of thing that you want to hear when you're trying to get into the zone for Bad Bunny.
3:05 Speaker 01 Not really Bad Bunny's vibe.
3:06 Speaker 05 It's not really Bad Bunny's vibe. I started messaging you. My phone reception was way down because obviously everyone's uploading things to Instagram. A couple of hours later, I get more notifications saying that Iran has launched retaliation strikes and that they had hit a building in Tel Aviv and several military bases. Again, I'm like jostling and trying to look at my phone at the same, trying to kind of manage and keep the vibe up, but also looking at extremely serious news happening and really, really not being able to do anything about it. I didn't have my laptop in the mosh, you'd be surprised to hear, but I really
3:47 Speaker 05 just had to enjoy the Bad Bunny mosh, knowing that that was going to be what the next couple of days would look like for me.
3:53 Speaker 01 At concerts these days, of course, you have to watch the performance through a sea of phones being held up.
3:59 Speaker 05 Exactly.
4:00 Speaker 01 So everybody else around you is holding up their phones to film Bad Bunny and you're holding up your phone to monitor the situation.
4:07 Speaker 05 Exactly. I was very much the monitoring situation meme over the entire weekend.
4:14 Speaker 01 Okay.
4:14 Speaker 05 Yeah, and so there's a lot to unpack. So we put out a call for questions, basically, and we've got, in just a few hours, a lot of very great questions from online. So we wanted to get through some of those today.
4:28 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:28 Speaker 05 First of which is from Paul on X. He asks, could Iran disintegrate into ethnic factions now, like Iraq, if the regime falls?
4:40 Speaker 01 That's a very good question, Paul. And yes, absolutely, it could. In fact, there's more risk really of that happening in Iran than almost any other country. And I'll show you why this is, Cara, because I'll send you, I'm gonna send you two maps.
4:56 Speaker 05 You know, I'm famously very good at reading maps. So this is, this is good.
5:01 Speaker 01 One of them is a topographic map, and one of them is a map of Iranian language groups.
5:08 Speaker 05 Okay, so I'm looking at a topographic map. It's just showing me that there's a whole lot of mountain ranges that are all throughout Iran. So it's very mountainous.
5:18 Speaker 01 It's kind of a ring around the edges of Iran. You can also see that there's a central plateau of flatness. That's where the big population centres are, Tehran and Isfahan and the big cities up on that central desert plateau. But the other important thing that you can see is that there's lots of sort of very low-lying flatland.
5:40 Speaker 05 Yes.
5:41 Speaker 01 Around those mountains. So on the shore of the Persian Gulf, on the shore of the Arabian Sea, on the shore of the Caspian Sea.
5:48 Speaker 05 Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
5:49 Speaker 01 So now look at the language map.
5:50 Speaker 05 Well, I mean, the vast majority of Iran are Persians.
5:53 Speaker 01 Yes, and that is the the central desert plateau area.
5:57 Speaker 05 Yes.
5:57 Speaker 01 Where Tehran, Isfahan, the the big cities are.
6:00 Speaker 05 I mean, and then we've just got a whole range of language groups kind of surrounding that.
6:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, there's enormous language and ethnic diversity in the mountain ring.
6:10 Speaker 05 Yes.
6:10 Speaker 01 Around the edge of Iran. And you see that Iran borders a whole bunch of countries. And you can see that there's a lot of influence of those surrounding countries coming up into those low-lying flatlands around the coasts and into the mountains. So in the case of instability, from particularly the central government in Tehran, it's very likely that some of these ethnic groups around the edges are gonna decide, you know what? We'd rather be either independent or we'd rather be more closer to other people from our ethnic and language group. We Azeris would like to be independent or part of Azerbaijan, or we Turkmen's would like to have more to do with Turkmenistan than Tehran.
6:55 Speaker 05 Yeah.
6:55 Speaker 01 And that is one of the things that the Iranian regime has been most terrified of, really since the Iranian revolution of nineteen seventy nine. They've been doing so much work to try and keep all those ethnic groups united and subjugated under their control. And one of the reasons that they need to do that is those mountain areas and those flat areas are where all the water and oil is.
7:20 Speaker 05 Very important for their economy.
7:22 Speaker 01 Yes, the two things that make the country run.
7:24 Speaker 05 Yes.
7:25 Speaker 01 But yeah, no, that is, that is definitely something that the regime will be acting as quickly as possible to try and defend itself against. They're more at risk of this than almost any other country in the region because of the incredible ethnic diversity they have around the edges of the country.
7:42 Speaker 05 Uh, we've got a couple of questions coming in about which group or who is likely to fill the power vacuum in the next coming days and weeks. One question from Chris is, is it possible the crown prince could return as the first elected non-hereditary monarch with elections to select future heads of state as opposed to president of a republic?
8:05 Speaker 01 Okay, could the crown prince return as the leader of a, of an Iran after a regime collapse caused by these strikes and the death of the supreme leader? The answer is kind of two parts. One is, is the regime going to collapse in the first place? I don't think that's at all assured. The regime isn't as singularly focused on a single person as some other regimes around the world are. Like the Ayatollah Khamenei isn't kind of like Vladimir Putin or Saddam Hussein or any of these guys for whom if you get rid of that person, then really the regime will sort of collapse around them. There's enormous bureaucracy around the Iranian regime.
8:48 Speaker 01 And there is also an enormous armed revolutionary guard. Hmm. Which is designed to protect the regime and has a lot of incentives to do so. There's a lot of people, we're talking hundreds of thousands, even millions of people with a vested stake in the regime remaining in power and they're the ones with the guns. They do have sort of people around who can take up positions of people who have been killed by American and Israeli airstrikes. So potentially the regime survives, but let's go into the hypothetical with Chris's question and look at
9:27 Speaker 01 could, if the regime doesn't survive, the Crown Prince, Reza Pahlavi, who is the son of the Shah of Iran, who was deposed in nineteen seventy nine as part of the Iranian Islamic Revolution and died soon afterwards. His son, who was twenty at the time of the revolution, is now sixty two and is a bit of a favourite of Western media and has been doing a lot of Western media interviews whereby he sort of talks about potentially being available to lead some sort of a transition to democracy in Iran. He's a person that does have some level of popularity in Iran itself.
10:11 Speaker 01 It's difficult to tell in a closed system like Iran how much support he really has. Hmm. But I wonder whether he's a bit more like Alexei Navalny or a Juan Guaido figure. Where the Westerners like to portray him as a legitimate opposition leader. But inside the country that he's exiled from, he's not as much of a popular figure. A lot of people obviously don't like the regime of the Ayatollahs. Yes. But a lot of people really didn't like the Shah either. No.
10:41 Speaker 05 Famously.
10:42 Speaker 01 If the regime was to collapse, a lot of people would be like, uh, can't we have something that isn't either of those things?
10:48 Speaker 05 Yes.
10:49 Speaker 01 And I think the Americans have very much decided that they're sick of trying to find people to install in the regimes they topple. Donald Trump has made it pretty clear that he's happy with whoever rises out of the disappearance of Nicholas Maduro from Venezuela.
11:06 Speaker 05 Hmm.
11:06 Speaker 01 He's allowed Maduro's vice president to take over and is negotiating with her, as though she is the new legitimate president of Venezuela. He's not trying to install Maria Corina Machado, the Venezuelan opposition leader who is living in exile and gave her Nobel Peace Prize to him.
11:26 Speaker 05 Hmm.
11:26 Speaker 01 He's happy with just not Nicholas Maduro. So.
11:30 Speaker 05 Yeah.
11:31 Speaker 01 Whether the United States, if the regime was to fall, would be like, all right, and here's your new guy, it's the crown prince. Uh, I don't know that they necessarily would do that.
11:40 Speaker 05 Exactly. I think when we've seen this happen in the past in the region, if you think about Afghanistan, when the Taliban was toppled, or with Iraq, when it was Saddam Hussein, there was at least some kind of semblance of nation building aspirations from the US, that they would kind of try and do their best to install some sort of leader or some sort of kind of infrastructure that would help the people. Whereas I feel like this time it feels more similar to the removal of Gaddafi in Libya in two thousand and eleven, where the country basically shortly descended into a civil war that is ongoing. There was never really any resolve.
12:23 Speaker 05 And so I, I think there are a lot of people who are concerned that Trump really doesn't have any long-term plans for this and that he's just started a situation that will result in. A prolonged civil war and also millions of refugees, you know, and, and the country is already enduring water shortages. They've already got economic issues, you know, they're going through so much already that this will be catastrophic, kind of regardless of what happens.
12:51 Speaker 01 Well, Cara, Cara, you're predicting the future. Didn't we just do a whole series about not predicting the future?
12:55 Speaker 05 Sorry, sorry, sorry.
12:56 Speaker 01 No, I think you're right in saying that ingredients are certainly there for chaos to break out.
13:00 Speaker 05 Yes, absolutely.
13:01 Speaker 01 You have an already angry, impoverished, frustrated population.
13:05 Speaker 05 Yes.
13:06 Speaker 01 Alongside a regime that has shown they are extremely willing to shoot their own citizens if they cause any problems. We're going to be talking about that in our series. Just weeks ago, we saw thousands of people killed in the streets of Tehran by the Revolutionary Guards in an attempt to put down any sort of challenge to the regime at the time. The regime will feel even more cornered now than they were before. They will be more terrified of collapsing and that is unlikely to make them more peaceful. So I think the ingredients are there, but obviously we, we don't predict the future on this show.
13:48 Speaker 05 That's right.
13:49 Speaker 01 We, we talk about hypotheticals. We don't talk about, we don't predict the future.
13:52 Speaker 05 Okay. Our next question is from Bob Harris on Blue Sky. He asks, is there one historical case where outside decapitation of a leadership has led to democracy?
14:07 Speaker 01 Well, that's a good question, Bob, but I would refer you to our back catalogue because we kind of did an episode about the precedent that a lot of these American war planners look at, which is Panama. There was a straight decapitation of the Panamanian dictator, Manuel Noriega, and Panama pretty rapidly became quite a successful, by regional standards, country with a functioning democracy and competitive elections and free press and all the great things that the Americans say they want everybody to have. The problem is that like that was more of the exception than the rule. I think Donald Trump is sort of hoping that that's what's gonna
14:50 Speaker 01 end up happening in Venezuela, but he's made it very clear that he doesn't want to be involved in that kind of thing. Donald Trump's involvement in these things, he's made it pretty clear, is limited to things that can be delivered by fighter jets and attack helicopters.
15:06 Speaker 05 Hmm.
15:06 Speaker 01 He will happily drop missiles and drone strikes and he will send in commandos for very limited strikes or kidnapping operations. But he is not interested in long term involvement in these wars.
15:22 Speaker 05 I mean, he's also just said recently that his intention is for this to go for four to five weeks.
15:27 Speaker 01 Yep.
15:28 Speaker 05 Which famously isn't a very long period of time to establish a entirely new democratic system in a country, so.
15:36 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah. Well, he's definitely not going to try and establish a democratic system. No.
15:41 Speaker 05 No, exactly.
15:42 Speaker 01 He's hoping to bomb enough of the existing system that it collapses on its own.
15:47 Speaker 05 There's obviously also the other modern cases after World War Two.
15:52 Speaker 01 Hmm.
15:52 Speaker 05 Germany, Japan and Italy. The differences there would be that they were absolutely devastated by the war economically, militarily, they unconditionally surrendered. They also started the war in the first place and they had very recently been functioning democracies in the past.
16:12 Speaker 01 Germany and Italy had been.
16:14 Speaker 05 Germany and Italy had been. So they had kind of the democratic literacy for how that system worked. So it wasn't like you needed to bring in and shift an entire way of thinking for an entire population. So they had democratic infrastructure in place. They already had all of the democratic understanding and so to revert back to that system with a different leader wasn't as much of an ask as it would be for, say, a country that is not democratic at all.
16:39 Speaker 01 Well, on top of that, Germany and Japan were under military occupation by the United States and its allies for many years afterwards.
16:50 Speaker 05 Yes, exactly. That's right.
16:51 Speaker 01 And still retain. Massive military presence by the United States Army in both of those countries. The United States is still there eighty one years after the end of World War Two, making sure that there's no problems.
17:05 Speaker 05 Yeah.
17:05 Speaker 01 And Donald Trump is, I don't think, I did watch the speech with the baseball cap on and the speech without the baseball cap on. And I don't recall that he's planning on having a military involvement in Iran for the next eighty one years.
17:18 Speaker 05 Our next question is, why have Anthony Albanese and Mark Carney suddenly decided to side with Trump?
17:26 Speaker 07 We support the United States acting to prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon and to prevent Iran from continuing to threaten international peace and security.
17:37 Speaker 01 Our colleague Patricia Carvellis has an interesting take on this, which is basically that they are being very specific about their support.
17:44 Speaker 05 Hmm.
17:45 Speaker 01 They are saying that their support is specifically about making sure that Iran doesn't have the ability to make a nuclear bomb. They haven't come out to say, you know, we support the attempt to topple the Iranian regime.
18:01 Speaker 05 Hmm.
18:01 Speaker 01 They have said that we support the idea of ensuring global security and ensuring the continuation of the rules-based international order by making sure that Iran can't have any nuclear weapons. Mark Carney in particular has made it clear that he is a big proponent of trying to hold some semblance of the rules-based international order together.
18:26 Speaker 05 Yeah.
18:26 Speaker 01 Through this era where international norms are being shredded. He's trying to hold alliances together and he's trying to find areas where he and the United States can agree. But if this turns into a broader regime change effort over weeks, months, years, it will be interesting to see how they respond to that. Mark Carney is going to be in Australia this week. And I imagine that he's going to get quite a number of questions about his and Anthony Albanese's decision to conditionally support what Donald Trump has done with Benjamin Netanyahu as well.
19:07 Speaker 05 And that leads nicely to the next question, which is if the US can assault Iran like this, what is stopping China from bombing Taiwan whenever they feel like it?
19:17 Speaker 01 Hmm.
19:17 Speaker 05 That's, that's really the point of kind of upholding rules based order is basically that not a whole lot. You know, you would hope that there would be more stopping him, but there doesn't seem to be a lot. So, yeah, that is a big concern because there are other regions, there's Greenland, there's Cuba, there's Mexico, that he has been eyeing off, you know, Canada obviously being one. Where if you set a precedent that you can bomb a country because you disagree with the leadership of that country, then we're entering very dangerous and murky territory.
19:50 Speaker 01 I think the, the one thing that you could say to push back on that is that Taiwan is a far better functioning, far more cohesive society than either Venezuela or Iran.
20:05 Speaker 05 Absolutely.
20:06 Speaker 01 We're not seeing regime on the verge of collapse in Taiwan. We're seeing a, a functioning democracy with, you know, a functioning and well-equipped military and functioning, well-equipped civil institutions and a populace that is generally quite supportive of the government and of their current status, of their status quo. I didn't say independence there, but their status quo, their current ability to govern themselves.
20:36 Speaker 05 Hmm.
20:36 Speaker 01 Certainly those things will make doing anything similar to Taiwan far more, far, far, far more complicated. Taiwan also theoretically has a lot more international support than Iran and Venezuela, both of whom were kind of regional pariahs. If China was to attack Taiwan, they would certainly see a response from Japan and Korea and possibly the Philippines. And they would potentially see a response from the United States and US allies, which is a much bigger threat than the US apparently faces. There's certainly some finger wagging going on, but in terms of the region.
21:21 Speaker 01 Iran has made the extraordinary decision
21:25 Speaker 05 Yeah.
21:26 Speaker 01 to respond to being under attack by attacking US bases in the surrounding area in countries that didn't necessarily support America's decision to attack Iran. Now has given, you know, countries like Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Bahrain, a lot of reason to really not like the regime in Iran.
21:45 Speaker 05 Yeah.
21:46 Speaker 01 So it's going to be an interesting thing to see who, if anybody, comes to Iran's aid.
21:51 Speaker 05 We've got one final question. Trump has stated America's involvement could last one month. Given he said he could stop the Russian Ukraine conflict in one day, do you believe him? And what does our government do if he asks for our help?
22:07 Speaker 01 Well, that last part is very much something that I imagine that the Australian government is just really crossing their fingers that they don't have to answer.
22:16 Speaker 05 Absolutely.
22:16 Speaker 01 Australia certainly has a history of helping the United States in things. But I would say that Donald Trump isn't the sort of person that asks for help. You've got to remember that when Australia has followed the United States into these conflicts, we have been asked to. The United States was seeking a global coalition to go into Vietnam or go into Iraq or go into Afghanistan. They were asking for help. Donald Trump is very clear that it's America first and I don't need anybody's help. Thank you very much. So it's not as though Donald Trump is potentially looking for assistance in the same way as George W. Bush or Richard Nixon or Johnson or Bill Clinton. All of them wanted us to join in. I don't know that Donald Trump cares.
22:59 Speaker 05 Yeah.
22:59 Speaker 01 As for whether we trust him that it can last for a month, well, that is certainly what he thinks.
23:06 Speaker 05 Yeah.
23:06 Speaker 01 And that is going to be the subject of our episode coming up on Thursday, where we're going to be looking at why Donald Trump thinks that he can contain conflicts this size in a way that no other US president has ever managed to be able to do. So that is what we're going to be talking about on Thursday. We'll give you a full-length episode all about that.
23:28 Speaker 05 Looking forward to it.
23:29 Speaker 01 I better go write it. Thanks, Cara.
23:30 Speaker 05 Thank you. Bye.
23:44 Speaker 08 In the country, it's unusual to give away your chickens.
23:48 Speaker 00 It's definitely going to raise eyebrows. Everyone in rural Australia knows you just don't give away laying chickens. So, two decades ago, when a family on the outskirts of an isolated town called Nannup in Western Australia started getting rid of things... And she's saying to Chantelle, "Are you sure that you want to let go of these things?" People started noticing. And Chantelle said, "Yes, Leila's not going to need them anymore." Daddy, stop doing that, please. I'm Dominique Baynes, and I live and work about 45 minutes away from the Little Blue farmhouse where those four people lived and disappeared from.
24:33 Speaker 09 The family lived a bizarre, alternative lifestyle.
24:36 Speaker 00 Chantelle and Leila McDougall, Tony Poppage, and Simon Cadwell vanished in July 2007.
24:43 Speaker 10 Hey, somebody did a castanet. I'm feeling all Latin now.
24:47 Speaker 00 They left behind a note saying they'd gone to Brazil, and rumours of a dark, online cult swirling in their absence. They were never conclusively seen again.
24:59 Speaker 09 They have not accessed their bank accounts, or travelled overseas on their passports.
25:03 Speaker 00 What began as a missing persons case morphed into an international investigation, as evidence of secrets, hidden identities, and a mysterious cult leader emerged.
25:14 Speaker 11 He was working the room. It was like a car salesman trying to sell you a bomb.
25:18 Speaker 08 Something wasn't right.
25:20 Speaker 00 Outlandish theories became distinct possibilities.
25:23 Speaker 09 He had told someone online that he was planning a family suicide pact, but later it changed his mind.
25:30 Speaker 08 I always thought that was their grand plan, to go to South America. This is where I have to take a deep breath here, all this stuff, because, yeah.
25:40 Speaker 00 Why didn't we see any signs? For months, I've been picking at the threads of this story to find out who the Nanup Four were, and what led them down the rabbit hole and into the face of disaster. And the further I've got, the more I've realised, nothing is what it seems in this story.
25:59 Speaker 08 I'm a non-gossip person, but it's very easy to hear lots of gossip.
26:04 Speaker 10 Wow, check that out.
26:06 Speaker 08 He said Jarnetel's got end time syndrome. Oh boy, he's weird. To me, it was off the planet. Very strange. My son's going, "What is going on?"
26:14 Speaker 10 That's what happens when you cheat, see?
26:19 Speaker 08 I was starting to think, "This is not going to end well."
26:23 Speaker 00 There are so many people left behind, looking for answers, all the while, trying to face two stark possibilities. Was the disappearance a choice, or was it murder?
26:35 Speaker 08 Turns out, he wasn't trying to hurt them. Beat them all. He was actually trying to warn them.
26:42 Speaker 00 All trying to work out how to live with the choices they made, or didn't make, that led them here.
26:48 Speaker 08 I just wished I'd asked a lot more questions, no matter what. I'll regret it till the day I die.
26:54 Speaker 00 I'm Dominique Baynes. I didn't want to lose her. I can't change the past. And this is season six of Expanse, The Nanup Four.
27:06 Speaker 11 You've got two choices: be strong or be weak.
27:08 Speaker 00 Subscribe to Expanse to hear the whole story.
Previous Where did Epstein’s money come from? Next Trump thinks he can switch off the Iran War Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated