Pod Insights If You're Listening How good are Australia’s gun laws really? About this episode Australians are very proud of our gun laws, and we have good reason to be. The laws are world famous and frequently referenced in the wake of almost every mass shooting in the United States. And yet, we have now seen two men terrorise Australia’s Jewish community at a Hanukkah event at Bondi beach with legally-owned high-powered guns.
Despite almost universal support for stricter gun control, there are more guns in Australia now than there were before the famous gun laws were introduced.
So, what are the specifics of Australia's laws? Are they really as water-tight as we all like to believe? And if they are about to change what will that actually accomplish?
Follow If You're Listening on the ABC Listen app https://radio.abc.net.au/help/apps.
Check out our series on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDTPrMoGHssAfgMMS3L5LpLNFMNp1U_Nq
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:09 Speaker 01 Hi, I'm Patricia Carvallis, the host of Politics Now, the ABC's podcast unpacking the latest political news when it happens. Every weekday you'll hear me and the sharpest political minds at the ABC.
0:21 Speaker 02 Me, Jacob Greber. Me, Raf Epstein. Me, Fodi Alon. Me, David Spears.
0:26 Speaker 01 And me, Frank Kelly, for the party room every Thursday. So join me for Politics Now, download and follow on the ABC Listen app.
0:35 Speaker 03 This podcast was produced on the lands of the Uabakal and Gadigal people. A warning before we start, this episode discusses the details of the Bondi shooting of 2025 and the Port Arthur massacre of 1996. We're not going to be graphic, we are talking specifically about the firearms used in both events. The first video footage I saw of the horrific attack on Australia's Jewish community in Bondi was of one of the gunmen being disarmed by a bystander.
1:10 Speaker 03 Ahmed Al Ahmed, a Sydney tobacco shop owner, tackles the shooter from behind and wrestles his gun out of his hands. In an unbelievable scene, Ahmed then points the gun at the shooter, forcing him to retreat. He stands his ground as the second shooter advances on his position, firing as he goes.
1:37 Speaker 03 We've all had a lot of different emotions this week: shock, horror, incredible sadness, anger. But one thought that I've been dwelling on since seeing that video is, what on earth is that gun doing in Bondi? It's a big gun, a 12-gauge shotgun, and it's firing rapidly. At one point, before Ahmed disarmed him, video shows the shooter firing two shots in two seconds.
2:10 Speaker 03 He's firing over and over and over before he's finally forced to reload.
2:17 Speaker 03 This happened in Australia. I thought, in fact, the world thought, that a shotgun capable of firing so many rounds so quickly was banned here. Even former Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull thought so.
2:31 Speaker 04 I read a report that there was a pump-action shotgun involved. Now, I thought pump-action shotguns were not available. So, I was very much of the impression that they were not available.
2:44 Speaker 03 And yet, according to New South Wales Police, apparently, the gun that the shooter had was legal.
2:50 Speaker 05 He had a Category A-B licence, which entitled him to have the long arms that he had as registered firearms.
2:55 Speaker 03 The government is now talking about tightening our gun laws to restrict firearms like this.
3:01 Speaker 06 If you're not a farmer, if you're not involved in agriculture, why do you need these massive weapons that put the public in danger and make life dangerous and difficult for New South Wales Police?
3:14 Speaker 03 Australians are very proud of our gun laws, and we have good reason to be. They are world famous. The laws are frequently referenced in the wake of almost every tragic mass shooting in the United States. And yet, we've now seen two men terrorise Australia's Jewish community with legally-owned high-powered guns. There are, in fact, more guns in Australia now than there were before the famous gun laws were introduced. So what are the specifics of Australia's gun laws? Are they really as strict as we all like to believe? And if they are about to change, what could that accomplish? I'm Matt Bevan, and this is If You're Listening.
4:02 Speaker 03 Something that you don't see much anymore is a high-profile politician deliberately seeking out a hostile crowd to speak to. Good news, what are you here for? Meet Mr Howard and see what he's got to say. What are you, do you think you'll be happy with what he's got to say? I doubt very much. On the 16th of June 1996, a cricket field in the small Victorian town of Sale was filling up with rather angry people. You come for stick-up for our rights? Why do you need to? Why do we need you? Because if we don't make a stand now, we'll lose everything. The headline speaker was set to be the Prime Minister, John Howard. Can you just tell us why you're here? Why? Mainly because people are... Have been taken away from them. They've done nothing wrong and they're being victimised.
4:47 Speaker 03 The issue at hand was whether people should be forced to give up their high-powered firearms.
4:52 Speaker 02 All I'd like to know is, you keep saying that 95% of the public don't want guns. Where does he get his figures? Just answer me that. It's all I want to know.
5:00 Speaker 03 Ahead of the event, the police became concerned that the Prime Minister was in danger. The AFP tell me they've had a quite explicit warning. The local police have had a quite explicit warning that somebody's going to shoot you. He was urged by police and one of his top advisers to wear a bulletproof vest. I don't know if they're right or wrong, but I have no idea how I would go and tell Jeanette and your family that we were warned for you to wear this flak jacket. You didn't and you got shot. I have just no idea how I would say that to your family. When Howard arrived, wearing the bulky vest under his suit jacket, he was greeted by a local gun control activist.
5:40 Speaker 06 Thanks, Mr Howard, for coming to sail. On behalf of 10,000 Victorians, I present to you these petitions, which strongly support your view on gun control.
5:52 Speaker 03 But as he climbed the steps to the grandstand, the crowd let him know that they were not happy to see him.
6:02 Speaker 03 National leaders don't usually do this. They don't usually organise big events where they know they're going to face a furious crowd. A crowd so furious that police are advising you to wear a bulletproof vest. But John Howard was determined to do it anyway because of the importance of the policy he was trying to implement. If the political process in Australia turns against me because of the decision that I have taken, I will accept that decision. His conviction to get this policy over the line was because of something that happened seven weeks earlier.
6:37 Speaker 00 A lone gunman, armed with a high-powered rifle, entered the Port Arthur historic site and began firing randomly.
6:44 Speaker 03 I'd only been in the job of Prime Minister a few weeks, and I was at home at Curragh Billy House that weekend.
6:51 Speaker 06 Flicked on the television and before long I knew he had this unbelievable disaster.
6:59 Speaker 03 The Port Arthur massacre, the worst gun massacre in Australia's modern history, took place over the course of 20 hours, but most of the fatalities took place in less than two minutes. It was all over in 90 seconds. He murdered 20 people and a number of other people were seriously injured. The shooter was able to do this because he had an AR-15 semi-automatic rifle, a lightweight gun that can fire a lot of bullets very rapidly. Despite not having a firearms licence or even a driver's licence, the shooter had been able to buy the gun from a local dealer. In 1996, you technically needed a licence to buy a firearm, but some gun shops just didn't bother asking for them.
7:44 Speaker 03 High-powered, rapid-fire rifles like this one were easy to get. There were hundreds of thousands of them across the country.
7:51 Speaker 06 I was totally and utterly thunderstruck that there could be such an appalling loss of life at the hands of one man. It affected me.
8:01 Speaker 03 In the days after the massacre, John Howard attended the memorial service for the victims in Tasmania and met Dr Brian Walpole, an emergency specialist from Royal Hobart Hospital.
8:11 Speaker 06 And it was a doctor who'd treated a lot of the people with horrific injuries and he started explaining what had happened and he broke down and I embraced him and seen the most natural thing in the world to do.
8:23 Speaker 03 Howard listened to several tragic stories about what had unfolded that day.
8:28 Speaker 06 Walder Meckag, of course, had lost his two beautiful daughters and wife and he wanted me to do something to stop it happening again.
8:35 Speaker 03 He returned to Canberra determined to do just that.
8:38 Speaker 06 I can remember discussing this issue with some of my staff and one or two of them said to me, "You're not really thinking of..."
8:46 Speaker 02 Banning all semi-automatics, eh? And I said, yes. I said, we might as well go for broke on this.
8:52 Speaker 03 The barrier Howard faced wasn't the opposition Labor Party. He'd just won a landslide victory and the new opposition leader immediately threw his full support behind gun control. Those who would resist him have got to understand that 90% of the public believes in the propositions that he put forward. The barrier was from inside his own conservative coalition. Howard, a lifelong resident of suburban Sydney with no background in agriculture or hunting, was surrounded by rural colleagues who were opposed to his point of view.
9:23 Speaker 02 You know, sitting around the cabinet table were people who actually owned a lot of guns.
9:28 Speaker 03 Howard knew virtually nothing about guns, so he called his primary industries minister and asked him for advice.
9:34 Speaker 02 He said, "Your job is to explain to me and convince me as to what sort of firearms farmers need and legitimately must have access to. What sort of gun do you use?" And I hesitated for a moment because I thought I don't quite know how to tell the prime minister that I have what he would regard as an arsenal.
9:55 Speaker 03 He was asking for fine detail, though. He wasn't interested in his colleagues' arguments against banning guns.
10:02 Speaker 05 We realised that Howard wasn't going to change his mind. I mean, you could give your arguments against the gun control and you knew he would listen to you politely and he would be patient with you, but you knew you were talking to a brick wall. He was not going to change his mind.
10:17 Speaker 03 Consultation inside the government was brief, to say the least.
10:20 Speaker 02 I have not changed my views. I will not be changing my views.
10:25 Speaker 03 Within two weeks of the Port Arthur massacre, Howard had consulted with police commissioners and state and territory governments and come up with a final plan.
10:33 Speaker 02 I'm very happy to announce that the Commonwealth and the states and territories have agreed on a uniform.
10:40 Speaker 03 And much tougher approach to gun laws, which will, in our view, make Australia a much safer place in which to live. The decision was that identical laws would be introduced across all Australian states and territories. The laws would organise guns into categories and implement a licensing and registration system for their use. Handguns, pistols effectively, would be category H. Long guns, like rifles and shotguns, would be split into four categories, A, B, C and D, with A being the least restricted and D being essentially banned with very few exceptions. They clearly have in mind the police and the armed services. But already you can start to see how this gets complicated.
11:26 Speaker 03 The police and military need exceptions. So do some farmers and some professional shooters who are charged with controlling feral animals. And figuring out which guns go into the most restricted category is difficult. The problem is that it's like drunk driving. You have to set a threshold and that threshold has to be somewhere. What you want to say is nobody can have the guns that kill large numbers of people very quickly. But how do you write that into a law? There's thousands of different models of guns with hundreds of different firing mechanisms and dozens of different types of ammunition. Where's the threshold between very, very dangerous and still dangerous but okay for people to have if they've got a licence?
12:12 Speaker 03 What goes into category A and B, which are available to most people with a gun licence? And what goes into category C and D, which are only available to people who? Can satisfy the police, that they have a genuine need for them which cannot be met by any other methods or any of the non-prohibited weapons. The government eventually decided to make these guns essentially illegal. All other self-loading centrefire rifles.
12:38 Speaker 04 All self-loading and pump-action shotguns and all self-loading rimfire rifles.
12:44 Speaker 03 This was effectively a restriction on all guns that can fire lots of bullets quickly. Self-loading, or semi-automatic guns, are guns that can fire like this quickly.
12:56 Speaker 03 The action of pulling the trigger is both firing a bullet and loading a new bullet into the chamber. Those are all highly restricted in category D. A pump-action shotgun is your classic chuk chuk boom type of shotgun. You need to pull a slide on the barrel to load each cartridge, but they can still be fired very quickly, like this. Those guns would be put in category C, which would be available to some farmers, but only if they have a magazine capacity of less than five rounds. If the gun was capable of firing more than five rounds without reloading, they would go into category D. If a gun met any of those criteria, self-loading or pump-action,
13:42 Speaker 03 they were not available for gun enthusiasts, amateur hunters, or most farmers. They were very strictly controlled. People who already owned the newly banned guns would be able to hand them into the government in exchange for the market value of the gun. As for the firearms that remained legal under the new guidelines, they'd be registered on a centralised national database and checks were to be carried out to make sure people were storing their guns safely. Another element that was introduced was that all gun owners would now be required to demonstrate that they had a legitimate need for a gun, either for work or because you're a member of a gun club. You couldn't just get a gun licence because you like guns. And that was a big change.
14:27 Speaker 04 Needless to say, this represents an enormous shift in the culture of this country.
14:32 Speaker 03 Towards the possession, the use and the ownership of guns. It is an historic agreement. Public support for the agreement was enormous. Polls at the time indicated that around ninety percent of Australians were behind the Prime Minister's law changes. Of course, ninety percent isn't everyone.
14:50 Speaker 06 You can send a message all the way down to Canberra to that sawn-off little dickhead, Jackboot Johnny.
14:59 Speaker 03 Around the country, there was serious anger among gun club members in particular.
15:03 Speaker 06 The only currency that you can purchase freedom back with is blood.
15:08 Speaker 03 And yet, despite the resentment, John Howard decided to tour these gun clubs to speak to people about the decisions he'd made.
15:19 Speaker 03 He made it clear to the crowd at Sale Oval that this was not a consultation. It was an explanation.
15:26 Speaker 06 Sir, I haven't come here to negotiate the government decision. I've come here to explain it. I've come here to try and justify.
15:39 Speaker 03 John Howard has never been a physically imposing man. His small stature and flinty voice were a constant subject of ridicule during his political career. The oversized jacket that day in Sale didn't help, nor did the obvious bulletproof vest underneath. Howard says he doesn't regret anything about his speech that day, except for wearing that vest. I'm sorry I did. I really am. I felt a bit of a goose afterwards for having worn it. But the image of this small man shouting a defence of his policy over the furious jeers and boos of the crowd with a plane circling overhead, pulling a sign saying, "Stick to your guns", was seared into the public mind.
16:28 Speaker 06 Which can only be effectively implemented in the interest of the overall national good if they involve some disproportionate inconvenience and some disproportionate deprivation for one section of the community. I'm sorry about that, but there is no other way, there is no other way.
16:49 Speaker 03 John Howard was willing to face people who had supported his election and stubbornly shrug off their anger because this policy was really important. He wouldn't go through this otherwise.
17:02 Speaker 06 Will benefit the overall national good, and that is the reason behind this decision, ladies and gentlemen.
17:08 Speaker 03 And the proof was in the pudding because the reform was an exceptional success. During the 12 months after the legislation was passed and the government's buyback scheme was implemented, Australians turned in about 650,000 guns. In the years since, Howard's policies have been heralded by gun control advocates all over the world. Since they were passed, Australia's gun homicide rate has gone down by more than half. Australia remained mostly safe from mass shootings of the kind we see in the United States, which is why the Australian community was so shocked by what happened on the first day of Hanukkah celebrations in December 2025.
17:52 Speaker 03 Two shooters, Navid and Sajid Akram, a father and son, arrived at Bondi with a cache of guns and started shooting at the large Hanukkah celebration at the crowded beach. Video evidence shows the father, Sajid, firing a shotgun rapidly. I count at least eight shots between reloads. Police say that he owned this gun legally with a category A B licence, but how is that possible? Rapid fire shotguns, capable of firing more than five rounds between reloads, were put into category D all the way back in 1996.
18:37 Speaker 06 In Australia, if you're wanting to use a shotgun for hunting, it has been difficult to get it.
18:42 Speaker 03 Get a gun that has more than two shots. Well, despite the fact that pump-action shotguns were in category D and essentially banned, it turns out that some gunmakers have been sliding through the cracks by changing the firing mechanism, the way that the shotgun loads each shell into the chamber. It can fire eight shots in as many seconds, using a firing mechanism straight from the Wild West. In 2015, a company in Turkey started making shotguns that use a very outdated lever-action mechanism, which is not as good as a pump-action. But because of this change, it means it fits into category A instead of the far more restrictive category D.
19:27 Speaker 00 This weapon is clearly not far off a pump-action shotgun, and we severely restrict the use of those because of the speed with which they can be used.
19:37 Speaker 03 The ABC was given a demonstration of both a pump-action shotgun and the lever-action shotgun being fired by the same person. Watching them firing side by side, the lever-action gun is about half the speed, one bullet every second instead of two. But still, one bullet every second is a lot of bullets. People are going to have no defence against it for eight rounds. That is a rapid-fire weapon. When these new guns started entering the country, proponents of gun control were extremely concerned. If you're a mass shooter, which is what the Port Arthur laws were designed to curb, then that's the type of gun you go for. You go for something that's going to just fire and fire and fire and fire and fire.
20:20 Speaker 03 Gun importers argued these new guns were very different, but not everyone was on board with that idea. Some users of online gun forums clearly see this as a way of getting around the 1996 gun laws. The lever-action loophole was closed in 2017, when these shotguns, if they had a magazine capacity of more than five, were restricted. But the reprieve didn't last long, because soon after, new shotguns with different types of firing mechanisms were designed to take their place.
20:55 Speaker 03 This has meant that over the last decade, there has been a cat and mouse game between governments and gun importers as different types of high-powered shotguns are introduced into the market and then restricted. This is how the Bondi shooter was able to legally own a shotgun that can fire so many shells in rapid succession without reloading. Both of the shooters can be seen using guns with straight pull mechanisms, which have only recently been introduced to Australia and are still available to Category A owners. High-powered weapons like this creeping into the more accessible categories A and B is just one of several examples of how gun laws have been neglected since 1996.
21:40 Speaker 03 A few gun owners have contacted us since the Bondi attack to tell us that they're shocked by how easy it is to get a gun licence in Australia. They've also told us that they think that audits by regulators are too infrequent. People smuggling guns into the country has also become a serious issue. There are now an estimated 260,000 unregistered illicit firearms in circulation in Australia. Another issue is there's no cap on the number of guns you can own, which has led to growing instances of people stockpiling guns.
22:14 Speaker 07 Last week, police searched 70 properties throughout the state. They seized 135 firearms and cancelled or suspended 44 gun licences.
22:23 Speaker 03 Police conducted weapons inspections have been met with heavily armed and very angry people.
22:29 Speaker 04 Police came here at 7.30 this morning to conduct a firearms inspection. They say that when officers arrived, they were threatened.
22:35 Speaker 07 A candlelit vigil was held in Toowoomba for the young constable shot dead at Weambilla last December.
22:42 Speaker 03 Most Australians are proud of our gun laws, and most think that they keep us safe from the horrors of mass shootings that we see around the world. But clearly that's no longer the case. And now, in the wake of this attack on the Jewish community, Australia's biggest mass shooting since Port Arthur, the government is looking to update laws that have been left fairly dormant for three decades. National Cabinet agreeing to consider limiting the number of firearms.
23:10 Speaker 07 arms a person can own, curbing open-ended gun licences and restricting gun ownership to Australian citizens.
23:18 Speaker 03 In the days after the shooting, New South Wales Premier Chris Minns announced that his government would be specifically addressing loopholes in the law that allowed these guns to be legally bought.
23:27 Speaker 06 We are proposing a bill to reclassify straight pull-up and pump action shotguns, to look at reducing magazine capacity for shotguns.
23:38 Speaker 03 The laws are likely to pass quickly as there is still strong popular support for gun control measures. But John Howard, author of the original gun laws, says tightening those laws isn't the only thing that needs to be addressed.
23:52 Speaker 06 Focus on guns, it's welcome, always, provided it's designed to tighten existing laws to eliminate loopholes. But I do not want the focus on guns to be used as a pretext to avoid the broader debate about the spread of hatred of Jewish people and antisemitism.
24:14 Speaker 03 And of course he's right. There's no doubt that further tightening gun laws will make Australians feel safer in their communities. But figuring out how to stop gun importers finding legal loopholes is going to be complex. What's even more complex is figuring out what to do about the fact that there are people in our society who are willing to attack a religious celebration on a sunny summer afternoon in a beachside playground.
Previous 24 hours after the Bondi shooting Next What's the deal with fluoride? Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated