Pod Insights If You're Listening 03 Black Swans | Burning Hill About this episode In 1959 a flight to London took days and cost half a year’s average salary. But things were changing rapidly. The invention of the Concorde meant that you could fly from Adelaide to London in just under seven hours. Travel was getting faster and many expected we’d be routinely zipping around the world and travelling to other planets in no time. But now, aside from planes, most of our transport is not much faster than it was back then, so why are we still so slow?
Transcript 4,669 words · 21 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:07 Speaker 01 In a tiny Victorian town, the football club isn't just a weekend ritual.
0:11 Speaker 00 It's country footy. You get there really early. You leave late.
0:15 Speaker 01 But then, one day, something happens.
0:17 Speaker 00 In the back of a caravan, just over the road from this footy club. Once I realised what was going to happen, it like, yeah, it was not good.
0:27 Speaker 01 And suddenly, everyone must pick a side. I just felt angry. Those blokes were meant to be my mates. Hometown Boys, a new series by Background Briefing. Listen now on the ABC Listen app.
0:38 Speaker 02 This podcast was produced on the lands of the Uabakal and Gadigal people. If you had to think of a perfect metaphor for how terrible people are at predicting the future, it's hard to go past Sydney's burning hill. These days, it's a nondescript part of the Randwick Bus Depot, but back in the 60s, it was the site of one of the most short-sighted acts I have ever heard of. Let me explain.
1:06 Speaker 02 Here in Australia, we tend to associate tram networks with Melbourne, but in 1945, Australia had 12 of them, not only in all the state capitals, but in Ballarat, Bendigo, Geelong, Calguli, Launceston and Newcastle. In fact, Australia's largest tram network, the largest in the southern hemisphere at the time, was in Sydney. The city had more than 1,500 trams, carrying 404 million passengers every year. And despite this, it wasn't long before cars became king.
1:39 Speaker 03 The problem of traffic is common to all our cities. Hold-ups occur wherever different needs conflict.
1:44 Speaker 02 Traffic became a serious problem in Australia's cities in the years after World War Two.
1:49 Speaker 03 What would you give, lady, to get home in five instead of 50 minutes?
1:52 Speaker 02 Many people started identifying a culprit. You guessed it, trams. They block the roads, um, traffic just can't get past them. I think we could do without them. So state governments everywhere but Victoria decided to dismantle their tram networks. This would make more room for cars and buses could pick up the slack. But it wasn't going to be as simple as ripping out all the tracks. In 1945, Sydney had more than 1,500 trams in service. So what were they going to do with all those trams? Well, starting in the mid 1950s, the New South Wales Transport Department began rolling them up into the tram depot next to Randwick Racecourse. They would remove the motors and wheels,
2:37 Speaker 02 then drag them up onto a hill. Then they tipped engine oil from the nearby bus depot onto the floor of the tram. Then they lit the oil on fire and stood back to watch them burn.
3:03 Speaker 02 Up to 15 trams at a time were burned on that hill in Randwick. By 1970, Australia had gone from 12 tram networks to one.
3:16 Speaker 02 55 years later, and there is now work underway to build new networks in six cities at eye-watering cost. I mean, can you possibly think of a better example of how bad we are at seeing what's coming in the future than that? That's what this show is all about, how bad we are at predicting the future. Decades ago, we shackled ourselves to oil-based energy sources. And now, instead of getting us moving, it's left us trapped in place. I'm Matt Bevan, and from if you're listening, this is Black Swan.
3:55 Speaker 02 So our last episode was all about housing and how the Australian dream of owning a detached house on a quarter acre block had unexpectedly become unattainable to most young people. One solution put forward for solving the crisis was improving our nation's transport. Because really, housing is only unaffordable in certain places. If you jump on a real estate website and look up property prices in rural Australia, you can get a real nice house for a very reasonable price in Broken Hill, Gladstone, Stal and Port Augusta. That being said, by moving there, you're almost certain to have to take a pay cut. Median incomes are much lower in rural towns. In some, they're barely above the national minimum wage. The key problem is that you can't have the best of both worlds.
4:39 Speaker 02 You can't work in the city but live in the country unless you want to spend half your life commuting. And yet, according to these letters that we found in the ABC archive from 1959, they thought that we would be moving a hell of a lot faster by now.
4:52 Speaker 03 You all commute daily at hourly, so fast through space in your private flying sources, spaceships, time and space equalisers, or whatever you may call them, that of course you can go to any point in our old world in a matter of minutes.
5:06 Speaker 02 That's Rowan Rivet. He was one of 20 people who were asked by the ABC in 1959 to write letters to the unborn, messages to people living in the future, messages to us, right here and now. They were fascinated by how we might be getting around. Here's organist John Horner.
5:25 Speaker 04 I wish you could get through to us somehow and tell us whether the future of travel is going to be worth waiting up for.
5:32 Speaker 02 John thought that by now, we might not need to travel. We could just experience the world through technology.
5:36 Speaker 04 There's your TV so good there now that you no longer need to travel at all. You simply press a button and there's the place of your choice on the screen before you and around you in natural colours with natural smells and breezes added out of an effects box.
5:51 Speaker 02 Well, look, VR headsets are certainly a thing, but Silicon Valley hasn't added a smell box to them yet, as far as I'm aware. Poet Max Lammshed was stunned by the incredible increases in travel speed he'd witnessed in his lifetime.
6:04 Speaker 05 For hundreds of years, the speed of man's mobility was governed by his own movements or the metabolism of a horse. Its limit was thirty miles an hour or less. Then, soon after the dawn of the 20th century, came the motor car. And with a generation, he could be transported at 200 miles an hour.
6:24 Speaker 02 But we didn't stop there.
6:26 Speaker 05 Then in half a century, 1,000 miles an hour. Where will it all end? And now we see man-controlled rocket propulsion just around the corner with 2,000 miles an hour.
6:37 Speaker 02 In 1959, the land speed record was 634 kilometres per hour. And the air speed record was 2,300 kilometres per hour. Max thought that speeds like this would become normal.
6:51 Speaker 05 The possibility of leaving Adelaide, fulfilling a luncheon engagement in London or attending a theatre or the opera, say, and being home again within 24 hours is no longer a fanciful dream. That really does seem wonderful to us. Though to you, as I said, it may be commonplace.
7:08 Speaker 02 It's easy to see why they thought that air travel for the average person would get faster and faster. That is what had been happening their whole lifetime.
7:20 Speaker 02 Let's say you wanted to take a flight from Sydney to London. Your options were two and a half days flying in a Lancasterian, a converted World War II bomber, or five and a half days in a seaplane. The Lancasterian stopped to refuel seven times and the seaplane stopped 12 times. The price? £500 return, or about a third of the price of a house at the time. Totally inaccessible for most people. When our letter writers, like Dr Derek Van Abbey, were considering the future, a lot had changed, but...
7:51 Speaker 06 Your great-great-grandmother and I aren't very happy about the marvels of modern air travel.
7:57 Speaker 02 Speed had increased significantly, but the price hadn't come down much.
8:01 Speaker 06 They tell us what a wonderful thing it is that aeroplanes can now fly from Sydney to London in 48 hours. But the dreadful thing about it, as far as your great-great-grandmother and I are concerned, is that we can't.
8:13 Speaker 02 Flying to London still costs more than half a year's salary. Why? Well, airline economics is obviously very complicated, but it basically comes down to the resources needed to haul all these people across the globe. In 1959, Qantas's flagship fleet of jets each carried 120 passengers. So to fly to London, you and 119 other people had to share the cost of, for a start, 135 tonnes of aviation fuel. Yes, that is more than one tonne of fuel per passenger. As elegant and graceful as a jet can look at an airline ad, when you stand right under one... They're very, very loud! You remember that it really is dragging itself up there on the back of an absolute butt-load of kerosene.
9:00 Speaker 02 On top of the fuel, there are the people that you need to get the plane from A to B. You've got to pay at least three pilots and half a dozen flight attendants for 48 hours. Plus, you have to stop at least six times for refuelling, so that means eight sets of ground staff. Fuel and staff are by far the two biggest costs for airlines. There are obvious ways to cut those costs: carry more people, fly faster, make the planes more fuel-efficient. A development in any of these areas would make flying cheaper and more accessible to regular people. Most people, including the Qantas chair back then, the tremendously-named Sir Hudson Fish, thought that higher speed was going to come first.
9:41 Speaker 03 The 707 represents the intermediate step to the supersonic liners of the 1970s. San Francisco would be reached in three and a half hours' flying time, and London in only seven hours.
9:54 Speaker 02 Supersonic in the 1970s. Invent a plane that could safely speed through the sound barrier and you could be in London in seven hours. In 1962, Britain and France started the process of designing what would become known as the Concorde.
10:07 Speaker 03 Representatives of the two countries sign an agreement to share the $300 million cost and hope they have the plane operational by 1968.
10:15 Speaker 02 Remember, they only started the process in 1962, so pretty ambitious, they would need to get a wriggle on.
10:21 Speaker 07 In today's high-pressure world, speed is comfort. Speed is time saved. Speed means business, and Concorde delivers speed.
10:30 Speaker 02 So, speed first, then capacity and efficiency. But wait, what's that in the sky?
10:38 Speaker 08 Apart from aircraft makers, no one was expecting the superjet. Supersonics were the planes of the future.
10:43 Speaker 02 It's a black swarm.
10:45 Speaker 08 Now they're preparing for the superjet, the Jumbo, the Boeing 747.
10:50 Speaker 02 In 1969, the Boeing 747 took off for the first time. That's 10 years after Dr. Van Abbie was griping that only rich people got to travel. The 747 wasn't any faster than the previous generation of jets, but it was much, much bigger.
11:05 Speaker 08 The Jumbo is roughly equivalent to three Boeing 707s. On international flights, it can carry 450 people.
11:13 Speaker 02 Its enormous size meant it could carry more fuel, and that meant it could get from Sydney to London with only one stop to fill up.
11:21 Speaker 09 The superjet transport is the economy plane for every man. The plane in the 70s will offer the most economical,
11:33 Speaker 09 the swiftest, the strongest, the safest transportation for the peoples of the world.
11:38 Speaker 02 When fully booked, the plane was quite economical. In 1971, Qantas started offering $700 return flights to London, nine weeks' average salary, down from 31 weeks in 1959. There was no way the Concorde was going to be able to compete with that price. According to Swinburne University Professor of Transport Technology Hussain Dia, the 747 changed the game.
12:02 Speaker 10 It carried nearly four times as many people at a fraction of the cost per seat, and it really just opened up international travel to millions of people, which actually improved equity in transport and in travel.
12:18 Speaker 02 This was really unexpected. A flying ocean liner was not at all what people in Dr. Van Abbie's day thought was coming next. They were waiting for supersonic jets. And the 747 didn't immediately change that expectation. Even Boeing was expecting supersonic jets to make their very, very large boy obsolete. They designed the 747 for easy conversion into a cargo jet once Concorde arrived.
12:42 Speaker 07 The world's cities will be linked at new speeds. Athens will become a neighbour of New York and Tokyo. Australia will lose its isolation.
12:49 Speaker 02 But creating a supersonic jet was an incredibly complicated engineering project, one that Boeing gave up on after spending $2 billion on research.
12:59 Speaker 08 This is the mock-up of the American SST, grounded permanently by combined economic and ecological opposition.
13:07 Speaker 08 It too promised to be a triumph of technology. Now it's just a storage problem.
13:15 Speaker 02 Planes really don't want to fly faster than the speed of sound. As you approach Mach 1, the atmospheric drag increases dramatically and tries to slow the plane back down. Concorde's engineers developed an incredibly high-tech, dart-shaped plane with four massive engines which could push past the sound barrier and reach speeds of Mach 2, twice the speed of sound. At high speed, the design worked extremely well, and the passengers tended to agree.
13:44 Speaker 11 One hardly feels the aircraft going through the sound barrier. It's quite smooth, hardly any different from any other flight one would take.
13:54 Speaker 04 She is a very normal aircraft, and not at all kinky.
13:58 Speaker 02 Concorde is not kinky, got it.
14:00 Speaker 07 She's a magnificent, a magnificent plane. I believe that she has a tremendous future.
14:07 Speaker 02 But while a dart is a great shape for high-speed flight, it's not a great shape for actually getting off the ground. In videos of Concorde's prototype taking off, you can see a thick trail of exhaust billowing from its engines as it leaves the ground. The plane had to use afterburners, squirting extra fuel into the exhaust of the engines in order to get enough thrust to get airborne. While taking off, they consumed 32.5 litres of fuel every second, a colossal amount. Throughout its trip, it burned five times more fuel per passenger than a fully-loaded jumbo jet.
14:45 Speaker 02 But that was okay, because at the time, fuel was quite cheap. In fact, fuel had been cheap for decades, and this reliability shaped the way most people at the time thought about the future. It was a key driver behind so many decisions that still affect our lives today. The way we get around both in the sky and on the road was entirely determined by reliably-cheap fuel. It was actually the reason that they felt like it was a good idea to rip out all those tram lines across the country.
15:14 Speaker 04 Australia has become one of the most motorised countries in the world. One in every four Australian owns a car. Many in fact own two vehicles.
15:23 Speaker 02 The sudden influx of cars in the 1940s and 50s meant that cities had to be redesigned to accommodate the increasing traffic demand.
15:30 Speaker 03 This elevated expressway is one idea to get Sydney's traffic moving.
15:34 Speaker 02 But it wasn't that people just spontaneously one day decided to go out and get a car. There were a lot of different forces driving this change to city infrastructure from behind the scenes.
15:43 Speaker 12 Try to imagine what this country would be like without automobile. It would be impossible to live in many parts of the country without them.
15:52 Speaker 02 From World War II onwards, the American auto industry did their best to portray cars as the only truly modern form of transportation.
15:59 Speaker 12 There's nothing like a car. Fifty million Americans can't be wrong.
16:04 Speaker 03 And their 1940 Chevrolet will get them to their destination easily, safely, and with the utmost economy.
16:11 Speaker 02 As car ownership increased, trams and cars started getting in each other's way. After all, most tram networks just ran down the middle of the street. What was the solution? Well, Professor of Transport Technology Hussein Deah said that in the US, the auto giant General Motors just started buying up the tram systems and removing them.
16:30 Speaker 10 They tried to buy out large networks of trams and dismantle them on purpose to make room for vehicles and trucks and buses, et cetera.
16:42 Speaker 02 There's some debate about how widespread this was, but GM was accused of orchestrating a conspiracy to destroy tram networks.
16:49 Speaker 10 A number of companies were actually collaborating and colluding, if you like, to essentially dismantle public transport.
16:58 Speaker 02 They needn't have bothered, though. They were being ripped out all over the world, with or without the help of the big auto companies. GM certainly didn't force Sydney to rip out its tram lines. By the 1970s, reliably cheap oil and petrol were fueling the transport industry. Electricity in trains and trams was barely being used.
17:17 Speaker 10 The car was seen as a form of freedom and building more roads was not only to accommodate transport and travel, it was seen as a form of modernity, as a form of economic development and recovery.
17:33 Speaker 02 Melbourne's tram network had become the largest in the Western world, not because of expansion, but because every other large Western city burned or scrapped their trams.
17:44 Speaker 02 Today, present Melburnians are rightfully very proud of past Melbourneians' decision to keep the tram network, though it was a decision that was by no means unanimous.
17:54 Speaker 13 I think they clutter up the roadway and they're a sort of a hazard.
17:59 Speaker 02 In the 1960s, many Melbourneians wanted their city to follow the rest of the country and rip out the trams.
18:04 Speaker 03 Well, I think they're past their usefulness now, but out of date. They want to do something a bit more modern.
18:10 Speaker 02 But Sir Robert Risson, the chairman of the Tramways Board, said he wasn't really interested in their opinions.
18:15 Speaker 14 All the objections, I think without exception, come from the people who very rarely if ever use them. They're not qualified to speak in that respect, and yet, if they stop sensibly to think, they're the people, perhaps more than almost anyone else, who should be anxious to see the trams remain. Do away with the trams and you'll have more and more people trying to drive their private motorcars.
18:39 Speaker 02 It was really a matter of timing. Sir Robert was sure that if they just held the line long enough, everyone would come around to his point of view. Experts were beginning to realise that solving traffic problems wasn't as simple as increasing the capacity of the road network.
18:55 Speaker 15 The appetite for roads of car users is absolutely unfathomable. It just goes on and on. If you build a superhighway, it fills with cars, and the more highways that you put in, the more cars you create.
19:11 Speaker 02 In Sydney, two extra traffic lanes had been opened up on the Harbour Bridge by removing the tram lines. They were almost immediately full of traffic, and it took just as long to cross the bridge as it had before. By 1970, every tram network but Melbourne's was gone, but by 1972, even the strongest sceptics were beginning to change their mind.
19:33 Speaker 03 I think the public a few years ago were like me. We had doubts about trams, but... My doubts have been resolved the more I've studied the role of trams.
19:42 Speaker 02 And yet Melbourne continued to see a steady decline in usage across all forms of public transport right through the 70s. The tram network was running at a significant annual loss. Why do you think they're losing so much money?
19:55 Speaker 16 Because of that evil polluting monster, the motorcar. I think if they only got rid of the motorcar, particularly from the centre of the city, then the trams would have a fair go.
20:04 Speaker 02 The ABC took journalist Keith Dunston and TV personality Noel Ferrier out for a ride on the trams to see if they could come up with ideas for making them more attractive to Melbourneians.
20:15 Speaker 16 They should be beautifully plush inside, padded leather like the Melbourne Club. And they should be a bar with whisky and beer being served and perhaps even nice little light meals down either end.
20:27 Speaker 02 Now that is a great idea Keith, I love it. Noel, what have you got?
20:31 Speaker 04 Having seen some of the very charming young conductresses that are now working on the Melbourne trams, I think perhaps a leaf out of Yelke's book and pop them into goal leotards to add a little more attraction, a little more colour perhaps to the tram life.
20:46 Speaker 02 Okey dokey, thanks for your input Noel. But then things started to change.
20:52 Speaker 02 In 1973, the Arab oil-producing states briefly cut off supply to countries which supported Israel. While the oil embargo was short, only six months long, its effects were massive.
21:05 Speaker 02 And that's because oil had been cheap for essentially the entire first half of the 20th century. It was an abundant, reliable, densely packed bundle of energy. The global price of oil, which had been stable for decades, suddenly went up by 650%, which had a massive impact on car owners in Australia.
21:23 Speaker 03 petrol finds its way into the tanks of New South Wales motorists at around 17 cents per litre.
21:29 Speaker 02 Okay, that doesn't sound like a lot to our modern ears, to be fair, but it was enough to change people's attitudes towards oil as a fuel. This was the global transport industry's largest black swan event. The world had been redesigned around the idea that oil could power our cars, buses, supersonic airliners and shipping forever.
21:47 Speaker 17 Unless profound changes are made to lower oil consumption, we now believe that early in the 1980s, the world will be demanding more oil than it can produce.
21:58 Speaker 02 For Concorde, this was catastrophic. These increased fuel costs had a massive impact on their ticket prices.
22:05 Speaker 08 Concorde can fly from Sydney to London in 15 and a half hours, about half the time for a Boeing Jumbo, but at three times the fare.
22:13 Speaker 02 Three times the first-class fare, that is. Concorde's manufacturers were hoping that the price difference wouldn't matter.
22:20 Speaker 18 We are offering a better product. You fly by aeroplane from A to B to get to B as fast as possible for no other reason. This aeroplane will get you there in half the time. It's a better product. It will command a higher price.
22:38 Speaker 02 But the market did not agree.
22:40 Speaker 08 There's more enthusiasm for filling cheaper seats than for introducing dearer, though faster ones.
22:47 Speaker 02 The dream of faster travel was slipping away. When Concorde was finally grounded permanently in 2003, a return ticket across the Atlantic Ocean would cost you about $12,000, compared with $9,000 for a first-class seat on a Jumbo and $750 for economy. Most people who could afford it were happy just riding first class. Concorde's failure was another black swan event. Everyone, from experts in the industry to the letter writers of Adelaide, thought that by now, all international passenger transport would take place on dart-shaped, non-kinky supersonic aircraft. And the reason it never happened is fuel.
23:31 Speaker 02 We never managed to invent... Your atomic aeroplanes and your time and space machines? When our letters to the unborn were written in 1959, flights were getting faster and faster. They had seen the flight time to London decrease from 12 to two days in just 15 years. They assumed that travel would keep getting faster, but it didn't. Black swans got in the way. The interesting thing is, after the Black Swan event changed the trajectory of travel, people adjusted and assumed that the new trajectory would continue. They thought that fuel would be unbelievably expensive and then run out. This had a huge impact on the way people got around as governments tried to um
24:14 Speaker 02 unburn all those trams.
24:17 Speaker 06 We've got to think about not only phasing cars out of the city centre, but bringing back light rail, bringing back trams and trolley buses.
24:24 Speaker 02 Cars did become more efficient, but not less popular. People didn't want to go back to public transport.
24:32 Speaker 03 Oh, come off it. Buses and trams and trains that are dirty and slow and uncomfortable. They must be joking.
24:38 Speaker 02 In the midst of the oil shocks, the South Australian Transport Authority produced a film trying to encourage people to use more public transport.
24:46 Speaker 03 Right now, public transport is beginning to compete with the motorcar.
24:50 Speaker 02 The film they produced included animated sections of what the future of public transport might look like.
24:55 Speaker 03 Personalised rapid transit is a system which provides vehicles for single passengers or for small groups of up to six, which move automatically along a network of guideways, taking the passengers directly from any station to any station in the system without stopping.
25:09 Speaker 02 They were discussing this hypothetical system as a way of combining the convenience and privacy of cars with the speed and efficiency of public transport.
25:18 Speaker 03 Perhaps it's one possible solution to the problem of giving our cities a chance to be the kind of places people want them to be.
25:24 Speaker 02 That film was made 50 years ago, and in the intervening 50 years, there have been countless attempts to make that personalised rapid transit system a reality.
25:33 Speaker 19 They can be ordered like taxis for individual journeys to the village or the city.
25:38 Speaker 20 They hope to make this next generation transportation a reality by 2025.
25:43 Speaker 02 Elon Musk is attempting to figure out ways of turning his self-driving Teslas into personalised rapid transit cars by building tunnels under American cities.
25:53 Speaker 20 So there are working tunnels in Las Vegas that you can use. It feels like teleporting from one part of Vegas to another.
25:59 Speaker 02 Yeah, but so does a train. We've spent decades dreaming about little pods instead of building trains.
26:07 Speaker 02 When I commute from Sydney to Newcastle, the train takes about two and a half hours, travelling at an average of 66 kilometres an hour. When our letter writers were putting pen to paper more than six decades ago, and the route was operated by steam trains, the trip could be completed in less than two hours at more than 80 kilometres an hour. A lack of investment over decades has meant that we've gone backwards. Professor Hussein Dia says that we should be investing a lot more in public transport.
26:36 Speaker 10 Australia is a very large country, and even Sydney to Melbourne, or Sydney to Brisbane, these are very expensive projects. But I think there is no denying that high-speed rail is going to come on top, and a lot of countries around the world are investing in it. The more we delay it, the more expensive it will become.
26:57 Speaker 02 All of this is not just a rant about the decades-long destruction of public transport. This series is about predicting the future. Nobody in the 1950s thought that by now, we would have only made tiny incremental steps towards higher-speed transport. Getting around isn't much easier now than it was back then. Maybe they shouldn't have set fire to all those trams.
27:25 Speaker 02 Now, all of this seems a little bit grim.
27:29 Speaker 02 And if I told you that in the next episode, we're looking at doomsday predictions, it might sound like it's going to get even grimmer. But I think you might be surprised. After all, people have been predicting the end of the world for a while, and yet we are still here. Hopefully, we'll still be here next week.
27:51 Speaker 02 I'll see you then.
28:01 Speaker 02 This special series of If You're Listening was written by me, Matt Bevan. It was produced by Adair Shepherd, Caroline Gates, Pat Sunderland and Jess O'Callaghan. Supervising producer is Cara Jensen-McKinnon.
28:13 Speaker 02 On my desk, I've got a bestselling book from 1980 called The Book of Predictions. It's a collection of predictions from both experts and psychics. Forty-five years on from its publication, we're going to be hearing from the author, David Woloschinski, and talk to him about the strike rate of correct predictions by both camps. Who do you think did better? The experts or the psychics? You'll find out on Tuesday. I'll see you then.
Previous The city that ten beers built Next Did a 1981 book correctly predict the future? Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated