Pod Insights If You're Listening 01 Black Swans | The Population Bomb About this episode Until recently people were scared our planet would be outstripped by the weight of a colossal population. Experts feared that by 2026, there would be so many people that we would be starved of resources, and eat ourselves to death. Ironically we now find ourselves in a world where we’re not scared about having too many babies, but rather too few. So what happened?
Follow If You're Listening on the ABC Listen app https://radio.abc.net.au/help/apps.
Check out our series on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDTPrMoGHssAfgMMS3L5LpLNFMNp1U_Nq
Transcript 4,443 words · 22 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:09 Speaker 01 Hi, it's Patricia Carvallis here. I'm the host of the Politics Now podcast and I spend a lot of time talking to politicians, usually grilling them. But over summer, I want to introduce you to the people behind the politics.
0:23 Speaker 02 People think politicians love talking about themselves, but it's not really the case.
0:27 Speaker 00 I genuinely, I'm not actually going to, well, who, no, I'm not going to name any names.
0:30 Speaker 01 Why not?
0:31 Speaker 00 No, I'm not.
0:32 Speaker 01 You can find the interview series in the Politics Now podcast feed.
0:37 Speaker 03 This podcast was produced on the lands of the Uwabikal and Gadigal people. Look around the spot where you're sitting right this very moment. Now, imagine being in that spot 67 years in the past or in the future. Would it look different? Well, take where I'm sitting, my house, for example. It's only 32 years old, so 67 years ago, the spot I'm sitting in would be bushland. What about 67 years into the future, though? Will the building you're in still exist? Or will our AI overlords have forced us to live in sad little pods by then? Hard to imagine, though, right? That's because it's really hard to predict the future.
1:21 Speaker 03 But this isn't new. We've actually always been very bad at it. Don't believe me? Well, let me show you something really cool I found in the ABC archives.
1:33 Speaker 04 Hello there, you in the future.
1:35 Speaker 03 Hello. This is Reverend Frank Balland, talking to us from 1959.
1:40 Speaker 04 Am I thought waves reaching you?
1:42 Speaker 03 Um, yes.
1:43 Speaker 04 You know, when the ABC rang up and said, would you like to write a letter to the unborn? I immediately said, why not? I'm going to try anything once.
1:52 Speaker 03 67 years ago, Reverend Balland was invited to participate in an extraordinary project conducted by the ABC in Adelaide to record a letter to the future.
2:03 Speaker 04 What kind of a fool thing was this I've been asked to do? A letter to the unborn? To a nobody, in fact? A non-existent person?
2:12 Speaker 03 A bit rude, but of course, to the Reverend, I am a nobody. I was born seventeen years after his death. But thanks to this project, The Letters to the Unborn, written in 1959, that's not an issue. In fact, we can hear from all sorts of interesting people.
2:32 Speaker 05 Well, hello to you. This is being written in 1959.
2:38 Speaker 04 Hello there, hello? Hello, can you hear me? Dear Future One.
2:43 Speaker 06 Dear Unborn One.
2:47 Speaker 03 These letters are beautiful and strange and touching and occasionally quite racist. And also, almost all of them make predictions about the future.
2:58 Speaker 07 When you open it, unless I'm very wrong, letter-writing will be as outmoded as speech. And the word "speech", I feel I should explain, because it may mean little to you.
3:10 Speaker 03 Yep, we're still across the concept of speech here in the 21st century. Now, I have to be fair here, many of the letters are addressed to dates that are still very much in the future.
3:19 Speaker 05 This letter isn't supposed to be read until 2100 AD.
3:24 Speaker 03 So yes, we might have dug a couple of these up a little early.
3:27 Speaker 05 So if you stumble upon a copy or dig it up earlier, read it by all means, I can't stop you. But then put it back.
3:34 Speaker 03 But the extraordinary thing about the letters is that even the ones addressed to us right now, in the first half of the 21st century, get all of their predictions pretty much wrong.
3:46 Speaker 08 Global peace and international harmony will be completely attained by the year 2000. The price of this great and ultimate good has been the faculty of criticism in every individual.
3:59 Speaker 04 Perhaps you just press a button or twiddle a knob on some time machine and pop into any point in time and space you feel inclined to visit.
4:07 Speaker 05 You all commute daily in alleys so fast through space in your private flying saucers. I suppose when you dine in a supernuclear heated Antarctic cave way below the South Pole, it may be barely twenty minutes since you left Tibet.
4:22 Speaker 03 But predictions of interplanetary trips on your lunch break aside, reading all these letters, I noticed something fascinating. There seems to be almost a consensus about the direction humanity was headed. Remember, 1959 was the height of the Cold War, so many of the writers were convinced that by now we would be living in a post-apocalyptic hellscape amid nuclear fallout.
4:45 Speaker 04 Our chances of survival on this earth of Europe's forefathers are not quite as rosy as they might be.
4:52 Speaker 03 Listening to these letters kind of got us obsessed with this idea of predicting the future. How predictions that can seem so obvious to everyone at the time can be so totally off.
5:05 Speaker 03 Why? Well, it turns out knowing more about an issue can actually make you worse at predicting what's going to happen next.
5:20 Speaker 03 Let me give you an example. Let's say I have a box and I'm telling you that inside this hypothetical box is a swan. If I asked you to guess the colour of the swan, what would you say? Well, you, in 2025, will probably hesitate. You've seen swans of multiple colours. But if I had presented this box to a man in London in, say, 1650, he would have said with 100% certainty that the swan inside was white. Saying that something was like a black swan was a common way of saying that it was impossible, like saying something is as rare as hen's teeth or it's like getting blood from a stone. That's because until Europeans landed in Australia and saw the Australian black swan for the first time,
6:05 Speaker 03 they had no idea that the swan in my box could be anything other than white. They were missing key information, just like our friends from 1959. But what was the key information they were missing? Over the next four episodes, we're going to go through these letters sent to us from 1959 and investigate why they were so wrong. We'll look at where those black swans they couldn't see coming came from, and what we can do to avoid being bitten by them ourselves. I'm Matt Benham, and from if you're listening, this is our special series, Black Swans.
6:50 Speaker 03 So we're going to start with something our letter writers were obsessed with, and that's the problem of overpopulation.
6:57 Speaker 09 Even if official attitudes were to change quickly, I for one expect the population problem to be with us for many generations.
7:05 Speaker 03 Our letter writers were convinced that the earth was destined for horrific overcrowding. People who make a study of these things tell us that in the foreseeable future, there'll be standing room only on our earth. So why did they think that? Well, it's not hard to see if you look at how the global population has changed over the course of human history. From the beginning of humanity until the 1800s, there were less than a billion people on this planet. But by the late 1920s, we were already at 2 billion, and we were passing 3 billion by the time the letters to the unborn were being written in 1959. It would have felt like the population
7:47 Speaker 03 was increasing exponentially, and it was such a concern that the ABC actually produced a documentary about it in 1965.
7:55 Speaker 09 The world's population now stands at about 3,300 million people. It is expanding at the rate of about 65 millions each year. In 1980, the estimated figure is 4,300 million, and in the year 2000, 7,000 million people, and so on in geometrical progression.
8:17 Speaker 03 You can understand why people believed this was all heading towards inevitable disaster.
8:22 Speaker 09 Statisticians warn that the population of the world was growing so fast that it would be jam-packed full in November 2026 AD, doomsday 60 years from now.
8:35 Speaker 03 November twenty twenty six A D, that's this year. Anyway, at the time, an impending doomsday wasn't the only thing waiting on the horizon. There was also the fear that a rapidly increasing population meant that they would run out of food.
8:50 Speaker 10 Are you living a future one against the background of a continuous series of famines as populations outstrip their food resources?
8:58 Speaker 03 That's because at the time, the most horrific famine of the twentieth century was underway in China.
9:03 Speaker 11 In this age, two thirds of the people of the world are half-starved.
9:08 Speaker 11 In the places where this is worse, like India or China, the population leaps forward so fast that it is impossible to improve the situation.
9:17 Speaker 03 Meanwhile, experts were warning that worse was yet to come.
9:20 Speaker 12 By nineteen eighty, I look for the entire continents of Asia, Africa and Latin America to be engulfed in virtually a total famine.
9:28 Speaker 03 Three whole continents in total famine by nineteen eighty. It sounds like a serious crisis, and a serious crisis needs a prominent spokesperson. And this one had a really good one.
9:39 Speaker 09 Paul Ehrlich has become the best-known advocate of immediate population control.
9:44 Speaker 03 Paul was a media dream. He was young, he had sideburns, he was always ready with a snappy retort.
9:51 Speaker 13 He would seem to cut right across inalienable human rights.
9:55 Speaker 14 You say these are inalienable rights, as a favorite sport of people is to make up inalienable rights uh to fit their own preconception.
10:02 Speaker 03 In his nineteen sixty eight book, The Population Bomb, Ehrlich wrote that the battle to feed all of humanity is over. In the nineteen seventies, hundreds of millions of people will starve to death in spite of any crash programs embarked upon now. So doomsday was coming not in twenty twenty six, but much, much sooner.
10:22 Speaker 14 It could happen tomorrow. That's how thin things are. In other words, a serious change in the world's weather or a an even sharper drop in world fisheries last year than this year, uh and we could be in very serious trouble immediately. But I would say, if I had to put my money somewhere, uh I would bet somewhere around nineteen eighty now, but that could change in either direction.
10:40 Speaker 03 He thought people needed to be restricted by law from having large families, a prospect that many people thought was appalling. At the time, it had never been attempted anywhere in the world.
10:50 Speaker 14 The best answer from the point of view of democracy seems to be on across-the-board limitation of family's eyes to two children unless the second birth is a multiple birth.
10:59 Speaker 03 If governments couldn't stomach this kind of restriction, then Dr Ehrlich prescribed a propaganda campaign.
11:05 Speaker 14 The first thing that has to be tried is a governmental programme of propaganda, the president simply announcing that it's stupid and irresponsible to have more than two children.
11:12 Speaker 03 The president at the time was slightly more hesitant to call people stupid than the current occupant of the Oval Office. So what else have you got?
11:20 Speaker 14 He ought to make the FCC see to it that large families are always treated in a negative light on television wherever they appear.
11:26 Speaker 03 Sorry, Brady Bunch, you're the villains now. The Population Bomb was wildly popular, selling millions of copies. But why? Demographer Bernard Salt has a theory.
11:37 Speaker 15 I wonder whether in fact it struck a chord with people fearing the future, having concern for what lay ahead, and what seemed to be a logical narrative, there seemed to be evidence for it. I can understand people making that projection.
11:55 Speaker 03 Now, it's worth noting here that Ehrlich was not the only person making pronouncements and predictions like this. In 1972, a group of academics, politicians, civil servants and industrialists called the Club of Rome, published a series of computer simulations they devised to predict the future.
12:12 Speaker 11 It shows that Earth cannot sustain present population and industrial growth for much more than a few decades.
12:18 Speaker 03 They set doomsday a little later than Ehrlich did. Round about the year 2040, 2050, civilised life as we know it on this planet will cease to exist. The Club's book Limits to Growth, which includes a blurb by Ehrlich and cites his work in multiple places, was an even bigger hit than The Population Bomb and was translated into dozens of different languages, including Chinese. The American government didn't follow Ehrlich and the Club of Rome's advice on population control, but the Chinese government sure did. At the time, the Chinese population was hurtling towards a billion and the government felt that the best way to avoid future famines and to increase their standard of living was to have fewer kids around.
13:01 Speaker 03 They started with propaganda campaigns encouraging people to get married later and to only have two children. And in 1979, they implemented the one-child policy.
13:11 Speaker 16 The state keeps records of the breeding potential and performance of all residents. Who's been sterilised? Who's taking the pill? Who's signed the promise to have no more children?
13:23 Speaker 03 They were aiming for Ehrlich's dream: zero population growth. But while China, South Korea and other countries were implementing their Ehrlich-inspired population control policies, the Australian government was actually looking to increase population growth. They even appointed a minister to head up a national population inquiry in the early 70s, a sharpshooter called Al Grasby. In Al's opinion, trying to control Australia's population was pointless and wrong.
13:50 Speaker 17 You'd have to appoint a police force that would have special lots that would enter all the bedrooms of the nation and say, "That's enough." That's the first thing you'd have to do, and secondly, you would have to put a kangaroo curtain around the nation and say, "No one else will enter." Now, that would be wrong, immoral and impractical in both cases.
14:09 Speaker 03 And a big reason for this attitude was that Australia's domestic birth rate had started to decline.
14:14 Speaker 09 I think it will go up and down, but I think the long-term change will be downwards.
14:19 Speaker 03 It was doing this even without any population control policies or propaganda. The interesting thing experts were noticing was that, given the choice, many people were deciding entirely of their own accord to have fewer children.
14:32 Speaker 18 But if you want to have a bit of your own private life, perhaps continue a career that you started. It's impossible, with all the money in the world, to bring up eight or 10 children.
14:43 Speaker 03 So perhaps Ehrlich's population bomb wasn't quite as explosive as he thought. Oh, and the enormous famines he predicted, they weren't happening either. In fact, despite his prediction of hundreds of millions of people starving to death in the 1970s, the decade saw fewer deaths from famines than any of the previous six decades. But Ehrlich was not phased. He just revised that chapter of his book. Now, the first line read in the 1970s and 1980s: "Hundreds of millions of people will starve to death." But the 1980s saw deaths from famine drop even further. In fact, three times more people died from famine in the 1960s than in all the decades since combined.
15:30 Speaker 03 So what's going on here? Where's all the famines? Why does it now seem unlikely that the planet will be?
15:36 Speaker 19 Jam-packed full in November 2026 AD.
15:40 Speaker 03 Well, at this point, I think it's worth pointing out a very important fact about Paul Ehrlich. The Population Bomb was his fourth book. His first three books were How to Know the Butterflies, Butterflies and Plants, and Process of Evolution, which was in large part a book about butterflies. Ehrlich is a lepidopterist, a butterfly scientist. It was his wife Anne who researched population. She had, in fact, co-written the book. But the publisher said it would sell more with just one author, so goodbye, Anne. But even Anne's expertise was as a biologist. She studied animal populations, not human populations. And the book is full of comparisons to the behaviour of animals, rats, rabbits, that kind of thing.
16:25 Speaker 03 Animals that breed and consume resources until they overtax their environment and have a massive population crash. Here in Australia, we see it frequently with kangaroos. Variations in rainfall lead to massive variations in the kangaroo population, booming in wet years and then in drought, it's like Armageddon. The argument set out in The Population Bomb is that this is what would happen with humans, but on a longer timescale. Resources would become scarce and then all hell would break loose. Or, in Paul Ehrlich's words...
16:57 Speaker 14 I think the eventual consequence is that sometime between now and the turn of the century, we're going to have a huge die-off from either a massive famine, or a nuclear war, or vast plagues, or a combination of all three.
17:11 Speaker 03 So what happened? Why didn't we have a human ru-pocalypse?
17:16 Speaker 03 If you look back at Oelke's predictions and compare it to actual population trends, you'll notice that they do not match up. Let's go back to demographer Bernard Salt.
17:25 Speaker 15 There is a concept now, peak humanity. We expect the maximum number of human beings on the planet to be reached in about 2080, so it's about 60 years into the future. And thereafter, the projections by demographers are that the number of people on the planet will slowly start to subside.
17:45 Speaker 03 What about feeding all those people, though? Well, global food production has managed to keep pace with population, and then some. And we've managed to do it without turning enormous tracts of wilderness into agricultural land. So we're making way more food using the same amount of land. How? Well, remember that black swan in a box that nobody could predict? Well, here's our very first one.
18:09 Speaker 20 Born in Cresco, Iowa, in 1914, Norman Borlaug pursued his commitment early to fight against hunger. Since the age of 30, Dr Borlaug has been in Mexico.
18:18 Speaker 21 I've been here for 26 years, working in wheat all of this time.
18:22 Speaker 03 When Norman Borlaug started his agricultural work in Mexico, he couldn't afford a mule or a horse, so he pulled the plough himself. By 1965, he was leading a multinational crew of wheat scientists, all working to breed new types of wheat. Borlaug and his team developed a type of wheat that was far more resistant to bad weather, could grow in lots of different conditions, and could produce more food than the traditional type. And this wheat formed the basis of what became known as the Green Revolution, as more and more strains of cereals were developed.
18:55 Speaker 05 In the last decade, these new crops have achieved remarkable results in several parts of the world, often doubling and even tripling previous yields.
19:03 Speaker 03 The Green Revolution is now being credited with saving a billion people from starvation, and won Borlaug the Nobel Peace Prize.
19:11 Speaker 06 I call upon you, Norman Ernest Borlaug, to receive the Nobel Peace Prize for 1970.
19:20 Speaker 03 With these new, more robust seeds, crop yields, that is, the amount of food that you can get from a set amount of land, skyrocketed. And that's how we can produce more food from the same amount of land. Of course, it also relies on a lot of pesticides and fertiliser which many people are opposed to. But Norman Borlaug said that's just the price we're gonna have to pay.
19:41 Speaker 21 The world must decide that either we use agricultural chemicals and use them wisely, the right amounts, the right kinds, to produce the food we need, or we will all starve.
19:52 Speaker 03 That seems reasonable, but according to Ehrlich, even if it all works perfectly, it won't be enough.
19:58 Speaker 14 If we're very fortunate, the Green Revolution will buy us 10 to 20 to 30, perhaps, years to solve the population explosion.
20:05 Speaker 03 Are we like kangaroos, rats and rabbits? Will our population expand until we reach the limit of the planet's resources? One of our letter writers, just one, expressed some doubt.
20:16 Speaker 10 Is the only limit to population that of starving thousands following a limit in food supply? In fact, it is my hope that neither will happen. Experiments with animals such as mice, birds and tiny weevils have shown that population increase may cease, notwithstanding the presence of ample food supply.
20:36 Speaker 03 In fact, some demographers saw this happening in human populations, well before Ehrlich or our letter writers put pen to paper. In 1945, the American demographer Kingsley Davis wrote that people who attempt to calculate the theoretical maximum population of the planet by looking at food production were being unrealistic because, quote, "It is impossible to guess what technological improvements will be made during the next few centuries," unquote. As he was writing that, Norman Borlaug was pulling a plough by himself somewhere in Mexico. But the possibility of technological advances wasn't the point of Davis's piece. It was about what he called "the demographic transition," the way that as a society's
21:20 Speaker 03 quality of life increased, the fertility rate decreased. Let's go back to Bernard Salt.
21:25 Speaker 15 It's a very interesting view that Kingsley Davis has put forward, and especially in 1945, quite prophetic when you think about it.
21:34 Speaker 03 It was already pretty obvious in the data. There was a clear fertility decline in all the richest countries in the first half of the 20th century. Davis drew a direct link between high literacy and low fertility. He predicted that as societies like China and India industrialised, their population would stabilise and then begin to fall. He wrote, "A rapid growth of the world's population need hold no terrors. It seems likely that the next century will see the peak of the world's population growth reached." For the first time in this episode, we've found someone who is absolutely bang on in his prediction. But Kingsley Davis wrote that in 1945, and by the end of that year, the baby boom had
22:19 Speaker 03 started. And Kingsley seems to have lost all faith in his own predictions and became a strong proponent of population control policies. He is quoted in Paul Ehrlich's The Population Bomb as saying that just offering contraceptives to parents is not an effective form of population control because it leaves individuals in charge of population growth. And yet Bernard Salt thinks that educating people and providing them with contraceptive pills worked better than anyone expected.
22:50 Speaker 15 At the time that Paul Ehrlich published The Population Bomb, the pill of course had been invented and had been distributed, but it hadn't really had a significant impact by the late 1960s. 10, 20, 30, 40 years later, of course, it has profoundly changed the future of humanity.
23:10 Speaker 03 In 1967, just over two decades after his first entirely accurate prediction, Kingsley Davis wrote something that I find extraordinary. He said that a government could, if they wanted, control population by following these steps: squeeze consumers through taxation and inflation; make housing very scarce by limiting construction; force wives and mothers to work outside the home to offset the inadequacy of male wages; yet provide few childcare facilities; encourage migration to the city by paying low wages in the country and providing few rural jobs; increase congestion in cities by starving the transit system; increase personal insecurity by encouraging conditions
23:54 Speaker 03 that produce unemployment. Yeah, let that sink in.
24:00 Speaker 03 Now, he said he didn't think governments would do this because it was like, you know, obviously immoral and evil, but I reckon he was probably on to something there. It seems like a few did all those things by accident. That paper was written a year before the population bomb and seems to have had very little impact. In fact, as far as I can see, Kingsley Davis has spent the last six decades basically buried in obscurity.
24:28 Speaker 03 In the 1950s and 1960s, when our letter writers and butterfly experts were fretting about catastrophic famines and high birth rates, they were assuming that those things would just keep happening. It's a perfect example of recency bias. We assume that the things that are happening now will keep happening, trends will not change direction. If things are getting worse, they'll keep getting worse, and if they're getting better, they will keep getting better. They were missing two black swans. One was that wealthy, literate societies stop having so many babies. The other was that human ingenuity can find ways to eke enormous amounts of food out of every hectare farmland. Today, those black swans are having extraordinary ramifications.
25:12 Speaker 03 China, South Korea, and most countries that pursued aggressive population control policies in the 1970s and 80s are now facing a demographic crisis.
25:23 Speaker 15 It's an entire generation in China that has been reduced. The problem is, when you extend that across a generation or two, then you're not just reducing the current population generation, but you're reducing the next generation of people who will produce the next generation.
25:41 Speaker 03 The people born before those policies are retiring, and they didn't have enough children to replace themselves in the workforce. The demographic transition that Kingsley Davis talked about happened in China, but it was hidden, masked by the one-child policy.
25:57 Speaker 15 And in actual fact, if you look at government policy, the policy is more likely these days to encourage people to have children.
26:05 Speaker 03 Just 45 years after they were worried about too many babies, China now faces the prospect of having too few. Oops.
26:17 Speaker 03 The thing is, our letters are full of things like this. Predictions that seemed so obvious at the time but turned out to be so wrong.
26:27 Speaker 03 And the reasons they were wrong are fascinating. They say a lot about the assumptions we're making now about what the future holds for us. So I hope you'll join me in the next few episodes as we look into three key questions that were a big deal then and remain a big deal now, but for entirely different reasons. Where are we going to live? How are we going to get around? And are we all going to die in some kind of apocalypse? But I can promise it's not all doom and gloom. And I can say that with certainty because spoiler, I know where we're going to end up on this journey. I mean, I wrote the script and I can confirm that by the end of it, I feel kind of uplifted, optimistic. Given the state of the world right now, I know that's unexpected, but I think you'll
27:11 Speaker 03 probably feel like that too. I'll catch you next week. Maybe, I mean, I can't predict the future.
27:31 Speaker 03 This special series of If You're Listening was written by me, Matt Bevan. It was produced by Adair Shepherd, Caroline Gates, Pat Sunderland and Jessa Callahan. Supervising producer is Cara Jensen-McKinnon.
Previous Matt got lost on his way to the costume department Next 02 Black Swans | The Australian Dream Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated