Pod Insights I Catch Killers with Gary Jubelin The death investigator: Hugh Dillon Pt.1 About this episode How did a person die? That’s the question Hugh Dillon asked as he oversaw more than 300 cases during his career as Deputy State Coroner. Working in death investigation, the retired coroner has seen the best and worst of humanity. He joins Gary Jubelin to talk about some of the cases that he’ll never forget.
Want to hear more from I Catch Killers? Visit news.com.au.
Watch episodes of I Catch Killers on our YouTube channelhere https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLlq8In_ATbJnjFcb-fykqJ8HV9W9OOJWX.
Like the show? Get more aticatchkillers.com.au https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/truecrimeaustralia/i-catch-killers/i-catch-killers-gary-jubelins-new-podcast-series-and-book/news-story/6848df9e1b6feccf7508878fc0438f7f Advertising enquiries: [email protected]
Questions for Gary: [email protected]
Get in touch with the show by joining ourFacebook group https://www.facebook.com/groups/844896725918656, and visiting us onInstagram https://www.instagram.com/icatchkillers/?hl=en orTiktok https://www.tiktok.com/@icatchkillerspodcast?lang=en.
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 10,074 words · 2 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 The public has had a long-held fascination with detectives. Detectives see a side of life the average person is never exposed to. I spent 34 years as a cop. For 25 of those years, I was catching killers. That's what I did for a living. I was a homicide detective. I'm no longer just interviewing bad guys. Instead, I'm taking the public into the world in which I operate. The guests I talk to each week have amazing stories from all sides of the law. The interviews are raw and honest, just like the people I talk to. Some of the content and language might be confronting. That's because no one who comes into contact with crime is left unchanged. Join me now as I take you into this world.
0:46 Speaker 00 Today, I had the privilege of sitting down and having a chat with former New South Wales Deputy State Coroner Hugh Dillon. I say privilege because Hugh shares a passion very much aligned with what I considered the most important role I had as a homicide detective. That was looking after the families of people who have died in tragic, violent, and unusual circumstances. Bringing whatever comfort possible to the deceased families by providing answers as to what happened to their loved ones, and where possible, prevent unnecessary deaths. Throughout his career, Hugh presided over more than 300 inquests, including the horrific School of Happiness case, where one man hunted police with a crossbow in the middle of the night during a hippie festival.
1:31 Speaker 00 He also oversaw murders, suicides, and tragic accidental deaths. As you'll find out in our discussion, the coroner's court is filled with sadness and emotion. Hugh takes us through the cases of the oversaw, how the system can be improved, and the personal impact of dealing with death on a daily basis. Hugh Dillon, thanks for coming on I Catch Killers.
1:55 Speaker 01 It's a great pleasure, Gary. Very nice to see you again.
1:57 Speaker 00 Well, it is good to see you and I always, I had a lot of respect for the role that you did as a coroner. And you were the deputy state coroner, or was it coroner for nine years?
2:08 Speaker 01 Yes, that's right.
2:09 Speaker 00 And in prepping for it, I believe that you oversaw probably 300, roughly 300 inquests?
2:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a bit hard to work it out exactly, but around about 300, I'd say.
2:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's a lot. And I don't think people fully appreciate the impact that the coroner's court has. I found that in all the areas of policing I work, that's when I saw the most emotion at coroner's courts. Because you're talking about someone's died, that's generally what the inquest is about. And you've got the families and loved ones there, holding on to hope or trying to get answers. Is that how you felt?
2:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a surprising place, a surprising niche in the legal system. And most people in the law, most people in society have no idea. But I can remember the first day I went to the coroner's court, I was a new magistrate. And I was really surprised by it.
3:17 Speaker 01 Apart from anything else, the coroners were doing this kind of work that no other lawyers in our society do. And also they're working in teams. And as you say, their concern is who has died, how they've died, why they've died. But also what can we say to the families? And the families, my father was a coroner's case himself around about 40 years ago. And I remember, I remember very, very well getting the news that he'd died suddenly.
3:57 Speaker 01 And the shock and the confusion that that throws you into. So to walk into this place as a coroner and to try and grapple with that confusion, the bewilderment, and of course, the sadness was somewhat bewildering to me as well.
4:20 Speaker 01 But Gary, I really liked being a coroner. And it's, some people would be astonished to hear me say that, I guess. Because of course, you're right, it is a very sad place in lots of ways. Families are devastated, they're confused, they want answers. Sometimes they have interesting theories about how someone they love has died. Some of those theories are right, but some of them are wrong. And it's very difficult to walk people into the evidence and through it. And then bring them to some sort of understanding, some sort of sense of what happened.
5:06 Speaker 01 I think some people might call this sense-making, you know, how do we make sense of these terrible events?
5:11 Speaker 00 There's a lot of expectation when people get to the coroner's court. I saw that over the years with families. And it's almost like, okay, the answer's going to be forthcoming when the matter gets to the coroner's court. And I think meeting the family's expectation, or that's a difficult part too. Because sometimes, you know, the facts don't present the way the family expected it to. And quite often, the evidence that is given at a coronial inquest is quite confronting to the families and loved ones of the deceased person.
5:41 Speaker 01 Well, that's right. And although you're always very glad as a coroner, if you have found the answers.
5:50 Speaker 00 Yeah.
5:50 Speaker 01 There are lots of cases where you don't. And you, as a homicide or an ex homicide detective, would be very familiar with some of those cases. You know, there are unsolved homicides as well as, you know, all the, I want to call them happy endings, but they're cases in which there is an answer for people.
6:11 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:11 Speaker 01 And to leave people without answers is, it's not only very frustrating, but it's also very sad because you can't help empathising and feeling for them, but also with them, you know.
6:27 Speaker 01 If you lose a daughter, you know, I'm thinking about my daughter as I'm talking to you about you losing yours. What a shattering and incomplete kind of sense of life you might have. So, as I say, sometimes you can provide answers and that can give people a sense of resolution.
6:51 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:51 Speaker 01 I don't believe there's any such thing as closure. I think that's a false hope.
6:57 Speaker 00 I'm glad you say that and that tells me you understand the situation that families go through. And I got clipped very early in my career when I used the word closure to a family. And they pointed out very, very clear to me, it's not the closure. You'll never get closure from that. And that's what happens when, and it's not always homicide. If someone's, I would find that in the coroner's court, those tragic accidents are hard to deal with too.
7:25 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, very much so.
7:27 Speaker 00 Because I look at homicide and often the families can allocate blame to a particular person.
7:33 Speaker 01 Hmm.
7:33 Speaker 00 Where there's accidents, where does the fault lie? There's built up anger and sadness and there's nowhere to channel it.
7:40 Speaker 01 Hmm, that's right. And I think the families of missing people have a particularly onerous load to bear.
7:51 Speaker 01 I guess if you can bury your loved ones, you can, you can have a sense of, not completion or anything like that, but you can say goodbye. But if you, all you have is your last memories of them and then they disappear off the face of the earth, how do you deal with that? I really don't know. And I never really learned how to, how to give people a sense of peace or any sense of forward movement.
8:27 Speaker 01 I think the only thing you can do for people where their loved ones disappear is respect.
8:35 Speaker 00 Yeah.
8:35 Speaker 01 Recognition, you know, we will do our best to to find out what happened. But sometimes the answer is beyond reach.
8:44 Speaker 00 That's not there. I saw with families on missing persons cases, quite often that I I felt like it was a step that helped them in processing what had happened when the coroner would declare the person deceased.
8:56 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:56 Speaker 00 Because what I what I've seen with families and friends of people who have just disappeared, they always hang on to that smidgen of hope that the person's going to walk through the door one day.
9:07 Speaker 01 Hmm.
9:07 Speaker 00 And they're going to yell at the person, go, what have you done? And then they're going to give each other a big cuddle and and get on with their lives. So I think sometimes they they hold on to hope and quite often I I've seen it in coronial inquest where the coroner's declared the person deceased. Manner and cause might have known, but believed that the person is is deceased because of checks that have been done. And I feel like it's a step forward. But the coroner's court, I always found the expectations were high by the families.
9:37 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:38 Speaker 00 That was a lot of it's built up, like if if the investigation into a death of someone hasn't revealed the information or the person responsible, quite often the hope is, well, we'll get the answers at the coroner's court. But that's not always the way. And that that must have carried hard on you being a coroner, that the family's staring, but where else do we go? And the sad part is sometimes there's nowhere else to go after the coroner's court.
10:02 Speaker 01 Yeah, and and it's very frustrating and and from time to time, I think coroners, I think they they fail people by not saying what they really think. Sometimes I think, and I've seen this happen, particularly with inexperienced coroners, they will, simply because they know how sad people are and how hard it will hit them if you say, I think your loved one is dead. Um, they say, oh, well, you know, the evidence isn't quite sufficient, so maybe there's still.
10:40 Speaker 00 Soften the soften the.
10:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I I I, to be honest, I think that does not help people.
10:48 Speaker 00 Yeah.
10:49 Speaker 01 cope with what has actually happened. If someone has disappeared and they've, I mean, very occasionally, people do turn up. I know, we all know that, but it is so rare. It's, it's once in many, many blue moons.
11:05 Speaker 00 Yeah.
11:06 Speaker 01 And I think as a coroner, you have a duty of care, both to the dead in respect to them, but also to the families, to be upfront with families and say, "The investigation has got this far. We don't know precisely what happened, but your loved one more than likely is dead."
11:28 Speaker 00 Yeah.
11:29 Speaker 01 "We can't prove it beyond a reasonable doubt perhaps, but it's almost certain. So that's all we can do."
11:36 Speaker 00 I think, I think that's kind of, the false hope can be a very cruel thing if, uh, false hope is, is offered, offered out. So I think role of a coroner and, and that is quite often the final step for families, uh, trying to find out what's happened to their loved one, especially with, uh, people who disappeared. Tell us, what was your story into becoming a coroner?
11:56 Speaker 01 Uh, well, um, I obviously did a law degree. In Australia, coroners are lawyers. Um, in New South Wales, they're all magistrates. I did some legal research. Uh, I worked for a judge. I worked for the New South Wales Ombudsman. And then I got a job as a Commonwealth prosecutor. So I worked for the Commonwealth DPP for a number of years. Then I was appointed a magistrate, did about 12 years as a magistrate. And I was on the point of leaving the magistracy. Uh, and, uh, my friend Mary Jerem, who was the new state coroner, heard that I was contemplating leaving and she got in touch with me and asked me whether I'd
12:40 Speaker 01 like to have a go as a coroner and, uh, To be honest, I thought, oh my God, this is so depressing, this kind of work.
12:48 Speaker 00 Yeah.
12:49 Speaker 01 Um, but I really liked Mary and she said, well, she, she said a few flattering things about me. So I found it hard to say no to her.
12:59 Speaker 00 She can be very forthright.
13:01 Speaker 01 She is very forthright. Um, she also uh is very persuasive. And I thought, okay, well, I'll, I'll put off going to the bar for six months. I'll go and see what this is like, you know, all experience is good experience. Um, and I really, when I got there, I really liked the work. Partly because I was working with really good people like Mary. But one of the things I'd really missed as a magistrate was working in a team.
13:32 Speaker 00 Yeah.
13:33 Speaker 01 And Gary, you, you know what it's like working in teams, most um homicide cases.
13:39 Speaker 00 You share the pressure.
13:41 Speaker 01 Share the pressure, but it's also sharing uh ideas and a community, a small community, a team.
13:50 Speaker 00 Yeah.
13:51 Speaker 01 Can generate more ideas than a bunch of single individuals can.
13:55 Speaker 00 Much definitely.
13:56 Speaker 01 And so strangely enough, although the work could be very confronting and very sad and saddening, um, I really enjoyed working with the, the team of people I was working with. So instead of leaving after six months, I stayed and I just stayed on until basically the chief magistrate um said, well, your time's up, you've had enough time here and you're coming back to the local court. And I thought, well, no, I'm not. Um, I like being a coroner. I don't want to be a magistrate anymore. So that's when I left.
14:37 Speaker 00 Decide to uh to leave. It's funny that, that, that uh you get rotated or a tap on the shoulder that you've been there too long. I would imagine something in the role of, of um pathway as a coroner, you'd be learning all the time.
14:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah.
14:52 Speaker 00 Like you'd be learning how, not just the processes in, in place, but how to deal with families and uh all that. I, I could imagine every day you went to work, you, you learned something.
15:02 Speaker 01 I, I think that's absolutely right. And I, I remember saying to. We had this rotation, three-year rotation thing. And I remember saying to the chief magistrate, I don't think I was any good at this job until I'd been in it for two years.
15:18 Speaker 00 Makes sense, yeah.
15:18 Speaker 01 And then, so three years, I'm just starting really to get good at it. And I, I thought I wasn't an expert coroner until I'd been doing it for five years.
15:30 Speaker 00 Yeah.
15:31 Speaker 01 But look, after I left, I've done further study. I've done a PhD, which is a study of the New South Wales coronial system. And I've learned so much more. So I know that you're absolutely right. Nine years, I was learning all the time. And since I left the coroner's court, I've been learning even more.
15:53 Speaker 00 Yeah.
15:53 Speaker 01 So you need to stay in these jobs to get really good at them.
15:57 Speaker 00 Well, it is a specialist field. I would imagine the, the role of a magistrate as compared to the role of a coroner is vastly different.
16:05 Speaker 01 Very, very different. A magistrate's job is primarily running small summary trials and sentencing. So some days you sit in a court and sentence people who are pleading guilty to various things. Other days you have hearings. You might do bails and apprehended violence applications and that sort of stuff. After a while, it becomes very repetitious. You become, to be perfectly honest, I think I, I was quite a good magistrate. But practice makes perfect.
16:40 Speaker 00 Yeah.
16:40 Speaker 01 And you were doing a lot of practice. So after a couple of years of that, I think I was pretty, pretty good at it. After five years of it, I really needed a change. And so I did civil, civil cases mainly. And again, it took me about five years before I thought I was expert at that. And then the coroner's job came out.
17:04 Speaker 00 Okay, can you explain what the role of the coroner's court is? So I'm obviously aware of it, but if you could explain to the listeners, because I think there's a misconception on some of the aspects of coroner's courts, what their role is, if you could explain it.
17:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's death investigation.
17:20 Speaker 00 Yeah.
17:21 Speaker 01 So if someone dies suddenly or in an unexplained or difficult to understand way, or due to an unnatural cause, accidents, suicide, homicides, these sort of things in our society. And since the 12th century, actually, there have been coroners who investigated these sudden, unexplained or unnatural deaths.
17:51 Speaker 01 Coroners are one of the oldest legal institutions in the world. And so Australia imported coroners when the first fleet arrived. The first inquest in Australia was in December 1788. A convict died and an inquest was held. And so we've had this 250-odd years of people inquiring into how a death came about. And it's a very different process from a criminal trial.
18:23 Speaker 00 Yeah.
18:23 Speaker 01 As you're well aware.
18:24 Speaker 00 If you could break that down as well, because I think people think sometimes the matter goes to the coroner and the coroner could find this person guilty of an offence. But that's not the case at all. And that's a whole different set of rules.
18:36 Speaker 01 Well, even if you think a person is guilty of a criminal offence, you have no jurisdiction to decide that. That has to be decided elsewhere, first of all by the DPP and then by a criminal court. But to go back, what's the process? Well, first of all, I talked about teams.
18:58 Speaker 01 The coroners, coroners work in a system, a coronial system, and it's a multidisciplinary system. You were part of it, I was part of it. Forensic pathologists are part of it, family counsellors, support people, administrators, et cetera, are part of it. But the first thing that happens, of course, is that someone reports a death. And that's usually done by police officers. So, police might be called to a hospital because someone's died of injuries or something like that. The doctors will, will report to the police, the police will report to the coroner, and then there'll be a medical examination.
19:41 Speaker 01 The coroners and the forensic pathologists will decide how to examine the person's body for evidence of the physiological or the medical cause of death. So that's the first stage. Of course, families are notified, and there's a whole process of informing them, which is a shattering event, as I was talking about a little, a little while ago, a really shattering event for people. So, there's a process of talking family members into this strange process.
20:23 Speaker 01 They may have heard about, or may not have heard about, but they, most of them will never have experienced before. So, how do you bring people into that? That's part of it. So, we have a team, we had a team at the coroner's court, a family support team, and the forensic pathologists also had social workers who were dealing with families. Then we have police involved. If the circumstances of a case look like they're unnatural, if the cause of death is, looks like it's unnatural, then the police will do an investigation on behalf of the coroners. Yeah.
21:04 Speaker 01 Sometimes that will look like a homicide investigation, and if it is a homicide, it'll be a very, very thorough investigation. If it's an accident, there'll also be a police investigation, there may be other experts called in, you know, aviation experts or all sorts of people. If someone takes their own life, there will also be a police investigation, and that will be somewhat different from a homicide investigation because...
21:35 Speaker 01 Clearly, not only has a person whom other people love died, taken their own life, or apparently so, the family will be so psychologically shaken by this that they need real care.
21:53 Speaker 00 Yeah.
21:54 Speaker 01 And that's difficult because the first responders will usually be young police officers, followed by detectives. The detectives are usually much more experienced and have, you know, seen terrible things usually. And, but there are lots of things going on in those scenarios, the shattered love relatives, but also what happens to the young police officers who have possibly seen these sort of scenarios for the first time in their lives.
22:30 Speaker 00 Yeah, you mentioned, you mentioned the police and we'll talk further about that later on, but the impact of police because we mentioned at the start, the full range of emotions and the heavy emotional toll inquests take, but there's a lot of people that are affected by it. On the issue of suicides too, they're, they're difficult ones, and I know from early, because quite often the family don't want to accept that someone's taken their own life, so their mind's ticking over it, yeah, there must be something more to this. So you're dealing with that aspect of it as well, but yeah, it's, it's confronting the whole, whole range of things.
23:09 Speaker 00 And then accidents, the purpose of investigating an accident is to find out, is there ways of preventing that accident from occurring again? That's something that the, yeah, the coronial process is involved in as well.
23:23 Speaker 01 That's right. And although I think we do that quite well in, in a lot of cases, we only hold about a hundred inquests a year in New South Wales, but there are eight thousand, well roughly eight thousand deaths reported every year. So, and around about forty percent of the reported deaths are due to unnatural causes. So we, we don't really investigate enough.
23:55 Speaker 01 Enough accidents, I think, to learn all the lessons that could be learned. Ideally, a coronial system should really thoroughly investigate all the accidents that occurred, fatalities, and try and put them into patterns or identify trends.
24:13 Speaker 00 Yeah.
24:14 Speaker 01 So that we can, we can pull out life-saving lessons. One thing that people don't often think about, and frankly, I didn't think about when I was a coroner, but I have thought about since, is the economic value of a human life.
24:33 Speaker 01 The Australian Government puts an economic value on an Australian life. It's called the value of a statistical life. And that in 2024, it was estimated to be $5.7 million.
24:50 Speaker 01 And a life year is valued by actuaries at around about $240,000 or $250,000.
24:58 Speaker 00 Right.
24:59 Speaker 01 So investigating thoroughly the causes of accidents should be regarded as an investment in life-saving, because if we could save more lives, if we could prevent more accidents, then it would be obviously good for the families and the community in general. If this human cost wasn't, wasn't spent or incurred, but there's also a value to the economy. So if you think about it, 3,000 unnatural deaths a year, that's possibly $15 billion
25:42 Speaker 01 just putting it in dollar terms, which is a very crude and unsatisfactory way to put it, but it's really worth looking at. This is not just a lot of grief and a lot of sadness. It's, it's an enormous cost to the society that we live in.
26:01 Speaker 00 That we've, we've lost a life.
26:03 Speaker 01 Yeah.
26:03 Speaker 00 Well, there's things like, and I'll pluck this as an example, because it's fairly, you know, topical at the moment or current, like e-scooters. When there's a death on an e-scooter, we see the e-scooters along footpaths or that. The role of a coroner, I would imagine, I'm talking hypothetically here, is if there's a series of accidents, inquests, okay, well, how did this accident? There might be recommendations, like the helmet recommendation is an obvious one, or not to ride on footpaths, or certain things that might prevent deaths as well. That's the role of a coroner.
26:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, and ideally, most inquests would result in recommendations to public health and safety officials who would then work through the practicalities of this. I mean, coroners are not engineers or those sort of things, but a good inquest should bring in experts.
26:59 Speaker 00 All the experts.
27:00 Speaker 01 That's right. And then, and very often, families also have good ideas about how to, because they've given a lot of thought to how their loved ones have died, they often have good ideas. So in New South Wales, if we could increase the number of cases in which recommendations were produced, or if we could identify more patterns and trends of fatalities and serious injury, then we would have a more effective and more productive coronial system than we have at the moment.
27:38 Speaker 00 Is there any accident you've seen that's really stuck in your mind?
27:43 Speaker 01 Well, one of them is a terrible collision on Sydney Harbour, which I spent some weeks inquiring into. Yeah, that was, that was very, very interesting.
27:57 Speaker 00 And is that, is that the one where four people were killed?
28:01 Speaker 01 Four people were killed. There were passengers on board a pleasure cruiser, which was proceeding from west towards Circular Quay. And a Rivercat ferry came out of Circular Quay. It was on its way back to the Balmain Dockyard where it birthed.
28:24 Speaker 00 Yep.
28:25 Speaker 01 And right under the Harbour Bridge on the, on the southern side.
28:32 Speaker 01 Uh. The boat was run over by the, uh, by the ferry.
28:35 Speaker 00 How, how many people were on the boat?
28:37 Speaker 01 Uh, I can't quite remember. I thi- I think it was around about nine people.
28:41 Speaker 00 Right, and, uh, four, four people died.
28:43 Speaker 01 Four people were killed, yeah.
28:44 Speaker 00 Um, what was it about that, uh, stuck in your mind that, uh, that particular, uh, matter?
28:50 Speaker 01 Well, uh, there were a number of things really. Um. My councilor's assistant and I and my team went out on Sydney Harbour and, and, you know, took a view, as it were. And we went up that, the river with, you know, in a ferry, in a river cat. The, the father of a young dancer, uh, who was killed was representing his family. He didn't have a lawyer. And, um, he was on the, he was on the ferry trying to talk to me. And one of the, one of the difficulties you have, um, if you're a coroner is you, you can't really
29:28 Speaker 01 talk to the lawyers and the families in the course of, um, either taking a view or taking evidence or that sort of thing. And I could see this poor man really trying to understand what, what the hell are these lawyers up to, you know? Why can't I talk to the coroner? And my councilor's assistant was saying, trying to say, um, look, the coroner's very, very interested in, in, in what you've got to say. But we've, we've got certain rules about all of this sort of stuff. So that was one thing.
30:00 Speaker 00 And, and just on that hue, it's, it's difficult, isn't it? Cause I, I know I've, I've been at, at scenes and, and locations. Circumstances like that and the coroner's there and you've got the families there or the, the people that have a vested interest in, uh, in the situation. Obviously they wanna speak to, speak to the coroner, but you can't, you, you've got to have that independence that, uh, you're not speaking to them directly or on specifics of the evidence.
30:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, actually, since I've finished as a coroner, I've given more thought to this. And I wonder whether sometimes coroners might not be better off at least having a meeting with the family with representatives or, you know, someone. To to ensure that you don't make any false promises or or cuddle up, if you like, um, become biased towards families. But I I wonder sometimes whether we could do more to show the families that we actually care about them.
31:02 Speaker 00 Yeah.
31:03 Speaker 01 As well as care about finding out what the answer to the question about how their loved ones died is.
31:09 Speaker 00 Well, it it carries a lot, doesn't it? If the the families know that you care, whether that's a police officer, a coroner, a legal person, or anyone that gets caught up in in those situations. If if there's, you're showing that you care, that that can help the family so much.
31:25 Speaker 01 Well, I think so. And and sometimes, not always, but sometimes after an inquest, I would step down from the bench and I'd talk to the family, um, that's after I'd given the decision. And I remember a particular case, um, I I was doing, I was doing an inquiry into, an inquest into a murder-suicide case. A father who had separated from his wife had taken his three children off in a car and put a, I won't describe what happened, but anyway, they, he killed himself and the three kids.
32:06 Speaker 01 The mother came to the court and she, this was, I think, three years after the murder-suicide. And she was pregnant, she had repartined since.
32:18 Speaker 00 Yeah.
32:19 Speaker 01 And after, and she spoke about how much she missed her children and so on and so forth. And I I just admired this woman so much, her courage in not only putting up with what had happened. And as I've said, I don't think there's any such thing as closure. But she'd managed somehow to face the world and go forward.
32:43 Speaker 00 Yeah.
32:43 Speaker 01 And now she'd repartined, and now she was bringing a new life into the world. And I just thought, respect.
32:51 Speaker 00 I, I, I get it.
32:52 Speaker 01 And I spoke to her.
32:54 Speaker 00 Hmm.
32:54 Speaker 01 And she, and I said, how do, how do you do this? And she said, look, I'm not gonna let this guy get away with killing my kids. I'm not going to be crushed by it.
33:07 Speaker 00 Yeah.
33:07 Speaker 01 I'm not going to allow him to destroy the life that I had. I'm going to give new life. And I just thought, wow, she's amazing. And, and very often I saw things like that happen in court.
33:25 Speaker 00 I, I'm, I'm sure you, you took strength and inspiration from the way some of the families conduct themselves.
33:31 Speaker 01 Absolutely.
33:32 Speaker 00 That's what I saw and I thought, where, I, I would often think, where do you get that strength?
33:36 Speaker 01 Yeah.
33:37 Speaker 00 Where do you get that strength to ca- carry on? And also, they can even see, see joy in life, like the ability to get through, as you just described with the, the mother there.
33:48 Speaker 01 Yeah.
33:48 Speaker 00 That she's gonna live a life despite what's happened.
33:51 Speaker 01 That's right. And, I mean, some people are obviously very angry and they never really get over their anger. But some people can be remarkably forgiving.
34:02 Speaker 00 Hmm.
34:02 Speaker 01 You know, pe- people can make mistakes and sometimes those mistakes cause deaths by omission or commission. Uh, so sometimes, you know, for example, nurses or doctors miss clues that suggest a child is very, very sick and needs some sort of urgent intervention. And by the time there is an intervention, it's too late. Um, I remember a case involving a little boy um who died and he'd been seen by, well, by the time he died, he'd been seen by six doctors. The last two doctors realised what was happening and and tried to give him urgent care.
34:47 Speaker 01 But um the four previous doctors thought he was sick but had a flu or some sort of, you know, viral thing, but he'd get over it. Anyway, in the inquest, some of the medical and health practitioners, once they'd finished their evidence, turned and faced the family and said how sorry they were. But there was, there was one doctor, young doctor, and I, I, I still feel quite sorry for her, but she couldn't bring herself to apologise. And I don't know why not, but I, I really feel that she lost an opportunity because the family were very willing
35:30 Speaker 00 Yeah.
35:30 Speaker 01 to forgive all these other people who, who did apologise. And I just thought, gosh, if you turned and said you were sorry, that this had really affected you as well. And I'm sure she was affected. Um, but maybe she got legal advice, you know, don't speak, who knows? And maybe she just couldn't bring herself to say anything. But I just thought,
35:57 Speaker 01 if, if you could turn around and talk to them, I think it would make both of you, the family and this doctor, so much happier
36:06 Speaker 00 Yeah.
36:07 Speaker 01 than they were.
36:08 Speaker 00 I, I, I think you've just encapsulated when they talk about the emotion that comes in a coroner's court, just with that, that one, one story, that's the type of thing that lives are, yeah, lives are shattered. And it's about how people, people move forward, but I think you might be right. And yeah, saying sorry can often be the, the thing that helps people move forward.
36:29 Speaker 01 Can I tell you another story, Gary?
36:30 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
36:31 Speaker 01 This one had a happier ending, really. A young woman, she was nineteen years old. She got very sick. She was a, she was working in a shearing team, somewhere in the southwest of New South Wales. And it looked like she had a flu. So her boyfriend, who was on the team, said, go to bed. The shearing team boss, he was this Maori guy, little Maori guy, said, yeah, go, go and lie down. And she just got sicker and sicker, though. And at some point in one of the breaks, her boyfriend went in and saw her and thought, oh, my God, she's really sick. So they called an ambulance. But it took nearly an hour for the ambulance to get there.
37:17 Speaker 01 It was way out somewhere. They got her to the hospital, but she was very, very sick. And, and despite getting urgent attention, she died. We held an inquest because one of the difficulties was there wasn't a clear diagnosis of what was killing her.
37:37 Speaker 00 Yeah.
37:37 Speaker 01 And we still don't really have an absolute diagnosis, actually. But in any event, we held the, the inquest. And her father, who was a Victorian farmer, very big man, you know, six foot four or something, came in. And we went through the evidence. The family was represented by a very good barrister from Victoria. And I had a very good counsel assisting. You may know her, Peggy Dwyer.
38:06 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah, yeah.
38:07 Speaker 01 Now, a silk.
38:09 Speaker 00 Yep.
38:09 Speaker 01 Also, as the Victorian. And one of the great things about this inquest, I thought, was that there was no bitterness. And at the end of the case, I gave my decision and my reasons. And I explained how, you know, what had happened. And as best we could, what the diagnosis we thought was most likely to be. I give my decision. I walk off the bench. I'm sitting in my chambers. And Peggy comes out and says, Hugh, Hugh. Come to the, come to the door of the court. So I got up and I went to the door of the court and we pulled it open a little bit.
38:50 Speaker 01 And there was this enormous Victorian farmer with his arms around the little Maori cheering boss, both in tears, both embracing and both so sad but so happy to have this moment with one another. They were both, they both loved this girl.
39:15 Speaker 00 Yeah.
39:15 Speaker 01 Though the, the Maori boss was so devastated by her death. I mean, when he gave evidence, he was just weeping, pouring, tears pouring out of him, very, very emotional, as was her dad.
39:31 Speaker 00 Yeah.
39:32 Speaker 01 And so there was this moment of catharsis. It doesn't always happen. Some, you know, some people walk away still feeling angry or whatever. But this was one of those moments where you thought, today we did something good.
39:47 Speaker 00 Yeah.
39:47 Speaker 01 And having spent a lot of time in criminal courts, I can say, I don't think on a lot of days I ever walked out of a criminal court thinking, today we did something good.
39:58 Speaker 00 Nah, well, it's, yeah, there's not, not many people walk out happy out of the criminal court that's, if the person's convicted, he or she is angry. If the person gets off, that's the police or the prosecution angry. But the way you've described that, I, I can picture it and that is doing something good. Like it's.
40:16 Speaker 01 It was.
40:17 Speaker 00 To.
40:17 Speaker 01 And it was, it was a moment of grace, really. You know, there's, there's very generous hearted men were embracing each other and owning the loss that they both felt.
40:33 Speaker 00 Yeah, and I, you could imagine the, the types that you're describing, they could bottle it up, but the fact that they let the emotion go. And you see that quite often in, in the coroner's court, that is, that is that emotional place. The breakdown of the adversarial system for the criminal courts and inquisitorial for the inquests, what, what's the difference in, in the way that evidence is allowed into those courts?
40:57 Speaker 01 Uh, well, um, the two things rely on different ways of thinking. So in a criminal trial, um.
41:07 Speaker 01 One party, the prosecution, has a, has a theory, a hypothesis. The hypothesis is you, Gary.
41:16 Speaker 00 Yep.
41:17 Speaker 01 Have murdered me, Hugh.
41:20 Speaker 00 I deny that allegation, Hugh.
41:22 Speaker 01 You deny that allegation. And I, the prosecutor, have to try to prove my hypothesis. And I do that by producing proof, which I hope will satisfy people in the jury beyond a reasonable doubt. That this is the only reasonable answer you could come up with. That's deductive thinking. The other way of thinking is inductive thinking, which is to say, we look at all this evidence, which may be scattered and fragmented in different ways, and we try and come up with a theory. What theory makes sense of all this stuff that we have collected?
42:05 Speaker 01 So that's theory building or inductive thinking. Now, of course, the adversarial side, there is an adversarial side to inquest.
42:16 Speaker 00 Yep.
42:16 Speaker 01 And you've experienced that. And that's where people who have a different theory or have a particular theory, challenge the, the range of theories that have been developed. So a coroner might think, okay, well, the possibilities available for me are suicide, homicide, jumped off a cliff, fell off a cliff accidentally, was kidnapped by martians and assaulted, who knows what. So there might be a range of possible theories. And some of the people who have an interest in this, and it might be police
42:58 Speaker 01 or it might be persons of interest, as we call suspects, might want to challenge some of these theories because they don't want the coroner to ultimately settle on a particular theory that blames them.
43:16 Speaker 00 Yeah.
43:17 Speaker 01 So there is a degree of adversarialism in it, or can be in an inquest. But it's all about really this inductive thinking. What is, what is the most satisfactory theory we can come up with that explains this death and the circumstances that surrounded it?
43:37 Speaker 01 And that means you have to look as carefully as you can at the surrounding circumstances. And that might mean that you take a wide look.
43:47 Speaker 00 Does that allow for like opinions to come in?
43:50 Speaker 01 Yes, it does.
43:52 Speaker 00 Rare in the criminal court, you get off your opinion, but in the coroner's court, quite often opinions. The coroner takes that into account.
44:00 Speaker 01 Opinions can be very important and they can be quite persuasive.
44:06 Speaker 01 And also hearsay evidence.
44:08 Speaker 00 Yeah.
44:08 Speaker 01 So some hearsay evidence obviously can get into a criminal trial, but only under very limited circumstances. Because there are questions about the reliability of hearsay and of opinions. Juries have to come up with their own opinion about whether someone's guilty or not. That's the idea about opinion evidence, unless it relates to some sort of area vex that's beyond common knowledge, et cetera.
44:38 Speaker 01 But coroners are running an inquiry, not a trial. And that's the fundamental difference. And that's what I'm saying. Inductive thinking, that's I'm thinking about what's the question? How do I answer the question? What's the theory I can come up with that answers the question? So the question is, how did this person die? How did this death come about? What explains it? But if we go to a trial, the prosecution thinks it knows the answer to that. Then it's got to persuade a jury to agree with that answer.
45:18 Speaker 00 I'm just reflecting back on my first experience at an inquest. And I think it was even in my uniform days where a young child, the mother was in the bathroom and they hairdryer fell into the bath.
45:32 Speaker 01 Oh dear.
45:33 Speaker 00 Two kids in the bath, just toddlers. And one died and one survived from that. And I remember. And this was probably the first sort of situation I've been to like that where a brief had to be put together for the coroner. So we put together a coronial brief.
45:49 Speaker 01 Um.
45:50 Speaker 00 Lot of questions were asked by, you know, what sort of system did they have in the fuse box with the electrical work? Why wasn't the safety? Why didn't the circuit break a trip at the time? And, and things like that. Long time ago, but I think some recommendations came on, on, on the back of that. That's the type of, um, incident that would be, uh, uh, brought before the coroner.
46:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, definitely. And it's, it's very kind of incident, um, that should be brought before the coroner because there's obviously, if you, if you explore that scenario, um, thoroughly enough, there are, there's real potential for saving life in future.
46:28 Speaker 00 Yeah, and, and warnings about, uh, you know, electrical appliances near the bath and where power points are located near the bath.
46:34 Speaker 01 All of that. And, and, and, yeah, well, um, I, I would imagine a, a good coroner came up with a number of recommendations. And no doubt the police, which might have been you, Gary, uh, contributed to that thinking process.
46:49 Speaker 00 Yeah, well, it was a, I, I remember it because it was such a tragic, uh, tragic accident. And that's what it was. It was an accident. But whether that accident could have been safeguarded against by, you know, putting things in place or just letting people be more aware of the, the situation. Um, another one, and I'm just reflecting on all the different experiences I've had in a, a coroner's court, uh, the Baurival matter.
47:12 Speaker 01 Yeah.
47:13 Speaker 00 Um, you're, you're familiar with it and people that listen to the podcast would be familiar with it. The murder of, uh, Evelyn Green up Colin Walkland, Clinton Speedy.
47:20 Speaker 01 Um.
47:21 Speaker 00 In nineteen ninety and ninety-one over a five-month period.
47:24 Speaker 01 Um.
47:25 Speaker 00 A person had been, uh, charged with one of the murders, uh, went to, uh, went to court and the person was acquitted. I became involved in a reinvestigation and we just saw that we we reinvestigated. We thought we had enough information for the matter to go back before the courts for the other two, because the double jeopardy legislation wasn't in on the other two matters that a person hadn't been charged with, but the DPP knocked it back. We then went to an inquest and had an inquest where it was the first time witnesses in regards to all three matters had provided any form of evidence in a court environment, because the person that was charged with that crime was only dealt with the facts relating to
48:09 Speaker 00 the murder of Clinton Speedy.
48:13 Speaker 00 We've gone through the inquest. The inquest ran over a number of, number of weeks. Everyone, everyone gave evidence and there was opportunities for people to be, be cross examined. On the back of that, I think it was John Abernathy, was the coroner at the time, made a recommendation to the DPP that these, he has reasonable cause that the known person is involved in the matter and that all three matters should be looked together.
48:38 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
48:38 Speaker 00 On the back of that, the DPP then, little bit down the track, but the weight that was carried from the, the inquest and John Abernathy's recommendations, decided to ex officio indict, indict the person.
48:52 Speaker 01 Right.
48:53 Speaker 00 I raise that as an example, because that's where I see the coronial court working in an investigation, in that it gave the witnesses the opportunity to give evidence in, in a courtroom environment. And then an assessment could have been ma, was made on the weight that could be placed on, on the evidence. Is that how you see a coroner's court can be used?
49:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, and, and in fact, in New South Wales, um, if a person has died and homicide is the suspected cause of that death, an inquest is mandatory. And so I was, yeah, I was thinking about this the other day. Um, I'm quite sure how many homicide inquests I did. It's probably, I would say probably twenty something.
49:39 Speaker 00 Okay, yeah.
49:41 Speaker 01 In some cases, I did refer cases to the DPP. In other cases, we didn't get far enough.
49:49 Speaker 00 Yeah.
49:50 Speaker 01 And in fact, the very last case I did as a coroner was in Newcastle. It was a double murder. And we had a person of interest who gave evidence. But there simply wasn't enough evidence, in my opinion, the opinion of my counsel assisting or the police investigators to refer to the DPP. An interesting, very interesting case.
50:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, and you never know. Sometimes people say things or do things which pushes a case where the DPP has doubts that the evidence is sufficient over the line.
50:37 Speaker 00 Yeah.
50:38 Speaker 01 And so a couple of times, I referred cases to the DPP after they had initially decided there wasn't enough evidence. And sometimes they put people on trial, sometimes they don't. Sometimes they take it, you know, once they have a look at all the evidence, they think, yeah, that'll work or not work.
51:01 Speaker 00 And I think that's what perhaps the public aren't fully informed on, that when the coroner makes a recommendation, it's still, that's not the end of the story. That doesn't mean the person's going to trial. The DPP's got to assess it from a criminal point of view, whether there's sufficient evidence to warrant charges against the person. I suppose I lost my faith, and I'm sorry to say this, when you're seen here as a coroner, very early in my career, but got it back. Naive young detective, working on a case, it was a brutal case. A person had been shot with a shotgun and dumped in the boot of his car. And his car was abandoned. Locals called the police out.
51:45 Speaker 00 It was a horrendous scene. It was during a heatwave and the deceased body was in the back of the boot for five days. I remember the case well, I remember the postmortem, it was a horrendous situation. There was what I considered evidence, a person, person of interest, we won't mention the names or the case.
52:04 Speaker 01 Hmm.
52:05 Speaker 00 Young detective thinking, this is frustrating, we know this person has done it. And it was sort of suggested, let's take the matter to the, to the coroner. And maybe further evidence will be forthcoming.
52:17 Speaker 01 Hmm.
52:18 Speaker 00 What, and I, I knew this was a possibility, but it shocked me when I saw it actually it work in the process. The person of interest got in the witness box. We had presented the brief to the coroner. I was excited as a naive young detective thinking, okay, well, this is, we're going to watch this person get carved up. He got in the witness box and he was, um, said, I declined to answer any questions on the ground, I might incriminate myself.
52:43 Speaker 01 Hmm.
52:43 Speaker 00 He got thanked by the coroner and left the court. And it was sort of, my expectations were high, the family's expectations were high. My expectations were high because I was naive as the workings of the court. But I thought there, I, I just lost a little bit of faith in that, that, uh, right to silence. I fully understand the concept of right to silence, but a coronial inquest is to find out what's happened to a person. And this person clearly had relevant information about the, or about how this person died, but was allowed to, um, just say, I'm not going to say anything. What, what's your thoughts on that?
53:19 Speaker 01 I have mixed feelings about that. Um, from a purely coronial point of view, uh, like everybody else, I would like to hear the story from the, from the person who probably knows most about it. On the other hand, if there is a strong case against a known person, I'd be quite reluctant to force them to give evidence.
53:44 Speaker 00 Yeah.
53:45 Speaker 01 The reason being that if you force them to give evidence, they object. And then you say, no, no, no, you're going to give evidence. They have to give evidence and then they, then they talk. But whatever they say cannot be used and it can't be used in any way at all.
54:04 Speaker 00 Yeah.
54:04 Speaker 01 So you, it can't be used directly against them or indirectly against them, which is even worse. So.
54:13 Speaker 01 If you force someone to speak, my view was that you run the real risk of jeopardising what may be a strong case at trial, because they'll be able to say, oh, well, the cops went and got this evidence.
54:29 Speaker 00 Well, it's not just the evidence they've provided can't be used, it's a flow-on.
54:33 Speaker 01 That's right. All the evidence that is obtained indirectly as a result of them speaking is inadmissible.
54:41 Speaker 00 Well, I'm sure you are familiar with the Matthew Levison case. And that was an interesting, I found that an interesting case for a whole range of reasons. But basically, and we've had Mark and Fay on the podcast, so people have probably heard this talk about the situation. Matthew disappeared. He'd been out Saturday night at Oxford Street in Sydney with his partner and disappeared. The partner was eventually, circumstances around the disappearance was a bit strange. They've woken up and Matthew's gone and the partner got on with his life.
55:21 Speaker 00 And then Mark and Fay, when they were contacted by Matthew's employer, he hadn't turned up for work, they went to the police and reported Matthew missing. There was an investigation and I can say the name, he hasn't been convicted of the murder, but it's all public record. Michael Atkins, his partner at the time, was charged with murder. A murder trial was conducted. And we should note that Michael Atkins was acquitted of murder and manslaughter in 2009. So Mark and Fay are left in, and I'm sure you'd understand the situation, left in this horrible situation where they've, okay, they've put their faith in the justice system, it's gone to court, and then what have we got?
56:04 Speaker 00 Well, we've got no answers because we've been told that this person wasn't responsible for the son's murder by the court during the trial.
56:14 Speaker 00 I became involved in it. They spoke to me and we looked at, okay, we could go to a coronial inquest because, and I, I think the representations they made to the coroner were, we put our faith in the justice system, as in the court system, we still don't have answers for our son. Can we have a coronial inquest? And on the back of that, there was a decision that an inquest would be held. There's a lot of layers to it. But it got to the point where I was satisfied from a homicide detective's point of view that we'd taken the investigation as far as we possibly could. There was not going to be, we'd gathered all the evidence, available evidence. So there wasn't an opportunity because double jeopardy legislation had come in by that stage.
56:58 Speaker 00 There wasn't going to be an opportunity to recharge because we hadn't gathered fresh and compelling evidence.
57:03 Speaker 01 Hmm.
57:04 Speaker 00 So then a bit of a conundrum and, and, you know, Mark and Fay would on weekends go look for Matt's body. They were desperate to get Matt's body back. And I, I still remember having the conversation with them about, you know, what do you hope to achieve from the inquest? And I think it was, Elaine Truscott was the coroner and very, very considerate of everyone's feelings and, you know, the appropriateness of, of the whole way the matter was being run. And a decision was made to give Michael Atkins a section 61 certificate.
57:34 Speaker 01 Yep.
57:34 Speaker 00 So that he could, and this, when the listeners hear this, they think this is ridiculous, but he could have got in the witness box and said, yes, I murdered Matthew Levison and this is how I did it. And that we couldn't use that evidence. But that's the deal that we made. A lot of processes that we had to go through to do, do that, and it was contested at court and Michael Atkins' defence were doing a great job in, in protecting them. Eventually a decision was made that he could give evidence with a section 61 certificate. He perjured himself whilst giving evidence in the witness box for a week, trying to answer questions and
58:12 Speaker 01 Hmm.
58:13 Speaker 00 Uh, dodge around. And then he was given indemnity from the Attorney General if he took us to Matthew Levison's body, which he did. That's using an inquest in a way that's, I don't think those set of circumstances would present themselves very often. I know there was some sort of pushback on people thinking, oh, well, are we really usurping a person's right to silence?
58:36 Speaker 01 Hmm.
58:37 Speaker 00 To me, I felt that it was the right thing to do. I, I think, yeah, Mark and Fay have got their son's remains back, no one's been charged with, with the murder. I'm just interested in to get, getting your thoughts, because I know it caused some, you know, differing opinions, I won't say controversy, everyone wanted to see it resolved in, in some way. What, what's your feelings on that?
58:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, um, well, and I've talked to various people about this. Some people I, I know and respect, some lawyers I know and respect very much, uh, don't like it at all, for the very reasons you've just explained, um, that it seems to run against the ethos of our, our criminal justice system. On the other hand, I couldn't help feeling for the Levison family, to be honest, to get their son's body back, to be able to bury him, to at least get some idea of what
59:37 Speaker 01 actually happened to him, I think was, was worth the cost in that particular case. Um, there's a, there's a very rare circumstances, and I don't think the principle that people are concerned about of protecting people's right to silence is in any way undermined. Um, and in fact, in some ways it's strengthened, I suppose, uh, because it's shown that if you, if you force someone to speak against their, against their own interests, to tell the truth, in other words, then there, there is a price to pay for that.
1:00:20 Speaker 01 And, um, you know, when you, when you go back and think about the right to silence, it goes back to the days when, uh, if you were found guilty of an offence, you were hung for it.
1:00:32 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:00:33 Speaker 01 Um, so obviously there had to be some protection against people being hung on the evidence that came out of their own mouths. You know, that's torturing people really, one way or the other. So I fully support the right to silence and you know, would always do that. But I thi- I think in this particular case, and I really respect Elaine Truscott as well as a human being, as well as, as well as a coroner, I think she made the right decision.
1:01:03 Speaker 00 Yeah, it was a difficult one. I suppose even though a precedent has been set like that, it hasn't opened the floodgates because it was such a rare combination of circumstances.
1:01:14 Speaker 01 That's right.
1:01:15 Speaker 00 Require, require that. And it's one that, yeah, I, I won't say sleepless nights, but there was a lot of thought that went into that. And there was a lot of counterviews and different things, but the safeguards were put in to, and, and his defence team pushed it as hard as they could on defending his right to, um, yeah, a- avoid giving evidence in those circumstances. But look, I, I feel satisfied by it. I think the system worked. Um, it was a different way of approaching the system, but the system, uh, worked in that regards.
1:01:47 Speaker 01 And you'd know from, from your general career as a police officer too, that sometimes for the law to work, you have to give people who've done bad things an indemnity for the greater good.
1:02:02 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:02:02 Speaker 01 It's a utilitarian concept, I know, but, uh, you know, when I was at the Commonwealth DPP, we quite often would indemnify people who would give up, uh, major drug importers and so forth. So, you know, that was, that was the price you paid for the evidence.
1:02:19 Speaker 00 It's a necessary tool and I, I break when there's, um, a different narrative or, or different discussions on what should be done. And, and with the Levison matter, I said, okay, well, the option is we don't do that, but we're not going to find out where Matt's body is. So what are we risking here? Like it's, we either just, yeah, just pack up our, our tools and, and go home.
1:02:43 Speaker 01 But you're right anyway, Gary, the floodgates have not opened.
1:02:47 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. Well, I saw that and many a debate and discussion in Parliament with the double jeopardy legislation. When that came in and that was on the back of the bearable thing. People probably know about it in summary, if you'd been acquitted of a crime before the double jeopardy legislation came in, you couldn't be retried. So again, the analogy at the extreme. You could be acquitted of murder, walk out on the steps of court and say, I did it, I got away with it and we couldn't charge that person. The double jeopardy legislation came in and there was a lot of pushback about that. I was involved from the bearable point of view, using it sort of as a test case. And the world, the sky was gonna fall.
1:03:31 Speaker 00 The naysayers that didn't want this legislation coming. If this comes in, it's gonna turn our legal justice system upside down. I think to this day, this legislation still hasn't been acted upon, but it's in there as a safeguard if circumstances like happened in bearable, so.
1:03:49 Speaker 01 And the DPP, you would hope, would be very careful in any event.
1:03:54 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:03:54 Speaker 01 You know, you wouldn't want people being dragged up from years and years and years ago with some sort of weak evidence. You're right, it has to be very, compelling is compelling. It's a very high standard.
1:04:11 Speaker 00 It's a high, high standard. And look, I understood there was an argument there that it would allow. And it was fresh and compelling evidence and it's got to be in the interest of justice and it had to be an offence that carries a minimum of 20 years. There was a lot of things that went into it. But I understood, one of the arguments I understood was it would allow police or investigators to do a half-hearted job the first time. And if they lost the trial, I will do it properly this time. And I could understand that concept, that sloppiness, but it clearly hasn't come into play. But yeah, they're interesting thoughts on the way justice can be approached. When we get back, we might.
1:04:53 Speaker 00 Take a break now, but when we get back, I want to talk about some of the cases that you've overseen.
1:04:58 Speaker 01 Um.
1:04:58 Speaker 00 Um, uh, some very interesting cases and your, your reflections on, on those cases. And something that you're very passionate about and, uh, full credit to you, I, I support what you're trying to do in how we could, uh, make the, uh, the, the coronial process or the cor- uh, coroner's court a, a better place, cause I know you've been doing a lot of work on that since you've left.
1:05:19 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, I have. Okay, great.
1:05:22 Speaker 00 Okay, we'll be back soon.
Previous When a cop meets a bikie in prison: Adam Smith Pt.2 Next Hunted and killed at School of Happiness: Hugh Dillon Pt.2 Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated