Pod Insights I Catch Killers with Gary Jubelin How this lawyer won an unwinnable case: Judith Fordham Pt.2 About this episode From the man who accidentally stabbed himself in the back to the jury who used a ouija board to connect with the dead witness, Judith Fordham has seen a lot. The former criminal barrister joins Gary Jubelin to share some of her most memorable “unwinnable” cases, and reveals what really goes on behind the jury doors.
Want to hear more from I Catch Killers? Visit news.com.au.
Watch episodes of I Catch Killers on our YouTube channelhere https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLlq8In_ATbJnjFcb-fykqJ8HV9W9OOJWX.
Like the show? Get more aticatchkillers.com.au https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/truecrimeaustralia/i-catch-killers/i-catch-killers-gary-jubelins-new-podcast-series-and-book/news-story/6848df9e1b6feccf7508878fc0438f7f Advertising enquiries: [email protected]
Questions for Gary: [email protected]
Get in touch with the show by joining ourFacebook group https://www.facebook.com/groups/844896725918656, and visiting us onInstagram https://www.instagram.com/icatchkillers/?hl=en orTiktok https://www.tiktok.com/@icatchkillerspodcast?lang=en.
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 The public has had a long-held fascination with detectives. Detectives see a side of life the average person is never exposed to. I spent 34 years as a cop. For 25 of those years, I was catching killers. That's what I did for a living. I was a homicide detective. I'm no longer just interviewing bad guys. Instead, I'm taking the public into the world in which I operate. The guests I talk to each week have amazing stories from all sides of the law. The interviews are raw and honest, just like the people I talk to. Some of the content and language might be confronting. That's because no one who comes into contact with crime is left unchanged. Join me now as I take you into this world.
0:46 Speaker 00 In part two of my chat with former criminal barrister Judith Fordham. Judith continued to entertain me with stories from the bar table. Judith also took us inside the jury room. And some of the things she said might make you question whether the jury system has had its day. We also found out how Judith defended a client accused of stabbing a person. A case that she thought was impossible to win. And we had discussion about forensic science in the criminal justice system. This was a really unfiltered look at the justice system. I think you're going to enjoy it as much as I did. Judith Fordham, welcome back to part two of I Catch Killers.
1:23 Speaker 01 Thanks for having me back after the first part.
1:27 Speaker 00 We considered that we had a discussion off mic and we said, no, we'll let you back for the second part. Can I ask you about you winning the unwinnable case? And the way you described it to me was, you're perfect. That you're representing a client that had gone into a room and got into a fight with the person in the room. The person hadn't been stabbed. But when your client walked in the room and when your client walked out, the person had been stabbed in the back.
1:57 Speaker 01 In the back.
1:58 Speaker 00 Take it from there.
1:58 Speaker 01 And you can't stab yourself in the back, by the way. I have one trials where we ran the defence, he cut his own throat and that's been successful. But you can't do, he stabbed himself in the back. It's just not going to work. This is a client who came in to see me late in the day. And she won't mind, if she's still around, she won't mind being identified, I know. Because this may identify to someone who actually knows her, but she won't have a problem with it. She came in and...
2:30 Speaker 01 She walked into my office and I'm sorry, but she wasn't very well dressed. She was, she, and there's a reason that I, I say that. Um, she was looking pretty daggy, uh, and she'd been a, uh, gem fossic or opal prospector in a, uh, an outback town where they have gems and opals there, trying not to identify things. Um, but, uh, she was a transsexual. And, uh, sadly, uh, because many transsexual clients I've had have got wonderful dress sense. She was standing behind the door when dress sense was being handed out, as my mother would have said. And so she came in looking pretty daggy with terrible taste in makeup and clothes and everything. But she was very upset. And she came in and she said,
3:17 Speaker 01 I don't want to go to a men's prison. And I said, well, how about, stop a minute. How about you tell me what you're supposed to have done? Or what you haven't done is how I often open an interview with a client. Tell me what you haven't done. Tell me what they reckon you've done. So I know I just don't want to go to a men's prison when I get convicted. I said, well, let's just see if you're gonna get convicted first. And as time went on, I was starting to agree that she would get convicted. Because what had happened, the background to the story was that she'd, um, collected a whole lot of gems in her prospecting days. And by the way, she had to be pretty tough because if you're gonna be in an outback town, uh, like that as, as a, uh, prospector,
3:56 Speaker 01 it's a pretty rough and tough blokey sort of a world. So she was pretty handy with a fist, had to be. And she was big too. She was probably six foot three and quite solidly built. Um, now, uh, she'd got all these gems and she'd come to Perth to, to, and she, she'd made these dreadful souvenirs. I'm sorry if you're listening. I'm sorry I called your souvenirs dreadful, but they were. Um, she'd made these Jarro maps of Australia, varnished them, and what you do is you errol died on a precious stone. Um, where each state capital is, you know, leave Tasmania off because that's just too darn hard. You can't do that. Um, and you flog them as souvenirs and you make money.
4:40 Speaker 01 And she was gonna make money for her gender reassignment surgery. You can't, it's not sex change, it's gender reassignment because you're being assigned the gender that you've always felt you were. Okay.
4:54 Speaker 01 And she went to a fairly cheap boarding house in Perth with all her JARRAR maps of Australia. And she met this young man who was quite personable and he said, I'll sell them for you, you know, I'll, I'll. I reckon I can get you about thirty five thousand dollars worth for this lot, or whatever the amount was and. Great, she's impressed by him. Okay, you, you take them and you sell them. He came back later on, um, I think he only had about fifteen hundred dollars. And all the maps are gone and it's like, where's me money? Um, her money was probably up his arm, I suspect. Um, you know, it was in the days of heroin, I, I still remember.
5:36 Speaker 01 Where he would have injected and bought, injected himself and blown a lot of the money and brought back what was left. And she was pretty angry and they had, um, uh, they had a, uh, a re- really. Intense argument about this in the sort of loungy area of this boarding house. And it devolved into a fistfight. And as I said, my client was, you know, really could handle herself in that situation. She wasn't charged with thumping him though. She was charged with stabbing him because, um, although. Uh, there, there were only two people in the room, him and her, and he didn't have a stab wound. When he entered the room and he did at the end of the altercation.
6:21 Speaker 01 Uh, and no one else had come in and asked her all of this. Did anyone come in? No. Um, did he have a stab wound when he came into the room? No. Um, did he have one at the end? Yes. Did you stab him? No. I'm going, I actually went, read my lips. I cannot win this trial. You are going to have to plead guilty. I mean, yeah, which is sort of an answer to how do you defend someone you know they're guilty? Um, I tell them to plead guilty. I tell them they're insane if they don't. She said, I don't care. I didn't do it. How did he get the stab wound? I don't know.
6:59 Speaker 01 So, oh, you know, read my lips again. I, I still didn't know how I was gonna win the trial, but she insisted on going to trial. In fact, her main question was, what do I wear? She said, will I come secretary or will I come astronaut? And I said, well, come secretary. Um, that was a mistake. I should have said astronaut because I, yeah, she. I seem to remember she was wearing uh blue sparkles and white gloves. I could be wrong there, but it was just. Um, but astronaut would have been worse, I guess, because it would have been a silver lame. But anyhow.
7:32 Speaker 00 Uh, would have, uh, would have made the statement.
7:35 Speaker 01 So I'm at the beginning of the trial and uh. How am I going to defend her? And I'm looking at the crime scene photos again, just as you do, going through everything you've got. And it dawned on me, it dawned on me, and thank heavens it dawned on me before the trial and not after. Cause I could never have forgiven myself. Um, there were some stairs leading from this room. And no, it wasn't that somebody came down the stairs, it was stairs leading from this room upstairs to the kitchen. And I said to her, I said, where do the stairs go? Oh, to the kitchen. There was a plastic bag on the stairs, just like a Woolies bag or a Coles bag, uh, something like that. And the bag looked like it had been damaged. It had a, you know how they're made of not great plastic and it had like a split in the back.
8:20 Speaker 01 I said, whose bags? Actually, that's mine. I said, well, what was in it? She said, oh, it was me dinner. I was gonna go upstairs to the kitchen and cook me dinner. Uh, I said, so what was in it? She said, oh, you know, me bread and, you know. Butter or margarine or whatever, and me steak and, you know, me fork and me. Knife, knife. Ha, and there's a split in the bag. I worked out what had happened. They'd had a punch up, he'd fallen back on the stairs. The knife was in the bag at such an angle that he actually fell on the knife. The defence was he fell on the knife.
9:04 Speaker 01 Luckily, he only had one stab wound because you're not gonna be able to run. He fell on the knife, got up. Ran backwards and fell on the knife four more times.
9:12 Speaker 00 Yeah.
9:12 Speaker 01 But he uh.
9:13 Speaker 00 Well, that, that would have been a hard one to explain.
9:16 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:16 Speaker 00 So uh, how, how, how did that play out at the trial? Did the trial commence?
9:21 Speaker 01 Yes, the trial commenced. No, uh, um, the, the trial commenced and she gave her evidence. Um.
9:29 Speaker 01 And we explained to the jury why she looked the way she did because they would have been wondering. And I, she gave not the explanation we'd rehearsed, but another explanation. I said to her, because we had to explain wh- what the money was for and why she was so upset, you see. So it was actually an essential part of the background. So I said, you know, what was the money for? Why were you so angry? Because she admitted hitting him. You know, she wasn't charged with hitting him. She was charged with something called unlawful wounding. I probably should have said that, which involves stabbing. So she wasn't charged with punching him. So why were you so angry? He, he stole me money. And what was your money for? Uh, was for me, me operation. And what was your operation for?
10:13 Speaker 01 It was for me, you know, gender reassignment surgery. And what was that for? And she was supposed to say was to make me look more feminine. Um, in fact, she was supposed to, I was going to ask a leading question. I was going to say, was it to make you look more feminine? Which is technically a leading question, but no one was going to object. So I, I knew I could get away with asking. Was it to make you look more feminine? But she forgot what she was supposed to say. So I said, was it to make you look more feminine? She said, nah. Just gonna cut me dick and me balls off. Nothing's gonna make me look more feminine. And I went, oh, you could have heard a pin drop. The judge glared at me like, this is all my fault.
10:53 Speaker 00 Yeah. You're the instru- uh, in- instructor.
10:57 Speaker 01 Say that. I hadn't at all. She was supposed to say it's to make.
11:01 Speaker 00 Oh, no, but you, you'd instructed her to say what was appropriate or, or the what and she. But you can't, yeah. It makes for court, uh, it makes for courtroom dramas, things like that.
11:14 Speaker 01 But I reckon, my, my little theory is that the jury thought, no one could give an answer like that and not be telling the truth. I, I reckon it probably impressed the jury.
11:23 Speaker 00 I I've I've seen witnesses that come in there and or or people involved in uh in trials. That they're too stupid to lie.
11:33 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:33 Speaker 00 Like in the way that they're giving evidence and that's sounding sounding like I think I'm smart. But there are some people that are too stupid to lie and and like I I would have legal people come to me and say, well, why do you think they're telling the truth? I don't think this person is capable of telling a lie.
11:48 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:48 Speaker 00 Sit down, have a chat and you'll understand.
11:50 Speaker 01 And and at least continuing the lie, you know, and and getting away with it. You can tell stupid lies, but you you you'll you'll get sprung. You've got to have a certain degree of intelligence to carry the lie through and to make it consistent with everything else.
12:02 Speaker 00 And and consistently keep keep that going.
12:04 Speaker 01 Anyway, this jury came back in seventeen minutes and acquitted her in seventeen minutes. I timed it.
12:10 Speaker 00 High fives?
12:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. And she gave me um a a necklace which I've still got made out of a crystal that she mined. And araldite it into a into something. Yeah.
12:24 Speaker 00 Are you wear are you wearing it today?
12:25 Speaker 01 No, but I I do still have it and I treasure it.
12:29 Speaker 00 Okay, look, uh uh things like that, that makes, yeah, a a battler for a whole range of reasons. But little things like that make a difference and you you could have potentially missed that.
12:38 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
12:39 Speaker 00 And uh and and and lost that. So that must uh give you some sort of uh feeling of you're doing doing good work.
12:47 Speaker 01 Well, I was really pleased, but you know, most of me was going, thank heavens, I noticed it before the trial. Because, you know, I beat myself up about the things that I mess up because honestly, she wasn't guilty. She absolutely wasn't guilty. Um, and she should have been acquitted and I'm glad the jury did it so quickly. But it was almost an accident and I don't like that. I don't like accidents.
13:13 Speaker 00 Don't like it coming down to coming down to the wire. Yeah, I want you to take me into the jury room now and let's, I think we touched on it in part one, that generally jurors in this country are not allowed to speak about what goes on in the jury room. So it's a big mystery. The jurors are shielded from everyone involved in the trial and they're boarding down the back alleys and they're not allowed to talk to anyone. So it's very rare that people working in this field get an opportunity to talk to jurors. How did you come to get that opportunity?
13:44 Speaker 01 Again, accident. There seem to be a lot of accidents happen in my life. I was doing a postgraduate degree in forensic science, as you do when you've got nothing better to do with your life or, you know, have so much free time. And I was invited to do a PhD and it's
14:07 Speaker 00 The kids can look after themselves, don't worry about that.
14:10 Speaker 01 I'm fond of saying that mine thrived on neglect. And again, it's sort of a fairly sick sense of humour there.
14:17 Speaker 00 You're toughening them up for the life that
14:20 Speaker 01 Look, not one of my children has a criminal record, so I call that a success.
14:26 Speaker 00 Or you are a very, very good barrister.
14:29 Speaker 01 No, I call that an absolute, anything better than that is a real win, but no criminal record.
14:36 Speaker 00 Fantastic.
14:36 Speaker 01 Anyhow, accident was what happened. You've got to do a PhD. And when I did my postgraduate work in forensic science, there was no such thing as forensic science for lawyers. I had to do a proper postgraduate science course. And honestly, yes, I had a science degree, but mine was biological sciences. And, you know, I was having to learn forensic chemistry. Chemistry. I didn't do, last time I did chemistry was at school and I wasn't very good at it.
15:02 Speaker 00 And that was scary.
15:03 Speaker 01 Yeah. So what am I going to do a PhD in in forensic science? What on earth can I do? I don't actually know enough science. A jack of all trades, master of none was me. I thought, I know, I'm going to do expert evidence.
15:19 Speaker 01 Because that sort of straddles the worlds of law and crime. And I thought, I'm going to see whether I can talk to jurors, because we always wonder, you were saying earlier in part one, you know, these jurors sitting there have the lawyers and the experts lost them, the lawyers and experts having their own learned conversation, the jury sitting there going, what happened, what's going on, you know? Has, have they forgotten about us? Because the jurors just happen to be the most important people in the courtroom. And they, they get forgotten about. So I thought, I, I want to know what works. I want to know what type of communication works. How do they wrap their heads around it? Um. Do they go out and do their own investigations, their own research? And we, we know that that's a complete no-no.
16:00 Speaker 01 Um, you know, you mustn't go out and do your own research and bring it back to the jury room, or if you get found out, the trial will be aborted. Because you're supposed to only rely on what's presented in court. So I'm curious about how they handle expert evidence. And the only way to do that, because it is against the law to talk to jurors after trials, except with the permission of the Attorney General. So I went off to the Attorney General of the day and said, I'd like to talk to jurors and I'd like to find out about this. And uh, he was very receptive and gave me that permission. And it became a very, very big study. In fact, I, I think it's the biggest study that's ever been done.
16:42 Speaker 01 Certainly in Australia, UK, Canada, all the law systems that are very similar. Um, where you're not allowed to, for example, you don't have the jurors being interviewed on the court steps like they do in the US. And um, I had a lot of support too. The, the Law Society was in support, the um, uh, police actually gave some funding towards it, Legal Aid gave some funding. Um, the Department of Justice funded it, the Sheriff's Office cooperated with me and sent out three thousand questionnaires. Um, and yeah, and, and uh, that way you see the jurors could remain anonymous unless they opted into the study. So they just, they sent them out. I didn't know
17:23 Speaker 01 who they were sending them out to, except it was random. Uh, and then jurors opted in. And the amazing thing is, Um. It was a twenty four page questionnaire, not just tick a box, it was, you know, write down what you, what happened here and what happened there. And you know, uh, approximately a third of the jurors actually completed that form. And sent it back, which is an amazing response rate for a complicated form. Um, and of those, um, until the funding ran out, we interviewed something like five hundred of them. And so.
17:55 Speaker 00 Wow, that's a big cross section.
17:56 Speaker 01 It's huge, it's huge. Um, but in the process of that, obviously, I learned a lot about what goes on behind closed doors.
18:06 Speaker 00 Take a say where you can, what, what goes on behind the jury door.
18:11 Speaker 01 Well, one of the things that came up, uh, because it became not just expert evidence, became a whole jury experience study. It grew and grew and grew. Um, one of the things that I learned was, you know, people say, oh, you know. The jurors would have acquitted this person because he's evil and they're scared and, you know, that it wasn't because there wasn't enough evidence. It's because they were scared of this bad dude. Um, it was. Almost, it was in fact always, I didn't find one instance where a juror said, and, and they were. I do believe they're being honest with me, they had to opt in for starters, where a juror said it was because I was scared of this bad dude, that's why I acquitted him.
18:54 Speaker 01 No, it was because there were significant gaps in the prosecution case and the prosecution was relying on. The fact that he's a bad dude to get a conviction and the jurors took their oath seriously and would only convict if there was in fact. Enough evidence. Now, that's a jury doing their job and doing it properly. It's, it's sort of. You know, on a different topic, which I'm sure probably end up touching on, it's, it's sort of why I can sleep at night. Believing that my client was a bad dude, but he got acquitted because, uh. As I said at the start of the thing, part of my job then was to keep the bastards on it. I did come across quite a lot of examples where the jurors actually went out and did their own investigations,
19:39 Speaker 01 which they're totally not allowed to do. And that was usually because they had questions that they wanted answered and neither side had given them the answer. Because of course, a trial is about who presents what evidence on the day. And there might be good reasons why certain evidence is not being presented. For example, if someone has a really bad criminal record in things that are not logically to do with whatever they're accused of this time. Often the jury won't be told about that because the theory being that they'll be influenced by that and convict him without the proper evidence. I actually don't believe that'll happen. I do believe jurors do a really good job, I've learned generally.
20:23 Speaker 01 You know, you've got the occasional rogue jury, but again, that's another story.
20:28 Speaker 01 But they have gone out and for example, gone to the scene of a chase or a, you know, a traffic accident or even a nightclub where something's supposed to have happened. And they will report back and tell the other jurors what they did. I had them conduct experiments where they've, you know, thrown things out of the window of a moving car to see how far away they land. Now, maybe we should have had someone give that evidence so they're not tempted to do that. And no, I couldn't and didn't and wouldn't report that because everything they told me was confidential. And you can see I'm being very, very careful not to give any identifying information about the particular trial.
21:14 Speaker 00 You talked about the past criminal history and the jury not being given that because that might influence their decision. Use an example, someone's been committed of an assault years ago and then been charged with drug-related matters or whatever. It could be that, is that going to influence the jury? I'm a big believer, and we had this chat off mic the other day, that all the information that's kept from the jury. We put our faith in being judged by our, you know, 12 peers or whatever, then that's the basis of the jury system. I have concerns that not enough information is put to the jury and we don't put enough faith in the role of the jury to make informed decisions.
21:56 Speaker 00 Like, they're told not to, the only thing that they need to take into account in deciding guilt or innocence here is the information that's been presented to the court. They still get instructed not to, uh, yeah, it used to be, don't watch the news tonight if it was a high-profile case, don't read the papers.
22:13 Speaker 01 Of course you're gonna watch the news.
22:14 Speaker 00 And they go, yeah, as if they're not watching the news or reading the papers about it. Now they're instructed, you know, not to look, examine this on social media and different things, as if they're not doing it. I think we've got to say, there'll be reports in the media, don't put any weight on that, that's unsubstantiated information. What you need to do is concentrate on what we're presenting to you at court. We need to make the instructions more respectful to the role that the jury have, I think.
22:46 Speaker 01 Well, if we're gonna have a system that completely relies upon them, then we've got to have some trust in them. And as I said, most of my research uncovered the fact that they can generally be trusted and they will have arguments in the jury room. No, you're not allowed to think about X, Y, Z that you've learned and, you know, what the media reports will be sensationalist, might not necessarily be correct. And, you know, we have to only take into account what's said in the jury room. And remember I said in part one about this jury 40 years ago, who said, we understand that there might be some new work out on what causes ulcers, but we weren't told about it, we wish we had been.
23:27 Speaker 01 Now, we were forced to convict even though we didn't feel happy about doing it. So they will do as they're asked generally. But that leads me to another thing I learned, and that is that there are... Really two types of juries. There are evidence-led juries and verdict-led juries. And the evidence-led ones are the ones that produce the most satisfactory verdict. By satisfactory, I mean they've actually considered the evidence and come to a conclusion because the evidence takes them there. And just, I'll just explain that a bit. You get the sort that will go into the jury room.
24:05 Speaker 01 Uh, someone has volunteered to be the foreperson, fore per offspring, for, for, you know, in charge of, no, the communicator of the jury to the court, but that, because that's really all they should be doing. And it'll often be the person who really, as they've seen on television, they just really wanna be the important. And they've got fixed views about what, what happened and they're gonna get this jury to do what they want. That's why I think four, four persons should not be chosen until a couple of days into the trial. And some judges do that now. Some judges, I think, have that point of view.
24:42 Speaker 00 Uh, just a subtle change, but I, I think that's a worthwhile change. Cause you, you could imagine uh, uh, the twelve people sitting down there and whoever thinks I'm, I'm smarter or quicker, uh, bigger. I'm gonna take control of this.
24:55 Speaker 01 Yeah.
24:55 Speaker 00 Yeah. I, and then you get that, that bully type or domineering type that will influence the other, other people. So, okay, uh, sorry, I interrupted, but the judges are now awake up, awake up to that, that, uh, let's, you don't need to pick it straight away. Just feel the dynamics of the group, dynamics of the room, and then work out who, who you think is best suited as the, uh.
25:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, particularly with a longer trial, you've got the, the luxury to be able to do that. And I think it's a good idea as well. But, uh, a, a verdict-driven jury, not led verdict-driven jury, will be one where, you know, the foreperson says, right, let's take a vote. Who thinks he's guilty? Who thinks he's not? All right, you know, three of you think he's not, nine of us think he is. How can we pummel you three into submission? How can we make you see our point of view? What's your problem? You know, and, and that sort of thing will happen. And I've heard tales of jurors lying on the floor crying because of the amount of bullying. Now, that you have to say, if there's a verdict of guilty after that sort of treatment, that's not satisfactory.
26:02 Speaker 01 And, no, and I measured it by asking jurors. Whether there was anything that happened that influenced them to vote a certain way, which they later regretted. You know, in the cold light of day, if you like. Um. Now, that's your your verdict driven. And that has to be in anyone's book, unsatisfactory and not necessarily going to do justice. Then you've got your evidence led where people say, right, okay, we've been told what pieces. The prosecution has to prove what the elements of the offence are, what things they have to prove. Let's look at each one. What evidence have we got that relates to that? Pro and con, you know? What did this witness say? What did that witness say? And go through it, you know, carefully and thoroughly.
26:47 Speaker 01 And they find sometimes, even though, for example, their sympathies might have been with. The victim or their sympathies might have been with the accused, the verdict, the evidence takes them to a particular conclusion. That's got to be far more satisfactory. So one of my recommendations, if. I hadn't had a publication uh stopped by a change of government, one of my recommendations was going to be. Uh that there ought to be a facilitator in the jury room, someone who's just experienced at. Holding meetings, if you like, and getting people to some sort of agreement.
27:24 Speaker 00 This is gonna say shallow when I say this, and I was thinking as you were talking, describing it. I wasn't gonna say facilitator, but. I was thinking that exact thing, that if you had someone there that could just keep them all i- in line and that have to. Yeah, be the right person with the right personality, just explaining what the role is there, because I could see a group of twelve people. Going off in completely the wrong direction. So what you're saying, a facilitator. I I think that's a, you're on to something there.
27:55 Speaker 01 Yeah.
27:56 Speaker 00 That would that would give me more confidence that they're doing what they should be doing in that room. Because I I think too much is ass of jurors, because I I sit there on cases I might have worked on for years. And sit there and thi- and I'm getting confused.
28:11 Speaker 01 Yeah.
28:11 Speaker 00 As the argue, the legal argument's going, I'm sitting there going, I I'm getting lost on this. And I'm thinking, these people have just come into it. I've lived and proved it for months or years. Understand and understand the broader picture, so I've got a better starting point. You've got these people that get this sanitised version of information. They're asked to leave the court why of what is going on, there's a legal argument in the absence of the jury. And they must be sitting there going, what are they talking about, then coming, coming back in and not being informed of what was discussed, other than a look at something that wasn't relevant to your role here. We're sorry that we're asking you to leave the court, but could you now leave the court? And they sit in their jury room for three hours, probably guessing, what are they going to ask this witness?
28:56 Speaker 01 Well, I can tell you from my work that they are guessing that and they're offended as well. Why are we not trusted? You know, why do we, you know, they think we're children. They think we can't actually, you know, sort, sort things out. Also, it used to be, not anymore, thank heavens, that jurors were even told not to take notes. Now they can take notes and some judges will allow them to have copies of the transcript. In other words, the typed up version of what's said in court. Why should it be a memory test? Why should the person who misremembers something hold sway in the jury? Why should it be just the person who took notes that, you know, is, is the one who has more influence? Because they've got notes, they only took notes of what mattered to them.
29:42 Speaker 01 So access to transcript and people say, oh, they'll just get bogged down or, you know. Well, how about putting a bit of faith in them? And if they want to check something, rather than having to come back into court, which is what often happens, to have transcript read to them, why shouldn't they have it searchable on a computer in the jury room and look it up for themselves?
30:03 Speaker 00 Well, I, I think it's evolving and changing with the times and definitely it, it, it should be something. Because the jury system is, yeah, the, the lineage goes back hundreds, hundreds of years. The world has changed and it used to be, yeah, we'll call the jury from the, the village because you're going to be judged by your peers. But it doesn't sort of really sit that way anymore. There's a whole cross section.
30:24 Speaker 01 Twelve, twelve men in fact. It was only relevant recently that women could be on juries.
30:30 Speaker 00 When did they, I didn't realise they let women into juries? When did that happen? That's outrageous.
30:35 Speaker 01 Have them while you're asleep, Gary.
30:37 Speaker 00 All right. Well, that's, yeah. When did that come? When did that come? When was it twelve, twelve men? How long ago was that?
30:44 Speaker 01 I don't actually know, to be honest, which is embarrassing. But, you know, back in the thirties, for example, it was always just men. I don't know when it actually changed. But, you know, don't forget that women couldn't vote at one point. And we only get to know the person's occupation.
31:02 Speaker 01 And, you know, very little other than their occupation, the suburb they live in, unless that's changed. And, you know, very little else. And all you could do is to say, well, I guess if you're defending a bank robber, you wouldn't want a bank manager on the jury. And it used to be you wouldn't put teachers on the jury because the theory was they'd be too judgmental. One other thing I've learned from my study is the more educated the person, the more useful they are as a juror. And, you know, give me a teacher any day on a jury, even though the received wisdom was you don't put them on juries. That's just probably due to people's bad experiences when they're at primary school or something, I suspect. I don't see any.
31:45 Speaker 00 Let it go.
31:46 Speaker 01 Yeah. So, you know, the more educated they are, the more able they are to indulge in that intellectual exercise of putting aside preconceived notions of examining their thinking and being critical of their own thinking. And I mean critical in the good sense of the word.
32:04 Speaker 00 Do you, do you think it would get to the, get to the stage where we're not having the jury trials? Like, I know there's options there. You can have a judge alone trial. Do you, do you see it evolving to the point where, look, this is all getting too complicated, forensic evidence, scientific evidence, even A I coming into play? Do you see the courts evolving? Will they keep up with the times?
32:26 Speaker 01 Uh, look, I still think there's a strong argument in favour of having, you know, I, they appears, that's another question. But having a jury of, you know, twelve.
32:38 Speaker 01 People who are not otherwise involved in the criminal justice system to actually judge this. Because in the end, it's society that's punishing or acquitting somebody and they're representatives of society. I think we need to get better about how we communicate information so that things don't get too complicated. And the forms we presented in, should we be giving them visuals? Should we be giving them, you know, graphs? Should we be giving them pictures? Should we learn to communicate? Like, I'm a great, wonderful scientist and I can talk fancy language and I can use fancy terms and all my colleagues understand me. Or how am I going to present this to a jury? How am I going to explain this so they understand?
33:23 Speaker 01 And I firmly believe you can, I believe people can be trained, not just to ask the right questions of them if you're the lawyer end of it. But as the expert, to use the right language and to explain and to have, you know, the lawyers help them explain it. So I think the answer's in the training and I don't think just having a jury of, say, three accountants in a, you know, um, fraud case is the answer at all. And with judges, I mean, you can't pick which judge you get. Judges, I have to say, the quality of judges is improving a lot, a huge lot over my career.
34:01 Speaker 01 Um, but, you know, back in the olden days, um, I would be very nervous if I had a judge alone trial, which judge I would get. Because some judges, you knew that they were going to convict, some judges.
34:14 Speaker 00 They, they had strong learnings one way or the other, the type of judge.
34:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, and so you'd only go for, the ability to have judge alone trials are relatively recent innovation anyway. And I did it in the baby shaking case because at the time of the trial, there was a lot of, there was actually a public information campaign about don't shake your babies, um, which.
34:36 Speaker 00 Okay, so that, that could have played.
34:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, that worried me.
34:40 Speaker 00 The minds of the jury.
34:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I was glad that particular judge that we got, um, was a thoughtful. You know, very fair judge. He may even recognise himself, but you know, I was very glad about that. Whereas I remember one particular judge, my client actually passed out in the dock because he he was so drunk. That's after they found him and got him to court because he didn't turn up the first day because he's on a bender. And he passed out and I said, Your Honour, you know, I have to ask for an adjournment because my client's sort of unconscious. And the judge said, Miss Fordham, he'll sober up and you can, as the day goes on, you can tell him what happened. And it's like.
35:18 Speaker 00 That, that, that, you're not shocking me. But, uh, different, different.
35:24 Speaker 01 I said to the judge, look, I've never been asked to justify this. I thought there was some sort of rule that the accused had to be conscious.
35:33 Speaker 00 Well.
35:33 Speaker 01 Anyway.
35:35 Speaker 00 I, I can imagine it. I, I can imagine it happening there. Would you, and it's a huge question. You, you don't have to, you know, dig into it too much, but we've got the adversarial system, which is not actually a search for the truth. It's proving the guilt or guilt or innocence. And then we've got the inquisitorial system, which is a search for the truth in basically finding out what happens. Some countries have that system in place. Do you think it's a better system? And it's a big question. I, I'd just be interested in your thoughts.
36:05 Speaker 01 We have that in the coroner's court, where the coroner can actually direct investigations, and it is a search for the truth. And coroners are specially trained to do that. And I think certainly from in the investigation of deaths, where it's not an attempt to pin blame on someone, or certainly shouldn't be. But other countries, I mean, I've been a member of the Law and Society Association, where a lot of, some of the work they do is on justice systems, and you compare systems in different countries. So I'm actually in a position where I do have some views about that. And one of the issues with the inquisitorial system, and one inquisitor, if you like, one,
36:48 Speaker 01 inquisitorial literary means questioning. You have one person doing that, is that they can be liable and have been in some countries to, for example, bribery or corruption, because it's just one person. Also, some people are better at the job than others, and some people are better, you know. If if you're acting as judge and jury, which is really what it amounts to, you may have your preconceived ideas and you may, um, in some countries, um, judges are elected as well and you want to be elected again next time round.
37:28 Speaker 00 Keep the favour of society.
37:30 Speaker 01 So there are all sorts of ways that system can go wrong as well. Um, do we, you know, I can't tell you whether one system's better than the other. We have what we have and I take some comfort in the fact that at least society's represented. Did did the judge who's doing the inquisition, who's doing the questioning, uh, did they go to an expensive private school and never see real life? Um, after they left their private school, um, did they live a sheltered life? Or were they beaten up by their bully of a father? Or do they go to, um, and there have been cases of this, go to particular sex clubs where they can be, um, vulnerable to blackmail
38:15 Speaker 01 if they don't come up with a certain verdict. Uh, just because you've got a trained judge doesn't mean you're safe. And again, I say the quality of judges today is so much better than some.
38:30 Speaker 00 Well, you brought up some very valid points there because I I often raise this with, uh, you know, inform people just to try to get a sense of it, people who under- understand the systems. I I get frustrated with the adversarial system because quite often I don't think all the evidence is presented. I'd like to see more evidence presented. What you touched on, what you learnt with your your studies with the jury, they seem to be, uh, yeah. Why don't they trust us? They're putting us in such a powerful position, position of responsibility, but they, we're not clever enough to absorb all the evidence. So, yeah, maybe maybe we've got the right system, it just needs some improvements and adjustments. And I I love the thought of a facilitator in there, keeping those juries on on board.
39:14 Speaker 00 Because you you mentioned something the other day without referencing the trial, but what the jury came out, because after all the evidence. Has been presented, if people aren't aware of that, then the juries are sent away to consider their verdict. And what was that one after three days?
39:29 Speaker 01 Yeah.
39:29 Speaker 00 They came out, what was the question they asked?
39:31 Speaker 01 Murder trial and it was actually a trial I was involved in as as a lawyer. It wasn't one of my uh study ones. And the jury deliberated for three days. In fact, we're all just debating, do we give them more time? Are we ever going to get a verdict? You know, the the lawyers and the judge were sort of looking at that question. And the jury is allowed to send questions out to the court. And often what happens, always with, except for this occasion, the judge and lawyers will agree as to what the answer should be to the jury's particular question. And this jury came out after three days of deliberation and said, does the accused have to prove he didn't do it? And the judge didn't even bother consulting us.
40:12 Speaker 01 He just, but we looked at each other in horror and thought, what have we been going on about for all of us? Prosecution will tell the jury, because of the type of, you know, you have to prove this beyond reasonable doubt. How can you, if you're a.
40:26 Speaker 00 So they've missed missed the whole.
40:28 Speaker 01 Point of it.
40:28 Speaker 00 Purpose of the uh.
40:30 Speaker 01 But I thought about it later and I thought, nah, what's probably happened? And I thought about this after I did my research. What's probably happened is that there's some one juror who's being a complete idiot, who won't shut up, who will say, no, the accused got to prove he didn't do it. And he didn't prove he didn't do it, so I'm going to convict. And everyone else is saying, no, no, no, it's not how it works. And in the end, they probably said, look, we'll settle it once we go back into court and ask the judge. I I hope that's what happened.
40:57 Speaker 00 How, how, yeah, you would like to think not all twelve of them sitting there debate debating that.
41:02 Speaker 01 Yeah.
41:02 Speaker 00 The fact that uh it's now in courts, it used to be unanimous decision, like all twelve jurors. But now there's some leeway for certain cases that it can be majority of a a decision. I thought that was good because you only needed to have one drop kick on the jury. And it could just, for whatever reason, they might just be a painful person, disagreeable type person, that's gonna sit there and argue to the cows come home regardless of what facts have been presented. I think that was a step in the right direction.
41:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's not the case with homicides, it's still got to be unanimous, and that's because the stakes are so high. And I think that's fair enough, but you can get a verdict of eleven one or ten two now in many others. But this is another example of not trusting the jury. The jury is told, your verdict has to be unanimous. And the lawyers and the judge have all got their fingers crossed behind their backs because they know that if the jury's having trouble reaching a verdict, they'll eventually be told it can be, you know, ten two or eleven one. Well, why not tell them that in the first place? And then you get the juries where a juror has been on a jury before and knows that. And they'll tell the other jurors, look, we can actually have a majority verdict. Well, why not tell them that in the first place?
42:17 Speaker 00 Yeah, give it, give them the information, that, that makes sense, that, that does make sense.
42:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, and then it shuts up the turkey who's, you know, because the, the juries will say, we don't have taken any notice of you anyway, because it's just one of you.
42:30 Speaker 00 Yeah, because the chances of getting twelve people selected randomly, and you're not going to get a drop kick or a turkey, as you, you say, on that group. You've got to be pretty lucky, you've got to be pretty lucky.
42:44 Speaker 00 The studies that you've done, is it available to the public? Has it come out in any form?
42:47 Speaker 01 Uh, yes and no, um, I've written several articles.
42:52 Speaker 00 No, it's either a yes answer or no, it can't be yes and no.
42:57 Speaker 01 It can, watch me.
43:00 Speaker 00 Oh, okay, I wish you'd taught me this trick when I was in the witness box.
43:03 Speaker 01 I, I have taught people that trick, I'll just digress and say, I, I, I teach people, what you say is you turn to the, if the lawyer's saying, I'm ans, I'm asking you the questions, yes or no, yes or no, give me a yes or no answer. What you do is you turn to the judge and you say, your honour.
43:19 Speaker 01 If I were to give a yes or no answer, I would be in danger of misleading the jury. And a jury goes.
43:25 Speaker 00 Perfect.
43:27 Speaker 01 And they'll never do that to you again. So.
43:31 Speaker 00 Perfect, perfect. I like it.
43:32 Speaker 01 So anyway, that was a digression. But now, what was the question again, counsel? That's the other thing. Half the time, the lawyer's forgotten the question by then, too.
43:41 Speaker 00 It was about the papers from your extensive study into the jury system.
43:46 Speaker 01 Yes, of course.
43:47 Speaker 00 Is it available to the public?
43:48 Speaker 01 Some is, some is. And you know what? I'm actually, firstly, you can just Google and you'll find some of the publications. Also, if anybody's actually keen to find out about it, I'm actually perfectly happy to be emailed about it. And you will find my email address if you just Google me. So it's pretty easy. There's nothing private about my life or anything.
44:08 Speaker 00 Well, the fact that you've done the study, like it was something that needed to be done. There's so much value in what was learnt from having access to people that were not normally given access to. For anyone to do a study, it gives an understanding. So it makes sense.
44:22 Speaker 01 That's why so many bodies were on board with it and everybody wanted the, the results.
44:28 Speaker 00 Just one question. Is this just a myth or a rumour that there was a jury, a personnel jury trying to use a Ouija board to speak to the deceased in a trial?
44:39 Speaker 01 That actually happened. That's real. It did actually happen. And what happened was the, it was a murder trial. We're saying to be talking about murders a lot, which is good. It was one of those circumstantial cases because one of the things about murders is usually the main witness is dead. In fact, invariably, the main witness is dead because that's why it's a murder trial.
45:00 Speaker 00 It is, yeah, yeah. You usually know that aspect. Other proofs, but.
45:05 Speaker 01 See again, dark sense of humor, we're actually laughing about it. Anyway, okay.
45:09 Speaker 00 I know. People understand.
45:10 Speaker 01 We're a pair of sickos. Let's move on. So the juror thought, well, you know, there's two opposing stories and they both make sense. You know, this could have happened this way, could have happened that way. I know, we'll ask the deceased. And they brought the Ouija board into the jury room. And they set about having a seance to try to communicate with the deceased. This was discovered and the, and the appeal was successful.
45:39 Speaker 01 So, yeah.
45:40 Speaker 00 Well, see, now, if we had your facilitator in there, that could have, he could have, or she could have sorted that one out and go, no, we can't have a source in the jury.
45:49 Speaker 01 That would never have happened.
45:51 Speaker 00 Not, not allowed.
45:52 Speaker 01 Absolutely.
45:53 Speaker 00 But, okay, bizarre. Look, there's a thousand more things that we could talk about. I, I wanna make mention of your book about life law and not enough shoes. How did you come up with the title of your book?
46:07 Speaker 01 Probably through being a girly criminal lawyer and dealing with all the things that came with being a girly criminal lawyer. And the thing is that shoes don't judge you. Shoes are non-judgmental. You know, shoes love you no matter what. And, you know, sometimes I just took pleasure in the fact that I could be a girl doing a bloke's job and I could still stay a girl. They haven't been dipped in blood, but.
46:34 Speaker 00 Right.
46:35 Speaker 01 There, there you go.
46:36 Speaker 00 They, they, they, they look, they'd rock it.
46:39 Speaker 01 Yeah. And, and also I got into trouble from a judge for wearing zebra striped shoes once in court because he said it was distracting the jury. I know who it was distracting and it wasn't the jury. And I reckon black and white went with my lawyer's outfit anyway. So.
46:53 Speaker 00 You wear, you, you go, girl. You wear that. Look, there, there's a lot of, lot of other stuff that I wanted to speak to you about, but I think we've only scratched the surface of some of the things you've seen and done. I was gonna ask about cruising the world on the QE2, entertaining guests. After sitting down with you for the podcast, I can see why you were invited on cruise ships as, as a speaker. Just tell us briefly about that experience, because that would be quite, it's not, not the typical career path that a high-profile barrister goes down, but a talking gig on cruise ships.
47:31 Speaker 01 Well, again, it happened by accident, of course. And this seems to be a bit of a thing.
47:34 Speaker 00 I'm gonna start to call you Forrest Gump. You know how he went through his life?
47:38 Speaker 01 Life, life's a box of chocolates.
47:40 Speaker 00 Okay, how, how did this accident, how did this accident happen?
47:42 Speaker 01 I was actually on a cruise, paying for it, and there was this guy.
47:47 Speaker 00 Had too much to drink at the bar and then started talking and.
47:50 Speaker 01 What? What? Drink? What? Seriously?
47:53 Speaker 00 Sorry.
47:54 Speaker 01 And, yes, you should apologize for that slur on my character. No, I was actually listening to one of their lecturers and he was terrible. He actually got the staff to wheel a desk on a stage and then sat behind a desk and read. Um, from a stack of papers. It was awful. And see, I'm carefully not saying which cruise line it was, but it was terrible. And I thought, anyone, not, not just me, anyone can do better than that. So I asked him how he got his gig. And he said, I've got an agent in Miami. And they get me the gig. So I wrote to the agent and said, how about it? And you have to give a bit of outline of the sorts of things you can talk about. So I gave them a bit of an outline. And of course, CSI was all the rage. And I could talk about forensics and crime.
48:34 Speaker 01 And next thing I knew, my, my first gig actually was on the Queen Mary. Um, and I went from there to all sorts of other cruise lines. And what happens is you go on these six star cruises, you don't have to pay, uh, you're treated as a guest, you can take a friend, um, play your cards right. No, you'd have to share a room with me. You won't want to do that. So, yeah, and, and I have to talk about stuff I know about. But the other cool thing about is these audiences are usually quite, uh, well, no one's forcing them to go to lectures. They're choosing to. So they want to learn. They want to know about this stuff. And it's been some of my most satisfying teaching moments. Um, because I've done a lot of teaching over
49:19 Speaker 01 my career. Um, people will go out and say, you know, I'm thinking about things differently from now on. I have this thing called A B C, assume nothing, believe no one, check everything. I said, gonna be more critical in a good sense of the word. We, we're not going to take what the media tells us at face value. We are going to ask questions, you know, we, we've, we've learned a different way of thinking. And that just gives me such joy.
49:48 Speaker 00 Well, what a, a great gig you got there. And I, I can imagine you would be, uh, be very popular and entertaining for, uh, for the people listening to your talk. Cause I've got a sense of, uh, the way you tell a story from our sit down today. So I, I want to thank you so much for coming, coming on the podcast. How the people get your book?
50:08 Speaker 01 The, the only way now is you have to actually, again, Google me, go to my website, you can order it there, or, um, flick me an email. It's out of print. Now it went to three print runs, I might add, and it wasn't vanity published either. It had a real publisher. So it's a real book. Um.
50:25 Speaker 00 You're the real deal.
50:26 Speaker 01 I am, I am. So you can contact me and while stocks last, I can post the book or get it to people.
50:35 Speaker 00 Well, thank you very much. And I, I want to thank you for the work that you've done because I know having people that genuinely care in the legal, in the justice system makes a difference from, uh, from police to victims.
50:47 Speaker 01 Yeah.
50:47 Speaker 00 Everyone involved in it. And I can see your care and you're smart. You've got everything that people need. And I can see why people were lucky to have you defending them if they, they got into trouble.
50:59 Speaker 01 I'm, I'm no good at compliments taking.
51:01 Speaker 00 I, well, if I do get over the WA a bit, if I get into trouble, I know who I, who I'm calling. Not that I'm ever gonna get into trouble again. I've had enough of that. I don't want to be in a court again at this stage.
51:14 Speaker 01 I hear you, I hear you.
51:16 Speaker 00 Okay. Thank, thank you very much.
51:18 Speaker 01 No problem at all.
51:19 Speaker 00 Cheers.
Previous Forensics and why fingerprints lie: Judith Fordham Pt.1 Next Psychopaths, murder and unmasking incels: Dr Nathan Brooks Pt.1 Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated