Pod Insights I Catch Killers with Gary Jubelin Bringing down predator Malka Leifer: Nicole Meyer Pt.1 About this episode Nicole Meyer was first abused by her school principal when she was 15 years old. Malka Leifer continued abusing her, and her sisters - Dassi Erlich and Elly Sapper, for years. From grooming the community to breaking off Nicole’s engagement, Leifer controlled every aspect of her life. The sisters finally broke their silence, reporting the rapist to police. But, in the middle of one night in 2008, Leifer fled the country.
Watch the Stan documentary, Surviving Malka Leifer https://play.stan.com.au/programs/5529640, out October 5.
Want to hear more from I Catch Killers? Visit news.com.au.
Watch episodes of I Catch Killers on our YouTube channelhere https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLlq8In_ATbJnjFcb-fykqJ8HV9W9OOJWX.
Like the show? Get more aticatchkillers.com.au https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/truecrimeaustralia/i-catch-killers/i-catch-killers-gary-jubelins-new-podcast-series-and-book/news-story/6848df9e1b6feccf7508878fc0438f7f Advertising enquiries: [email protected]
Questions for Gary: [email protected]
Get in touch with the show by joining ourFacebook group https://www.facebook.com/groups/844896725918656, and visiting us onInstagram https://www.instagram.com/icatchkillers/?hl=en orTiktok https://www.tiktok.com/@icatchkillerspodcast?lang=en.
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 11,525 words · 2 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 The public has had a long-held fascination with detectives. Detectives see a side of life the average person is never exposed to. I spent 34 years as a cop. For 25 of those years, I was catching killers. That's what I did for a living. I was a homicide detective. I'm no longer just interviewing bad guys. Instead, I'm taking the public into the world in which I operated. The guests I talk to each week have amazing stories from all sides of the law. The interviews are raw and honest, just like the people I talk to. Some of the content and language might be confronting. That's because no one who comes into contact with crime is left unchanged. Join me now as I take you into this world.
0:45 Speaker 00 Today, I spoke to Nicole Meyer. It was a very difficult conversation to have. You may not recognise Nicole's name, but it's likely you've heard of the case she was closely linked to. Nicole and the two younger sisters, Ellie Sapper and Dacey Elrich, made allegations about being sexually assaulted by their school principal, Malka Leifer, whilst at the ultra-orthodox Jewish school called Adas Israel School. Just days after the allegation came to light, Malka Leifer fled back to Israel with her family. That led to a 13-year legal battle to get Malka Leifer extradited back to Australia to face 29 charges relating to the sexual abuse of Nicole and the sisters.
1:28 Speaker 00 There was a seven-week trial in August 2023, where Malka Leifer was convicted of 18 counts relating to the sexual abuse of Nicole's two sisters, but was cleared of the charges relating to herself. We talked about the impact this horrendous situation had on Nicole. It was a deeply personal and troubling story, but one I think is important to talk about. Before we listen to this conversation, I need to reiterate that Malka Leifer was found not guilty of charges relating to our guest, Nicole Meyer. So, in the eyes of the law, these offences were not proven. We need to acknowledge and accept that. But if we're going to put our trust in the court's decisions,
2:10 Speaker 00 let's also accept Malka Leifer was found guilty of 18 counts of sexually abusing Nicole's sisters and was sentenced to 15 years imprisonment.
2:21 Speaker 00 Nicole Meyer, welcome to I Catch Killers.
2:23 Speaker 01 Thank you.
2:24 Speaker 00 Well, look, thank you for coming in and talking about what's occurred to yourself and your sisters. It must be difficult to talk about, but I think it's important that people like yourself talk about what happened.
2:39 Speaker 01 It has been difficult initially, but now I find it actually healing and I hope validating and supporting for any other survivor that actually tunes in and listens.
2:48 Speaker 00 Yeah, we've had, we've had previous victims and in my time in the police, victims of sexual assault or survivors of sexual assault that some people refer to it as. And I think there is strength in people speaking out because quite often there's, there's victim blame. The victims blame themselves for whatever bizarre reason that, oh, this has happened to me. But the more people that speak about it, I think it makes people more comfortable that you are a victim and it's nothing to do with the person that's been assaulted. It's the person that's created that environment.
3:21 Speaker 01 Absolutely, and I think it also removes the shame. There is so much shame when it comes to being abused and not being able to say your story or feeling too ashamed is a difficult one. So being able to speak out gives strength to others as well, that they don't have to stay quiet and don't have to feel that shame.
3:36 Speaker 00 Yeah, talk, talk me through the shame, why, why the shame, where do you think that comes from?
3:42 Speaker 01 I think many victim survivors sometimes feel that the abuse is their fault or why they didn't say no, or why they couldn't stop it, or why they didn't walk away. So there's a lot of shame associated with our self-blame and our self-criticism. And even myself, I reflect back and I think, where was my head in those years? But when someone has such control over you, like Makalifa did over me, there was no options of no. And that was just one factor of why I couldn't say no. So the shame is associated with, could I have done something different to stop it? Or why was I chosen to be a victim? Or did I somehow ask for it? Not really, but did I do something that made that person think I was an easy target?
4:22 Speaker 00 That's the insidious nature of a crime where the perpetrator is grooming people too, isn't it?
4:27 Speaker 01 Absolutely.
4:28 Speaker 00 Creating that, creating that doubt. And that's where the, the nature of the crime, and it continues on that guilt that's attached to the victims because of the, the way they've been groomed.
4:38 Speaker 01 Yes, grooming is just the very beginning of the whole abuse cycle, unfortunately.
4:43 Speaker 00 Yeah.
4:44 Speaker 01 And particularly with Makalifa, she was a woman. And she was nurturing and she was kind and she was caring. So it wasn't just her coming in and taking advantage. It was a slow build up of crossing boundaries that I didn't even know were there until the abuse started. And it all was disguised under care, love and nurturing, which I was severely lacking from home. So I was appreciative of that care, attention, love, that she was so freely giving to myself and others.
5:14 Speaker 00 Yeah, it adds to the confusion, doesn't it? It adds to the confusion of what's occurred to you. The matter itself attracted the, yeah, such an intense interest from the, the community, the public and also, also the media. Did you feel that, that pressure of, uh, yeah, your life has almost become very public?
5:35 Speaker 01 I think when I slipped into becoming a public figure, I remember that moment quite well. Because I felt anonymous. I was still working in the school where I was abused. I went and gave a police statement and a week later I took a week off. And a week later I went back and continued teaching as if I didn't do it, teaching in the very same building I was abused in. So I was very private, so I thought. So when I became more public and I stepped out with my story. All of a sudden people knew, but at the same time, I think I grew stronger and stronger as it became bigger. And I realised I'm fighting for a story that's not just mine, but on behalf of so many survivors and being a voice for so many. That it didn't matter anymore. And also the, the media really helped us along the way.
6:19 Speaker 01 So we felt encouraged by their support as well. We created some really good relationships with some of them.
6:25 Speaker 00 Okay, well, that, that's a good way to navigate yourself through a very difficult situation. I, I'm thinking the attention that the, the media and the public or the fascination that the, the people had in the actual case. Was the perpetrator was a female, because that's not the perception that we hear, yeah, sexual abuse, sexual assault. Is quite often linked to the man being the perpetrator. In your case, it was a female. Do you think that made a difference?
6:53 Speaker 01 I think he opened the minds of so many that may have not realised that a woman can be a perpetrator in that way, to that extent. And I think since then, I've become aware of quite a few female perpetrators. But it felt like Malka Leifer was one of the first, and maybe because it was so publicised, because of the extradition. But it just, I think he opened the minds of many Australians and really around the world, around female perpetrators being right up there.
7:17 Speaker 00 Um, tell me a little bit about your upbringing.
7:21 Speaker 01 I was born, first child in Australia. My parents immigrated before I was born from England. And I was born after eight years of my parents not having any children. So I was almost like the oldest of the second lot of children, so two older siblings, um, four siblings, two years consecutively each below me. We had a very strictly controlled upbringing.
7:45 Speaker 01 There's a version of, like, I guess, being strict and insulated because of the religion, but then there was also the abuse on top of that. So unfortunately, my parents were primarily, my mother, very abusive, um, to an extent that is extremely severe. And that is probably what is most difficult to talk about, because I feel that many don't have the capacity to understand the severity of the abuse that we grew up with. And there's been times where sharing something has been met with disbelief and that couldn't be possible, while no one could, no mother could be like that. But that was our experience growing up and it was very hidden. No one knew. We turned up to school looking well dressed and even if it wasn't in trend, so to speak,
8:30 Speaker 01 but we had the clothing.
8:31 Speaker 00 Yeah.
8:32 Speaker 01 We had food at least some of the time. There were many times we didn't have food for either punishment or just there wasn't. And people could not see that we had bruises or we stayed home from school or left home school early to go home and clean. It wasn't obvious, it wasn't extremely obvious to someone who wouldn't know to look out for signs of what a child from an abused home could look like.
8:54 Speaker 00 It's a horrible situation to find yourself in, like, a childhood that should be support, nourishing and to have that. I know when we spoke the other day, you said it was, um, uh, difficult to talk about. There's a couple of things that I I picked up in the judge's sentencing comments when he talked about the upbringing of yourself and and your two sisters. Um, comments about the treatment, are you fine for me to read read those those out?
9:21 Speaker 01 Absolutely.
9:21 Speaker 00 Okay, this is from Judge Gamble at the County Court of Victoria in the reasons for sentencing. And the complainants, and this is from the sentencing report, the complainants were raised in an ultra orthodox Jewish family. They had other siblings, including older sisters and younger brothers. The complaints was, the complaints were subjected to a very difficult upbringing due to cruel and unpredictable way their mother behaved towards them. Each was mistreated and witnessed the mistreatment of their siblings. Their mother neglected and abused her children regularly, both physically and emotionally. She also threatened them. The physical abuse included slaps, kicks, pinching, as well as the use of objects, including straps.
10:05 Speaker 00 This caused bruising and other marks. The complaints were expected to do the housework and mistreat it if it was not done perfectly. And to their mother's liking. On occasions, she would lock one or more of the children in a dark cupboard, sometimes for lengthy periods. On other occasions, she would tell one of the children that they were discarded and no longer part of the family. And then get her husband to drive that child to a park and leave them there alone for a significant period. Food was often withheld as a form of punishment and control. For each complaint, feeling hungry is an enduring childhood memory. On any view, it was a miserable home life for the complainants, who were starved of love and affection and left in a perpetual state of fear and confusion. It's pretty heavy.
10:50 Speaker 01 Yes.
10:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, um, that must have been part of the evidence that came out, that came out in the trial.
10:57 Speaker 01 It did, because it explains some context as to why we were, I guess, desperate for some love and attention.
11:03 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, and in my experience as a police officer and from people that to sat in the seat you're you're sitting in now. It's um, apparent to me that perpetrators look for people like yourself and your sisters, that were in a difficult environment and it makes them easier to groom. Would you agree with that? Perception.
11:27 Speaker 01 Yes, I think there's also a part of that could be obedient and listening to adults, which I think any child will go through regardless of their upbringing, that you always listen to adults. So there is that, but definitely Malka Leifer saw and very quickly understood that our home life was far from perfect and realised that if she gave us food, love, care.
11:48 Speaker 00 Yeah.
11:48 Speaker 01 Then she had us.
11:50 Speaker 00 So the school, can you tell me a little bit about the school and the community? Because a lot of people don't understand the ultra orthodox way that you were brought up or the environment that you grew up in. Can you explain that a bit to us?
12:03 Speaker 01 I'll try and explain it shortly.
12:08 Speaker 01 I would say it's an insular community with not much influence from the external world. What each home does will be according to the level that they agree on. So there'll be some families that will go to the public library, there'll be a lot of families that don't. For example, when I grew up, we were so strictly brought up, we couldn't even have a Coles catalogue allowed into our home. So that's how insulated we were. Um, there'll be families that won't have any idea of the sports or what's going on in the external world surrounding them, and there'll be others that do. So it's just, it's mostly a very insulated community with our own kosher shops and butcher and even hairdressers and services, nail salons, any of that kind of stuff you need. Does not mean you cannot get services elsewhere, but you would support the people in your community first if you can.
12:52 Speaker 01 Um, boys and girls are kept strictly segregated and the modesty is a huge component of all of it. And in saying that, then the girls will be dressed very modestly from the age of three and up. And there is no male interaction other than your family members at all until you are in the dating or getting ready to be engaged from birth, pretty much.
13:15 Speaker 00 So within that insular environment that you're living in, that's the community but also the school. So it wasn't sort of you're living in an environment at home, but going to school and getting a more worldly view or a wider view of what goes on. The school adopted that approach too, so you and your sisters were very insulated from what was going on.
13:37 Speaker 01 Absolutely. It was, my whole life was my home, my school, my synagogue, all interrelated, all connected, all the same people and nothing beyond that.
13:46 Speaker 00 Yeah. That played in, and again, I picked up some comments from the judge's sentencing report, that played into your naivety in regards to sexual matters as well, because of the insular world that you were living in.
14:02 Speaker 01 Absolutely, there was no sex education in our schools whatsoever.
14:07 Speaker 00 So that would have, I would imagine, when the offences started occurring, that would have caused confusion, because you wouldn't have had much understanding of what was going on?
14:16 Speaker 01 I had absolutely no idea what was Markoliva's intentions or what was happening. That's even before the dissociation stepped in.
14:24 Speaker 00 Yeah.
14:24 Speaker 01 Even just her putting her hand on my thigh or my back. I would have not known that that was a red flag, and that was her testing the boundaries to see what my response would be.
14:34 Speaker 00 Yeah.
14:35 Speaker 01 I just froze and didn't say anything, didn't do anything, didn't understand anything.
14:39 Speaker 00 It's so understandable, like when you're describing the environment in which you grew up and how naive you were, it must have been so confusing for you.
14:49 Speaker 01 Yeah.
14:49 Speaker 00 Yeah, the judge made a comment, and I'll refer to that, because it was a seven week trial and obviously delved very deeply into all the issues relating to the offences.
15:01 Speaker 00 Due to the ultra orthodox upbringings, the complaints remained ignorant in sexual matters until shortly before they got married. They received no form of sexual education, either at home or at school. They had no understanding of human anatomy, puberty or sexual relations, and didn't even know the words ascribed for intimate parts of the body. And from a very early age, they were taught that girls and women must dress very modestly and not reveal or discuss their bodies. The complainant's ignorance in sexual matters continued well into their late teenage years until shortly before they got married. So while these offences were occurring against yourself and your sisters, you were ignorant to what was going on.
15:43 Speaker 01 Absolutely.
15:44 Speaker 00 Did you talk amongst yourselves? Did?
15:48 Speaker 01 No, there was one incident where there was a school camp.
15:51 Speaker 00 Yeah.
15:52 Speaker 01 And my sister slept in the same room. She visited just for one night. I was there as a young teacher. And she, Michaela, I thought she was sleeping and she abused me in the bed that I was sharing with her.
16:02 Speaker 00 Right.
16:02 Speaker 01 While my sister was on the single bed. And that's how my sister found out I was being abused. The next morning, I gave her a look, just a look, nothing else. And I went to find her something she needed because she didn't bring all her stuff with her. So I went to ask some other people for some stuff. And I didn't want her to be left alone with Michaela. And Michaela kicked me out the room and then went into the bathroom where she was showering.
16:22 Speaker 00 Right. How, how did you feel as the older sister?
16:26 Speaker 01 At that moment, which is a very visual memory for me, I felt awful because I did not want, even if I had no words. I just did not want Michaela alone with my sister. And that was my understanding that Michaela was abusing her.
16:39 Speaker 00 Okay.
16:40 Speaker 01 And that was it.
16:41 Speaker 00 Horrible, horrible situation.
16:44 Speaker 00 This went on for a, a number of years.
16:46 Speaker 01 So when Michaela entered my life, I was fifteen and a half years old in year ten. Um, what the courts did not get to hear was that she continued to abuse me post me getting married. And being pregnant and first child. And that is something that I'm not ashamed anymore to share. Because even though I know that the prosecution and potentially the defence made that decision based on what the general understanding of abuse is. It felt at the time extremely invalidating to me because abuse didn't stop when I was engaged. It continued. And what stopped me from allowing her to abuse me the way that she was, to the extent that she was. Was her lying herself down on me when I was pregnant.
17:27 Speaker 01 And my naivety even then was thinking that her, in my mind, fat, which is not a nice word to use, her large body was going to squash my baby. And that is what instinctively.
17:40 Speaker 01 Did not allow me to be in the same room with her again, to be able to be in that position.
17:44 Speaker 00 Right.
17:44 Speaker 01 Not that the abuse stopped, but that she was not able to lie full length on top of me like that again. And that is a very significant moment because I still didn't have words. I still was extremely naive. But the protection of my child is what
17:58 Speaker 00 Over right.
17:59 Speaker 01 allowed me to make sure that there was some protection from the full amount of the abuse. Then when she left in two thousand and eight. It was simply because my sister was incredibly brave overseas, living in Israel alone and disclosed to a social worker there. That social worker could not believe that it was Malka Leifer because she knew she used to live in Australia herself as well.
18:21 Speaker 00 Right, then she she knew her.
18:22 Speaker 01 She knew Malka Leifer personally, very personally. She called me to confirm and I said, yes, because I am too. And that was, and there's a bit of not quite remembering properly whether Dasi, my sister, called me first and said, you know, Hannah's going to call you or not. Both of us don't remember the same exact what happened then. But it was a shock. I went to school and it felt like someone died. She had packed up and gone in the middle of the night, but it didn't happen straight away. It happened a couple of days later and there was such a, you could feel the tension in the school. Malka Leifer was still there. They were trying to figure out what to do. She was principal of the school and I don't remember who and I wish I did.
19:04 Speaker 01 Someone or some bodies prepared me that she might come to my classroom and ask me what's going on.
19:09 Speaker 00 Yep.
19:10 Speaker 01 And that is the last memory I have I have of her. She pulled me out of class. It was the only time I've ever seen her look scared and she asked me what's going on. I stammered out some kind of reply that I couldn't and I don't know. And that night she left.
19:22 Speaker 00 Okay, I I want to talk about how it it came about and how quickly and readily she she left the country with with her with her family. So just breaking it down, your sister, and let's put it in a timeframe. When were the offences occurring over what what period of time?
19:38 Speaker 01 So she arrived two thousand and one, all the way to two thousand and eight.
19:41 Speaker 00 Okay.
19:41 Speaker 01 And I was there the entire time that she was.
19:43 Speaker 00 And and what sort of age are we talking about when the offences started happening?
19:48 Speaker 01 So the grooming started when I was fifteen and a half.
19:50 Speaker 00 Right, yeah.
19:50 Speaker 01 So year ten.
19:51 Speaker 00 Yeah.
19:51 Speaker 01 And I was the first class that she groomed and then any class below me all the way until she left.
19:57 Speaker 00 Your sister's told the counselor over over overseas, made contact with you. And then I would imagine mandatory reporting, she's reported it. What were the circumstances in which it came to Leifer's attention that there's been complaints made against her? How was that dealt with?
20:18 Speaker 01 I'm not sure what happened at that time. I just know that it was within days, one, two, three days and she was gone. It was not long after my sister disclosed that she left the country. The exact intricacies, I don't know if anyone's ever going to be fully honest about what happened in that time.
20:33 Speaker 00 Yeah, I'm just breaking down like the timeline that I've looked for the documentation that's available that your sister made a disclosure to a councillor in late February two thousand and eight. School board stood Leifer down on the fifth of March two thousand and eight. And at one twenty a m. the very next morning, Leifer and her family caught a flight to Israel.
20:58 Speaker 01 Yes.
20:59 Speaker 00 Okay, when you found out that Leifer had left the country with her family shortly after it's been brought to the attention of the school, how did you feel?
21:09 Speaker 01 I was in utter shock because being a victim of hers but still being abused till the day she left, there was no closure, there was no, this is happening and mentally preparing, okay, I'm not going to see this person. So she was there one day, she was not there the next. From an external perspective, it's almost like I was in a de-realization kind of perspective. I'm watching hordes of teachers and students go to the main lunchroom or gathering room and everyone's in a state of grief and I'm like, this happened because of me, this happened because of my sister. This, this is something I had a part of, but no one knows that. So I didn't know where to place myself.
21:53 Speaker 01 It was the oddest feeling and no one has ever actually asked me that question. You are the first person that has.
21:58 Speaker 00 Right.
21:59 Speaker 01 And it was just, there was shock, there was shame, there was, I wonder if anyone's going to find out that it's me. My sisters weren't in the school. They were, like, I was the only out of the three of us still working in the school. And what does that mean for my life? Like, what have I set in motion?
22:15 Speaker 00 It's a lot of pressure to carry because I would imagine the rumours and people would be speculating on what's happened here and you've got the, yeah, you understand what's happened. It must have been very difficult.
22:28 Speaker 01 It was incredibly difficult and the person who stepped up to be interim principal actually. Took me to a therapist, one session.
22:37 Speaker 00 Yeah.
22:37 Speaker 01 And she, I was so numb and dissociated and disconnected. She took out cards and said, tell me your feelings from these teddy bear cards. I said, I don't do teddy bear cards. And that was the end of the session. And I never went to therapy again until years later.
22:48 Speaker 00 Good on you. I don't, I don't like teddy bear cards.
22:50 Speaker 01 No feelings, no cards. I'm in shock. Like back then, I wish I could say to her, you're dealing with a victim who's just had her life turned upside down. Who has no idea what's just happened, doesn't even understand the impact of the abuse. And you're asking her to describe her feelings. Not happening.
23:03 Speaker 00 Okay, to teddy, on teddy bear cards.
23:06 Speaker 01 Yes.
23:06 Speaker 00 I like that. Police investigation was not commenced until mid two thousand and eleven, when your sister came forward with, and statements were taken around June two thousand and eleven. So I'm just trying to understand this sister's report that council has reached out to you. Obviously, a formal report has been, or the school has been notified.
23:28 Speaker 00 There's been, it's obviously been discussed. And then Lifa has left, left the school and went to Israel.
23:39 Speaker 00 It's not till a couple of years after that it's reported to the police. And who reported it to the police?
23:46 Speaker 01 So I just went back to normal work, having kids, my sister living overseas, another sister getting married, living. So it was just, it was just this complete disconnect. It was a shock. I remember being in the school and everyone in utter shock and a interim principal stepping up and everyone in shock. Like it was a huge shock and displacement in the school. But then it just settled, school had to keep going on, kids still had to be taught, life still had to keep happening. And then my sister, my youngest sister, the youngest of us three, gave a police statement. She was the first one. I hadn't even entertained the idea of giving a police statement when she did.
24:21 Speaker 00 Did you know that was an option for you? That was, and I'm, yeah, looking at the world in which you grew up. Did you see that as something that you could have reached out to the police?
24:33 Speaker 01 I always had a burning desire for justice to happen. When that exactly started, I don't know. But no, I I don't I don't know if I would have ever initiated going forward if my sister hadn't first. Simply because shame, fear, dissociation. And just not even knowing that that is something I could do. It was not even, it was never given to me. Like, I've had people ask me directly. Well, if they knew that you were victim right before she left, why didn't you say anything? I said, no one came to me and said. Can we go to the police? I'll support you. Let's tell them what happened so that we can. No one gave me that option. I didn't even know that was available.
25:08 Speaker 00 Okay, like, it's, I understand what you're saying now, sitting down, down, talking to you, but I also understand why people would be saying, well, why didn't you go to the police? But that's why I think the judge has made such a point of talking about your upbringing and the environment in which you grew up with. But, yeah, that to me makes the offence, well, it doesn't make it any more sinister. It's an evil offence to start with. But clearly she was preying on exactly the things that were holding you back from going to the police is your ignorance.
25:37 Speaker 01 Yes.
25:37 Speaker 00 And and not understanding. Okay, so your sister's decided to go to the police. Did the police reach out to you or did you you go to the police?
25:47 Speaker 01 Could be they did. I don't think they did. Ellie went first, Dusty a couple of months later. And finally, on the day I found out I was pregnant with my youngest, I went to the police station and gave my reports. It was so traumatizing and I think any survivor, victim survivor that listens to this will understand, I actually have no. Memory of giving my police statement. I don't know who took it. I don't know what I said. Obviously, I've got the papers. But I don't have any physical or visual memory at all of doing that. That's how hard it was for me to step out of. My entire insulated, closed, private life and do something so extreme, even though it felt right to do. And that was the first time in my life, even post all my babies, I took a week off work for mental health needs that I didn't even know I needed. I just knew I couldn't go back to work for a week.
26:30 Speaker 01 And I needed somehow to figure out what I had done. Yeah, even when I was doing the committal hearing.
26:35 Speaker 00 Yeah.
26:35 Speaker 01 Before trial. The defence lawyer was saying, did you sign that statement? And I was like, well, my signature's there, so I did. But I actually have no memory of doing that because that's how traumatizing giving my first statement was.
26:46 Speaker 00 And that's not unusual for traumatized people.
26:49 Speaker 01 Not at all.
26:49 Speaker 00 In situations like that. It's difficult to understand unless you've been in that that situation, but it's not not unusual. Okay, so we've got now a police investigation. Your sisters have have come forward, the three of you. Um, did you think there would be, uh, how did you think you were going to get justice, given the fact she's gone back to Israel? Did they explain the complexities of extradition and all that type of thing?
27:15 Speaker 01 I smile wryly now because I was so trusting and so innocent. And when I heard the words, sure, we'll send the statements to Canberra, get the paperwork done, go to Israel and get her, I was like, great. Story over.
27:29 Speaker 00 Hmm.
27:29 Speaker 01 I had absolutely no idea and I can still remember the relief I felt, how simple that all was. How long can it take it to get paper stamped in Canberra and then just pick her up? It was like one plus one and it did not happen like that at all. It was the most.
27:46 Speaker 01 It, I don't know the word, it pulled me down so much in my entire life was surrounding around dates. Around who's the next police contact that we can keep in contact with, because it changed a couple of times over the years. Who's ignoring us or giving us any update? What's happening? What's happening in Israel? Why is there complete silence? It was three years of utter waiting and silence and hopelessness and it's never going to happen.
28:12 Speaker 00 Yeah.
28:12 Speaker 01 But we didn't understand why because we didn't have enough information happening, what was going on.
28:17 Speaker 00 The complexities of of trying to organize this. We'll talk about the extradition and and how long it took, but before we do, can we just break down? Can you explain to people that, um, what actually happened to you? We've talked about it in in a general sense, but the grooming started. And that, uh, lifer would, uh, take, uh, take you to the locations where you're on your own. You'd go to a place on a Sunday for extra, extra tutoring or or schooling. Can you explain the pattern that she created? That allowed her to commit those offences against you and, uh, and what it actually involved?
28:55 Speaker 01 Recently through my healing journey, I've actually thought I could write a book on the seven years that I was with Malka Lifa, because it is so extensive. And the coercive control and the impact and the control she had in every single area of my life is extremely difficult to understand unless it's really fully understood. So she entered my life when I was in year ten. She started immediately that year already crossing boundaries, like no teacher ever put their hands on the student's shoulders to like push them down the corridor. No teacher ever touched a student, full stop. It just wasn't in our school, female, and we didn't have male teachers. It just wasn't. So she already with everyone showed that she was that kind of touchy feely person,
29:36 Speaker 01 caring, smiling, chaotic, but she was just everywhere and anywhere, interested in everyone. Very quickly made favourites and those favourites shifted and changed over time. And very, and everyone knew who her favourites were.
29:48 Speaker 00 Yeah.
29:49 Speaker 01 Pulled kids out of class to ask them to do errands or to get little jobs or help them with a newsletter or all that kind of stuff. Then we moved to them back to the main building with the rest of the school and she was still the teacher. And she would have this little office between our classroom and she would just like be on the phone and just like keep an eye out. You just somehow knew that her eyes were always everywhere. And if she wanted you, it doesn't matter where you were in the school, she would send someone to find you and bring you to her. So you were never quite free of her. And then she became principal of the actual school. So that was a whole messy fiasco where she literally kicked off the other principal and proved that she was better to do that job. And once she became principal of the school, there was no stopping her. I went through year twelve and that's when there was serious abuse happening already.
30:32 Speaker 01 And she was just everyone's favourite, like she groomed a community, she groomed the teachers, she groomed all the students. It was Mrs. Lifa this and Mrs. Lifa that. It was, there will always be a couple that said, oh no, they thought she wasn't so great. And I can understand that. But for everyone else, I would say she groomed majority of the community with her actions, her behaviours, where she was, her visibility was always there with all the functions and events that were happening. And I was definitely one of her favourites.
30:59 Speaker 00 Yeah.
30:59 Speaker 01 And she'd pull me out of class, she would lock her door, she would pull down the blinds and then she would abuse for an hour and then send back to class. She would be red faced, I would be red faced and no one blinked because you wouldn't even for a second think that's what she's doing. So, and it wasn't just me, it was allegedly many other students as well. And it's kind of, you got to know which students she took privately because you just notice, if you're one, you notice who else is being pulled in. And then I went to first year teaching. She was very, very proud. She has six girls going from year twelve.
31:31 Speaker 00 Yeah.
31:31 Speaker 01 Right into the school the next year. This is the product of why she's become head of the school. It was a huge moment for her. We took over the school, three, four, five, six, seven, eight. We were like amazing powerhouses of teachers. We had teacher training.
31:42 Speaker 00 Yeah.
31:43 Speaker 01 We taught the Jewish studies, so we weren't qualified to teach general studies. They had the qualified teachers for that. But we did a really good job. I mean, I love teaching. I was passionate and I loved every minute of it. I had this life that I loved of teaching and I respected her knowledge and everything. And this is what was brought up to me in court. Here you are writing Michaela Leifer thank you letters for helping you and at the same time, you're saying you're being abused. And I was like, that was two different lives. The abuse was a whole life of its own that was happening, completely disconnected from that. I was giving my, everything to my job and then even disconnected to that, the abuse that was going on at home. It was like I was, my whole life was my teaching and she completely invaded every part of that.
32:21 Speaker 01 And the big shame of the whole case is that no one, all the witnesses in the school, no one came forward and said, I saw this or I saw that, even retrospectively. And that's what is very deeply hurtful and upsetting because they were witnesses, they didn't know they were witnesses at the time. But over the years, had so many opportunities to come forward and say, yes, we saw this. And I saw Nicole being pulled out of class by Michaela Leifer as soon as the bell rang when her class finished. And that did happen. And I saw this person in camp in a room with her alone. I saw that person. There were witnesses that did see things, even if they didn't quite know what they were seeing at the time.
33:00 Speaker 01 And then I taught year one of teaching, absolutely loved it. Year two, in the second year of teaching, I actually got engaged. And I will say this because I want to explain the level of her control. I got engaged to the son of the person she kicked off the principal.
33:15 Speaker 00 Right.
33:16 Speaker 01 She broke that engagement.
33:18 Speaker 00 She had that.
33:19 Speaker 01 She was the cause, yes. She managed to convince my mother that he's not appropriate for X, Y, Z. She even pulled in another prestigious woman who happened to be visiting from overseas and helping with the school at that time. Got her to sit down and talk to me. I was given a phone and told, call the boy and tell them you're not getting married in five weeks.
33:36 Speaker 00 That's horrible control.
33:38 Speaker 01 That is the level and I, and I was given a whole paper of all the sins he did, poor thing, that he didn't do. There were no sins and I had to read that to him and that was it.
33:48 Speaker 00 I, I'm speculating here, but the, the motive for that, whether it's jealousy or whether she's concerned that someone that she's made an enemy to and things might pass between you and him and it might lead to her being discovered.
34:02 Speaker 01 Correct.
34:02 Speaker 00 So she's moving all these things around just to cover up her actions and just take you back to a, a, a couple of things you said there where people had seen things or, yeah, you both go of students taken out of, uh, out of class and in an office and comes out red faced and the, the principal's red faced. These are red flags, aren't they? These should be warning signs and I, I think the days are gone where people can just say, oh, well, you know, I, I wasn't sure, so I didn't report it. What do you say to those people that, uh, have seen that, that, uh, suspect something's going on that didn't speak out?
34:37 Speaker 01 I will say to anyone that is in any educational position or anywhere really, if you sense something, go and talk to someone about it. Don't hold it to yourself because the damage that you can be causing by your silence is more harmful than you can imagine. Red flags are there, they're non-verbal, they do happen and we see with abuse cases coming out like the childcare centres.
34:57 Speaker 00 Yeah.
34:57 Speaker 01 And how many people have said, oh, they saw this or they wrote this or they said this. We do, as humans, we do notice things. Sometimes we don't, but when we do, act on it. Talk to someone, talk to your superior, talk to a friend and ask advice and then decide together what's the best course of action. But don't, don't just keep it to yourself because that is what is most damaging.
35:15 Speaker 00 Yeah. The, uh, the, the role that she created and the way that you've described her, she sounds like a larger than life character. And I, I'm just, it's annoying me that the thought of it, cause I can imagine the type of person you're talking about, the chaotic and oh, she's always touchy, handy, handy on, on kids, but that's just her, that's the way they cover, cover their actions. Isn't it?
35:37 Speaker 01 Yes, and she ran the school so chaotically, but somehow it worked. She would literally be giving me material right before a lesson that she asked me to substitute, five minutes before, and then race into class and teach. And then she would be working out timetables middle of the night and call me and ask her to help with that, or writing newsletters, or ask me to help with policy and the legal stuff that she had to fill out, or the admin stuff, and I would help her with that. So I was really her, I would say her assistant in a way, with the amount of work and help that I did for her in every possible way. But that was also her involvement in my life in every possible way.
36:07 Speaker 00 The, you use the word coercive and there's legislation that's come into a lot of states around the country with relationships where people are in relationships and the need for that coercive control and the police to have those powers. What you're describing there, sort of ticks the boxes, it's coercive control. It's not in a domestic relationship, but it's coercive control in, in the environment you were working. Would you agree with that?
36:30 Speaker 01 Absolutely, because there was no decision and no movement that I made without her saying it was okay, or without knowing she would have an opinion about it after. And even when I got married, there was a time she couldn't get hold of me on my phone. She stalked me to find where I was, where she thought I was. Now, I happened to be somewhere private that I didn't want her to know where I was that moment. And she came careening around the corner with someone that drove another victim of hers. And as I walked out that building, she saw where I was, she was satisfied. I should have not had my phone not available to be telling her where I was.
37:04 Speaker 00 Did you ever have any conversations with her about, um, yeah, I'm uncomfortable with this? Or was that just sort of, it was an area you just couldn't go?
37:14 Speaker 01 Absolutely none. It was no, there was no possibility to say no. One time in the whole seven years that I knew her, I had a little bit of backbone. I wanted to go and work somewhere else other than the school I was working in to earn more money, to have an opportunity to work in a different Jewish school. She shut that down so fast.
37:32 Speaker 00 Hmm.
37:33 Speaker 01 And then to punish me, she took away a secretarial job that I did have in the school I was working in and gave it to some new person that had come in from overseas.
37:39 Speaker 00 Yeah.
37:40 Speaker 01 As well to curry favour because her father was on the board. So it was all, you know, complex in that way. And I just knew I won't, I won't even try and cross her because that was the financial impact of if I did.
37:51 Speaker 00 How did she have the um uh standing within the school? Like, what, what's, she came over, what year did you say she, she came?
37:59 Speaker 01 Two thousand one.
38:00 Speaker 00 To teach. And then she was there until two thousand eight and rose to be the principal of the school. What, what was her backstory before she came, came across to the school?
38:10 Speaker 01 She was teaching before she came to Australia. She had a lot of knowledge. She probably had some degrees and stuff that she did when she finished school. And she was very religious. So she looked the part.
38:22 Speaker 00 Yeah.
38:22 Speaker 01 But she definitely wasn't the part at all. So she looked like someone that had good values, good attributes. And was a respectful person of the faith and the religion and would inspire, would inspire the students under her care to be more connected to God and religion through their, through her actions and the things that she's doing with them, the learning programs. And they were all, all those programs were amazing. It's just it was all covering up as well. A lot of what she was trying to get away with underneath because deeply underneath she was evil. She was not what she was portraying to the community and the school. So she earned the respect by her actions and her knowledge and her wisdom in the Jewish religion and all the textual stuff that she knew, but in everything else.
39:05 Speaker 00 And the hypocrisy of it too.
39:07 Speaker 01 Yes.
39:08 Speaker 00 Yeah, saying this is the values I'm following and being completely opposite. Is there any suggestion that, I'm, I'm speculating here, but any suggestion that there was any rumours about her or any knowledge of this type of behaviour before she came to Australia?
39:24 Speaker 01 Only after stuff came out here, yes. Some of her former alleged victims overseas did contact a reporter, but the statute of limitations were over.
39:33 Speaker 00 Right.
39:33 Speaker 01 So it wasn't something they were willing to come forward because it was such, caused such an uproar, you know, upheaval to their lives. And if they can't do anything with information, they don't just want to give their story.
39:42 Speaker 00 Yeah.
39:42 Speaker 01 But they did affirm that that was the case.
39:44 Speaker 00 Okay. Um, your sisters, the, the offenses that occurred against your sisters and the type of grooming. Uh, can you talk about, are you comfortable just talking about what, what they went through as well?
39:56 Speaker 01 So I'm not entirely sure.
39:58 Speaker 00 Yeah.
39:58 Speaker 01 Because even though we are allowed to read each other's statements now and we have seen the charges that came out, that's pretty much all that I know.
40:04 Speaker 00 Okay.
40:04 Speaker 01 We actually haven't sat down together because there was so much going on through the trial, which was nine weeks, including deliberation. We haven't had time to sit together and actually debrief.
40:14 Speaker 00 Yeah.
40:14 Speaker 01 And that's something that we might be able to have the strength or the energy to do one day.
40:18 Speaker 00 Yeah.
40:18 Speaker 01 But I do know that whatever abuse happened to me, happened to them and allegedly to many others.
40:23 Speaker 00 I I would imagine then this would have made it difficult that when the matters were reported to the police, you would have been instructed not to talk to each other about their offences in protect the potential contamination.
40:36 Speaker 01 Yes.
40:36 Speaker 00 Of the the evidence.
40:37 Speaker 01 Yes.
40:38 Speaker 00 From an emotional point of view, without talking about the the evidence, you must have been aware that your sisters had, um, yeah, made complaints as well. How difficult was, again, being isolated from being able to speak to, um, people that you're close to, your sisters that have been through similar experiences?
40:56 Speaker 01 I think the shame was so great at that time and the disconnect from the actual abuse. It was like done, dusted, gave the statement, okay, I need her to come back. It wasn't, we grew closer and closer over the years, but Lifa wasn't the centre of that.
41:09 Speaker 00 Okay.
41:09 Speaker 01 Our campaigning made us absolutely impossibly close because we were so closely working together to bring her back. But we knew, like you said, and we all knew from very early on, that the topic of the abuse and any acts or anything like that could never be discussed.
41:22 Speaker 00 Yeah.
41:23 Speaker 01 So it literally was only what we witnessed of each other during those years. So my younger sister witnessed my second sister being taken to a different room. And like I said, the camp situation and things like that.
41:33 Speaker 00 The process for the extradition, how, when you've made the report to the police, um, I know the people, when they report to the police, quite often they think, well, that's the first step and I'm going to get justice. You touched on it a little bit earlier on, you had no idea how long the process would take. Tell us through what was going through in your life, why that was going on and the type of information you were receiving. Cause it was, you said three years, but by the time she came back to Australia, it was something like 12 years?
42:04 Speaker 01 Yes, yes. It was three years until her first arrest.
42:07 Speaker 00 Okay, so the the process was warrants had to be taken out and she got arrested over over in Israel. You would have been notified of that?
42:15 Speaker 01 So I.
42:17 Speaker 01 I was working in a new school, so I actually had left the school that I was abused in and went to work in a new school. And it was just early on in that year that all of a sudden I got this phone call from a reporter that Malka Leifer was arrested. And my sisters were holidaying away and they weren't even in Melbourne. And I'm frantically trying to call them and say, guys, Malka Leifer's been arrested like this. It was huge. It gave me, it was such a shock, but it was also like, why did it happen? No, no one warned us.
42:40 Speaker 00 Yeah.
42:41 Speaker 01 Like, did papers suddenly land on someone's desk and they're like, oh, right, we're gonna go and arrest her? Was it in relation to the fact that there were some civil cases going on? So suddenly it sparked a memory, oh, okay, we should go and arrest her. Like, I still don't know what caused that first arrest. And then we had some, a little bit of contact from the prosecutors there in Israel, but very shortly after she was arrested and charged and all that, she was released on bail. And that was the one mistake that the prosecution team admits to. Because they weren't in contact with us enough yet to know that we would not want that to happen, that we know what she's like. And that if she escaped Australia, she's definitely going to try and escape anything there to come back. And they released her on bail. And that was a huge pivotal moment.
43:22 Speaker 00 And, and did you feel like you'd been let down with, with that? Like, when, when you, you've, you've come out, you've done the statement, you're doing everything that, yeah, we say you should do in a situation like that. Did you feel like the system had let you down?
43:36 Speaker 01 I didn't know enough and my sisters didn't either at that time to still not trust in the system. Okay, she was on bail. She'll go to her house. She won't be allowed to leave. She'll turn up to court to the next court date. And she will have to say that she is or isn't, you know, able to come to Australia. There was no indication that this still would not work and she would be back within six months.
43:55 Speaker 00 Right. So that's the expectation you had.
43:58 Speaker 01 Yes.
43:58 Speaker 00 Even, even though she had been granted bail. Um, so why did it take so long?
44:04 Speaker 01 That's when the game started.
44:06 Speaker 00 Yep.
44:06 Speaker 01 Once she got bailed, there were probably around seventy or more court hearings around her mental fitness to stand trial.
44:14 Speaker 00 Right.
44:15 Speaker 01 And even a judge over there, which is mind boggling, reported, like, he stated that Malka Leifer checks herself into a psych ward the day before court hearing
44:24 Speaker 00 Yeah.
44:25 Speaker 01 and checks herself out the day after.
44:29 Speaker 01 He stated that at one point, we had the prosecution team saying, we will go to hospital with the court to her. That didn't happen. And then it was just a game of psychiatrists after psychiatrists saying that she's not mentally well to stand trial. Now, if she's not mentally fit, she can't be extradited. And that is their decision to make. So then that's where my sisters and I, and my sister Dussey started first to campaign and start speaking to leaders in Australia and saying, hang on, what's happening here? We've got to start putting pressure because if we don't, she's going to keep playing the system. Again, not knowing how extensive we would have to fight and how big the fight would be to actually bring her back.
45:10 Speaker 00 It's, I'm just, I'm, I'm sitting here stunned because I'm, I'm hearing your story, but what you've been, been through and then the battles. Break down the fight. I, I think I've got a, a quote here from the A B C about the extradition. And it was from a, a liberal M P, Mr. Southwick, Southwick. And this is two thousand seventeen. So this is years down the track. And in two thousand seventeen, the liberal M P brought a petition with seventeen thousand signatures calling for the extradition of Leifer to Israel politicians. But Mr. Southwick said, members of the community from all sides of politics had joined together to support
45:51 Speaker 00 the sisters. Doesn't matter who you are and where you come from. When you see the pain and suffering that innocent women have had to go through from a perpetrator like Malka Leifer, then you do everything possible you can to bring, uh, bring that person to justice. It was, it became political. You had to, like, signatures. I'm, I'm asking you from a, a personal point of view. How, how did that affect you personally?
46:18 Speaker 01 We were on a roller coaster that was going so fast. And when it dipped, it was so painful. But then it went so fast up again. Every single court hearing, we had people in Israel, in the courts, live texting us. We had a whole group chat of reporters and everyone that was present, telling us what's going on. Because of course, it was all in a different language that we couldn't even understand, even if we could log in, which we couldn't most of the time. And so we would need translators. And we, my sisters and I just sat down and I was two thousand and Seventeen, I stopped working for the first time in my life. I had been working from eighteen years old, post all my pregnancies, right back to work right after. I didn't have any long maternity leave, and I stopped working in two thousand and seventeen to be able to
47:00 Speaker 01 campaign and advocate and haven't gone back to teaching since then. And it was a huge moment, but I don't even understand how big that was. And I stepped out, and that's when I kind of became public and joined my sisters. And we are like, we are going to actually go overseas. From our own resources, our own limited money, no one funded us, no one told us what to do. We didn't have a publicist. Everything was completely our own organising. And we hopped on a plane and went to Israel, October two thousand seventeen or November. And we started, we went to Rape Crisis Centres, we went to the Knesset, and we met with politicians who didn't want to talk to us because it's an uncomfortable topic, but we we imposed and made sure they did. And we had someone in there helping us to get into some politicians. We attended events, there was some big event happening
47:44 Speaker 01 then between Australia and Israel, so we attended that. Um, we sighed, kind of met the Prime Minister at the time. We we just did everything possible for two entire weeks, every day, all day, meeting people to raise awareness about this story. And we met the prosecution team.
48:01 Speaker 00 Yep.
48:01 Speaker 01 And we said to them, we think there's something more going on. There's some corruption happening. Something's happening in this case that's not adding up why she's not coming back.
48:10 Speaker 00 Yeah.
48:11 Speaker 01 And the prosecutor looked at us and he said, if something's happening, like if someone's corrupt, I'll eat my hat.
48:17 Speaker 00 Yep.
48:18 Speaker 01 And then a year later, when we went, and by then we all found out that the Health Minister was involved in asking the psychiatrist to doctor her her mental health certificates.
48:28 Speaker 00 Right.
48:29 Speaker 01 He looked at us and he's like, I can't believe that happened. I I think to myself, if I was in a position of power and I was asked to help someone like that, I couldn't do it. It would go against my whole moral compass. Like, he was, we could see how visibly shocked he was that within a year, we had, because we went back on our second campaign trip a year later, and he understood that there was corruption going on.
48:53 Speaker 00 Yeah.
48:53 Speaker 01 That there was something much bigger.
48:55 Speaker 00 The prosecutor felt there were other forces.
48:58 Speaker 01 Well, we felt it, we raised it, they didn't want to believe it.
49:00 Speaker 00 Yeah.
49:01 Speaker 01 Then when we came a year later, by then the Litzman story had broken out.
49:04 Speaker 00 Yeah.
49:04 Speaker 01 And we found out that the Health Minister had been pressuring the psychiatrists who were treating Michael Leifer to say she was mentally unfit, based on their own sort of little dirt story there that was happening. And the psychiatrist said that she was unfit and she wasn't.
49:20 Speaker 00 How how frustrating was that for you guys?
49:24 Speaker 01 It was validating because we knew who we were talking to, but at the same time, it was horrible. How could someone in power, someone that we met the year before, who claimed he had no knowledge of what was going on with Michael Leifer? We met him in Parliament and then we find out that somehow he's involved in the corruption that's stopping her from coming back. I actually, and I can talk about this now because I'm not doing it, I was thinking of lodging a lawsuit against Slitsman. Because I didn't feel that the way that the criminal court dealt with him, a slap on the wrist and a little fine and you can't work in government anymore.
49:56 Speaker 00 This was dealt with, like it's come out publicly, what you're talking about?
49:59 Speaker 01 Yes, he received charges, some were dropped because I think he pled, it was obstruction of whatever, I don't know what exactly it was titled. He had got a fine and he was told he can't work in Parliament for seven years.
50:10 Speaker 00 Okay, so that that was prosecuted over in Israel.
50:12 Speaker 01 And that was minor compared to the incredible impact he had on myself and my sisters. Making the delay years longer than it should have been because of his involvement and corruption, which is now proven.
50:25 Speaker 00 Well, I'll I'll I'll join in with you now, but it's it's been in court and it's been been proven, that's disgraceful.
50:33 Speaker 01 Yes.
50:33 Speaker 00 Absolutely disgraceful. And this is a person that you had met the previous twelve months before with all the false promises and I'm gonna do this and.
50:40 Speaker 01 Well, he didn't say he would do anything, he just said he had no involvement in these kind of matters. He really shut us down, but also made it seem like he doesn't even know what we're talking about.
50:47 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
50:48 Speaker 01 Which is obviously not true.
50:50 Speaker 00 Okay, how did how did it get disproved that she wasn't fit to stand trial?
50:55 Speaker 01 Well, once the corruption came out and it hit national news, like all over Israel, that that propelled the story to the highest level. I mean, look, that's second in command, you can't actually, you can't push that down when someone's that powerful and that high up in government.
51:09 Speaker 00 Yep.
51:12 Speaker 01 Then my sisters and I went, decided we're actually going to keep going to court. We're going to let this judge see us and look at us in the face. And she cannot possibly see the three of us sitting in the back of a court. We did a third campaign trip.
51:24 Speaker 00 Yep.
51:24 Speaker 01 This time someone stepped up and actually funded our tickets, which was amazing.
51:27 Speaker 00 Well, that's, that's.
51:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, that was incredible, but we still paid accommodation and travel and everything and.
51:32 Speaker 00 And this taking time out of your life and everything else.
51:34 Speaker 01 And my kids and life and everything, and I've got four children. And we sat in the back of the courtroom and we looked at that judge like, remember you are dealing with victims here. Whoever, who are sitting here watching you do justice, give justice to the case. But it's for some reason, it seemed like she had to just keep asking for more. And then finally, in early twenty twenty, right before COVID hit, there was the most incredibly important court case. It was when three psychiatrists, three, who all said that she's fit to stand trial, were going to be cross-examined by the defence.
52:07 Speaker 00 Yep.
52:08 Speaker 01 And there was someone from Israel visiting here and we met him for coffee. He used to live in Australia and he came back, comes back twice a year. And he said, would you go? And I looked at my sisters and I was like, call my husband, I was like, I'm going to Israel in three days. And my husband was like, sure, because he's used to this already. And I hopped on a plane, tickets were crazy cheap. We didn't know COVID was going to be so bad, but it was like literally under fifteen hundred. I hopped on a plane by myself, no sisters, because they weren't available at that time. And I went and sat in court for two whole days in a language I didn't fully understand, but because it's my story, I could.
52:37 Speaker 00 Yeah.
52:37 Speaker 01 And I listened to every single word that was said and saw how those psychiatrists were put under the grill by the two defence lawyers, who we know who they were. We met them over all the time. And they did theatrics in the courtroom and they tried to discredit. One of the psychiatrists was a little bit unwell. She just wasn't feeling so good that morning, but she still gave, you know, she still did a good job. And after two whole days, I was like, okay, that's it.
52:58 Speaker 00 Yeah.
52:59 Speaker 01 We're waiting for a decision. And I went home, I was feeling very heavy. It was actually very hard to be without my sisters.
53:04 Speaker 00 Yeah.
53:05 Speaker 01 Like I sat in the apartment all day, so depressed, but not depressed because depressed, but just because it was so heavy and so. It was, everything was relying on this. We had waited years till to this, this point, to, to twenty twenty, to hear what this decision's going to be. It's been seventy five court hearings. And the next, I got home, spoke to my sisters, debriefed them and everything. And within a couple of months, I don't know the exact dates offhand, it came through that she's fit to be extradited. And that was like the penny drop. That was like, oh my goodness. Everything we fought for, everything, it is still for me personally, and I don't know about my sisters. When I look at the picture of her on an aeroplane, going up those steps and then landing on Australian soil. That can literally, still I am in shock at that picture.
53:49 Speaker 01 Because by that time, a lot of people were thinking, it's actually not going to happen. She's not going to come back. They could see the battle we were fighting and they could see and we had more and more support from the whole Australian community. But it just seemed that we were fighting the impossible.
54:04 Speaker 00 Yeah.
54:05 Speaker 01 And then it came through that she's fit to stand trial. The judge could not swing it any other way. It was not possible.
54:12 Speaker 00 For- force them basically into it. But what a battle for what you've been through and then have to battle just to get to the court. A court matter. And I, I do remember the image of her getting on the plane. It's an iconic sort of photo and you're just, yeah. It was, uh, it was so powerful seeing it when you're not involved in it. So I can only imagine what it felt like for you. You mentioned seventy five court matters. Is that how many?
54:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
54:39 Speaker 00 Times it appeared at court?
54:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's how many. And every single one we were involved in, every single one we had contact. Every single one we knew when it was adjourned, because there was adjournments that happened many times. Every single one we debriefed, we spoke to media before or after. We met with my sisters. I'll be on holiday, like summer, for a couple of days away with my kids. I'll drive back from Rye with my sister, sit in her house together, doing a court hearing. It didn't matter what was going on in our lives. We dropped everything to do this court hearing. And actually, we had prosecution teams in Israel and in Australia, look at us in the face and say, if you had not done what you had done, she would not be back.
55:12 Speaker 00 Well.
55:12 Speaker 01 So to have two teams saying that to us, we know that what we did is what caused her to be able to finally come back.
55:19 Speaker 00 Well, I, I was gonna make the comment because I, I see hard investigations that get results and invariably. It's, it's not the police, it's not the prosecutors, it's the family just driving, just driving and pushing and not, not giving up. And, uh, yeah, where, where did you, did you know you had that type of resilience? Or did that, it, it just, it came out because of the circumstances where? Where did you get that type of resilience? Because I could imagine there would have been times there where you just, it's it's too hard. Why am I focusing on that? And the focus on that, that's time away from your kids, your husband, your your professional career.
55:54 Speaker 01 I think once I gave my statement, and that was such a huge step out of anything in my life that I'd ever done, adverse to the way I was brought up and raised. There was this tiny flame of the need for justice.
56:06 Speaker 00 Yeah.
56:07 Speaker 01 And that just burned and got bigger and bigger and bigger over the years. It never ever went down for me personally. Absolutely did not. The justice, the thought of justice drove everything.
56:19 Speaker 00 Yeah.
56:20 Speaker 01 Absolutely everything.
56:23 Speaker 00 I'm exhausted from you had delivered. That's just to hear hearing the story.
56:27 Speaker 01 It was exhausting, I can tell you.
56:29 Speaker 00 I I'm I'm fascinated by the drive that victims have got to get get justice. And I I I fully understand it, but full credit to you that you got to that point. We're going to take a break now because it's still not over because then this is just the start of it. I often said in homicide or with investigations, it only starts when you get to the court. And we haven't even got to trial. This is just getting the person to trial. But we'll talk about that, the impact it's had on you. And of course, the fact that at the the trial, that the allegations that you made were, she was found not guilty for those, how that impacted on you. And we're going to discuss a lot of other things, lessons that you've learnt from here, and messages that you want to get out.
57:12 Speaker 00 Because I think it's such an important story to talk about, as we said at the start, that, you know, let's learn from from what's happened here. So it makes it harder for these type of, I was going to say so, these offences don't happen again. They will happen again, but let's make it harder for them to happen again.
57:29 Speaker 01 Absolutely.
57:29 Speaker 00 Have a short break.
57:30 Speaker 01 Thank you.
57:31 Speaker 00 Cheers.
Previous “I was going to die”: Kate DeAraugo Pt.2 Next “I turned my pain into power”: Nicole Meyer Pt.2 Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated