Pod Insights Human Capital Leadership The Impact of Employee-Ownership On Morale and Productivity, with Kelly Finnell About this episode In this podcast episode, Dr. Jonathan H. Westover talks with Kelly Finnell about the impact of employee-ownership on morale and productivity.
Kelly Finnell is a sought-after speaker and leading expert on Employee Stock Ownership Plans. He has spoken at more than 300 conferences and meetings throughout the U. S., London and Sydney, and he is a published author on using ESOPs in succession planning. A trusted resource to business owners and exit planners, Kelly is the author of The ESOP Coach: Using ESOPS in Ownership Succession Planning and the president of Memphis-based EFS ESOP Consultants. Kelly graduated magna cum laude from the University of Memphis and from its law school.
Check out all of the podcasts in the HCI Podcast Network!
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 0:03 Speaker 00 Welcome to the HCI family of podcasts. We're your source for personal, professional, and organizational growth and development. We share our own original research, explore industry trends, and interview executives and thought leaders from across the globe. Join us for practitioner-oriented content around all things leadership, HR, talent management, organizational development, and change management. Maximize your personal and organizational potential with the HCI family of podcasts.
0:35 Speaker 00 Kelly Fennell, welcome to the conversation today.
0:37 Speaker 01 Thanks. It's great to be with you, John.
0:39 Speaker 00 It's great to be with you. You're joining us from Memphis, Tennessee. I'm south of Salt Lake City in Utah. And today, we're going to be talking about the impact of employee ownership on morale and productivity, ESOPs, the like, and really how they can be leveraged within organizations. I love this topic. I think it's one that we don't explore and talk about enough. You know, it's really not the norm in a lot of organizations, honestly. And it's a really great untapped opportunity that we really should be thinking about and finding ways to incorporate more often in today's organization. So I'm excited to pick your brain and get your insights as we have this conversation. As we get started, I wanted
1:21 Speaker 00 to share Kelly's bio with everybody. Kelly Fennell is a sought-after speaker and leading expert on employee stock ownership plans. He has spoken at more than 300 conferences and meetings throughout the US, London, and Sydney. He is a published author on using ESOPs in succession planning. A trusted resource to business owners and exit planners, Kelly is the author of The ESOP Coach: Using ESOPs in Ownership Succession Planning, and the president of Memphis-based EFS ESOP Consultants. Kelly graduated magna cum laude from the University of Memphis and from its law school. There's a whole lot more I could highlight about Kelly and his background, but Kelly, I'm going to pause there. Anything you would like to share with the audience by way of your background or personal context before we dive on in?
2:06 Speaker 01 Well, maybe something that would be helpful is I have a little bit of Experience in this area. It still amazes me when I think about the fact that I've been doing this for forty four years now. It's been the sole focus of my business for the last fifteen years. And we're actually doing ESOPs all over the country. Last year, we did a transaction in Portland, Oregon, and in South Carolina, and at lots of places in between.
2:32 Speaker 00 Yeah, very cool. Forty four years. That's a good amount of time doing a lot of, a lot of good work. So congratulations to you on a long, successful career. That's awesome. Okay, as we dive on in, let's, let's start by just defining things. You know, probably a lot of the audience is familiar with employee stock ownership plans, but can you spend just a little bit of time explaining what these are? And how they differ from other employee benefit plans?
3:05 Speaker 01 Absolutely. An ESOP is really two things in one. For a business owner, an ESOP is an alternative to selling to private equity or to a strategic buyer. So an ESOP gives a business owner a way to cash in on their life's work by selling to their employees using the ESOP trust as a conduit for that transaction. And the reason people use it as a conduit is because of the many tax benefits that are offered by ESOPs. But we'll come back to that subject. And so for the employees, an ESOP is a retirement plan. So it's a first cousin to a 401k plan.
3:46 Speaker 01 But there are three key differences between an ESOP and a 401k plan that allow it to serve that dual purpose of being a liquidity strategy for the business owner and a retirement plan for the employees. So those three key differences are that an ESOP can borrow money. And no other type of retirement plan is allowed to do that. It would be illegal for a 401k plan to borrow money. The second difference is that an ESOP can engage in certain transactions with parties in interest. And the third difference is that an ESOP is required to invest primarily. In the stock of the sponsoring employer. So when you put those things together and ESOP is a retirement plan, it can borrow money.
4:27 Speaker 01 And so it borrows money from a bank and also from the selling shareholder in the form of what we call a seller note, a promissory note. The second key difference is that it can engage in certain transactions with parties and interests. So the ESOP uses those two sources of capital, those loans, to buy stock from often a company's founder, the existing shareholder. And then the third key difference is that it, the, the stock that's purchased becomes an asset in the employee's retirement account. So unlike a 401k plan where you have a family of mutual funds to select as an employee to invest in.
5:10 Speaker 01 With an ESOP, you don't have to make an investment decision because the stock of the company is going to be often the sole asset in your ESOP retirement plan account.
5:20 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's awesome. Thank you for that explanation. You know, what I'm suspecting some are thinking is, well, isn't there some risk in not diversifying? You know, with, with this kind of a plan?
5:32 Speaker 01 Absolutely. There are risks. And so one of the most fundamental theories of investing is that you want to have a diversified portfolio. And an ESOP is the ultimate concentrated investment program because typically the only investment of the plan is the company's stock. So what do you do about that? The answer is almost all of our clients, when they adopt an ESOP, they at the same time continue the 401k plan. So that we have a balance. We have a diversified retirement plan for the employees in the form of the 401k plan. But then we also have this concentrated investment in the ESOP.
6:13 Speaker 00 Yeah, and I think that's really important. You know, I think about it as other forms of investment and other forms of like company ownership that you might choose to be involved in. And you're still going to have your more traditional diverse. Retirement plans in place. You really need to, right?
6:35 Speaker 01 Absolutely.
6:36 Speaker 00 Because, because, yeah, just like if I were to start my own business, there's lots of risk in that. If I were to, you know, buy into some other business or buy stock, you know, heavily into another business. Same thing, like you could always have a lot of risk in that. But there's, there's tons of potential benefits. So let's talk about that. Let's talk about, you know, what ESOPs can do for the business. Like if, if someone's about to exit and owner is, is looking towards succession planning and exiting, and they, they turn towards ESOPs, like what, what can that do for the organization in terms of culture? In terms of, you know, just the, the ownership mindset for the other employees?
7:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, culture is a key concept involved in most of our clients that are interested in doing an ESOP. So many times we'll have a business owner tell us that the key to the company's success is the culture that they've created and nurtured. And a wise business owner knows that if they sell to a third party, that third party might tell them that nothing's going to change. But the reality of it is, if they've bought the business, they're going to make the decisions and the target's culture is going to become the culture of the acquire. And so wise business owners know that fact. And so if a business owner wants to be sure that culture is going to be maintained
7:57 Speaker 01 and enhanced after their liquidity event, they can use an ESOP for that purpose. Because the people that control the company before the transaction are going to be the people that control it afterwards. And because of that, they're going to be able to maintain the culture. And because the employees are now going to have in their retirement plan account, company stock, it's actually going to not only protect, but also enhance culture. Because now they're going to be the beneficiaries of the company's growth. The business owner is going to cash in and then in the future, the employees are going to cash in. So all of the employees are in the same boat, rowing in the same direction to make the company as profitable.
8:40 Speaker 01 As possible, so that when they have a retirement or other distributable event, they get the maximum amount of money.
8:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think one of the the really great, cool things about this kind of an approach is, you know, maintaining the culture that you have, as you mentioned, you know, that's as a really excellent benefit. Just, just, you know, the idea of me working in an organization where I know that I have control over the success of the organization, that I'm part owner of that organization, I'm going to reap the benefits of ownership of that organization, that collectively, we're all in it together towards the success of this organization. Like, there's just something different about that, you know, than being just like one of a bunch of employees.
9:27 Speaker 00 And, you know, what often happens in many organizations is just kind of sometimes an us versus them mentality between employees and management and, you know, some of those types of things, right? And, but one of the cool things about different forms of employee ownership approaches within organizations, and ESOPs is one of them, is is that you start to break that down because everyone is in it together, right? Everyone is part owner, everyone wants to see the the organization succeed, and whether you're a C-suite exec or you're, you know, whoever, you know, kind of lower rung employee, you all are part owners and you all have an invested interest.
10:08 Speaker 00 And, and, you know, it it's just a different thing, like it's it's it. So when you talk about culture, yes, you get to maintain the the the existing culture, but there's a a different level of buy-in, you know, to to the culture and the success of the organization than I think that you're typically typically going to get in just kind of the run-of-the-mill types of employees that you typically have in, you know, the average organization, right?
10:36 Speaker 01 Yep, that's exactly right. And that is not just theoretical. That has been proven out over and over again. One of the favorite topics of people who are getting a PhD in management is to Study employee ownership and the impact that it has on productivity and the profitability of a company. So there are literally dozens of dissertations that have been written on this subject. That quantitatively prove the theoretical assumption that you would make that. When employees become partners, the companies fare better. And so that is now a provable fact.
11:17 Speaker 00 Yeah, which which is super cool and it's it's always fun when you can put some data behind it. But you know, it also just theoretically makes common sense, right? Like anyone just sitting here listening to it is like, well, duh, of course. And and now we have data to go behind it to support it. And so lots of benefits for the for the. The business owner who's selling, who's who's exiting, who you know, thinking about succession planning. Lots of benefits for the organization as a whole, lots of benefits for the employees. Who who are able to buy in, you know, as a secondary option towards, you know, their own investing in retirement. You know, I I also just think as an employee, how cool is it for me to to be able to have a piece of the business?
12:01 Speaker 00 You know, like to just be able to have this option to be able to buy into it. Like, I just think that's cool. To to have that option and that's not something that everyone gets. And in fact, it's it's fairly rare.
12:12 Speaker 01 And the great thing is that the buy in, the cost of. Employee ownership is borne by the company, not by the employees. So with a 401k plan, another key difference between. It in an ESOP is with a 401k plan, employees contribute their own money and often get a match. With an ESOP, there are no employee contributions. The company funds the entire thing with a big helping hand from Uncle Sam. So I'd mentioned earlier that there are great tax benefits associated with. In ESOP and one of the key benefits is that if you have a 100% ESOP owned S corporation. And now about 80% of the new ESOP transactions that are done are for 100% ESOP owned.
13:00 Speaker 01 S corporations. And if you have that situation, then after the transaction, the company operates tax free. So we can have a for profit business that's taxed like a church or a synagogue. No tax on the company's income at the company level because it's a flow through entity. It's an S corp. And no tax at the shareholder level because our only shareholder is going to be the ESOP trustee. And like a 401k plan trustee, the ESOP trustee is tax exempt. So many people realize that at the end of the year, they get financial reporting on all of their investment accounts except one. And that's their 401k account. You don't get tax reporting on that.
13:43 Speaker 01 That grows on a tax deferred basis. And the reason is employees don't own their 401k account. They assume that they do, but legally they don't. That account is owned for their benefit by the 401k trustee and they don't get tax reporting because that trustee is tax exempt. So the same thing with an ESOP. And so Uncle Sam is going to provide a 40% tax subsidy for the company to share ownership with its employees because Congress feels that that is a very worthy goal.
14:18 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, all those tax benefits are pretty cool.
14:22 Speaker 01 Yes, absolutely.
14:23 Speaker 00 As you mentioned, um, let's talk about some of the best practices around fostering a positive ownership culture within a company. So let's say we're, we're going about this prac, this pop, this process of establishing an ESOP. We decide, yeah, this is a good idea. We're going to do it. We're going to set this up. Let's talk about some of the best practices.
14:46 Speaker 01 Well, employees are only going to appreciate the ESOP to the extent that they understand it. And so having a robust communication process is critical for ESOP companies and is a very necessary best practice. So what we often see is our clients will provide a very brief quarterly.
15:10 Speaker 01 One-page newsletter to their employees. It's often just sent electronically, no paper. And it reminds the employees that first, they're owners of the company and that their ultimate benefit is going to be dependent upon the success of the company. And then we often break down one of the rules or regulations that are involved in the ESOP. So that they can begin to understand the plan better. So we do that quarterly. And then we always have an annual meeting where we talk to them about the plan, answer their questions. And at the end of the meeting, distribute their annual statement. It shows how much stock was in their account at the beginning of the year, how much was contributed during the year,
15:54 Speaker 01 how much is in their account at the end of the year, and the value per share and the total value of their account. And so that dynamic of constantly communicating and reinforcing the benefit of the ESOP is a critical best practice.
16:10 Speaker 00 Yeah, and I mean frankly, organizations need to do a better job. I mean, almost all organizations need to do a better job of explaining benefits to their employees, regardless of what benefits we're talking about.
16:20 Speaker 01 Yes.
16:21 Speaker 00 And so that's, that's a challenge and a problem for most organizations that I've seen. And so especially if you're talking about something like this, that's less common, not as many people are familiar with. You're going to have to really go out of your way to over communicate it. If, if people are going to even really understand and be aware of the implications. And if you're going to leverage the, the motivational value of it, if you're going to be able to leverage the cultural value of it, you're going to have to go out of your way to over communicate it. So I appreciate you highlighting that. I, I don't think it can be overstated.
16:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I think, and I think you make an excellent point, John, about companies not communicating their benefits effectively. And so what we encourage clients to do is to have a benefits afternoon once a year. And so they have someone coming in, talk about their health and welfare plan and the ESOP and their 401K.
17:20 Speaker 01 All in one afternoon so that the employees can understand that, you know, the company often is spending thirty percent of the employees' compensation in addition to their salary and bonus to provide these very valuable benefits to them.
17:36 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, absolutely. So let's, let's double down, make sure that we're really committed to openness, transparency, open communication, leverage the benefits of that motivation, the morale, the, the culture components that are huge, you know, research-backed benefits of, of, of doing employee stock ownership plans. Um, you know, if, if not, we're missing out, right? We're, we're just not
18:02 Speaker 01 Absolutely.
18:03 Speaker 00 leveraging, uh, those, those benefits. Well, where, where can people go to find out more about this? Again, I think a lot of people probably might, you know, they might be vaguely aware, kind of understand, but, you know, for many, this conversation might be one of the first times they've really heard more about it. So where can people go to find out more?
18:22 Speaker 01 Well, you can go to some websites. So our website has a wealth of just educational information. That is www.exefin, E X E C F I N dot com. Then, like every industry, we have industry associations. And so you can go to the industry association websites. The two of them are N C E O, National Center for Employee Ownership dot org. And the other one is T E A, the ESOP Association dot org. And so you can get lots of educational information there. You also can order my book, uh, which is available on Amazon.
19:04 Speaker 01 And is the only book on the market that is written for business owners about ESOP. So it explains what an ESOP is in common language and has half a dozen case studies because I think business owners oftentimes learn best from stories. And so these are Actual client case studies where the names have been changed.
19:23 Speaker 00 Awesome, awesome. Well, this has just been a fantastic conversation. I know at the time I'm gonna have to let you go here in a minute, but before we wrap things up for today, I wanted to give you a chance to share with the audience how they can connect with you, find out more about your work and team, and then give us the final word for today.
19:40 Speaker 01 Well, you can go to our website and find my email address there, which is [email protected] . So K F I N at E X E C dot com. You'll also find our phone numbers there, me and my partner. And so you're welcome to contact us either by email or by phone.
20:03 Speaker 00 Awesome, awesome. Thank you so much, Kelly. It's been a real pleasure. I encourage the audience to reach out, to get connected, find out more about what Kelly and his team can do for you. And as always, I hope everyone can stay healthy and safe, that you can find meaning and purpose at work each and every day. And I hope you all have a great week.
20:24 Speaker 00 Thanks for joining us for this episode of the podcast. We hope you stay healthy and safe, and please join us again soon.
Previous Life Lessons in Courage, Integrity, and Leadership, with Robert Dilenschneider Next The DNA of a Leader, with Wendi Swanson Page updated November 7, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated