Why cocoa farmers are abandoning chocolate

In today’s episode on 11th March, we explain why cocoa farmers in Ghana and Ivory coast are abandoning cocoa farming. Book a FREE call with Ditto https://ditto.sh/vx51ji

• 0:00Speaker 00

  Hello folks, you're tuned to Indian Shots Daily. In today's episode, we explain why cocoa farmers in Ghana and Ivory Coast are abandoning cocoa farming.

• 0:11Speaker 00

  Before we begin, here's a quick word from Team Ditto. Life has a way of surprising us and not always in a good way. Sometimes, it's a sudden illness or an unexpected hospital visit that can shake up everything. In India, families still pay about 39% of medical expenses directly from their own pockets and just one hospital stick and wipe out years of savings. The easiest way to protect yourself is by getting a good health insurance plan. It's way cheaper than footing one huge bill. And if you're unaware where to start, book a free call with Ditto. No spam, just honest, jargon-free guidance. Trusted by over 8 lakh people for their health and term insurance needs. The link is in the description. Now, back to the story.

• 0:53Speaker 00

  If you've ever looked closely at a chocolate bar wrapper, not the shiny packaging and design, but the back where the truth sits in fine print, you may have noticed something common. The bar has either become smaller, more expensive, or both. But here's a little secret. The main ingredient behind chocolate, that is cocoa, is actually getting cheaper. Yep, that's right. Two years ago, chocolate prices went on a wild ride. After raw cocoa prices ranged between $2,000 to $3,000 a ton, they suddenly shot up to an eye-watering $10,000 a ton. That was in 2024. Back then, the spike had a lot to do with El Nino, the warm-climate pattern that severely affected harvests. So much so that we expected to see a chocolate deficit never seen before.

• 1:36Speaker 00

  But today, that's all changed and cocoa prices have come down to more realistic levels. Now, that might make you think that maybe people simply stopped eating chocolate, but that's hardly true. The demand for chocolate hasn't vanished. It's just that cocoa became too expensive, especially after the ordeal of 2024. As prices surged, chocolate manufacturers like Mandela's International and Nestle responded by raising prices, shrinking portions, and in some cases, reformulating products to use less cocoa. Nestle even altered the recipe of some bars so they no longer met the legal definition of chocolate after cocoa cost spiked. And all of that meant companies started buying less cocoa beans. But here's the thing, while chocolate companies could tweak recipes and raise prices, the people growing cocoa had far fewer options.

• 2:20Speaker 00

  In Ghana and Ivory Coast, which together produce roughly two thirds of the world's cocoa, many farmers are now grappling with the failing incomes and unsold beans. And that's surprising because cocoa prices had surged not too long ago. So you'd expect farmers to have benefited from that boom, but most of them didn't. Even when global prices shot up, farmers saw only a small slice of that increase. On the contrary, now that prices are cooling again, the economics of cocoa farming look far worse for them. In some regions, yields are already falling due to aging trees, crop disease and climate stress. And the income farmers earn from cocoa represents only a tiny fraction of the value created in the global chocolate industry, which raises an obvious question. When cocoa prices fall, farmers struggle, but how can they still struggle when cocoa prices surge?

• 3:05Speaker 00

  The answer lies on how the cocoa market itself works. Unlike most commodities, farmers in Ghana don't sell their crop directly at global market prices. Instead, cocoa is sold through the Ghana Cocoa Board. The goal is to protect farmers from wild commodity price swings, but it also means that farmers don't immediately benefit when global prices suddenly surge. So when cocoa prices exploded in 2024, farmers saw only gradual increases in the price they were paid. That's far below the global market spike. That's because cocoa prices for farmers are fixed ahead of the harvest season. There are two harvest cycles in West Africa. The main crop between October and March and a smaller mid-crop from April to September. Before the season begins in October, the government announces the farm gate prize that farmers will receive for their beans.

• 3:50Speaker 00

  That means farmers know exactly how much they'll earn per tonne, regardless of what happens in the global commodity markets. For example, last October, Ivory Coast set the farm gate prize at about $5,000 per tonne, while Ghana set it around $5,300 per tonne. But right now, world cocoa futures, that's basically the market price traders expect cocoa to sell for, well, they're trading at around $3,300 per tonne, a far cry from what the bot set just five months ago. And that's where the paradox. The system is designed to protect farmers from volatile cocoa prices. But when market conditions shift suddenly, it can create the opposite problem. If global cocoa prices fall or demand weakens, exporters and processors may hesitate to buy beans at the government's set price.

• 4:35Speaker 00

  In fact, ICCO, that's the International Cocoa Organisation, recently estimated the global cocoa market could swing into a surplus of about forty-nine thousand tonnes this very season. That simply tells you that the world suddenly has tens of thousands of tonnes more cocoa than chocolate makers currently want to buy. And when cocoa piles up, the shock travels all the way back to the farm. Because cocoa farming is a slow business. Trees take years to mature, harvests happen only twice a year, and incomes fluctuate wildly with global markets. So when the economics stop working, farmers start looking for alternatives, and no, it isn't other crops. In parts of West Africa, those alternatives are increasingly found underground, quite literally.

• 5:15Speaker 00

  Across regions of Ghana, cocoa farms are being leased out for illegal sand mining to feed the construction boom, while others are being converted into small-scale gold mining sites, often through illegal operations locally known as galamsi. Because mining offers something cocoa farming rarely does: quick cash. A cocoa harvest might bring income once or twice a year. Mining, on the other hand, can generate money almost immediately. But mining comes with a heavy cost. The excavation process damages soil, contaminates water sources with chemicals like mercury, and often leaves farmland unusable for agriculture. And once a cocoa farm becomes a mining site, it's rarely restored to productive farmland again. Governments know exactly what they're up against.

• 5:55Speaker 00

  Cocoa remains a critical export for West Africa, contributing nearly forty percent of export revenues in Ivory Coast and about fifteen percent in Ghana. So, when farmers abandon cocoa for illegal mining, the stakes extend far beyond the farms. In Ghana, authorities recently moved to stabilise the sector by announcing a three-hundred-and-thirty-seven million dollars payment to LBCs, that's licensed buying companies, to clear outstanding due spending since November twenty-twenty-five, and support growers struggling with volatile prices. According to the LBCs, the funds haven't been released yet, and because of that, farmers are yet to receive their dues. But payments like these are more of a short-term relief measure than a long-term solution. They also slashed the farm gate prices to $3,058 last month, hoping to grow demand.

• 6:39Speaker 00

  But that also means farmers have to accept lower prices on already thin margins. Because as long as cocoa farming remains financially uncertain, farmers will continue to weigh the same difficult choice, stick with cocoa or dig for something more profitable beneath the soil. All this means that the story of chocolate today isn't just about prices on supermarket shelves. It's about what's happening thousands of kilometres away on cocoa farms in West Africa. Because if farmers keep walking away from cocoa in search of quicker money underground, the world might soon face a different problem altogether. Not a shortage of chocolate lovers, but a shortage of cocoa farmers. All right, folks, I'll see you in the next one. Thank you for listening to today's episode.

• 7:19Speaker 00

  And if you want to share your feedback or suggestions, do drop us an email to [email protected]. Until next time.