Pod Insights Finshots Daily The MTNL story - Rescue, repeat, regret About this episode In today’s episode on 24th April 2025, we tell you why MTNL’s rescue is stuck in a limbo and how it could end up hurting Indian banks, and you. Speak to Ditto's advisors now, by clicking the link here - https://ditto.sh/9zoz41
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello folks, you're listening to Finshots Daily. In today's episode, we tell you why MTNL's rescue is stuck in a limbo and how it could end up hurting Indian banks and you.
0:12 Speaker 00 Before we get into today's story, here's a quick word from Ditto. Did you know that 83% of Indian households face serious financial trouble if the breadwinner passes away? That's exactly why buying term insurance is a no-brainer. If you're young, you can lock in a one crore cover for just 10,000 to 15,000 rupees a year. At Ditto Insurance, a product by Finshots, we've helped thousands pick the right plan with zero spam, no sales pressure, and real humans guiding you throughout the process. Book a free call with the link in the description or just Google Ditto Insurance to talk to an advisor. Now, let's get on with today's story. 1986, that's when it all began. The government launched Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited, or MTNL, to improve telecom services in India's two biggest cities, Mumbai and Delhi.
0:57 Speaker 00 For a while, it thrived with a monopoly on landlines and even becoming India's first telco to launch 3G in 2008. But the good days didn't last. Private players like Airtel and Vodafone entered with faster networks and better service. And when Geo landed with rock-bottom prices and high-speed data, the game changed completely. But MTNL, it stayed stuck. We say that because while telcos were rolling out 4G and preparing for 5G, MTNL was still figuring out 3G. Even today, its 4G rollout is barely visible despite government backing and BSN's support. And that's just one part of the problem. Because in telecom, once subscribers start fleeing for better services, it's hard to win them back. And that's what happened with MTNL.
1:43 Speaker 00 Today, it has only 5.2% of India's wireline subscribers and a measly 0.1% share in wireless. And with less business, MTNL started bleeding tons of cash. Revenue fell from 3,000 crore rupees in 2015 to about 800 crores in 2024. Losses meanwhile remained firmly in four digits, from 2,900 crores in 2015 to 3,200 crores in 2024.
2:10 Speaker 00 Because it kept issuing bonds with government guarantees as well as getting loans from banks to run its operations, interest costs just kept going up too. Then, it had another issue, people, too many of them. With an aging workforce, MTNL had massive salary and pension bills. It had more employees per customer than other telco. So, while revenues fell, costs didn't. The writing was on the wall, but since MTNL is a public sector company, the government tried to save it. In two thousand nineteen, it announced a sixty-nine thousand crore revival plan, including a merger with BSNL, free 4G spectrum and a voluntary retirement scheme, that is VRS, to cut employee costs.
2:50 Speaker 00 Nearly fourteen thousand employees took the VRS and MTNL's staff strength dropped by over ninety percent. But it didn't work. Revenues kept shrinking, the 4G spectrum remained unused and 4G services, well, they never took off. So, the government kept writing checks. One point six four lakh crore rupees in a second revival plan, eighty-nine thousand forty-seven crore rupees more after that, and most recently, six thousand crore rupees. That's over three point two lakh crore rupees just to keep MTNL and BSNL running. Now, to be fair, the revival money went to BSNL as well, the larger of the two, but MTNL is badly operational. BSNL now runs MTNL's operations under a risk survey arrangement.
3:35 Speaker 00 Meaning, BSNL has temporarily taken over MTNL's operations to assess the risks involved without committing to a full merger. So, MTNL is, for all practical purposes, a shell. That's still its own headache and it's a massive one. Allow us to explain. As of March two thousand twenty-five, MTNL owes thirty-three thousand five hundred crore rupees including bank loans, sovereign guaranteed bonds and dues to the Department of Telecom. And as you may have guessed already, it has defaulted on its bank loan repayments. Banks now have declared MTNL a non-performing asset or NPA, a sign that repayment might not come back easily soon or ever.
4:16 Speaker 00 They've even formed a group to recover what they can, but here's the problem. Dragging a government-owned company like MTNL to insolvency court isn't exactly a walk in the park. Technically, there's nothing that can stop banks from doing it. But in practice, PSU's rarely end up there. And now, the government has stepped in and asked lenders to hold off on that option for the time being, at least. So, banks are stuck. There are other options: wait, or take a haircut. And MTNL has proposed to repay just forty percent of what it owes, which is sixty percent haircut.
4:52 Speaker 00 The banks obviously are in thrill and they've countered with a twenty percent haircut instead. But even that's uncertain as MTNL makes less money in a year than it loses in a single quarter. So, where does that leave us? Well, the government hasn't announced a new bailout. No fresh cash, no winding it down either. It's letting MTNL fade away while PSU keeps things going on the ground. But taxpayers, well, they're still footing the bill. You see, when the government guaranteed MTNL's bonds, it effectively signed a blank cheque. If MTNL can't repay, the government must. That means your taxes fund the debt and interest payments. If the bank loans are written off, the pain shifts to banks.
5:34 Speaker 00 That could mean lower profits, higher provisions, and the need for fresh capital. And guess who funds that capital? Again, the government. Again, your money. This isn't a one-off either. Just a couple of years ago, the government had to take over Air India's debt before selling it. Then, there's a three lakh crore rupee plus infused into PSU banks since 2015 to clean up bad loans. Or the three lakh crore plus liability sitting on NHAI's books. Or Food Corporation of India's ballooning debt that doesn't even show up in the fiscal deficit. MTNL is just another entry on that growing list. And what has MTNL done so far? Nothing much, to be honest. It has tried selling assets to reduce debt, mostly land, buildings, towers,
6:18 Speaker 00 and it has raised just 2,100 crore rupees through it. So now, things are in a weird limbo because MTNL doesn't serve many customers, doesn't have viable revenue, doesn't launch new tech and doesn't get shut down either. It just, well, exists. In fact, MTNL agrees that it just can't compete the way things are today. It said in its report, "The existing network of MTNL has become obsolete. The heavy debt burden and the recurring losses during the past 12 years have resulted in a financial crunch, making MTNL unable to invest in the modernization, upgradation and expansion of its network." And the strangest part is that despite all this, MTNL's share price keeps holding steady and shareholders keep rising.
7:02 Speaker 00 Maybe investors think that government will eventually merge MTNL with PSNL or sell its land or privatize it. Maybe they believe something, well, anything will happen to unlock value. But the fundamentals don't back that up. MTNL has a poor debt servicing ratio. It's fundamentally insolvent. Its revenue is tiny and its liabilities are massive. The bigger picture, however, is that this isn't just about one PSU. It's about how PSUs can quietly burn money without anyone noticing, until it hits the banks or the budget. The government has said that MTNL won't be shut down until its liabilities are cleared. But here's the problem. MTNL issued sovereign guaranteed bonds worth 24,000 crore rupees
7:47 Speaker 00 and those mature only in 2034, which means banks will have to wait for years and MTNL might need more asset sales or even another fund infusion. And every delay adds more into its cost. So yes, it's a vicious cycle and the government knows this too. There's already talk that MTNL could be wound down in the next decade, which makes us ask, why keep reviving something that has clearly run its course? It doesn't serve the public well, it burns taxpayer money and it adds stress to an already stretched banking system. Now, the truth is, we've seen this story before. We've kept pouring money into entities that lost their edge years ago, hoping they'd turn around. But maybe it's time to accept that not every revival is worth it.
8:31 Speaker 00 Because when MTN L finally winds up, it won't look anything like the company that once ruled India's telecom space. And maybe, that's the only way forward. Thank you for listening to today's episode. And if you want to share your feedback or suggestions, do drop us an email to [email protected] . Until next time.
Previous Devyani wants a seat at the biryani banquet Next How the dinosaur fossil trade is hurting science Page updated November 11, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated