Pod Insights Finshots Daily SEBI wants tighter ETF bands About this episode In today’s episode on 18th Feb 2025, we give you an oversimplified explanation of how ETFs are priced, and why SEBI has proposed a few changes through a recent consultation paper.
Book a FREE call with Ditto https://ditto.sh/vx51ji
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello folks, you're tuned in to Finchart's Daily. In today's episode, we give you an oversimplified explanation of how ETFs are priced and why Sebi has proposed a few changes through a recent consultation paper.
0:14 Speaker 00 Before we begin, here's a quick word from team Ditto. Life has a way of surprising us and not always in a good way. Sometimes it's a sudden illness or an unexpected hospital visit that can shake up everything. In India, families still pay about 39% of medical expenses directly from their own pockets and just one hospital's take can wipe out years of savings. The easiest way to protect yourself is by getting a good health insurance plan. It's way cheaper than footing one huge bill. And if you're unaware where to start, book a free call with Ditto. No spam, just honest, jargon-free guidance. Trusted by over 8 lakh people for their health and term insurance needs. The link is in the description. Now, back to the story.
0:57 Speaker 00 All the chatter around gold and silver lately has probably made one term very popular: ETF. You likely know what it is, some of you might even own one. But for anyone new to this, an ETF or exchange traded fund is simply an investment fund that mirrors something else. It could track an index like the Nifty or Sensex. Or it could follow gold, silver and other commodities, government bonds or save debt instruments. There are more varieties out there, but these are the basics. And since ETFs are listed on stock exchanges, you can buy and sell them as easily as shares. This also means that an ETF's price is shaped by two forces. First, there's the underlying asset it mimics, that determines the NAV or the net asset value,
1:41 Speaker 00 which is simply the total value of everything the ETF owns, which is the net of expenses, divided by the number of units. Second, there's regular market demand and supply. All the buying and selling on the exchange, which decides the traded market price. Now, in an ideal world, the two move almost together, that's the ETF's job. But sometimes they drift apart. And when that happens, often called as market makers, step in to close the gap. For example, let's think of an ETF that tracks apples. One unit equals one kilo. of apples which cost hundred rupees per kg. But heavy demand pushes the ETF's market price to hundred and five rupees, which means that it's now trading above its actual value. Here, market makers will respond by selling ETF units in large quantities.
2:24 Speaker 00 More supply brings the price down and soon it moves back close to hundred. You'll notice that we said close to hundred rupees because NAV also includes small adjustments, such as accounting for fund expenses. Which means there will always be a tiny gap between an ETF's NAV and market price. Now, this is called a tracking error. But coming back to the point, this constant buying and selling by market makers to keep price and value aligned is called arbitrage because they also pocket a profit from the price difference. But why are we explaining all this to you, you ask? Well, SEBI put out a consultation paper a few days ago saying it's thinking of changing how ETF prices are determined and how extreme volatility is handled.
3:08 Speaker 00 And all that context we discussed was needed to understand what SEBI is now trying to fix. And now that you have it, let's talk about what SEBI is suggesting. When we spoke about ETF pricing, we explained how an ETF gets its value. But there's another layer to this, that is which day's value becomes the reference point for trading. Let's go back to the apple example. Apples were hundred rupees per kg today, so the ETF's NAV was hundred rupees. Simple, but in the real world with stocks and commodities, you can't use live prices to declare the official NAV. The fund house managing the ETF calculates and publishes the final NAV only at the end of the day, usually around eleven PM. In some cases like certain commodity ETFs, it can even be nine AM the next morning. Exchanges and brokers then use that published NAV as a reference.
3:54 Speaker 00 But because of these timing constraints, ETFs currently use the T minus two day closing NAV as the base price for trading. Meaning if today is T day, the reference value is from two days ago. That creates problems, especially if an ETF tracks a bunch of stocks. Let's suppose a stock inside the ETF announces a dividend on T minus one day. The NAV should reflect that as cash comes into the ETF because it owns that stock. That cash doesn't come Directly into your bank account but rather automatically gets reinvested back into the fund either by buying more of the same stock or allocating it within the portfolio. But because the base price is two days old, exchanges have to manually adjust it and manual adjustments always carry the risk of errors.
4:35 Speaker 00 But the bigger issue shows up when you look at price movements. Since ETFs trade like regular shares, they're subject to price bands too. A price band is simply a limit on how much a security can rise or fall in a day. For most stocks, that can go up to twenty percent on either side based on the previous day's closing price or T minus one day. There are also market-wide circuit breakers if indices swing widely. For ETFs though, exchanges currently apply a fixed plus or minus twenty percent band on the base price. And other like overnight ETFs, the lowest ones that track one day at instruments, have a tighter plus or minus five percent band. And that creates a problem because the stocks inside the ETF are governed by T minus one base limits.
5:16 Speaker 00 But the ETF itself uses a T minus two NAV as its base price, so they aren't anchored to the same reference point. Let's give you another example to make this one clearer. On Monday, that is T minus two, the ETF's NAV is hundred rupees, alright? Now on Tuesday, that is T minus one, markets jump and the real NAV becomes a hundred and ten rupees. But Wednesday's band is still calculated using a hundred rupees. So on Wednesday, the ETF can trade between eighty rupees and a hundred and twenty rupees because remember how I mentioned plus or minus twenty percent? And this is even if nothing dramatic happens. It could legally trade at one twenty rupees, which is nearly nine percent above its actual value. Now, that is mispricing, right?
5:58 Speaker 00 Now, these are precisely the problems Sebi wants to address. That's why it's essentially saying, "Hey, we need to revise the base price for ETFs by shifting to a T minus one based NAV instead of a T minus two NAV." And we need to rethink the price bands as well. So temporary mispricing doesn't create unnecessary distortions in the market. Sebi's ideas are actually quite straightforward. First, on the base price, if you're moving to a T minus one reference instead of a T minus two, what exactly should we use? One option is the ETF's closing price on T minus. T minus one, defined as the weighted average traded price of the last thirty minutes. Another is the average INAV of the last thirty minutes on T minus one.
6:39 Speaker 00 Now, INAV simply a live indicator value of what the ETF should be worth based on its underlying assets. Fund houses usually calculate it every ten to fifteen seconds and publish it on their websites. It helps you judge whether the price you see on your trading app is fair. Now, you might ask, why not just use the latest available INAV? Sebi says that could be risky. A single INAV reading could also be an outlier. So, instead of relying on one snapshot, it suggests averaging the last thirty minutes. The third option is to use the official closing NAV of T minus one, if available. Then, there's a price band change. Sebi wants to move away from the fixed plus or minus twenty percent band because it may not make sense for all ETFs and there's evidence to back this up. Its analysis between April and December twenty twenty five shows
7:24 Speaker 00 that equity and debt ETFs rarely move beyond ten percent in a day. Commodity ETFs mostly stay within nine percent, whereas overnight ETFs usually stay within plus or minus five percent. So for equity and debt ETFs, Sebi proposes starting with plus or minus ten percent, with flexibility to expand up to plus or minus twenty percent in stages, with cooling off pauses in between. For gold and silver ETFs, the starting band would be plus or minus six percent, expandable in three percent steps, again capped at plus or minus twenty percent. It's also considering a short pre-open session before nine fifteen AM, specifically for commodity ETFs. In that window, buyers and sellers could place orders to discover a fair opening price that reflects overnight global moves, since commodities trade almost twenty-four hours a day across different markets.
8:09 Speaker 00 It would work just like the regular pre-open session for stocks but tailored only for commodity ETFs. Now, remember, this is just a consultation paper. Sebi is inviting comments till March sixth. Nothing is final yet. But if these changes do go through, what could they actually mean? Now, on the positive side, ETFs won't rely on a stale two-day-old reference price anymore. Now, that's a big deal, especially for commodity ETFs, gold and silver move globally almost around the clock. Now, if price bands don't adjust fast enough, the ETF can start trading far away from the real value of gold. Silver and that's bad for everyone. So fresher reference prices and smarter band could reduce those distortions. But there's a flip side. Remember arbitrage, the mechanism that keeps ETF prices aligned with NAV?
8:52 Speaker 00 Under Sebi's tighter initial bands and cooling off periods, ETF trading on the exchange could pause more often during volatile moves. Imagine silver is rallying sharply, the underlying prices keeps climbing. But the ETF hits its band and trading pauses, it can't immediately move in tandem unless the band expands after cooling off period. During that pause, large institutions that can transact off exchange may still find ways to capitalize on price difference that potentially creates bigger arbitrage opportunities for them. Meanwhile, small traders stuck on the exchange screen can only wait. So ironically, the small trader Sebi wants to shield from bad prices may not be able to do much during these pauses.
9:33 Speaker 00 Meanwhile, the so-called solution of tighter price bands could end up creating larger arbitrage opportunities for big institutions that have the ability to transact outside the exchange framework. So yes, we'll have to wait and see how market participants respond to this proposal and what ultimately plays out if and when it actually gets implemented.
9:54 Speaker 00 Thank you for listening to today's episode and if you want to share your feedback or suggestions, do drop us an email to [email protected] . Until next time.
Previous India’s new CPI explained Next Can India get carbon credits right? Page updated November 10, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated