Pod Insights Finshots Daily RBI lands a gut punch on prop traders About this episode In today’s episode on 3rd July 2026, we explain why prop traders are worried about the RBI’s latest capital market exposure rules for banks.
Sign up for FREE insurance masterclass by Ditto https://ditto.sh/2cgegs
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Hello folks, you're tuned into Finshots Daily. In today's episode, we explain why prop traders are worried about the RBI's latest capital market exposure rules for banks.
0:14 Speaker 00 But before we begin, here's a quick note from Team Ditto. This weekend, we're hosting a free two-day insurance masterclass that helps you build real financial security by understanding health and life insurance the right way. Well, the masterclass is completely free and you can head to the link in the description to register while your seats last. Okay, let's start with the story. Of late, the RBI has become something of a villain for the stock market. That's because, starting this month, the central bank has effectively pulled back how much leverage proprietary trading firms can use while trading in the capital markets. Now, we know what you're thinking, the RBI regulates banks and it's the SEBI that regulates capital markets.
0:59 Speaker 00 So how is the RBI suddenly influencing what happens on the LAL Street? We'll get to that, but first, some context. A prop trading firm or desk is simply a firm that trades using its own money. So unlike stockbrokers who execute trades for clients or mutual funds which invest other people's savings, prop desks put their own capital as well as borrowed money at risks to earn profits. They trade everything from stocks to futures and options, either manually or through high-frequency and algorithmic trading, where computers, programs, and not humans execute trades. But to trade, exchanges typically ask participants to maintain sufficient money margin. Think of it as a security deposit.
1:40 Speaker 00 If a trade goes wrong and you make losses, the exchange can recover those losses from the margin. As an example, let's imagine you're a prop trader with 1 lakh rupees. The exchange tells you to keep aside 20% as margin. Now, we're ignoring leveraged trades here for simplicity. That means 20,000 rupees gets locked up with the exchange, leaving you with only 80,000 rupees to actually trade. That's not a great situation, especially if your business depends on deploying as much capital as possible. But thankfully, margins don't Don't always have to be cash. Exchanges also accept government securities and even bank guarantees. And that's where banks come in. Instead of parking twenty thousand rupees with the exchange, a prop trader could approach a bank and ask for a BG. That's bank guarantees.
2:24 Speaker 00 In simple terms, the bank tells the exchange if this trader fails to pay, we'll pay instead. Of course, the bank doesn't do it for free, charges a fee which is usually much smaller than the amount of capital the trader would have had to lock up. The bank also protects itself by typically checking whether the trader has a strong enough financial profile to avoid defaulting. In the first place, apart from asking them to provide collateral such as securities, deposits or cash, where there are half the guarantee amount. So if the trader defaults, the bank can sell that collateral to recover part of its money. This essentially means that instead of locking away twenty thousand rupees, the trader pays a relatively small fee.
3:05 Speaker 00 Ledges some collateral and gets to use almost the entire one lakh rupees for trading. In the real world, that translated into prop traders being able to operate with roughly one point seven times the capital they actually had. And this system worked fairly well for years. To put that in perspective, according to a Care Edge Ratings report. Banks' exposure to the capital markets accounted for less than three percent of their total advances in F I twenty five. As a share of their net worth, it was only around seven to thirteen percent. Even defaults in this segment was extremely low. Another interesting thing is if you look at Sebi's analysis of equity derivatives trading between F I twenty two and twenty four. Prop traders actually earned the highest profits of around thirty three thousand crore rupees on the N S C.
3:51 Speaker 00 That's even more than foreign portfolio investors and like individual traders, ninety one percent of whom lost money in F and O. But think about what were to happen if a bunch of prop trading firms suffered massive losses and failed to meet their margin calls. Banks would then have to honor the guarantees they issued and pay the exchanges on behalf of those traders. Sure, they could recover part of that money by selling the collateral, but the rest would come from banks' own funds. Money that would otherwise be useful. Lending or other banking operations. If such failures become widespread, it could eventually threaten the banking system and indirectly depositors like you and me. Now, that's certainly an extreme scenario, but regulators don't seem to be waiting for worst case scenarios anymore.
4:34 Speaker 00 And that may be exactly what prompted the RBI to tighten the screws. A few months ago, it directed that banks issuing guarantees to pro trading firms must now do so against a hundred percent collateral, with at least half of it being cash or cash equivalents such as fixed deposits. The rule was originally supposed to kick in from April twenty twenty six, but after brokers, banks and other and other affected market participants argued that they needed more time to transition into the new framework, the RBI prospect implementation. And on Thursday, the new rules finally came into effect. There may also be another reason the RBI isn't entirely comfortable. Remember the thirty three thousand crore rupees profit prop traders made?
5:18 Speaker 00 If you take deeper into Sebi's report, you'll find that ninety six percent of those profits came from algorithmic trading. But only a little over half of the six twenty six prop trading entities that the regulator analyzed actually use algorithms. In other words, a relatively small number of large sophisticated firms generated most of the profits, while many smaller firms could very well be breaking even or even losing money. This means that a bank guaranteeing a mid-sized or a smaller prop trading firm gets no comfort from the fact that some large algo desk elsewhere in the country made money, and that's a risk. There's another factor too. India is now the world's largest derivatives market with average daily notional turnover touching nearly five point two trillion dollars by the end of twenty twenty five.
6:00 Speaker 00 That's not exactly something regulators are proud of because excessive leverage and such a massive market can amplify risks and trigger market shocks. It's also one of the reasons the government hike the securities transaction tax on equity derivatives in the latest budget. And while the RBI can't do much about all the hype in the stock market, it can at least make sure banks aren't taking on excessive risk, which is what it did. As you can imagine though, prop traders aren't thrilled. For one, they say the move slash. The leverage they once enjoyed earlier, they could effectively trade with about 1.7 times their capital. But now because they have to lock up much more money with banks to obtain a guarantee, that falls to roughly 0.85 times.
6:43 Speaker 00 Less deployable capital could also mean lower liquidity in the markets, especially considering prop traders accounted for more than half of the NSC's options turnover last year. Their second complaint is that the new rules only affect Indian prop trading firms because foreign firms fall outside the RBI's jurisdiction. And that can create an uneven playing field. That said, some folks in the broking industry believe the sector will eventually adapt. After all, the markets have weathered plenty of regulatory changes over the years. Besides, this wasn't really a surprise. The industry was known for a while that this blow was coming. And now the only way forward is to adapt and move on.
7:25 Speaker 00 How quickly that happens or how painful the transition turns out to be, something we'll have to wait and see. All right, folks, I'll see you in the next one.
7:33 Speaker 00 Thank you for listening to today's episode. And if you want to share your feedback or suggestions, do drop us an email to [email protected] . Until next time.
Previous The OYO IPO Explained Next Can AI really fix America's $39 trillion debt problem? Page updated November 9, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated