Pod Insights Finshots Daily Memecoin fraud just became easier About this episode In today’s episode on 4th March 2025, we explain why the US SEC says that memecoins aren’t securities. Speak to Ditto's advisors now, by clicking the link here - https://ditto.sh/9zoz41
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello folks, you're listening to Finshots Daily. And in today's episode, we explain why the US SEC says that meme coins aren't securities.
0:11 Speaker 00 Before we start today's episode, here's a quick announcement from Team Ditto. Did you know that 83% of Indian households are put in grave financial danger if the breadwinner passes away? This is why it's important to be financially prudent and buy a term insurance. If you're young, you can secure your family with a cover of over 1 crore at nominal premiums of just 10 to 15K a year. At Ditto Insurance, a product by Finshots, we've helped thousands of people select a term plan with the help of certified advisors. We promise a spam-free experience, no pressure to buy, and a claim support team always by your side. Head over to the link in the description or Google Ditto Insurance to speak to an expert now.
0:56 Speaker 00 Now, on to today's episode. A few months ago, a Canadian teenager did something wild. He created his own cryptocurrency called Gen Z Quant. It wasn't meant to be a serious project, just a fun meme coin. And if you're wondering what meme coins are, they're basically cryptocurrencies inspired by internet jokes, pop culture, or social media trends. You know, like Dogecoin. They have no real-world use case, but people buy and sell them anyway, hoping to make a quick buck. The hype around these coins can send their prices soaring or crashing in no time, making them super volatile and risky. And Gen Z Quant was no different. The teenager released the coin into the market and then bought 51 million of them,
1:39 Speaker 00 or about 5% of the total supply, for just $350. Then, he did something very clever. He started live streaming on a website called pump.fun, a platform that makes it incredibly easy to create and distribute meme coins. Before this, launching a cryptocurrency was complicated and expensive, but pump.fun changed the game.
2:01 Speaker 00 But there was a catch. While Pump dot Fund tried to prevent outright scams like rug pulls, it didn't stop creators from buying and selling their own coins. So while the teenager livestreamed, people watching got excited and started pressing the buy button on Gen Z coin. And within just 10 minutes, the price shot up by a jaw-dropping 8,400%. This meant that the dean's $350 investment was suddenly worth $30,000. And without wasting a moment, he sold them all and cashed out. The result? A massive price crash. But the teenager wasn't done yet. Seeing an opportunity, he quickly created two more meme coins, pulled off the same trick,
2:43 Speaker 00 and walked away with a total of $50,000 in just one night. In the stock market, this would be called a pump-and-dump scheme. Buy low, hype up the stock, get others to buy in, and then sell heavy, leaving everyone with losses. But in the crypto world, things are different. There are many rules and a whole lot of what happens exists in a legal gray area. And that gray area just got even bigger because US Securities and Exchange Commission, that is SEC, recently ruled that meme coins are in securities. Simply put, people who create or trade meme coins don't need to register with SEC. So if you lose money because of a scam or price manipulation, you can't go crying to regulators.
3:27 Speaker 00 Sure, you can try suing under regular fraud laws, but the strict protections that exist for stocks don't apply here. And this stance has raised some eyebrows, especially given how many scams exist in crypto. For context, Chinalysis estimates that about 5% of all crypto tokens issued in 2024 may have been rug pulls, leading to $2.8 billion in investor losses. And with numbers like these, you'd think that the US government would want tighter regulations to boost investor confidence. So why isn't the SEC stepping in, you ask? Well, their decision isn't based on whims and fancies. Instead, it's based on something called the Howey test.
4:08 Speaker 00 This legal precedent determines whether an asset is a security and should be regulated. And it comes from SEC versus W.J. Howey Co., a 1946 US Supreme Court case. To put things into perspective, W.J. Howey Co. was a Florida company that sold citrus groves to buyers, who then leased the land back to the company. And since the company hadn't registered these lease-back transactions with SEC, the regulators sued the company. The SEC argued that this counted as an investment contract, and the court agreed. But how did the court decide that? It check for four criteria. Number one, there must be an investment of money. Investors must put in money or something of value. In Howey's case, investors paid for the land.
4:53 Speaker 00 Meme coins pass this test since people buy them with money or other crypto. Number two, a common enterprise must exist. Funds should be pooled into a venture where profits are shared, like how investors and Howey were part of the citrus grove project. Meme coins don't pass this test because they don't involve a shared investment. Number three, there must be an expectation of profit. Investors must believe they'll make money. Here, investors expected profits from the deal, which is why they leased the land back to Howey in the first place. Definitely applies to meme coins. Number four, profits must come from the efforts of others. The investment must rely on someone else's work.
5:35 Speaker 00 In Howey's case, investors made money based on how well the company handled everything, from planting to harvesting and selling the citrus produced. Meme coins don't pass this test either as their prices are driven by hype and not a business or a team's performance. And since meme coins fail two out of four tests, they aren't considered securities. But here's where things get tricky. The SEC's previous chair, Gary Gensler, believed that most cryptocurrencies were securities. And guess what? He used the same Howey test we just went through to make his point. He was worried that crypto traders would use loopholes to avoid regulations. But now, the SEC seems to be singing a different tune. So what changed? Well, two things.
6:19 Speaker 00 For one, the fact that every cryptocurrency is unique. Take USD Tether or USDT for example. It has a much stronger case for being considered as a security than a meme coin. USDT is a stable coin backed to the US dollar and its backing by Tether Limited could be seen as a common enterprise. Plus, the stability of its value depends on Tether Limited's actions, meaning profits come from the efforts of others. So, it has a much higher chance of passing the Harvey test. That's why Gensler previously argued that most digital assets should be regulated. And secondly, the SEC's substance overform principle. This means even if a crypto technically meets the Harvey test,
7:01 Speaker 00 the SEC can still decide that it's not security based on how people actually use it. For example, if a cryptocurrency is marketed as a utility token but investors are buying it purely for profit, the SEC might say, sure, it looks like an investment, but it's really just a collectible. All that makes regulating crypto incredibly complicated. So yes, a separate governing body might be needed to oversee it properly. Until that happens, anyone can create a meme coin without worrying about breaking securities law. And that's exactly what the Canadian teenager did. After the Gen Z quant stunt, he came back and launched two more meme coins called Test and Don't Buy. The names were clear warnings, yet investors still rushed to buy them.
7:46 Speaker 00 And just like before, he made a killing. Crazy times and crazy investors.
7:53 Speaker 00 Thank you for listening to today's episode. Finshots Daily is available on a bunch of streaming platforms such as Spotify, Apple Podcasts and Google Podcasts. So make sure you follow us on your favorite podcast streaming platform. Until next time.
Previous Can India’s IMEC trade corridor vision become a reality? Next FIIs are upset. Should you be too? Page updated November 11, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated