Pod Insights Finshots Daily Do government bailouts work? About this episode In today’s episode on 13th May 2025, we look at India’s long line of corporate bailouts and ask a simple question: When the government swoops in with taxpayer money, does it actually fix anything?
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello folks, you're listening to Finshots Daily. And in today's episode, we look at India's long line of corporate bailouts and ask a very simple question. When the government swoops in with taxpayer money, does it actually fix anything?
0:16 Speaker 00 A quick announcement before we begin. Finshots and Ditto are hiring across a bunch of marketing roles. So if you're into content, design, SEO or influencer marketing and you actually enjoy working on meaningful creative stuff, we'd love to have you. The team's young, fun and genuinely collaborative. You will find the link to apply in the episode description or you can head to joinditto.in. Come join us. And now, here's today's story. 62,000 crore. That's the cheque taxpayers had to cut just to clean up Air India's books before it could fly into Tata's hangar in 2022. The very next year, the government promised nearly 90,000 crore to BSNL in yet another revival bid. More recently, Vodafone Idea's mountain of dues to the government was converted into equity.
1:02 Speaker 00 Add to that, the SBI-led bailout of Yes Bank, that's in the news and you begin to see a pattern. Every one of these lifelines pulled taxpayer money away from highways, hospitals and public universities. The kind of stuff that builds nations. For instance, Air India's rescue in FY22 alone took about 0.26% of India's GDP at the time. And yet, officials argue that some institutions are too big to fear and that a timely intervention is better than a full-blown collapse. So what gives? Do these bailouts actually fix anything or do they just delete the inevitable wild taxpayers for the bill? Let's look at a few marquee cases. Take care, India.
1:42 Speaker 00 For nearly a decade, from FY2012 to FY21, the airline racked up nearly 78,000 crore in losses. Interest payments alone were eating up 4,000 crore rupees a year. Ballooning fuel costs, polytime fleet orders and a service reputation that lacked private rivals send the airline from one red quarter to the next. So, no one to potential buyers stayed away. Acquiring Air India meant inheriting its mountain of debt and a sprawling bureaucracy culture. And that's when the government made a decisive, if expensive cut. In 2022, it parked nearly 61,000 crore rupees of liabilities in a specially created holding company called Air India Assets Holding Limited and handed over a near-debt-free airline to the Tatas.
2:24 Speaker 00 Add it all up and the taxpayer had shelled out over 90,000 crore rupees in total for the bailout since 2012. This was steep, but the logic was clear. End the bleeding, save over 10,000 direct jobs, preserve precious airport slots and let someone who knows this business take over. And it did change things. Two years on, early metrics hint at a turnaround. Punctuality has climbed, wide-body cabins are being refurbished and the Tatas have merged with Tara into Air India to create scale. The airline is still some distance from profitability, but analysts believe operational profits could arrive as early as a 527. So, for Air India, it's safe to say that the bailout was a partial success.
3:05 Speaker 00 Yes, the government funded the bill of over 90,000 crore rupees, but at least that nightmare is over. And they were able to sell their stake to someone who manages it responsibly. Compare that with Yes Bank. By 2019, the bank's headlong rush into risky corporate loans had poisoned its books. It had lent primarily to struggling companies, which led to Yes Bank's non-performing assets or NPAs being seven times higher than they had reported. NPAs are basically loans on which the borrower has stopped paying interest or principal for over three months. This means that the bank no longer count on getting the money back easily. The RBI uncovered this, credit rating agencies quickly downgraded ratings, depositories panicked and the share price collapsed by over 80% in just 12 months.
3:50 Speaker 00 So, the RBI stepped in and issued a moratorium which capped withdrawals at 50,000 rupees. Bondholders were forced to absorb over 8,400 crore rupees in write-offs and an SBI-led Injected ten thousand crore rupees for a forty-nine percent stake. It was a forced rescue, but it worked. Because four years later, the turnaround looks almost clinical. Net non-performing assets set at point three percent, the best since the scam in two thousand twenty. Net profit leapt ninety-two percent year-on-year in the recent quarter, the highest since scandal broke. And Japan's Sumitomo Mitsui is in talks to purchase SBI stake, signaling private capital is happy to take over. Then give the case of Vodafone India or V. Its troubles began when GEO entered the telecom sector in two thousand sixteen with rock-bottom tariffs.
4:35 Speaker 00 I still remember people waiting in line to get a free SIM. GEO's entry ate into Vodafone and Idea shares, dwindling their average revenue per user. And this led to Vodafone and Idea Salil are merging in two thousand eighteen to increase market share. However, this only worsened their losses. Then came a Supreme Court verdict in two thousand nineteen. Then came a Supreme Court verdict in two thousand nineteen, slapping the new entity with fifty-eight thousand crore rupees in adjusted gross revenue dues. In two thousand twenty-five, total debt and interest crossed two-point-five lakh crore rupees mark. Routine capex for four G, let alone five G, became impossible. So, why did the government bear it out, you ask? Well, you see, there are only two other prominent players in the market, GEO and Alter.
5:18 Speaker 00 If Vodafone Idea went bankrupt, it would hollow out the competition, giving the incumbents far more power over pricing and service quality. Policymakers therefore scrambled to keep the company afloat because an imposition would have left the country teetering on a de facto deopoly. A condition where only two companies dominated the market share. However, the government didn't write a check this time. But it did convert sixteen thousand crore rupees of interest dues into equity, becoming a shareholder. No fresh cash changed hands, but the move it brought Vodafone Idea time to seek investors. And more recently, the government also waived thirty-seven thousand crore rupees in spectrum dues to raise its stake to forty-nine percent in the company. But even after raising eighteen thousand crore rupees from private investors last year,
6:01 Speaker 00 Vodafone India still loses thousands of crores in cash every quarter and lags in spectrum holdings. Survival too remains doubtful at this juncture, at least for now. So, yes. The bailout bought time but not certainty. And lastly, we have BSNL, the black hole of bailouts. It has already absorbed over 3.2 lakh crore rupees from taxpayers. Yes, its latest bailout package in 2023 was for around 89,000 crore rupees. This package includes amounts for 4G, 5G spectrums, wall entry retirement schemes for employees and debt restructuring. On paper, the reasoning makes sense. BSNL plays a vital role in defence communication, especially in far-flung regions. It also ensures the telecom sector doesn't devolve into a private teopoly. BSNL 2 is doing its bit to bounce back.
6:46 Speaker 00 It hopes a steep price reduction will lure users back. For instance, BSNL's 365-day unlimited plan now costs 1,999 rupees compared to GIO and Airtel's at 3,599 rupees. But will this attract more people if they continue to have poor coverage and bad 4G and 5G reception? This is why the government gave more money to companies to purchase spectrum allocations. Will it work out? We're not sure, but we're hopeful that it does. And all of that brings us to today's topic. Do government bailouts work? Well, sometimes they do because Air India got a clean break and a private owner. Yes, Bank got new capital and better governance, but not as always, as we see with Waterphone Idea and BSNL.
7:30 Speaker 00 And one pattern is hard to miss. Bailouts succeed only when accomplished by ruthless restructuring, fresh governance and an exit plan for the state. When the discipline goes missing, things unravel. BSNL proves that money without change is just an expensive denial. Waterphone Idea sits somewhere in between, a company with potential and a lot of support but still nothing to cheer about. It is difficult to balance this out, but a blanket ban on bailouts is no answer either. The knock-on effects run deeper. Most troubled giants owe their largest dues to public sector banks, banks that hold out deposits. If a rescue doesn't come, the damage simply trickles down to the rest of the financial system. And eventually, it lands right back on the taxpayer's lap. So, yes, bailouts are messy.
8:14 Speaker 00 And maybe the only way to tilt the odds is to pair every rupee of rescue with hard, uncomfortable reform and a countdown clock that tells us exactly when the state will get out of the way. Otherwise, the taxpayer fits the bill again and again and again with nothing to show for it.
8:32 Speaker 00 Thank you for listening to today's episode. And if you want to share your feedback or suggestions, do drop us an email to [email protected] . Until next time.
Previous Is Pepsi losing its pop? Next Are Humanoids the next big leap for humankind? Page updated November 11, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated