Pod Insights Finshots Daily Are CEOs always to blame for a company's struggles? About this episode In today’s episode for 9th Demeber 2024, we explore whether it’s fair to blame CEOs when a company doesn’t perform well. Speak to Ditto's advisors now, by clicking the link here - https://ditto.sh/9zoz41
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome to Finshots Daily. In today's episode, we discuss if CEOs are always to blame for a company's struggles.
0:10 Speaker 00 Before we start today's episode, here's a quick message from Team Dito. Did you know that eighty-three percent of Indian households are put in grave financial danger if the breadwinner passes away? This is why it's important to be financially prudent and buy a term insurance. If you're young, you can secure your family with a cover of over one crore rupees at nominal premiums of just ten to fifteen K a year. At Dito Insurance, a product of Finshots, we've helped thousands of people select a term plan with the help of certified advisors. We promise a spam-free experience, no pressure for you to buy, and a claim support team that's always by your side. Head over to the link in the description below or Google Dito Insurance to speak to an expert now. Now on to today's episode.
0:55 Speaker 00 Even if you're not a maritime expert, you probably know that a ship's captain's job is pretty important at sea. They plan the route, make the big decisions, and handle pretty much everything on board. But it's the helmsman who physically steers the ship, ensuring it follows the set course. These are different roles, quite different in fact, one more strategic and the other more tactical. Yet both are essential for keeping the ship on track. Now, think of a company. It wouldn't be an exaggeration to compare its CEO to a ship's captain, would it? For starters, the CEO sets the vision, crafts strategies, and ensures the company stays afloat amid challenges.
1:39 Speaker 00 But when the waters get especially turbulent, they might also need to step in as the helmsman, taking direct control to navigate through storms. Simply put, CEOs are always at the helm, whether planning or actively steering. And this brings us to today's story. Last week, a Reuters article gave an in-depth account of CEO Pat Gelsinger's tenure at Intel. He recently stepped down, or as some suggest, was ousted even before completing his planned turnaround of The company. Here's what happened. Intel was the one uncontested leader in computer chips. And they had a pretty sweet deal with TSMC, Taiwan's chip-making giant, to manufacture their chips.
2:22 Speaker 00 But when Gelsinger took over in twenty twenty one, he had a lofty dream to make Intel a key player in the foundry business. That's producing chips in-house, just like TSMC. He aimed to reduce reliance on the Taiwanese chipmaker and manufacture these indispensable chips on American soil. The US government was enticed to believe in Gelsinger's vision. And through its Chips Act, poured billions into bolstering Intel's domestic manufacturing ambitions. But things quickly went south. When Gelsinger made some not-so-humble public remarks about Taiwan's geopolitical instability. Further stating that relying solely on TSMC was not ideal due to Taiwan's strained relations with China. Naturally, this didn't go well with TSMC.
3:07 Speaker 00 They retaliated quickly by scrapping Intel's forty percent discount on chip production, forcing Intel to pay full price. This hit profits hard. This was the first blow that shook the ground for Gelsinger. And then came the AI wave. Tools like ChatGPT boosted demand for AI chips. But Intel missed the train. With its cutting-edge GPUs, Nvidia became the go-to choice for AI applications, skyrocketing its stock price. Though Gelsinger had plans of jumping onto the AI bandwagon, Intel struggled to find its footing in this booming AI market. Two major blows and Gelsinger's tenure was cut short. Sounds fair? Maybe. A similar fate befell Starbucks's Lakshman Narasimhan.
3:52 Speaker 00 Declining sales and plunging stock prices in key markets like the US, China, and India led to his abrupt exit. Despite his earlier stellar track record at McKinsey, PepsiCo, and Wreckit. Nike's John Donahoe, Nestle's Mark Schneider, Boeing's Dave Calhoun, and Hertz's Stephen Share. Each of them had to step down recently amid sales slumps, competition, or even a shrinking market. In fact, according to exchange.com, seventy-four of the one hundred and ninety-one CEOs who resigned from their roles in FY twenty four were allegedly forced out. So here's the question, is it fair to put the blame on the CEO alone for a company's struggles? Well, it's a tricky debate. On one hand, CEOs are the face of the company.
4:37 Speaker 00 But let's not forget the fact that companies are complex ecosystems. The performance of a business isn't solely dependent on the person at the top. Market conditions, geopolitical factors, and even decisions made by teams below the CEO might influence outcomes. Take Hertz's Stephen Share as an example. His futuristic plan to electrify Hertz's fleet by buying 100,000 Teslas initially looked like a stroke of genius. His decision not only boosted Tesla's valuation but also positioned Hertz as a forward-thinking leader in the EV revolution. However, when Tesla unexpectedly cut prices of its EVs, the resale value of those cars decreased, forcing Hertz to swallow a $245 million charge.
5:22 Speaker 00 Add to that weak demand and mounting losses, and suddenly Share was not a great leader and was shown the door. Could he have foreseen Tesla's pricing strategy or the lukewarm response from renters? Perhaps not. Then, there's the matter of execution. Even the best-laid plans can falter if middle-management fails to deliver. No doubt, it's one of the toughest jobs out there. CEOs have to navigate internal operations, external market challenges, and economic headwinds while maintaining profitability and stock value. They need confidence, adaptability, and the ability to make and revise critical decisions on the fly. But on the flip side, with great responsibility comes great pay.
6:03 Speaker 00 You see, the average S&P 500 CEO earns 196 times more than the typical employee. Global CEOs earn hundreds of millions of dollars. In India too, these top bosses are paid handsomely. Wipro's former CEO, Thierry Delaporte, took home a whopping 167 crore in FY24. HCL tech's C. Vijay Kumar wasn't far behind with 84 crore, whilst PERSISTence Systems' Sandeep Kalra made 77 crore. The list is long. This hefty compensation reflects the immense pressure, and more so the expectations placed on their shareholders. Shareholders, if they earn this much, they had better be constantly on their toes
6:47 Speaker 00 and fulfill all their responsibilities. And rightly so. When there is so much at stake and the compensation is also massive, there cannot be much room for faults or bad decisions. And when they falter, even the most respected leaders can be shown the door. As Alan Laffley once said, quote, "In football, if a team has a bad season, the players are in the first to go. It's the coach or the manager," unquote. What do you think? Thank you for listening to today's episode. Finshots Daily is available on a bunch of streaming platforms such as Spotify, Apple Podcasts and Google Podcasts. So make sure you follow us on your favorite podcast streaming platform. Until next time.
Previous Breaking down Raymond’s break up Next Why India needs more import duties on Aluminium Page updated November 11, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated