Pod Insights Finshots Daily A CEO can't be Eternal About this episode In today’s episode on 24th January 2026, we unpack Eternal’s Q3 (FY26) results and why the stock looks confused after Deepinder Goyal handed over the CEO reins to Albinder Dhindsa.
Book a FREE call with Ditto https://ditto.sh/vx51ji
https://ditto.sh/vx51ji
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello folks, you're tuned in different charts daily. In today's episode, we unpack Eternal's Q3 FY26 results and why the stock looks confused after Dipendh Goyal handed over the CEO reins to Albindh Dhinza. Before we begin, here's a quick word from team Ditto. Life can be unpredictable and if the main earner is not around, the bills won't stop. That's why term insurance is so important. It gives your family a fixed payout so they can cover school fees, EMIs and daily expenses without stress. If you buy it early, you can get a one crore cover for as little as ₹1000 a month and the premium stays the same for your entire policy term. That's real peace of mind at a very small cost.
0:43 Speaker 00 And if you're not sure which plan is right for you, book a free call with Ditto. No spam, just honest guidance. And we're trusted by over 8 lakh people for their health and term insurance needs. Now, back to the story.
0:57 Speaker 00 On Wednesday, you probably saw the news. Dipendh Goyal stepped down as CEO of Eternal. In a letter to shareholders, Goyal said he would resign as director, managing director and CEO effective Feb 1st because he wants to pursue experimental ideas that in his view are better explored outside Eternal's core business. Now that said, he isn't walking away entirely. Subject to shareholder approval, he'll continue as director and vice chairman of the board. The bigger headline though is succession. Albindh Dhinza, the current CEO of Blinket will take over as CEO and step into Goyal's shoes. The timing made things even more interesting. The announcement came after market hours on a day
1:40 Speaker 00 when the stock had already jumped 5% on expectations of strong Q3 FY26 results. That momentum carried into Thursday's opening with the stock touching its highest level in two months. But by the end of the day, it had given up ground and closed down a little over 2.5%. And today, the stock seems to have slipped even further. That's a pretty mixed reaction for a stock over just two days. So let's see why. And to do that, let's first zoom into the Q3 FI26 results. Eternal reported a solid quarter on the surface. Revenues rose 20% quarter-on-quarter to 16,315 crore, beating Bloomberg estimates by about 1%.
2:21 Speaker 00 Operating profit, that is EBITDA, jumped even more sharply, up 54% quarter-on-quarter to 368 crore, which was nearly 10% better than what the street was expecting. That pushed margins up to 2.2% compared to 1.7% last quarter. Net profit also climbed, rising 57% quarter-on-quarter to 102 crore. But it still fell short of estimates by around 11%. So yes, the results are a bit of a mixed bag. And you might have also noticed something missing. We haven't spoken about year-on-year growth at all. That's intentional because the year-on-year comparison seems heavily distorted right now, largely because Blinket shifted from a marketplace model to an inventory-led one, starting Q1 FI26.
3:06 Speaker 00 That change mechanically inflates revenue and profit numbers, making straight year-on-year comparisons far less meaningful than they appear at first glance. Now, if you listen to our podcast on the removal of 10-minute delivery branding in quick commerce, this might sound familiar. In Blinket's original model, it wasn't really selling groceries as a retailer. It functioned more like a connector. Local Kirana stores or FMCG brands stock their products in Blinket's dark stores. When you place an order, Blinket matched you with the seller, handed the delivery, and took a commission for its service. The inventory didn't belong to Blinket, which meant it had limited control over pricing. And if products went unsold or spoiled, that risk sat with the seller. Now because of this, Blinket earned only a commission.
3:50 Speaker 00 So on a 500 rupees order, it pocketed roughly 18%, which is just a small slice of the total bill. Now contrast that with inventory-led model Blinket has shifted to. Here, it behaves like a traditional retailer. It buys goods directly from brands, stores them in its own dark stores, and sells them under its own name. That gives Blinket full control over pricing, but it also takes full responsibility if products remain unsold or lead to customer complaints. The upside however is that when you place a 500 rupees order, the entire amount comes to Blinkit. And after accounting for the wholesale cost of goods, whatever remains is its margin. This shift matters because the old model capped Blinkit's earnings by design as it could only earn a commission.
4:30 Speaker 00 The new model is riskier, but it allows Blinkit to retain a much larger share of every order, which can meaningfully improve profitability at scale. There is evidence that this works. Zepto, which has always operated on an inventory-led model reportedly earns higher margins of around 23%. But the point here is that this also changes how Blinkit reports its numbers. Earlier, it recognized only the commission as revenue. Now it recognizes the entire order value. So revenue and operating profit growth suddenly look explosive. As much as over 200% year-on-year growth in revenue from operations and over 125% year-on-year growth in EBITDA. If you look a little closer though, the picture is less rosy.
5:13 Speaker 00 Net profit margins have actually fallen from 1% in Q3 FY25 to 0.6% in the most recent quarter. Which tells you that while the headline numbers look impressive, the underlying improvement is far more modest than it first appears. There is another factor at play here apart from the broader market itself falling. It's the management change. And that's likely why the market's reaction looks so polarized. The easiest way to explain this is through something called the halo effect, sometimes also called the halo error. The term was coined by American psychologist Edward Thondike back in 1920. In simple terms, the halo effect is a cognitive bias where we form an overall often inaccurate judgment
5:56 Speaker 00 about something based on one strong positive trait. Over time, this idea made its way into business thinking too. When a company performs well, we tend to evaluate its leader too favorably. A classic example is Apple and Steve Jobs. Even today, many people instinctively link Apple's innovative edge to Jobs. Some even feel the company's innovation may have plateaued because he isn't around anymore. But that belief is shaped by bias because you don't really know what the alternative best-case scenario is. could have been. The same logic applies to Dipendar Goyal and Eternal. Goyal founded Zomato and took it from zero to one. It grew into a food delivery giant, went public and then expanded further through acquisitions
6:36 Speaker 00 of O2, rebranded as Hyper Pure, Growfer, which is now Blinket, and Paytm's entertainment ticketing business, which later became Distract. Now, that journey took the company from one to ten, and Eternal went from a single product business to a platform trying to do many things at once. Naturally, investors may end up attributing much of Eternal's success to Goyal alone, but if the company now wants to scale further, this transition might actually be the right moment to test what Eternal looks like under new leadership. Especially when that leadership comes from Albin Dinsa, the executive who turned Blinket into Eternal's fastest-growing vertical. In fact, there's some compelling research showing that founders who run their companies far too long can actually hurt valuations, sometimes by as much as fifty percent over time.
7:20 Speaker 00 Another study suggests that there's an optimal sweet spot for CEO tenure, that's about four point eight years. That's the point where performance tends to peak across customer satisfaction and employee relations, stock returns and, well, even volatility. Now, as the research puts it, in the early days, your founders' heroics were the engine of growth. You build the company to existence, but as you scale, those same heroics signal to investors that the machine is broken. They don't see a high-performing CEO, they see a single point of failure. If you are the hub in a hub-and-spoke model, you haven't built a business, you've built a high-paying job that no one else wants to buy. Not just that, studies from the University of Chicago and MIT suggest that individual
8:02 Speaker 00 CEOs account for just two to four percent of a company's overall performance. This means that keeping one leader at the helm for too long can quietly limit growth. Ideas saturate, perspectives narrow, and execution starts revolving around a single vision. So, yes, maybe the leadership change at Eternal is not only justified, but also well-timed. And we'll only have to wait and see if Dinsa's stint at CEO takes Eternal from ten to hundred as Goyal believes. I'll see you in the next one. Thank you for listening to today's episode. And if you want to share your feedback or suggestions, do drop us an email to [email protected] . Until next time.
Previous Why are Indians scared to invest in the stock market? Next Part 2: What will happen if India gets a 500% tariff? Page updated November 10, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated