Pod Insights Everyone's Talkin' Money Are You Moneying Too Hard? Here’s Why It’s Not Working About this episode What if you’re moneying too hard? Financial stress, constant budgeting, and trying to “get it right” with money can leave you feeling exhausted. Enter financial therapist Amanda Clayman, host of Emotional Investment on Audible, who believes true financial wellness isn’t about working harder—it’s about aligning your behaviors with your values, setting loving boundaries, and shifting money from a “problem to be solved” to a source of empowerment. And wait until you hear the wild story of her $19,000 haircut—it’s a lesson in money choices you won’t forget. In this vault episode, we dive into: Why we overcomplicate money (and how to stop) How to create financial wellness that actually feels good The infamous $19K haircut (yes, really) LINKS: Listen to Emotional Investment Connect with Amanda Clayman Follow Amanda on Instagram Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by State Farm. Football has a play for just about everything. You can go deep, keep it on the ground, or draw up something nobody sees coming. And whether you want to run a flea flicker or the tush push, you need a plan to fit your unique situation. That's why State Farm takes the time to get to know you so they can help personalize coverage for your life and budget. Now that's a solid game plan. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.
0:29 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed sponsored jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed sponsored jobs. Get a $75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.
0:59 Speaker 02 Your sausage muffin with egg didn't change. Your receipt did. The sausage muffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time.
1:11 Speaker 03 Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing.
1:14 Speaker 04 Hey, it's Shawna and welcome to Everyone's Talking Money.
1:26 Speaker 04 What's the hardest part of making financial changes? Well, you might think it would be a lot easier if I just made more money, but that's not always the case. Sometimes it's more about looking face to face at your money behaviors that show up. Why you make the choices you make does have a direct impact on your financial situation, the good, the bad, and everything in between. Now, yes, of course, I don't want to downplay the real issues with money, things like the pay gap and discrimination, cost of medical debt and college. These are all hard facts that unfortunately come with life. But financial challenges are sometimes just inevitable. So you must develop a healthy way to manage them and find ways to align your behaviors with your intentions.
2:09 Speaker 04 Our guest, she is amazing, my friend. Her name is Amanda Clayman. She's a financial therapist and host of Emotional Investment, an audio series on Audible. Amanda is the real deal. She thinks we all must stop moneying so hard and instead develop something called financial wellness. Financial wellness is all about shifting money from a problem to be solved to a source of empowerment. Sounds pretty good if you ask me. So sit back as we go in session with money therapist Amanda Clayman. Oh, and wait until she tells the story of the $19,000 haircut. That is really, really good. All right, let's start talking.
2:50 Speaker 04 I want to talk about this idea of financial wellness and I want to dig in a little bit and dissect it and really understand what it means. But before we get there, I just, I'm super curious. I have to ask you about the $19,000 haircut story because I feel like, I feel like we need to know these details. So tell us a little bit about this ridiculously expensive haircut.
3:16 Speaker 05 Well, the good thing is that the $19,000 was, was, I would say, over the course of time, really a bargain. Because what happened is that this haircut was really kind of the moment of clarity, of looking in the, in the literal mirror in terms of, of what was happening in my financial life and kind of recognizing a lot of the emotions and even the, the kinds of like, I would say the, the misconceptions that I had about money. So what had happened is I moved to New York City from the Midwest where I grew up when I was just out of college and I had all of the
4:00 Speaker 05 Bravery of a young adult and just none of the information about kind of what it would take to move to a high cost of living city, the kind of financial preparation that it would be prudent to make. And so when I landed in New York, there were a number of financial problems that I I had to contend with. Number one, I didn't have enough savings to put down a security deposit, to pay a broker's fee, like all of these really expensive things. And so in order to to land some housing and get on my feet, and I did have a job, thankfully, that I was starting, that really was the beginning of a cycle of debt for me, because I had to take on kind of all in one fell swoop, a pretty significant multiple
4:43 Speaker 05 thousands of dollars of credit card debt there in order to just get myself settled. And I was on a very, you know, entry level salary, and the debt just kind of kept creeping up and creeping up. And and I was getting further and further away from the kind of like entry level salary excuse. And I would expect that like my my financial ship was going to automatically right itself, and it really wasn't. So as the debt crept up, I got more and more anxious. And for me, anxiety equals avoidance. I'm sure any listeners can relate. And so the more anxious I I got about the damage and and like, you know, penalty fees,
5:26 Speaker 05 those penalty interest rates, all of that, my debt had crept up to what would now be about $31,000, but what was then $19,000. And my mother came to visit me in New York, and I asked her to cut my hair. And she used to cut my hair as a child. This was not so so unprecedented. But, you know, it had been at least a decade. And when she cut my hair, she did not do a good job, shall we say.
5:53 Speaker 04 I'm having visions of like a bowl cut or some, you know.
5:56 Speaker 05 Well, it's funny, because I do have a mullet now. But in in the mid 90s, when this story or late 90s, when this story takes place, mullets were not cool. And and it kind of looked at her, it was this asymmetrical lopsided mullet. And I promptly burst into tears. And my mother was horrified and sympathetic and said, Oh, don't worry, we'll call your hairdresser. We'll tell her it's an emergency. And I had that was when I had to confess, because I had actually paid my hairdresser with a check. That check had bounced. Like this was just one of the many pieces of this kind of financial house of cards that that was was so vulnerable to just one little tap to kind of fall down. And my mother was shocked and and that was just like I I had to say this happened.
6:40 Speaker 05 By the way, I have all of this debt. Oh, let me look literally under my bed and pull out this bag of bills that was slipping under there. But it took that kind of that moment of clarity of going like, oh, I am not some romantic bohemian who's, you know, just throwing herself at the world and figuring it out. I am a hot mess with bad hair who can't solve her own problems. And thankfully, I I that was the beginning of of some really like good truth telling with myself, with my loved ones. And that was really critical because what my mother really revealed to me in that conversation
7:24 Speaker 05 was the place that I was going really wrong is that I was using money and paying attention to money and money management as really like a tool of punishment for myself. I would take all of my money and just throw it at my credit cards, you know, trying to get those balances down, but then I wouldn't have any money left and I need to use my credit cards then to pay for expenses. So so she she gave me that piece of advice, which was a budget should be a tool of yes. What do you want to say yes to? And what I wanted to say yes to was financial stability. I wanted to pay down this debt and to not necessarily have to experience that as a penance,
8:04 Speaker 05 but rather to to reframe that as a as a growth experience for myself. And so I I joke that it's the $19,000 haircut because that really was like that was the haircut that made me pay back $19,000 in debt. But sometimes we have to look in the mirror, wouldn't you say?
8:23 Speaker 04 I think your story, though, is I thank you for like the transparency because I think it's something that so many of us can relate to. And I think The strange thing about money is we tend to think that the more money we make, the more we're immune to these feelings, or to being in debt, or to not knowing what to do, or to throwing money on our credit card, and not having a strategy, all of these things. And because we do our version of stuffing the bills under our bed, it feels very lonely, and it feels very scary and isolating. And, you know, I think for a lot of us, I've had this moment myself, where you reach that moment that you're talking about with the haircut,
9:06 Speaker 04 and it's like, okay, all the dominos have just collapsed, and you gotta figure something out. You know, so talk to, talk to somebody listening who's feeling a connection to, to your story and to these really strong emotions. How do you want them to maneuver their way through this very complex situation they might be in?
9:32 Speaker 05 So what I would say is that a lot of times, these, these moments of real crisis in our financial lives,
9:42 Speaker 05 and, and I, I want to use crisis in a, in a really kind of subjective way. Like, mine was a very emotional crisis, and it had a, a financial aspect attached to it. We can be dealing with lots of different kinds of, of even more severe crises than the one that I'm describing. But the crisis itself, I'd like to describe it as the thing that opens the door. It opens the door to looking at money. And, and it's that moment where we say, like, the way, the patterns that I'm just kind of acting out with my money, the ways that I, I habitually do this, the things that maybe feel intuitive to me, that is fundamentally, there's something about it that's not working, that's either too limiting, or, or I just really need to outgrow this. It's become exhausting.
10:27 Speaker 05 Maybe that's the kind of central, like, our, the struggle has just come to a point where we're exhausted with it. So the crisis is the thing that opens the door and it says, okay, I'm now willing to pay attention. Stress, you've got my, you've got my attention. Here I am, I'm looking at it. But that's just really the first step in, in bringing us in the direction of wellness. So I really, I, I think that alleviating the crisis can be the thing that, that brings people in to say like, I just need this to feel a little bit better because I'm really suffering. But as we're paying attention to it, then we can sort of look at those other pieces that
11:06 Speaker 05 need to be healed or, or where we have opportunities to grow. Like with my situation, um, I was carrying a lot of anxiety for my parents who had both grown up very poor. And I had, but I didn't have any awareness of that until I, I recognized how it was really unconsciously kind of pushing me towards certain behaviors. So, once people have, have opened that door, walked through that door, paying attention to money, the idea is, what can I find in this experience? It's going to help me be able to understand that money is this neutral resource that we
11:46 Speaker 05 project all kinds of meaning onto. And in fact, if we just pay attention to money and we can sort of develop good, healthy habits around it, these better behavioral patterns. Um, when we do that, what we're really doing is we're creating, I think, an opportunity for sustainable engagement in our lives with what's happening with us emotionally, relationally, how we want to use these resources in our life toward things that are important to us. Like, money can be this really great lens to, to experience your life. And I mean, I know that sounds really big, but like, to me, I feel like money is kind of the, this
12:28 Speaker 05 magical thing that's both a symbol and a tool. And it gives us all of these wonderful kind of therapeutic experiences. Um, if we kind of learn to work with money in a financial wellness framework, as opposed to just like, and here you can picture me kind of wagging my finger. Um, like, these are the rules and you follow the rules. And if you don't follow the rules, then you're a bad person.
12:53 Speaker 04 Bad person, yes.
12:54 Speaker 05 Yes. I, that, I wanted, I wanted just like, blow it at, yes, I want to kick that down.
12:59 Speaker 04 Yes. You and me both, you and me both. I really like what you said there and this idea of getting rid of the perfectionism around money. And so kind of coming back to this concept of financial wellness and healthy money habits. How do we create that without the finger wagging, without us thinking that, okay, now we have to follow like these other set rules in order to be financially well?
13:25 Speaker 05 I think part of it comes from really reframing why, why we're doing money in the first place. And the first place I would say a lot of us start, if this is not a natural kind of something that we're interested in, something that we find gratifying, the first thing that we want to do is just reduce or avoid pain. And so I mentioned earlier that for me, that's a lot of avoidance. So one of the first kind of fundamental aspects of financial wellness is the ability to pay attention and gather information while staying self-regulated and prioritizing that self-regulation. So it's, it's less about like, I really try to think of it as more of like an embodied
14:09 Speaker 05 financial experience as opposed to we're trying to transform the state of some external, like the number of zeros in your bank account. Like this is first and foremost, a, an experience of, of healing and growth. And money is just kind of the path that we're walking down. So, and that to me feels a lot kinder and more engaging.
14:34 Speaker 04 Yes.
14:35 Speaker 05 Then we're just all supposed to be, you know, chasing some kind of capitalist dream, fever dream, right?
14:42 Speaker 04 Right, robotic and.
14:43 Speaker 05 Right, yeah. Like I, I think it, it, we're, what we're doing is we're kind of putting the human being first and we're saying, how can money and, and the experience of money like enable this person to be their full human self? So we're reducing the anxiety, we're being able to pay attention and we're using that paying attention to not just focus on kind of the, the information that we're gathering, but also coming back into that place of like, am I, how's my heart rate doing? Am I feeling a buzzing in my ear? Like what is my physiological?
15:20 Speaker 05 Am I in the state of physiological arousal here because I'm so anxious? All right, let me just sort of, I can employ, I employ some, some tools to help kind of contain that. So we could do, for example, one of my tactics with folks is do not just have like a time that you're going to do money in your calendar, the, the time that you're going to pay attention to money. And that doesn't only have a start time, that has an end time.
15:48 Speaker 04 Yes.
15:48 Speaker 05 And the end time is, is really helpful in, in helping our brains and bodies to reduce the resistance to the task. Because when we feel like, oh, my gosh, I'm going to open this money box and every demon is going to jump out of it. And then I, I don't know if I'll be able to close that money box for five hours. That's a scary thing. We're right. It's logical to avoid tasks like that, that are overwhelming. We need to be functional in other aspects of our life, right? But if we kind of put a boundary on that, that can help make that endeavor feel safer. It increases our feeling of control over that, which is another thing that a lot of us are
16:32 Speaker 05 avoiding is that feeling of being so completely out of control and overwhelmed. And, and it gives us permission to say, I am in charge of how this task gets structured. I am an important resource and factor in this process, and I need to be my best me while I'm in here. So I, I love, actually, like, I love money's ability because we never get done with it, right? We're never going to be done. So it doesn't really behoove us to sprint.
17:03 Speaker 04 It's not going away.
17:04 Speaker 05 And that we're never going to be done with it. And we really benefit from paying attention to it in a regular basis. So as we're doing that, we're building these psychological capacities, these emotional capacities to pay attention to something, to find our way to re-regulate, to be able to stay out of that fight or flight zone so that we can, you know, do all of the cognitive tasks associated with money. And that becomes kind of a training ground, I would say, for better self-regulation across all the different domains of our lives. So money, I think, is kind of a lucky, we want to treat it this way.
17:43 Speaker 05 It's a really wonderful training ground for how to organize tasks and how to organize ourselves to feel like this is something that I can create a growth opportunity out of, not just, I don't want to do what the finger waggers say. That's not motivating to me. But what is motivating to me is I want to feel good and have my best life. And money is a part of it. And in fact, managing and sort of coming at this from a wellness perspective is not only going to help decrease the pain that I feel around this particular area of my life, but that can have really transformative effects, even, I would say, across the whole person.
18:31 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by State Farm. Football has a play for just about everything. You can go deep, keep it on the ground, or draw up something nobody sees coming. And whether you want to run a flea flicker or the tush push, you need a plan to fit your unique situation. That's why State Farm takes the time to get to know you so they can help personalize coverage for your life and budget. Now that's a solid game plan. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.
18:59 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed sponsored jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed sponsored jobs. Get a $75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.
19:29 Speaker 02 Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change. Your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time.
19:41 Speaker 03 Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing.
19:44 Speaker 04 All right, Amanda, it's time to play your relationship with money is. So question number one, if you had to describe your relationship to money as a cartoon character, who would it be?
19:55 Speaker 05 I think it would be Snoopy and Woodstock. And I specifically, I'm feeling like the Woodstock, but like Woodstock, if anybody's read these Peanuts cartoons, just kind of speaks in these little, there's no like words. But Snoopy understands what's happening. And I feel like that's a good, like that little voice that doesn't always make sense. The kind of like the friend who is attuned.
20:18 Speaker 04 I love it. That is so great. I love like the tandem aspect of that, too. Next question, tell me, what messages around money did you learn as a child?
20:30 Speaker 05 That money was scary and a source of shame. I learned those.
20:35 Speaker 04 I would imagine that a lot of people share that same sort of message from, from a child. And I think a lot of us, you might have more to add on this, but I think a lot of us don't even maybe recognize like, oh, that actually came from my childhood. I was talking to somebody the other day about my podcast and I was sharing about how a lot of our, the way we interact with money actually comes from what we saw and heard and didn't see and didn't hear as a child. And she was just in awe, like, that can't even be possible. And I thought, wow, okay, yeah, that just shows again how we don't, we don't connect those things together.
21:15 Speaker 05 Right. I mean, what I learned was all implicit. Nobody ever taught me anything or sat down and said money is this, that, or the other. But being a sensitive person, I absolutely absorbed the message that there was something inherently shameful about poverty and having less than other people. But that the relief to that shame would come in having money and getting to some kind of fantasy place where there would be enough that we, as a family, would be freed from shame. That was the thing that was. Driving us in a large way, but I didn't see that at the time.
21:59 Speaker 04 All right, flipping the switch just a little bit. Tell me, what is the your most favorite best thing ever that you've spent money on?
22:09 Speaker 05 The best thing that I've spent money on are classes. Oh, my gosh, I cannot stop spending money on classes.
22:17 Speaker 05 And I would be hard pressed to say I did this wonderful class recently at the Context Institute around kind of like future planning. And I took a sociology of emotions class at UCLA Extension recently. And that just really blew my mind.
22:35 Speaker 04 All right, last question, this one specifically for the the money therapist in you. If you could change, just wave a magic wand and change one thing about money for everyone, what would that be?
22:48 Speaker 05 I would change the way that we educate people around money. I would teach it as as part of not only sort of the the lessons of how money works, but really getting into the dilemmas around money. You know, like, what does it mean when a friend has more or less money than you? What does it mean when you really want something, but you don't have the money to get it? What like to to bring people into this conversation to elicit that sense of an internally authentic voice that has the right to express itself through money and through financial
23:32 Speaker 05 behavior, as opposed to just there are right behaviors and there are wrong behaviors and you're either on one side or the other.
23:44 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by State Farm. Football has a play for just about everything. You can go deep, keep it on the ground, or draw up something nobody sees coming. And whether you want to run a flea flicker or the tush push, you need a plan to fit your unique situation. That's why State Farm takes the time to get to know you so they can help personalize coverage for your life and budget. Now that's a solid game plan. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.
24:13 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed sponsored jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed sponsored jobs. Get a $75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.
24:42 Speaker 02 Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change. Your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time.
24:54 Speaker 03 Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing.
24:57 Speaker 04 I love that, that trick about a start and an end time. It's something I started doing a couple of weeks ago because I get, you know, down a task and then I get all over the place. And so I started like, okay, let me set like a 15 minute timer or 20 minute timer. And it's just so great because you're right, like psychologically, you know, that there is an end time where you have given yourself permission to walk away from money or whatever the task is. And I think that so often we overlook these practices around money. You're saying, you know, paying attention to what's going on. Are you, you know, your ears buzzing?
25:42 Speaker 04 Is your heart racing? Are you clenching? Is your jaw clenching? You know, breathing, we forget to breathe and, and all of these tools that help, help us in that situation, deal with whatever we need to deal with money. But those things are usually overlooked in the conversation where we're talking about money strategy or, or any of that. And it's really frustrating to me because. I don't know how you feel about this. I would imagine it's similar. So much of our relationship with money is bound up in feelings of shame and judgment. And a lot of times those are put on ourselves, but we just, we don't even know how to escape it.
26:24 Speaker 05 And it's overwhelming. Like, I, I think there's not enough awareness in our conversations about money of how important the body is, not only as kind of our, our, it's giving us a lot of signals that are important, but literally when we are in that fight or flight state of limbic arousal, our higher cognitive functions are offline. So we may be, let's say that we're even like forcing ourselves to kind of put the butt in the chair and look at money. All right, I'm gonna do it. But if we are in that kind of teeth clenched, white knuckle state, I would, I would argue how, how effective are we in that state? Because when we're at that level of arousal, everything that
27:08 Speaker 05 we perceive is going to, is going through a kind of threat filter.
27:14 Speaker 04 Right. That's like those moments where we feel like the tiger's chase, right? Yeah. And we don't know the difference.
27:19 Speaker 05 And, and something I kind of learned recently about this is I, and I love this term, maybe you're familiar with it, but have you ever heard the term long-term urgency?
27:29 Speaker 04 I have, yes.
27:30 Speaker 05 That I feel like should be like everywhere in how we think about money. And, and basically it's the idea of like, this is something that is urgent, but occurs over the long term. And these are the kind of things that often are easy to ignore today with the, the intention that we're going to get to it tomorrow. And one of the things that we know about acting consistently toward our long-term urgent goals is that there needs to be more of a pull, kind of, we need to be pulled forward into something. We need to sort of feel Like there's something attractive that we're moving in the direction of as opposed to, you know, there's that hungry tiger behind me and my motivation is to flee it.
28:15 Speaker 05 Because that motivation is immediate, short term, decontextualized. Usually we're only kind of like, it's me with my credit card bill, right? Like I'm going to, oh, this bill is really stressful. Here's how much money I have in my bank account. I'm going to give it all to that thing because that's the tiger that's right in front of me that I'm scared of. There's no strategy in that. So this long-term urgency really is, is I think a call to reconfigure what our motivations are around money. And that means I think in many cases, kind of pushing back against the culture.
28:55 Speaker 05 That gives us so many misleading and negative and toxic messages about kind of what the quote unquote right things are to do. Like, how, how do we do that practically? Like, how do we push back? Well, I think sometimes it's an act of psychic survival. Like, like for me, I really, I was in the place of such shame that it was either, and, and that shame was just, it was eating at every other area of my life. Like no matter what success I had as a good friend or in my job. Um, I always felt like, well, if people really knew what a mess I am with money,
29:35 Speaker 05 then they would know that I'm like, you know, in my worst moments, I would be like, I am a complete garbage person. I am an imposter, like. So the act of psychic survival was this emotional dynamic is going to take me into a, a really destructive and potentially dangerous place. I need help and I don't know where that help is. So the first thing that I did was just be honest with a trusted person. And we spend so much time pretending that everything is fine, especially with money, that this is a really hard thing to do. And I think this is a place where the cultural programming really pushes back.
30:17 Speaker 05 Um, and says, gives us all kinds of things about like money isn't a polite topic. It's, you know, off limits. You should never ask somebody kind of about how they do money.
30:29 Speaker 05 But there was something in me that needed to survive and really hoped that the mean voice in my head was was wrong and that there was something better out there if I was brave enough to overcome the silence and the shame and to go looking for it. And that's the reason why I like do podcasts and write and practice and like I, I want to reach the people who are experiencing that level of shame and say, go look, look outside of that, connect, find something, begin the journey, walk through that door. There's beauty on the other side.
31:05 Speaker 04 Oh, I love that. I just got chills. That's great. Um, I, I, I want to talk a little bit about your, your Amazon series, Emotional Investment. I know that you help individuals and couples really solve their money dilemmas. And I would imagine as a financial therapist, you've, you know, you've seen, you've seen some things. How do people, I guess maybe it's a two parter, how do people get stuck financially? And then how do you see people get to the other side, get unstuck? Are there any commonalities that a lot of us share that again, we're not having these conversations, so we don't know that we share these things?
31:44 Speaker 05 Well, that's a really important thing. The last thing that you said, that, that there's so many commonalities out there, but because we're not talking about them, we don't know. People, I would say, get stuck when there are two things missing. Either emotional capacity is overwhelmed around this topic. So when we try to, to explore the dilemmas or kind of go into the, the, whatever the financial problem is, we get emotionally swamped. And that kind of like, you know, that becomes the priority of our brain and body is just that physiological experience.
32:21 Speaker 04 And then we can't do anything else.
32:23 Speaker 05 Until we, we find the way back to self-regulation. And so, so the first thing is, is sort of like that, that the disproportionate kind of danger response that's happening to us about money. And, and the other one is an information gap. A lot of time, and I would say that the two of these really play off of each other. Um, so it's like when we're feeling anxious, we are, are thinking like, it's like our brain just finds all of the negative data to sort of reinforce that feeling and confirm that the feeling that we're having is correct. And so gathering information is usually like the first place that I start with people because it's the place where we need to just make sure that, that
33:09 Speaker 05 like information gathering is a resource skill. And if, and it's the first capacity that we need to develop in order to be able to have the, the construction materials, if you will, to build our way out of our present situation into the place that we're, we're trying to get to.
33:29 Speaker 04 So in, in part of that process, the gathering information, are we also looking for ways in which we haven't been a terrible horrible person around money, like things that we've done well along the way, or skills that we have that are actual strengths that maybe we've just convinced ourselves that they are not?
33:48 Speaker 05 Absolutely. I mean, I think that's one of the things that people find most surprising in working with financial therapists is that they, you know, like I'm not mean, I'm not mad at people. I'm not, I'm not there to say like,
34:02 Speaker 04 What do you mean? You're not gonna, come on, come on. Isn't that the way we do money talk, right? We just yell at people and tell them they're horrible and terrible and send them on their way.
34:12 Speaker 05 Like I, I believe that all financial behavior has meaning. I mean, all behavior has meaning, but financial behavior in particular, like we're always trying to, to meet a need of some kind, whether that's just like, I'm hungry and tired and I need to like grab a sugary caffeinated drink, or whether that's like, I, I feel safer in my social group when I have the same bag, you know, as the other people in my group. Like humans are funny. Like those are both kind of safety concerns of, of different varieties.
34:48 Speaker 05 I I think all of that is beautiful and interesting. None of it is bad or good in the sense that there's some kind of like moral stamp. And even things that that people tend to be really self critical about like being impulsive. For example, with money. And there are ways that we can kind of like develop guardrails around that in different practices that can help to curb that. But impulsivity in itself isn't necessarily a moral failing. So we're we're kind of like we're we're neutralizing or trying to to view with a neutral eye.
35:28 Speaker 05 What is happening with the money to connect that with the things that are more or less important to us and those things that are important to us like I I recently worked with someone and part of her homework was I said, I want you to go through your credit card statement. And those things that you enjoy, like when you look at I want you to remember those experiences and those and to luxuriate in those things that felt good. Feel them, right? When you're spending money, like one of her things was social spending. So like on those times, like, think about what felt good to you about going out to a meal
36:08 Speaker 05 with a friend and try to identify those different parts of that experience that maybe could be either we we kind of can maybe curb some of the spending on other areas that are less important, or we can say the thing that I really enjoy about this social spending is XYZ. I I love the feeling of glamour, you know, going out and getting dressed up. That feels really fun. I mean, you could have a fancy dinner party that can be a potluck at your house. You know, we can get creative about these things. Once we, once we give ourselves permission to love what we love and then try to make that.
36:54 Speaker 05 Fit as well as we can with the facts of our financial situation. And that's really just a, I see that as kind of a puzzle that we put together. We look at the money stuff, we look at the feeling stuff and we look at those simultaneously.
37:10 Speaker 04 I, I really love that. You know, I often say that our, our spending, it tells a story of us and we want to make sure that it's telling a story that we actually enjoy. And I think that, yeah, we spend a lot of time listening to money advice that is about limiting everything that we enjoy to the point where we, we don't feel human. And then I think all of those nasty emotions around money come up because it's like, well, I can't do anything that I enjoy apparent.
37:39 Speaker 05 Right.
37:40 Speaker 04 And it's just not that simple. So I love what you're saying here is it is this puzzle. It's putting these pieces together and there are lots of different ways to put this puzzle together. There's not just one way. And that's, I think what's really, uh, really interesting about bringing creativity and like curiosity to, uh, to our money situation. Well, I was wondering, so you, you talked to us about one trick about setting a time. I was wondering, are there any other little tips or exercises that you could share with us that we could put into practice today if we wanted to?
38:17 Speaker 05 Yes, I, I really think that it's helpful to differentiate between our committed spending and our discretionary spending. I don't love needs wants. I think that that's a really kind of judgmental framework. Um, what I think of it in terms of is kind of cognitive load. So what are the things I've already decided? These are my committed expenses. I've made a decision. I've signed a lease. I've gotten a cell phone plan.
38:45 Speaker 04 Done, yeah.
38:46 Speaker 05 These are done. I can kind of just, if I, if I can add all of those things up, that's a number and those are my committed expenses and they're easy to predict. That narrows what we're trying to track and pay attention to in our lives. And I'm, I'm using this as an example specifically around changing spending.
39:08 Speaker 05 The discretionary stuff, then we get to get interesting and creative in it. And I use a framework of review, predict, plan. So we're kind of reviewing what happened last time with the discretionary, like, did everything go last month as I, as I thought? Or were there some kind of surprises that came up along the way? Did some of my intentions maybe not work as planned? Then we predict, we look at the time ahead. Where am I going to be? Who am I spending time with? Anything that's out of the ordinary. Like, maybe I'm going to a wedding. Maybe it's my friend's birthday. Maybe I am going to be taking, I'm not able to work and I'm not getting paid. So my income's going to be different for these many days.
39:51 Speaker 05 We're, we're predicting kind of what are the knowable things coming up? And then we make that, we set our puzzle pieces for that month. Um, because that puzzle, you don't just do it once, right? Um, that is an ongoing process. So in that sense of, of trying to bring the decision-making, like to, to partialize, these are the decisions I've already made. These are the decisions that I need to make about the near future. And to consider all of those, or as much as you can, in the context of how these things fit together.
40:26 Speaker 05 It doesn't mean that we're not still kind of doing impulsive things necessarily, but it helps us have a much fuller picture. So that it's not just like, what's a $5 Starbucks? It's more like, where does this $5 Starbucks fit within all of the other decisions that I need to make around my money?
40:48 Speaker 04 So, yeah, you need both parts. You need the classic money advice because that's how you transform the numbers piece of your wealth. But you can't overlook the financial wellness piece because that's how you transform your emotions around money. So if you understand and have the tools to manage your emotions, guess what happens? You are motivated to do the things you need to do to change the numbers piece of your wealth. That's why a session with a financial therapist like Amanda Clayman could be just what the doctor ordered. You can find out more about Amanda on her website, amandaclyman.com, or head to her Audible series to listen to Emotional Investment. I will have all those links in the show notes, as well as links to our sponsors who make this show
41:32 Speaker 04 possible. Please go over and give them some love, and I will see you back here in a few days for a brand new episode.
41:50 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by State Farm. Football has a play for just about everything. You can go deep, keep it on the ground, or draw up something nobody sees coming. And whether you want to run a flea flicker or the tush push, you need a plan to fit your unique situation. That's why State Farm takes the time to get to know you, so they can help personalize coverage for your life and budget. Now that's a solid game plan. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.
42:18 Speaker 02 Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change, your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5, only at McDonald's for a limited time.
42:30 Speaker 03 Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing.
Previous Tariffs Are Screwing Your Wallet—Here’s How to Fight Back Next How Paula Poundstone Dug Out of $1M Debt—With a Sense of Humor Page updated November 7, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated