Pod Insights Equity Podcast Yes, we're talking about Elon About this episode This is our Wednesday show, where we niche down to a single topic, think about a question and unpack the rest. This week, Natasha was out due to a family matter, so Alex and Amanda came together to chat through the larger Elon Musk-Twitter saga.
Yes, the TechCrunch crew got together on Tuesday for a very long, fun, and relaxed Twitter Space when the news broke. However, instead of going back through all that audio to just pull out the key bits, we decided to focus ourselves down to the core elements of that team chat and produce something a bit tighter.
Here's our question set:
How much of an active participant will Elon really be?
What does the deal mean for Twitter employees?
What impact will the sale have on security, and algorithmic transparency?
The free speech question
What does the transaction mean for users?
In case you need more, our coverage of locked code changes is here, more on the privacy question here, and our larger tick-tock can be read here. Ok, we are live on Thursday for the live show! Chat then!
Credits: Equity is produced by Theresa Loconsolo with editing by Kell. Bryce Durbin is our Illustrator. We'd also like to thank the audience development team and Henry Pickavet, who manages TechCrunch audio products.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript 0:11 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome back to Equity, a podcast all about the business of startups where we unpack the numbers and the nuance behind the headlines. This is our Wednesday show where we niche down to a single topic, ask a question, and then unpack the rest. Well, as you can already tell, I am not Natasha. She had a family emergency and therefore will not be joining us. She will be back. Do not worry. And we're sending her all of our love and kindness. I hope she's doing well. Now, this is me doing the show, so it's gonna be a little bit different. And I'm not going to be doing a 20-minute speech, so I brought along a friend. I have Amanda Silverling with us. She's one of TechCrunch's newest and greatest and most interesting and most fun writers to read. Amanda, welcome back.
0:45 Speaker 01 Hello. That was so nice. You know, Natasha once called me the most online writer at TechCrunch on Equity, and I feel like whenever I go on, it's like a free compliment.
0:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, the issue with that is that used to be me, and now I'm no longer the most online person at TCA. And I don't really know how I feel about that. You know, it's a badge of honor, but also not at the same time. Does that make sense?
1:05 Speaker 01 I think that you're very online in the literal sense, but in the sense of knowing weird memes from like 10 years ago that were on Tumblr, like My Immortal, which we found out you do not know what it is.
1:17 Speaker 00 True.
1:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, I did do a Twitter poll, and my followers were more likely to know what My Immortal is than not to know what it is.
1:23 Speaker 00 In my defense, when we discuss the whole concept of being online, there's various online buckets. And I think that the phrase that you're using is to a very specific demographic and a point in time, important cultural time on the internet, that's now kind of gone. And now, I'm not just rambling, by the way, we're getting to a point here, which is that being online is not a good or bad thing, but some people could use less time on the internet, perhaps. One of those people, just throwing a name out there, Amanda, just having a little kind of a brain sash here, maybe Elon Musk, you know, could be online a little bit less than he currently is. Maybe he missed the Tumblr era, but he certainly made a lot of news this week and kind of upended our plans as a news team. We're going to talk about this today. We're going to talk about the Twitter. And Elon Musk deal, and we're gonna do this in the form of questions. So we're gonna ask a couple of questions as a pair and talk through what's going on.
2:06 Speaker 00 But Amanda, for those people who are on Twitter too much, they may have seen this yesterday talking about something similar. So why are we here today doing this again?
2:13 Speaker 01 I think there's just so much to unpack with what it means for one of the richest men in the world, if not the richest man in the world, to buy a platform that is, I mean, I do think he's right when he calls it the de facto town square, so to speak. But I think there's also a lot at stake with that public town square changing hands into the hands of somebody who historically, just as CEO of Tesla, not to mention all his other companies, has been busting unions. He's been sued for racial discrimination in his workplace.
2:49 Speaker 00 Yep.
2:50 Speaker 01 It's like the list goes on.
2:51 Speaker 00 Controversial, I think, is what we might call Mr. Musk, but we're all familiar with him. We all know what's going on. And the reason why we're not just playing for you our Twitter space that we recorded yesterday with really the kind of the TechRunch family, if you will, that was a good time. It's too long, it's a little bit meandering, and the audio quality is a little bit mismatched. So what we've done is we've gone back through it, pulled out the highlights, the key questions, the key things to dive into, and we're gonna do that for you today, but with less audio crackling and children screaming in the background.
3:15 Speaker 01 Sorry, the children were my fault. Not, I don't have children, but I was just sitting outside on a street and some children walked by. But now here we are, not outside.
3:24 Speaker 00 I spent a chunk of the Twitter space in my backyard playing with my dogs and just muting and unmuting myself, and I think it went okay.
3:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, I had no idea.
3:29 Speaker 00 Twitter spaces are casual.
3:30 Speaker 01 Wow.
3:30 Speaker 00 Yeah, see, exactly. Ninja. All right, so the first question that we're gonna dive into today, Amanda, is just how much of an active participant Elon Musk is going to be in the management of Twitter? I'm going to let you have first bite of the sample.
3:41 Speaker 01 I hope he's not very active, but that's extremely optimistic thinking.
3:46 Speaker 00 Why do you think a less engaged Elon is a better situation for Twitter?
3:50 Speaker 01 I think that some of his plans just don't really seem fully formed. He seems like someone who will kind of go on a power trip and make things happen without fully thinking about the implications. I said this on the Twitter space yesterday, but a constant recurring theme in tech is that when you have people who are in positions of extreme power, building and controlling services that people of all walks of life use and that have the capacity for harassment, they're not thinking about how things can be used in the worst possible way. So things like open sourcing the algorithm, verifying all human beings, making Twitter more of a
4:34 Speaker 01 free speech first platform, whatever that means to Elon Musk. These are things that to somebody in a position of power, they may seem good in theory. But then when you think about how this affects people that are most vulnerable, there's a lot of room for this to enable even more harassment. And we know Twitter's a place where harassment already happens because it's the internet.
4:53 Speaker 00 Yeah. If you don't know about the harassment problem on Twitter, be a woman and be a reporter for a couple of months. I literally check in with my friends who are women and are reporters because I get so little harassment. I get pot shots occasionally, but like not much, you know, I don't even get that much hate mail. Don't start everybody, but like, I don't, I don't get that much of it. So I'm always looking at the internet through a much more rosy lens, which is why, Amanda, I wanted you to take a punch at that. Daryl called him the Eye of Sauron yesterday on our chat. And I think that the analogy is pretty good because if you recall in the Lord of the Rings realm and kind of lore, the Eye of Sauron can fix itself to one point of Middle Earth at any given time. And Elon, Amanda, as you pointed out, has a couple of jobs. He has the Boring Company, he's got SpaceX going on, Tesla is of course very busy. And now he's throwing Twitter onto the mix. I don't think it's actually physically humanly possible to run all the companies at once.
5:37 Speaker 00 So when it comes to his activity, I wonder if we're asking the wrong question. I wonder if the question is, how much will he give whatever person becomes the de facto COO at Twitter? How much room do they get to pursue their own perspectives? And how much are they just taking marching orders from Elon's Twitter feed, you know?
5:51 Speaker 01 Yeah. And I think it's so interesting too, because Twitter's already had a huge executive shakeup in the last couple of months with Jack Dorsey suddenly stepping down and Parag Agarwal, who was the CTO before taking the CEO role.
6:05 Speaker 00 Poor guy. I mean, can you imagine, like you're there at Twitter, Jack's leaving, you're the CTO, you probably don't. Really wanna be CEO because the CTOs tend to like being CTOs, in my experience at least. And then suddenly the entire world stares at you at once.
6:18 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:18 Speaker 00 And then the company gets sold out from underneath you effectively. Ah, it's just what a mess. I feel sorry for the guy. But Twitter employees are an enormous part of this picture because of course they are the people that make Twitter run. And in the last 18 months, as we've all said, Twitter's had a pretty solid product run or at least product cadence. Not everything's been a hit fleets. No one is really saying RIP, but Twitter's been on a roll to some degree. And so the question is, what portion of Twitter's staff want to stay and work to generate more wealth for Elon Musk? I don't know the answer to that. I don't think it's a hundred percent. It's not zero. Amanda, what are you thinking? People are gonna get poached pretty often here or is Twitter gonna stick around?
6:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think for Twitter employees, it's a big time of uncertainty. I wrote about how Bloomberg had a scoop that Twitter is locking down its code. So that only VPs can make changes to the product because they were worried about what if somebody who is angry about the situation goes rogue and just messes around with a platform that millions of people are using. I think that kind of speaks to the sentiment of they don't think everything is hunky dory on the staff. And people have tweeted being like, what happens to our stock options? Because suddenly you're not working for a publicly traded company.
7:30 Speaker 00 RSUs or grants, but yeah, there's nuance to it. It's a good point, but I think it just goes to show like how this came together so quickly. This wasn't a deal that was fully hammered out ahead of time, behind closed doors, and then presented to the world. It's a deal that got dragged to the front door screaming, you know? And so, no, not everything is sorted out. Yes, there is a lot of uncertainty at Twitter. And it's critically uncertain that the current CEO can't actually resolve. Because there's uncertainty based on what happens once it's sold and it's not yet sold. The shareholders haven't voted yet. It's not done. It's pretty much done, but there's still official things to happen. On the security front there, on the whole idea of working on the Twitter product. Elon has mentioned things like verifying or not registering.
8:08 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:09 Speaker 00 Individual humans. What was the language there?
8:11 Speaker 01 The language. Essentially, the idea is that you confirm that a person is a real person and not a bot. But Carly Page for Tech. Crunch wrote about what's at stake with open sourcing the algorithm and the cybersecurity ideas that Elon Musk has. He's really excited about potentially figuring out a way to solve the bot issue on Twitter, where there's a lot of crypto scam bots and whatnot.
8:37 Speaker 00 Just a few.
8:38 Speaker 01 And in Carly's article, she quoted the EFF saying that, at least in regard to the issue of verifying humans are humans, that anonymity is essential to protecting users who may have opinions, identities, or interests that do not align with those in power. And I think that is really important. Like, I cover labor movements in tech quite often, and a lot of the time, there are Twitter accounts like Apple too, where it's Apple employees speaking out about mistreatment, but it's not tied to a specific person because then they wouldn't have the power to speak out because their job would be at stake. So I thought that was an interesting point about that.
9:17 Speaker 00 I mean, that's a much better angle than I was gonna take. You're out here protecting people that are often discriminated against. I was gonna rise up and speak in favor of the crypto community who really hold on to anonymity and pseudo anonymity as kind of a cultural construct of their world. And we've seen some reporting on individuals in the crypto space to very negative reaction from the community. And then Elon said that they're all gonna have to register into their real name. And so to me, there's some dissonance here between the woo Elon crowd and people who now may have to register into their real name. I personally don't mind because I've done it by real name anyways, but I'm also the most generic white dude in America, so I'm not exactly a target. So I'm worried about that. I'm also worried about the open sourcing of the algorithm, though, because if you make the code available,
9:59 Speaker 00 everyone can kind of figure out how to hack around it. And so I understand the impetus there, but I'm curious about the implementation.
10:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's one of those things where it feels like it seems good in theory, where it could be really cool if there's a greater understanding of how algorithms work. So often on social media, it's very mysterious what the algorithm is actually seeking to do and surface. And that has been brought up pretty frequently as an issue that leads to misinformation and that leads to inflammatory Content on social media, et cetera. But if you make the code open source, then that also aids bad actors because they know exactly how to dupe the code and trick the code and whatnot. And also in Carly's article, the senior technical manager at the security firm Extra Hop,
10:48 Speaker 01 Jamie Moles, said that this could make Twitter a much bigger target for attackers. And then when you think about how many US politicians at least use Twitter as a way to communicate with constituents, that's really scary.
11:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, Twitter is a company. It is a private company that it's owned by individuals. It is a public company in that it's on the stock market, but it is in no way part of the government. And so it doesn't have the same First Amendment questions regarding its users as people want it to. And I think the general vibe of having space for people to talk is good. But really, there's been a lot of talk about the kind of broader free speech question. And the thing that I'm struggling with overall, Amanda, is the idea that Twitter has somehow been stifling speech. Like, they let Trump be on after he broke the rules a while before they booted him. And it seems to be that the company has made lots of room for people to talk, at least according to my Twitter feed, people are nice and busy. So what is this free speech argument that people keep bringing up?
11:45 Speaker 00 What's going to now be allowed on Twitter that was previously banned?
11:49 Speaker 01 That's my reaction. But so often, there is a confusion about what the First Amendment and free speech actually means. The First Amendment protects people in the US. Like, you can say anything you want about Joe Biden and nothing will happen to you, which, that's a good thing. There are many countries where you cannot say whatever you want about government officials, and that stifles public debate, obviously. But on Twitter, the difference is that there are rules around, like, don't harass people, don't make targeted attacks, don't release people's personal information, don't spread misinformation about COVID.
12:29 Speaker 01 There's things like that that just sort of make Twitter, in my opinion, a more healthy place to spend time than, let's say, Parler, for instance, which takes Very similar approach where they're basically like, anything goes as long as you don't get us kicked off the App Store, which I mean, that's a whole other layer of like,
12:48 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah. But like, I've been perplexed by this idea that Twitter's still going to have a different free speech setup when all the other Twitter like applications that have been set up to have a by their own advertising, more free speech focus have terms of service that seem very much like Twitter. They don't seem to be super different. You know, you can't break the law. You can't, you know, tell people you're gonna murder them.
13:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, I don't think that Twitter's terms of service currently is super stringent, but it brings up the question of what do people like Elon Musk, who again are often people that are white men with a lot of money that have a lot of institutional power. What do they think is at stake?
13:27 Speaker 00 That's the thing. I can't figure it out.
13:28 Speaker 01 But even like, for example, a policy that Twitter has is that you aren't allowed to dead name a trans person. Like if you're repeatedly using the name that they do not go by, that is not their name, then you can be suspended from Twitter. And seems like a basic level of human respect that you want to call people by the name they want to be called by. But I guess some people would argue that like, now we can't debate whether trans people are humans, but like they're
13:58 Speaker 00 Well, you can. You just
14:00 Speaker 01 This is maybe not phrased the best way, but yeah.
14:03 Speaker 00 I don't see a lot of restrictions in Twitter's TOS and setup that are highly restricted for free speech in any way that conservative run Twitter clones don't also have. The only thing that I can think of is the purported, and as far as I can tell, entirely artificial belief that social media is somehow trying to infringe upon quote conservative views, which in America really means far right reactionary. If you're not in the States, you need to have a translation there, which is not true. What there has been is a work to cut down on disinformation. And I think that does impact certain parts of the political spectrum a little bit more than others, depending on which country you're in and so forth. But I think people are going to be disappointed when Elon does eventually buy Twitter that suddenly doesn't change much. That's my take. I think for a while, it's going to be pretty much the same. And it's gonna be kind of embarrassing to people who are like, oh, thank God Elon's
14:45 Speaker 00 gonna save it. And it's gonna be tweets, you know, in a row, as it has been for all of my life, you know?
14:51 Speaker 01 Yeah. Also, I'm just gonna make a note. Maybe the trans policy thing is not the best route to go, because then people get very angry, but whatever.
14:59 Speaker 00 No, no, I mean, like, look, I just, I'm an absolutist about this. No being dicks to trans people. It's not necessary. It's nonproductive. It's not intellectual. And it's just mean. And so to me, like, in the way that, like, casual homophobia back in the day when it was more common was a great indicator that someone that you're talking to is kind of a jerk, you know? For me, anyone who complains that I have pronouns in my bio, I can just kind of write them off, because all they want to do is find some sort of nitpicky issue with something and just quibble about it. And I would rather stick my head in a barrel full of lava than entertain morons. Yeah, just no patience for it.
15:33 Speaker 01 Yeah. Okay. So the end of the bracket. But yeah, even at Elon Musk's TED conversation that happened last week, he said that one of his goals for Twitter is for it to be a place where people can disagree with each other and have open civil discourse. But I don't think Twitter isn't currently that place. And I don't think that any lessening of the strictness of the Terms of Service, which aren't very strict, I don't think that would make it more of a place where people can have civil discourse, because then you're just kind of making it easier for people to harass each other. But I think he has this idea that because people disagree with him, that means that they're not being
16:14 Speaker 01 civil and in good faith in their discourse or whatever. But one example is recently, he made a meme comparing Justin Trudeau to Hitler, and people got mad about it, because Hitler jokes are not funny. And then he ended up deleting the tweet himself. But that was a decision that he made, because people voiced their dissent with his view on what is comedic or not. And isn't that what he wants? Doesn't he want people to disagree with him? And then he made the decision himself that, yeah, maybe that joke wasn't in good taste. I'm gonna take it down.
16:47 Speaker 00 It's the market in action, which is why Twitter seems to work today. We were all on Twitter last- Last week before Elon bought it or announced that he was going to successfully get a shot at buying it. I'm going to be on it the week afterwards. The thing that I have to say, man, is that I'm just, I'm too far gone to start anywhere else. Like, I'm, I'm not.
17:03 Speaker 01 Yeah.
17:03 Speaker 00 If I'm the last person on Twitter, it's going to be me, age 94, in the nursing home with one of those big ass iPads, you know, typing on my tweet one at a time, like, not feeling w- and then I'll die doing my last tweet. But that's me, you know, I respect that some people are going to leave. And as a final question for us today, let's do something dangerous. Let's do some predictions and do some prognostication and shoot for the future here. Twitter user growth faster or slower after Elon completes the transaction?
17:30 Speaker 01 Honestly, I would say maybe about the same because I think some people might be like, oh, cool. Tucker Carlson's back. That's my guy. And then maybe the same amount of people will be like, I hate billionaires. I'm going to go on Tumblr, even though I've never seen the TV show Supernatural. And nobody who hasn't seen Supernatural should be on Tumblr.
17:52 Speaker 00 What is Supernatural?
17:54 Speaker 01 I haven't even seen it, but it's just this show that like, it's been on for like 15 years and people are still actively obsessed with it on Tumblr. And that is my impression of Tumblr culture. And people don't realize that it is still a health site as much as it was in 2012.
18:07 Speaker 00 Oh, no, nothing ever gets better on the internet. I mean, think about the content moderation issues that Tumblr has had over the years. Remember when Yahoo deleted all the porn?
18:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, remember when Yahoo like deleted all the porn on Tumblr and then also ran Flickr into the ground? And now we work for Yahoo.
18:21 Speaker 00 Um, I can neither confirm nor deny what happened to Flickr, but that has been our discussion. No, you're welcome to the show. Say whatever you want. It's a free speech show, Amanda. You're always welcome to speak your mind.
18:32 Speaker 01 Yeah.
18:33 Speaker 00 But Amanda, we should come to a conclusion here, but I want to remind everybody that this Thursday, we are recording the Friday episode of Equity Live. We do this every two weeks. You can come hang out on Hoppin'. You can come hang out on Twitter Spaces. We chat away through the show and then we hang out for a bit, ask a couple of questions, answer a couple of questions, have a good time. We would love to see you in the show post on TC. There is a link to sign up. It's always free to come hang out with us. We use Hoppin', so people can ask questions, but you can just be on Twitter Spaces if you'd like, and we'll see you then. Our heart goes out to Natasha and her family. All right. Bye.
19:00 Speaker 01 Bye.
Previous What will Elon actually do if he buys Twitter? Next Does it smell like teen spirit, or teen bankruptcy? Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated