Pod Insights Equity Podcast Instacart now delivers market trends About this episode Welcome to our Friday show! Our regular co-host Natasha was off this time, so Mary Ann and Alex linked arms with our producer Grace to blast our way through the news of the week. As always, we had to pick and choose what seemed to matter the most.
Here's what we got into:
All Things Y Combinator: Here's our first set of favs, and our second. Here's a rundown of fintech companies from the batch, and our look at the Indian participants, and those hailing from Africa.
Instacart as trendsetter: The well-known grocery delivery company has lowered the price at which it will value employee equity comp, something that could become a trend. It seems so, with Instacart leading a potential vanguard of similar actions from other companies in time. Also we're thinking about how startup valuations could regain their shine.
Gaming: With the huge Axie Infinity hack making headlines, we talked about the matter and how other startups are tinkering with the play-to-earn market.
And we closed with the topic of social networks, what Elon Musk is up to, and how Facebook managed to confirm everyone's suspicions about its ethics.
Whew! What a week, y'all. Chat Monday!
Credits: Equity is produced by Theresa Loconsolo with editing by Kell. Bryce Durbin is our Illustrator. We'd also like to thank the audience development team and Henry Pickavet, who manages TechCrunch audio products.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript 0:09 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome back to Equity, a podcast about the business of startups where we unpack the numbers and the nuance behind the headlines. My name is Alex and I'm joined today by my friend, my colleague, my longtime collaborator, the excellent Mary Ann Azevedo. Hi.
0:23 Speaker 01 Hey Alex, how are you today?
0:24 Speaker 00 You know, for a YC week, I'm pretty good. I have survived. I have made it through the gauntlet. I'm on the other side of the chasm. I've crossed the transom and I'm not dead.
0:33 Speaker 01 You're surprisingly chipper. I was expecting more of a YC hangover.
0:37 Speaker 00 Well, I mean, you remember that old joke about PowerPoint poisoning when you saw too many slides and you begin to just kind of like blur and want to cry? Every YC demo day, by the end of day two, I'm like, I don't care anymore. But like, it's so hard to get cynical when so many people who have an idea they're excited about are working on it and want to tell you about it. It's fun. Like, I fundamentally enjoy it.
0:56 Speaker 01 It's awesome.
0:57 Speaker 00 Yeah. Well, kind of a spoiler there. We are talking about YC, but not only that. And I'll throw in there, Natasha is off. She is back next week. She has not left the podcast. She's just been a very busy person. So we will have her back in the rotation next week. So if you've missed her, fret not, she'll be back. But today, Mary Ann and I are going to walk you through quite a lot of stuff. We are going to talk about YC, some favorites, some trends, nothing too crazy. But if you didn't spend two days watching the show, we got you. Mary Ann, then we're going to talk about valuations in the context of Instacart, unicorns, and what we learned from the co-founder of Equities Zen. Then gaming, I know your favorite thing. Mary Ann, by the way, is the source for all your Elden Ring tips and tricks. We'll also talk about the Axie Infinity Hack and then Ampverse, which is a very interesting esports company from Asia. And then, whoo, we'll talk about the adaptation of social
1:41 Speaker 00 networks from the lens of Instagram, Meta, and some startup news. Mary Ann, did I forget anything? Is that the list?
1:46 Speaker 01 I don't think you got it all, Alex.
1:48 Speaker 00 All right. So YC this week, a couple, I almost said a couple hundred, it's actually 400 companies.
1:53 Speaker 01 Right.
1:53 Speaker 00 I want to dig into the fintech side of things. I know, Mary Ann, we spend a lot of time on this show talking about fintech, but we do because it matters. And that was very evident at the YC demo day this time around because there were dozens of fintech companies.
2:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, nearly three dozen to be exact. There were 35 international fintechs in this Cohort, that's not including crypto companies, which even though they're technically fintech, they were under their own category. So under international fintech, what was interesting to me was the variety of countries that were represented. There was Indonesia, Vietnam, Costa Rica, which I never hear of startups out of Costa Rica. So that was intriguing. Nigeria, of course, Kenya.
2:31 Speaker 00 Of course.
2:32 Speaker 01 So I think this kind of is reflective of what we've been seeing here at TC over the past year in general, like this booming fintech scenes in Africa. And now it's starting to grow even more in Asia outside of India, where we've historically seen more fintech activity.
2:48 Speaker 00 Yeah, but I mean, I love the range of things that we've been seeing. So we're not just seeing a single model applied to the world. I mean, I'm just going back through this now. And the startup from Costa Rica is called Boten, or maybe it's Boten, one of the two, one T. I'm gonna go with Boten. That just sounds like slang and we have a ship. Anyways, they're doing kind of a one stop mobile investment app for Latin American consumers. And there's also some DeFi yield in here. And then there's African corporate expense companies. And it's really a wide array. I think it just goes to show why fintech is hard to cover slash maybe is too wide an umbrella for one startup category, just given the diversity of individual efforts inside of it.
3:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's true. I mean, we saw buy now, pay later companies. We saw plenty of corporate spend, which is not surprising.
3:30 Speaker 00 Not a surprise.
3:31 Speaker 01 Including one company that actually focused on creators, which I thought was interesting, and freelancers and helping them manage their expenses. So that was new. And so, you know, embedded payments, all of it. The things, again, that we are seeing reflective in fintech currently were all represented in this cohort.
3:49 Speaker 00 On the corporate spend front, here's a bit of a preview. By the time you read this, this piece will not be out because we haven't finished it yet, but we will by the time this is a few days old. So check the site. There were so many companies building a Brex or Ramp or Airtable-ish company that we began to kind of collate them in their own bucket. And so there's Transfis, which is Brex for small businesses in Indonesia. There's Upbanks with an X, which is quote, Brex for D to C brands and content creators in Indonesia, the one Mary Ann just mentioned. There's a capital with a K, and we're not allowed to call it DAS Capital, because it's not a people get that joke. That's Brex for Latin America. And then there's Boya, which is Brex for Africa. And I actually guarantee you, Mary Ann, there were a few others we missed. But those are the ones that we caught and wrote down.
4:28 Speaker 01 Right. Yeah, I'm sure we probably missed some, but it was definitely notable.
4:32 Speaker 00 Yeah. On the trends point, I wanted to go back to the crypto separation from fintech because I kind of thought there was going to be more from the web three crypto world than we saw. I didn't see that many NFT marketplaces. I didn't see that many, you know, metaverse-y things. It almost felt kind of old school YC in this kind of hot blockchain era.
4:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, I think that's because we were looking at a global set of companies. And I feel like here crypto has just become so mainstream, but we have to remember that all over the world it has not. And it's still very much like this emerging thing in a lot of markets. So maybe next year we'll see more. I think there was a total of about 25 that Lucas, Matt and you took a look at.
5:11 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think that's about right. So a good number, like not zero, but 25 out of 414, it's just lower than I expected. I mean, that's a pretty small overall percentage. It's single digits, right? Which is, I would have guessed 15 to 20% was kind of my bias going into this, but you know, proves what I know. Couple of other little standout facts. India, as always, did very, very well. I think it was the second most represented country. But the thing that really caught our eye, and we covered this, is that Nigeria was third. Nigeria was the third most popular country for the founding location of YC companies in the winter 22 batch. And Mary Ann tells me two things. One, Nigeria is certainly the dominant country for startups in Africa, comma, Africa's a big deal now. Just flat out, period, big deal.
5:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think it's the first time that Africa was in the top three, right?
5:56 Speaker 00 Yes. I think it's the first time an African country made the top three country list for a number of startups in a demo.
6:02 Speaker 01 Right. Thank you.
6:02 Speaker 00 It's a very specific fact.
6:06 Speaker 01 Yeah. I think, again, it's not surprising because a lot of this we could see just based on our site. We've got Tej and Annie in Africa doing some excellent reporting. Tons coming out of Nigeria specifically, but other countries as well, Kenya. And can't think offhand of some of the other hot countries there. But yeah, this is interesting. And I don't think it's some passing trend. I think it's probably something we could see again next year.
6:28 Speaker 00 Yeah. Well, I mean, next year, don't you mean later this year when we have the other YC demo day?
6:33 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:34 Speaker 00 400 companies a year. Not enough. We need to have 800 or whatever it is.
6:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:39 Speaker 00 Mary Ann, I was gonna do a couple of favorites. How does that sound? I helped, okay, so every demo day TC writes up a lot of coverage on the companies because it's a lot of startups and that's what we cover. And then we do some favorites and I helped kind of put together our favorites posts. So I'm going to call out some favorites and who liked them. So if you want to just dive into a couple of picks, here's some suggestions. Christine Hall from our team also has been on the podcast, really liked Luna Joy, which is mental health care for women. Natasha Moskrenis, you may have heard of her if you listen to Equity, that's a company called KAGAZ, K-A-A-G-A-Z, a deli-based startup to make it easier to run your business from your phone. I thought Peak Flow was cool, which is kind of Bill.com for Southeast Asia. And Mary Ann, you liked a company called Digit Ventures, I think it was?
7:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, Digit Ventures, based out of Argentina. And I was just, I was really impressed with Attraction. They've been around a few years. They're trying to help banks digitize, which, you know, in Latin America, that's really ramped up over the past couple of years. So they were definitely in the right place at the right time since they started this four years ago. So as soon as all these banks were like, hey, we need to get to digitizing. This company was there and they already have, like, I think they said they're live with 30 clients, including seven banks in nine countries. So I was impressed with Attraction.
7:50 Speaker 00 No, no, I dig that. And just to close off our look at this particular YC batch, because there's so much coverage on the site. I don't want to overly index on it. My favorite of the whole two days, and I saw probably 80% of the presentations. I had to do a meeting here and there, but I really tried to stay tuned in, was Andy, A-N-D-I. Search for the next generation is the tagline. They have some cool search tech. They are kind of like, I think, taking aim at part of what Google does, which is a big market, huge TAM. And I love to see startups not dodge incumbents, but go straight for their jugular. So Andy, A-N-D-I, really caught my eye. Search is cool. With that, Mary Ann, I think we can finally drop YC, the accelerator, and instead talk about a YC company called Instacart.
8:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's right. Sometimes we forget that, right?
8:33 Speaker 00 It's been a while. I know you've been on the fintech side of things, so a little bit less focused on the grocery delivery service side of things. But just before we get into what happened, what's your current read of the grocery delivery market as a consumer? Did you find it an appealing thing to use? Or is it mostly something that you talk about in the abstract?
8:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, so honestly, I got into the grocery delivery bandwagon about six years ago and not using Instacart, the grocery store that's very popular here in Texas is called HEB. It's based here. It's one of the top grocers all over the country. So they came up with curbside pickup six years ago. And as a mother of two who dreaded having to spend two hours going grocery shopping with a young child who wanted everything off the shelves, this was a godsend. And so I started doing this six years ago, way before the pandemic even started. I never really used Instacart, to be honest with you, but I know a lot more people did turn to it during the pandemic.
9:24 Speaker 00 Absolutely. It was an enormous time of growth for the company. Instacart was raising what it felt like every other week. It was actually every other quarter, I think, but it felt like it was faster than that. And then the company really kind of didn't grow that much last year. On one hand, Mary Ann, I'm like, hey, you know what? Reasonable. It grew so much in 2020, holding on to all this 2020 growth and putting some more up in 2021 is impressive. The downside was it was valued at nearly $40 billion. And that's a valuation that demands faster growth than the company could essentially deliver last year. And I don't mean that ironically, just I think every time I say deliver now it's going to be kind of a tinged word. But they have repriced to some degree down to 24 billion. And the conversation really here is they did this so they could better price employee compensation in terms of equity
10:06 Speaker 00 and make it a bit more fair and reasonable and therefore better retain talent. And then also maybe have a better chance at hiring the talent that they want. So kind of like an admission that things had changed at the company and in the market. And it really set headlines. I mean, Mary Ann, this was everywhere.
10:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, it was. And I just want to be clear to make sure that we all understand. This means that employees could get shares at a lower price.
10:29 Speaker 00 Kind of. So let's say, Mary Ann, you're joining Instacart and I'm thinking, Mary Ann is going to be a great CEO. Let's pay her, let's put as part of our compensation, $100 million in stock because Mary Ann's just worth it, worth every penny. Now, at a $40 billion valuation, that would convert to a certain number of shares. But at a $24 billion valuation, it converts to a very different number of shares. In fact, a lot more equity. And so if you're looking at the $40 billion price and thinking, oh, gosh, are we ever going to beat this? Your equity is essentially frozen or maybe even underwater. So by bringing the valuation down through what we think is a different 409A valuation, if you want the mechanics, they essentially make it easier to offer equity that employees have more confidence in and therefore they're more likely to stay or come.
11:09 Speaker 01 Okay. Appreciate the clarification. I knew on a high level, something like that. But yeah, that's interesting. And I think Instacart did a good job of coming out ahead of this news and just putting itself out there and not, you know, not like waiting for someone to say, oh, Instacart really is not worth what it was last year. So from that respect, I think it did a pretty good job.
11:27 Speaker 00 Yeah, well, I'm also not proud of a company, but happy to see a company talk about hard decisions and be clear about them. Instacart's complained at me a little bit over the years for headlines and so forth. So I don't have like the closest relationship to them, but I will say in this case, I think they made the right choice. And critically, I think they set the tone.
11:44 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:44 Speaker 00 Because Marion, you and I have been talking about the better.com layoffs and other startup layoffs that are starting to pop up more often. And it seems that some companies are going to have to make some hard choices this year, if it's layoffs or if it's valuation change. And so I talked to Equities Zen's co-founder and chief revenue officer, Phil Hasslett. And he was like, you know, frankly, Instacart is being the kind of a trendsetter here and boldly going where other companies sell shouldn't have to.
12:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think it's a great point. I think you're right. We're definitely going to be seeing more valuation shifts in coming months. Not shocking about Instacart, really. I think it was just one of those companies that, again, boom during the pandemic, found itself struggling. Post pandemic, it was hard to predict exactly what was going to happen in terms of consumer demand when they were going to start going in stores again. You know, reminds me a little bit of better.com in that they over indexed on refinancings and business was booming for a while there. And then everything sort of crashed. Sounds like Instacart obviously didn't crash and burn in the way better.com has, but certainly it saw a decline, but a decline in not growth didn't decline. Like it still grew, but at a slower rate. Isn't that right, Alex?
12:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, companies like Instacart that are posting simply enormous revenue gains as the market kind of turns towards their business model can raise just enormous amounts of money because they have so much momentum. But that evaluation isn't really set at where they were per se. It's set at where they're going to probably be going.
13:06 Speaker 01 Yeah.
13:07 Speaker 00 And so if your growth slows from triple digits to low double digits, nothing really shakes out the way it was supposed to. And you have to make some choices. Now, this is kind of a talking point for what I'm calling paper unicorns, for lack of a better phrase, but essentially companies that raised a lot of money last year at a relatively high revenue multiple and are now going to have to choose between not hiring or layoffs to conserve cash, to have more time to build more, or to like take a valuation cut. I mean, I don't want to say it, but there may come a time when flat is again, the new up.
13:36 Speaker 01 Yeah.
13:37 Speaker 00 But I feel like every time we say that, the market then shoots up 50 points the next day. So I don't want to, maybe I should jinx it in that case.
13:43 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm almost, it'll be interesting to see how all of it plays out.
13:46 Speaker 00 Yeah. I'm just curious to see if we're going to see more Instacart style repricings, or we'll see more investor-led repricings in next venture rounds, or we'll see more layoffs. What's the mechanism that becomes the thing?
14:01 Speaker 01 It might be a little bit of all three, although with your first one, I feel like not as many companies are going to be super public about it in the way that Instacart was necessarily. But, you know, last year we saw so many companies raise in quick succession with valuations quadrupling even in some cases. Obviously, yeah, that's probably not going to be happening as often. So yeah, you could be right about the flat.
14:25 Speaker 00 Being the new up. So before we move on to the gaming world, let's circle back to fintech. Better.com fits into the fintech world, even though it's pretty much real estate tech or consumer, what the hell would you call better?
14:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, it really, there's so much overlap, right? Between fintech and prob tech, but you know, it helped make the loan origination process easier and faster. And to be clear, it did. It did at one point really do that very well. So from that respect, I still would consider it fintech.
14:55 Speaker 00 Okay. By the way, there's never been a time in history when accelerating the pace of mortgages and mortgage origination has led to any issues. So I'm glad that we have no historical overhang here to worry about. And if you're younger than 25, go look up what I'm talking about. Okay. Cause I'm just curious about the fintech world more generally and how much trouble there might be, because I feel like last year, it was probably the hottest space apart from crypto. And you were running around like the proverbial headless chicken, trying to keep tabs of it all, because there was so much. And so I'm curious if there's actually more weakness in fintech than we might have otherwise expected, given that we're seeing some issues. I'm curious if they'll become kind of legion in the fintech late-stage space.
15:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, you know, I covered this in my column last week. You know, you helped me write the headline for that. Thank you, Alex. I do think last year was just too nuts. We all kind of figured that was not sustainable, even in the fintech world. It was just too much money going into companies very, very early stages. So I think, you know, we're going to see fintech. Investors are going to take a little bit more measured approach and let some of these companies prove themselves. All these promises that were made last year are like, okay, now show us, show us what you can do before just writing another check. So like, let's see some real traction or, you know, I would hope that investors are going to be a little bit more, what's the word?
16:10 Speaker 00 Conscientious, engaged, polite, rude.
16:14 Speaker 01 More due diligence prior to writing checks. Yeah, so we'll see. I will say on a personal note, I kind of am happy that there's a little bit of a slowdown because even though my inbox is still a disaster, it's a little bit less of a disaster than it was, say, third or fourth quarter of last year.
16:31 Speaker 00 You know how I fixed my inbox?
16:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, I know. You tell everybody.
16:34 Speaker 00 So I just didn't read email for a couple of weeks. And now Google inbox just marks nothing as priority because I didn't read anything for so long. I trained it that all email is bad. And so now I don't see a lot of email. It's great. I finally have the inbox of my dreams.
16:48 Speaker 01 Love it.
16:50 Speaker 00 All right, let's talk about gaming. We were going to talk about gaming from a different perspective, but then something happened this week that really kind of added to this theme. And Mary Ann, it's the Axie Infinity Ronin Network exploit, maybe, let's say, that ended up leading to a roughly $625 million decentralized finance hack. So first of all, how much of those words made sense? And how much should I try to explain this and make a fool of myself in front of our dear friends?
17:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, I think on a very high level, we can explain that this company is what you would call a crypto gaming giant. Our new reporter Jacqueline described it as such, raised last year at a $3 billion valuation. And then found out like days after the fact that it had been hacked and that users lost a lot of what coins, I guess. And it amounted to $625 million worth. Is that, is that right?
17:41 Speaker 00 Yeah, I'll take most of that. So the way that I understand it, and like, as long as you and I can both get to 80%, I figure we'll overlap and get 100% of it between the two of us.
17:49 Speaker 01 Yeah.
17:50 Speaker 00 We're over our skis, but this matters. And I think it just goes to show that having passing crypto knowledge is now kind of table stakes. So here we are doing our best. Mary Ann, we both know the Ethereum blockchain. Which is one of the biggest, most important chains out there. It used to be kind of second to Bitcoin, but now I would kind of say it's the most important, not the most valuable per se, but the most used.
18:07 Speaker 01 Yeah.
18:07 Speaker 00 And it's pretty backed up most of the time. So people don't want to do transactions on the Ethereum main chain, if you will, the level one. So people build side chains, a way to kind of interact with the broader Ethereum universe without having to deal with the main thing. It's like driving on an access road next to a highway if the highway is closed off because of a car crash.
18:24 Speaker 01 Love your analogies, Alex. Love them.
18:25 Speaker 00 In this case, Ethereum though, is the access road and the side chains are actually the highway. And so you have to bridge this stuff. You have to have a way to go from one road to the other. You can't just have your car teleport. You have to have, you know, some sort of bridgy bit between the access road and the highway. Those are called bridges, shockingly enough, and they are apparently something that people can hack. And so the company behind Axie Infinity discovered they had a problem when they had a report from a user. They were trying to pull some ETH out of the bridge and didn't work because there wasn't any because it had all been taken. And it ended up being 173,600 Ether and 25.5 million of the Stealocoin USDC, making it the largest DeFi hack to date. So essentially, the technology that makes main chains more palatable for other
19:08 Speaker 00 companies have some structural current cybersecurity issues that are pretty bad.
19:13 Speaker 01 Yeah.
19:13 Speaker 00 Is my read of this. Like, it's not good.
19:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, pretty bad is an understatement in my opinion, and I think this actually is not good for the world of crypto because I think it points out that there are still, it's being decentralized appeals to a lot of people, but that also can be a negative. And so this kind of thing could probably happen more often. And from what I understand, like, the users are going to get what they lost back, but the company's probably going to have to eat those costs. That's a lot of money to, or, you know, yeah, I don't know what to call it anymore.
19:42 Speaker 00 You can call it money is good. Stored stored value. You can pick a different unit of measure, if you will, but yeah, it's a lot of money. I mean, flat out, because let's say that, and I don't know that this is true, so I'm speculating here, but let's say that Axie has to essentially pay up the lost amount of funds as people try to remove money and kind of move between their side chain and the main ETH, ETH net. Well, do they have to pay out $600 million? And if so, can they? And then if so, at what pace? And what does that do to their business model? And so I don't know if they can. Do they have that kind of money? It's a lot of money, even for a crypto startup. It's a lot of money.
20:15 Speaker 01 It could potentially be devastating for a company. Maybe not this one, but it's still a huge hit. And, you know, I think the big question is, how can you avoid this from happening in the future?
20:25 Speaker 00 Yeah, but we are not only going to talk about one play to earn company today. There's in fact more of them. And another kind of lens into how the gaming world is changing is a company called Ampverse. It's Singapore-based esports startup, just raised a $12 million series A, Mary Anne. But it took me a while to actually figure out what it did. And I'm curious if you had a similar sort of like, what does this company actually do moment?
20:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, I did. And I think what we came to was that it lets players earn rewards by playing games and then get training from pro esports people.
20:56 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's a kind of a mix of like play to earn pros, play to earn support, maybe traditional esports and some other stuff. Okay, maybe that's the future, but it was a surprise to me to see in an esports headline, a startup that had this much of a footprint into the play to earn world, which is where Axie Infinity and a lot of other crypto games sit. And so it was kind of to me like watching the crypto world creep its way into my world because I've been esports dweeb for a thousand million years. And so I was kind of surprised to see this, frankly. It took me a little bit. I was shocked.
21:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, this company is based in Singapore, which I think this was, wasn't this like the largest, what Catherine, she wrote this and she said it was the largest series A raised by an esports organization in Southeast Asia, according to like pitch book data. So that's, that's notable as well.
21:44 Speaker 00 That's a very specific stat. I have raised the largest pre-seed round of any person named Alex inside of Providence, Rhode Island. I gave myself $5. It's a $12 million series A. And let's not overindex on how big it was. As far as A's go, that's middle or median or whatever. But I mean, it's the company's makeup that surprised me. It's diversified for such a small firm.
22:03 Speaker 01 And well, also, I mean, that's a lot of money for probably that region and this category still here. We've been talking about esports for how long now, Alex? I remember at Crunchbase News, we used to write about it four years ago. And it was kind of newish at that time. And it was like, oh my God, wow, people can get paid to play video games. This is just mind blowing concept. And here now in the US, this has become much more mainstream and sort of just accepted. And people get scholarships now for esports can go to college on an esports scholarship. Again, other parts of the world, it's probably taken longer for esports to become as popular.
22:40 Speaker 00 Well, the question really becomes like where in Asia does it have the biggest footprints? We know that China and South Korea are enormous gaming markets. Well, China was until the recent changes in their gaming rules for minors. But essentially, we're seeing a lot of fun esports stuff. Don't forget that Metaphy raised 25 million earlier this year from Tiger. That's a gaming coaching platform for serious amateurs, but not pros. So there's so many models, so many methods. If you're into gaming, it's a great time to be a gamer. There's a lot of good games out there. There's esports. It's kind of like we're feasting, is my read.
23:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, and just really quickly, and one of the things you said, Catherine quotes her source, the founder of this company, saying that Indonesia is the largest gaming market in Southeast Asia. And that in Philippines, actually, the number has grown almost 13% in recent years. So.
23:24 Speaker 00 That's a lot.
23:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah.
23:26 Speaker 00 I mean, more evidence of how big and culturally important gaming is, not just domestically to where you and I live, but really everywhere. I mean, as people go online, they can compete in digital games, and it seems to be a pretty big deal.
23:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
23:39 Speaker 00 We have one last thing to talk about, and it's my favorite thing, because nothing makes me happier than talking about Elon Musk. He is my, I'm trying to find some polite way of not getting in trouble. Elon Musk is a human that I'm familiar with. There you go. What has he done now, Mary Ann?
23:54 Speaker 01 Well, he kind of hinted that he wanted to start his own social network, which had a lot of people freaked out.
24:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, can you imagine the all Elon social network? I'm just imagining him and Grimes just like reading into like a voice recorder, having their tweets transcribed. Elon made an interesting argument here, and he kind of said Twitter is the town square, and it's censoring people, and so we need to go off and make our own, which is a little rich from a company with a litigious history. You might say, Mary Ann, about things.
24:21 Speaker 01 I think it's also interesting because he has, what, like 70 some million followers on Twitter? He tweets all the time, lots of controversial things. So Amanda, who wrote a piece on this topic, was actually quite funny, and her headline kind of sums it up. Don't lose sleep over Elon Musk's desire to build the next Twitter.
24:38 Speaker 00 Yeah, we have historically seen people struggle when they go out to build their own social network, because it's very, very hard to do. Former American President Donald Trump is trying this, failing.
24:46 Speaker 01 Yeah.
24:47 Speaker 00 And I think what Twitter has that people don't take into account is Twitter has a lot of people who don't agree with modern American right wing politics. And so if you are someone who likes to quote troll libs, and then you go to Getter or Truth Social, there's no one for whom you control. You're all trolled out, and it doesn't really appeal. Like, if Elon goes on Elon.social.musk or whatever and posts, all he's gonna get is like his fanboys' face. I don't know. Is that what you want? Is that really the thing?
25:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, I agree. You know, in general, social networking, it's a hard thing to do, right? Like, look, even companies that have been doing it for years are looking for new ways to keep users engaged and retain them and compete against other social networks, right? And we saw that in some other headlines this week.
25:27 Speaker 00 I will grab that segue and take it the rest of the way. And we're thinking about Instagram's latest test that's going to make it easier to support social movements through hashtags. There has actually been a really long history of Facebook properties doing things that allowed people to mention social, not phenomena, but like social efforts. Like, I remember back on Facebook.com, a thousand years ago, there was a very popular app when they first opened the ability to build on Facebook, where you could like pick a thing and promote it on your profile and kind of support a social.
25:53 Speaker 01 Social cause, yeah.
25:54 Speaker 00 Yeah. So Instagram, I feel like it's kind of following those footsteps. We know that they're a little worried about some competitors. And so I think as Instagram looks to kind of retain its user base, Facebook's broader corporate structure is kind of worried. We learned this week that Facebook paid a company, what's the name of this, Targeted Victory, to, quote, orchestrate a nationwide campaign seeking to turn the public against TikTok. I don't know if I can improve on that. It's one of the funniest things I've ever read. Facebook, it turns out, is the company you thought it was and has the moral fortitude of a tapeworm.
26:23 Speaker 01 Yeah. I mean, this story was just kind of made jaws drop everywhere, right? I think the campaign included things like getting op-eds and letters placed in newspapers all over the country, just promoting dubious stories about alleged TikTok trends that originated on Facebook.
26:40 Speaker 00 Right.
26:40 Speaker 01 Things like that.
26:41 Speaker 00 Here's a question that I have. Do people just not have like a moral compass? Like, do they just not care when they're being hypocritical and horrible? Because like, I feel like I would feel bad. Like, I would be like, huh, here I am, trying to ask to retrieve slander, not in the legal sense, I mean, that's just the definitional English sense, against TikTok for stuff that we did. Like, how do you go to bed at night and be like, I'm a good person?
27:03 Speaker 01 No, there's no conscience, clearly. I mean, there's a quote, Washington Post that broke this, "The dream would be to get stories with headlines like 'From Dances to Danger', 'How TikTok Has Become the Most Harmful Social Media Space for Kids.' Let's make sure we should point out that Facebook has been losing younger users pretty dramatically, right, over the past couple of years.
27:23 Speaker 00 Well, yeah, that's because Facebook has become essentially a Florida retirement community, and Instagram has become some sort of like 2016 version of influencers from LA. Boring, like fucking boring. Who gives a shit? WhatsApp is still pretty good, but that's not where the money comes from. And so TikTok rolled in with a much better experience. And I think the ability to drive culture because TikTok has led to music becoming popular, dances becoming popular, center of the spotlight is how it feels.
27:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, and you know, I'm going to say this, I hesitate almost to say it because I don't want in any shape, way or form to defend anything that Facebook has done or Meta has done here. Cause I don't like, I don't support a condone. But I did read a pretty horrific article the other day that maybe was placed by targeted victories somewhere about a kid who like set himself on fire based on a video he saw on TikTok. Well, you know, these things are going to happen. Kids are going to be dumb all over the world, not to, you know, that sounds mean that I'm calling this kid dumb, but like doing a dumb thing rather. So, you know, I can't say this is necessarily TikTok's fault, but surely there is some questionable stuff that does take place on there.
28:30 Speaker 01 So not diminishing that it is highly entertaining to people of all ages, because it is. But like, maybe it can also do a little bit better on some things.
28:38 Speaker 00 Sure, sure. But like I did dumb things when I was a teen. We didn't even need TikTok. We just thought it up, you know?
28:44 Speaker 01 Did you set yourself on fire? Did you set yourself on fire though?
28:48 Speaker 00 We did once make a cannon and my brother did blow him his eyebrows off with a pile of black powder in our back driveway. I grew up next to cows, so we had a gun safe and you know, like we could take guns out in the morning and go rabbit hunting. I had a different childhood from a lot of folks in the tech world. Yeah. So no one got shot with anything other than paintball guns. It was fine. Yeah, it was, it was all good.
29:08 Speaker 01 No, no, no, I, I'm not trying to sound like, you know, oh, TikTok is bad. I'm not saying that. I actually, like I said, I know many people who love it or are highly entertained by it, even in my age group and younger. Not at all. I mean, I think what your earlier point really just hit the nail on the head. This coming out just kind of confirms everything that most of us have thought about Facebook and Meta and what it's doing behind the scenes. And it's just a very underhanded way to stay competitive. And to me, it shows how insecure the company is about its standing as a social network that it had to resort to something like this.
29:41 Speaker 00 Well, the thing that Facebook has had is completeness, right? Everyone was on there and then suddenly they began to lose users. And now they're starting to lose their core value prop. But here's some numbers just to kind of put this in perspective. Today, according to Google Finance, Facebook is worth, sorry, Meta Platforms is worth $610 billion, plus or minus 100 million. Today, Tesla, going back to our dear friend Elon from earlier in the show, 1.13 trillion, which means that Tesla is now worth nearly two Facebooks. That is an inversion of a couple of years ago. I think if I'm doing the math correctly in my head. That's crazy. Goes to show not only how far Tesla has gone, but also how far Meta has fallen. And a lot of the folks that were defending Zuckerberg's tenure at the company for years
30:26 Speaker 00 because they made them money have some splaining to do, I think. So. Agreed. All right, we should shut up. We've been going on for a while. I don't know how far ahead we are. This has been fun. It has been fun. If you see a TikTok story about how people are huffing paint cans or something, just don't forget, one, we've all done that. Two, we don't need TikTok. And three, it's probably a Facebook plant. And with that, Mary Ann, we'll be back Monday morning. Yeah, see y'all next week. Don't huff paint.
Previous Demo days definitely amplify a brand, but not the one you'd think Next Equity Monday: Elon's Twitter stake and the fate of rival social networks Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated