Pod Insights Equity Podcast How close are we to understanding what's going on? About this episode This week we recorded live, which is always good fun, meaning that we took some questions from the audience. If you want that version of the show, we have a YouTube archive of it here.
For those of you more into audio, we have you covered here. Natasha, Alex, and Grace teamed up with Julio and Yashad to host the shindig, allowing us to cover the following:
The end of iPod, a time to reflect on technology trends.
The exit of a Modern Fertility co-founder, and the MARA round bringing more money to Africa's fintech scene.
From there it was onto the Terra crash, Coinbase's earnings, and the general sentiment shift in the crypto scene.
Next up was Tiger and the downturn in startup valuations.
And we closed on some personal notes.
All told we had a blast. Mary Ann is back with us next week! Chat soon!
Credits: Equity is produced by Theresa Loconsolo with editing by Kell. Bryce Durbin is our Illustrator. We'd also like to thank the audience development team and Henry Pickavet, who manages TechCrunch audio products.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript 0:11 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome back to Equity, a podcast about the business of startups, where we unpack the numbers and the nuance behind the headlines. My name is Alex Wilhelm and I am joined today by senior TC reporter Natasha Moskarenas. Natasha, hello. I hear we only have good news today.
0:25 Speaker 01 We only have good news. I've been laughing and smiling all week and not at all stressed and about to cry.
0:30 Speaker 00 Yeah, I just stopped checking my 401ks and I think that's going to be the path forward. Before we get into a bunch of stuff, some small housekeeping notes. One is Mary Ann is off today. We miss her. We adore her. She will be back next week. The other thing is we are recording this live. This is our Thursday live show that we do every two weeks. So if we reference something that we're seeing visually that you can't see, that's our mistake. We're going to try to make sure that this translates as well to the standard podcast format as it does this live thing.
0:55 Speaker 01 That said, just to make it not translate, feel free to ask us questions at the end of this episode. We will try and answer them as we can and that is an exclusive live show feature. So I hope you have FOMO and show up next time if you're not already here. And if you are here, thank you.
1:09 Speaker 00 You can also heckle us in the hop and chat if you're there. If you're on Twitter Spaces with us, you can't heckle us. Ha ha. Natasha, let's go over the rundown. We're going to talk about the end of the iPod, which we have a lot of emotions about, frankly. We have a couple of deals of the week. Modern Fertility's co-founder leaving and also Mara and crypto in Africa. Then we're going to talk about USD's crash, Coinbase, cryptocurrency and the current state of affairs in the blockchain world. Then Tiger Global, the global downturn. And then we'll finally reflect a little bit on the chaos and talk about how frankly our posture as reporters is changing. Fair enough?
1:39 Speaker 01 Fair enough. Thank you for running through that with somehow optimism and excitement in your voice because it is, it is a really negative show in a lot of ways, but we're hoping we can bring some analysis that either will make you feel heard as a listener or connect some dots if you're feeling overwhelmed by all the different news items out there.
1:54 Speaker 00 So I so respect the emotional place from which that comment comes from, but like the thing about the doom and gloom of this current moment is that it just feels like, not comeuppance, but like the obvious final stage of a period of exuberance. And so like, if you go out partying all night and Have a great time, probably not going to wake up at 8 a.m. feeling refreshed. You know, so that's my vibe with the current market.
2:15 Speaker 01 Hundred percent. I think a lot of people have pointed this out already, but a lot of startups, lucky ones still have money right now, unlike the last complete bubble bursting. So I feel like there is opportunity as well. I mean, we'll, we'll get into a lot of the companies that are raising still throughout this, but just know that for heading into the episode.
2:31 Speaker 00 Absolutely. Now, talking as we were just then about a change in the guard, a change in the cycle. Well, one cycle is coming to an end in the world of technology and that is the iPod is kaput. Natasha, Apple announced this week that they are going to cease production and essentially sell the rest of the inventory, but the iPod is done.
2:48 Speaker 01 Oh my gosh. When I saw this headline, I definitely had like two reactions. The first was, oh my God, I haven't thought about this thing in a while. Then the second was now I'm thinking about it and I'm really sad that something that was such a hallmark of my childhood and definitely the first way I, other than the Walkman, this was like the first way that I like walked around and listened to music at the same time. So I just, I, all the feels, as I'm sure you as well did, Alex.
3:11 Speaker 00 I mean, I remember my friend had one of the original iPods. It was the, the first generation and I have all the iPod stats pulled up here from Wikipedia. It came in five and 10 gigabyte varieties.
3:25 Speaker 01 Wow.
3:26 Speaker 00 Firewire only Mac OS, or back then it was Mac OS nine and uh, OS 10.1. So like, it was like back in the day and it sounds small, but it was an absolute revolution in day to day music. You could take your music with you more than just one CD or a pack of CDs in the back of your car. Like that was such a change. It shook up music consumption, music distribution. It's set the stage for streaming later on, a hardware foundation for smartphones. Like it's, it's an amazing seminal moment that is now seeing the final chapter written.
3:55 Speaker 01 Yeah. And honestly, like in a way, maybe this is controversial, but I'm kind of happy to say goodbye to it because I think it needs to have such a dramatic ending, or it needs to have a ending of sorts for us to sit down and talk about our equity and reflect on what it did for consumption and what it did for the legacy of how we listen to music. So I do feel like moments like this do force everyone to pause and think about their first interaction with tech, which as a softie, I'm very here for.
4:18 Speaker 00 Yeah, no, I mean, fellow softie, but like, this is a great example of the cliche that you don't get your flowers while you're still alive is true for a reason, right? We wouldn't have stepped back and talked about our history with these devices if there wasn't some cause. I'm just bummed we waited until it was death.
4:32 Speaker 01 I know. Well, let's stay on the optimistic theme, though, because I want to hear about your relationship with iPods. Like, what was your go-to iPod? What songs did you have on it? Like, tell the people, but tell me more importantly.
4:43 Speaker 00 So for me, the seminal iPod that I had, the most important one, I had a shuffle. I had one of the USB shuffles at one point in time.
4:50 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:50 Speaker 00 I think I had a friend's old, like, second gen, maybe. But the one that I remember as being my best friend was my iPod fourth generation Color, because it had a color screen. And we were doing cool stuff back then. Like, you couldn't put videos on them, but you could, like, bring on a gazillion photos and, like, slide through them as the scroll function on the wheel, and it would make the little video play, you know? But I remember the first iPod actually had a physical wheel that spun before it was a little touchpad.
5:16 Speaker 01 No way.
5:17 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah. They were huge and terrible.
5:19 Speaker 01 Oh, my god.
5:20 Speaker 00 But they were enough of a step forward. A thousand songs in your pocket, a thousand, that it changed everything. And, I mean, I used my iPod religiously, Natasha, until I bought a Zune. And then I became a Zune boy. And then Microsoft killed the Zune, and I'm still pissed about it, so.
5:33 Speaker 01 I remember the ads, like, yesterday, like, all of them, the dancing, the just unleashing these products. I don't remember seeing as high quality of a production as we now see for the iPhone. And so comparing and contrasting how they would announce a new iPod versus a new iPhone is kind of funny in retrospect.
5:49 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, back then, there was so much emotion and joy. Like, Apple was having those iPod ads that had the dancing person, like, a white silhouette, and the music, and the action. And now I feel like they're like the new iPhone now with four cameras. And I'm like, eh, I don't really care.
6:02 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:02 Speaker 00 But back then, like, you got, like, they would double the storage, and people would be like, oh, my gosh, 40 gigabytes in your pocket? Holy crap.
6:08 Speaker 01 I know.
6:08 Speaker 00 It was such a change.
6:09 Speaker 01 Oh, my god. I think, like, I don't remember the name of the iPod, my first iPod. I think it was, like, the OG silver one that was a touchpad as the wheel. That's me talking about hardware. I love hardware. But
6:20 Speaker 00 This is not our strong point. Let's be clear.
6:23 Speaker 01 The one that I'm like emotional about is the purple nano. I just, I thought purple was such a cool color. I was so excited about it. I downloaded all of Hilary Duff's songs and I will forever be thankful for those moments because I felt like the coolest person in the world. And it was, it was an accessory. Technology was an accessory.
6:38 Speaker 00 It was a fashion item.
6:39 Speaker 01 Yeah. And it doesn't feel that way anymore. Like I have a green phone case, but I take it all for granted now. And I'm happy that at one point I didn't.
6:46 Speaker 00 Yeah. Like on that point, I wanted to get a pink iPhone and my wife and I went to the Verizon store to buy new phones because I had like dropped mine one too many times and she hers was really old and they only had purple ones. And so I just got a purple phone, put it in a case and forgot. Like I just don't care. But my iPod four was like, it was like, when I dropped it, I felt like my heart broke. You know what I mean? Like, oh, I've scratched it. Maybe it's because I was in high school and didn't have any money.
7:09 Speaker 01 Definitely part of it.
7:10 Speaker 00 Yeah. I want to go into the thing about Hilary Duff there really quick. I know we have to move on to the Saudis. But like, for example, about how important music was at this earlier iPod Zoom time, when the online music world we live in was really coming into its own. I remember when I downloaded the Zoom software from Microsoft, it had a couple of tracks on it and you could download some music videos. And so I saw 30 seconds to Mars's The Kill video. And I was entranced because that song absolutely bangs and it's still holding up to this day. It's incredible. And then, you know, 30 seconds to Mars kept putting out, you know, big records, going on big tours. Jared Leto became some sort of movie celebrity quasi cult leader. I don't know.
7:47 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:47 Speaker 00 Anyways, I got to interview Jared Leto once at a box event.
7:50 Speaker 01 Oh, my God.
7:51 Speaker 00 It was one of those like full circle technology moments. I was like, you don't know this, but Microsoft made me a fan of you.
7:55 Speaker 01 Oh, my God. What an opening line.
7:58 Speaker 00 I didn't say that because that would have been strange. I was trying to be cool.
8:00 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
8:01 Speaker 00 But these devices were huge in our childhood and our early, you know, adulthood, frankly.
8:06 Speaker 01 Yeah. Well, I'll raise my, my seltzer water to that.
8:09 Speaker 00 Yeah. Cheers from the coffee mug to iPod. Bon voyage. Thank you for all that you did. I'm going to miss the memory of you, even if I do not miss the hardware because we've moved on. And as Grace just threw in the chat here, bipod. All right, now, let's pivot. Deals of the week, Natasha. The first one is one that I got to read before it went out. And I'm fascinated by the story because it shows change at a unicorn.
8:30 Speaker 01 Yes, so I've been reporting about Ro, which is a healthcare unicorn for a few months now. And about six months ago, I first heard rumors that one of the companies that they acquired, Modern Fertility, was losing its co-founder. The co-founder will be stepping away. That ended up not getting confirmed until just this week, when I was talking to sources of the company and an internal memo had been sent saying that Afton, one of the co-founders of the now women's health practice at Ro, is leaving to return to entrepreneurship. And in her words, per an email she sent to the company, "It's a way that she can best be the most effective in impacting global women's health." So turnover at Ro continues, especially at the executive level. They just lost their COO and a GM a few weeks ago.
9:11 Speaker 00 Now, are those three senior exits the only ones that we're keeping in mind? Or were there more exits like last year that I'm? My memory says that's the case, but I want to double check that.
9:19 Speaker 01 There was. And listen, the great resignation was a huge theme and will continue to be a huge theme, but based on the conversations I had with current and former employees, a lot of people across all levels were leaving last year on a bunch of teams, especially the customer support team. So I think seeing it trickle down to the executive level means something, especially because Ro recently raised money at a higher valuation. People don't leave a higher valuation company unless something is better out there or isn't great inside. I don't think that's too much projection to make.
9:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, and it could be either things weren't going well internally for their project, or there were now too many cooks inside the same kitchen, essentially. And like, you don't need everyone to stay, so some people were going to leave. I mean, seeing exits post-acquisition, not rare. These exits, given Ro's litany of departures, seems a bit more material to me.
10:03 Speaker 01 And there's kind of precedent with Ro losing the people behind their women's health practice.
10:08 Speaker 00 Yes.
10:09 Speaker 01 So Ro used to have a business stream called Rory, which was led by Rachel Blank, who eventually left to start her own hormonal health company, Alara. I covered it. It was very interesting to cover. But I think that that context made me especially want to cover this. But hey, I think the takeaway here is executive shakeups are continuing. And we're seeing Ro, it's leaving like that this is a portion of growing pains as you hit the growth scale. And now... Now have to kind of prove and explain itself past its ability to raise, sure, but still losing people.
10:37 Speaker 00 I just realized something very important. Because we're doing this live, Grace can't jump in and say, hurry up. So we can take as much time as we want. We're essentially off the chain right now. This is lovely. Let's do it live every week.
10:46 Speaker 01 I know.
10:46 Speaker 00 So staying to this theme, Natasha, we saw Roe by Daddy, which is the sperm freezing company, which is
10:53 Speaker 01 A name.
10:53 Speaker 00 Hell of a name. They bought Modern Fertility. They used to have Rory, which actually is a really good name. Roe and Rory? That's actually clever. How seriously should we take Roe's broader efforts into the world of both women's health and fertility? Because when I watch sports games on the television, the only time Roe comes up is for dick pills.
11:10 Speaker 01 Oh, interesting. I didn't even know that they were still doing ads like that.
11:13 Speaker 00 Be Roman ready. And I'm like, ah, get out of my living room.
11:17 Speaker 01 I mean, I'll respond to that question with quoting an email that Roe sent their team last month. They said that they are going to be putting more energy and resources towards fewer initiatives for the rest of the year, but are also saying that they're not going to stop launching products and services. At the same time, they're going to continue building for new and existing patients, but want to grow with discipline. So I think we're getting mixed messages on what they're doing. And it's a little hard to kind of glean from the outside on exactly how ambitious they're going to be in the next few months.
11:45 Speaker 00 That's like telling your date, like, I'll see you eight o'clock. By the way, I'm breaking up with you. I'm also married, but we got divorced. See you at eight. And like, you're like, how do I read that? Like, what's going on?
11:54 Speaker 01 Exactly. Their language that they used to use internally was, we want to be the Amazon of healthcare. Their language they're now using internally is, we want to grow with discipline. So I think that tells us all we need to know.
12:03 Speaker 00 Yeah. Which is that Amazon's market cap lost like $700 billion. Next week, we are continuing on this theme, Natasha. You are hosting a really exciting Wednesday show with the founder and CEO of Hey Jane. Is that true?
12:14 Speaker 01 Yes, yes. So we're going to be talking about the impact of Roe v Wade being potentially overturned. And we're also going to talk about everything about digital health that we can fit into a 30 minute episode. Please come by.
12:24 Speaker 00 I should have entered this, Natasha. What is Hey Jane and what do they do?
12:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, so they help deliver abortion pills across the country and they're trying to make medical abortions more accessible towards anyone who wants to have an abortion. So I'm very here for it. News recently came out via Axios that they're going to be raising a new round soon. So I think we're going to get them at a good time and talk about the venture side of trying to get your company funded when for some reason, people think that what you're doing is political.
12:49 Speaker 00 Never have I thought that the Supreme Court would lead to a growth round at a startup. And yet.
12:53 Speaker 01 Here we are.
12:54 Speaker 00 Here we are. Speaking about rounds, though, at startups, the other round of the week is Mara. And we're pretty sure it's Mara. We talked about Mara versus Mara. I think for sure it's Mara. A crypto company in Africa just raised $23 million from Coinbase Ventures and FTX. So two of the bigger corporate venture names in the crypto world, Natasha, they're kind of in, it seems like every deal that it matters, if you will.
13:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, definitely.
13:14 Speaker 00 And other VCs, just in case you want some names, TQ Ventures, Digital, all caps, Nexo, Day1 Ventures, Infinite Capital, and then my favorite, Dow Jones, D A O Jones, which is just, I mean, I'm here for a pun all the time.
13:27 Speaker 01 My God. I mean, that is the part of crypto that I'm like very happy has, it's made tech silly again in some ways.
13:33 Speaker 00 Yes. I love silly things. I'm here for a laugh, you know, absolutely. What matters is that Mara is a pan-African crypto exchange platform that wants to kind of bring more Africans into the quote crypto economy. And its CEO and co-founder, Che Nadi, used to run sustainability efforts, I think as part of the UN, used to fly a lot, travel a lot, see the discrepancy in kind of economic conditions in Africa and other places and said, hey, we should fix this. Now quite a lot of money. And according to TechCrunch.com, Natasha, crypto usage in Africa across the continent was up like 1,200% in the last year, which is, I think, the third fastest pace of growth in the world. So one, it goes to show how fast everything's going in crypto land up until.
14:09 Speaker 01 Totally.
14:10 Speaker 00 You know, yesterday. And also how important Africa could be as a place for it to grow. Because as we talked about on the show, fintech in Africa. Big freaking deal.
14:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, 100% and you'll appreciate this Africa's cryptocurrency market, like you said, has grown 1,200% by value, but it's also still the smallest cryptocurrency economy of any region we study as of right now. So I feel like the startups play at its heart is really like, can we bet on activation energy from consumers and make that a product? But that in and of itself has so much competition, which I think Tej really put really well in his piece. He kind of walked through how many startups there are right now. And I think the way that Mara appears to be differentiating beyond ambition is really trying to work with governments and be a, quote, legalize exchange. I kind of like that it's talking about oversight and not screw people in power so early on because it definitely could do that. But instead, planning to do a maybe a slower growth, higher stickiness sort of growth scheme.
15:01 Speaker 00 Yes, but also Tej and Annie covering Africa for TechCrunch, absolutely brilliant. If you don't follow them on Twitter, I mean, you're just missing out. Anyways, according to the piece, I think they're going to launch their own layer one blockchain, which is like Ethereum or Bitcoin, kind of the base layer and have their own token. And the idea I think here is to have kind of an Africa focused native crypto token. And I don't know much about geographically targeted tokens, but if it would increase financial access across Africa, I had no beef, you know, sounds great.
15:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, going off of that, it sounds like they're starting with financial infrastructure, but they want to help people do more than buy crypto. I think them creating their own coin would help. As they said, African engineers create their own projects and be a source of incubating and creating talent. So I like that they're doing a platform play with the exchange. And this is one of the biggest Web three crypto rounds to be happening in Africa right now. So definitely noteworthy.
15:50 Speaker 00 It may soon be one of the biggest crypto rounds happening, period, because things have really, really changed in the last couple of weeks in crypto land.
15:58 Speaker 01 Yes.
15:58 Speaker 00 You know, not that long ago, Natasha, I was writing posts like, did no one tell crypto that the party was over? Because like, software VCs and hardware VCs were all like pulling back and crypto was just like, you know, partying.
16:10 Speaker 01 The exuberance versus the winter that we felt otherwise. I feel heard this week because things are catching up to each other.
16:17 Speaker 00 Yes, it turns out that gravity is real and it's still true. So what happened this week, that's really been the flashpoint and what I've been staying up too late watching and waking up too early to check. On has been the dramatic de-pegging of U S T or essentially Terra, which was a stablecoin, not a stablecoin in the sense that every single dollar of Terra was backed by a hard set of assets. Instead, it was an algorithmic stablecoin, which is to say it had a sister token called Luna. Natasha, stop me if I get too far in the weeds here at any point.
16:45 Speaker 01 I actually, well, I wanted to pause you because I wanted to hear why it's important before we get into it, why it's important for us to be looking at stablecoins as a signal for anything. Why do you look at stablecoin prices?
16:55 Speaker 00 Well, I don't usually look at stablecoin prices because they're usually flat at $1 or a euro or whatever. But stablecoin volume is very important and also stablecoin aggregate value. So most stablecoins are pegged to the US dollar, just as a data point. I'm not trying to be overly US specific here, but I'm not really aware of one pegged to like the Japanese yen, for example, and so forth. And what matters is stablecoins are a way to have dollar equivalents inside the crypto world because you can't really bring your fiat money into the crypto world without turning it into a token. So you can participate in the broader blockchain economy. Stablecoins help you do that and they're very easy. And one of them, Tether, does besquillions of dollars a month in volume. And then there were some other ones, U S D C from Circle, then there was Terra,
17:35 Speaker 00 which had a sister token Luna. And the idea with it was that the two tokens would essentially balance one another. So if Terra, the stablecoin, became too valuable or too far away from its peg, Luna would either be burned or created and balance it out. And the idea was it would kind of sit there at the middle point of a theater totter. That's an algorithm and balance with people essentially trading back and forth, looking for small edges as a way to kind of keep it in sync. And that worked well for about a year.
17:59 Speaker 01 Yeah. And it helped people basically break into starting to think about and use crypto more, right? The fact that this was doing well for a year?
18:06 Speaker 00 No, I don't think Terra helped anyone outside of crypto get into it. I think if you got into crypto, it was via Coinbase or similar and probably didn't. And the whole thing was there was a bunch of Luna tokens that were like, I think staked on the Alchemy DeFi network. And then you could get yield. It was an intra-crypto play.
18:22 Speaker 01 I appreciate that context because I think on the outside you hear stablecoin and you're like, is this stable? Do I interact with this? And I don't think that's always the case, clearly. And now as we kind of get to today's news, it's a lot more volatile.
18:33 Speaker 00 Yes. And just to kind of wrap this up before we get into the regulation point that I think you're nudging us towards, the value of Luna, the sister token, DeTara, the stablecoin, went from like $100 per coin to one or two cents as we talk. Like, it's a collapse in price. I mean, I'm not going to say without precedent because Enron was the thing, but like, almost without precedent. And this has caused carnage across the crypto economy. Everything is sold off. Wah wah, sad times. I care about the people that are hurt by this, not the actual technology, because technology goes up and down. We're not making light of your pain. We're making light of the, sort of comedy of the situation. And Natasha, it's bringing in clarion calls for regulation.
19:07 Speaker 01 Yeah. US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen mentioned this week that there is going to need to be more stablecoin regulation. And that was in front of the Senate Banking Committee. And I think that, kind of similar to what we saw in India, where regulation was a response to volatility. It's a very natural part of something like this going up and down. So we started the segment off by talking about crypto's exuberance. Now we're seeing it kind of hit a, I wouldn't say maturity level, but like a realistic level that's causing people to speak out about it, which I think is healthy.
19:35 Speaker 00 Yeah. I just, I'm trying to fit some sort of Janet Yellen, quote, Janet's yelling joke into this show, and it's not quite coming together.
19:42 Speaker 01 I think that's the headline. We can make it a headline if we needed to.
19:44 Speaker 00 I think if we said Janet's yelling, everyone's gonna think we're talking about like Jane's Addiction to the Band.
19:48 Speaker 01 Oh, I don't even know that band.
19:49 Speaker 00 Yeah. I don't know if it would work.
19:51 Speaker 01 Okay, we'll talk offline.
19:52 Speaker 00 Usually we delete these joke workshops, but because we're live, you get them live. Hey! And that's how we named the show. I want to bring in Circle though, and USDC, which is a rival stablecoin, I suppose. You might have heard of Circle if you're listening in, because Circle is a crypto company that is going to go public via a SPAC, at least in theory. It has pushed back its SPAC and doubled its targeted valuation because its stablecoin is doing so well. And Natasha, I'm going to explain to you how it works. And it's going to sound very simple, because it is. Let's say I want a USDC. I give them a dollar, and they create a stablecoin for me, and hold on to the dollar.
20:24 Speaker 01 That's it. Hard stop.
20:25 Speaker 00 That's it.
20:25 Speaker 01 Wow. Yeah.
20:26 Speaker 00 Yeah. And then if they have a chart and you can track it and you can look at the assets and it's really easy and it's done well for them because it's not complicated. It's not, quote, "too clever by half." It's easy and you can do it that way. And Jeremy Allaire, the co-founder and CEO of Circle, quoted by, I think it was Jacqueline Melnick on the TechCrunch side. He said, "Frankly, the shocking thing to me is how many apparently intelligent people in the crypto universe bought the hype on USD or Tether." "The biggest remark I have is that disappointing so many thoughtful people believing that you could meme this into existence and stability, that was the surprising thing." And I disagree with Jeremy because his presumption here is that people are rational.
20:59 Speaker 01 I was gonna say, you're surprised people are memeing stuff into existence?
21:02 Speaker 00 Unlike, have you ever heard of the history of booms and busts across the financial landscape of human? I mean, he's being kind. I'm not.
21:09 Speaker 01 As we should, as we should. You know, it's interesting to me that Circle is pursuing this back, maybe not as surprising given it's a very simple business model or explanation to be giving, but based on how some other public crypto companies are performing this week, it doesn't seem like the markets are necessarily arms wide open for crypto companies.
21:25 Speaker 00 Julio, can we get Creed arms wide open in the background as I talk through Coinbase's earnings? Thank you. Coinbase did report earnings this week. If you listen to the Monday show, we presaged this. We said, "Look, you know, it's a tough week in crypto. Coinbase's earnings are going to be very important because they're going to show essentially what's going on inside of these exchanges in terms of volume and active users and provide us a really great kind of proxy for crypto activity outside of the Twitter echosphere, if you will." And Coinbase had bad earnings. And this is the first time I can say that about Coinbase. They've been really a kick-ass company for a long time. They would post big revenues, they would do cool tech things, they would generate tons of GAAP net income. And you know, beef or not with crypto world, Coinbase always had the results to back up its, let's call it self-confidence, maybe is the right phrase for that.
22:08 Speaker 00 In Q1, they shrank year over year and they also ended up losing money. And for investors and companies, what you want to see is growth and increasing profitability, demonstrating operating leverage and it's kind of standard business concepts. If you shrink and you start to lose money, it's bad. And they had a roughly, if I recall them out, a $1.2 billion profit swing year over year.
22:30 Speaker 01 I think that, you know, the other...
22:35 Speaker 01 I think the socks play. I was like, is that just me?
22:38 Speaker 00 No, that's Julio playing with arms wide open by Creed. We're gonna get... Okay, Julio, play it. We'll be quiet.
22:46 Speaker 01 I mean, I wish I knew the lyrics or else I would have totally sang for you guys.
22:51 Speaker 00 I'm not gonna sing.
22:55 Speaker 00 We have to go to the chorus. Oh, it's gone. Okay. Well, we didn't quite get to the chorus, but if you haven't listened to Creed in a long time.
23:03 Speaker 00 Okay, look, Creed is not like Nickelback. They have some great tracks and I will, I will go down on that ship.
23:08 Speaker 01 Can you tell that Equity is leaning heavily on the music category this week to stay positive and light?
23:14 Speaker 00 Well, you gotta have fun somehow and mostly talking about sad things. I mean, you and I like to kind of like, you know, banter and have a good time, make some jokes and enjoy this because it's fun. Podcasting is the best part of my week. But it is a little sad, but every item is like, okay, and then three more ponies fell into the ocean. You're like, ah.
23:29 Speaker 01 I know, I know. I mean, you were talking about Coinbase losing tons of money and I was hearing like the beginnings of a song playing in the background. And I was like, I, I can't, what is happening right now?
23:40 Speaker 01 Exactly. But I will pick up, I will pick up where you left off because there's one quote that I think is getting a lot of traction. Going back to crypto Twitter, which is that the crypto exchange in its earnings warned that bankruptcy could wipe out user funds, elevating the point that we've always known, which is that if all of your crypto is on Coinbase, you don't necessarily own that crypto. Is it fair that this is the quote that people are focusing on or does it feel like a soundbite that's getting?
24:03 Speaker 00 Okay, there's a lot to unpack here. I'm going to do it as quickly as I can. By the way, this is the question to ask. So dead on. There's a meme in the crypto world that says, not your keys, not your crypto, which is to say that if you hold your crypto worth on a centralized exchange that has the kind of custody of it, you don't have it. You have a theoretical right to it, but someone else holds it. An important concept as we think about exchanges and decentralization. In terms of the company's warning about possible bankruptcy, one thing that people do who don't read a lot of financial filings, and it's no fault of their own, they're allowed to have a life and be normal, is overly fixate on boilerplate. And one thing that we see when companies go public that have a history of losing money is they have a risk factor and they're asked one filing that says, we have not achieved profitability and they never achieve profitability because they have to cover their backside.
24:48 Speaker 00 And it's a standard bit of boilerplate and people go, oh, you know, company X is never going to make money. And I'm like.
24:53 Speaker 01 They admitted it. Yeah. I'm guilty of this. I think risk factors are for me, the first place I go when I see an S1 because it's the spiciest stuff on like more of the like the theory side. Like I think the numbers leave up to you. I like knowing them admitting that they're going to fail and that they need to randomly rely on Peloton for half of their revenue.
25:10 Speaker 00 Let's not make fun of a firm this early in the show. That's for next week. That's fascinating because it's the last thing I read, if I even read them.
25:16 Speaker 01 There we go. It's good. We work together.
25:18 Speaker 00 Yeah. And that's two P's, one P. So in this case, my first read was that Coinbase was just boiler plating. They're just saying like, look, if we went bankrupt, you know, these assets might be possibly part of that and you might not be able to hold on to them. I struggled to have as bearish a take on the company's financial solvency as others, but there are some indications that things aren't so great. Q1 operating cash burn was high, although it's very nuanced, given that they are moving around crypto assets like USDC. And so it's not exactly as clean as the SaaS companies. They do have a lot of cash. Their debt's not due for nine years, give or take, but we are seeing a sell off in their bonds. Coinbase is not going to broke unless there is a cascading catastrophic potential issue in its finances that I can't see in the next couple of years.
26:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
26:00 Speaker 00 So to me, that was more boilerplate. And then the CEO caught on Twitter and said, we're not going bankrupt, period, or something like that. And I was like, oh, ah, risk, risk.
26:09 Speaker 01 I mean, I do love that. That this just means people are reading financial documents more closely. Like to your point, I think that that elevating as a thing that's controversial probably wouldn't have been five years ago.
26:18 Speaker 00 And I didn't even mean to do this on purpose, but I'm wearing my Brian Armstrong costume today.
26:22 Speaker 01 Oh, my God. Great to have you on the show, Brian. Thanks for responding to our emails for once.
26:26 Speaker 00 Sorry, I'm a billionaire. I will be flying away.
26:29 Speaker 01 I do want to, sorry. I was going to try to workshop one last thing about Coinbase before we move on. So I think originally I was using Coinbase as the best signal to track how excited people are about crypto and how stable it is. But as I was looking into it for this show, I guess I remembered that the company makes money with transaction fees, meaning that a sell off does positively impact it, if I'm correct, and big swings in general, either way, will help the company make money. And so I'm wondering if long term Coinbase is the best company to try and extract, I don't know, sentiment from, or if we're seeing other players take its spot. Long term and you don't have to have an answer on the spot, but I'm just wondering.
27:07 Speaker 00 Oh, I do. I'm just trying to figure out how long to phrase it. What I would prefer is if we could take aggregated information from all the major exchanges, Kraken,
27:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
27:14 Speaker 00 FTX, Binance, Coinbase, and add up all the results together to get kind of a unified set of how much our consumer is trading right now. And then I would bring in all the DeFi exchanges, which are smaller, but also very important. Then I would bring in all the NFT companies, calculate all that. And then I would have this master spreadsheet. Only one of them is public. So we only have Coinbase.
27:31 Speaker 01 Okay.
27:31 Speaker 00 So I think you're dead on. In terms of signals we can really lean on, I think Coinbase is kind of it in terms of financial results of operating companies versus on-chain things like trading volume for ETH or whatever.
27:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. Tell us more about like the business of crypto companies than the future of crypto interest so far. But I do love this tweet that's on the screen right now.
27:53 Speaker 00 Yeah. If you can't see it, I'll read it to you. It's a tweet from someone named Alex, who has a really dweeby profile picture. He says, "Am I wrong that Coinbase has hella cash? Do I write like this? Has hella cash RN? Long-term debt not at term for nearly a decade and is in no danger of running out of funds? Question mark? I mean, it's cashless. Statement is a journey, but am I missing anything major?" And then people were like, yes. And they tried to like argue that Coinbase was in more trouble than I thought, and I wasn't quite convinced.
28:17 Speaker 01 I mean, it means something for us to be, yeah, not entirely cynical on Coinbase. I will take that and I will let us run with it.
28:24 Speaker 00 Oh, I mean, Coinbase is in a trough for sure, but like if volume goes back up in crypto trading, they print money. So really the question is where is crypto trading volume going? And if you're bullish or bearish, place your bets accordingly. But Coinbase, I nerdily track this company. I have a running spreadsheet of all of their historical transaction data, calculating out their take rates.
28:41 Speaker 01 That's why we love you.
28:42 Speaker 00 And yeah, I have questions, but like if volume goes up, they're fine. Let's move on to, ah, car crash number three. Natasha, Tiger Global.
28:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm actually kind of happy that we're ending our crypto segment for the episode. I was like, I have hit my peak, but let's talk about Tiger Global. Connie had a piece this week in which she wrote about this report that's still yet to be confirmed. Huge loss though for Tiger Global. They basically have a $7 billion hedge fund loss and have narrowly depleted its latest VC fund. So we're seeing it experience one of the biggest dollar declines for a hedge fund, not Its own hedge fund, a hedge fund in history and erased a lot of its gains since its first launch in 2001. Huge reckoning for Tiger Global.
29:22 Speaker 00 All that was well said. Just one tiny quibble. It's a $17 billion loss, not a $7 billion.
29:26 Speaker 01 Oh my God. Sorry. Did I say seven?
29:28 Speaker 00 I think you did. And I hate to correct you because you're brilliant.
29:31 Speaker 01 Seventeen, seventeen.
29:33 Speaker 00 It's a big enough differential that I felt the need because it goes to show the scale of the issue that Tiger has run into. And Natasha, just rewind the clock 12 months. It's May 2021. What are we talking about? The latest Tiger round, the index fund of growth stage companies, the IPO cycle, how Tiger has changed venture capital, according to everyone in venture. And now it turns out that they haven't.
29:53 Speaker 01 Oh my God. They added almost 120 unicorns to their portfolio in 2021. And so in some way, their exposure is so clear because what have we been talking about this past week? A lot of unicorns are having layoffs and are figuring out how to trim costs. So it's not all surprising that they are very exposed and thus very impacted by the venture winter this summer.
30:15 Speaker 00 Yeah. Well, let's pause and ask a question and then get back into the other stuff we have in this section. But like Tiger Global, how did they lose this much money?
30:21 Speaker 01 Oh my God.
30:22 Speaker 00 After they just put together an enormous Fund 15 worth about 12.7 billion that they've already nearly entirely put to work? Well, we've seen a massive sell off in the value of software companies, one of their key investment categories. We have seen a massive sell off in BNPL companies, harming all startups in kind of the fintech space. We have not seen things like neo-bank liquidity, apart from New Bank, which has gone eh. Things like better.com and the massive change in their business due to external factors and some internal mistakes, to be clear. But it just goes to show that the change in the valuation and worth of companies that Tiger was 28 minutes ago pumping cash into with a fire hose has changed broadly. And that means that they had to write all this stuff down. And then now they look currently about as silly as they looked strong last year.
31:04 Speaker 01 It's such a weird contrast. And I, to me, from the early stage world, seeing this sort of headline pop up is yes, another chapter in proving why Tiger Global might be going towards the early stage. There's more of a capital bubble around it and it isn't yet as prone to valuation slashes.
31:19 Speaker 00 Yes.
31:19 Speaker 01 But last week I was writing about OnDeck layoffs and sources said that OnDeck was raising a fund largely from Tiger Global, then Tiger Global pulled out support. So I am wondering if
31:30 Speaker 00 Fund or round?
31:31 Speaker 01 Fund. They have a fund for their accelerator program, which is now kind of going to be scaled back. This is a detail that I am maybe over indexing on, but I, you know what, I'm not because I think that it's surprising that Tiger Global pulled out support from OnDeck and therefore pulled out some early stage exposure because it's making me think that we've already gotten past the point where Tiger Global is moving to the early stage.
31:48 Speaker 00 Oh, oh, oh. Okay. Let me, let me spit this back to you, make sure I'm tracking this. OnDeck, accelerator, different classes. Some of our friends worked there. I don't know if any of them still do. I haven't checked in with anybody, but we knew people who worked there at least at one time. Okay. And then they're going to put together a fund to invest in their own accelerator companies. Tiger was going to put money into that fund. Fair enough. Tiger pulls out of that fund, which means their capital will not be flowing through OnDeck into the OnDeck accelerator, limiting early stage exposure, comma, we heard recently they were doing more early stage. You're asking, is that already over?
32:18 Speaker 01 I think it's already over. I think Tiger's early stage party is over. You know, they did an investment in Angel List a few months ago, but that feels like a lifetime ago, based on how much the market's been corrected since. And so maybe it's OnDeck that is the reason they pulled out, but maybe it's also that they're not thinking that early stage is the answer. Let's see. I just think Tiger going quiet is the same way Tiger going loud had a huge impact for venture. Tiger going quiet will definitely have a huge impact for what we see happening.
32:43 Speaker 00 Oh, man. Tiger Global. What a name.
32:45 Speaker 01 I know. And what a website. You pulled up the website as we were prepping for the show. Give people a brief update of who not in the reporter's seat, how easy it is to talk to Tiger.
32:54 Speaker 00 No, it's about as easy as yelling at a brick wall and asking for poetry in return. Their website is a static page, essentially, that has like probably 100 words on it total and a phone number. And I'm not going to lie, Natasha, I'm a millennial journalist. I would rather saw off my fingers than call someone I don't know on the phone. I will do it when I have to, but please give me an email address. For the love. If you're on hopping with us right now, you can see the website in all of its glory.
33:17 Speaker 01 So impressive. It's so smart because it's similarly, and I guess I just sound lazy right now, but I'm like similarly has weeded me out from trying to talk to them at times because of this.
33:26 Speaker 00 Yes.
33:27 Speaker 01 So I usually just go the portfolio company route and try and reverse engineer my way into an email address, but.
33:31 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah, absolutely. If you're on the audio podcast Friday morning, imagine a seventh grader's first HTML project in their first web dev class when they make a static page and then just change out the text for really boring generic financial words. That's what it looks like.
33:46 Speaker 01 Perfectly said.
33:47 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's not much. Let's go ahead and move towards our conclusion here because we're a little bit over time and talk about just how much things have changed and where we are, you and I, in terms of figuring things out because that's what the real question here is. How close are we to understanding what's going on? And when was the last time we had to do so much retooling of our priors, if you will?
34:04 Speaker 01 Oh, my God. Yeah. I was thinking about this when talking to founders a few weeks ago, and I felt like when March 2020 happened, every company was suddenly newsworthy because they were reacting to this once in a lifetime event, changing product, changing their fundraising plans, et cetera. And I meant it in that moment. And now I haven't meant it in a while, but I think it's happening again where every company is again, kind of really newsworthy in how they're pivoting. I think that there's going to be the companies that say that this is not impacting business and VC firms will say that we are, what's the phrase that they use? Business as usual?
34:34 Speaker 00 Yeah, business as usual. We're still writing checks.
34:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, exactly. So I think those stories will not be interesting, but it's challenging me because I don't think that funding rounds have been super relevant for a long time. And now they feel like they'll be even less relevant in a way. What about you?
34:50 Speaker 00 Well, I started tracking the late-stage issues in the startup world late Q4, maybe like mid Q4 to late Q4, somewhere in there. I was not the first to this. I'm not trying to Keith Reboy this. I was medium early at best because I was busy. I should have been paying more attention. The changes in my world, the kind of late-stage startups, unicorns and IPOs have happened. Like, we're already there. And so my question that I'm trying to figure out now is just how far down the stack does it go? And does the pain trickle down in similar amounts as we get earlier and earlier? You know, a month ago, I would have said, yes, it trickles down, but less so. And now, after this conversation, maybe that was a little conservative of me. So I'm very curious about companies and what they're going to do. But one thing that we do as the market changes is we shift our focus a little bit. We try
35:33 Speaker 00 to make sure they're recovering the most interesting and most impactful things. And so Natasha, you've moved from ed tech during COVID to an early-stage focus to now something more on the fintech side. Walk me through this.
35:44 Speaker 01 Yeah. So I mean, one thing I've always struggled about, I guess, to get personal as a reporter, is figuring out the best way to frame what I'm interested in. Like, I know it when I see it, but I don't really think about branding it, for lack of better phrasing. But I've most Recently landed on fintech through the lens of access, education and really wealth and how people make money and talk about money as the thing that gets me interested. I always kind of light up when I hear someone either break access open to investing, teach them how to invest, or they themselves learn how to be like a more selfish worker. Like those are kind of the themes I care about. Yes, I mean, so that is my sector that I'm focusing on. Ed tech falls into that. Health tech falls into it. Any unicorn changing the way that they serve their employees falls into that. But it's been the latest way that I felt like I can kind of sum up what I care about, especially in the market today.
36:28 Speaker 00 So on the financial literacy point, you mean teaching regulars, like folks, just like, you know, people that we see at the coffee shop, how to better manage their money and also how to better demand their worth, if you will, in the market.
36:40 Speaker 01 Yeah. And I think that can go from anything from like social fintech that gets you to, you know, learn how to invest in crypto, to helping you learn how to buy a house by sharing that down payment with a couple of your friends. I feel like there's like a lot of interesting ways we're seeing fintech be more accessible that in some ways is like, okay, fintech, you've had a few years. What's happening? Like what's changing? But in other ways, like I'm kind of glad we're past the neo bank boom and can kind of take away some of that early noise. Like the noise is kind of in web three and crypto. I will cover that as part of it, but I'm glad to be covering fintech with Mary Ann. It'll be fun.
37:10 Speaker 00 Yeah, I was just about to say, well, you happen to be paired up with our ace fintech reporter, Mary Ann, who's been stuck in the, in the salt mines of that part of the world for so long. I don't know how she's still alive, frankly. There's just like, software is always busy, but fintech for the last two years just seemed to be regular explosions. Like it was just insane.
37:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, totally. And what we saw with Fast and Bolt and Main Street and so many of these fintech companies that they're having their moments of reckoning. So I think those are such interesting things to cover. I guess shooting it back to the late stage, I saw a tweet that I wanted to get your thoughts on, which is from Haystack, the investor at Haystack.
37:46 Speaker 00 Sumail Shah.
37:47 Speaker 01 Sumail Shah, thank you. He was saying how investor kind of feedback periods have always been long, but they're about to get a lot longer. I think he was probably insinuating that companies are just not going to go public anytime soon and we just won't know venture performance. What does that change for what you're covering, what TC plus is covering? To me, that was like a good way to frame that our jobs are going to be getting harder in terms of accountability.
38:07 Speaker 00 Exactly that. I mean, when he says venture feedback periods are long and they're going to get longer. My read of that is saying that if you make a seed bet and Haystack famously has invested around the earliest stages, call it seed, pre-seed, pre-pre-seed, mango seed, whatever the hell you want to call it. It's a long journey. You put $5 million into a seed company, you might not see an exit if it does great for eight, 10 to 12 years, right? So it's lengthy and everything just got pushed back because no one's going in public now because the IPO window is closed and there's antitrust concerns amongst major technology companies. They now have less money to play with because their stocks all went down and people are caring more about cash and shareholder returns in the form of buybacks and dividends. So if you're Microsoft, are you going to be out there splashing money around the startup world or are you probably being a bit more conservative, fewer exits, less velocity in exit pace?
38:51 Speaker 00 And that means that investors don't really know how they're doing for longer. And that means that, Erica, we also don't know how they are doing. So it's going to be harder, quieter, less loud and probably more boring. Last year was exciting at least.
39:05 Speaker 01 Oh my God, I remember there being a conversation we were having where I was like, what's the best, everyone's inflating their IRR right now. I'm like, which is the better, more accurate metric to use? And I feel like we're going to see a lot less leaks of IRR coming.
39:17 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think, I think those little tidbits are going to slow down. Look, let's stop because this is the right place to do it. Lot of questions, lot of things that are going on at once. I'm glad we have the show that we do to talk it through and stick with us because even though the show was not exactly the most positive show, I'm finding the world fascinating and there's so much to learn and I don't know what's going on yet. I'm trying to figure it out and trying to write it down.
39:40 Speaker 01 Totally. And if you are listening to us while you are running or listening to us during lunch right now, I hope you enjoyed the entertainment. I feel like I've recently gotten that feedback a lot that they're listening to us when they're running. So I mean, hopefully this keeps you going, literally.
39:52 Speaker 00 Yeah, if you're running right now, come on, pick up the pace. Look at your split times. Pathetic.
39:58 Speaker 01 Never, I never look at it because it is pathetic.
40:00 Speaker 00 Well, mine are. All right, we adore you all Natasha, thank you so much. And as always, a thank you to Grace Minden Hall, our producer, to Julio Berentos, who helps put the graphics together and host the whole thing, and also Yashak Kulkarni because he is the Tech Runch video god still. So thank you very much, everybody. Thank you for tuning in. We're back on Monday morning. Bye.
40:19 Speaker 01 Bye.
Previous Tech layoffs don't happen to companies, they happen to people Next What's ahead for crypto startups? Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated