Pod Insights Equity Podcast Bonus Episode: Say Hello to the Startup Battlefield Winner About this episode It’s the moment we’ve all been waiting for—the winner is announced! In this episode, we get to know the winner of the 2022 Startup Battlefield competition. We’ll hear what’s next for their company and get insight from TechCrunch staff, VCs, and audience members on why they were the right choice.
Be sure to check out all of the other podcasts in the TechCrunch Podcast Network: Found, Equity, The TechCrunch Podcast, Chain Reaction and The TechCrunch Live Podcast.
Credits: Equity is produced by Theresa Loconsolo with editing by Kell. Bryce Durbin is our Illustrator. We'd also like to thank the audience development team and Henry Pickavet, who manages TechCrunch audio products.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript 6,070 words · 13 speakers
0:06 Speaker 00 Hey everyone, welcome to Startup Battlefield.
0:08 Speaker 01 In this podcast mini-series, we're taking you behind the scenes of TechCrunch's illustrious pitch competition. You'll learn how we pick the top 20 companies and what it takes to win over the panel of judges.
0:18 Speaker 02 I feel good and I want to win.
0:25 Speaker 02 I want all my hard work to just come true, that's it.
0:28 Speaker 03 I love a good underdog story, and that feels like one of those.
0:31 Speaker 00 With that, we will go ahead and move to the winner of Startup Battlefield 2022, and that is...
0:38 Speaker 01 Let's give them one big round of applause.
0:45 Speaker 01 Hello and welcome to the final episode of Inside Startup Battlefield. It's me, your host and the Startup Battlefield editor, Nisha Tammbe. Thank you all so much for coming on this journey with us. In this episode, we'll be sitting down with the winners to get to know them a little bit better.
1:02 Speaker 04 When a company is ready to go, I give them a reminder of why they're in this competition. We pick them for a reason. We pick them out of thousands of applications. It is harder to get into Startup Battlefield than it is to get into Harvard. So to be able to remind them that it's not just, hey, this is a stressful thing to be pitching on stage, or, oh my God, here's a competition and I need to win. They've already won by being selected. When they come offstage, it is just celebration. It does not even matter how the pitch went. You know, I'm backstage watching every single pitch, every single Q and A segment. And when they come offstage, it is a huge accomplishment.
1:42 Speaker 04 To put yourself and your company on a stage of this magnitude is a big deal. And the fact that these founders have done it, I mean, I get nervous going onstage to announce who the runner-up and the winner are, actually pitching a company. I think, you know, I'm in awe of the founders I get to work with, and it's honestly an honor. But when they come offstage, it is a hug and a high five and you did well. Like, you got this. This is, this is going to be great for you. So I'm really excited that that was, that's our flow. They're prepped before they go onstage, and they come offstage, and it's just a celebration.
2:23 Speaker 05 So you just came offstage, you're on the finals. How are you feeling about how pitch number two went?
2:30 Speaker 06 I think it went well. I'm glad it's over. I can relax finally and maybe watch some other pitches and get to enjoy what people talk about.
2:39 Speaker 02 I feel good and I want to win. If we win, like I said, we were here for fundraising. That would be one step for us to go back and get some things done very quickly because we have few lags back my workplace. So we'll get that done so that it will help us to get more funding.
3:00 Speaker 05 So came offstage again with another massive smile. How did it go?
3:05 Speaker 07 It went really well. So first off, I think just being up there and being in the top five is awesome. Like I've had people reaching out already since yesterday, like, oh, we want to try your stuff. Oh, we're interested. Like, oh, tell me more. Like, oh, what roles are you hiring for? So I've already started getting what I wanted from being up on there, which is amazing. And then if we win, like, that's just going to give us so much more clout. It's like perfect for when we go to raise our next round. We can point to this, like, hey, we won Battlefield, right? Can also point that out to customers. I actually even had someone I've been in conversation with who hadn't responded to that last email I sent, send me a message this morning and say, can we chat next week?
3:44 Speaker 01 Picking a winner is honestly impossible and I'm glad that I don't have that task. It's really up to the judges in the final round to pick the winner. Every company is the best in their field or they are doing one of the most innovative things in their field. So to pick just one is very hard. I mean, they're all the best of their category or even the best of the best.
4:11 Speaker 05 After watching all the pitches, who do you think is going to take it home?
4:15 Speaker 08 Well, initially I thought that the lithium startup just has the biggest TAM. But the very last one, I didn't like it initially, but the more traction that they showed and the more, not only LOIs, but actual contracts that they booked, it seems that they've got the most traction that they've taken off like a rocket ship. And so if I really had to pick one, I think they're the easiest one. I mean, just the easiest pick. They've de-risked everything. They just need to scale up the robotics.
4:46 Speaker 09 Okay, I'm gonna go counter to that. I think it was definitely the two ladies from Lithium. I think, you know, good presentation. They clearly have an incredibly close relationship to the problem. And if they can make that work and get that to scale, I think that's a giga corn right there.
5:03 Speaker 10 I was just really impressed with the caliber of presentations and the companies. People are solving problems I didn't even know existed in ways that are unbelievably sophisticated. So yeah, I was just overall very impressed.
5:16 Speaker 11 I arrived, I just watched the last one. Cool. But I really liked their women talking about the lithium. But I don't know the name of the company because I really arrived in the middle of their presentation. But I'm up.
5:31 Speaker 00 Well, with that, I think we will go ahead and move to the winner of Startup Battlefield 2022. And that is Minerva Lithium.
5:48 Speaker 01 Minerva Lithium created a nano mosaic technology that when put into brine can actually extract lithium. And side benefit is actually drinkable water. So they're creating some really game changing technology in their space. And let's give them one big round of applause.
6:08 Speaker 02 All right, how do you feel? I feel top of the world. Yay! And yeah. And this is my dream country. It's not a simple thing for me. So yeah, this is another step for me, which will, you know, it is an affirmation that I am on the right path. And you know, there's more to do.
6:31 Speaker 01 Now we'll hear some excerpts from Sheba's interview from the Tech Crunch's Bound podcast. Daryl Etherington is the host, and I stepped in as co-host for this one. Enjoy and check out the Bound feed for the full episode.
6:44 Speaker 12 You know why you're here. This is our podcast focused on the stories behind the startups, as told by the people who built them, the entrepreneurs and the startup founders who create these companies. And the reason Nisha is here is because we're going to be talking to the winner of the most recent startup battlefield competition on this show. Today, we're talking to Shiba Daiwo from Minerva Lithium, a clean energy technology that uses a proprietary nano mosaic filter to extract critical materials from non-traditional water resources. So excited to hear more from Shiba and also learn a bit more about what goes on behind the scenes at Battlefield.
7:25 Speaker 12 Hi, Shiba. How's it going?
7:27 Speaker 02 All good. How about you?
7:29 Speaker 12 Oh, it's going great. I'm very excited to talk to you. Can you tell us a bit about what Minerva Lithium does?
7:36 Speaker 02 In Minerva Lithium, we do direct lithium extraction technology for critical minerals. And what we do is we are aiming to develop sustainable energy technology to kind of address the national security and economic prosperity of United States. So we are developing a very efficient direct lithium extraction technology and as well purifying the water. So that is what our technology lies in.
8:02 Speaker 12 Nice. Yeah, that sounds great. I think obviously addresses a problem, growing problem. We need lithium. We need it from somewhere. It's not readily available and this direct, the direct extraction is like an area of growing interest. I think the thing that always comes up, at least in my limited experience, talking about this or learning about this, is cost, right? So it seems to be always like it's too, it's too expensive in terms of the end result and sort of the profit margins that people have. So how do you kind of address that part of the problem?
8:32 Speaker 02 So there are two different things that currently Minerva Lithium is focusing. One is definitely to cut down the cost. And the second most important right now, there is lot of awareness among people in the world. That is because of global climate change crisis. And right now, we require a sustainable technology, sustainable way to do things to move forward. So it's like a cycle. So if any new technology is coming and if they're producing lot of carbon emission and there's lot of damage that is being done to the environment. You're trying to address the global climate change and you're producing, actually contributing to it in a way. So that is like a cycle and that's what I have been seeing and we are trying
9:15 Speaker 02 to break this down and considering the impact, the global impact, the, you know, the pollution has. So we are trying to cut that down and as well provide, you know, a much more efficient technology which is cost effective. So considering, you know, I just would like to give some, you know, economics there. So currently the technology that is being used to extract lithium, it is called solar evaporation. And as the name itself sounds, it is very Asian technique and it uses about twenty thousand acres of land. And they extract lithium, for example, if they extract one metric ton of lithium for months, we extract lithium within seventy two hours.
9:56 Speaker 12 Wow.
9:57 Speaker 02 And the usage of water, they use up to dry that water, you know, they use up about five hundred thousand gallons of water to produce one metric ton of lithium, whereas we use thirty thousand gallons of water and we are recycling that water. So we are recycling and that water can be reused. So there's no wastage that you see here and that's what we are trying to achieve. And this is not happening in a day. So we have been working from the science and right now we have reached at the pilot scale. So I would say that it would definitely take time, but we will get there.
10:29 Speaker 12 So Nisha, I'm curious, because you work with all these companies so closely and you obviously worked with Minerva, what was the initial conversations like and how do you do the kind of discovery around, you know, talking to Sheba and learning about like the company and what, how do you, how do you say like, oh, that sounds really cool? Like, just take us through that.
10:48 Speaker 04 Well, we have an open application process which y'all came through. And I remember when I read the application, quite frankly, I didn't believe it. I was just like, this is impossible.
10:58 Speaker 12 We get a lot of those. We get a lot of those where it's like, well, I have a perpetual motion machine. And you're like, I don't think you do. I don't think you have that.
11:05 Speaker 04 No, you don't. But one of the things we do in the review process while we're doing our due diligence, much like a VC fund does, we go to experts and we say, hey, like, this company says they can do this. Is this possible? And the people that we went to were like, yes, what they're doing exists. What they're doing is real. And then when I talked to them more and heard about their backgrounds, because, you know, both Sheba and her co-founder have pretty, pretty significant academic backgrounds. And they're, they're researchers. They really know what they're doing. And to then be able to put that on stage was amazing. It, it took us a little time to get the messaging right, I think.
11:43 Speaker 02 Yes.
11:44 Speaker 04 But by the end of it, it was, it was pretty flawless.
11:47 Speaker 12 Cool. Well, and Sheba, do you want to maybe take us into some of that background? So what brought you to this? Like, was it your academic work? Or how did you get into this to begin with?
11:56 Speaker 02 This is something that it kind of goes into my personal journey. I actually wanted to be a doctor. And my father wanted me to be a doctor. It's, it's like that in India. You are either an engineer or a doctor, either of the two. So that's how I grew up, thinking that I'll be a doctor. But I couldn't, because I couldn't get into one of those schools. And that is when I decided to do something different. And I've heard of nanotechnology, got into the research. And I still remember those conversations that I used to have during my traveling for my graduation from, you know, from my home to my university. What is nanotechnology? What do you do? And they really don't get, no one gets it, you know, what research is. And they don't understand
12:39 Speaker 02 the value. And somewhere, I take criticism, maybe constructively. I'm like, you know, maybe I need to do something about this. Maybe people need to know what, you know, we have a value. I know it's not seen on a daily basis, like how doctors' value is seen on a daily basis. But we are valuable too. So that is something that I grew up. And then when I came to US, fortunately, my university promoted entrepreneurship. And I thought this is a great chance for me. And I really wanted to work on this and I believe in the product.
13:13 Speaker 04 You know, shifting shifting into like the battlefield side of things a little bit. You know, what was that experience like for you over some of the highs and lows of the battlefield process?
13:22 Speaker 02 I would say that actually, whenever I used to participate in different competition, I kind of get the sense of it. You know, what my audience are and what's the pattern. It's very important. But this time, I feel that I kind of had a break with the pitch competitions because I just delivered a baby in January. And getting back to the work immediately, getting my head into this, it took me time. And I I I I struggled there a bit and managing all of this. And at the same time, while I had TechCrunch Battlefield, I had two other competitions. We actually won in all of those. But yeah, everything had a different pattern. So there were a lot of things that were going on and off.
14:02 Speaker 02 And I was like, I used to have a lot of conversations with Nisha and I was like, I was able to get what she was trying to tell. But I couldn't get that to her. You know, I I knew that what she was trying to tell me and what she was trying to direct me. I know that I could take that, but I really couldn't present it to her immediately. But somehow I just got some time for myself and I was able to do that. But I would say that Nisha played a significant role. And I would say till date, wherever I have been presenting and wherever I have actually done well. I've had people who, you know, criticized me. I mean, like, gave me a very good criticism. So and from that, I kind of, you know, grew and I take them constructively.
14:47 Speaker 12 Nice, yeah. It's just to switch gears a bit, I I'm curious, what have you been up to since in the months? What has happened as a result of Battlefield? And I guess, you know, what has the progress been for Minerva in general?
14:59 Speaker 02 Yeah, I would say that personally, I felt like a celebrity for a few days.
15:04 Speaker 12 That's what we hope will happen.
15:06 Speaker 02 Yes, it was amazing. And I was like, okay, how, when is this going to end? Even after coming back to my hometown, not in North Carolina, mayor called me and she was like, she's very proud of me. And then they're recognizing me.
15:20 Speaker 12 That's great.
15:21 Speaker 02 Yes.
15:21 Speaker 12 The mayor.
15:23 Speaker 02 So they're recognizing me this. Yeah, so they're recognizing me this December and giving me an award. And then otherwise, uh that that's my personal achievement that I would say. And then otherwise, for for company, it has been a huge shift. Now people know us and I had like fifty venture firms reaching out to us. I had uh every day, my last twenty five days, I was just in meetings. And we were trying to get the lead investor. So right now, uh we are raising about ten million and we have shortlisted few lead investors. Now they are doing due diligence and very soon they will visit our facility. And our round will be closing in the first week of February.
16:06 Speaker 02 So that is where we are and yeah, I thank Tech Ranch. I I actually didn't know that this would be coming after this. I just thought it's about hundred K, but later what I saw was much more bigger than that.
16:18 Speaker 04 So I have a question for you, actually I have two. But when you were on stage, there was a lot of wow, you know, kind of the same thing I felt when I was reading the application was like, this can't be real. Like it's it's too good to be true. What was that like on stage? Like I remember you and you know, and and Himalaya coming off stage just being like, they didn't believe that this is real.
16:40 Speaker 02 Yes.
16:41 Speaker 04 What, how was that, you know, for you when you were on stage experiencing that live?
16:47 Speaker 02 Yes, I would say, Nisha, this was not first time that we came across something like that. Because I know uh when we say something like that, they were like, then why are you here? Give us money kind of thing. So where's the money, you know, I I get that from lot of investors. But what we are doing is a, we have proved the basic science. So we have, you know, the foundation, because I have been to lot of D L E technologies. I have interacted with them and I personally have seen how they work. They don't work unfortunately because there's no science. So that is how, that is where we have our confidence and that is the U S B that we have in our intellectual property that we have. And the patent and the process that is so different from the others. So um I wasn't surprised.
17:30 Speaker 02 I was actually, uh I knew that this was coming because I have already faced these kind of questions lot of times. But we were prepared in a way and we tried to, uh you know, I felt that we answered in a right way, showing them like how from where we started. And what all we have proved and where are we getting? So I felt that it was a. Great way, actually, in a good way. I see that by highlighting that, I felt that the message was much clearly delivered to the people, you know.
17:57 Speaker 12 Hmm.
17:57 Speaker 02 Because they were just thinking, oh, this is just lithium extraction company. But later, when you know, the VCs were kind of highlighting that, that is where I saw that people were trying, oh, they also do the water. So next day, when I was seeing the LinkedIn post and all of that, they were all like, this is cool tech, really helping the world. So I saw that this actually made a, you know, good, um, it played a significant role there.
18:19 Speaker 12 I had a question just kind of around, you know, you talked about the progress so far in terms of funding and everything else. Just on the company building side, how has that been for you and how have you kind of evolved as a leader? And then as, as you're like looking into being the person who's like, you know, running a company, like, how do you deal with that? Where do you look for guidance and how have you kind of developed over time?
18:42 Speaker 02 I would say that while I was doing my PhD and while I was back in India, I used to participate in a lot of, you know, public speaking forums. So that way I know to express myself well, that is one quality that I had with me since back when, from when I was in school. But otherwise, leading company and all of that, I would say that I somewhere learned it from my co-founder, who is also, who was also my professor. The leadership skills that she has and the command that she has and how she lead, like, she's a woman and I have seen how she kind of fights back for everything. So I would say that she was, in a way, one, whom I was looking up to. And also, back at home, I, my mother, she runs schools, I mean, she's a principal.
19:25 Speaker 02 And then I have always seen her, how she manages stuff and she's a team leader and she manages everything on her own. So these two had played a very significant role and that somehow got into me, it's naturally, I would say. And as a leader, right now, in my team, we have like almost six to eight people, like scientists that are working under me. And mostly I try to have more communication and also much more clear on the daily basis, because in that way, that will help us to move forward. So I would just say, keep it simple, not complicated and have communication. And I think things will just work for you and that's how it have worked for me. So, yeah.
20:05 Speaker 04 You know, to, to grill on that a little bit, you know, you had mentioned that Himalaya had faced some challenges being a woman in academia. Your company is interfacing with a lot of. For lack of a better phrasing, cisgender, straight, white, American males, right? If you're looking at the oil industry or looking at a lot of the energy industry, that's what you're facing and you are not that. How are those interactions for you when you go into those conversations?
20:31 Speaker 02 Oh, okay. These are my nightmares that I have faced, actually. I'm sorry, how did I forget about that initially, my journey? Yeah, I was, to be very honest, I was made fun of because of my accent. I was made fun because of my, there were a lot of things that I have, I have faced. But right now, that is the reason I just said that I developed thick skin. I am actually very sensitive as a person. That's how I am. I cannot take it. But I know that I have to achieve this. And these things are going to come in my way anytime or the other. And there are intellectual people who can see what I can do. And that's how my approach has been. So I just look for the people who understand and who will help me to move forward.
21:15 Speaker 02 And I collaborate with them. And then that's how I have moved on. But otherwise, yes, I have faced inequality on every basis. But that is not going to stop me. I would put it that way.
21:28 Speaker 12 It sounds like when you encounter that, it doesn't sound like you, well, maybe this is incorrect, but it doesn't sound like you want to, you're trying to change minds. You're just like, you know what? You're not, you're not ready for what I have to offer and I'm going to find the people who do see that value. Is that accurate or do you?
21:42 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly. That's more, even like I, last year I was invited for TED Talk. And so there were, when I was presenting and there was a one person who said like, you know, maybe I need to change my accent. I said, I will present it the way I speak. If it is acceptable, I'll come. If not, I
22:00 Speaker 12 They actually suggested you change your accent?
22:02 Speaker 02 Yes, yeah, yeah. So like
22:05 Speaker 12 So offensive.
22:06 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, because it, it'll be much more approachable to people and all of that. But I, what I have seen, your personality matter, your energy matters and the content matters. And that's what I have learned and that's how people have been accepting me. So I said, I'm not going to change for anything. This is how it is going to be. Yeah.
22:24 Speaker 12 Yeah, you mentioned too, before the, the last answer about, you know, there have been some really low times. Is it mostly that when you encounter that kind of resistance? Or what else has been kind of, what have been the biggest challenges as you've gone about building this business?
22:38 Speaker 02 Um. I would also say that in a way, the area that we are in, uh, I mean, the lithium industry, uh, it's not a comfortable place to be in. Like, I've been to many conferences and I see among four hundred industries that were attending during one of the conferences in Arizona, I was the only woman there. And to have those conversations, cold conversations, and there were many uncomfortable situations that I had to be there. But only end of the day, I remind myself, this is what I have chosen. And I'm going to go ahead, no matter what, because I need to prove this. I want this to get into the world.
23:18 Speaker 02 Not just in case to make, uh, you know, to do something better for myself, but also as a concern for the environment too. And also, back in my country, water purification, there is a need for it. So considering all of this, I've just kept moving forward. But, uh, yeah, I have faced some harsh things, but, um, that is how it is. Oil industry, oil lithium industry, men and like what Nisha have mentioned, there were a lot of uncomfortable encounters that I did have. But I, like I said, I find people who are more collaborative and just move forward.
23:52 Speaker 04 And then a couple of years later, you're going to have the same companies that were not in, in favor of working with you, calling you up after disrupting.
24:02 Speaker 02 Sorry, I, I, maybe I didn't, uh, mention this. I have seen people who, uh, you know, shed dotes upon me and people who have rejected my business model and our vision that we had. They have actually approached us. The way they talk, the way things happen are happening to me right now. They're surprising. So that's how it, you know, it's going to work out. And I've seen, oh my God, the shift and the transition are completely different. And, yeah.
24:27 Speaker 12 That's great.
24:28 Speaker 04 You made waves on, on the tech branch side too, and that, I believe if I have my research done correctly, y'all are the first all-female, all-woman of color team to have won a disrupt.
24:40 Speaker 02 Thank you.
24:41 Speaker 12 Yeah, I think that's right, yeah.
24:42 Speaker 02 Yeah.
24:43 Speaker 12 Oh, I was gonna ask about, so what comes next? So you talked a bit about, you know, you're, you're looking for the lead and you're in the due diligence process for that. But what, what's next for the company? What are your next, your goals for even into 2023 or beyond?
24:55 Speaker 02 So right now in North Carolina, we have Toyota battery manufacturing unit. That's going to be, you know, a very huge one that's going to start in 2025. We have sunlight batteries coming around and they're just here in Greensboro. All of them at one place. We are trying to get there. So we process battery grade lithium. So once we do pilot demonstration, so like I said, even mayor and you know, government is trying to help us, like city council is trying to help us. So if everything goes well, do the pilot demonstration after the customer validation. We would either have strategic alliance or a partnership with these companies and they could be our customers.
25:36 Speaker 12 Nice, yeah. And then does that require, do you think, is there a lot of growth or hiring that you plan to do? Or what, like is that coming off the round? Like what, what is the round then going to be used for?
25:45 Speaker 02 Yeah, so the round right now we are also using for hiring. Basically soft skills like marketing and business, business development officer. And also on the technical end, we do require operational engineers and process engineers. So that would help us to leverage to pilot scale. And then maybe, once we get to the commercialization, it's going to also boost the economy of, you know, of the place that I live in. So that's how we are being promoted right now. Yeah.
26:15 Speaker 12 Nice. More longer term, like what do you imagine in your ideal world? Like where does Minerva sit in like 10 years' time? Like as an established company, as a mature company? Like what do you think the future looks like for you?
26:26 Speaker 02 Definitely my ambition is to go public and that's what I am aiming for. Even now I keep getting advices, you're a woman and you need to take care of your family. You better license the technology. So this is something that I keep getting even now, even after coming this far, you keep getting those. But that is my ambition that I want to take it to, you know, public and have this a public company. And then from there, maybe we will have a research and development center where we will be developing more exciting technologies because we know what the crisis would be. Next, Rudy cobalt, nickel. And then we have other things coming up. So maybe, you know, there's also other crisis where there's a lot of clay in the water.
27:10 Speaker 02 How to separate clay from the water? There are so many things that can be done. So I definitely want to have my own research and development center and then keep developing. So maybe I could also do that.
27:22 Speaker 12 Yeah, cool. Well, that's great. I just out of curiosity, personally, do you have any goals now? What do you want to accomplish, you know, with your own personal life over the next couple of years?
27:32 Speaker 02 For next couple of years, like I gave ten years of time for myself to be in because each day, actually, after I graduate, I'm an international student, like former. At that point of time, I did get job in Intel, one of the biggest semiconductor company. And then there was another university, Harvard University, that is in Washington DC. And I had these different choices and I had to make choice with this, which is so indefinite.
27:59 Speaker 12 Right.
27:59 Speaker 02 There's nothing there and I'm an international student. I get lot of my friends, colleagues, you know, you're an international student, you do not have luxury to, you know, experiment. You do not have luxury to go ahead in this. You don't see anything here. People come to earn money here. So it was that way. And today I get phone calls saying that, how did you make this decision? How did you know that, you know, this is going to come? So I would say that I believe in what I'm doing right now. And within ten years, I believe that I'm going to accomplish what my vision is. And like I said, in also sustainable way and also do something for my home country too. So considering all of this and maybe at that point of time, like I said, I would just,
28:42 Speaker 02 you know, get it public and then have my own research and development and develop new technologies.
28:48 Speaker 04 I think that's really powerful. And, you know, I'm Indian American and my dad came here, my mom came here. Well, mom's complicated, but my dad came here, you know, in the seventies in the engineering wave that came over at the time, but it was still following that very traditional path. And to see what you've done is as an Indian American person in the community, it's like, wow, like, you know, I'm not a doctor and engineer and to be able to see what you've done is equally as inspiring. So thank you for that. And doing it with your personality, because I think you're also one of the only companies to have ever put a SpongeBob character on your lead slide. Definitely, definitely a first that we've had.
29:30 Speaker 02 Yeah, so like I said, like I'm good at telling stories. And I, when I tell story, I look at my audience. Are they interested in what I'm saying? And to grab their attention, I kind of get these things. Uh, so that the story becomes much more, uh, you know, interesting for them and they are able to absorb it. So that's how I have learnt and I've got my way until here, you know, comparing because science is so difficult to get there. So I ha- I also keep training these graduate students. They have their pitch presentations and they have to do pitch their thesis within three minutes. And I've been topping in that all my four years because I know to deliver that message. Like I say, you know, what you're using your phone, you know, I can make changes in that using my research.
30:15 Speaker 02 So people have to feel your story personally. So it's not cancer for them to feel it. Because when I say cancer, people are like, oh my God, you know, I, there's a, they feel for it. So I have seen that because, uh, and I, I always compared, why is the, why are these people winning? And why am I not winning? Because I'm not making my story personal. They're not connecting to my story. So this is a way I kind of add little humor in a way. And so that they can also remember it at the end. Maybe they remember now Nano Music as Sponge, you know how Sponge works? So the story is in their head somehow. So that's what I try to do.
30:51 Speaker 12 That's great. Yeah, it's, it is super important to make things relatable.
30:54 Speaker 02 Yeah.
30:54 Speaker 12 Something we struggle with on a daily basis as writers at TechCrunch. But I think, I think that's a terrific place to end because you made an absorption joke in a SpongeBob answer. Which I just want to point out, wonderful, genius.
31:12 Speaker 02 Thank you.
31:14 Speaker 12 But thanks so much. It's been lovely talking to you, Shiva, and this is fantastic. And, you know, we're very excited to see what Minerva does next. And we're thrilled that you won the competition as well.
31:25 Speaker 02 Yeah.
31:25 Speaker 04 And because I'm, I'm always, you know, closing, it's been a pleasure working with you for so many weeks. And also, you know, when that IPO comes around, you know, you know who to announce that on stage. You just come back, come back again to disrupt and then we'll put you on stage when you're announcing that IPO as well.
31:43 Speaker 12 Absolutely.
31:44 Speaker 02 Sure, I already saw myself there, so yeah, definitely.
31:47 Speaker 12 There you go, yeah.
31:58 Speaker 01 Inside Startup Battlefield is hosted by me, Startup Battlefield editor, Nisha Dambay. We're produced and edited by Maggie Stamet and Grace Mendelsohn. Rice Durbin is our illustrator and Henry Pigabett manages TechCrunch Audio Products. Special thanks to all of our founders, experts, and MTC staffers who lent us their voices and expertise. Inside Startup Battlefield is part of the TechCrunch Podcast Network.
Previous Why hasn’t generative AI come up with something easier to say than “generative AI”? Next Equity Monday: We'd give an arm and a leg for an ARM IPO filing Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated