Pod Insights Equity Podcast 2022's best and worst dinner guest: Elon Musk About this episode In honor of 2022 finally coming to a close, the Equity crew is getting reflective. We dug through the archives, and this week, we're listening back to Alex, Natasha and Mary Ann's coverage of the biggest stories of the year as they unfolded.
Here's what the trio got into with help from guest hosts, Becca Szkutak and Anita Ramaswamy:
How Alex jinxed us from the start when he asked for more tech drama (TC+) back in January
Early signs of the downturn to come with Better.com and the human cost of layoffs
The will-they-won't-they courtship of Elon Musk and Twitter
The downfall of FTX (TC+) and why you should never let FOMO guide your investments (TC+)
Some of these stories are still evolving as we type, but don't fret - we'll catch you up in the new year.
Of course, we can't sign off without saying thank you to all of you for sticking by us during this rollercoaster of a year, and we can't wait to see you in 2023!
Equity drops at 7 a.m. PT every Monday, Wednesday and Friday, so subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Overcast, Spotify and all the casts. TechCrunch also has a great show on crypto, a show that interviews founders, one that details how our stories come together, and more!
Credits: Equity is produced by Theresa Loconsolo with editing by Kell. Bryce Durbin is our Illustrator. We'd also like to thank the audience development team and Henry Pickavet, who manages TechCrunch audio products.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript 11,310 words · 5 speakers
0:10 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome back to Equity, a podcast about the business of startups where we unpack the numbers and nuance behind the headlines. I'm Natasha Mascherini and this is our Friday show, our last one of the year. Yes, it is somehow December 30th, and it has been a year. And I know we've already done our big recap on what exactly happened, but there's nothing quite like the moment you see on air that Elon Musk is actually going to buy Twitter. So we're doing something a little fun, which is putting together a highlight reel of some of the best moments that happened on the pod this year, just because nothing really can replace the emotion of processing a crazy 12 months. So stay tuned.
0:50 Speaker 00 We of course have to talk about Mary Ann's beat this entire year, which was better.com. To many, better.com signaled the beginning of a downturn that just kept on going. But there were so many more specifics that you have to take a listen to.
1:04 Speaker 01 And Mary Ann, somehow better.com is back in the news. And how did we get here? Maybe is the right question to start with.
1:11 Speaker 02 Okay, well, I don't think it's a big shock that better.com had more layoffs, right? I mean, after the events of the past couple of months, for those who've been paying attention, or those who haven't, this saga kind of all started in earnest, early December, when better.com laid off about 900 people or 9% of its workforce.
1:30 Speaker 01 Yep.
1:30 Speaker 02 Via or during a Zoom call, the way the CEO did it, Vishal Garg was condemned all over the world. The video went viral.
1:37 Speaker 00 Which like, wow, what a moment to be in a tech CEO, have your layoffs go viral. What?
1:43 Speaker 02 Right. I mean, like I said, they're not the first company to lay off people during a Zoom call, but I guess it was the way it was done. And then all sorts of things came out that some of it had been reported on, but just, you know, Vishal's reported history of verbal abuse of his employees. Emails came out where he was insulting investors, lawsuits filed against him for all sorts of things, and just on and on and on. So he ended up taking a break where the company hired a crisis firm to help. We were all wondering, like, how does he still have a job? A month later, he comes back. He's still CEO.
2:17 Speaker 01 A month long break? What is this, an episode of Friends?
2:20 Speaker 02 That's like, yeah, I feel like people do that.
2:23 Speaker 01 Sorry to date myself there, but like, I really do feel like this is a Ross and Rachel situation. Sorry, Mary Ann, back to you.
2:27 Speaker 02 No, no, no, I'm trying, like, I'm just trying to, I don't want to overdo it with the history, but it's good context. So, you know. Yeah, no, please handhold us. Yeah, during this whole time, like, a bunch of people are resigning, ton of senior executives were resigning. The company's just like slowly sort of falling apart, to be honest. In the meantime, market conditions are getting worse. Better.com is a digital lender, mortgage lender. It was really big on refinancings, which was really huge 2020. And then started to dip in 2021 as interest rates started to climb. So its business took a large hit.
3:00 Speaker 01 Yep.
3:00 Speaker 02 So with fewer people refinancing and also people struggling in general, just to purchase with a higher interest rates. It's been suffering and you combine that with the hit to its reputation that occurred in December. Its business hasn't been doing well. So I heard that it was going to lay off thousands of people this week, which let me be clear. It is not fun as a reporter ever to cover layoffs. Like it sucks and we always feel, we don't enjoy it, just, you know, we enjoy getting scoops. We don't enjoy writing about people getting laid off, just to make that clear. Yes. I had heard about 4,000 and it ended up being just over 3,000 people. All right. So again, understandable market conditions, [__] up situation.
3:39 Speaker 02 You're going to have some layoffs, but what better.com did is manage to make it even worse.
3:49 Speaker 02 Because they sent severance checks out through their payroll app after midnight before anyone was even notified that they were being laid off. And then realized their mistake and then took them back. So for people.
4:03 Speaker 01 They took them back.
4:04 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah. Until they announced it for some. So that's where we're at today, basically. Yeah. So, so here's what I believe happened. I don't know for sure. They were originally planning to lay off people on one day and then realized that that had kind of leaked. So they moved it to like another day, but forgot to change that in the payroll system. So severance checks started going out too early. Now for the employees who've already been through hell and back, this was just like insult to injury. I had people emailing me, commenting on my LinkedIn post about how disgusted they were without everything had been handled. They felt completely disrespected, you know, it just, it couldn't get much worse at better.com.
4:45 Speaker 01 A SoftBank company.
4:47 Speaker 02 A SoftBank company.
4:49 Speaker 01 Throwing that in there because Marion, they raised last April, May, somewhere in there.
4:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, last year they raised about $500 million, I think it was. Was it all from SoftBank? I don't remember, but it was a big chunk was from SoftBank.
4:59 Speaker 01 Yeah.
5:00 Speaker 02 Yeah, they were going to go public via SPAC. That's definitely on hold. I don't think going public will happen anytime soon for this company if it even manages to survive all this. And there are comparisons to WeWork, right? Another kind of prop tech or real estate tech company that was SoftBank backed with a very eccentric or controversial CEO. So there are definitely some parallels there.
5:20 Speaker 00 Yeah. So like my, after reading your coverage, literally for the past like few months, I at first was like, okay, we're seeing what we are seeing with a lot of growth stage companies. They grew too fast, have to scale back, blah, blah, blah. But now I'm at a spot where I feel like it's, it's very different than just a growth stage company being a little too spendy. It's a company that missed the correct business model, lost top talent and has a shitty culture. And that feels a lot harder to recover from than, than a company that just had to have a heart to heart moment and really rebuild its processes. And I think that's kind of what's different about Better right now.
5:54 Speaker 01 Think about Airbnb. Airbnb had a catastrophic start to COVID. They had to lay off a bunch of staff and then they did it, I think in pretty good format. Like they were super upfront about it. They paid a lot of money out. They were like, look, this is just what happened. Sorry. And it was generally not well received, but about as well received as it could be, which is I think indicative of what happened next to the company, which was strong performance, good execution, a recovery, if you will, because Natasha's right, they didn't have a completely shattered culture essentially surrounding one asshat who was the CEO. And it's amazing how culture does in fact matter at companies, shockingly enough. So.
6:28 Speaker 02 Absolutely. I mean, who that worked at better.com after the mess in December had any motivation? Who had any pride, honestly, anymore in their job? Like I would venture to say it's very few people and it's really sad situation. I feel terrible for those laid off. I hope they bounce back. We'll have to see what happens next with the company.
6:51 Speaker 00 Mary Ann, you and Christine wrote a story that was really looking inside the human story of Better.com's layoff spree, including just recent news on more layoffs coming out of them. So I thought you could walk us through some of like the news and then we can get into the more specific stories.
7:05 Speaker 02 Yeah, I've been writing about these layoffs since December of last year.
7:09 Speaker 00 Wow.
7:10 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's been going on that long. And so this company, Digital Mortgage Lender, has had like four known mass layoffs, but they're also apparently doing lots of kind of smaller layoffs that that aren't getting as much like press or notice. And over time, that's happening more often. Apparently, we've I started having people who used to work at the company reach out to me over the past few months. And they're that well, actually, they've been reaching out to me ever since I started covering them. But all of a sudden, it was like a big flurry of people and they were pissed off and upset and even really felt hurt because like they got laid off, they were getting some of them like two weeks severance, whereas people who got laid off earlier this year were getting
7:53 Speaker 02 like three months severance. And, you know, they're just like, what the hell, I've actually stuck through this with this company through all this ups and downs, negative headlines, and all this crazy and now I'm getting less than two weeks of severance. It's like really upsetting. And that's just one of the many reasons that these people were upset.
8:12 Speaker 00 We'll link the timeline in the show notes, because I think it's important for people to see really, I mean, the one year anniversary of you covering that story is actually coming up pretty soon, which is wild. But there was one stat that I think put it really well into context that you included, which is at its peak late last year, Better had about 10,000 employees. I mean, now it's much closer to 2,400 workers and one employee estimated that it needs to get to 500 employees in order to actually become this like a more stable business.
8:41 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, obviously, they leaned too heavily into the refinancing when interest rates were super low and we saw a refinancing boom. Things dramatically changed since then. Interest rates for mortgages are like sky high again. And they just, they bet too much on it, overhired, all those things. And you know, that happened to a lot of different companies over the pandemic boom, right? Better was not alone. I think, again, what, what stood out about Better is just really the, the terrible way it handled all of these layoffs. They're very insensitively, really just upset these people. And I have to say, after talking to so many of them, I felt it was really important to get their stories out. And yeah, in the past, like I've written these stories and, and we focus a lot on the employers when we write about layoffs. But I thought we really need to give these employees a voice.
9:26 Speaker 02 Like, we really need people to hear what I'm hearing because it's horrific. And, you know, it's, it's sad and, and I'm not saying that like I want to share bad news, but I really feel like people need to know this. Christine and I talked to several different people. We ended up writing like the four individual stories. We didn't write it in their voice, but we wanted to break it out like, because they are individuals. They're not, I didn't want to just lump them together as, oh, employees were pissed off because we just wanted to give them an opportunity to tell their stories. And so that's what we did.
9:56 Speaker 00 I think it's so important for, for people to read every story that you include. I think there's, there's four of them, but the, the common like vibe I got after doing that was that there was like, it did a good job of explaining how employees feel like a back and forth. And something that even though we try our best with a lot of layoff stories, like you said, they focus on employers. They focus on people losing their jobs, but it doesn't ever get into what you guys did this time, which is there's this back and forth of like choosing to stay at a job. What does it mean to have, to stay at a company that's getting negative press? But you are on maternity leave or you are, you know, you can't, you don't want to look for a job during like the looming recession. I think this did a good job of explaining that it's not as simple as quitting your job. And I think sometimes even as tech reporters, it can be like, this is such as like annoying layoff and who could stay at better.com?
10:42 Speaker 00 And it's like, well, these people, because it's hard to leave your job. And I'm kind of glad that we were reminded of all the actual human costs.
10:49 Speaker 02 Right. And one quick thing to say is a lot of these people started with like huge high hopes, right? The company was doing really well. The CEO is very charismatic. They were kind of, you know, they were really excited when they started. And what I heard from every single one of them was by the time they left, they were just, you know, so disheartened and felt just basically crushed by their experience. Like I felt like they were all just traumatized.
11:12 Speaker 03 But I was just gonna say, I really liked how the story also talks to some people who were still there. Because I feel like that part of the conversation gets left out with the layoffs. I mean, if a big chunk of people in your department or a big chunk of people in that you work with day to day get laid off, like that drastically changes the jobs of everyone else who still works at the startup too. I know I have a friend who works at one of the big Boston unicorn companies that recently had layoffs and she now has like four different jobs and she didn't before. And it's like, it drastically changes those people's careers too. And I know the story about the woman on maternity leave just really struck me as just like, how bad can it get if a company's cutting staff in the way it is for the people who are still there? And it's sometimes hard to remember that it gets really bad sometimes.
11:57 Speaker 02 Yeah.
11:59 Speaker 02 And I know none of you expected that we would be talking about this during our 2022 recap. But Elon Musk and Twitter, there's so much to the saga from when we believed it wasn't going to actually happen to when it happened to the layoffs. So let's just go listen to what happened.
12:13 Speaker 01 Speaking of dying on hills, apparently Elon Musk was not [BLEEP] posting when he decided that Twitter needs help. And Twitter's gonna die on that hill. So where did it begin with this one, guys?
12:23 Speaker 02 Unbelievable.
12:25 Speaker 00 Alex, let me just say, I am blaming you because
12:28 Speaker 01 Okay.
12:28 Speaker 00 a few months ago, you wrote a piece about how you want more drama on in tech and in tech Twitter.
12:34 Speaker 01 Oh, that's right.
12:35 Speaker 00 Ever since, ever since, we've jinxed the category of fintech. There has been only tech drama. I feel like Equity is the podcast you want to listen to because we're just gonna throw out these statements and then they're gonna age very, very interestingly. But yeah, I mean, this week, I feel like Elon kind of went from mocking Twitter, kind of wanting to build the next one, to then taking nearly 10% of it, to then taking a board seat. And to where we are today, I guess, promising that they're working on an edit button and Twitter, in fact, confirming that they've been working on an edit button. So it's just so many kind of bingo boards all clashing together.
13:11 Speaker 02 First thing that I thought of was if you can't beat them, join them. And I feel like that's what happened here is that Elon recognized that, you know, he talked about starting his own social network, maybe realized that was a really dumb idea. And since he can't defeat Twitter, join it. And that's exactly what he did.
13:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, there's some nuance to this, though, because he announced on Monday via an SEC filing that he had purchased, it was about 2.9 billion, I think, in Twitter stock, or roughly 9.2% of the company, if my memory serves. And he's going to be a passive stake, which is a distinction that matters. And then, you know, 12 minutes passed and he was like, oh, JK, I'm joining the board and I'm actually going to be an activist investor. And there are rules about this and they seem to have been abrogated. I do seem to think that Elon Musk has managed to build not a reality distortion, you know, sphere around him as people said about Steve Jobs, but instead kind of like a regulatory keep it away from me bubble. Like, how does he do this consistently and get away with it?
14:03 Speaker 00 Yeah.
14:03 Speaker 01 It's amazing to me. But Twitter stock went up, so that's nice.
14:06 Speaker 00 Yeah, I'm kind of confused here because we know that Elon has gotten in trouble for changing the price of Tesla stock because of his tweets. And so now is he going to change the Twitter stock because of his tweets? I feel like there's more room for like mistakes in the Elon world, but I don't know if that's even illegal because he's not the CEO.
14:23 Speaker 01 What counts as legal and what Elon Musk can do and not get in trouble for, I think, are different things. In the case of Tesla stock, he tweeted out about taking Tesla private at $420 per share because we're all 12. And he said funding secured when it wasn't. That would have actually ironically been one of the better investments of all time because Tesla stock has appreciated greatly since then. But in this case, he announced it in a reasonable manner, which is through a filing. And the reaction to that is what the market did, which was excitement.
14:50 Speaker 00 Right.
14:51 Speaker 01 And I think that's okay. But I also wish that I could make a billion dollars in about three days just by buying some stock in the company. Because whenever I buy index funds, nothing happens. It's quite sad.
15:01 Speaker 00 I know. It would be great to be a market mover.
15:04 Speaker 01 Actually, I'm glad I'm not because that really, that means whatever I tweet, I don't have to care about it. You know what I mean? My tweets don't do shit. My tweets are pretty boring and it's nice to be a nobody.
15:14 Speaker 02 No, they're entertaining, though. They're entertaining, Alex.
15:16 Speaker 00 There's like the light reaction to Elon getting involved in Twitter and like the normal sorts of jokes we'll make about it. But then there's also a little bit of a more serious take we should probably give some time to, which is like, what does it mean for someone who, you know, really wants an edit button and has questionable positions on free speech to get involved with one of the most powerful social media platforms? And how does that also line up with Twitter definitely prioritizing revenue growth, wanting to grow its daily users and being in a spot where it wants Elon Musk to take a board seat? Elon Musk is not a neutral, rich person.
15:47 Speaker 02 Yeah.
15:47 Speaker 00 I don't know if any rich person is neutral, but he's definitely the least neutral you can go. And so I do think we're seeing Twitter show some of its vulnerability. We're seeing Elon get involved in a serious way that some people have been really worried about, but I guess I'm just thinking that there was nothing stopping him before and there's nothing that will stop him now from having the impact he wants to have. So, I don't know. That's just something that I want to remind people is like, it kind of is fraught that we're seeing something so dramatic happen and him wanting to have corporate influence in this way. I feel like that's kind of insane.
16:14 Speaker 02 I think it's insane, and I think what's even more insane is that even though we were surprised, we weren't that surprised, right? It's not as shocking as it should have been, really. And I am surprised, though, that we actually didn't see this one coming.
16:29 Speaker 01 I want to say I had jet lag this morning until I was up ridiculously early in bed looking at my phone. And that was good. It was propitious. It was fortuitous because Elon Musk has made a bid to purchase Twitter. Now, not startup news, Natasha, but certainly the biggest news in tech today.
16:42 Speaker 00 Hundred percent. And I want to ask you more about your thesis for the exchange this morning because you wrote about it. But the move for him to offer to buy Twitter for, I think, 43 billion after joining the board and not joining the board because of maybe a background check? And then overall, there being a Twitter investor that sued him due to a disclosure of stake, I mean, lack of disclosure of stake? I don't think it's even helpful for everyone to fully run through every single step of how we got here. But I do think it's helpful to be like, why is Elon Musk trying to buy Twitter? Like, why was that the move? I thought 9% was enough.
17:13 Speaker 01 When you discuss people who have a lot of power and an ability to follow their emotions, I think finding the core why behind something is tough. And also probably even if we had a really good guess, it would be incomplete.
17:29 Speaker 00 Yeah.
17:29 Speaker 01 If you [__] post, part of it is the enjoyment of making noise, being a little random, pushing buttons. And Elon Musk is, you know, even if you like him quite a lot, a bit of a troll.
17:40 Speaker 00 Hundred percent.
17:40 Speaker 01 So to me, this reads like he bought 9% of Twitter, expected to get his way. They offered him a board seat, which is super boring because being on a public company board, dull. And then he realized probably he wasn't going to have the sway that he wanted. And so in a fit of pick, seems to have decided to buy the whole company.
17:56 Speaker 00 It's an interesting move for Twitter employees. I mean, Elon is a market mover notoriously, but I didn't have Elon bringing up Twitter shares around 12%. So they're currently trading at around $51 per share, just compared to yesterday's closing price. And it's like, okay, Elon impacting Tesla's price, fine. This was not something I could have predicted. And I mean, I think it's something that like jokes aside, is pretty frustrating to have to cover in a way because you know that he's just messing around. He's not actually going to buy this thing, right?
18:23 Speaker 01 Well, I also didn't think that they were going to be able to ramp up Model 3 production at the pace they did. And I also didn't think that they were going to be able to land the stage ones of Falcon 9 rockets on drone ships.
18:33 Speaker 00 Oh, my God.
18:34 Speaker 01 So with Elon, you always have to kind of go with maybe. Now, in this case, this bid, I don't think is super serious. He's put out $54.20 per share, getting the key 420 number in there.
18:45 Speaker 00 Of course he did.
18:45 Speaker 01 100% of Twitter, all cash, value sort of at 43.4 billion. And to me, it's a little bit cheap. It's too low. Now, he's making a point that it's a premium based on where the stock was before he bought into it, but I don't think that's the right measurement.
18:56 Speaker 00 Yeah.
18:56 Speaker 01 I think really their kind of Q3, Q4 pricing from last year is where Twitter investors want to get back to, which is more the $60 to $70 per share range. And 43 billion for Twitter with the growth they had last year and expectations just seems kind of bullshit.
19:07 Speaker 00 I mean, let's not forget Twitter very loudly has been like, we need to double revenue by 2023.
19:11 Speaker 01 Yes.
19:11 Speaker 00 They have a lot of things they have to do, and this is a huge distraction. It's something that's going to probably take up a lot of Parag's time, their new CEO.
19:17 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
19:18 Speaker 00 And so I kind of find it at a very not casual, quiet time for Twitter. We've seen their products, we've seen their goals, new CEO, Jack leaving, Elon joining is just like adding more fuel to the fire.
19:27 Speaker 01 Elon not joining, like sitting down at a table, he wasn't invited to that, and then demanding to tell everyone else how to use their forks.
19:32 Speaker 00 The best and worst guest.
19:34 Speaker 01 Best and worst guest. Yes, you will never be bored, but you'll also be glad when they leave.
19:38 Speaker 00 Yes.
19:38 Speaker 01 Yes, we've all had a friend like that.
19:40 Speaker 00 Well, I'll end this maybe Elon section with a quote from him. He basically said, since making my investment, I now realize that the company, AKA Twitter, will neither thrive nor serve the societal imperative, obviously subtweeting free speech in its current form. Twitter needs to be transformed as a private company. He wants to bring Twitter private.
19:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, but he was tweeting the other day about how they should have Twitter without the W.
20:00 Speaker 00 Of course he was.
20:00 Speaker 01 And I don't think he was referring to small bits of laughter. He wasn't tittering about that. And so to me, like, he's not, he's not being serious. Twitter is a very important company.
20:10 Speaker 00 It really is.
20:11 Speaker 01 It's a private company in that it's not owned by the government. And that means that it does have its own ability to make and determine its own speech.
20:17 Speaker 00 I was thinking private in like, public versus private.
20:19 Speaker 01 Exactly. I'm just clarifying for people who might be thinking about private enterprise versus private company. Obviously Twitter is a private company that is currently on the public markets. He wants to make it a private company that's also on the private market.
20:29 Speaker 00 Got you.
20:29 Speaker 01 But critically, when we talk about free speech, the public government versus private corporate split, using similar language, it's a little confusing. Twitter does matter a lot because it is a place where a lot of speech happens, a lot of people around the world talk on it, has over 200 million monetizable daily active users or N Dows, which is a terrible metric. But I just don't trust it in Elon's hands, given that he doesn't seem to appear to be ready to treat with a similar level of seriousness as he does with his other business endeavors. And Twitter is my baby and I am a Twitter Blue subscriber and I'm sure I own some shares in it through index funds. So, you know, piss off.
20:58 Speaker 00 Yeah, Elon making things complicated was what we expected from the start. We're going to continue covering our equity because we have to. It was funny, we actually originally had this section as like a quick mention, but then
21:07 Speaker 01 This morning.
21:07 Speaker 00 He wanted to buy it.
21:11 Speaker 02 I continuously get floored by the things that Elon Musk does. And he violates so many things. He breaks so many rules and he keeps getting away with it. It's shocking to me. But now I think the big deal this week, right, is that he's trying to say he may not buy Twitter because he's worried that there's too many users that are actually bots. And the big question is, did you not figure this out before you made your huge offer? I mean, why are you just now bringing it up? And the reason we all think is
21:43 Speaker 00 He doesn't actually.
21:43 Speaker 02 He doesn't want to really buy it.
21:45 Speaker 00 Yeah.
21:45 Speaker 01 Right.
21:46 Speaker 00 It's weird. The hard part about what's happening, and as you perfectly just Describe Marianne is like, there's the news that's happening, which is Elon Musk might not follow through with the deal. And then there's the method in which we're finding out about the news, which is Elon clashing with his contract and kind of going against his contract that he's in right now, which is helping him buy it. So it's like from both angles. And so that's why it's hard for me to like, know even where to start or where to focus on, because it's like so many layers. I think the very clear through line between both Elon Musk's actions and the news we're finding out as a result of them is that it's clear that he doesn't really want to buy this thing. And it really sucks that it's watering down the work of Twitter, people trying to cover it. And just kind of the lawyers behind it as well. I just feel like there's, there's so much happening that it's really hard to follow this like a traditional news story. I've never seen anything like it.
22:31 Speaker 02 Yeah.
22:31 Speaker 01 It's also been fascinating to see who's stepped up. I think Chris Dixon was gonna put money into this. I think Jason Calacanis was like putting together money for this and Elon's in there. And there's another VC firm that's putting money, was it Sequoia? I forget who it was.
22:43 Speaker 02 It's Andreessen, I believe.
22:45 Speaker 01 No, that's Chris Dixon.
22:46 Speaker 02 Oh, okay. Yeah, yeah.
22:47 Speaker 01 So maybe, anyways, the point is it's a murderer's row of white dudes that are ponying up money to support this weird crusade.
22:55 Speaker 02 Well, I think a big issue is this, he's violating non-disclosure agreements that he's made with the company. He's talking about things that he should not.
23:02 Speaker 01 Yes.
23:03 Speaker 02 You know, in front of conferences on Twitter, and he's acting so maturely by responding to the CEO of Twitter with a poop emoji. I mean, really, come on. What is this? Are we like five years old? I mean, it's just shocking.
23:17 Speaker 01 No, even for a five year old, it's not very sophisticated humor. But early in the saga, Elon was talking about how, you know, he wanted to make Twitter more politically neutral, when he still seemed to want to buy Twitter and wanted to work on bots as a thing versus complaining about bots as an issue that makes the deal untractable, right? And that went out the window really quick. He's now referring to buying Twitter as a way to quote, own the libs, which is idiot speak for basically annoying people who are interested in a more equitable world. Anyways, and now he's, he's using the word woke, which has become kind of like a shibboleth among right wing people to essentially complain about anyone who wants a more kind society. Like, don't be a jerk to trans people. So to me, like, I don't trust him to take over this company because I don't think
23:59 Speaker 01 he has anything like the seriousness needed to actually to take on free speech questions and let alone handle foreign governments' demands for user information. Adashia, am I being too negative? Because I'm kind of mad.
24:08 Speaker 00 No, no, I don't think any of us are being too negative, but we're all going to probably be on the same page here. I'm sure we're going to get some fun Twitter mentions as a result, but I'll just add that there's something specifically frustrating about us knowing this was going to happen, us seeing how he's talked and violated SEC regulations on Twitter before buying, trying to buy Twitter and seeing his attitude towards people of color and leadership. I just, I think that it's very frustrating that there's like the, we know it's going to happen, but capitalism is making this happen anyways conversation that we've had and continue to have. But the reason it makes sense for us to talk about on this show is that it still is like tech history and it's also like coming at a really interesting time for when the market is changing. Elon's words are not kind of being looked at in a vacuum. They're around a lot of doom and gloom.
24:50 Speaker 00 So I just think that's like an interesting time for him to be also falling on the sword.
24:54 Speaker 01 Well, I mean, falling apart, falling on the sword, kind of pick one. The thing that I think is most important to realize is that Elon is not operating in good faith here. And I think Matt Levine from Bloomberg had the right quote responding to Elon's complaints about Twitter's bot issues and spam issues, which were known, and again, were part of the reason why he wanted to do the deal. Matt wrote the following, I'm just going to quote a couple of sentences here because I can't improve on it. "I think it is important to be clear here that Musk is lying. The spam bots are not why he is backing away from the deal, as you can tell from the fact that the spam bots are why he did the deal. He has produced no evidence at all that Twitter's estimates are wrong, and certainly not that they are materially wrong or made in bad faith. Of course, Musk can get out of the deal only if Twitter's filings are wrong in a way that could cause a material adverse effect on Twitter, which is vanishingly unlikely."
25:37 Speaker 01 So what we are seeing here is Elon essentially just being a jerk because he doesn't want to buy the company anymore, but Twitter didn't want him to buy to begin with, but he just started the process anyways. Like, I don't know, take a nap.
25:48 Speaker 00 It's kind of like someone asking someone else out on a date and that person's kind of like, I'm not so sure, but okay, I mean, you're really being pushy about it. I'll give it a chance. And then that person's like, yeah, you know what? Never mind, I don't want to go out with you. I mean, what the?
26:06 Speaker 01 Now, we could go on for six weeks on the Twitter Elon Musk fracas, perhaps goat rodeo? I don't know what you want to call it. It's not great. And this week, we reached a new chapter in this particular book in which Twitter has now sued Elon Musk to make him buy it. And there's some logic behind this, but before we get into the new ones, Natasha, when the lawsuit dropped, one, did you find it surprising? And then two, what was your take about Twitter's overall argument?
26:36 Speaker 00 Much like all the news these days, and all of its variety of shades, I feel like I'm pretty numb to anything happening right now. And so when the lawsuit dropped, I wasn't surprised, Alex. I was very much curious on what exactly we'd see Elon tweet next, because I do think he consistently has a, and I'm part of the problem there for sure. But I was just like, okay, like, what possibly are we going to see now? Of course, we did see some tweets right now, but Twitter's argument was basically that Elon Musk changed his mind when the market began its downturn. So in the lawsuit, lawyers basically say that like Musk raised this call to defeat all the spam bots and showed a lot of interest, obviously offered to buy Twitter. The market declined and that became a lot less attractive. He shifted everything and then demanded that verification that spam was not a serious problem
27:20 Speaker 00 on Twitter's platform and claimed a burning need to conduct, quote, diligence that he had expressly foresworn, a word that we don't use quite often enough, honestly. I don't know if I can pick a side necessarily, but I am, it's very clear, obviously, that Musk is trying to backpedal his way out of the deal and that Twitter is ready with receipts, as Amanda Silberling showed us as to why it's not okay.
27:42 Speaker 01 All right, we're not here to pick sides, but I will say, I read the Twitter lawsuit. I don't know how you, anyone would choose to do business with Elon Musk, because he rolled into Twitter, bought a bunch of its stock, didn't produce the right filings, talked his way into a board seat, then dropped that, then forced a kind of hostile takeover, made Twitter agree to this, and then immediately afterwards tried to back out of it after trashing the company all over Twitter. And he essentially just flipped his argument entirely. He said, I need to buy Twitter to take it private, so that way we can get rid of spam. And then he said, I can't buy and take it private because of spam. Just some bullshit. And it was infuriating to read.
28:19 Speaker 02 Yeah, I have to agree. Infuriating is a good word. I mean, we saw this coming. We knew he was trying to back out. So like him backing out is not a shock. Twitter, I've made this analogy before. It's kind of like, you know, being ousted on a date, being wooed by someone that you're not that interested in. You finally give in and that person just like, eh, you know, changed my mind, you know, you're not my type. And it's just, it's very frustrating and I don't blame Twitter for being livid. It's done a lot to the company to have to go through all this. And I think it's beyond a joke that Elon is getting away with it. It says a lot about the way business is conducted in this country and how much certain people of certain stature and wealth can get away with. And that really pisses me off.
29:00 Speaker 01 There are two legal systems in this country. There's one for the wealthy and then there's one for us. And if you can afford to buy access and time for a fleet of lawyers, you can essentially just tie things up in court forever until everyone wants to scream. If you're poor, you get a public defender and then you go to prison.
29:16 Speaker 02 Yeah.
29:16 Speaker 01 And Elon is one of the richest people in the world. And so that means that the system that is set up to protect and defend the wealthy protects and defends the wealthy. And so I don't know where this is going. I don't know if Twitter is going to win, but I will just say in terms of how Elon behaved during this process, the way the communication seems to have played out, the way he was tweeting his way through it, it reminds me of like a truculent teenager rather than a titan of technology.
29:37 Speaker 02 Totally unprofessional. I mean, really, really unprofessional.
29:41 Speaker 00 I think as you both so beautifully put it, it's just like has evolved past this, even the memes of the memes. It has evolved past that to be like these really like important and frustrating statements on like the way the world works. And it's not lost on me that Twitter has also like internally, it has laid off a hundred employees within its talent acquisition team. It's about 30% of its department, you know, it's restructuring. I can't imagine motivation is the same it was when they were on their product spree. And so it's just this frustrating thing to see happening at, you know, selfishly, one of my favorite platforms of all time. So I think the impact will be felt for a really long time.
30:17 Speaker 01 Sticking to the theme of M and A because there are no IPOs, insert crying emoji here. The Elon Musk Twitter deal probably is now going through. It seems that Elon has given up trying to get out of the deal he forced into existence and now will pay 5420 per share for Twitter, valuing the social network at around 44 billion.
30:37 Speaker 00 Wow.
30:37 Speaker 01 Thoughts, everybody?
30:39 Speaker 00 I'll go first because I don't have a strong one at all. This happened on Tuesday and you're listening to this on a Friday, maybe a Saturday, maybe late. Things could have changed by the time that this episode comes out. And so a huge asterisk to everything we say, and that is my take. But no, jokes aside, I feel like it was, it was interesting to see this happen now. We knew that the Musk versus Twitter trial was set to begin kind of smack dab in the middle of disrupt on October 17th. So that's up for question now. Um, and I think Amanda put it well for tech journalists, especially those at TechCrunch. This is a blessing because now we don't have to miss out on drama because we'll be on stage interviewing people.
31:14 Speaker 02 I mean, I think that it's believed that that's part of the reason why he decided to move forward with the deal is that he wanted to avoid trial and he didn't want, I think the judge was ordering deeper dives into communications he had with a alleged whistleblower, things like that. So, I mean, honestly, after as hard as he's fought over the past couple of months for him to kind of cave right now, makes me really curious as to what he doesn't want to be shared with the public.
31:42 Speaker 00 Yeah.
31:43 Speaker 01 I wonder also how much of it is just his friends all texting him things like, hey, do you want a billion dollars? And I, and they probably didn't expect their private communications to end up not just in the public sphere, but dissected by the entire technology Twitter community and ruthlessly mocked.
32:00 Speaker 00 It was, it was a fun day. People were like waiting for that.
32:03 Speaker 01 I, I had a blast. It was, if you followed the Adam Levine Instagram DMs fracas, this was the equivalent of that in the technology world because we don't cover celebrities per se.
32:13 Speaker 00 Good analogy.
32:14 Speaker 01 There are many good memes. We'll put that aside. Let's just handicap this and then move on. Natasha, you go first. Percent chance the deal happens loosely at the original price sometime in the next three months? What's your, what's your guess?
32:26 Speaker 00 I would, like, I'm going to say yes, it's going to happen because if it doesn't happen, then I don't know what to believe anymore. So.
32:33 Speaker 01 Okay. That's, that's where I'm at too. Mary Ann, do you have a dissenting view?
32:36 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think same. I think he's really, like I said, I feel like Elon's trying to avoid something in a big way. And so, you know, he's, he's willing to just go ahead and get this over with. But you never know, right? How many times have we seen things change over the course of the past few months with regard to this deal? Exactly.
32:53 Speaker 01 The last thing I'll say, and then we're going to move on to a very important story about crypto shilling, is that there's been some commentary that the CEO of Twitter actually has been holding up pretty well. I think it's since Parag, and he's been, I mean, he got this job, and then the whole world exploded underneath him. And so you got to give the guy points for just being in a tough spot. But if you look at the text messages he had with Elon, very measured, very calm, a level of maturity, I'm just gonna say it, that I don't have. Because if Elon Musk was [BLEEP] posting in my SMS, I would be very cross with him. And Parag was just so mature. And so I think the only person who comes out from this entire episode looking good is the currency of Twitter.
33:31 Speaker 02 That's a great take, and one that I haven't heard much. I'll co-sign that. Agreed.
33:35 Speaker 01 Shout out Bloomberg for writing that and letting me paraphrase it. I forget who wrote that story at Bloomberg, but you're great.
33:42 Speaker 01 The news is that Twitter might not undergo as many layoffs as we thought. This is something that we learned on Thursday. As of Wednesday, when we put together the script originally, we were expecting Elon to lay off around three quarters, or up to three quarters of Twitter staff. And it turns out via him dropping by the office, that's not going to be the case. So 70%, 30%, I have no idea. But the context here has dramatically changed. And then I'll add one more thing before I get your feedback. But the company is going to be taking on presumably quite a lot of debt in this transaction, which means that it needs to generate more cash to service that debt. One way to generate more free cash flow is to fire people, at least in the short term. So I need us to start with you. Vibes on the Elon axe swinging that may or may not come?
34:22 Speaker 04 The vibes are really off. Like, I'm super confused. I guess he said that he's just kidding, not going to lay off 75% of the staff after all. But either way, I mean, this is just really awful. Having your whole workforce of this social media platform sort of hanging in limbo and wondering what, like, what the hell is going to happen next?
34:37 Speaker 02 Right. And it's also like Twitter, unlike some other social media platforms, it has always had a smaller staff. So cutting 75% of people.
34:46 Speaker 00 Makes a bigger dent here than in other places. It would have impacted around 5,600 employees and they only have 7,500. And I don't know, I just think about that too is like, one thing I've always thought about is like, for how important Twitter is to the world, it doesn't have that many employees. So we'll see, even if he doesn't lay those people off, there's going to be churn in many ways. We'll see over the next few months. There is even when the leader isn't that controversial. So add in the controversy, add in the fact that Twitter has a very political and thoughtful staff. And I think we're going to see a lot of change on the personnel front. I want to end with this section a little bit with talking about this letter. Employees wrote a letter to Elon Musk, the Board of Directors and General staff,
35:27 Speaker 00 and basically said that this layoff will hurt Twitter's ability to serve the public conversation. Quote, "A threat of this magnitude is reckless, undermines our users and customers' trust in our platform and is a transparent act of worker intimidation." And I think that it's, I mean, it's such a powerful letter. I'm sure we'll link it in our show notes. I think it's important to read. We don't know too many details about it, but I do feel like a little bit like, this, this is the theme I was talking about last week where it's like, reputation matters and the power of the employee is really important right now.
35:56 Speaker 01 And I think it's been interesting to watch that letter get mocked by a lot of very wealthy people.
36:00 Speaker 00 Yeah.
36:00 Speaker 01 Arguing that, you know, these people are more activists than employees and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Oh, man, someone's out of touch.
36:08 Speaker 00 Yeah.
36:08 Speaker 01 I mean, you can decide who it is in this particular scenario. But if I was buying a company and I was overpaying 3X for it, given current market norms, I might not attack the people that are currently making the servers blink.
36:19 Speaker 00 I think that's why him walking in with like, holding a sink, just like, didn't sit right with me. The news that he is kind of reversing this rumor or whatever, that the 75% layoffs aren't going to happen. That happened after he walked in with a sink. And I just think that like, just morale wise, it's an exhausting place to be right now. I'm not a Twitter employee. I don't know what the exact temperature is. I'm glad I'm not one right now, to be quite honest. Yeah, it just, it seems like, I'm sure there's a lot of disagreement internally, even, I mean, it's just a spectrum of emotions and I'm sad I'm not in SF or else I would just go camp out in their cafe and, and try and, I don't know, talk to some of them.
36:50 Speaker 01 Well, someone please let me into Twitter HQ again. Thank you. I know the last time I was there, we drank a whole bottle of Jameson, but we're going to move on though. No more Elon Musk for the rest of the show.
36:59 Speaker 00 Yay.
37:00 Speaker 01 Pretty sure about that. If we don't live up to that, we owe you a Coke.
37:04 Speaker 00 We ended with somehow a crazier news cycle than any month before, which was FTX. We're talking bankruptcy, we're talking SBF's interviews and his eventual arrest. I mean, there's so much, stay tuned.
37:16 Speaker 01 Speaking of layoffs, FTX has laid off its market cap, its market reputation, its relationship with regulators, its US political clout, and I think all goodwill in the crypto community in the last couple of days. Where should we pick up this thread is my question, because there's been so much going on. Should we give an overview, guys, or should we just pick up on the last couple of bits of news? I'm torn.
37:35 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's hard to say. I mean, obviously, it kind of all started with Binance saying it was going to buy FTX, right? Was it non-US assets?
37:43 Speaker 00 Yeah.
37:43 Speaker 02 And then they backed out, and then all sorts of [BLEEP] has come out since.
37:47 Speaker 01 Well, okay, I'm going to extend that back a little bit further. It turns out that the rise of FTX and its sister company Alameda, which was its kind of trading sister company, was a little bit more full of chicanery than we might have thought, and there was apparently some lending back and forth and some counterparty risk, as they say, and that was not really, I think, made clear to us on the reporting side or the public side. And then Binance kind of helped to engender a run on the bank, if you will. I think that's a legally safe way of saying that. FTX became apparently much more fragile than we thought that it was. And then the most recent thing is the Binance deal has fallen apart. There is squawking from American regulatory bodies, and it appears that FTX could go to zero, Becca, and Sequoia actually talked about that.
38:32 Speaker 03 We were talking a little bit all in Slack about Sequoia's memo that went out yesterday. One, I can't think of a time in my experience covering this space that I've ever seen that an LP memo like that purposely made public by the firm in question, and them writing down the company to zero was, I mean, probably accurate, but it's just stark to see, especially at this point in the process, because, I mean, hard to believe anything that Sam Bankman-Fried is saying right now, but he is saying like the company may be in talks, like some stuff may be able to come back, like they may be able to sort of save or gain some of that liquidity that they're missing, obviously, especially with Binance walking away, but Sequoia.
39:13 Speaker 03 To just already be like, nope, we're writing it down to zero. It's a loss. Like even with what happens from here, like that's very telling about sort of how venture will approach this, especially going forward.
39:24 Speaker 02 Right. I mean, just earlier this year, FTX was valued at what $32 billion, has raised about $2 billion to date. Sequoia being so public about this is it's obviously making a point that it wants to distance itself from FTX. And Connie, who wrote the the piece about it, her assumption is that most investors are going to. So if FTX is looking for its backers to bail it out, probably not going to happen here.
39:51 Speaker 01 Well, no, VCs won't throw more money after bad.
39:56 Speaker 02 To sinking ship.
39:57 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah. I mean, like if you if you add weight to sinking ship, it doesn't gain buoyancy. The question is just what will individual FTX users get back, if anything? Hopefully they get back 100%, but we'll see. Jackie, our senior crypto reporter on TC Plus noted that the volume on FTX, it's cratered so much that even if it did somehow survive, I don't think it's ever going to survive. Right? I mean, like, who's going to trust them now? So the question really is just how much, how much damage is there once the smoke clears from the impact?
40:28 Speaker 03 No, and you make such a good point there, too, about the users. Because I feel like when we had sort of the issues with Robinhood and some of like the Wall Street, that stuff from last year, users and users losing money and sort of consumers losing money was a much bigger part of the conversation than it has been thus far, at least from what I've seen from FTX. It seems like a lot more asset recovery as far as the business goes and sort of investors and sort of like that type of player. Maybe I've missed it. But that is something I thought last night as I was going through things toward the end of the day was that I felt like I had seen significantly less coverage on sort of the actual human aspect of this in the people who just wanted to try investing their money. Of course, obviously,
41:09 Speaker 03 you take risks doing that. No one doesn't know that, but you also don't expect a $32 billion company to evaporate overnight either. So I just feel like that hasn't been as big of the conversation with FTX thus far, and I'm not sure why, but definitely something. That I noticed.
41:24 Speaker 02 So you're saying you don't, you know, when you're taking risk, investing in crypto, you're taking risk because you think, okay, the, the prices might be volatile. You're not, you're not taking risks and thinking that the company is going to crash and burn a few months later. You know what I mean? So, yeah, and then, and I think Jackie tweeted recently, there was about $5 billion of withdrawals on Sunday alone, FTX, which is insane.
41:46 Speaker 01 Yeah, but you know what? Why would they be operating on a fractional reserve basis? Maybe, maybe you shouldn't make your own token and then print it and then give it to your sister company to borrow against and get yourself levered up to the frickin neck. And then so that way you can get exploded over the weekend. Like, how did no one sit him down, SBF, and be like, this is dumb. You're gonna get caught.
42:13 Speaker 01 Let's talk about FTX, but not about Sam Bankman Fried. I'm not going to bring up the words drugs, polycule, really most of the things that are going on. I want to talk instead about the fallout. And Natasha, something that we covered this week on Tech Runners was that Nestcoin, which was an African Web three startup venture thing, had a bunch of its assets in FTX. And it's not alone, but it did feel representative or indicative of the damage that the FTX implosion will cause, not just to the company itself, not just to its backers, but other nascent technology companies.
42:45 Speaker 00 Yes, and you know, Becca, last week on Equity, shout out Becca for stepping in, said that she was missing the human interest story here. We knew that a lot of people, big people, influential people were losing money. But like, what about a startup employee? And I think this story really hit at home for me. So Nestcoin had to lay off some employees because they had put a lot of their day to day operational budget, a significant portion of the staple coin that they had raised in FTX. And to me, it really like, it really cemented this idea that the fact that someone is losing lots of money, things are being marked down to zero. Like, I think those are all really big statements that we don't really know how they play out in real time. And so I don't want to say I'm happy to have this example, but I do want to say, I think it like, is a warning and a more specific one, a more impactful one than Sequoia marking
43:30 Speaker 00 its investment down to zero. To me, when I hear that, I'm like, sucks for Sequoia and LPs. But this is like, okay, no, like, people were actually impacted here, real people, not just investors.
43:39 Speaker 01 See, the scale of impact on a per entity basis can be much greater than the dollar amount might make you kind of think. So let's say you're a venture capital company. You put 200 million into FTX. If you could put that much money into FTX, a single deal or a single company, you have billions of dollars in assets under management. So if you lose that, it's not good. It's a painful write down. It's gonna be a bad letter to your LPs, but you don't lose your house. You know, you still have a gig.
44:05 Speaker 00 Exactly.
44:06 Speaker 01 If you're an employee of Nestcoin, where they had their assets on FTX and just got laid off, you could be in a much bigger jam, even if the dollar amount's smaller. So it's really the human capital that we care about here versus the financial capital.
44:18 Speaker 00 It's exactly, it's what's, that's wrong with me. Like, you know, the next kind of impact that we saw happen this week was that SoftBank has written down its nearly $100 million investment in FTX. And we can say more about that, but I think like the thing that frustrates me is like, it does feel just like a little tone deaf to be like, we marked it down to zero, but here's how much money we actually have and how many gains we actually have LPs. Don't be worried. I get why they're doing it. Don't get me wrong. And I think it's a signal. Don't get me wrong. I don't know. It feels like an awkward flex in an environment where people are losing jobs. And I haven't talked about FTX on the pod yet. So I've just been holding on to this.
44:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
44:52 Speaker 00 For a while.
44:52 Speaker 01 So Natasha, how, on a scale of one to mad, how livid are you? Because my, my read is that you have a small chip on your shoulder about the, the loose use of capital here and regulatory oversight and internal controls.
45:04 Speaker 00 So I think you wrote a story this morning that really, I think, put it well, that I'll add to, which was maybe FTX was the poster child of 2021's hype, if I'm not butchering that headline.
45:13 Speaker 01 Close enough. Parker Thompson didn't like it, but that's.
45:15 Speaker 00 Great. Well, it's like, that is what I agree with. And I think that's why it hurts in a way. Cause it's like, we've been talking about due diligence. We've been talking about discipline and we've been talking about how FOMO impacted investment decisions. But now we have this really visceral example. And I'm kind of like, I don't know, my hands are a little up saying, I think this will impact crypto. I don't know if this is gonna make investors do more due diligence on companies.
45:36 Speaker 01 Just to explain what I was trying to do in that piece, the thing that I was trying to say is, it seems like FTX had a exacerbated or more extreme version of a lot of the issues that we saw last year. And I was trying to compare its lack of a traditional board, founder control, opaque finances, rapid fire fundraising, you know, et cetera. These things that became more prevalent, I would say in 2021, when capital was fighting amongst itself to get money in the startups. And therefore investors gave up or passed on a lot of stuff that they would have traditionally demanded in terms of oversight, due diligence and so forth. And so to me, FTX kind of got to where it was on the back of a crypto boom. And then also a non-governance boom combined for an epic explosion, but it was indicative of stuff we saw last year.
46:19 Speaker 01 And if that's a stretch, well, then I apologize, but I was out of ideas on Thursday morning.
46:23 Speaker 00 I mean, I co-sign your perspective clearly, but I think this is where we bring in former SoftBank COO Marcelo Clor. He tweeted, quote, "I have been reflecting personally on the whole FTX fiasco, and it taught me one more time that we should never invest because of FOMO and we should always 100% understand what we are investing in. I totally failed here on both." There's two ways to read this. One is kind of like the faux, like humbleness of a mistake that is now clear to everyone. But I will hit the more optimistic approach of like, I actually think it was really helpful for Marcelo to tweet this because it makes something explicit that people are kind of whispering about. He actually cited FOMO as a reason for why he invested in FTX. And to me, it's just helpful because it shows that someone like, you know,
47:05 Speaker 00 we know soft banks made mistakes in the past, but I still think it's helpful to hear how they were thinking and what went wrong here from an investor perspective.
47:15 Speaker 01 Let's be brief on SBF because I presume everyone was inundated with all of this as it happened. But Natasha, I'm so glad you watched the big interview yesterday live and you came away convinced that everyone in crypto is on the up and up and that Sam Bankman-Fried is the person you should make the godfather of your first child.
47:33 Speaker 00 Wow, you stole the words. I don't know what to say for this section anymore. The interview was at the New York Times Annual Deal Book Summit, which for some reason was controversial. I'm going to try and not talk about the fact of how annoyed I was that people were surprised that a publication Would want to frickin interview him, but anyways, SBF showed up and as we put in the headline, just claimed a lot of ignorance on on conflicts and quotes that you should think about was, you know, he said he didn't knowingly co-mingle funds. He said that he believes this, from what I know, maybe. It was a lot of hedging. It was interesting because he also admitted that his lawyers told him that they're not very much in support of him doing interviews. And so maybe there is this middle ground where SBF is choosing to be vocal, but not in a way that's really giving any clarity.
48:16 Speaker 00 So at this point, it's just kind of this like round table and you'll see with his GMA interview today too, or it came out on Thursday morning, where he just kind of is playing dumb a little bit. And I think Vice had the best headline where he was like, they were just like Sam Bankman Fried is looking for the guy who did this. And I loved that. I loved it. That is the vibe I'm getting.
48:33 Speaker 02 I don't know. I kind of go with Connie's take on it. She wrote a story with her own headline of was SBF's appearance or performance. I mean, if this guy was that ignorant about so many things, then what the hell was he doing starting up a company like this and raising all this money? I mean, I just, I'm sorry, I don't buy that he was that ignorant about so many things. Give me a break.
48:54 Speaker 01 Yeah. You know what? If there was like one company and then there was Alameda and he got a little, little confused by it. Okay. You know what? Sure. I always ascribe to incompetence, what could always be ascribed to malice, blah, blah, blah. But there were like a hundred and some entities, right? In this bankruptcy proceeding, they don't prop up like mushrooms on the ground. You have to make these things and approve them and sign them. He was involved. He was synonymous for a reason with this company.
49:20 Speaker 00 Yeah. It was really confusing to see someone show up and act this way. And I think it was like, I honestly recommend people to go watch the interview. It should still be on the Times website because it is like, you don't see someone, as he even said in the interview, like the advice is to hole up and not talk to the press or people as you figure this out. He is not doing that. And I do think it's offering this kind of crazy window into how a billionaire falls from that to someone who has one working credit card in like a matter of days. I will try and share some news that broke during it, kind of broke. One was that he keeps claiming that FTX US is solvent, which we kind of knew, but he says that if they were to open withdrawals today, US customers could be made whole. And towards the end of the interview, he still thinks all customers could be made whole. Yeah. And I'm just kind of like, okay. Well, thank you for giving us more and more on the record statements.
50:04 Speaker 01 Yes, but he said that a lot of the assets are illiquid. So if you give me my accounts worth in FTT tokens, it's it's a little bit like McDonald's paying me in McBucks.
50:15 Speaker 00 Yeah.
50:16 Speaker 01 Except for McDonald's is closed.
50:17 Speaker 00 Yeah, right, right. Yeah, you don't really know what it what that means. Like, what does fully holy even mean in this context? I mean, we'll keep following it. The story, like I said, is like, it's not even a chapter in. There's volumes to come. And I feel like with the way that he's handling the press, maybe it'll come on Equity next year.
50:34 Speaker 01 Sam, Sam, we'd love to have you on. We we have kind of the same questions as everyone else. But if you want to come and not answer them on this show, cool. Sounds good.
50:43 Speaker 00 All right, well, that is a wrap. And let me just speak on behalf of the entire Equity team that we are super thankful for you to stick with us during the craziest time in tech, one that include a lot of yelling, spicy headlines, and probably annoyed some of you at some point. So let's do it all over again. Next year, you can follow Equity at EquityPod on Twitter. But take a break, enjoy the rest of the year, and we'll start fresh in the new year.
51:08 Speaker 01 Equity Fridays are hosted by myself, editor in chief of TechCrunch Plus, Alex Wilhelm, and TechCrunch senior reporters Natasha Mosqueros and Mary Ann Azvedo. We're produced by Teresa Locan Solo with editing by Kel Kel. Bryce Durbin is our illustrator. Alyssa Stringer leads audience development, and Henry Pickavet manages TechCrunch Audio Products. Thanks so much for listening, and we'll be back next week.
Previous Failure is a choose-your-own adventure for startups (re-run) Next Equity Monday: Remember how this whole working thing works? Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated