Pod Insights Empire: World History 353. Hezbollah, Hostages, & Exploding Pagers (Part 8) About this episode What lessons have been learned from Occupation? How did Hezbollah emerge in the wake of the Iranian Revolution and the Israeli invasion of Lebanon? How did Hezbollah evolve from 1982 to 2023?
In the final episode in the series on the Arab-Israeli Conflict of 1967-1982, William is joined by Kim Ghattas, author of Black Wave: Saudi Arabia, Iran and the Rivalry That Unravelled the Middle East, to discuss the origins of Hezbollah and their role in the Middle Eastern conflict of the 21st century.
Try Attio for free at attio.com/empire
Join the Empire Club: Unlock the full Empire experience – with bonus episodes, ad-free listening, early access to miniseries and live show tickets, exclusive book discounts, a members-only newsletter, and access to our private Discord chatroom. Sign up directly at empirepoduk.com
For more Goalhanger Podcasts, head to www.goalhanger.com.
Email: [email protected]
Instagram: @empirepoduk
Blue Sky: @empirepoduk
X: @empirepoduk
Assistant Producer: Imogen Marriott
Editors: Charlie Rodwell and Harry Swan
Social Producer: Charlie Johnson
Producer: Anouska Lewis
Executive Producer: Dom Johnson
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by Atio, the AI CRM. The larger an empire becomes, the harder it is to know what's happening across it. Modern organisations face the same sort of problem and Atio helps solve it. Atio is an AI CRM designed for how teams really operate. Sync your email and calendar and you're up and running in minutes. From there, Atio brings your conversations and contacts together in one place so your team can see what is happening in real time. Ask Atio goes a step further. Simply ask questions about your pipeline, which deals are moving fastest, where the
0:40 Speaker 00 momentum is building or what needs attention next and get a clear answer in moments. With Atio, you can focus on the real work of building your empire from day one onwards. Try Atio for free at A-T-T-I-O dot com slash empire.
1:15 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome to Empire with me, William Drumpel. I'm afraid Anita has another project, but I am back with my wonderful friend, Kim Gattas. Kim, welcome back to Empire.
1:26 Speaker 01 Thanks for having me again. It's a joy to be with you, William, and to talk about all this history, even though it's incredibly depressing and makes me very angry, but talking about it with you helps.
1:40 Speaker 00 Well, thank you. And it is a very dark story we have to tell today. We left the last episode with the Sabra and Shajila massacres, the horrors of one of the worst massacres in recent Middle Eastern history. And today for this final episode in our series on the Arab Israeli wars, we have the crucial story of the birth of Hezbollah, a story which of course leads us directly to the present and the current horrors that poor.
2:10 Speaker 00 Lebanon is again suffering. And this is another dark moment in your history. And I'm sorry that as you sit with us here, that your your friends and neighbours are suffering attacks and rockets and and the villages of South Lebanon are being dynamited on our social media uh as we speak.
2:30 Speaker 01 Indeed, it is very painful to watch from from a distance. Um, I wish I didn't have to leave, which I know, as I said in the previous episode, sounds strange to to people who might think, well, why wouldn't you want to leave a country at war? It is my country. I grew up in the civil war there, uh very much at the heart of it. War, very unfortunately, is familiar to me. We know how it works, we know the rhythm, uh and we take strength from being together. And it is actually much more anxiety inducing to be far away because you don't have your finger on on the pulse, you don't know exactly what is going on. So I stay in touch very, very closely uh with friends and um and colleagues back back home.
3:11 Speaker 01 But well, for me, what has been most difficult almost to deal with is, as you may know, I have uh another book coming out in the fall, uh which, interestingly enough, is called The Best Kind of of American, a title I chose um because it was a quote of of someone about the main character in my book, Malcolm Kerr, the American president of A U B, who was assassinated in nineteen eighty four in Beirut. But it is also incredibly interesting to have that as a title of a book in this time when we're all wondering what is America uh about? And that book and the research I did for it brought me through the four, five decades
3:51 Speaker 01 that we've been exploring in our conversation from nineteen eighty two up until today and this latest paroxysm of violence that we're watching.
4:01 Speaker 01 Unfold in the region, rippling across not just in Lebanon, but Iran and the UAE and Saudi Arabia and the Gulf and Israel with America very much at the centre of it. And the argument I make in the book is that it really all started with the 1982 Israeli invasion of Lebanon, when it collided with the Islamic Revolution of Iran and at the time, the desire and the ambition of the leader of that revolution, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, to export the revolution outside of Iran.
4:34 Speaker 00 Kim, I think what's incredibly important about your last book, Black Wave, which is a book that we absolutely love here on Empire Pod, and we have promoted as really one of the most essential books to understand this region. You make the crucial point that Iran's interest and fixation with Lebanon predates the 1982 invasion, that it goes actually back to the 1979, to the Iranian revolution. This is against the conventional narrative, really, that Hezbollah grew out of the invasion.
5:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, the conventional narrative, and that is not necessarily wrong, but it's not the entire story. So the idea that Hezbollah grew in reaction to the 1982 Israeli invasion as a resistance movement is not the entire story. Iranian revolutionaries who wanted to bring down the Shah were training in Lebanon before 1982, before 1979 even, the fall of the Shah and the birth of the Islamic Republic. They were training in Lebanon with Palestinian militants in Palestinian camps in Lebanon, military training camps, with the Yasser Arafat's people from 1975 onwards, when Lebanon was
5:57 Speaker 01 in the middle of a war, pitting the Palestinians and their allies in Lebanon to the right-wing Christians. And Lebanon became a kind of free-for-all for training of all kinds of leftist groups.
6:09 Speaker 00 Across the world.
6:10 Speaker 01 From across the world. Including the Badr Meinhoff Brigades, the Red Army, they all came to Lebanon. This was the era of, you know, the international left, right? It was not Islamist movements yet. And there's a great book, actually, I'd like to promote that book by Jason Burke.
6:26 Speaker 00 Revolutionists.
6:27 Speaker 01 The revolutionists. So that is the story of how these leftist movements, you know, changed the world at the time and how eventually some of it became Islamist groups like Hezbollah. And so a lot of the revolutionaries who were training in Lebanon, leftists but also Islamists, and then succeeded in bringing down the Shah, had their eyes on Lebanon and wanted to export the revolution back to Lebanon to fight Israel. And even as early as late 1979, you had some engaged Shia Zalats from Iran who knew Lebanon, traveling back to Lebanon to try to go down to the border and fight Israel.
7:09 Speaker 01 And the Lebanese government at the time still had enough authority to say, you know, "You're crazy, we don't want you here, go back home." Everything changes in 1982. Several things happen at the same time. Of course, Israel invades Lebanon. Hafiz al-Assad, who is not a president of Syria, who is not a fan of Islamist movements at all, he's killing his own Muslim Brotherhood Islamists in Hama in 1982, early 1982. His army is being kind of decimated by the Israelis as they invade Lebanon. Because remember, in the previous episode, we talked about how Syrian army had their surface-to-air missiles positioned in Lebanon's eastern Bekaa Valley.
7:54 Speaker 01 And within the first few days of the Israeli invasion, there's a battle there, including Syrian jet fighters. And Hafiz al-Assad loses so much of his air force then and is very angry with the Soviets for having supplied him with such, you know, terrible...
8:09 Speaker 00 Substandard, old-fashioned equipment.
8:11 Speaker 01 Exactly, yeah. And so he's trying to think how he can recover from that. He dallys a little bit with the idea of maybe very quickly, but he does, maybe he should ally himself with the Americans and leave the Soviet camp. But that idea doesn't last very long, because as we've seen also in the previous episode, he decides to start countering the American project by, for example, ordering the killing of Bashir Mayel. The third thing that happens, which is crucial to our history... Into this episode is that Iran, which has now engaged in a war with Iraq since the end of nineteen eighty.
8:50 Speaker 00 So only a year after the revolution, Saddam stages a massive invasion of Iran.
8:58 Speaker 01 Absolutely. He thought that he would face a weak Iranian army and he was in for a major surprise. At first, he, you know, racks up some wins, but so tactical successes, successes, strategic defeat, again, not the first person to discover that while fighting the Iranians. Because also by then, Arab countries have realized that Khomeini is a threat to them. They were sorry to see the Shah Goh, who was their friend, including in Saudi Arabia. And then they thought, okay, well, there's a, you know, new Iranian leader who kind of speaks our language of religion, et cetera. We can do business with him. But they quickly realized that he is actually going to be their enemy.
9:37 Speaker 00 And competition also.
9:39 Speaker 01 And competition, absolutely, across the Muslim world. Because Khomeini brandishes the Palestinian cause as his ticket to legitimacy across the Arab and Muslim world. And he promises to deliver for the Palestinians, where Arab countries have only delivered defeat. He doesn't do that either.
10:00 Speaker 00 I remember around this time going to Tehran, and on the outer wall of the British Embassy in Tehran, the revolutionaries put up these very, rather brilliant cartoons. And there were all sorts of different cartoons. But on the street that they renamed Bobby Sands Street, it used to be Winston Churchill Avenue, and they changed it to Bobby Sands Street after the IRA hunger striker. And on this was all these different causes, particularly the Palestinian cause, all over the British Embassy back wall.
10:32 Speaker 01 Absolutely. It was a cause of the left. And so the reason why I mentioned the Iran-Iraq war, and it's important, is because by May nineteen eighty-two, the Iranians have regained most of the territory they've lost to Iraq. And they think the Iran-Iraq war is over, and they're victorious, and they can move on. And then they see the Israeli invasion of Lebanon, and they think, if we can take on Iraq. We can take on Israel.
11:01 Speaker 00 So they move their forces in some numbers into the Bekaa Valley. Tell us about that. Give us the geography, because you've got Bad Lebanon, which is where the cedars are, which is where the skiing used to be, which is a very Christian area. But then down below, backing onto Syria, you've got the Bekaa Valley where Baalbek, the great temple is, where the great festival had used to be.
11:23 Speaker 01 Great agricultural land, also of course, and orchards and agriculture and very mixed also. Baalbek used to be a very mixed Sunni Shia Christian town. Zahle also, big city in the Bekaa Valley, dominantly Christian, lots of Shia villages, Christian villages, Sunni villages. But the Iranians decide to send an exploratory mission first to Damascus to discuss this idea of sending men to fight Israel, to Lebanon. And they discuss it with Hafiz Al-Assad, president of Syria, who, as I said, has just lost to face and lost militarily to the Israelis and sees the Israeli occupation
12:06 Speaker 01 of Lebanon and he can't do very much about it. He's lost two wars with Israel already. He can't fight another one. He's not a fan of these Islamist movements, but he ponders the possibility that they could be useful to him in fighting the Israelis in Lebanon by proxy instead of him having to do it. But they don't want a traditional war. The Iranians come thinking that Hafiz Al-Assad will give them tanks and fighter jets, et cetera, to fight the Israelis. And they are met with a flat no. So they send most of the contingent back to Iran, but they leave a small number of people who set up in the Bekaa Valley.
12:50 Speaker 00 There's a barracks, isn't there, behind the temple to Baal?
12:54 Speaker 01 So the barracks, that comes a bit later. It comes a year later, when they are really already established. But they start just in the homes of local clerics who were their friends from when They were training back in the mid seventies. And they set up a training camp in a small village called Janta. And they start recruiting people to this new idea of a party of God. A party that fights the enemy with the values of, of, you know, the Quran, um, et cetera. They never fight the Israelis themselves.
13:33 Speaker 00 And this is Hezbollah.
13:35 Speaker 01 And that becomes, yes, the party of God, Hezbollah. The name is chosen, uh, quite early on, even though Hezbollah does not announce its official coming into existence. Until much later, but Hezbollah is born then. Very much a creation of Iran. And very much a project backed by, at the time, the Iranian ambassador in Damascus. Muhtasemipour, Ali Muhtasemipour. A, a, a Daur cleric as well, who knew Lebanon very well, also from having trained in the camps and having visited.
14:10 Speaker 00 And we should say that Damascus has this Shia shrine to Zainab. Which is full of Iranian pilgrims and is, is a kind of major center of Shia activity in the region.
14:21 Speaker 01 It becomes so after nineteen seventy nine, but before nineteen seventy nine, it was a shrine. Um, that was also visited by, by non, by non-Shias, by Sunnis. And, and it is really Iran's project to turn all these shrines. That were often visited by Sunnis and Shias into just a Shia dominated symbolism of the Islamic Republic. And what is very important to mention here, and I wish actually we'd also mentioned it in the previous episode, but we'll do it here. Is that Ali Khamenei. Who was Supreme Leader, killed in the first opening shots of this recent war. Was president of Iran at the time.
15:05 Speaker 01 And it is his pet project to start these proxy militias. These Shia proxy militias outside of Iran.
15:13 Speaker 00 These are his babies, right?
15:15 Speaker 01 It is. Very much Khamenei's pet project to start all these proxy militias. Because actually, the Supreme Leader at the time, Ruhollah Khomeini, isn't very keen on the idea. He wants, and he's the one who says, "Bring all the men back because we have to fight. We still have to fight Iraq. The war is not over." And so they leave the small contingent. But you know who else is on the scene, Wili, which we did not mention, and who gets called in to the State Department after the Sabra and Shatila massacre? It's the Deputy Ambassador of Israel to Washington, Benjamin Netanyahu.
15:54 Speaker 00 Yes, he first appears in Washington at this point.
15:57 Speaker 01 He first appears as Deputy Ambassador in Washington in 1982, where he is just arrived as Deputy Ambassador, Deputy to Moshe Aron's ambassador, who wants somebody who is not really a diplomat. He wasn't a diplomat at all, but he was a very good man at PR.
16:15 Speaker 00 So all the roots of everything we're seeing are gathering at this point. And what you're also seeing, and this is something you point out very prominently in your book, is that the Black Wave begins, the Black Wave of the title. You begin to see the Iranian chadha, this black outfit, spreading through the Bekaa Valley and even into southern Lebanon and the suburbs of Beirut.
16:40 Speaker 01 Absolutely, because these Iranian young Basij, the sort of the religious police, these Iranian Revolutionary Guards who have come from Iran to initially fight the quote-unquote Zionist enemy, then to set up Hezbollah, don't actually do any of the fighting themselves. They are only there to train the young Lebanese. It's like a force multiplier, right? They recruit all these young men who will become the fighting force, the young Shia who are driven by religion, by ideology, by testosterone,
17:16 Speaker 01 who, you know, feel as Shias in Lebanon traditionally oppressed, impoverished, discriminated against.
17:26 Speaker 00 Yes, we need to make that point very, but we haven't said that. The Shia are the bottom of the social pyramid. And that South Lebanon, which has been the area that the PLO was first based in, which they've been driven out, and there's a kind of vacuum of power there now.
17:42 Speaker 01 Yes, there's a vacuum of power, but the other story that is often misunderstood or mistold and which I try to rectify in in my next book is that the PLO leaves a vacuum and young Shias start looking for an alternative. And it's not quite like that either, because somebody like Ayman Muhnij, who would later become famous or infamous as the architect and Machiavellian mind behind a lot of what Hezbollah will do, including bombings and kidnappings. Ayman Muhnij is a young Shia who is an eager recruit to the newly founded camp, training camp by the Revolutionary Guards.
18:28 Speaker 01 Ayman Muhnij is not suddenly at a loss about what to do because the PLO has left and, you know, where should where should he go. Ayman Muhnij was close to the Palestinians, but not really a member of their guerrilla guerrilla movement, the Fatah, although it's often thought that he was, but he actually wasn't. But he had trained with the Palestinians, that's where that's where he got his training from. But he had already been to Iran before 1982. He wasn't just picked up on the street as some, you know, stories or or movies depict. He wasn't just picked up on the street by Iranians who arrived in Lebanon. He had already been in touch with the Iranians. He'd travelled to Tehran
19:10 Speaker 01 with Lebanese clerics. In fact, on the day of the Israeli invasion of Lebanon, in June 1982, Ayman Muhnij was in Tehran with several Iranian clerics who, by pure serendipity, had been on a pre-planned trip to Iran to ask for Iran's help in setting up something to fight Israel. And Ayman Muhnij flies back to Lebanon to begin the battle against the Israelis as they advance towards Beirut. But he had already been in that milieu of being close to the Iranian revolution. He was enamored with the Islamic revolution and was already in that context.
19:54 Speaker 00 Now, Kim, the first time that the world begins to wake up to realise what it is about to face is in April 1983 at the American Embassy in Beirut. Tell us what happens.
20:09 Speaker 01 1983 is the year where everything goes wrong for America and for Israel in Lebanon. Actually, it went wrong just a little bit before for Israel, not just with the Sabra and Shatila massacre and the assassination of Bashir Mayel, but the first suicide bombing attack in Lebanon is targeting the Israeli military headquarters in the southern city of Tair. And that is the first suicide operation organised by Ahmad Mughniye.
20:38 Speaker 00 He is responsible?
20:40 Speaker 01 He is responsible for organising that. The Israelis pretend or deny, pretend they don't know or deny that it was a suicide bomber, because it's suicide bombing, because it's just catastrophic to admit that not only are they involved in massacres, but now they've birthed some, you know, new form of terrorism with this invasion that was supposed to change the Middle East.
21:02 Speaker 00 And this, again, is the lessons, again and again, of the Lebanon Quagmire, that every attempt to stamp out for the final time resistance doesn't do that. It produces new monsters.
21:16 Speaker 01 I think it's the lesson worldwide of, you know, trying to stamp out local resistance against occupation, whether it's in Vietnam or in Afghanistan or in Iraq or in Lebanon. It doesn't work. It doesn't work without a political vision that is constructive and without diplomacy, and we can get to that as well. But just one very quick point about these Iranian Revolutionary Guards who don't end up fighting anyone, they just train, and they're very busy proselytising, which is how this Black Wave starts. Radio stations with, you know, lessons of the Quran and pushing women to put on the veil, marching
21:57 Speaker 01 down the streets of Baalbek with pictures of Khomeini and green flags of the revolution, etc. It starts... Starts to change the city and it starts to change the community, the Shia community. And then it spreads to, as you said, the southern suburbs and southern Lebanon.
22:15 Speaker 00 And Ahmad comes up with this idea of attacking the American embassy. This is the crucial moment.
22:21 Speaker 01 I'm not sure he comes up with it, but he is definitely part of the operational plan. The man who is at the center of a lot of this is a man called Hussein Musawi, who is the founder of something called Islamic Amal, which is an offshoot of Amal, the Shia militant party or militia and now political party led by the man who is now the Speaker of the House, but was at the time a warlord as well. And Hussein Musawi sits at the nexus of the relationship between Iran and Damascus, between Tehran and Damascus, and he facilitates a lot of that. And there is, there are records of his conversations, intercepted conversations with Iranian officials
23:05 Speaker 01 about wanting to do something spectacular in Beirut. And the Iranian ambassador in Damascus gives the go ahead. And because Ahmad Muhri is just 22 at the time, he cannot plan something like that. This is a huge amount of explosives and something really that requires more involvement than just a few kids.
23:29 Speaker 00 So take us now to April 18th, 1983, noon. The Middle East changes dramatically with a single attack.
23:39 Speaker 01 Indeed, it is the first time that America becomes the target of a bombing in the Middle East. And it is a result of everything we've discussed in this episode so far in the past, the previous episode, of the Israeli invasion of Lebanon colliding with the Islamic Revolution of Iran and meeting on the shores of the Mediterranean in a project that Iran and Syria spearhead to push America out of the Middle East.
24:17 Speaker 01 And after Ahmad Muhaniye organizes the bombing of the Israeli army headquarters entire, they go for the next big thing with an action coordinated, I'm sure, with the capital Tehran, the Iranian ambassador in Damascus, and most definitely with the knowledge of Hafiz al-Assad in Damascus and and his people. So a pickup truck loaded with some 2,000 pounds of explosives.
24:46 Speaker 00 Which is a lot of explosives.
24:47 Speaker 01 A lot of explosives, which one young man like Ahmad Muhaniye cannot necessarily gather on his own, which is why this is a much bigger plot. It drives through the front into the front door of the embassy because the embassy had not yet installed the barriers. They had some thought that perhaps suicide trucks could become a problem because they'd seen what happened in entire, but they were, you know, not ahead of, they were behind behind their planning. And it drives through the central section of this eight-story building, a three-tower compound, which collapses entirely. Sixty-three people
25:30 Speaker 01 are killed, including seventeen Americans, and the whole CIA station is killed as well. Eight CIA officers, including Robert Ames, famously depicted in Kai Bird's book, The Good Spy, who was the head of Middle East at the CIA. It's the deadliest attack on an American diplomatic mission up to that point.
25:54 Speaker 00 But it's not the last, because another one comes soon after.
25:58 Speaker 01 It's not the last, but but crucially, it's the sort of the the opening salvo in this war by Iran and Syria to drive America out of the Middle East. And yes, absolutely, it's not the first and it's not the last. By October, we have the tragedy of the Marine barracks, which get bombed as well on the morning at 6:00 a.m. on a Sunday, on October 23rd.
26:22 Speaker 00 And this is even bigger death toll, isn't it? This is an absolutely vast.
26:27 Speaker 01 Even bigger dramatic death toll, two trucks, one into the Marine barracks and one into the French barracks. Remember, we didn't go over that in the last episodes after we finished on Sabra and Shatila. But Willie, after the Sabra and Shatila massacre, Reagan decides to send the Marine back to Lebanon. And it is out of guilt because they have failed in their mission.
26:53 Speaker 00 They're meant to have been there protecting the Palestinians. They've given that guarantee that they will be safe, but Weinberger brought them out. And so now they go back in.
27:03 Speaker 01 They go back in and with an undefined mission, other than to sort of help the Lebanese government and the Lebanese army, you know, prop themselves up. And on October 23rd, they are targeted in this Marine barracks bombing, the worst, deadliest day for the US Marines since the Battle of Iwo Jima in the Second World War. A total of 241 American soldiers are killed and 58 French paratroopers. And it's a moment that is also defining for the history of the Middle East and America's role in the Middle East.
27:39 Speaker 00 We're going to take a break there. When we come back, we will be in the middle of another horror story, which is the Western hostages.
28:06 Speaker 02 The Great Game, strategic struggle between Britain and Russia.
28:13 Speaker 03 We assess, Prime Minister, with high confidence it was Russian.
28:19 Speaker 04 Holding the Russians accountable is World War III.
28:21 Speaker 05 They took down a British passenger jet containing 350 people.
28:24 Speaker 02 Man in the Kremlin is playing, Alex. Got to ask yourself, do you want to play or not?
28:30 Speaker 05 You're the Prime Minister. You've done nothing!
28:38 Speaker 06 We would need to understand the policy context.
28:40 Speaker 02 All the relevant context will be structured as a framework today, disseminated into an operation order, or FRAGO.
28:48 Speaker 07 A FRAGO that says to kill the president of Russia?
28:53 Speaker 02 Yes.
28:55 Speaker 04 New from Goalhanger. Who is going to be able to pull this off?
29:00 Speaker 05 You're my soldier, are you Sergeant Tom McDuff Duffy?
29:04 Speaker 04 An audio drama journey like no other.
29:06 Speaker 05 And like Duffy, they are our most valuable weapons.
29:10 Speaker 04 Devized as a technically rigorous geopolitical action thriller.
29:13 Speaker 05 We have two times friendly KIA.
29:15 Speaker 04 Where Britain plays its strongest hand. He's the best. Against its strongest foe. Don't do it Duffy! Bear Hunt. Available now wherever you get your podcasts.
29:39 Speaker 00 Welcome back. Kim, I want to talk now about something which was very much something I was afraid of as a young journalist in the Middle East at this time, which was the kidnappings, which also begin around this time. Tell us about this.
29:54 Speaker 01 So one episode that is a little bit forgotten in these layers of tragedy that happen in Lebanon at the time is a separate string of attacks, bombing attacks in Kuwait in December of 1983. So after the embassy bombing in Beirut, after the Marine barracks bombing,
30:13 Speaker 01 the US embassy and various other targets are targeted with bombs in Kuwait. There are several casualties, but the attacks mostly fail and the people who carry out the attacks are caught by the Kuwaiti authorities. This is not lawless Lebanon in the middle of a war where the Lebanese central government is incapable of finding anyone who's done anything. They are caught. One of them is the brother-in-law of Aymad Mughni, and he is sentenced to jail for life. He is, Ahmad Mughnij is, stay with me because family ties are complicated. Ahmad Mughnij is brother-in-law and also his cousin, right?
30:55 Speaker 01 And Ahmad Mughnij's wife, whose brother is now in a jail in Kuwait, Mustafa Badradin is his name. Ahmad Mughnij's wife wants her brother back. And so Ahmad Mughnij comes up with a genius idea of starting to kidnap Western hostages in Lebanon to demand the freedom of Mustafa Badradin in Kuwait.
31:17 Speaker 00 And at this point, despite everything, people like your mother, who was Dutch, are living in Lebanon. They've been, this was a place where many Westerners had settled. There were people that loved Lebanon and this was a popular, a popular spot. Though the British at this point would send all their, their Foreign Office people that wanted to learn Arabic to Beirut. It's famous for, still despite everything, for its nightlife, for its music, for its food.
31:46 Speaker 01 There is a famous story anecdote that Thomas Friedman tells, or it's famous because he tells it in his book, Thomas Friedman's also excellent book, From Beirut to Jerusalem, where he talks about the, how normal life continues in Lebanon even throughout the war.
32:03 Speaker 00 Yeah.
32:03 Speaker 01 And there are these dinner parties and, you know, clubs. And depending on where the fighting is, the party moves a little bit. It's just part of social life. It's just part of how people cope as well. There are some incredible descriptions also of people from opposing factions coming together for dinner, which is a lost art in today's world that is so partisan.
32:26 Speaker 00 And polarized, yeah.
32:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, polarized. You should still be able to sit down over a meal and discuss things. But Tom Friedman tells this incredible story of being invited to a dinner party for Christmas or something. And the shelling around them is insane and the hostess is waiting for things to calm down. And she finally says, well, would you like to have your dinner before or after the ceasefire? I mean, let's just proceed with, with things. So there are still many foreign Living in Lebanon at this stage, including my mother, who does does not, you know, who we all somehow miraculously come out of this war completely unscathed. My father had a business partner or acquaintance, rather, who was kidnapped.
33:10 Speaker 01 He was an Italian, not a very well-known incident, but he was a man who'd lived in Lebanon for thirty years, who was in the import-export insurance business and who gets kidnapped. And I will never forget, William, I will never forget the phone calls of his wife to our house, asking my father if he knew anything, if he'd heard anything. And it was just so haunting, this woman, Madame Molinari, would call. And I didn't know what it was about. I was a child. I was, you know, six or seven. And I would say, Papa, Madame Molinari is on the phone. And I didn't know what it was about, and I would ask him, and he's like, well, you know, she's looking for her husband. And he probably didn't want to tell me too much more because it was just so distressing that somebody could disappear.
33:54 Speaker 00 Our mutual friend Charlie Glass got taken at this time.
33:58 Speaker 01 Absolutely, absolutely. And and it stayed with me, Willie. I know it's slightly going off on a tangent, but if you'll allow me. This stayed with me, these haunting phone calls that stayed with me forever. And I always wondered, what happened to Mr. Molinari? Where is he? Did she find him? What happened? And in this terrible saga of hostages, some of them survived, some of them were released.
34:24 Speaker 00 Terry Anderson.
34:25 Speaker 01 Terry Waite.
34:27 Speaker 00 John McCarthy.
34:28 Speaker 01 John McCarthy, British, lots of Americans also.
34:32 Speaker 00 All tied to to radiators and basements, terrible stories.
34:37 Speaker 01 Terrible, terrible, vengeful, sick psycho stories of of of torture, of of pain, of of punishment by their by their hostage takers. Some of them died in captivity. They were sick. Michel Surat, a famous French, you know, political scientist, who was also taken hostage and died from hepatitis, apparently, or possibly leukemia, we're not sure. Died in nineteen eighty-six. Terry Anderson, longest-held American hostage, finally released in ninety-one. But during my research for the book. My next book, as I was exploring this hostage crisis,
35:21 Speaker 01 I finally looked up Mr. Molinari and I found the news reports about him. After ninety-one, when the hostage crisis comes to an end, people are still looking for Mr. Molinari because he has not come out and they're looking for information. And he had actually been killed almost immediately after he was taken hostage. And so his wife had been looking for him all these years, but he was already dead. And the cruelty of it will never leave me. You know, researching this chapter nearly made me want to give up this book because it was just too painful to imagine that somebody could be so cruel to do this to another human being
36:06 Speaker 01 and also to live through the pain that these hostages had gone through. And I understand that Ayman Muhnij was trying to get his brother-in-law out of jail in Kuwait, but his brother had a trial in court for something that he had done, which was considered to be a terrorist action. And the Kuwaitis were adamant that they would not release him and undo their own justice system. But crucially, and I know that this is where you want to go next, William, this crazy idea of Ayman Muhnij, which begins with a previous kidnapping episode, which I will not reveal here and you'll have to read my book because it is the genesis of it all.
36:47 Speaker 01 It is the genesis also of Ayman Muhnij as Iran's man in Lebanon. And so Ayman Muhnij's kidnappings with his people, and this can be done very quickly and very easily in Beirut, where people walk on the streets freely.
37:02 Speaker 00 Now, Kim, let's refocus on Hezbollah again. Hezbollah, who've been behind these hostage attacks, who've been behind in some form both the Marine and the embassy bombings, although there'd been different groups named at the time, Islamic Jihad, it's the same complex of Shia groups behind this. Now, the moment that people realize what Hezbollah has really become is in 2006. What happens then?
37:33 Speaker 01 Two thousand and six is the next big war between Israel and Hezbollah.
37:41 Speaker 01 Very briefly, in the 1980s Hezbollah is mostly busy proselytizing and fighting America, holding hostages and attacking American targets. It is also busy killing what was then known as the Lebanese Resistance against Israel, which was mostly leftist and communists. Hezbollah wants to dominate the scene of the fight against Israel and wants to Islamize it. So actually, they start by killing first their own as well, including within the Shia community. 1990, the Lebanese war ends.
38:21 Speaker 01 Syria is occupying Lebanon fully, except for the part that Israel is still occupying. And Syria and Iran agree that although all militias should disarm, Hezbollah can keep its weapons as a national resistance movement against Israel. It is now the dominating force, the dominant force on that scene. The communists are out of the picture, they've all gone home or they've been killed. And the other part of the agreement is that 3,000 Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps officers or members can stay in the Bekaa Valley. And that is crucial to understand today how it is that we still have Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps members in Lebanon. The 90s is fairly peaceful.
39:06 Speaker 01 By 2000, the Israelis decide they've had enough of occupying southern Lebanon. They pull back. They pull back. It is a victory for Hezbollah. The Israelis had made the decision anyway, but it is a victory for Hezbollah. And they claim it very much as such. Absolutely. And they claim it and they are revered and lauded, not just within the Shia community, but in Lebanon generally, including by Christians and across the Arab world. They have won where no other Arab army has managed to win. They have won against Israel. They have liberated Arab land.
39:45 Speaker 01 Against occupied by Israel, which no other Arab army, no other Arab faction, no other Arab country has managed to do.
39:53 Speaker 00 The Egypt had got Sinai back through a peace agreement, but this is the first time that there is Arab land that has been won through our force of arms. But 2006, tell us what happens then.
40:04 Speaker 01 So to clarify that after 2000, everybody thinks, okay, you know Hezbollah has done its job, it's going to go home, but it doesn't for various reasons, they find ways to maintain their raison d'être.
40:16 Speaker 00 Keep their weapons and yeah.
40:18 Speaker 01 Keep their weapons with support from Syria and Iran, and also because of major policy failures on America and Israel's side. Major policy failures that have to do with why Israel withdrew unilaterally and not as part of a peace accord. That was a failure of the Clinton administration in its in its waning days. So fast forward to 2006, Hezbollah kidnaps a couple of Israeli soldiers on the border and ignites a 34 day war with with Israel. In the backdrop, there's also a war happening between Israel and Hamas in Gaza. So a lot of similarities again with what we've seen over the last couple of years. It's a devastating war for Lebanon, but Israel,
41:02 Speaker 01 which has told the Americans, we need 30 days to finish the job, realizes it cannot defeat Hezbollah. It had asked the Bush administration, Prime Minister Houde Almert, had asked the Bush administration, give us 30 days, don't ask for a ceasefire, we can do it. And after 30 days, they told the Bush administration, we can't do it, we need a ceasefire. So again Hezbollah victorious, venerated around the Arab world for giving the Israelis a bloody nose and not losing the war, even though they didn't win it. There is a complicated element here, which we need to insert, William, which is very important for people to understand the very mixed feelings that people have in Lebanon about Hezbollah.
41:45 Speaker 01 Hezbollah also now stands accused of murdering assassinating Lebanon's prime minister.
41:52 Speaker 01 In a plot organized by Ahmad Muhnayeh and his brother-in-law, since freed since the end of 1990, who's now, you know, working with Ahmad Muhnayeh, Mustafa Badr Dine is back in Lebanon. With Iran's support and Syria's support and help, they assassinate Lebanon's prime minister. And there's a series of assassinations, including friends of mine, Jabran Twaini, editor of the newspaper An Nahar, Samir Asir, writer for An Nahar, author and historian, who are assassinated because they stand in the way of Iran's vision for the region. By now, in Syria, you have Hafzal Assad's son as president, Bashar al-Assad.
42:36 Speaker 00 Bashar, a former ophthalmologist from West London.
42:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, and there are even doubts about whether he ever finished his diploma, actually.
42:44 Speaker 00 I've heard that he's practicing again in Moscow, but that maybe that's not true.
42:47 Speaker 01 Gosh, I wouldn't want to go see him as a, to check my eyes. But he is, he is weak, he needs legitimacy, and he is enamored with Hassan Nasrallah, the leader of Hezbollah, who has been leading Hezbollah since the early 90s. And they form this sort of, you know, a very interesting trio, you know, Hezbollah, Bashar al-Assad in Damascus, and the Iranians in Tehran, who, if we can remind our listeners also, all of this is happening with the backdrop of the US-led invasion of Iraq, where the Americans are now occupying Iraq and facing two insurgencies, one Sunni and one Shia.
43:30 Speaker 01 The Iranians are worried that America's going to come for them. Damascus is worried that the Americans are going to come for them. And so they start using the playbook they learnt in the 80s in Lebanon, is to use violence against the Americans, blow things up, kill people. And so the project of ejecting America from the Middle East continues with these assassinations in Lebanon and, of course, with the insurgency in Iraq. And guess what? I mean, eventually, the Americans leave Iraq, right? And, and in Lebanon... Hezbollah rises as a political power with veto power over Lebanon's politics. And in Iraq, Iran becomes, you know, also the kingmaker.
44:15 Speaker 00 So let's fast forward again, Kim, now to October the 7th. We're now in the present Hezbollah's role in all this because Iran is supporting Hamas. But it's also supporting Hezbollah and there is an axis which is running from Tehran, through Damascus, through Beirut and southern Lebanon into Hamas land, into Gaza.
44:43 Speaker 01 So I want to be careful here to make clear that as far as we know, there is no clear information that Iran knew the details or supported or helped with the planning of October 7th.
44:54 Speaker 00 That's very important. What's your source on that, Kim?
44:58 Speaker 01 Western officials, high-ranking American officials. I think even the Israelis have said it.
45:05 Speaker 00 What is the nature of that if they didn't know about October 7th? Is it funding? Is it weapon systems or what's going on?
45:12 Speaker 01 It is funding and weapons, but it is not operational knowledge. Hezbollah and Iran were not aware of the operational details. And this is not to justify or excuse or make them sound like moderates. But from my conversations with Western diplomats based in Beirut, who speak to Hezbollah, Hassan Nasrallah was shocked by the savagery of the images of October 7th. This is from a man who, you know, is thought to have been behind the assassination of Rafik Haridi, Prime Minister of Lebanon. And it's a moment which I think, you know, we will need a lot of years of hindsight to understand exactly what happened.
45:55 Speaker 01 Hamas was expecting that the axis of resistance would rally and inflict Armageddon on Israel on that day. And it didn't happen. I know that missiles rained on Israel, but it wasn't what Hamas had anticipated.
46:11 Speaker 00 And instead, there is an extraordinary Israeli operation with the bleepers famously, which wipes out a great deal of the Hezbollah fighters and commanders, as well as obviously a number of civilian casualties.
46:26 Speaker 01 Absolutely. A year later, um, it is Lebanon that is at war or Hezbollah that is at war with Israel. Hassan Asrola has tried during all this time to do a very careful calibrated tit for tat with Israel. He wants to show support for Hamas, but he doesn't want to drag Lebanon into war because the lessons of two thousand and six were terrible for the Shia community. Hezbollah was not defeated, but it was devastating. Iran's key uh uh goal is survival of the regime. It does not want to have a direct confrontation with Israel. Um. It plays also a choreographed game of missiles and replies and tit for tat and
47:09 Speaker 01 very choreographed messaging. Because as I said, you know, everybody is guilty of hypocrisy, the Israelis, the Iranians, the Americans. And everybody is is deploying weaponry and and missiles uh uh and AI with full impunity. And and this is what, you know, is so difficult for us in Lebanon because we find ourselves um in the middle of it, a battleground, just as in nineteen eighty-two. I mean, we're not even caught between a rock and a hard place. We're caught between three rocks that are pounding, you know, on us.
47:43 Speaker 00 Kim, we have a a a couple of uh very important questions to ask. First of all, following the pages and following the the assassination of Nazrallah. You get the impression that that Hezbollah is, if not beaten, at least severely on the back step at the moment. Is that is that a a correct expression?
48:02 Speaker 01 That's what the Israelis thought at the end of uh the conflict in twenty twenty-four when they carried out a ceasefire, that Hezbollah was decapitated, that they could no longer inflict damage on on Israel and that seventy percent of their capacity was diminished. And then, you know, Israel did not do what it should have done, which is to try to begin diplomacy uh through the Americans or however which way they wanted and reach out to a Lebanese government that was uh the best government and president that we've had in in decades since before the war to try to turn this tactical military success into a diplomatic Strategic victory. And this is a pattern that is repeating everywhere across the Middle East with every conflict that Israel is engaging in.
48:44 Speaker 01 And similarly with Iran, similarly with Gaza and the Palestinians and with Syria. So fast forward to February this year, when Israel and America launched their first strikes against Iran and killed Ali Khamenei, whom we were discussing previously, who was president of Iran in the eighties, now supreme leader with Benjamin Netanyahu, Deputy Ambassador to Washington in nineteen eighty-two, today Prime Minister of Israel. You know Hezbollah decided to avenge Ali Khamenei's killing and launch missiles against Israel, even though Israel had been bombing Lebanon throughout the prior year despite the ceasefire. So Israel was in breach of the ceasefire.
49:26 Speaker 01 And they were able to rebuild their capacity during that year, even though they were being bombed by Israel and Lebanon was being bombed by Israel, probably because the IRGC, the Iranian Revolutionary Guards, were very actively working to rebuild Hezbollah's capacity, because they knew that another war was coming. You know, Israel and Trump last summer also said that Iran's nuclear capacity had been obliterated, and this was the war to end all wars. But it was very clear to me and many of us in the Middle East that this was not going to be the last war. And that Iran felt that if it did not strike back hard the next time, that this would be a recurrent pattern, that it had to show its enemies. And again, I'm not justifying, I'm explaining.
50:10 Speaker 01 It had to show its enemies that it could actually inflict real pain to others and that it would not just send choreographed missiles anymore.
50:20 Speaker 00 But Kim, nonetheless, there is a sensation that Nasrallah is assassinated. The Israelis are wiping out great swathes of southern Lebanon. A lot of the Shia villages and towns have been destroyed in front of us every day.
50:37 Speaker 00 Syria is no longer under the Assad's and they are no longer supporting Hezbollah. And Iran is obviously now under direct Attack on the face of it, you could take the view that Israel has made some strategic successes here. And that they have degraded their enemies more than we would have thought possible a few years ago. Do you agree with that? Or do you think that there is no reason to think that this this story is over?
51:06 Speaker 01 The story is not over. Brilliant, brilliant tactics. You know, I could sit here if I were an American general or an Israeli general and describe in detail the brilliance of the military strategy and the targeting and the.
51:18 Speaker 00 Penetration of intelligence also.
51:21 Speaker 01 Penetration of intelligence, including because the enemy is not as smart on both sides, right? I mean Hezbollah exposed itself dramatically to the outside world via social media as it bragged about the massacres. It was carrying out in Syria in support of Bashar al-Assad. And so the Israelis were just hoovering up all this information about who was going where and the videos and the posts and the funeral announcements. And it hoovered up all that information. And the pager operation which killed and maimed so many in Lebanon. Yes, you could describe it as tactically brilliant. But Leon Panetta, former CIA chief in in America, also described it as state-sponsored terrorism.
52:06 Speaker 01 Because it they blew up amongst the people, just regular civilians.
52:11 Speaker 00 Yep, in supermarkets, in in houses and in restaurants, yeah.
52:16 Speaker 01 In supermarkets and clinics and and and and homes. So my concern is that just as in nineteen eighty-two, you know, Israel claims victory because they've have gotten rid of the PLO, which has gone into exile, which was the goal of all this. Syria looks like it's on its knees, but it gives birth to something else. Hezbollah. We don't know what this is going to give birth to, but I suspect it is not the end of the story. And my deep concern is that if Israel occupies Lebanon, it will give renewed justification and raison d'être for Hezbollah.
52:53 Speaker 00 For new generations of of resistance.
52:56 Speaker 01 And and at a time when Hezbollah is, you know, resented by, I would say, a majority of the Lebanese population.
53:02 Speaker 00 So just as you can see in Iran, even those who hate the regime rallying around their country, are you seeing a situation in Lebanon where despite everyone being very irritated by Hezbollah bringing a new war on Lebanon, that that that again, there will be rallying of future generations to support against this coming occupation?
53:26 Speaker 01 It depends how the war ends in Lebanon, whether there is occupation or or not. Beyond the wholesale destruction of Lebanese villages, uh, it's not clear yet that Israel is going to physically occupy the South.
53:38 Speaker 00 They've said they will.
53:39 Speaker 01 We'll have to see. I think they've learned some lessons from their occupation. They can control this uninhabited area from from the sky. They don't need to be physically present, actually. So that may be one of their military strategies. Um, I don't discount two things. One, that the regime in Iran could still fall under the pressure. And in Lebanon, um, if there are enough smart people uh, in America, in Israel, in Lebanon, in Damascus, in Europe, um, there could still be a diplomatic outcome to this. Lebanon is much more complicated than Iran when it comes to Hezbollah in the sense that the sectarian tensions that are bubbling up, that is pitting the country against the Shia community. You know, all of that is, you know, for another uh, episode maybe.
54:22 Speaker 01 But I don't see a wholesale rallying of the country against Hezbollah. No, I see maybe pockets of the Shia community rallying again despite their anger at what Hezbollah has done to Lebanon.
54:34 Speaker 00 And finally, one last question, a brief answer. Uh, Kim, the fate of the Palestinians, this remains the the great unsolved sore at the heart of all Middle East.
54:45 Speaker 01 Israel tries to resolve all problems militarily. The Palestinian question remains at the centre of everything. Despite what the Israelis may try to say, that it's not important, that they can solve, that they can make peace with the whole of the Arab world and ignore the Palestinians, which is often what they try to do. I know we've had the Oslo Accords, the Madrid Conference, the Abraham Accords, which normalise Arab-Israeli relations, again with that resolving the Palestinian question. I think there is no way around this Palestinian question. And if I may end our episode with a quote by an American scholar of the Middle East
55:28 Speaker 01 and a president of the American University of Beirut, who was assassinated, as I said, in 1984, Malcolm Kerr. He wrote something in 1977, William, 1977, with so much prescience. And he says, "The Central Arab grievance has always been the dispossession of the Palestinians, personal dispossession for half of them, political dispossession for the other half. Because of the connotation of injustice and shame, overwhelming in their eyes, the Arabs have never been able to drop the issue. Because it casts into question the whole basis on which Israel came into being, the Israelis have never been able to face it.
56:09 Speaker 01 Efforts on one side or the other to bury or sidestep the question are always suspect. It is the common curse of all concerned, including the Palestinians themselves. This is the main reason why separate deals in the Arab-Israeli conflict are always likely to come unstuck."
56:30 Speaker 00 Kev, thank you very, very much. An extraordinary marathon. That brings to an end our series on the Arab-Israeli world, but sadly, this is an ongoing story which has no end in sight.
56:42 Speaker 01 Yes, I'm afraid we'll revisit this in a few months or a few years.
56:46 Speaker 00 Goodbye from me, William Derempel.
56:48 Speaker 01 Thank you so much.
Previous 352. Israel’s 1982 Invasion of Lebanon (Part 7) Next 354. Liberator of Latin America: Simón Bolívar vs The Spanish Empire (Part 1) Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated