Pod Insights Empire: World History 294. Gaza & The Islamic Conquest (Part 4) About this episode How did the expansion of Islam out of the Arab peninsular affect Gaza in the seventh century? Who was ‘Amr ibn al-As and how did he ambush the Byzantines in Gaza? Why is the Islamic Conquest described as the “invisible conquest” by some historians?
William and Anita are joined once again by Peter Sarris, Professor of Late Antique, Medieval and Byzantine Studies at the University of Cambridge, to discuss the Arab Conquest of Gaza in the seventh century.
Join the Empire Club: Unlock the full Empire experience – with bonus episodes, ad-free listening, early access to miniseries and live show tickets, exclusive book discounts, a members-only newsletter, and access to our private Discord chatroom. Sign up directly at empirepoduk.com
For more Goalhanger Podcasts, head to www.goalhanger.com.
Email: [email protected]
Instagram: @empirepoduk
Blue Sky: @empirepoduk
X: @empirepoduk
Assistant Producer: Becki Hills
Producer: Anouska Lewis
Executive Producer: Neil Fearn
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hi, this is Gary Lineker from Goalhangers, the rest is football. This episode is brought to you by Wise. It's only when you start moving money between currencies that you really think about the exchange rate, the fee, and what might be hidden away in the small print. Whether you're living abroad, paying someone overseas, or just trying to manage your money across borders, you want a fair exchange rate, an easy transfer, and no surprises along the way. Wise keeps things simple. Wise is a smart way to move the currencies you need around the globe. It works in more than 160 countries and with over 40 currencies. Most transfers arrive instantly. Wise uses the mid-market exchange rate, like the one you see on Google, with no markups or hidden fees.
0:44 Speaker 00 So when money needs to move, you can see the rate, know the fee, and get on with it. Join millions saving billions on hidden fees by downloading the Wise app today. Be smart, get wise, Ts and Cs apply.
0:58 Speaker 01 A BetterHelp ad. Your brain has limited storage, so why is it still holding on to that embarrassing moment from years ago? That tough breakup? The conversation with your boss you keep rehearsing in the shower? If you could permanently delete one thing from your brain, what would it be? BetterHelp is an online therapy platform that gives you space to talk about what's taking up too much of yours. BetterHelp is now in-network with more than 125 health plans, with many copays as low as $15 for eligible members. And if you don't have eligible insurance or live outside the US, you can still get 10% off your first month. Sign up and get 10% off at betterhelp.com/empire. Cost and coverage may vary.
1:34 Speaker 02 Are you looking for support in your weight management journey? Zepbound terzepatide may be able to help. Zepbound is a prescription medicine used with a reduced calorie diet and increased physical activity to help adults with obesity, or some adults with overweight who also have weight-related medical problems, to lose excess body weight and keep the weight off. Zepbound is approved as a 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, or 15-milligram injection. Zepbound contains terzepatide and should not be used with other terzepatide-containing products or any GLP-1 receptor agonist medicine. It is not known if Zepbound is safe and effective for use in children. Don't share needles or pens or reuse needles.
2:16 Speaker 02 Don't take if allergic to it, or if you or someone in your family had medullary thyroid cancer, or if you've had multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type two. Tell your doctor if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Stop Zepbound and call your doctor if you have severe stomach pain or a serious allergic reaction. Severe side effects may include inflamed pancreas or gallbladder problems. Tell your doctor if you experience vision changes before scheduled procedures with anesthesia, if you're nursing, pregnant, plan to be, or taking birth control pills. Taking Zepbound with a sulfonalurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Side effects include nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting, which can cause dehydration and worsen kidney problems. Talk to your doctor.
2:57 Speaker 02 Call 1-800-545-5979, or visit zepbound.lily.com.
3:14 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Empire with me, Anita Arnon.
3:18 Speaker 04 And me, William Durham.
3:20 Speaker 03 And we are joined again, I'm very happy to say, by the Professor of Late Antique, Medieval and Byzantine Studies at the University of Cambridge, Peter Sarris. Welcome, Peter. In the last episode, we talked about Christianity and the impact of Christianity and these sort of wild monks who really changed the fabric of what Gaza looks like. Sort of this boom time with monasteries and churches springing up in the Holy Land. In this episode, we're going to talk about the great conquests of Islam, because, you know, William left us on a cliffhanger at the last episode in the 7th century. And how ideas about this period have, by modern study, been completely overturned in some way.
4:03 Speaker 03 So, I mean, let's start at the very, very basic level. We're talking about a rapid expansion of Islam at this time. We're talking sort of 630s, aren't we? So just tell us what's going on and what is happening here.
4:16 Speaker 04 Over the course of the 6th and early 7th centuries, cultural Economic, military, religious conditions in the Arabian Peninsula had been revolutionised and transformed by the growing involvement in Arabia of the two great powers, the Eastern Roman Empire and Sassanian Persia. Partly as a result of this growing superpower involvement, you've seen new religious ideas come into circulation in Arabia, new forms of identity emerging. And in the context of these swirling ideas and new identities, in the early 7th century, a prophet has emerged in the settlement of Mecca, a significant trading centre known to posterity as Mohammed.
5:01 Speaker 04 Mohammed has preached the imminence of divine judgement, a very strong theme in contemporary Christianity and Judaism as well in the early 7th century. He's advocating the worship of the god of the Old Testament, who has previously revealed himself to the Christians and Jews, but whose worship of that true god Mohammed believes would become corrupted. And through a series of political, religious and military struggles, Mohammed has been able to unite many of the tribes of Arabia under the aegis of his new religion. As Will mentioned at the end of the last episode, Mohammed is believed to have died around the year 632, but the leadership of the community of believers, the Ummah, that he has established,
5:45 Speaker 04 would then pass to some of his earliest companions, who would reunite the Arabian Peninsula after some of the peoples who have joined the Ummah tried to break away, and who then, from the year 633 to 4, would begin to lead forces into the empires of the Eastern Roman Empire and Persia to the north, thus initiating the dramatic expansion of Islam over much of the known world, which will then proceed from the 630s down to the 650s in a series of lightning military campaigns.
6:16 Speaker 03 And right at the end of the last episode, William was talking about this sort of flashpoint that takes place in Gaza, where a unit called Serios is meant to be paying Arabs who have been protecting that frontier for the emperor. And he says, you know what, we hardly pay our soldiers, we're not going to pay the dogs. It is such an insult. It leads to something that the people of Gaza could not have foreseen. Tell us what happens next.
6:42 Speaker 04 Well, I think that episode is a later dramatization and sort of almost semi-mythologized retelling.
6:50 Speaker 05 What a shame, it's a good story.
6:52 Speaker 04 It is, I think a fine detail of it should be treated with some caution, but it's telling us something that's fundamentally true. And I think, take a step back for a moment. During the course of the Roman Persian warfare of the preceding century, the Romans have built up their own Arabian or Arab clients along the frontier zone, dominantly Christian Arabs or Arabians, the Gassanids or the Jaffans, and the Persians have built up their own clientage network as well. Now, at the height of the Roman Persian struggle, when the Persians think that they've got the Roman Empire beaten, just before the Emperor Herakles reverses the Persian games, the Persians seem to have dismantled these clientage arrangements along the frontier zones of southern Iraq and southern Syria and southern Palestine.
7:37 Speaker 04 They're probably planning to put something else back in their place, but they never get round to it. So when the Emperor Herakles suddenly defeats the Persians at the end of the 620s and nominally restores Roman control to Syria, Palestine, Egypt, you've got a power vacuum along those desert fringes. You've got former client peoples of these empires not receiving the pay that they're expecting. And as it were, the emergent forces of Islam and the emergent forces of the Ummah are filling that power vacuum.
8:07 Speaker 05 Ummah being the Muslim community.
8:09 Speaker 04 The Muslim community. And the first time the Romans spot this is when two Arab forces turn up near Gaza. And we have some later Arabic accounts of this, which don't mention Sergius. We have a later Byzantine account drawing, or a now lost source that does mention him. We have a very, very contemporary account written in Syriac, which is the Christian version of the Aramaic language of the region around Gaza, which not only gives us a fragmentary, but quite chilling, because it's a brutal account of the military conflict that ensues. But is also one of our earliest sources to survive from anywhere that mentions Muhammad by name.
8:51 Speaker 05 Really?
8:52 Speaker 04 We have a Syriac source written around the year 640 that describes how a battle occurs about 12 miles to the east of Gaza, as a result of which the Romans flee, leaving behind their general, who is killed.
9:07 Speaker 05 They sew the general up in a camel or something. It's a horrible story.
9:11 Speaker 04 According to the later sources, but the contemporary Syriac source describes is then the Arabs, as it were, raiding local villages and killing villagers in order to take control of the countryside and ravaging the whole region. But I say the Syriac source describes these as the Arabs of Muhammad as one of our very earliest mentions of him. So it's a crucial historical document, not just in terms of the military history of Gaza, but for the history of world religion.
9:35 Speaker 05 Goodness, and the leader we're always told is Amr ibn al-As, famous for later conquering Egypt.
9:41 Speaker 04 Absolutely, yes.
9:42 Speaker 05 And there's the mosque he established, which you can go and see in Cairo.
9:45 Speaker 04 These Arabian Arab soldiers and warriors are not unknown to the populations of Gaza and southern Syria and southern Palestine, because the empires have become dependent on such armed Arabs or Arabians for their region's defence for a long time.
10:00 Speaker 05 And they've been bringing in frankincense and stuff.
10:03 Speaker 04 And they've been bringing trade, and Muhammad's family have been merchants. But there was some suggestion, for example, that Amr ibn al-As's family may have had estates or lands on the fringes of Roman territory as well. So initially quite hard, I think, for the Romans to work out what's going on here. Not least because the Emperor Heraclius has defeated the Persians in the foothills of the Caucasus, with armies made up of Armenians and what have you. The Roman military present on the ground in Syria, Palestine, Egypt in the year 6334 is going to be pretty nominal. A lot of this so-called Roman troops are really going to be local levies, local recruits who don't really want to be serving, were being press ganged or armed peasants, or other Arab tribesmen who are being paid to defend it.
10:47 Speaker 04 And it's quite easy then, as it were, for the Arabs being employed by the Romans or the Arabs being employed by the Persians to then defect to these new Arabs emerging from Inner Arabia. And I tell you, lots of that is happening as well.
10:58 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, you can't imagine Heraclius, who has only had five minutes, well, not literally, but just a little bit of time to sort of bathe in his own success of taking back the One Tree Cross, which we talked about in the last episode. He's seeing all of this. What is his reaction? Is he sort of dispatching armies all over the place to try and quell these little fires everywhere?
11:16 Speaker 04 What seems to happen after the fall of southern Palestine, the Arab armies will advance very rapidly, I think we'll come on to this shortly. The whole of Palestine will be under Arab control. And a series of engagements will then take place along the banks of the Jordan, in which the emperor's own brother, leading a Roman force, is defeated by the Arabs. And that, in a sense, breaks the backbone of such Roman resistance as there is. But I think it's partly because there aren't really that many Roman troops there on the ground to start off with. It's interesting with Herakles, that Herakles, who has restored the True Cross, will be very well regarded in the Islamic historical imagination and memory. And as I say, the religious milieu out of which Islam is emerging
12:01 Speaker 04 and the Arabs that are joining the Ummah are emerging, is one that is actually, in many ways, more pro-Roman than pro-Persian. So there's a verse in the Quran, the verse on the Romans, that seems to be alluding to a battle between the Romans and the Persians that had taken place in southern Syria, in which the Romans had been defeated, but in which the faithful are reassured that, God willing, the Romans will be victorious.
12:26 Speaker 05 Peter, so this culminates, this Islamic advance culminates in the Battle of the Yarmouk. Tell us about that.
12:33 Speaker 04 Yes, so here we have a great difficulty in that we have a series of much later Arabic sources, which are in very fine detail. We have some later Byzantine sources, a bit more fragmentary. And then we have some more contemporary, very fragmentary sources in Syriac. And how we piece these together to make sense of the Arab advance is slightly complicated. So just to take a step back to see how we get to Yarmouk. Sixty-three to four, they have taken control of southern Palestine. By the end of that year, most of Palestine seems to be under their control. So by Christmas of sixty-four, the Arabs have got control of Bethlehem. We have a letter from the head of the church in Jerusalem,
13:16 Speaker 04 complaining, for example, that the Christian clergy can't make their use of it. Pilgrimage to Bethlehem in the Christmas of six three four because of the Arabs.
13:25 Speaker 05 And for those that don't know the geography, Bethlehem is just, you know, what, five miles to the south of of modern Jerusalem.
13:30 Speaker 04 Yeah, now, in the later Arabic sources, Jerusalem doesn't fall till six three nine. But that's actually quite unlikely. There's a good case to be made that Jerusalem probably falls by the end of six three five. And that then with Jerusalem having fallen by the end of six three five, the battle line then advances to the west bank of the Jordan. With the Arabs then advancing into Roman Syria and a series of engagements then take place. Along the northern fringe of the volcanic Haran Plain near the river Yarmouk. And these series of engagements then get, I think, tidied up by the later Arabic historical tradition. Into one big engagement we call the Battle of Yarmouk.
14:15 Speaker 04 But it's probably a series of struggles taking place as the Arab armies are advancing out from Jerusalem onwards into Syria.
14:23 Speaker 05 So Peter, quite soon after the Battle of Yarmouk or that series of engagements that you described. You get the establishment of a centralized Umayyad Caliphate. Tell us quickly about that.
14:35 Speaker 04 After the rapid expansion of Islam from the six thirties into the six fifties. The Islamic world is suddenly rent by a bitter civil war. Over the succession to authority and leadership within the communities out of this civil war. But the subsequent division between Shia and Sunni Muslims will emerge. We needn't go into that, but the crucial point is that the first major civil war is brought to a conclusion around the year six six one. With the rise to power of a dynasty that draws its support primarily from the armies of the Umar that are operating in Syria. A dynasty we know as the Umayyads, who will dominate the Islamic empire.
15:18 Speaker 04 And establish a more centralized Caliphate system ruling from Damascus, which will rule over this world from the six sixties until the mid eighth century.
15:26 Speaker 05 This is a vast empire, isn't it? It's what from the Indo- To Gibraltar or right into Spain?
15:32 Speaker 04 Yes, by 711, Spain has been conquered. So this is now an empire by the early 8th century, stretching from the Atlantic eating into Central Asia.
15:40 Speaker 05 And Peter, one of my all time favourite historical passages is my great idol. I'm not sure what you think of Sir Stephen Rudsmann. And he opens his famous history of the Crusades in the first volume with this description of the patriarch Siphronius taking the caliph into Jerusalem. The caliph arrives on a white camel. Tell us all that. Is that true? Or is that now not thought to be?
16:01 Speaker 04 I think a white camel may have been Stephen being a bit euphemistic. By this point, the leadership of the Ummah has passed this character Umar, known as Umar al-Farouq, the Redeemer, who makes the formal entry into Jerusalem when it's conquered. Early Islam is a very apocalyptic movement and this entry into Jerusalem has enormous cosmological significance for the Muslims, but also for the Christians. And we have our Byzantine account describes how the patriarch of Jerusalem, Siphronius, negotiated a treaty for the securing of all Palestine. So here he is negotiating Roman surrender. Umar entered the holy city clad in filthy camel hair garments. He's probably wearing something like a monk's robes, yeah, but it's being depicted negatively by the Byzantines.
16:46 Speaker 04 But he's adopting a humble demeanor, conveying an ascetic appearance.
16:50 Speaker 05 Peter, when this is sometimes presented, the Islamic conquest of Palestine, it's sometimes made to look as if this is an apocalyptic event. You know, the old world is wiped out, that a bunch of Arabs from the Hajaz come and replace the population. The beginning of Arab history in Palestine begins at this point. But historians today have a very different understanding, don't they? They say that the conquest actually is almost invisible, that you can't see it archaeologically, that there's just a new ruling class turning up, but that the administration continues for a while in Greek, that the same sort of Christian families are running the bureaucracies. I mean, I've got a book on my shelf here called The Invisible Conquest, which describes this as something
17:31 Speaker 05 that happens very gradually and is not one of the kind of great juncture points of history.
17:37 Speaker 04 The conquest of Jerusalem is apocalyptic in one. Absolutely crucial sense in that I think it has great sort of apocalyptic symbolism within early Islam itself. And what we will see over the course of the seventh century, particularly in the so-called era of the Umayyad caliphs and the second half of the seventh century, is very major investment in Jerusalem, the building of the Al-Aqsa Mosque on the temple mound. There's a very interesting argument made that Jerusalem is being prepared for gods to come and sit in judgment. So the intensity of apocalyptic expectation in early Islam is very important, I think, to how the early Muslim elite are viewing what they're doing in Jerusalem.
18:18 Speaker 04 Now, you're right that beyond that, partly by virtue of the rapidity of conquest and the way in which the conquerors initially concentrate on taking control of the countryside and then negotiating with civic elites, offering those civic elites continuity of property ownership and rights to worship. If they agree to pay tribute to the Arab conquerors, you see very little disruption on the ground. Although what is going on is a fundamentally military process, yeah? So that's why archaeologically you don't see much by way of destruction. The the the Arabs aren't turning up and doing what Mongols do of sort of razing cities to the ground. Controlling the countryside is the first military priority and that tends to leave very little by way of archaeological evidence behind.
19:03 Speaker 04 But it's also true that it's also and it's also crucial that their primary goal is to establish control over a region and extract tribute from the local population with the Arabs or Arabians establishing themselves as a separately cantoned, almost warrior caste initially, living off the tributes collected from the local population.
19:25 Speaker 05 And they build a new city camp, don't they, at Ramle, which is just kind of inland from Gaza?
19:30 Speaker 04 And that's a very common phenomenon we will see throughout the areas conquered by the Arabs. And this allows for an enormous amount of economic, administrative and cultural continuity on the ground. So in fact, the area of greatest continuity of literary culture from the ancient into the early medieval world in terms Of writing in Greek, for example, is Palestine as it passes into Arab rule. Because both the Persians and the Arabs have conquered Palestine rapidly and have been very happy to leave the existing infrastructure in in town. And in Palestine, as in Egypt, as in Syria, what you largely have are the same elites administering and dominating the same regions,
20:12 Speaker 04 collecting essentially the same taxes, but then handing those taxes over to Arab masters instead of sending them off to the Roman authorities in Constantinople or the Sasanian authorities in Satisifon. And they're doing so until the end of the seventh century in the same languages. And it's only at the end of the seventh century that the caliph Abdul Malik, who's one of the great caliphs of early Islamic history and who consolidates an imperial system, introduces Arabic as an imperial language and a language of administration. And it's at that point that local elites throughout this nascent caliphal world, whether they're adopting Islam or not, whether they're Christians or not, or Muslims or not,
20:53 Speaker 04 have to start learning Arabic in order to maintain their positions in local society. So the linguistic Arabization of communities in the Near East shouldn't be read to indicate that old populations have been swept away and replaced by huge numbers of settlers, as it were, coming in from inner Arabia.
21:14 Speaker 05 And in terms of religion, again, we think of Islam as a completely different religion to Christianity or Judaism, albeit that they have Abrahamic roots. But it's not at all clear to the people on the ground that this is not just another Christian heresy, is it? Islam looks quite like the sort of prayer that they're used to and the way that Muslims pray, prostrating themselves, is what the Greek Orthodox monks did at the time.
21:37 Speaker 04 This is further complicated by the fact that it is quite clear, and this comes across from a close reading of both the Arabic and non-Arabic sources, that the armies of conquest, although the leadership is made up of Arabians or Arabs who've been called to monotheism in what we might call a sort of proto Koranic or photo Islamic form. But there are also individuals and groups fighting in those armies of conquest who are still thinking of themselves as Christians or think of themselves as Jews. There are also Jews taking part in the conquest. And indeed, we're told that when Sergius, or whoever the Roman commander is, is killed by the Arabs,
22:18 Speaker 04 we're told by another seventh century source that the Jewish community near Gaza celebrates because they regard the Romans as persecutors and these Arabs as liberating them from Roman control. To some Roman onlookers, they say, well, what are these people preaching? They're preaching the worship of the God of the Old Testament, but they seem to deny the divinity of Christ. They sound like Jews. So some people are assuming they're Jews. Made more complicated by, thank God, there are clearly Jews in the armies of conquest and the first governor of Jerusalem appointed by the authorities is Jewish. Others look at the same claims and say, these are claims made by Christian heretical groups. They must be Christian heretics. And Islam itself is acquiring greater definition and form over the course of the seventh century.
23:02 Speaker 04 In the same way that Christianity adopted greater definition and form over the course of the fourth century, as each of these religions had become imperial religion. Islam acquires greater theological definition that people come to understand it as a separate and rival religion, rather than something derivative of one of the existing religions.
23:22 Speaker 05 Peter, when I was writing my book From the Holy Mountain and reading about this period and hanging around Jerusalem, talking to archaeologists, I met this Franciscan called Michele Picciolino, who dug up a lot of the churches from this period. And his view was that there was a great wave of church building after the conquest, particularly around the Jordan and in the desert. And that far from being a period when Christianity goes into decline, that the new conquerors have lighter taxes, less money is being sent off to Constantinople, and that many of the, particularly the non-orthodox Christian groups are actually flourishing at this point.
23:59 Speaker 04 I think the level of taxation issue is more complicated, but the point is that the taxes are being collected still by Christian elites. And as is always the case, the people collecting the taxes take a cut. Yeah, so it's a good time. For Christian elites and they're investing a lot of that in church building, a magnificent wave of church building, particularly in what is now Jordan, particularly for those Christian communities who had been regarded as heterodox or non-conformist by the increasingly persecutory imperial authorities in Constantinople. The period of Arab rule is something of a golden age and changes the way we think about this, particularly because early Islam isn't terribly interested in conversion. If we're looking at the Mediterranean world and the Near East,
24:40 Speaker 04 around the year 700 AD, the majority of Christians are subjects of the Caliph of Damascus.
24:48 Speaker 03 Well, look, let's take a break there and after the break, we're going to introduce you to an unexpected, perhaps, figure from this period of history. He's a saint, he's Saint John of Damascus, who lives just a few miles away from Gaza. Join us then.
25:35 Speaker 03 You sound horrible. Oh, I feel worse. This flu is not playing around.
25:40 Speaker 06 Dad, you promised you'd be in my band and it's showtime. Then it's Dayquil Intense Flu time. For fast and powerful relief of your flu symptoms, try Dayquil Intense Flu. Hit it. Yeah.
25:53 Speaker 06 Dayquil Intense Flu, the fast-acting daytime coughing, aching, aching, aching fever power through your flu medicine. Use is directed, keep out of reach of children.
26:04 Speaker 04 When it comes to my policy, Farmers gives it to me straight, so there's no surprises.
26:09 Speaker 07 It's your coverage. You should never be confused.
26:12 Speaker 04 You hear that? An insurance provider with a conscience.
26:16 Speaker 07 We're a choir, but yes, we have that too.
26:19 Speaker 04 Straightforward coverage you can literally understand. That's what you get when. You have Farmers.
26:27 Speaker 07 Learn more at farmers.com. Underwritten by Farmers Truck or Fire Insurance Exchanges or Affiliates. Products not available in every state.
26:38 Speaker 03 Welcome back. Peter, just tell us, Saint John of Damascus, first of all, where does he stand in the pantheon of saints in Christian belief? And who was he?
26:50 Speaker 04 He's regarded as one of the greatest theologians in the Eastern Orthodox tradition, and is a fascinating figure who really embodies and epitomises how, despite the Arab conquest, the establishment of Caliphate rule, the Christian communities of the Near East still remain part of a broader Christian universe and cosmos and world that still embraces Syria, Palestine and Constantinople. John belongs to a family of Syrian Christians, who have probably been serving as the bureaucratic class, who probably for centuries were serving as bureaucrats under Roman emperors in Syria,
27:33 Speaker 04 and who then simply continued their bureaucratic lifestyle under Arab rule, operating as bureaucrats ultimately at the court of the Umayyad caliphs, ruling over this new empire from Damascus. He then retires, as many civil servants did in this period, Christian civil servants did in this period, to a monastic cell. He becomes a monk and theologian.
27:57 Speaker 05 At Masaba, the monastery is still there, isn't it?
27:59 Speaker 04 Exactly, it's still there. And is particularly important for two aspects of his thought. First of all, I say by this point, at the end of the 7th century, it's now become apparent to Christians and others that Islam is a rival religion. It is acquiring much greater definition at the court of the Umayyads at Damascus, where the caliphs are presiding over formal disputations between Christian, Jewish and Muslim scholars over theological issues, which is making it clearer what the differences between these religions are, what they have in common, but crucially where they stand apart. And John writes one of our first detailed critiques of Islam from a Christian perspective, from an Orthodox perspective, where he emphasised...
28:42 Speaker 04 What it has in common with earlier Christian heresies. But he is treating it as a separate religion. He clearly knows Islam as religion in detail up close. He is referring to verses of the Quran, including interestingly, some verses that seem to have been lost since then, which is an interesting historical feature. But John's critique of Islam is particularly important because it's so close to events and he knows Islam so intimately up close. But actually, his critique then provides a sort of intellectual scaffold around which subsequent generations of Muslim scholars will then compose and draft their own justification of Islam. So in that sense, he makes a very important contribution to the emergence of Muslim theology.
29:27 Speaker 04 At the same time, the end of the seventh century, one of the major points of division that emerges between Muslims and Christians, and particularly Christians of the Roman Empire, is the place of religious images in worship. Images or icons such as those that survived from St Catherine's in Sinai are best preserved. Sixth century icons of Mary and the saints have come to play a central role in Christian worship. At the end of the seventh century, the Caliph Abdul Malik denounces the Christian use of images as idolatrous and affirms that Islamic opposition to the veneration of images is a cornerstone of the Islamic faith.
30:07 Speaker 04 This will then spark off a nervous reaction in the Byzantine Empire, which finds itself on a back foot militarily. And in the 730s and 740s, the Byzantine authorities will themselves crack down on the use of images in Christian worship. And John of Damascus, writing in Syria and in Palestine, having probably engaged in this dispute with the Arabs earlier, writes our most detailed and influential justification of the veneration of icons in the place of Orthodox worship. Again, he's ready for this debate because he's already engaged in it with the Arabs.
30:42 Speaker 05 And just again to clarify this, John of Damascus, in his youth, there was a story in, I think, one of those Ratzman books, that he was a drinking companion of the future Caliph Ali Azid. He's right there in the court.
30:55 Speaker 04 Yeah, absolutely. He knows this world intimately up his...
30:57 Speaker 03 But if you've got John of Damascus, or John Daneseen, as he's sometimes known, who's saying, you know what, this religion, Islam, it's heretical, let's say that, but it doesn't feel so different. One would assume then, that it would be easy and, you know, just a smooth transition to convert. But conversions don't happen in great numbers, do they, Peter? Why not?
31:19 Speaker 04 Islam isn't interested in conversion at this formative phase. What is it interested in doing really is extracting tribute from the subjugated populations, which can then be shared out amongst the Muslims. If anything, that then provides the Islamic leadership, the caliphate leadership, with a disincentive to see widespread conversion, because widespread conversion would lead to a diminution in your tax revenues.
31:40 Speaker 03 Right.
31:41 Speaker 04 Yeah. So when you do start getting large-scale conversion, it actually causes political crisis. The Christian communities of Palestine, Syria, Egypt will remain probably in a majority in each of those areas down to the period of the First Crusade and beyond.
32:00 Speaker 05 Really? So majority Christian till the 11th, 12th century?
32:03 Speaker 04 That's the position I would take, yes.
32:04 Speaker 05 That's so different from conventional views. So Palestine remains majority Christian right through this period. And yet, there are important things going on. And you mentioned the building of the Al-Aqsa Mosque and the Dome of the Rock. Take us there for a minute, because these are substantial projects, and really, the first mosques of Islam.
32:22 Speaker 04 In the 4th century, if we go back to the age of the Empress Helena and Constantine, with adoption of Christianity, we've seen, as it were, the monumental reappropriation of the Holy Land and Jerusalem by the Christian Roman authorities, with the building of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, or the Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem. Christians imagine themselves in the new Israel, reappropriating the Holy Land on behalf of God's new chosen people. In a sense, what we're seeing in the second half of the 7th century, with the Umayyad Caliphs and the investment in Jerusalem, the Ummah with their new revelation doing the same. The great centrepiece of this is the construction of the Al-Aqsa Mosque, the great mosque on the temple mound, which is...
33:05 Speaker 04 At the time it's built, is regarded by some of the caliphate's Jewish subjects, many of the Christian subjects, and possibly even by some of the Muslims themselves, as an actual restoration of the ancient Solomonic temple.
33:20 Speaker 05 Huh.
33:21 Speaker 04 So, for example, I was recently in Turkey. If you look at the frescoes at this Sumala monastery, one of the finest Byzantine monasteries in Pontus, it has a depiction of Jesus in Jerusalem, and you look at the depiction of the temple, on the temple site, and it's actually a depiction of the Al-Aqsa Mosque. Crusaders visiting Jerusalem centuries ahead will regard the Al-Aqsa Mosque as actually being the temple, and hence that's why the night templars partly end up there. Now, the Al-Aqsa Mosque, however, is very, very interesting, and there's something about it. There's a mystery there which hasn't quite been resolved, because what we see in these greater urban centres, in Jerusalem or Damascus,
34:02 Speaker 04 is the Umayyad Caliphs conveying the majesty of their new religion and the majesty of their new empire by appropriating key aspects of Roman and Greco-Roman monumental architecture to convey their authority to their former Roman subjects in terms they understand. The Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem is seen to be modelled upon an earlier Byzantine church, the Church of the Kafisma, a much smaller structure that was located between Jerusalem and Bethlehem, where the Virgin Mary supposedly rested on her way to Bethlehem to give birth to Jesus.
34:39 Speaker 05 But it's one of a tradition, isn't it, Peter, of these octagonal Byzantine churches? In your own town of Thessaloniki, there's one there.
34:46 Speaker 04 But the similarity in structure between the Church of the Kafisma and the Al-Aqsa is particularly striking, and this is important because the verse in the Quran on the Virgin Mary bears very close resemblance to the liturgy that was celebrated at the Church of the Kafisma in the pre-Islamic period. So there's some sort of fascinating connection between early Islam, Al-Aqsa, and the Church of the Kafisma, and the Virgin Mary.
35:13 Speaker 05 And people may not know that there's More mentions of Mary in the Quran than there is in the Bible.
35:18 Speaker 04 This is one of those aspects of, as it were, popular piety that late antique Christianity and early Islam very much have in common is very high regard of the Virgin Mary.
35:26 Speaker 05 And what we see in the Dome of the Rock is is the first sort of public presentation of Islam, isn't it? And of the Islamic conquest. So you've got the diadems of the Byzantine emperors and the Persian emperors up on the wall as sort of trophies.
35:40 Speaker 04 What you have is the declaration now of the faith in a public space, as it were, denouncing Christian trinitarian doctrine, saying, do not say three. Do not say three. God is only one.
35:54 Speaker 05 The idea of the Trinity, three gods in one.
35:56 Speaker 04 At the same time, we're getting the Islamic declaration of the faith, the declaration that Muhammad is a prophet of God, on the coinage being minted by the Caliphate at the same time. This is now becoming clear to people that the Holy of a living in a new empire is an empire dominated by a new faith. And this is being conveyed to them by the great monuments in the cities they're passing through, but also in the coins in their pocket.
36:17 Speaker 05 How interesting. Now, as well as the Dome of the Rock and as well as the Al-Aqsa Mosque, there's also another great Umayyad building in Palestine, further into the desert, away from Gaza. Which is the Kirbat al-Mafjar, is that how it's pronounced? Kirbat al-Mafjar, Hisham's Palace, the hunting lodge outside Jericho. And there you have images that look not unlike the images of Justinian and Theodora at Ravenna. They're now in an Islamic context.
36:47 Speaker 04 These desert palaces are fascinating. My favourite one is a place called Katar Amr in Jordan. First of all, it's very interesting that a lot of these desert palaces have figurative images in them. That's because, as it were, the hostility to images of living things that would be associated with some strands of Islam has not yet been consolidated or set in stone, hence some of which may have religious significance as well. But when you see the quality of art in these desert palaces, what you're seeing is a sense of both the way in which this early Islamic elite is comfortable with naturalistic art. But you're also seeing it's extraordinary wealth because these people are buying. The best quality art, the best quality artists that are available anywhere in Western Eurasia at this time.
37:32 Speaker 04 So if you want to see the best quality art you can get anywhere around the year seven hundred, you go to these desert palaces. They're not just there for people to sort of chillax in, yeah. These are serving a very important political function. In the great urban centres like Damascus or Jerusalem, that's where the caliphate authorities negotiate with the former Roman urban elites. You go to these desert palaces to maintain contact on the fringes of the desert with the existing surviving Bedouin tribal leadership there. That's where you negotiate with them. That's where you have your parties, drinking wine. The one in Kazan Amr has a hammam attached to it with a large depiction of a female nude at the entrance of the hammam.
38:14 Speaker 05 Hammam, just in case people don't know the word, is of course a Turkish bath. It's a steam bath and everyone's naked in there and there's pictures of naked women.
38:21 Speaker 04 Some people interpret this large female nude as a being of political significance. I think it's something a bit more leashed than that.
38:28 Speaker 05 In Indian Muslim history, hammams, Turkish baths are places where negotiations take place, partly because everyone is naked and they can't bring arms in. So it's this place where where everyone's sort of, you know, stripped down to their essentials and what goes on in hammams.
38:44 Speaker 03 Stays in hammams. Okay, got it. So, so Peter, I mean, this all seems to be thriving. There's all seems to be a template for, you know, harmony. What about the economy? I mean, is Gaza still this exporting hub that it used to be?
39:00 Speaker 04 I think by the time we're dealing with the golden age of the caliphate, as it were, Gaza is still extremely prosperous. The countryside is is prosperous, the wine production is continuing. A lot of the wine being consumed, of course, by the local Christian and monastic population and monasteries are still there.
39:18 Speaker 05 How amazing.
39:19 Speaker 04 There's no stopping that. Indeed, we even know we have documentary sources from Egypt showing that wine estates owned by the Caliph are sending wine to Damascus. The wine culture isn't quite what we might necessarily imagine.
39:30 Speaker 05 Pictures of naked women in the sauna and wine exports to Damascus, that's not what you imagine, no.
39:34 Speaker 04 But I think that the circulation of these goods is diminishing. For example, we look at the evidence from Constantinople. Constantinople is no longer sucking in goods from these areas on a large scale in the way they did before. It's much more dependent on trade with the Aegean and much more interested in the Adriatic. I think, as it were, the Gazan trade has become more locally concentrated. But it's still very prosperous. By the eighth century, population levels are rising again. In the sixth century, there'd been a major impact on the region of bubonic plague. So from the mid-sixth century to the mid-eighth, population levels have been down. By the mid-eighth century, the plague has burnt itself out and population levels are rising again.
40:12 Speaker 05 Peter, during the Roman Empire, it was always the East that was the richest half. The luxury and the really fancy lifestyles were taking place in cities like Antioch and Constantinople and Alexandria, as well as Gaza. After the Islamic takeover of the Eastern Mediterranean, do both sides of the Mediterranean remain out of contact with each other? I mean, would you still have traders going from Gaza and delivering wine to Marseille or to the Aegean? Or do you get the impression of a cut-off, the Mohammed and Shalhaneen idea that train is cut in half?
40:47 Speaker 04 People wouldn't argue any more that Mediterranean trade is brought to an end in the way that was once argued, but that it is operating at a much lower ebb, I think, is the crucial point. If anything, the developmental differences between East and West are exacerbated because Syria, Palestine, Egypt are conquered so rapidly that that's where you find, as it were, ancient levels of economic sophistication and complexity surviving in their healthiest and most fully-formed manner into the medieval period.
41:21 Speaker 05 That is wonderful, Peter. So we're coming to an end of this period of stability and prosperity now in this series on Gaza. After the invisible conquest and the prosperity of the Umayyad period, which had come after the prosperity of the Byzantine period. The whole of Palestine sees a century of instability from, really from the kind of ninth, 10th century onwards. And you get different Muslim powers, Tullunids, Fatimids, Bedouin and Turkmen coming in. The towns begin to go into a bit of a decline. Gaza changes hands again several times as it had done in the earlier centuries. And the instability is only beginning because in the 11th century, a whole new movement
42:04 Speaker 05 comes out of Europe that's going to change the history of Palestine very significantly for two or three centuries. And that is the rise of the Crusaders. And in the next episode, we're going to talk about Saladin, about Richard the Lionheart, and about what happens when the Crusades land in the Holy Land.
42:26 Speaker 03 That's next time. But for this time, thank you so much, Peter Cyrus. That was, you know, extraordinary and so interesting, comprehensive, very, very, very good. Till the next time we meet, it is goodbye from me, Anita Aron.
42:38 Speaker 05 And goodbye from me, William Durham.
42:48 Speaker 04 When it comes to my policy, Farmers gives it to me straight. So there's no surprises. It's your coverage. You should never be confused. You hear that? An insurance provider with a conscience. We're a choir, but yes, we have that too. Straightforward coverage you can literally understand. That's what you get when. You have Farmers.
43:11 Speaker 04 Learn more at farmers.com. Underwritten by Farmers Truck or Fire Insurance Exchanges or Affiliate. Products not available in every state.
Previous 293. The Gaza Erotic Literature Festival: Byzantine Gaza (Part 3) Next 295. Crusader Gaza: Saladin & Richard The Lionheart (Part 5) Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated