Pod Insights Empire: World History 272. Solving The Mystery of America's Lost Colony About this episode Have archaeologists finally solved the 400 year mystery of the lost American colonists? Who orchestrated historical hoaxes in the 1930s and did they get away with it? How has the history of the Roanoke Colony been reappropriated by the right-wing?
Anita and William are joined by archaeologist Mark Horton to exclusively discuss his exciting new discovery through his work on the Roanoke dig site this year…
-----------------
Empire Club: Become a member of the Empire Club to receive early access to miniseries, ad-free listening, early access to live show tickets, bonus episodes, book discounts, our exclusive newsletter, and access to our members’ chatroom on Discord! Head to empirepoduk.com to sign up.
For more Goalhanger Podcasts, head to www.goalhanger.com.
-----------------
Email: [email protected]
Instagram: @empirepoduk
Blue Sky: @empirepoduk
X: @empirepoduk
Assistant Producer: Becki Hills
Producer: Anouska Lewis
Executive Producer: Neil Fearn
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hi, this is Gary Lineker from Goalhangers, the rest is football. This episode is brought to you by Wise. It's only when you start moving money between currencies that you really think about the exchange rate, the fee and what might be hidden away in the small print. Whether you're living abroad, paying someone overseas or just trying to manage your money across borders, you want a fair exchange rate and easy transfer and no surprises along the way. Wise keeps things simple. Wise is a smart way to move the currencies you need around the globe. It works in more than 160 countries and with over 40 currencies. Most transfers arrive instantly. Wise uses the mid-market exchange rate, like the one you see on Google, with no markups or hidden fees.
0:44 Speaker 00 So when money needs to move, you can see the rate, know the fee and get on with it. Join millions saving billions on hidden fees by downloading the Wise app today. Be smart, get wise, Ts and Cs apply.
0:58 Speaker 01 Progressive's Accident Response can contact emergency services if you're in a major accident. The only thing worse than someone you love being in an accident is not being able to help them. So Progressive is here to help when you can't. So get peace of mind knowing your loved ones are protected with Progressive's Accident Response. Learn more at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Limited availability in California. Driver is responsible for emergency and towing charges not covered by the policy. Coverage subject to policy terms and conditions.
1:28 Speaker 02 They're running a cover two defense. But you're running to get game day deals on Uber Eats. Keep everyone at tonight's watch party fed with deals from your go-to restaurants. Or stock up with deals on your favorite snacks and groceries. Whatever the occasion, get game day deals on Uber Eats all season long. It's not football without food. Uber Eats, order now. Terms apply. Product availability varies by region. See app for details.
2:08 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to this episode of Empire with me, Anita Aronin.
2:13 Speaker 04 And me, William Durham.
2:14 Speaker 03 And we're all in sort of back of the bus mode because we've got one of our naughty guests back on, who we absolutely adored. I mean, honestly, could not love this man more. Mark Horton, archaeologist extraordinaire, who you might remember last time was on, talking about Darien, the attempt of the Scots to found their own empire. And can I just say, you got me into all sorts of trouble because you made me laugh so much. I had a heaving postbag from people off the north. Why are you finding this so bloody funny? It's a great tragedy. What's wrong with you? But you said it funny. It's not my fault you said it funny, but it was a very funny and very marvellous episode.
2:55 Speaker 04 Remind them, Anita, what it was that was funny.
2:57 Speaker 03 Oh, well, I mean, the thing was, it was Mark gave this list of reasons why this colonization attempt may not have been successful. And among them were the fact that they took leather cannons. I mean, already, I'm no military person, but I don't see how that was a good idea. And they took to trade with the natives bonnets and bibles as if they were going to get anything for that stuff. So the whole thing, it was just not, not great.
3:24 Speaker 04 Big potential market for bonnets, even today in Panama. The Scots knew exactly what they were up to.
3:30 Speaker 03 It was a planning snafu, as we say in the trade, which Mark told really well. Anyway, welcome, Mark.
3:37 Speaker 05 Oh, thank you.
3:39 Speaker 03 All right. We are here to talk about a very different subject, one that we have covered on this podcast before. But Mark is going to have a whole new perspective on this, and it comes straight from the dirt of truth and reality. So Willie, do you want to give people an idea of what it is we're talking about?
3:57 Speaker 04 I'd love to open this because weirdly enough, what Mark has dug, the same sort of time as he was digging it, I had one of the opening scenes of my book, The Anarchy, about the subject we're about to talk about, which is the first English attempts to found a colony in North America. And this is a period which immediately predates the founding of the East India Company. The East India Company, which as we know, went on to be the largest commercial organisation in history, controlled half the world's trade. Started off as this very unpromising idea, basically trying to keep up with the Dutch, who'd already found a route to the spice trade. And, you know, looking back, all Victorian historians looked on this decade when
4:41 Speaker 04 Raleigh is going off to found settlements in North America and other Protestant plantations are being founded in Ireland, which is what we did with Jane or Meyer in our Irish series earlier in the year. And when the British ultimately start their progress towards India, all this, the Victorians depict as this sort of inevitable progress to world domination. In reality, it was a period of enormous setbacks and half the attempts that the British were making to break into what was then a world dominated by the Portuguese and the Spanish, were often extremely unsuccessful. There was a search for the Northwest Passage to the Spice Islands that ended disastrously, not in the Malacca's, but instead on the edge of the Arctic Circle with all these galleons
5:25 Speaker 04 stuck fast in pack ice with their sort of battered hulls, punctured by icebergs and pike wielding crews mauled by polar bears. And that's the immediate background to this attempt by Sir Walter Raleigh to outsmart the French and the Spanish and to go to the north of where they were and to found a colony in south of Chesapeake Bay, in an area which of course he named Virginia after the Virgin Queen, Elizabeth. And the story that's normally told is that the colony survived barely a year, was abandoned in June 1586, after the relief fleet arrived to find the settlement deserted. And a shipload of eager new colonists jumped ashore to find both the staccato and the houses within completely dismantled.
6:12 Speaker 04 And nothing to indicate the fate of the settlers, except a single skeleton and the name of Crowatouens carved in capital letters on a tree. And there was simply no sign of the ninety men, seventeen women and eleven children whom Raleigh had left there only two years earlier. It was as if the settlers had vanished into thin air. Now, that is the background against which we're going to be talking about Mark's new discoveries, which completely rewrite that story, which is all very exciting. It's a empire scoop.
6:44 Speaker 03 Yes, it's a scoop, but also the story, when you say the story, the story kind of, you know, was big at the time and then it kind of fades a little bit into the background. But then it becomes a huge Victorian issue because of this man called George Bancroft, who publishes A History of the United States. This is an absolute study in, one might say, racism, because it has every racist trope in it, you know, that there are savages who massacred these people and took them away. And it pays specific interest in this little girl called Virginia Dare, a little white child who's apparently taken off by the savages and raised among savagery. And it really caught the public imagination. And Mark, it kind of coloured archaeological research as well, didn't it?
7:28 Speaker 05 Absolutely. I mean, you would have thought this founding story about America, historians, archaeologists would actually go to Crowatouen Island, the initials on the tree, and actually go and look for them, blinding the obvious. They obfuscated it a bit by saying, well, the Crowatouen were tribe. But John White, who'd done the map, actually put Crowatouen on his map. So we know exactly where the island is, it's Hatteras Island. So why did it take, as it were, till the 21st century for an archaeologist to go and look for where they might have actually ended up?
8:04 Speaker 04 So just to clarify, the idea preferred by the racists, as you put it, is that the savages wiped out these poor, innocent settlers, fresh from, from England. But your theory is that they actually just went somewhere else and no one's looked for them?
8:18 Speaker 05 That's right. I mean, you've got to realise, the racist view is all connected with manifest destiny. And the notion the white man has the right to colonise and settle the continent of North America. And it's an inconvenient truth that there are already people living there. And what's even more inconvenient is the notion that Virginia Dare, who is actually held up as the great icon of manifest destiny, and she's often shown as this sort of wonderful girl in flowing robes and so forth, this white icon, could actually have had sex with a Native American and her descendants would be Native Americans.
9:02 Speaker 05 That was just too much for these racist historians.
9:07 Speaker 03 So let's just lay out the story and flesh it out a little bit more. You mentioned John White. Just tell us exactly who John White was, who marked the place on the map.
9:16 Speaker 05 So John White was an artist in Queen Elizabeth's court and also probably a contemporary of Nicholas Hilliard and a miniaturist. And this is not irrelevant as the story emerges. So John White went out in the major military expedition, this is the 1585, as the expedition's artist. And he did a series of unbelievable pictures, exquisite pictures, that really set the scene of how you should represent Native Americans for the next 200, 300 years. The folios are in the British Museum, some of the finest, the most important things in the British Museum, actually. And then when it then came to set up a settler colony, the one that was rescued, was rescued
9:59 Speaker 05 by Francis Drake in 1585, so a settler colony went out in 1586 with women and children, including his own daughter Eleanor Dare, who was married to Anasius Dare, who was one of the colonists. So John White went back as the governor of this third colony, this settlers colony. And while he was there, his daughter gave birth to Virginia, named Virginia, obviously after the Virgin Queen. And unfortunately, we don't quite know the circumstances. John White's own account, so they ran out of food. So he then returned back to England to get more food for the colony.
10:43 Speaker 05 But unfortunately, he came back in fifteen eighty eight, fifteen eighty seven, fifteen eighty eight, when the Armada was being planned and it was not possible, as it were, for ships to leave England. So he didn't get back till fifteen ninety and then he found the colony abandoned with this C R O on a tree and Crotone written on the palisade of the abandoned fort. Unfortunately, he couldn't get back. He knew they were in Crotone Island. He'd mapped it earlier, but he was on a pirate ship, basically, who wanted to go pirating.
11:18 Speaker 04 And we should, we should explain that at this point, the British are making a lot of their money on what we would call piracy, which they called licensed privateering. And the British Crown would give out a licence to a bunch of pirates who, in the name of the Virgin Queen, would go and raid horrible Catholic ships, as the Protestant English saw it. And we're going to hear more of this when we have an episode on Panama. But huge amounts of cash get taken from Spanish and Portuguese vessels at this period, particularly silver from the Panama mines, and diverted to Charing Cross and Whitehall.
11:54 Speaker 05 That's right. So the captain of the ship wouldn't let him go and find his daughter on the islands of Crotone, but he then went for pirating unsuccessfully. And so we know about all this because John White then retired to Ireland and wrote a lengthy letter to Richard Hacklet, who was the main documenter of these Elizabethan voyages at the time.
12:15 Speaker 04 He's the one witness of the founding of the East India Company in fifteen ninety nine, which is the same sort of period.
12:20 Speaker 05 So he just wrote this letter, which was then quietly forgotten about. John White included a critical detail. He said that this was a pre-assigned, secret token. And if they put a cross underneath the letters, then they'd left in distress. If there was no cross, then they'd gone to this place voluntarily. And there was no cross.
12:42 Speaker 04 And Mark, I mean, how did you get on to this? Because it's all very well to say there was this letter which was forgotten about. Is this your archival research or does someone point you towards it and suggest you do the dig? What's the backstory to your involvement in this extraordinary tale?
12:55 Speaker 05 The stuff is well known and I've always been interested in pioneer colonies. We did some work in Bermuda and St Kitts and St Lucia.
13:03 Speaker 04 Unlike you to choose a very nice Caribbean island to do your digs in.
13:06 Speaker 05 That's right.
13:07 Speaker 03 Sorry, don't mock the man, he's in Birmingham now. He puts in the work as well.
13:11 Speaker 04 At a National Trust rally or somewhere, are you?
13:14 Speaker 03 He puts the hard work, hard graft in as well.
13:16 Speaker 05 But critically, I thought, well, the lost colony is the biggest nut crack of all. Let's go and see if we can investigate it. So there was an enthusiast called Scott Dawson, who was living, basically a school teacher on the island. And he's descendant from the very first European settlers, English settlers on the island Hattusa. And he was obsessed and wrote a little book about it, saying that, you know, why are we looking for all these things? So I went and visited him and he said, well, I'll organise a dig. So we set up a community archaeology programme called the Croatoan Archaeological Society. And we had great fun and since 2008, I've been working with Scotland local community.
14:00 Speaker 05 Because all these sites are on local people's private property. And so you have to work through the local community to get access to people's land. Otherwise you will get nowhere. And the white map shows where all the villages are on the island. And so it's really just a question of going to those villages and seeing if there's any archaeology.
14:21 Speaker 04 And when did you do this, Mark? When was this?
14:23 Speaker 05 We started in 2008, but I suppose the real breakthrough came when we managed to secure access to a site called Cape Crete in 2012. And that enabled me to really look at this site in detail, brought students from Bristol University. And we undertook British style excavations. The key thing was really careful recovery of the archaeology. So every little tiny piece of grain, every tiny bead, every, as it were, tiny bit of shell. We sieve these sites using mosquito mesh with a hose. So everything is recovered.
15:06 Speaker 05 And so we then have buckets and buckets of residue that then Scott and his volunteers spend their winter months going through, checking for any tiny beads or artefact that might be in there.
15:16 Speaker 03 Right, now before we reveal the reveal, let's just do a tiny bit more of what you were up against. Because you are pushing against not just sort of mounds of soil, but also. Collective rewritten memory. Now, in the 1930s, there was a particular play which muddies the waters with this. Can you tell us a little bit about that?
15:36 Speaker 05 Well, it was the play in the aftermath. So in 1937, there was a play called The Lost Colony, written by a Pulitzer winning playwright, well, the leading playwright in America at the time, a man called Paul Green. And he staged an open-air drama called The Lost Colony on the site of what was presumed to be the colony on Roanoke. Whether it was or not is a matter of debate. And actually, in the years since, a performance has been held every year annually. The first season had 50,000 people attending. Roosevelt attended, the president attended himself, and had a huge amount of publicity. Now, Green was quite
16:17 Speaker 05 a libertarian, even for the 1930s. And he ended the play with the colonists going off into the wilderness. And he speculated that some might have been killed, some might have starved, and some might have even been assimilated into the local villages, looked after by the Indians.
16:39 Speaker 03 Did he suggest it in such a paternalistic way, that they were looked after, or was there, you know, that they were taken and kind of forced?
16:45 Speaker 05 No, no, no, no. It was a very paternalistic thing, that they would have been looked after. So this was not a racist play? It was not a racist play. Well, it was like, I mean, the actors were blacked up as Indians and that kind of stuff. So, so until about three years ago, actually. So, yeah, there was, there was a certain amount of racism in the play about these savage Indians and things, with various battle scenes and so forth between the Indians, which had been played out. But it ultimately had a liberal view. But this was too much for what might describe as the racist historians that were very much dominant in America in the 1930s. There's a group of historians known as the Dunningites. This is named after a historian called William Dunning.
17:27 Speaker 05 And indeed, there was even a prize named after William Dunning. And this was buttressing the idea of white racial superiority, black inferiority, manifest destiny, and so on and so forth. And a lot of the historians, as it were, followed that view in particular. And it's difficult to recognise this, particularly in California.
17:50 Speaker 03 In Berkeley, of all places, like the most liberal place that you could go to on planet Earth these days.
17:56 Speaker 05 Was the absolute hotbed of this, as it were, racism. And particularly connected to, you know, they were sympathised to the Klan, the Ku Klux Klan. And I suppose connected to this was isolationism. This is 1937, an idea of supporting Nazi Germany as a subtext. These historians literally wandered around with Hitler-style moustaches to demonstrate their own allegiance to a right-wing racist cause because they saw Nazi ideas about racial purity as very much the same as theirs in terms of the issue of black people in their society.
18:39 Speaker 03 Mesegenation was the word of the era, wasn't it? You do not mix bloods.
18:43 Speaker 05 And it's worth pointing out that mesegenation was illegal. And of course, we have got the Jim Crow laws, which are also based on all sorts of discriminatory ideas. So the very nation that the first English in America could have ended up being looked after by Native Americans, indeed, their descendants today are probably to be found amongst the Native Americans, an idea that was, as it were, tentatively suggested in Paul Green's play, was of course completely unacceptable to them. And so they had to come up with a stratagem to undermine this notion of what John White had said with the initials on the tree and what was being promoted with this fabulously
19:29 Speaker 05 popular play.
19:30 Speaker 03 The stratagem is evil and awful, and we should, we should introduce one of the prime movers or prime actors in this, in this subterfuge, and it's a man called Herbert Bolton. Who is Herbert E Bolton, to give him his his proper title. Is he actually a Berkeley historian?
19:45 Speaker 05 He was the leading Berkeley historian of his day. There was a building even named after him in Berkeley until only about three years ago, when they worked out that he was a true racist.
19:56 Speaker 03 So what did he do? What did he do? What did he do?
19:58 Speaker 05 So he was the he was the curator of the Bancroft Library, but he had a dark side to himself as a trickster and a hoaxer. And he'd previously, maybe a few months earlier, had perpetuated possibly the most famous hoax in American history, which is Drake's plate of brass. That through the meticulous research of a historian called Melissa Darby, who I would be working with on this, has unearthed exactly the the link to Bolton. And this was Drake's landing, which they were determined had to be in San Francisco because of the whole English racism story.
20:37 Speaker 05 And had faked this plate of brass where where Drake said he claimed this land as New Albion. And it's a pretty palpable fake and was believed religiously by everyone until 1977, when it was then examined scientifically, metallurgically, it worked out to be a bit of rolled late Victorian brass plate. It could not have been Elizabethan.
21:00 Speaker 03 Can I just say, this is a tomato, tomato, potato, potato. You say trickster. I say absolute fraudulent shit. I mean, this is a man who's just trying to mislead academe, isn't he?
21:11 Speaker 05 And he was doing this because there was a rival historian, a Mexican historian, who was claiming that Drake hadn't landed in San Francisco at all, but up in Oregon. And having had all various, you know, tricentinaries and statues and postage stamps and everything else, they had to undermine this testimony by creating this historical fraud. Bolton, I say, also made a great deal of money out of it as a historical consultant because he was the person everyone went to to actually translate it and so forth.
21:43 Speaker 04 It's a fabulous story. So this is the founding myth of North America based on not one but two enormous fakes. So tell us the second fake.
21:54 Speaker 05 So having successfully, as it were, defrauded the world of the plate of brass. It was a very simple thing to go and defraud the world with this Dare Stone, as it became known. And the story goes that a few months after the opening of the play, a fruit dealer, a grocer basically, was wandering in the forest up the Chawain River, which is the Albemarle Creek, behind Roanoke Island, collecting hickory knucks, where he stumbled upon this quartzite stone with this inscription that he didn't have any idea what it was. His name was Ellie Hammond. So he didn't know what it was,
22:35 Speaker 05 but there was a well-known Elizabethan historian called Pearce, Haywood Pearce Junior, who was in Emory University, had just been employed at Emory University. He was a Dunedinite and connected, again, to the Bolton Cogery. And so the stone was taken to him to decipher, more money, change hands and so forth. And the stone, he was declared to be genuine, a great, enormous enthusiasm behind the discovery of not just one but two great Elizabethan mysteries within a few months of each other.
23:10 Speaker 03 What did they decipher? What did this bunch of hoodlums decide it said?
23:15 Speaker 05 So it's still there, you can still see the stone, and it describes how the savages had murdered all but seven of the colonists, including, of course, Virginia Dare and Anastasius Dare. And this stone was signed Eleanor Dare, basically said that, please, if anyone finds this stone, we've gone for walkers and please give it to my father.
23:39 Speaker 04 And the significance of this, just to emphasise this for those that haven't taken in this point, is that Virginia Dare is the first white girl born in North America. Is that right?
23:49 Speaker 05 Yes. So the historians have to kill her off.
23:51 Speaker 04 By savages.
23:53 Speaker 03 Kill her off by savages because she can't be in a relationship with them. She can't be sort of, you know, living with them. She can't be perfectly happy, you know, having been actually in many ways saved by them. There's no food. Dad hasn't come back. He popped off a nappy. He hasn't come back for three years. They had to do something. That story, that's not going to hold. It's got to be that they were all killed. And also, can I just also add, to have a grieving mother leave that inscription and say, please tell my father. All of it is so sort of... You know, melodramatic, it's designed to pull on the heartstrings and hate strings of anyone who already believes that these people are savages.
24:31 Speaker 04 And just to put it out there, that Vdare.com was an active right-wing blog started in 1999, backed by Trump supporters until it was shut down in 2024. So this is not some distant bit of sort of racist history. This is something that still sits at the foundational myths of of America.
24:50 Speaker 05 And Trump's ideology and the MAGA movement and underpinning notions of racism and immigration and everything else.
24:58 Speaker 03 So did Herbert Bolton go out in the dead of night and scatter this stone? Where did this stone come from, this fake stone, this piece of nonsense? Where did it come from?
25:06 Speaker 05 Ellie Hammond was actually George Hammond, who was one of Bolton's students and who actually succeeded Bolton as the curator of the Bancroft Library, the main library in Berkeley. And she's managed to prove this because she's got their signatures. So when it was handed over to Emory University, it had to be notarised. And so he signed it and she's also unearthed the signature of George Hammond. So what George Hammond did was change his earlier on the on the Tattletale driving licence, because you had to have some form of identity, and to change the Ellie to George and left the surname
25:48 Speaker 05 the same. So if you now look at these two documents, you immediately realise that it was George Hammond who was masquerading as this fruit dealer in cahoots with Hayward Pearce, who then validated the whole thing. So the three of them were involved, Bolton, Pearce and Hammond in this conspiracy.
26:07 Speaker 03 Look, we're going to take a break, but what we have here is a conspiracy fraud. It's extraordinary.
26:12 Speaker 05 Historical conspiracy.
26:16 Speaker 06 Life is all about making decisions. Sometimes you make questionable ones. Like buying a new TV that's too big for the wall because the electronics store employee was a little too good at their job. Then sometimes you make great ones. Like protecting your home and auto with Progressive. You get customized coverage options so you can be sure you have the right coverage. Get your quote today at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers, not available in all states.
26:45 Speaker 02 They're running a cover two defense. But you're running to get game day deals on Uber Eats. Keep everyone at tonight's watch party fed with deals from your go to restaurants. Or stock up with deals on your favorite snacks and groceries. Whatever the occasion, get game day deals on Uber Eats all season long. It's not football without food. Uber Eats, order now. Terms apply. Product availability varies by region. See app for details.
27:16 Speaker 07 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot, designed to keep you connected, powered by Verizon's 5G network. And no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month. Or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
27:49 Speaker 04 Welcome back. So Mark, tell us about the unmasking of this. Because I mean, presumably this is a massive deal. If this is the foundational moment of America and all these racists have muddied the waters. Is it your work or who has found?
28:03 Speaker 05 So Melissa's been doing most of the work. She lives in Oregon. And she's got on to this really by trying to unearth the plate of brass for who was actually behind it. And then realized that the darestone was perpetuated in a couple of months of the plate of brass. The two frauds must be related. I mean, she's just published this in the North Carolina Historical Journal. I should say, after enormous trouble, that all the Californian historical journals now all rejected this research and refused to publish it. So even today, there is a sense of racism in historical circles in America.
28:42 Speaker 03 But on what grounds? So let's, let's just do the thing that I do, which is let's look at the other side. What is the reason that they are giving for rejecting it? Are they, you know, just saying, no, this is just completely unacceptable for which reason?
28:54 Speaker 05 They didn't give any reasons.
28:55 Speaker 03 So she shows them the signatures, she shows them the licence, she shows them all of that, the timeline, everything is there and they say, well, no, we don't want to have a look at it.
29:03 Speaker 05 That's right.
29:04 Speaker 03 That's it. Okay. Now we need to dig into your dirt a bit more because.
29:08 Speaker 05 I would, I wouldn't advise it Anita.
29:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, and he's a friend, he goes, I'm not going to do that. But can we talk about the excavation at Cape Creek Village and what that taught you and how you back up Melissa's findings?
29:22 Speaker 05 And the darestone had just put everyone on the wrong track. So I thought, well, actually, the way to find these lost colonists is to excavate Native American villages of the right period. And then see whether we can find material culture associated with the Elizabethan colonists in the, as it were, midden, the rubbish heaps of these Native American villages, very simple methodology. And they have huge middens, metres high, full of stuff, lots of shells, lots of bone and everything else, all in these places. So the Cape Creek site was a particularly useful and important one because it was occupied until around 1700. So as we went down through the layers, you know, archaeologists go down horizontally, going down through time.
30:05 Speaker 05 The first thing we noticed in the 17th century levels was these were Native Americans, they were living with lots of Native American pottery, timber buildings, all that kind of thing, although we noticed persistently stuff that only Europeans would have. So we, for example, had pins, dress pins, we had dress clasps. Not impossible though, that these could be traded. That's right. And in fact, we have really good evidence for trade because what we found was three coin weights dated 1643. And these are weights that peddlers, ad chinran traders would carry around with them to work out the, as it were, the purity of a coin.
30:48 Speaker 05 So you put a coin weight on one side of a balance and a bit of gold or something on the other and you could, you could work out its value or its authenticity or whatever. So we had, we found three coinways. So clearly they were in contact with Jamestown. We found brass, for example, sheet brass that was clearly coming in as part of these imports. We found lots of beads, which are also part of this trade, but we also found gun barrels, musket balls that they were making. We found presumably evidence for gunpowder. We found the fact that they were shooting deer because we could see the fracture marks on their deer bones. So they had firearms, they were wearing European clothes, but they're also Native Americans, clearly.
31:32 Speaker 04 And what's the nature of the settlement that you're digging? I mean, are you digging a settlement? Or digging a midden on the edge of a settlement?
31:37 Speaker 05 Oh, we're digging both. So we dug the settlement area, which was an area full of post holes.
31:42 Speaker 04 Implying something more substantial than wigwams, you're saying?
31:44 Speaker 05 Yes, absolutely. No, no, these are very substantial buildings that they're putting up and being rebuilt on new occasions. There's almost too many post holes to actually work out the plan because they're all one on top of another, as it were. And then behind of the age of the sand dune is the midden deposits where all they threw all their rubbish down. So some of these artefacts are found in the settlement.
32:06 Speaker 04 And for an archaeologist, finding a midden, just for those who haven't worked on a dig, is the gold dust because that's where you find all the leftovers and all the goodies.
32:14 Speaker 03 Yes. Imagine that our rubbish will be, hope for God willing, if we're allowed around that long. But they'll be digging around in our trash as well to tell our story. So just think of that when you throw stuff away. That's what's going to happen.
32:25 Speaker 05 So absolutely. So, so everyone was saying, oh, no, it can't be because they are, you know, they could trade it from Jamestown. They like European clothes. The site is quite unlike any other Native American sites in the region.
32:37 Speaker 04 And the post holes, are they implying something quite different from other Native American sites? I mean, are they rectangular buildings as opposed to sort of round?
32:45 Speaker 05 They're probably rectangular buildings. We get evidence of daub, for example.
32:50 Speaker 03 Which is not what the Native Americans did, it's what Europeans did. So I mean, that's, that's the conclusion that you're finding is that, you know, look, this is so specifically English. It isn't as a result, you know, trade doesn't explain that, doesn't explain the post holes, doesn't explain the construction of these buildings. It doesn't explain the things that we're finding here. That's right, isn't it? I'm just trying to make it very clear that that's what you're saying.
33:12 Speaker 05 Absolutely. And we do have one historical, I know you being historians who like history, there's one historical account written by somebody called John Lawson in the early seventeen hundreds, who travelled along the Outer Banks. And he described the people on Hatteras Island as people who could read from the book, who had grey eyes and wore European clothes.
33:35 Speaker 04 But were basically, in his view, Native Americans.
33:39 Speaker 03 Oh, mixed race.
33:40 Speaker 05 And he describes also how they have this story about this ghost ship called Water Rally that was wrecked upon these shores. And so it's all garbled, and it's a hundred and twenty years later, a garbled version of the arrival of the lost colonists.
33:57 Speaker 03 So as you're, as you're finding this stuff out, and your heart must be beating faster and faster and faster, and you, Melissa, must be getting into, you know, a frenzy of phone calls about this stuff. Are you getting pushback even then from people saying, you know what, no, we can explain this. This is, this is trade. This is something else. This is, I don't know what you're, why you're drawing these conclusions. Talk a little bit more about that. I mean, what was that like?
34:17 Speaker 04 And is it from your society or people outside the, the society that you've set up? Who, who is pushing back?
34:22 Speaker 05 It's basically the, the North Carolina, I must say too frankly, but there have been various other attempts to look for the site on the Albemarle, the Chowan River, right next door to where the Dare Stone was discovered. And this is the famous Site X, and there's a, an organisation called the First Colony Foundation that's been doing investigations and has claimed to have found late sixteenth and seventeenth century material in the Albemarle on this mysterious and unlocated site called Site X.
34:53 Speaker 04 Just so I understand, these guys have found material which indicates what? What's their theory?
34:59 Speaker 05 Well, they found pottery called borderware, which is the type of pottery that dates from the late sixteenth into the late seventeenth centuries. It's made in the Surrey borderlands. Surrey Sussex border. It's green glazed pottery and it's found all over Jamestown and so forth, for example. And it's a bit of a sort of evidence of European settlement. The trouble is you can't date borderware. Between these dates, there's very little typological change between the late 16th and into the 17th century. And we know that a later columnist called Nathaniel Bat was very active in this area in the 1640s. So there's no reason why, you know, that stuff isn't, as it were, a generation, two
35:42 Speaker 05 generations later than the date that they claim.
35:46 Speaker 03 I've written down a thing which I need to ask you about, a hammer scale. Can you tell me what a hammer scale is and why it's significant?
35:51 Speaker 05 So we're happy at this point to say, well, okay, it could be trade, it could be settlement, we haven't found the smoking gun, everyone says the only way you're going to ever find it if you dig up a burial and do the DNA. But we have strong ethical issues about that. Digging up Native American remains is very tricky for all sorts of ethical and legal reasons in America.
36:15 Speaker 04 But you haven't actually found the Native American remains, or you think you know where they are?
36:19 Speaker 05 Well, let's say that there have been records of them on the island in the past, but one wouldn't want to go hunting for them for ethical reasons. So, you know, that particular line of argument is certainly closed down to us. Other people have tried to look at modern DNA, but of course, finding, as it were, a direct ancestral link back to the lost colonists, we're using ancestral DNA is also rather hard, given the scale of English settlement that's happened since the 17th and 18th centuries.
36:48 Speaker 04 And also the difficulty of dating at what point any intermarriage, if it did happen, happened.
36:53 Speaker 05 So we were basically hanging around for smoking gun. And this came about this last summer in one of these famous buckets of deposits. So we'd excavated through the 18th century, 17th century layers, through a great big thick shell midden that contained no European material in it at all, or maybe a little bit of daub.
37:16 Speaker 04 Which, again, just to clarify, shell midden is the mussels or the oysters or whatever they're eating. And so you have a bunch of people living on the coast, just putting their shells on the edge of their rubbish dump.
37:25 Speaker 05 That's correct. And then underneath that, we found a pit. So the good thick set of properly sealed, underneath that we found a pit. And in that pit, Scott, when he went through the buckets, found hammer scale, huge quantities, significant quantities of hammer scale.
37:41 Speaker 03 Not all of us know what a hammer scale is, so come on, explain.
37:44 Speaker 05 So hammer scale is the bits of metal that come off when you strike iron, bar iron or reworking, it's basically, if you go to a blacksmith shop, the floor will be covered in hammer scale. As you strike the iron, little bits, little splinters come off.
38:01 Speaker 03 Shrapnel, it's blacksmithing shrapnel. Okay, got it.
38:04 Speaker 05 And it looks like scales of a fish, really, but metal, and it's magnetic. So you can spot it really quickly, you put a magnet on and out the stuff comes. To get hammer scale, you have to heat the iron red hot, almost white hot. So you have to have a furnace, you have to have bellows, you have to really do intense, as it were, metallurgical activity.
38:25 Speaker 03 None of which is indigenous.
38:27 Speaker 05 None of which is indigenous.
38:28 Speaker 03 Wow, okay.
38:29 Speaker 05 And so this cannot be traded because this is hammer scale as a result of smithing activities. And we're very certain, we've got radiocarbon dates, that this pit has radiocarbon dates from the late 16th, early 17th century.
38:44 Speaker 04 This is very, very exciting. This is, this is as close as you can get to that smoking gun.
38:49 Speaker 05 So the presence of metalworking in the late 16th, early 17th century. So whoever was there was working. Now, one of the sites we excavated early on, which is another late 16th century site, contained a slab of bar iron. We know from Richard Hacklet's discourse on colonial plantations, that they would have taken this bar iron with them, they would have taken blacksmiths with them, they would have taken shipwrights and so forth, all of whom would have been metallurgists.
39:20 Speaker 04 So just to, again, clarify, so Hacklet is writing, in a sense, a kit that colonists take out with them, and it's a to-do list, or what you must pack if you're.
39:29 Speaker 03 Flat pack colony.
39:30 Speaker 04 Exactly.
39:31 Speaker 03 That's what it is, isn't it?
39:32 Speaker 04 Exactly, yeah.
39:33 Speaker 03 I am just blown away by this. And this is in the last year, you found all this stuff?
39:38 Speaker 05 This is the last year, yes.
39:39 Speaker 03 Bloody hell.
39:39 Speaker 05 So a combination with Melissa's brilliant work on the Darestone, and the fact that we've got, you know, this smoking gun evidence. In there with the clear evidence that they're making iron, they're forging iron. Of course, the next question is why are they forging it, which I'm sure you're going to ask me.
39:56 Speaker 04 Why are they forging it?
40:00 Speaker 05 So this is really intriguing. Well, maybe to make nails, to build their houses.
40:04 Speaker 04 And do these post holes come with associated nails?
40:07 Speaker 05 We find a few nails in the deposits, so that is possible.
40:11 Speaker 04 And they're European style nails?
40:13 Speaker 05 Well, they're nails.
40:17 Speaker 03 Got a pointy bit and a bit to hit. Okay, all right, okay.
40:20 Speaker 05 And so the really intriguing thing is, are they actually making nails for shipbuilding? And this is the really exclusive idea.
40:27 Speaker 04 Europeans down there.
40:29 Speaker 05 Europeans, but were they actually? They, all they had was a couple of what are known as penises, which are like sort of large yachts really, in size, you know, 10 metres long, something like that maximum, certainly not.
40:40 Speaker 04 How do you, how do you know that? Because from the nails?
40:42 Speaker 05 From historical sources. So we know they were left with two penises. And they could easily have disassembled those penises, because of course it had all the nautical kit on it, and rebuild the plenty of sources of oak on the, on the islands and so forth, and could rebuild there in order to escape. And of course, if they might then have been lost at sea, we have no knowledge, obviously, they never made it to any historical sources. But you think this is odd, but we have two very well documented cases of a people abandoned who then build their own boats to go home. Both actually in 1609, the Sea Venture, these were the people shipwrecked on Bermuda.
41:25 Speaker 04 Bermuda was meant to be rather improbably a Puritan colony, wasn't it?
41:30 Speaker 05 That's right, but it was discovered in this shipwreck, these people who were resupplying Jamestown in 1609. And they realised that on this uninhabited island was wonderful, but you know, they want to get home. So they then built a ship, salvaged what they could from the Sea Venture, and build a ship and sail back, said on to Jamestown.
41:50 Speaker 04 So Mark, rewrite the story then. So we, we start with the story at the beginning of this episode of colonies left on Roanoke Island. And when the, finally, the, the rescue fleet comes, there's no one there and they've disappeared. Now, in your version, after what you've dug and what you've found, what's your best guess for what happened to these guys?
42:12 Speaker 05 So they load all their stuff on board these small boats and go to Hatteras Island. They have good reasons why they want to go to Hatteras Island. And it's where Manio, who was their great supporter, he was a Native American. And he came back, he met Queen Elizabeth, was brought back to England. He was bilingual, he spoke Algonquian language, but also he spoke English, he was baptised. And he was their great friend and supporter. And he was the chief or sub-chief of the tribe of the Croatoans on Croatoan. And so the key thing about Cape Hatteras is that it sticks out into the Atlantic. So any ship that's coming back to Europe has to go past Cape Hatteras.
42:55 Speaker 05 Because it sticks out, you've got the Gulf Stream that comes out and then goes eastwards across the Atlantic. So Cape Hatteras is exactly the place where you want to go. Because you can sit there on the huge sand dunes, look out to sail, light a fire if the English are coming to rescue you. Robinson Crusoe stuff. Exactly, absolutely. So you've got friendly Native Americans who'll look after you. You light your fires, you have lookouts watching for ships coming. If it's Spanish, you go and hide. If it's the English coming to rescue you, you go and light a big fire.
43:26 Speaker 03 Okay, so I've had this question in the back of my head, it's now going to come out of my mouth. Indians have oral history. Is there an oral history that talks of settlers coming in to an Indian village and assimilating with the local people? I mean, these stories get passed down for, you know, hundreds, thousands of years. Is this story in the oral tradition anywhere, in any of the tribes, anywhere near this place?
43:50 Speaker 05 Not really. It's obviously in Lawson's account where he picked up the oral history in 1700. But it seems that the Croatoan Indians were largely wiped out in the course of the 18th century. They played a part in the French Indian Wars, they were resettled. And there's a tribe called the Lumbe who live up in the interior of North Carolina, who claim descent from the lost colonists. But we suspect that it was probably mostly created in the 19th century to give their As it were, an advantage to the English authorities so they could get better education and so forth.
44:28 Speaker 04 And Mark, what is your strategy now? If you found that there's great institutional inertia rejecting your findings or ignoring your findings, are you planning to do a documentary, write a book? Because this is a really important discovery.
44:43 Speaker 05 Yeah, absolutely. We did a documentary which recently was shown on PBS for the Discovery Channel, was then shown on PBS, but that was pre-Hammer scale. So I do think that time is now right, that we need to tie in this whole interpretation, the racist misinterpretation and the reluctance in even modern America to accept that the old first English were assimilated into Native American communities. I mean, it rewrites the origin history of America.
45:16 Speaker 03 I am shook and I am, seriously, this is, this is an extraordinary story. And we are, we felt kind of privileged to have you on so soon after the event to talk about these, these things. Look, it is always such a great privilege and we're going to have you on to talk about the Panama Canal as well, because that's another place where you've been a diggin, but some extraordinary stories have come from that. But thank you so very much. That's about it from us. Until the next time we meet, it's goodbye from me, Anita Anand.
45:46 Speaker 04 And goodbye from me, William Durumpo.
46:28 Speaker 02 But you're running to get game day deals on Uber Eats. Keep everyone at tonight's watch party fed with deals from your go-to restaurants. Or stock up with deals on your favorite snacks and groceries. Whatever the occasion, get game day deals on Uber Eats all season long. It's not football without food. Uber Eats. Order now. Terms apply. Product availability varies by region. See app for details.
46:54 Speaker 08 Now at Kroger, your points add up to more ways to save every trip. Use them your way to take dollars off groceries at checkout or save at the pump. You can even save up to $35 on your next fill-up. Same points, more choices. And with low prices on fresh, quality food, plus digital and personalized offers tailored to how you shop, your dollar goes further. Redeem your points online or in the app. Kroger. Fresh for everyone. Restrictions apply. See site or store for details.
Previous 271. Canada’s Dark Secret: Stolen Children, Unmarked Graves, & Survival Stories (Ep 5) Next 273. Panama’s Brutish Conquistador Who Found The Pacific and Lost His Head (Part 1) Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated