Pod Insights Empire: World History 254. Victorian Narcos: Fire Monkeys, Iron Gunships, & Peasant Warfare (Ep 8) About this episode Who won the First Opium War? Why did British troops feel guilty about their role? What treaty led to Britain taking control of Hong Kong?
Anita and William discuss the tragic imbalance of The First Opium War, and the traumatic ways in which Chinese citizens responded to the humiliation it entailed…
Empire Club: Become a member of the Empire Club to receive early access to miniseries, ad-free listening, early access to live show tickets, bonus episodes, book discounts, our exclusive newsletter, and access to our members’ chatroom on Discord! Head to empirepoduk.com to sign up.
You can get started with a 3-month trial for only £5 at https://historytoday.com/empire
For more Goalhanger Podcasts, head to www.goalhanger.com.
Email: [email protected]
Instagram: @empirepoduk
Blue Sky: @empirepoduk
X: @empirepoduk
Assistant Producer: Becki Hills
Producer: Anouska Lewis
Senior Producer: Callum Hill
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 9,115 words · 10 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Hi, this is Gary Lineker from Goalhangers, the rest is football. This episode is brought to you by Wise. It's only when you start moving money between currencies that you really think about the exchange rate, the fee, and what might be hidden away in the small print. Whether you're living abroad, paying someone overseas, or just trying to manage your money across borders, you want a fair exchange rate, an easy transfer, and no surprises along the way. Wise keeps things simple. Wise is a smart way to move the currencies you need around the globe. It works in more than 160 countries and with over 40 currencies. Most transfers arrive instantly. Wise uses the mid-market exchange rate, like the one you see on Google, with no markups or hidden fees.
0:44 Speaker 00 So when money needs to move, you can see the rate, know the fee, and get on with it. Join millions saving billions on hidden fees by downloading the Wise app today. Be smart, get wise, Ts and Cs apply.
0:58 Speaker 01 A BetterHelp ad. Your brain has limited storage, so why is it still holding on to that embarrassing moment from years ago? That tough breakup? The conversation with your boss you keep rehearsing in the shower? If you could permanently delete one thing from your brain, what would it be? BetterHelp is an online therapy platform that gives you space to talk about what's taking up too much of yours. BetterHelp is now in-network with more than 125 health plans, with many copays as low as $15 for eligible members. And if you don't have eligible insurance or live outside the US, you can still get 10% off your first month. Sign up and get 10% off at betterhelp.com/empire. Cost and coverage may vary.
1:44 Speaker 02 Hello and welcome to Empire with me, Anita Aron.
1:48 Speaker 03 And me, William Durumpel.
1:50 Speaker 02 Yes, and you join us in the midst of our Victorian narcos opium war series. And thank you very much for all your kind comments about this. I'm really glad you're enjoying it as much as we are. Shall I just remind you where we were at the last episode? So we left you with the nemesis, fabulously named, ironclad sort of suit of armour of a ship that's been sent by Palmerston. I think William described it like a stealth bomber last time that is going to be used against the wooden ships of the Chinese. So the British invade China on the pretext of protecting free trade. That's what they're arguing. Actually, the plan has been entirely formulated by this duo, this dynamic or dire duo, Matheson
2:33 Speaker 02 and Jardine, who has managed to find himself a tiny corner of Palmerston's office and is whispering into his ear constantly that, you know what, if we actually go for this, we can get quite a lot out of this. Hong Kong, for example, this island that actually nobody very much cares about, could be yours. It sits at the mouth of the Pearl River. And then, you know, we could attack Canton and we could get the ports and, you know, nothing could stop us. And then Beijing is just on the horizon. So all of this is being murmured into Palmerston's ear and he is being charmed by it, even though there are others saying this is not the right thing to do. So that is why the nemesis is chugging its way over to China. And you've got Charles Elliot, who we talked about in the last episode, who's this rather,
3:16 Speaker 02 I mean, sort of nervous and indecisive, but quite a decent man, I think, who is in charge of British trade in China. And he's trying to keep the peace as best he can and trying to stop lives being lost. And everything that poor old Charles Elliot has had to say is is being either ignored or mocked. And when he offers to diffuse the situation by buying up the opium of these traders who are otherwise reaching for guns and it's all going to get very, very ugly, he will get into trouble for that as well, because it is a cheque that he's writing that he has no right to sign, $6 million worth of a cheque.
3:54 Speaker 03 Which, as we discussed last time, is this extraordinary sum of money. Elliot sort of wildly says, oh, don't worry, I'll pay for it. And then the Brits find themselves with this enormous loss that they've they've promised the opium traders, particularly Jardine and Matheson, that they're going to reimburse their entire opium stocks, which is a considerable sum of money. It's an enormous bit of the British annual budget. $6 million at this time is a lot of money. The British basically end up going to war to try and get that money back.
4:24 Speaker 02 Get it back. Can't pay, won't pay, first of all. I don't know what this is all about. And, you know, actually, can we just put an end to all of this nonsense? Because we need to be able to do this trade because we need the money. We're paying too much to China for tea. We need to make some of it back. So let's just do something about it. Now, take us to where the nemesis is and how the whole of British diplomacy is, or a change in British diplomacy is sailing with it.
4:48 Speaker 03 Before I actually talk about the events, I should talk about the wonderful book that I've been reading to learn about this. There's a lot of books on the Opium Wars and opium in general. And we talked previously about Stephen Platt's wonderful book Imperial Twilight. We're going to get Stephen on in the next episode. And there's also Amitav Ghosh's extraordinary new book, Smoke and Ashes.
5:11 Speaker 02 Smoke and Ashes is fabulous.
5:13 Speaker 03 But the great book for the actual course of the first Opium War, particularly on the diplomacy and the fighting and the detail of different characters like Elliot and Commissioner Lin, is Julia Lovell's book, The Opium War: Drugs, Dreams and the Making of China. What she's done in this book is to give the Chinese side as well as the English. Because obviously, the people like Jardine and Matheson, they're writing diaries that we can all read sitting in the records office. And particularly Jardine's archive is in the Cambridge University Library. And anyone that wants to research it can just go there. But much less accessible is the Chinese records. And Julia spent many decades of her life reading the Chinese records.
5:54 Speaker 03 And what you're going to hear over the next hour is very closely based on Julia's extraordinary new research. No other account goes into the detail or has the extraordinary depth of understanding of what's going on in China at this time and the Chinese sources. So I have hugely, hugely enjoyed this book and recommend it every bit as strongly as Stephen Platt's and Amitav Ghosh's. So the story begins, as we said, with with the nemesis. The course of the open war is very different from many other imperial wars. If you think of, I mean, I've written about the war in Afghanistan, which is taking place at exactly the same time, eighteen forty two, the year that the open war reaches its climax, is also the year that the troops of the first Afghan war are massacred on their journey back to India.
6:39 Speaker 03 The two things are happening side by side. And you could not imagine two battles which happen more differently, because while the Afghan story is is extraordinary story of triumph by the Afghan resistance, and these guys not only managed to drive the British out, but to massacre every last soldier that comes into the country. The course of the war in China is the exact opposite. There are virtually no British casualties, sitting in their ironclad dreadnought, almost, this this nemesis, this stealth bomber, one hundred and eighty four by twenty nine foot iron steamer, specifically commissioned for the war in China, and which arrives in time to fight it with iron sides, accurate guns, a very shallow draft to allow it to go up
7:24 Speaker 03 the rivers. And it has a massive psychological impact, because whatever the Chinese do, they they're constantly sending firejunks down to try and burn the British ships. And you can't burn, you can't burn the nemesis. It's this incredibly unequal war. And the British, who are, you know, very much up for a good imperial fight at this period of their history, are longing for, in the Victorian way, for blood and glory, find themselves disgusted by the open war, not just because it's morally questionable whether there's any need or right to go to war to sell drugs, that at the time is very consciously realized by many of the participants, but also the fact that the Chinese really have no protection against the British weaponry of this period.
8:08 Speaker 03 The Afghans have their long Jazails, sort of sniper rifles, and they can sit at the top of their mountains with greater range than the British brand best muskets. And so the British are on the on the back foot in Afghanistan. But it turns out that the Qing Chinese army is completely unprepared for for war. In the way that the train sepoys of India are ready to fight and discipline fighting force. And particularly the navy, because this is a naval campaign as much as anything. You have the Nemesis, this fleet of British ships, they're sailing up a river. It's rather like, you know, remember Heart of Darkness, when those dreadnoughts are sailing up African rivers and sort of shelling randomly into African jungle. There's a bit of that in this war.
8:49 Speaker 03 It's just these these terrible ships that the Chinese can't deal with in any way, reeking destruction and occasionally gorging out troops into the countryside to commit massacres.
9:00 Speaker 02 So, I mean, we've talked about this and, you know, China's inability to respond. And it's partly it's the tech, you know, the Brits have got the tech with this ironclad ship. But it's also partly, you know, China's always sort of looked, it's had such a vast empire, which is sort of contiguous, and they haven't had to sail over water to get to their bits of their empire, you know, it's just a massive landmass. So naval concerns have not been their concerns for for years and years. And so this is just completely, you know, wrong footed them entirely. It just hasn't been a thing that they've been developing.
9:33 Speaker 03 It's a very good point you're making, Anita. They don't have a navy that's designed to fight other navies. What the navy's been doing is basically policing pirates. And so it's more like a coastguard is the Chinese equivalent of the coastguard that's there to stop the selling of opium. And then, and then when the opium payments and the money begins to pour into China, this is one of the forces that is completely corrupted by the opium trade in that the captains of these coastguards just take bribes to let the, what are called the crabs, these very fast oar ships that can dodge into into creeks and pick up opium from Western ships on islands like off Hong Kong, and then dive down the the different waterways and smuggle it into
10:17 Speaker 03 the centre of China. And from the beginning, this starts off as a naval campaign. And we left you, I think, on the on the last episode, when in the first big conflict of the first opium war, the British attacked Zoshan Island, and there's this massacre of the ships. Followed by a massacre on land. And this continues and the British continue to demand the money from the Chinese government that they're not willing to pay. War finally breaks out again and eighteen forty one, at the beginning of the year, we see this the Nemesis engaging with the Chinese fleet at the mouth of the Pearl River.
11:00 Speaker 03 And I'll read an account of what happens in that first conflict because it kind of sets the tone for everything that follows. So this line of Chinese war junks is blocking the Nemesis at the mouth of the river. And then the Nemesis brings its Congreve rockets into range. We were talking in our last bonus episode about Tibu Sultan. This is an Indian technology, the use of war rockets, which is adopted by the British and then then put into action.
11:29 Speaker 02 When we're saying rockets, we're talking about sort of repurposed fireworks in a way, are we? Or are we talking, yeah, that's what it is, isn't it?
11:36 Speaker 03 Fireworks with with fuses.
11:38 Speaker 02 With added boom. Yeah, okay.
11:40 Speaker 03 The Nemesis has these Congreve rockets, which are the British version of Tibu's rockets that Tibu has used in war in seventeen ninety nine against the British and a guy called Congreve brings them into the British Army and they now are very popular as weapons in the Navy. One of the British sailors called Captain Hill sets off these Congreve rockets into the line of war junks blocking the British path into the Pearl River. And he describes one of the junks, it blew up with a terrific explosion, launching into eternity every soul on board and pouring forth its blaze like a mighty rush of fire from a volcano. The smoke and flame and the thunder of the explosion,
12:26 Speaker 03 with portions of disheveled bodies scattering as they fell, were enough to strike with awe the stoutest heart that looked on.
12:35 Speaker 03 And I think both sides are incredibly shocked by this. No one has expected, I think it's been a bit of a fluke that obviously one of these congreve rockets has landed in the gunpowder of one of the warjunks, but the whole thing has just gone up.
12:46 Speaker 02 The explosion is tremendous, and I love that line, you know, sort of launching into eternity every soul on board. And well, the number of souls that we're talking about, it's an hour and a half that they're facing off against each other and fighting them. This huge explosion happens. And the Chinese lose two hundred and eighty people, four hundred and sixty two are wounded. So this is absolutely a bloodbath on the water for them. And the English, in comparison, they have thirty eight wounded and not one single death, not one person dies on the English side. It's not even David and Goliath. It's like a steamroller just rolling over the Chinese efforts to defend their own territory.
13:22 Speaker 03 And in terms of ships, eleven warjunks are destroyed, one hundred and seventy three Qing cannons are removed or spiked or captured. And the damage to the Nemesis is a little damage on her paddle box. That's all that happens. So the Chinese discover at this point that there's almost nothing that they can do. Once you're in the Nemesis sailing up the river, they have no defences against this. So the plan that Jardine has come up with is very simple. They've got to go back to Canton, which has been the foothold that the, where the British and the American and the French factories are all sitting on the riverbank.
13:59 Speaker 03 And as we know, and as we've discussed in earlier episodes, for a hundred years, these European factories have been sitting there doing business, initially buying tea, but more and more getting involved in the opium trade. The British and the French and the Americans have never been beyond the factories. They're not allowed into the city of Canton even. They're stuck in this tiny little sort of no man's land on the river. And what we see as their first plan of attack laid down by William Jardine in Palmerston's War Office is to capture Canton. So on the twenty fifth of February, the British arrive at the outer defences on the river. And these are the forts upriver from Canton on the edge of the city.
14:43 Speaker 03 I mean, it's a sort of tragic and it's almost comic horror story. The Chinese, in order to try and scare off the Brits, arrange for the garrison, which is not as large as it should be, to go round and round the hill, but they have to change their clothes on each circuit. So the Brits think there's more of them than there are. So they walk round and round with different coloured clothes on.
15:05 Speaker 02 In Home Alone, Macaulay Culkin does a similar thing with sort of cutouts in the window, just to make it look like there are more people at home than just him. This doesn't work. But, I mean, apart from the people changing their clothes, the Emperor does take this very seriously and is starting to mobilise troops because eventually there will be some 17,000 troops from seven different provinces who will converge on Canton because he knows as well, this is a prize, this is a jewel, this is a port that has marshalled an enormous amount of trade, not just in opium but in other things, and he can't afford to lose it. So, yeah, at the beginning, it's almost comical in his lack of of men and having to look like they're much more muscular and there are many more of them than there
15:48 Speaker 02 were. But, you know, he's not taking, he's not taking it lightly. He knows what what's at stake here.
15:53 Speaker 03 And he's actually put down three million ounces of silver, which is a considerable fortune to fight this battle. Anyway, by the 21st of May, the nemesis is sitting off the factories. Now, you may remember from the last episode that the British had withdrawn and the other, all the other Americans, everyone else had withdrawn from the factories, leaving them empty and they'd been looted and gutted by the people of Canton. So, on the 21st of May, the nemesis arrives off the factories to this, this place where the British have been for a hundred years, and they find utter silence. The factories have all been looted, there's no one around. And as they park their ships off these looted
16:34 Speaker 03 factories, and as night comes, they suddenly realise that there is an attack being planned on them. The Chinese have got all these fireboats, these junks and rafts, and they're all stuffed with oil soaked cotton. So the first move that the Chinese have is to wait until the right time. The current is at its height and they let these flaming ships out on the British fleet. Of course, not yet relating that the Nemesis is made of metal.
17:04 Speaker 02 This is their answer to torpedoes, isn't it? I mean, it's just to get them as close as you can and let them blow up and take as much out as they can.
17:11 Speaker 03 Exactly that. And then, at the same time, the Chinese have hidden among the the ruins of the factories and Canton houses opposite. All their artillery. So just as darkness comes and the fire ships begin to float towards the the British fleet on the Ebb Tide. A whole load of artillery opens up from hidden positions. So it looks as if it's quite a a serious defence. They they've planned for this and and the British have walked into the trap. But of course, it all starts to go wrong. The fireboats drift in the wrong direction and and and don't get anywhere near where the British ships are parked.
17:51 Speaker 03 The British unload troops, which immediately put out the artillery. The first skirmish has taken place. The next day is Queen Victoria's birthday, so they they begin with a a high noon salute on the twenty fourth of May. And then two thousand three hundred British troops, most of whom are actually sepoys sent from British India. Storm around Canton. And remember, this is a city they've never been allowed to enter in all the time that they've been trading there. And they tramp over the rice fields and the burial grounds on the outskirts of town, dragging these four enormous howitzers. Field guns and powder guns and lots of more concrete rockets onto the hill.
18:35 Speaker 03 Zuxian, the mountain of transcendent excellence, which overlooks Canton. And for the first time ever, the British look down onto Canton. They've never been able to see beyond the walls. You can't see over the walls when you. For a hundred years, there's just been the same picture that that all the the Brits who are there take back of of the walls of Canton. Now they get onto this hill and they're looking down and they prepare on the twenty seventh of May to shell the city of Canton, which is full of people. It's it's a city of a million people. It's an enormous metropolis.
19:05 Speaker 02 Forty thousand Qing troops against three and a half thousand East India Company sepoys. So, you know, the numbers seem to be in favour of the Chinese, but not if. The East India Company, sepoys, have howitzers at their command. So as soon as the howitzers start fighting, there is absolute disarray. You can just imagine it, this constant thud, thud, bang, bang of the cannon. And one of the descriptions says, "The cannon did not fall silent for a single moment." That's from a Chinese source. "When night fell, the fires burned as bright as day. Neither officials nor soldiers dared come out to help. All you could hear was the noise of burning and death."
19:46 Speaker 03 And the next morning, the infantry think it's their moment to actually charge into the city and take the city in a full-scale assault. And they're just revving up, getting ready for this, getting their tot of rum before running down the hill into the gates of Canton, when a single rather plump British officer is spotted blundering his way through the paddy fields, announces that the Chinese have backed down. They're going to pay a $6 million ransom. They're going to withdraw their troops from Canton. There's no need for the British to take this city by rape and plunder.
20:24 Speaker 02 Haven't they just blown it to smithereens, though, with the sounds of screaming?
20:27 Speaker 03 They've already killed many, many people by artillery, but there's not actually going to be bannets in the city walls.
20:31 Speaker 02 So there's a really interesting story about the bloke blundering to give this message. Because couldn't he have got there a lot earlier? But he got lost.
20:39 Speaker 03 That's right.
20:39 Speaker 02 And he had to sleep in a paddy field. So he goes to sleep in a paddy field. And I wonder whether, if he would have got there just a tiny bit earlier, whether, you know, the bombardment might not have gone on as long as it did, or, you know, the loss of life went on as long as it did. So what happens then?
20:54 Speaker 03 So then there's an example of what, you know, could have been if the Chinese had got their act together a bit more. Because on the next day, the troops who'd been about to attack the city suddenly realise that they've got a free day off. And so the troops just run off into the countryside and swarm around the little hamlets and villages and the burial grounds with their blood up. These guys begin to get into mischief. They start opening the tombs, taking the bodies out, which obviously is a deeply offensive thing to do. And there are accusations that the Punjabis have been raping the local women. And they call them black devils in the Chinese sources.
21:34 Speaker 02 But they also say things that it is a shame to even speak of because this is a society that's so utterly outraged and deeply ashamed of what happens. But that's what happens. I mean, you've talked about this before in Delhi as well. You know, when you have sort of troops who are thinking that they've got one day of fighting and putting their lives on the line and it suddenly disappears, or they've taken a city and they still have their blood up, Roman soldiers would be allowed to go and vent themselves.
22:03 Speaker 03 Soldiers of all periods of history, tragically.
22:05 Speaker 02 Yeah, so it's horrific.
22:07 Speaker 03 British troops are now basically taking a holiday, moving around people's villages, disturbing the dead, making mischief of themselves.
22:14 Speaker 02 And just taking what they like. I mean, there's a lot of looting reported as well.
22:17 Speaker 03 Remember that there's a big difference between the Manchu Empire, which is, you know, Manchus from north of the Wall who are the government, and the local Chinese. And the local Chinese are not going to take this ceasefire as a solid thing if the British are still molesting the women and disembodied the troops out of their tombs. So the local farmers line up in a sort of peasant militia and armed with spears, shields and swords, they fall on the British troops who are not expecting any resistance at all. And so the day after the ceasefire, the British suffer a major peasant revolt in the villages outside Canton.
23:01 Speaker 03 These guys are, you know, wandering around paddy fields, smoking their charoots, having a nice time on their day off, when suddenly they find this enormous peasant militia armed with swords and shields and spears coming down on them with a vengeance.
23:15 Speaker 02 The British think, okay, there's men with spears and shields, what are they going to do? So they send a detachment out to go and get rid of them and just, you know, scare them back. Fire in the air a bit, they'll run away. But about after three miles of sort of pursuing them into the fields and trying to get them to go home or go away or kill them, there's a spectacular rainstorm that breaks out. It is a downpour that is so heavy, so torrential, it's like the sky is falling down. You can't see even just metres in front of your face. And the guns are completely useless. So you know, that advantage those British troops have is lost completely because you can't fire a gun, you're not quite as scary, you know, even if the people you're pursuing only have
23:58 Speaker 02 sticks and stones and shields. So what happens is, is that, you know, the paths are all washed out, they can't fire their guns, they don't know which way they're going because as you quite rightly said, these are places they've never been before.
24:09 Speaker 03 And they're bogged down in the paddy fields.
24:12 Speaker 02 Well, the paddy fields just, it looks like water. If you've seen the paddy fields, it's just, you know, sort of a lake with things sticking out of it. There is no land, everything seems to be, you know, covered with water. So that's when the peasants start jabbing back with a bit more success. They stop running away from these troops pursuing them and they start fighting back.
24:30 Speaker 03 And it's the Qing government who gets the British off the hook. They've signed this peace, so they suddenly turn up and tell the peasants to go back home and not to resist anymore. And this, of course, is hugely unpopular because the peasants have got the British troops on the run. And they say, since the peace is signed, you must let the foreigners go. But this, of course, is now in modern China, a major moment. It's been turned into a big visitor's centre, and it's a major part of all school textbooks, and it's called the San Yuan Li People's Anti-British Struggle. You go there today, and Julie McFarlane says there's an enormous, very phallic monument to mark this reversal of the British troops. But again, it just shows that, you know, with a slightly different
25:14 Speaker 03 configuration, this war could have gone very differently. But it remains the, you know, the Manchu imperial forces who are underarmed against the British. And the Chinese, in the sense, are actually, the local Chinese barely take part in this, in this war.
25:31 Speaker 03 So at this point, the British carry on a little bit further up the river. They take a place called Zhenhe. There are, at this point, 1,500 Chinese dead for only 16 British casualties. They then take another place further upriver called Ningbo. And at that point, they decide to settle down for the winter and hope that the Qing will give in to their demands. And I think we should take a break there, while the British are wintering in Ningbo.
26:11 Speaker 04 The Great Game: Strategic Struggle Between Britain and Russia.
26:18 Speaker 05 We assess, Prime Minister, with high confidence it was Russian.
26:24 Speaker 06 Holding the Russians accountable is World War III.
26:26 Speaker 07 They took down a British passenger jet containing 350 people.
26:29 Speaker 04 Men in the Kremlin is playing, Alex. Got to ask yourself, you want to play or not? You're the Prime Minister. You've done nothing!
26:43 Speaker 08 We would need to understand the policy context.
26:45 Speaker 04 All the relevant context will be structured as a framework today, disseminated into an operation order, or FRAGO.
26:53 Speaker 09 A FRAGO that says to kill the President of Russia?
26:58 Speaker 04 Yes.
27:00 Speaker 06 New from Goalhanger. Who is going to be able to pull this off?
27:05 Speaker 07 You're my soldier, are you? Sergeant Tom McDuff, Duffy!
27:09 Speaker 06 An audio drama journey like no other.
27:11 Speaker 07 Men like Duffy, they are our most valuable weapons.
27:15 Speaker 06 Devized as a technically rigorous geopolitical action thriller.
27:18 Speaker 07 We have two tight, friendly KIAs.
27:20 Speaker 06 Where Britain plays its strongest hand. He's the best. Against its strongest foe. Don't do it, Duffy! Bear Hunt. Available now wherever you get your podcasts.
27:45 Speaker 02 Welcome back. So just before the break, we had this sort of slightly now lionised version of a peasants revolt, where the peasants say, you know what, actually, we had enough of your nonsense, Brits, we're going to fight you back. And they're quite successful, I mean, with the help of a huge downpour in pushing the British back. But it is their leadership, it is the Emperor himself, who says, no, I've signed a bit of paper, you lot, stop that, go home, we've got to do what we've said we're going to do, and we're basically giving up. So this is a huge success for the British. But what do they do? Well, they sack Elliot immediately. So, you know.
28:19 Speaker 03 Well, we're on that. The, one of the people who, who rather disloyally does for Elliot is his own cousin, Lord Auckland. While Auckland is making his own mess in Afghanistan, he's, he's pointing at his cousin, Charles Elliot, and saying that Elliot's making an even bigger mess in China. And it's his letters to Parmaston that actually result in Elliot getting sacked.
28:44 Speaker 02 Oh, really? He's being slapped off by his own family member? Oh, that's hilarious.
28:49 Speaker 03 And Emily Eden writes these very spiky notes about him, how hopeless he is, and how slow, and how dithery, in her words. And so, poor Charles Elliot, this is now the kind of the winter break. They've got as far as Ningbo, the Chinese have, have hunkered down for the winter too. Everyone sort of realises, this is a, this is a break, and there's going to be a pause in the fighting during the Chinese winter. Elliot goes off for some fun to Macau, the Portuguese colony, which has hotels and bars and is fun, and today is famous for its casinos. And it's a place where, at this time, people go for a bit of a break. And he's only just arrived. He has a nightmare trip to Macau. I think his ship sinks, or that, and he ends up on an island, he's nearly captured by the Qing,
29:31 Speaker 03 everything goes wrong. And he finally gets to Macau, walks up the beach, and is told he's been replaced by Henry Pottinger, who's arriving in 48 hours from India.
29:40 Speaker 02 It's the equivalent of getting a text message saying, don't come in tomorrow. But, but I mean, you say it's Auckland who's slagged him off, and said he's just made a hash of this. But it is actually Jardine and Matheson who really have done for Elliot, because they have not rested. At all in slagging him off, slagging the way that he has been getting in the way. He hasn't been muscular enough. They've been telling him for ages that Canton could have been taken. Why are we, you know, sort of kowtowing to these people? Well, we just, just take it. We're, we, you know, we're much better off. So really, the opium smugglers have won this war on their own. And they've also sacked, you know, a fairly decent man when they did it. And what still bothers me is that Palmerston just believes him.
30:24 Speaker 03 I, I think it's a close parallel to Elon Musk sitting in, in Trump's office, telling him what to do. Jardine particularly, and Palmerston are, are sitting in the same room in, in, in the Foreign Office, drawing up these war plans. Poor old Elliot, who, who's got this very difficult balancing act and trying to get the Chinese to do what he wants and repay the money without slaughtering tens of thousands of innocent people. He is being slagged off. Jardine is in now in London. He's not in Canton. He's come all the way home and he's got the ear of the Foreign Minister. And that's him. That's him finished. And, and he never gets another job.
30:57 Speaker 02 He never gets another job and he always has to put up or, or, or deal with that feeling that, you know, his entire career has been reduced to ashes and everyone thinks he's a chump, even, you know, his own family. But Palmerston writes a really scathing note to him. Basically, you were useless from the moment you got there. You've done absolutely sod all that I wanted you to do. Everybody else who's done that job has done it better than you. I mean, it really is sort of like a horrible text saying, don't come in tomorrow. And there is one, I'll just, I'll conclude with one bit. You seem, Palmerston says, to have considered that my instructions were a waste of paper and you were at full liberty to deal with the interests of your country according to your own fancy. I mean, basically, you were shit. I cannot emphasise how shit you were at your job and you will never work
31:42 Speaker 02 in this town again. It's just career ending, everything ending. And that's only because he's listening to these drug dealers.
31:49 Speaker 03 Sitting in his office. And the letter ends very promptly. You will accordingly return home at your earliest convenience. And poor Elliot writes in his diary, a line from Dryden, slack all thy sails, for thou art wrecked ashore.
32:04 Speaker 03 So Poirot Elliott, who was not, I mean, relative to the rest of them, was not a bad guy. Was trying to avoid bloodshed and do the decent thing. He's someone that spent his life fighting slavers in West Africa and has been sent into this thing and is comprehensively outwitted at every stage by Jardine and Matheson, who have the ear of the powerful. And instead, he's replaced by this character, Henry Pottinger, who I know all about.
32:29 Speaker 02 You've written about him in relation to Afghanistan, so tell me about this Pottinger replacement. What does he like?
32:34 Speaker 03 So Pottinger is one of the earliest British spymasters of the great game. And he's a very important figure in the whole story of the run up to the war in Afghanistan. There are two British intelligence centres, one on the west coast in Gujarat, which is run by Pottinger, and the others in Ludhiana, run by a character called Wade. And at this point, it looks as if Wade has won the battle and Poirot Pottinger has been outflanked by his rival. And he's given, basically, because Wade's got all the glories, it seems at this point, Pottinger is now given the chance, in a sense, to show his colours by replacing Elliott.
33:13 Speaker 02 He's capable, he's very, and he's annoyed.
33:15 Speaker 03 He's annoyed and he's very bullish. He's a big man with sort of button chop whiskers and is a much tougher, more blimpy character than Elliott, who's quite a sort of Christian and wants to save civilian lives. Pottinger's absolutely no worries at all about sacrificing hundreds of thousands of Chinese in order to get the money for the opium back. As I say, he's got a name to prove because he's been outflanked by his rivals in the service and his former protege has now got a knighthood. And he's longing to make his name by being tougher than Elliott. And on the Chinese side, there's also been a turnaround. Commissioner Lin, who, as we saw in the first episodes of this series,
33:56 Speaker 03 is the most capable and wonderful of all the Chinese civil servants, who completely outflanks Elliott and gets all the opium surrendered to him, who hasn't put a foot wrong. He now takes the can for the loss of Canton and he's sacked.
34:13 Speaker 02 Is it just a very short line? Noisy.
34:14 Speaker 03 Again, it's a very short note.
34:16 Speaker 02 Oh, really?
34:16 Speaker 03 And in the way of royal dynasties, um, the emperor, rather than sending another commissioner Lin, another man who's spent his entire life passing exams and rising to the top of the service and performing uh exemplary service for the emperor. Instead, of course, it goes to the emperor's nephew, who's a man called Yi Jing. And Yi Jing is is the worst possible choice for this job. His only, his only position prior to prior to taking on the the British army who are halfway up the Yangtze River already. He's been director of the Imperial Gardens, uh, and he's a noted calligrapher and a painter, just what you need.
34:58 Speaker 02 Wow, my god, he sounds amazing for this job. He sounds so qualified. It's perfect. Does he do origami? That's useful.
35:08 Speaker 02 Okay.
35:08 Speaker 03 So Yi Jing, who I think has hardly left Beijing before, has never left the Imperial Gardens, which he loves gardening in. Uh, is sent down to the lovely um sort of riverside resort of Suzhou. Uh, and there um he decides to spend the winter. And this is a lovely place with canals and it's got lots of brothels and and gorgeous courtesans and it's a place where the educated pleasure seekers of Beijing will go for their breaks. And he spends the winter rather than, while the troops are amassing, uh, rather than making war plans, he spends it dining, drinking, listening to operas, which is a very nice, very nice touch. Uh, cultivating his rock garden and honing his poetry writing skills.
35:53 Speaker 02 So in effect, what you have is uh somebody who likes flower arranging against a really wily warhorse who already has had a pretty rough time of it.
36:05 Speaker 02 In Afghanistan and been robbed of his laurels, he feels he's definitely, definitely on the move to make his name and no bastard's going to take the credit this time. It's not a fair match, is it, William?
36:16 Speaker 03 It's not a fair match. And what makes things worse is that the Chinese officials are so afraid, in a sense, to tell the emperor the reality, that these troops have got different generations of weapons, that there's nothing the Chinese have that can take on these trained British troops. So they keep sort of sending, well, simply fantastic reports of what's going in. So Yi Jing doesn't realise.
36:40 Speaker 02 Everything's fine. We're doing really well here, Emperor. It's all fine.
36:44 Speaker 03 And it's not just that Yi Jing is doing his flower arranging. He thinks there's no reason for concern because no one's told him that there've been all these terrible defeats and the Chinese troops have crumpled. He thinks that he's absolutely on top of it. And then the final coup d'etat, as far as he's concerned, is when on the 13th of February, 700 Sichuanese aborigines dressed out in tiger skin tunics turn up. And Yi Jing is a great follower of oracles and astronomy, and he realizes that this is the hour of the tiger and the month of the tiger and the year of the tiger. And as far as he's concerned, everything couldn't be more auspicious for the attack, that this Aboriginal regiment arriving at the moment it has is a sign that the gods and the heavens are with them and they're about to send the
37:29 Speaker 03 British off to their makers. They plan an assault on the foremost British town of Ningbo, which is as far as the nemesis has got up the river. And the Chinese attack is being prepared. And again, there's this other sign that if only the Manchus had left a little bit more to the locals, there could have been a very sustained resistance. Because in Ningbo, where the British have spent the winter, they're feeling very much under assault by the locals. They can't leave the garrison. Initially, they've been putting their troops out into different little pickets around the place. And every time someone goes off for a pee behind lines, they're found the next morning trussed up with a walnut in
38:14 Speaker 03 their mouth, sort of floating in a paddy field.
38:17 Speaker 02 Oh, okay. So hang on a minute. Wait, wait, wait, wait. Trussed up with a walnut in their mouth. Is that because they've been killed or just sort of tied up? I mean, that doesn't make sense to anybody.
38:27 Speaker 03 I will read you the description. This is from wonderful Julia Lovell's description of what's going on in Ningbo. She says that a captured private was found tied up in a bag, a large walnut with hair wound around it had been forced into his mouth, the sides of which were cut open to admit it. He was quite dead. The business was repugnant to the feelings of civilized nations, commented one British lieutenant.
38:51 Speaker 02 You're right. What's interesting is if the peasants had had their way, they were actually pinning them down. They, you know, they have, they have a fight back force. Everything feels a little bit, well, I mean, not realistic. So, so you haven't got real reports getting back to Beijing. You've got a man who thinks, hey, what else do we need? Have you seen my latest flower arrangement? We don't need anything else. I've done this beautiful swan. It's a crane. It's absolutely bloody useless. And he also has people with him who are inexplicably odd as well. Can I tell one of the preparation stories, which I love so much? So this is a commander who is facing the nemesis, okay, the nemesis, which has caused untold damage and got as far as Ningbo. So one commander purchases
39:32 Speaker 02 19 monkeys. Now, why, you may ask, does he want 19 monkeys? Because he has this brilliant idea that he's going to strap fireworks to their bags and then set them loose. Fly my monkeys, fly, like something out of, you know, Wizard of Oz. Fly my battle monkeys. And that they're going to crawl all over the British ships and then blow up. I mean, it's not a very lovely story for animals, but this is the caliber, this is the caliber of fight back that is coming from imperial China, whereas peasant China is doing a pretty, I mean, horrific, but good job with walnuts and stabby things.
40:10 Speaker 03 And the poor monkeys, in the end, no one dares get close enough to throw the fire monkeys onto the British ships, particularly the nemesis, which is towering up above any of the Chinese junks. So that their keeper leaves the attack monkeys of Ningbo to starve slowly to death in his front lodge in the end.
40:25 Speaker 02 I hate that, really.
40:26 Speaker 03 That's not a nice ending to the story. But anyway, there's a, there's a three-pronged attack. Yijing has spent the whole winter planning this, and there's meant to be a three-pronged attack, not just on Ningbo, but on two other cities, Zenghai and Zhaoshan.
40:40 Speaker 03 And the idea is that thirty six thousand men will hurdle themselves on the British troops and it'll be a great victory. Of course, everything goes wrong. And again, it's the British howitzers that see for the Manchu resistance. They're still fighting in close packs and they're just wiped out by the British shells. The British now got this horse artillery that can move very fast around the field. They've got explosive shells, they've got, you know, the latest logistics so they can work and ballistics so they can work out exactly where to plant the shells. And so when it does come to fighting in the city, the howitzer is set up and it just massacres the Manchu resistance.
41:21 Speaker 03 And again, there's these hideous descriptions of at least three thousand Chinese soldiers just being massacred by a couple of guns. "The effect was terrific," observed one campaign-hardened officer. "The enemy's rear, not aware of the miserable fate which was being dealt out to their comrades at the front, continued to press forwards in a mass, so as to force fresh victims upon the mounds of the dead and the dying. By the time that the howitzer fell silent after only three rounds, there was a writhing, shrieking hecatoom closely packed, fully fifteen yards." So this one gun sitting in the street in Ningbo slaughters the Chinese troops.
42:06 Speaker 03 Outside the city, there's a last stand of the Qing Imperial Guard, who are dressed up in this fantastic black and purple velvet. And these guys are very brave, but they are not fighting tactics that are going to win them against East India Company sepoys. So they just sit at the top of the hill, five hundred elite Qing soldiers, and eventually the company, one thousand two hundred sepoys, surround them on all sides with their artillery, and they just shoot them dead with the shells and finish them off with the bayonets. "We sat by, helpless, watching our comrades die," writes one of the diaries of one of the Chinese survivors. "Even now, the thought of it tortures me."
42:49 Speaker 03 So Yijing has lost, but again, Dan tell his uncle, the emperor, what's actually happened. So what he reports is that 500 British soldiers have been killed, including their chief Palmerston. Palmerston's actually sitting in the war office in London.
43:04 Speaker 02 This is insane. This is insane, though. This is insane. Yeah. Palmerston's been killed. We've got him. Okay. So, so now, I mean, and what happens to the civilian population, dare I ask?
43:16 Speaker 03 So as, as before rape, Julia Lovell gives very, very detailed and very upsetting descriptions of, of a kind of mass rape that takes place after the attack on Ningbo. And then in response to the rape and the loss of the Imperial Guard, there's a mass suicide in the city of Ningbo. So the British walk into the city after this battle to find just heaps of bodies.
43:42 Speaker 02 Well, I mean, I've seen one of the accounts on this and it is just awful. So if you are of a delicate disposition, maybe do something else for the next 30 seconds. But this is an account of what a British soldier saw. He says, old men, women and children cutting each other's throats and drowning themselves by the dozen. And no one either attempting or apparently showing any inclination to save the poor wretches, nor in fact regarding them with any more notice than they would a dead horse carried through the streets of London to the kennel. That's just horrendous. That's horrific. So, you know, they, the soldiers talk about wandering through this kind of almost like a ghost town. And it's
44:24 Speaker 02 the city is, you know, it's getting darker. So it's, it is getting more and more spooky with these bodies that they're having to tread over. But in contrast to that, the soldiers also write about, you know, the fragrance of the flowers that are hanging over all these really beautifully appointed, these civilian houses, you know, so it is, it smells pretty. If you look up, it looks beautiful. If you look down at your feet is just rivers of blood. And there's another one account, I'll just read. It's, I mean, these things are horrific. We entered an open court strewn with rich stuffs and covered with the clotted blood. And upon the steps leading to the Hall of Ancestors, there were two bodies of youthful tartars, cold and stiff, much alike. Apparently brothers. Stepping over these bodies, we met face to face, three women seated,
45:09 Speaker 02 a mother and two daughters, and at their feet lay two bodies of elderly men with their throats cut from ear to ear. The hardest heart of the oldest man who ever lived a life of rapine and slaughter could not have gazed on this scene of woe and been unmoved.
45:26 Speaker 03 There's a feeling of guilt in many of the British accounts because they're aware that morally this is a very dubious war. And then there's no resistance. There's no feeling that they've won a, you know, a great victory against a well organised opponent. This has just been a slaughter followed by mass suicides of the people who they're meant to be trading with. And so there's two more cities which are captured in succession and in similar horrors. And eventually they advance on Nanjing. They capture Shanghai, which is a relatively small city at this point. Shanghai's greatest days lie ahead of it. And that doesn't move the emperor to surrender. But when Nanjing
46:05 Speaker 03 comes under the guns of the nemesis is the moment that finally the penny drops and the Qing government capitulates. And finally, on the 26th of August, Pottinger is carried, Pottinger's a large chap, has to be said, and he's carried in a sedan chair to the Chinese camp where a surrender banquet has been organised. Rather improbably, he's invited to this enormous feast.
46:33 Speaker 02 Yes, I can tell you what they ate. I mean, you know, it's going to take a while. So numerous patties of minced meat, pork, arrowroot, vermicelli soup with meat in it, pig's ear soup, and other strange dishes were served in succession. And as a coup de grâce, Keing, I don't know who Keing is, insisted upon Sir Henry opening his mouth while he with great dexterity shot into it several times immense sugar plums. I shall never forget Sir Henry's face of determined resignation after he found remonstrances were of no avail, no more. So yes, Pottinger has to, you know, leave a lot fatter. But I mean, this is also, this is, um, this is, you can't imagine Elliot behaving like this, can you? You can't imagine even at this kind of moment of victory.
47:18 Speaker 02 Basically behaving like a member of the Bullingdon Club, which is what these guys are behaving like.
47:23 Speaker 03 The Qing perhaps hoped that the British would have been stuffed to the point of insensibility, and then they start negotiating the treaty. But the demands are very clear. Twenty one million dollars in indemnity, the opening of five more ports to trade, including Canton, the British right of residence, and the setting of tariffs, a very contemporary touch. And the Chinese just want to get the business finished as quickly as possible. The Imperial Commissioners, Pottinger observes, declared their readiness to sign and seal the treaty at once without further explanation. So this is the treaty that gives the British Hong Kong. It's thanks to this that the whole subsequent history of Hong Kong takes off in the way that it does.
48:08 Speaker 02 Which the British aren't that bothered about at the time, are they?
48:10 Speaker 03 At the time, they've no idea what they've got, exactly.
48:13 Speaker 02 Oh, well, take it. But, I mean, you know, thanks, thanks a lot. Yeah, you shouldn't have. I mean, it's kind of that kind of shrugging mentality. They don't realise what they've got when they get it.
48:24 Speaker 03 So this is an odd war. At the same time, as we say, you've got the Afghans completely defeating the British in Kabul. And in Hong Kong, in the Opium War, it's a total defeat that leaves such a bad taste even in British mouths. And Eliot writes in his diary, you know, this man has just been sacked, he's lost his career, and he lets out all the feelings of this hopeless war. He says, "Our visitations are so calamitous to the wretched inhabitants, a war in which there was little room for military glory, the slaughter of an almost defenceless and
49:04 Speaker 03 helpless people, and a people which in large portion of the theatre of war was friendly to the British nation." And that humiliation still rankles and and Julia Lovell opens her book with a wonderful story, which I think is where we should conclude with November the ninth, two thousand and ten, when David Cameron and his delegation arrives to try and patch up relations with China in the great hall of the people at Tianmen Square. It's November and they're wearing Remembrance Day poppies and the Chinese officials say they're not going to let them into the hall unless they remove their Remembrance Day poppies on the grounds that the flowers evoke such painful memories for the Chinese people. So this is not dead history for the Chinese.
49:49 Speaker 03 They remember this and and although this is no longer a part of history that the British choose to remember much about, one of the most shameful, immoral and horrific wars of empire ever fought, but one which has considerable echoes and ripples into the present. Anyway, we're going to leave it there. We've got the next Opium War and looking back on this whole debacle on the last episode. And next week, we're going to get the wonderful Stephen Platon, whose Imperial Twilight is along with Julia Lovell and Amatov Gojsh, the three great books that I've so enjoyed reading while doing this series. If you want to hear that final episode now, you can join the Empire Club, sign up, get
50:31 Speaker 03 all our wonderful newsletters and all these other goodies straight to your inbox. If not, we'll see you next week and it's goodbye from me, William Derumpel.
50:41 Speaker 02 And goodbye from me, Anita Aron.
Previous 253. Victorian Narcos: Drug Dealers Lead Britain to War (Ep 7) Next 255. Victorian Narcos: From Opium To Fentanyl (Ep 9) Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated