Pod Insights Empire: World History 224. Empire in Your Garden About this episode How did plants power imperialism?
Gardening may be a quintessentially British hobby, but many of the familiar plants in our lives have a global – and colonial – history. From “fern-mania” leading wealthy Victorians to decimate environments around the world collecting ferns for their drawing rooms, to mahogany harvested by enslaved workers in the Caribbean, plants played an important role in the British Empire. Even official scientific names for plants included blatantly racist language up until the 1990s.
Over-harvesting of popular imperial products created monocultures and environmental destruction on a huge scale, and the movement of native plants across continents allowed invasive species to run riot. Yet the same imperialists who caused these problems also led the way in the early environmentalist movement, creating National Parks and protection schemes for animals on the risk of extinction.
Listen as William and Anita are once again joined by Sathnam Sanghera, author of Empireworld, to explore the ways in which imperialists both destroyed and protected the natural world.
Twitter: @Empirepoduk
Email: [email protected]
Goalhangerpodcasts.com
Assistant Producer: Becki Hills
Producer: Anouska Lewis
Senior Producer: Callum Hill
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hi, this is Gary Lineker from Goalhangers, the rest is football. This episode is brought to you by Wise. It's only when you start moving money between currencies that you really think about the exchange rate, the fee, and what might be hidden away in the small print. Whether you're living abroad, paying someone overseas, or just trying to manage your money across borders, you want a fair exchange rate, an easy transfer, and no surprises along the way. Wise keeps things simple. Wise is a smart way to move the currencies you need around the globe. It works in more than 160 countries and with over 40 currencies. Most transfers arrive instantly. Wise uses the mid-market exchange rate, like the one you see on Google, with no markups or hidden fees.
0:44 Speaker 00 So when money needs to move, you can see the rate, know the fee, and get on with it. Join millions saving billions on hidden fees by downloading the Wise app today. Be smart, get wise, Ts and Cs apply.
0:58 Speaker 01 A BetterHelp ad. Your brain has limited storage, so why is it still holding on to that embarrassing moment from years ago? That tough breakup? The conversation with your boss you keep rehearsing in the shower? If you could permanently delete one thing from your brain, what would it be? BetterHelp is an online therapy platform that gives you space to talk about what's taking up too much of yours. BetterHelp is now in-network with more than 125 health plans, with many copays as low as $15 for eligible members. And if you don't have eligible insurance or live outside the US, you can still get 10% off your first month. Sign up and get 10% off at betterhelp.com/empire. Cost and coverage may vary.
1:42 Speaker 02 Discover the new Myself Odie Toilet Intense. A masculine and long-lasting fragrance for every day. A bold scent with sensual musk and woody notes.
1:53 Speaker 02 Myself, Yves Saint Laurent.
2:14 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Empire with me, Anita Aron.
2:18 Speaker 04 And me, William Derumpel.
2:20 Speaker 03 And we are once more joined by Satnam Sanghera, author of Empire World: How British Imperialism Has Shaped the Globe. His paperback is out right now, if you want to, you know, go and get it. I mean, if you want to, you just have to. It's a great, great book. It's really interesting and it's taught us a few things as well, just chatting to him in the last episode. And just before we sort of launch ourselves on something that is more miserable, which is something you touched on in the last part, Satnam, about the classification of plants. Linnaeus, I mean, I actually didn't realise, also classified human beings. Just remind people who may not have listened to the last episode of what Linnaeus did. I think a little recap of that would be interesting.
2:58 Speaker 04 Yeah, Linnaeus was a prominent botanist of the 18th century. He created the modern system of classifying plants and organisms, crucially, because he classified plants in this very clever way, but he put humans into the classifications according to their geographic origin and skin colour. Decided that Europeans were great, Africans were crafty and indolent. And this is the way in which botany helped to reinforce imperial racism. And it's, yes, it's a deeply controversial subject.
3:29 Speaker 03 This, this kind of classification is a, is a real thing. I mean, when I did Patient Assassin and I was talking about Sir Michael O'Dwyer, who was the lieutenant governor of Punjab at the time, he loved classifying people, like plants. And he went through the different sort of tribes, as he called them, of the Punjab and gave them all sorts of like sort of three line and none of them really very lovely. I mean, I think there were sort of two sets of people he quite endured and the rest, you know, they drink too much, they fall over, they're crafty, you know, all of those kind of words. But they were presented just like the biology classifications I studied at school. So it is, it is a real mode of thinking that you put people in boxes, like you put plants in boxes.
4:08 Speaker 04 And it continues now. It shapes because those people decided, for example, that certain people were martial races, including. Sikhs, as you can tell from our physiques, we're not, right?
4:18 Speaker 03 Speak for yourself. I could have you. I could have you in a fight.
4:22 Speaker 04 But it's so such a powerful idea that a lot of these people, like the Punjabi Sikhs, still see themselves as a martial race. And they're not. They're just people.
4:31 Speaker 05 And that's just the tip of the iceberg. There was a book published in eighteen sixty eight called The People of India. And it is an enormous, great sort of ethno-biological study. And it contains photographs of all the different castes and tribes of South Asia, ranging from Tibetans and Aboriginals right through to the Doms of Bihar. It is sort of, you know, to our ears, completely and astonishingly racist. The image with the label "The Mohammedan", it is illustrated by a picture of an Aligarh labourer who's given the following caption. It's, "His features are peculiarly Mohammedan and exemplify in a strong manner
5:12 Speaker 05 the obstinacy, sensuality, ignorance and bigotry of his class. It is hardly possible perhaps to conceive features more essentially repulsive." Now, that's a direct quote from this. And it goes on every single ethnic and tribal group in the subcontinent over a number of volumes.
5:30 Speaker 03 Yeah. And it talks a lot about caste identity. It reinforces caste identity, you know, that this is, this is what these people are like. And again, you put somebody in a box and it's very hard to get out of the box.
5:41 Speaker 04 That's exactly the reason Kew Gardens is full of all these samples. It's the same reason why the British Museum has so many human remains, because the Victorians were obsessed with measuring skeletons and brains.
5:52 Speaker 05 And noses and foreheads.
5:54 Speaker 04 Yeah, totally. And classifying people. It's the same ideology. And even though we've got rid of a lot of this weird nineteenth century racial science, lots of it persists. And weirdly and depressingly, some of it's coming back.
6:08 Speaker 05 What do you mean it's coming back, Salam?
6:09 Speaker 04 Well, there's some very controversial academics, one of whom was at Oxford lately, recently, who have been indulging in this racial science, who still believe there are differences between black people and white people and so on. And racial science is quite a big thing. On X, on Twitter, part of this new online racist anglosphere. People are saying, oh, we've got this brand new, you know, transatlantic anglosphere between Musk and Tommy Robinson and so on. But as I explained in Empire World, this existed in the 19th century. It's just the people involved were Rudyard Kipling and Roosevelt. They were, they were talking about weird racist ideas back in the 19th century. And Rhodes, Rhodes was a big guy for the anglosphere, wasn't he?
6:54 Speaker 04 Yeah, and you've got poems like The White Man's Burden, you know, and this is not a new thing.
6:59 Speaker 03 Can, can we bring it to, to plants again? Because I, I want to know, I mean, I, I probably don't want to know, but I, I should know about some of the names of plants that included words that we deem completely unacceptable racist now.
7:13 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean, there's different systems of classifying plants. There's Linnaeus's system, but there's also the common plant system. And until the 1990s, it was quite frequently, some plants were referred to with the N-word. You know, I could think of three in front of me, which I'm not going to say out loud. But there was also the dewbush, the caffir plums. And when you talk about decolonization, people are very allergic to that idea and that word. But actually, if it involves the eradication of those racist common plant names, I think it's an entirely good thing.
7:44 Speaker 03 Another thing that you talked about was the difficulties that some faced. These imperial explorers who wanted to bring back samples and see whether they could be refined and grown by empire in other territories. You talked about rubber and Singapore and Malay. I, I want to know about the difficulties in transportation because you were talking about a type of seed that needs to be kept moist to transport. Now, the, these difficulties that face a botanist who wants to bring back samples will inevitably lead to innovation. And they did, didn't they? I mean, the one thing I'm, I'm thinking about is the thing that you write about, the Wardian case. I'm fascinated by this. Tell us a bit more about the Wardian case.
8:23 Speaker 04 Yeah, so it's a great book by Lou Keo on the, on the Wardian case. We nowadays just assume it's easy to transport plants, right? But back in the day, in the 19th century, plants on a boat, they'd get killed by the salt. In the seawater, the heat, the darkness, being manhandled, being eaten by goats, you know, it's very hard to transport any plants. But a guy called Nathaniel Bagshaw Ward solved the problem accidentally in eighteen twenty nine. In an experiment in his own home in London, he placed a moth cocoon in a sealed glass bottle with some fern fronds and some moist soil. And discovered that the plant sprouted and thrived without being watered for three years.
9:03 Speaker 05 Really?
9:04 Speaker 04 And this led to the creation of the Wardian case, which is a portable.
9:08 Speaker 05 Named after him.
9:09 Speaker 04 Named after him, a portable glass sided wooden or metal container that contains a kind of controlled environment for plants to thrive in. So, you know, the case creates a regulated atmosphere like a modern terrarium, keeping the plants hydrated and healthy. The glass allows them to receive sunlight, there's ventilation to keep out the rodents. And you've got battens to kind of hold the plant into place. And this object appeared in the Great Exhibition in eighteen fifty one. And the historian Lim Barba described it as probably one of the best investments the British government has ever made. I mean, it totally transformed plant transfers.
9:50 Speaker 04 And the Wardian case was how tea was moved from China to India to establish the Assam and Darjeeling tea district.
9:58 Speaker 05 Something we're going to be dealing with in in our Opium War episode. Because of course, it was the deficit in British finances that the popularity of tea drinking created, which needed a solution. And the solution was selling opium to the Chinese in order to be able to pay for the tea.
10:15 Speaker 04 The Wardian case involved in that, the rubber industry, the plants were transferred from Brazil to Asia with the Wardian case. Moving bananas to the Pacific Islands and Central America and the Caribbean, that was the Wardian case. And also smuggling the cinchona plant from South America to India was also the Wardian case. So this, I don't know if you've ever seen one, I saw one in Kew Gardens.
10:35 Speaker 03 I I've seen it only because I looked it up after after reading about it through you, but describe it, I mean, just.
10:41 Speaker 04 It's kind of like a crate, yeah, I saw one at Kew Gardens, it's like. A crate, a bit like a Fortnum and Mason hamper. I'm saying that because I'm looking at a Fortnum and Mason hamper.
10:51 Speaker 03 You're so posh. You've changed. You've changed, Sangara.
10:56 Speaker 04 We remembered when you were a Wolverhampton boy.
10:58 Speaker 03 When you ate out of a tiffin on the beach like the rest of us. Yes, go on, like a Fortnum and Mason hamper.
11:04 Speaker 04 Like it's wooden or metal and it's got glass, it's got holes in it's, um, yeah, it's a box, but incredibly simple, but changed the shape of the planet. Incredible.
11:15 Speaker 03 Would you have had ships just filled with Wardian cases or it was part of a voyage? So try to imagine how this this all worked.
11:22 Speaker 04 Yeah, they'd obviously be on the deck because they need sunlight, right? Um, but yes, and it'd be a constant battle to make sure that they weren't disturbed or the glass wasn't broken and so on. But it was still easier than actually trying to transport plants in the old way.
11:37 Speaker 03 I mean, we, we, we thought about tea and we are going to talk about tea and opium a lot more in this series, but I, I want to know about some of the other plants that are lesser known now. Guta Percha, am I saying it right?
11:49 Speaker 04 Guta Percha, I've got some here.
11:51 Speaker 03 Oh, what is it? So it looks like a squash ball. It looks like a squash ball. It's black and round. Is it squishy?
11:57 Speaker 04 Actually, it's a 19th century golf ball.
11:59 Speaker 03 Oh, right.
12:00 Speaker 04 Yeah, Guta Percha, very important, is a natural thermoplastic and it was found in a tree found in Malaysia and Indonesia. And the gum was extracted by killing the tree and extracting it. And you might have some in your teeth because it's still used in dentistry today.
12:16 Speaker 03 For fillings.
12:17 Speaker 04 Yeah, but crucially, it made golf balls, but also more importantly, it became a vital component in waterproofing telegraph cables. So Guta Percha made telegraph communication, Morse code, speedy news reporting, international communication possible. So this one plant changed the way in which empires were managed, the way wars were waged. Incredible. And also the, the, the places where these wires, cables were laid are also where the cables are still laid because they chose the shortest route. So you could say this plant is the foundation of the modern internet.
12:55 Speaker 03 And when you say, I mean, we sort of gobbled up the explanation as it were, but you know, you said it's in your mouth because this stuff is used for fillings because it is waterproof. It's a sealant and even now, even now they use it.
13:07 Speaker 04 Though it's not used that much now for things, mainly because people went crazy about it. And they they over harvested it. And it's all but but it's all but forgotten, they got a perch. I mean, we don't even know how to pronounce it. But in the Victorian era, it was a household word. You know, but the scale of the demand was such that millions of trees were destroyed. And it was one of the first great industrial ecological disasters.
13:33 Speaker 05 And where is it now? Is it in the wild at all?
13:36 Speaker 04 Yeah, it exists, but it's not really.
13:38 Speaker 03 Hardly anything.
13:39 Speaker 04 Yeah.
13:39 Speaker 03 Yeah. Houseplants. Now, looking around, I think this will be really fun for people who are listening to this while they're doing the vacuuming. Or, you know, thinking about folding up laundry or all the things, all the wonderful things that you share with us that you do while you're listening to it. If people were to look around their house, I'm just thinking of like household favourites. So a lot of people have ferns, cheese plants. What are their their origin stories?
14:02 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's the thing. We see a lot of these plants as intrinsically British, but almost all of them came from the empire. So fern mania convulsed 19th century Britain. Became very fashionable to display ferns, actually in warden cases.
14:15 Speaker 05 Really?
14:16 Speaker 04 But there was a massive downside to this. So people were taking ferns from around, from Australia, from America and so on, bringing them back and causing huge damage just so they could have them in their drawing rooms. And the other great imperial plant in the in the household was the palm. You know, Queen Victoria famously introduced the palm into her residences and it became a symbol of empire. Rudyard Kipling uses the palm as a symbol of the empire in one of his famous poems.
14:41 Speaker 05 Was that part of her trip to Kew Gardens, you mentioned in the last episode, when she when she spent three trips to go and see the Palm House?
14:48 Speaker 04 Yeah, it's possibly related. But yeah, I mean, palm was not only beautiful, it's an industrial super product. So that became a symbol of empire. But then the biggest thing changed was in gardens. And obviously, you know, most of our plants in our gardens come from elsewhere. The Romans gave the British grapevine. The rosemary came in the 14th century. But in the 18th century, everything changed because of two men, a man called John Bartram and a man called Peter Collison. John Bartram was in America, was in Philadelphia. Peter Collison was in London and they came up with a scheme called Bartram. Boxes. And so you would order a crate for five guineas and it would contain around a hundred varieties of seeds and dried plant specimens.
15:32 Speaker 04 And through this scheme, we had introduced to Britain plants, including the magnolia, rhododendrons, mountain laurels, azaleas, sugar maples and sumac. So these plants, which are now seen as very British, actually came from MPA.
15:46 Speaker 03 I mean, azaleas and rhododendrons, I've been through many a posh house garden and, you know, they have little walkways filled with these enormous azaleas and rhododendrons in full bloom.
15:56 Speaker 05 All brought in from the Himalayas.
15:57 Speaker 04 Yeah. And actually, one of the people who bought in rhododendrons was Joseph Hooker, who was one of the directors of Kew Gardens. And he set up some very famous rhododendron gardens in Scotland, which are still thriving today.
16:10 Speaker 03 I mean, did they get enormously, eye-wateringly wealthy on the back of this? I mean, as you talk about fern mania and this desire to have, you see them in wealthy houses, as I say, azaleas and rhododendrons. Does it make them a lot of money?
16:22 Speaker 04 It's more that rich people spent absolute, the equivalent of millions of pounds of growing these plants. I don't know what the equivalent would be. I don't know, having a robot, if you're very rich, or having a Rolls Royce. Like, they were such status symbols in stately homes.
16:40 Speaker 05 And did people go and collect them themselves? I mean, if you were a landowner on the west coast of Scotland, would you make a trip to Bhutan or to Sikkim and get your rhododendrons and azaleas? Or did you just get a Bartram box?
16:52 Speaker 03 You get a Bartram Collinson box to do it for you?
16:55 Speaker 04 If you were relatively ordinary, you had the boxes, but if you were rich, you probably employed botanists. If you were the East India Company, you hired Joseph Banks or William Hooker to do it for you.
17:05 Speaker 03 Another plant, or rather, tree, which I'm not that familiar with, but everybody was mad for it at one time in Victorian England, is the Jamaican lace bark tree. Now, first of all, what does it look like? What is it?
17:16 Speaker 04 I've seen, I've seen a sample in Kew Gardens, actually. It's basically a tree. The only way I can say it, it's a tree, when you cut through the bark, it's got lace inside. It's incredible. It's like, got a doily inside it and it's. It grows to around thirteen or thirty feet. It was already found in the rocky crevices of Jamaica's mountains, but the Victorians who loved anything lacy went crazy for it.
17:41 Speaker 05 I'm just looking it up now. It's extraordinary stuff, isn't it?
17:44 Speaker 04 And so people used it to make hardware and clothing. People made whips out of it for enslavement, doilies and fans.
17:52 Speaker 05 Anti-macassas.
17:53 Speaker 04 Charles the Second was said to have been sent a suit made entirely of lace bark. And it was presented as a wonder material, again, at the great exhibition of eighteen fifty-one. It was a bit like graphene. I mean, you've got this bark where you've got a cloth inside. So it saves you a lot of the hassle of having to create a cloth.
18:12 Speaker 05 What, you just cut it? You cut it very thinly or is that how it works or?
18:16 Speaker 04 You take away the outer bark of the tree very carefully and it reveals inner layers. And it's like a net-like in structure. And then you soak that in water to soften it, to make it pliable. And then you stretch it and you can make amazing things or you can layer it. It's very lightweight, very breathable, very unique. And people went absolutely crazy, a bit like Gutter Percher. And guess what happened?
18:39 Speaker 03 Yeah, they killed it off.
18:39 Speaker 04 Over-harvested it, killed it off.
18:42 Speaker 03 Although, I've just had a look at one of these posh websites that sends pot plants to your home, a little bit like, you know, the bartram boxes. And you can buy lace bark trees for your home.
18:52 Speaker 05 We can all get mail-order lace bark, can we?
18:54 Speaker 03 You can get mail-order lace bark trees for thirty-five pounds. You can get a young lace bark tree. Also, I just wanted to explain one thing that William said, because this is something that if you're posh, you know all about it. And I only found out about it quite late in life. But an anti-macassar. This is a sort of a doily that goes on the back of a sofa. So that if you've got heavily brule-creamed, oiled hair, you don't stain the material.
19:15 Speaker 05 Or in a trains famously. All British Rail trains used to have anti-macassars on the back of the seats so that people travelling with oiled hair would not wreck the furniture.
19:25 Speaker 03 No, it was quite an advanced age when I learnt about this because, you know, in India, nobody cares and every seat is stained quite thoroughly.
19:32 Speaker 05 If not with, if not with that, with pan all over the walls and the floor.
19:36 Speaker 03 Yeah, nobody cares. Okay, so that's the Jamaican lace bark. And it also appeared at the Great Exhibition and the Great Exhibition, again, of 1851 is such an interesting place because it's a shop front.
19:48 Speaker 05 To be able to take a Tardis back there, wouldn't you?
19:50 Speaker 03 An amazing thing. It was, it was not only a flex, an imperial flex of look how powerful we are, look at what our reach is, but it's a shop window to say, look, this is something, you know, like the latest robot vacuum cleaner, this is what you really need in your life. And people would come, you know, I think it was one third of the population of Britain goes through the doors of the Great Exhibition and, you know, they, they would see things and suddenly covet them because if they were in there, in this, the greatest shop window on earth, also entirely made of glass, like, like the Palm House of the last episode at Kew Gardens, and you would want it. So these crazes, you can find their roots stretching into the soil of the Great Exhibition.
20:29 Speaker 05 The kind of world I grew up in, in, in Scotland, still had these, these plantings of trees, azaleas, rhododendrons, but also things like giant hogweeds, which we sort of take for granted and are now kind of virtually native.
20:43 Speaker 03 Giant hogweed is what?
20:45 Speaker 05 Giant hogweed comes from New Zealand originally.
20:47 Speaker 03 What does it look like for those who haven't seen a hogweed?
20:49 Speaker 05 It's, it's like a sort of, sort of giant cauliflower, but it's, it's, it's something that is one of those Victorian plantings and you see all over Victorian houses, all over the, particularly the west coast of Scotland. And same with rhododendron plantations. It's extraordinary to imagine that it's a foreign plant.
21:07 Speaker 03 No, I know. It's stately home.
21:09 Speaker 05 Azaleas.
21:10 Speaker 03 It's so at home in the stately home. Absolutely right. Absolutely right. Look, let's take a break here and when we come back, let's tackle the prickly problem of the prickly pear.
21:40 Speaker 06 Trifaya guselkumab, taken by injection, is a prescription medicine for adults with active psoriatic arthritis. Serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections or lower ability to fight them, and liver problems may occur. Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or need a vaccine. Imagine being a million miles away. Explore the possibilities. Ask your doctor about Trifaya. Tap this ad to see new joint data and learn more about Trifaya, including important safety information.
22:20 Speaker 07 Shop Black Friday appliance savings and get up to an extra $1,250 off select appliance purchases like GE Profile. Plus, free delivery on appliance purchases of $398 or more. Make life easier with the fridge that doubles as your personal kitchen assistant. Or upgrade your laundry room with the Ultra Fresh Vent System Plus Front Load Washer. So your clothes stay fresh after every single wash. Shop Black Friday appliance savings with fast free delivery at The Home Depot. Offer valid November 4th through December 2nd at participating stores and at homedepot.com. U.S. only. See store online for details.
22:55 Speaker 03 Welcome back. Now, it won't have escaped your notice that, you know, whenever you're traveling through an airport, and, you know, some, some countries are far more militant about this, you know, you can't even bring a sandwich in or a piece of fruit without getting jumped on and having to throw it all in the bin or declare it. But you bring a non-indigenous plant into a country, you have every prospect of spreading mites, disease, destruction, or indeed overwhelming a native population of plants and animals. You get all of these, you know, warnings not to do it. This must have happened, Satnam, when you have these clever cases and clever means of transporting. There is no way you can ensure that you don't have, and probably you didn't even have the
23:37 Speaker 03 science to know, what diseases and mites you're bringing along with them.
23:41 Speaker 04 Precisely. I mean, we've talked about all these plant transfers and it's very innovative and exciting. But at the same time as you're transporting live plants, you're also sending pests around the world. And the biologist Richard Mack said that the results of the 19th century nursery trade were both beautiful and disastrous. And it's the same now. So, you know, a large, a third of the invasive arthropods in Europe were introduced by the live plant trade. And in Britain, nearly 90% of the invertebrate pests first arrived on live plants. And this was part of the story right from the beginning. So when we started transporting plants, we started transporting problems. So one of the most damaging was
24:26 Speaker 04 coffee rust, which devastated the coffee plantations of Ceylon in the late 19th century, causing losses of up to 2 million pounds a year. And live coffee plants from British Guyana and so on were thought to have introduced the fungus. And so the planters had to turn to other crops like tea, rubber, and cinchona. And there was another cautionary tale in the prickly pear, which is this cactus found in Mexico and southern states of America. And it was introduced to Australia in 1788 by British colonialists. And it's prickly pear, I don't know if you've seen it, it's edible.
25:03 Speaker 03 I mean, it's sort of the red thing, you know, when you've got the fork shaped cactus, you've got the red fruit, which is also quite spiked growing on it. That's the prickly pear, is it?
25:11 Speaker 04 Yeah, and really good for cattle feed. Problem is, it spread incredibly quickly, and it swamped farmland. And so by 1925, it covered more than 60 million acres.
25:23 Speaker 03 Where did it cover so much territory?
25:25 Speaker 04 Australia.
25:26 Speaker 03 An Australian, gosh, it's a bit of Australia, right?
25:28 Speaker 04 Farmers just had to abandon the land. But it's also a rare example, and they almost completely solved the problem. They found that if you introduced the cactoblastis moth...
25:40 Speaker 04 This moth will lay eggs in the prickly pear and destroy it. So they actually managed to, it's a very rare situation where they managed to solve the problem.
25:51 Speaker 03 Yes, I know. Famously in Australia, they imported rabbits to feed people. The rabbits took over. Myxomatosis becomes a thing. They introduced the dingo, which then very happily starts taking over and eating livestock and stuff. You know, there are unintended consequences.
26:06 Speaker 05 And here, I'm talking from Delhi, but next week I'm going to be in Jaipur. And when you go to Rajasthan, the single most common plant in this grub around Rajasthan is mesquite, which comes from Mexico. And this was specifically brought in by the Maharaja of Jodhpur, who scattered seeds from his tiger moth plane. The botanical name is Prospis juliflora. And it's become this sort of, it's eaten up Rajasthan.
26:35 Speaker 04 Wow.
26:35 Speaker 05 Suits Rajasthan so well.
26:37 Speaker 04 Have you been, William, to St Helena?
26:40 Speaker 05 Never have. I'd love to go to St Helena.
26:42 Speaker 04 Because, you know, it's interesting. It's also where Napoleon ended up. But it's the ultimate example of what could go wrong. Because there were three phases of destruction by the different colonists. So first of all, the Portuguese introduced goats. I know you're a big fan of goats, William.
26:58 Speaker 05 I love goats, yeah.
26:59 Speaker 04 But they thinned the vegetation to the point of leaving the soils on the slopes very vulnerable.
27:05 Speaker 05 But they also fertilized it.
27:06 Speaker 04 Yes. Always a defender of the goat.
27:09 Speaker 03 He is. I mean, your honour, there's no talking to himself, ma'am. With goats and pigeons, you're going to lose. Just give it up. Okay, so they deplete the soil.
27:16 Speaker 04 Next, you had the East India Company, who set about chopping down all the trees for cooking and heating and making booze. And finally, you had the alien plant introduction by the British imperialists, many of which became highly invasive. So St Helena is a microcosm of what can go wrong. I'd love to go there to see.
27:37 Speaker 03 Is there any estimate of how many species were lost during that time of imperial planting and supplanting?
27:44 Speaker 04 I think it's impossible to really measure this stuff. But St Helena is a good place to study it because it's an island, isn't it? So it's a discreet entity where you can monitor it. The thing is that when you introduce plantations in particular, these one crop economies, you make the the nature very vulnerable because you need diversity for a healthy environment. And so whenever you introduce sugar plantations or cinchona plantations, you create huge environmental problems. And there were so many other things that the British did. They stopped the 18th century tradition in Australia of burning, controlled burning in southern Australia.
28:23 Speaker 04 They oversaw the cutting down of oak forests in the Himalayan regions of India and replaced them with pine plantations for resin. And obviously, dry pine needles become a cause of wildfires. Barbados was used to the point of utter erosion, the deforestation of Guyana, the West Indies, 60% of New Zealand's forests destroyed.
28:48 Speaker 05 Another example, not in the British Empire, but in the Stalinist USSR, is great swathes of Uzbekistan, where they had monoculture of cotton. And the entire cotton for all the Soviet armies was grown in Uzbekistan. So Stalin was very clear that it should be taken as a as a kind of national priority to keep this cotton coming in and growing more and more. And when you go to the area around Kiva and northern Uzbekistan, you pass miles and miles and miles of dead earth. And it's not desert, it's earth which has been killed by monocultures. And it is biologically dead. There's nothing you can do with it. And there's miles and miles of it. It's very, very striking.
29:28 Speaker 04 Mahogany is a very interesting one, because we all go to these stately homes and marvel at the mahogany furniture. But it was harvested from the Caribbean. And these mahogany forests were, you know, pulled down to the point of near extinction. And we don't make that connection between the beauty of these 19th century drawing rooms and the environmental destruction that we caused.
29:49 Speaker 03 So I mean, you you can sort of credit this monoculture with the awakening of Gandhi. I mean, he comes from South Africa. He wants to go and do a tour of India to get to know it before he'll get involved in the in the Congress movement. And he comes across the indigo farmers in Champai. And in Bihar in nineteen seventeen and he just sees, you know, look, they're forced by the British to grow indigo on fifteen percent of their land, give their entire crop as rent to planters and then harvests fail and they are starving. And this is the thing, just looking at those beleaguered farmers who are not allowed to grow the things that they need, awaken something in him. So, you know, there are so many stories, I mean, more stories than you'd think linked to this sort of imperial botany.
30:33 Speaker 05 The best example for this, we're going to be dealing with is obviously opium, where opium was was a crop forced on farmers throughout Bihar, a same area. And it led to not only famines, but obviously to the addiction, as we said in an earlier episode, to thirty percent of the Chinese population. And I I've just come back from Vietnam and I had no idea that the opium industry was also the main lure in terms of money for the French going into Indo-China. And the opium harvests in Vietnam and in Cambodia and in Laos paid for about thirty to forty percent of French imperial costs.
31:13 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, it's astonishing. We'll we'll do a big thing on on the opium wars. We will do much more. I just I'm just coming back again, circling back. I've got this sort of image of these enormous acres of of Australian land being colonized by these huge Mexican cactuses, holding up their little prickly pears in the air defiantly. But just thinking of some of the places which must have lost so many of their own indigenous plants and things and therefore indigenous knowledge and medicine and, you know, these things that stretch back thousands of years. I mean, you said it's really impossible to know what is lost, but has anyone started doing a study of what has been lost?
31:53 Speaker 04 I think you raise something very important in that we marvel at the accomplishments of some of these imperialists, but almost everything they did, all the knowledge they got came from indigenous people, you know? So, cut up perch, I mean, that was being used in Malay for canes and handles way before the Westerners discovered it, you know? And as you know, with the story of tea, you know, the Singapore people were drinking tea. Underneath the eyes of the British, who didn't realise, and the British dismissed them as kind of tribal nomads with no sovereignty over their land, and overlooked their use of tea plants. And when it came to rubber, there were people in South America who were
32:33 Speaker 04 using it way before the West. And one of the things I saw at Kew was a rubber item made in 1817 by South Americans. I mean, South Americans were using rubber for balls, torches, containers, even for helping with bruises and hemorrhaging, you know, way before the West came. And then, of course, you've got quinine and cinchona. And historians think that actually indigenous people were using this drug way before the West arrived. So we need to acknowledge that the indigenous often were ahead of the West.
33:08 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, 100%. Those are the ones that we know about that caught people's eyes. But the ones that they, you know, weren't interested in or didn't, you know, compute in those days that are now lost as a result. I'm just thinking about the number of times I've heard, you know, the depletion of the Amazon for, again, growing a monoculture of wood and trees. It's possibly wiping out things like cures for hideous diseases that will be lost forever, which exist in those enormously diverse places. You know, we're never going to bring them back because we don't know what we've lost. Again, these things are complicated. Two things can be true at the same time because Britain has
33:48 Speaker 03 done a great deal to conserve seeds from extinct species. And seed banks are just one enormous contribution, I think, to the future. I think I mentioned this before, and thank God they're doing it.
34:00 Speaker 04 And biological collections.
34:02 Speaker 03 Exactly. You know, sort of saving these things until we're in a position to bring them back. What do you make of this kind of paradox of also being the saviors of environment with these seed banks, but also, as you say, having depleted it all to begin with, with imperialism, whether it's British imperialism, Portuguese, or wherever it is from?
34:19 Speaker 04 Well, I guess you've got to the heart of my argument I make in Empire World in that opposite things are often true at the same time. British Empire was involved in slavery and antisemitism. Slavery, it spread the free press and press censorship, but it also it destroyed the environment. But also, British imperialists were involved in the birth of environmentalism. They saw what was happening in Saint Helena, they saw what was happening in Australia, and they acted upon it. You read some of these accounts from people like even Benjamin Franklin, I know he's a friend of the show, from certain nineteenth century scientists, and they're observing basically the greenhouse effect. And they then do things about it. So one of the earliest initiatives
35:02 Speaker 04 for soil and forest preservation in the colonies began in Saint Helena. You know, with the East India Company, starting environmental policies. And this is something that Peter Frankopan picks up on in his great recent book on on the environment, you know. The Bombay Forest Conservancy in eighteen forty seven was set up to solve the problem that the British had caused. And soon similar policies were taken up in Australia and Canada and South Africa and so on.
35:30 Speaker 05 And you get national parks too, don't you, being introduced quite early on. Seventeen seventy eight in Tobago, the Tobago Main Ridge, which is sometimes said to be the earliest forest reserve in the in the world, spreading to America Yellowstone National Park in eighteen seventy two.
35:47 Speaker 04 Banff in Australia, national parks in New Zealand, and we see national parks as, you know, they're definitely imperial creation as an intrinsically good thing, except they were created because the imperialists had caused the problem in the first place. And often, when they're set up, the indigenous people were often blamed for the problems, and also the indigenous people living there weren't allowed to live their lives as they wanted to. You know, because they were restricted by these environmental policies. So increasingly, even in the twenty first century, people are seeing national parks as a very problematic thing, as a contradictory thing.
36:21 Speaker 05 You have this paradox in India today, again in Rajasthan, where I'll be next week. There is this tension between trying to save the tiger and the problem of keeping out the villagers who live in the parks. And in the nineteen eighties, nineties, a lot Of the killing of tigers was being done by villagers who resented being kept out of the parks. So they'd leave poison. This happened at a place called Sariska. They'd leave poison so that the tigers would be killed, so they'd then be allowed back into the the empty parks. They saw the tiger being turned in a sense into their enemy as as an agent of their own exclusion. And that has now been worked through and they found ways of of not banning the villagers from collecting wood and and so on.
37:05 Speaker 05 And harvesting the parks in the way they need to harvest it.
37:08 Speaker 04 Yeah.
37:08 Speaker 03 I I think when we say parks, I mean, a lot of people will have in their minds sort of manured parks. We're talking about wildernesses of great swathes of tree filled fauna filled land, which is untouched, largely untouched, or should be untouched by by man.
37:23 Speaker 05 Sutton, and one thing we haven't talked so much about is the extinction of animals. I mean, famously, the dodo was one of the first examples of an indigenous animal which imperialists wipe out. Madagascar, I think, was the place where dodos were wiped out. Give us other examples of of imperial extinctions.
37:42 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean, you could think of any animal that is at risk today. And the British and German and European colonists were hunting them to near extinction in the 19th century. There was a massive hunting craze. Hunting memoirs would sell hundreds of thousands of copies.
37:57 Speaker 05 Whenever you go to one of those old hill station houses, you see these libraries full of unread books of so and so's exactly that. The hunting memoirs of pigs sticking in Meerut and days with the tigers and and and Nantital and this sort of thing.
38:12 Speaker 04 But then the British and the Germans start panicking because these animals are no longer available. So they set up protection schemes. I mean, there was an organisation, it's called Flora and Fauna International still working now, set up at the time to preserve animals. And it's a huge paradox. So I see with the royal family, the royal family now are very keen on protecting wild animals in Africa and India and so on. But they literally, the royal family were involved in these hunts. They were involved in helping to make these animals go extinct in the first place.
38:42 Speaker 03 But as were the Indian monarchs as well. I mean, I've just come back from a tour of a wildlife park where there are. Tigers, not many. There's elephants, again, not as many as there should be. And you go to the lodge where you can stay in this place. And it's the Kibani Park, if anyone's wondering, amazing place, amazing, amazing place. You sort of stay in these hats and the main Maharajas, what was formerly the Maharaja's Hunting Lodge, has just got so many pictures on the walls of Maharajas on massive hunts. And then inviting, you know, the local collector or the local governor when the British come along. But there's this history of just basically blowing the bejesus out of animals, which goes back even to the Indian Maharajas. I mean, they do it as well.
39:25 Speaker 05 It's a long history. When I was doing the Golden Road, looking at Indian imports into Europe, ivory is probably the single most lucrative import and live elephants. And on the Red Sea harbors at Myas Hormuz and Berenike, which are the two really important Roman ports where Indian and Ethiopian and Arab sailors would land and where Roman ships would leave from, the births for the ships there are 20% larger than the ones in the Mediterranean coast. Why? Because they were bringing in elephant transports, both for military use in the Roman armies and for hunts in the circuses, the Colosseum and so on.
40:04 Speaker 05 So tigers and elephants. And in Sicily, there is an extraordinary mosaic from the first century at I think Piazza Amarina. There's an image in the centre of this mosaic, in this lunette, of a personification of India. And she's holding a tusk of an elephant. And she, on one side is an elephant itself and the other side is a tiger. And these are all basically images of Indian exports, which this merchant who built the villa made his fortune by selling.
40:33 Speaker 03 So I wonder if it's true to say that, you know, humans have always been shitty to animals and they haven't really cared very much about the consequences. But with the introduction of imperialism and sort of this great, almost sort of a factory of exporting and production, it just accelerates our worst inclinations and does wipe things out in a way that actually our human proclivities dented but didn't destroy.
40:58 Speaker 04 Also created a massive hypocrisy. I mean, there's, there's TV footage of Prince Philip killing a tiger in the 1960s. It was never broadcast. But at the same time, Prince Philip and his grandsons are massive campaigners for animal preservation and conservation.
41:13 Speaker 05 Those two are not incompatible. You can have come from a past of, of killing tigers and, and become a conservationist. You, you can see a progression there.
41:21 Speaker 04 My problem is they never talk about it. So the Buckingham, all these palaces are full of mahogany, ivory, animal skins.
41:28 Speaker 05 Tiger skins, yeah.
41:29 Speaker 04 And it would be much stronger, their case would be stronger if they said, look, we've got all this stuff, we're going to get rid of it and we're going to set an example and we did something wrong. And for me, in, in, in Empire World, this is what my argument ultimately is. Britain pontificates in all sorts of areas, animal conservation, environmentalism, democracy, but we rarely reflect on what we did during the empire and our patchy records during the British Empire on all of these themes. We would be a healthier nation if we acknowledged what we did.
42:04 Speaker 03 Hmm. So I mean, rather than, you sort of said two different things there. You said, you know, get rid of all this stuff in the past. Wouldn't, wouldn't it just be better to have signage, like this is mahogany that was brought over from such and such a place and this is a potted history of how that happened?
42:19 Speaker 04 Yeah, actually Prince William has talked about getting rid of all the ivory, actually, himself. Um, yeah, I think education has to be the aim. So, but we have so much talk about signage and it doesn't happen. And also, who really gets to walk around these palaces at all?
42:35 Speaker 03 Hmm. I don't know. What do you think, William?
42:37 Speaker 05 I think, I think that there is forward movement in signage. And I mean, one example is the National Trust and they've obviously gotten to a lot of controversy about it. They have started redoing their signage. I begin my book, The Anarchy, with a, a section on Powys Castle and, and how when I went there 10 years ago, there was all this stuff about this loot being, quote, gifts from the grateful people of India to Lord Clive, who they were so pleased to be conquered by. And the National Trust, subsequent to that, because so many people who'd read the book then went round. And complained, resigned it, only to have people like Nigel Biggar and history came complain about the signage. And in a sense, Satnam, you and I have all contributed
43:20 Speaker 05 to a bit of the backlash we provoked. So when you get Kemmy Badenoch or before her, Liz Truss complaining about unpatriotic historians, it's us they're talking about and complaining. You've been at the centre of it, Satnam. You've had more than than I have.
43:35 Speaker 04 Yeah, all I want them is to talk about it. I would love to hear Prince William, Prince Harry, talk about conservation and talk about the royal family's history of destroying the environment and destroying animals. And that's mainly what I want. And to have a proper conversation and to acknowledge what we did.
43:57 Speaker 03 Would that conversation involved with the acknowledgement necessarily need an apology as well? Is that what you want?
44:04 Speaker 04 I don't think apologies really matter that much. I think we are so far from where we need to be. We need to begin by talking.
44:12 Speaker 05 And understanding.
44:13 Speaker 04 Yep.
44:14 Speaker 05 Understanding what we've done.
44:15 Speaker 04 Yeah. And I think basically we need what you're doing. We need to talk about this stuff and acknowledge the history and then doing something about it, it comes much, much later, I think.
44:26 Speaker 03 Well, listen, we are delighted to have you on to talk about it. And, you know, we talk about these things week after week, but it is always a pleasure having you on. Best of luck with the wedding, if we happen not to be there, Satnam.
44:38 Speaker 05 And the book.
44:39 Speaker 03 And the book.
44:39 Speaker 05 Available in paperback now.
44:40 Speaker 03 Yes, indeed. And until the next time we meet, it's goodbye from me, Anita Anand.
44:45 Speaker 05 And goodbye from me, William Durhample.
45:24 Speaker 01 Life is all about making decisions. Sometimes you make questionable ones. Like buying a new TV that's too big for the wall because the electronics store employee was a little too good at their job. Then, sometimes you make great ones. Like protecting your home and auto with Progressive. You get customized coverage options, so you can be sure you have the right coverage. Get your quote today at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers. Not available in all states. As wish lists grow, you know where to go. Head to Ulta Beauty. We have gifts they'll love from brands like Tato One and Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez. Shop beauty faves to give or keep from Shark Beauty, Sol de Janeiro, and more. Not sure what they want?
46:08 Speaker 01 You can't go wrong with Baumann, Clinique, or Redken. And don't forget to put yourself on the list. Book a salon moment or add a little more sparkle to your season. Shop holiday in-store or at Ulta.com. Ulta Beauty.
Previous 223. Empire of Plants: From Kew Gardens to Botany Bay Next 225. Painting the Empire: Art of the East India Company (Ep 1) Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated