Pod Insights EconTalk Will DOGE and Musk Make a Difference? (with Michael Munger) About this episode Can Musk use DOGE to reduce the size and power of the bureaucracy and big government? Michael Munger of Duke University thinks not, but EconTalk's Russ Roberts isn't so sure. Listen as they discuss the risks of empowering bureaucrats to rein in other bureaucrats and whether change can really happen given the power of the political forces operating below the surface.
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Welcome to Econ Talk, Conversations for the Curious, part of the Library of Economics and Liberty. I'm your host, Russ Roberts of Shalem College in Jerusalem and Stanford University's Hoover Institution. Go to econTalk.org where you can subscribe, comment on this episode, and find links to other information related to today's conversation. You'll also find our archives with every episode we've done going back to 2006. Our email address is [email protected] . We'd love to hear from you. Today is December 18, 2024, and my guest is economist Mike Munger of Duke University.
0:43 Speaker 00 This is Mike's 49th appearance on the program. He was last here in September, talking about Bruno Leoni. Our topic for today is the Constitution, the so-called Department of Government Efficiency, with the expectation of what will be led by Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy. And I'm sure we're going to get into many other things along the way. I want to remind listeners to go to econTalk.org and vote for your favorite episodes of 2024. Mike, I want to start with an observation about the current moment in America and see if you agree. You and I, historically at least, are what might be called classical liberals. At times, we have called ourselves libertarians. I've moved in various ways, I think, to what is closer
1:27 Speaker 00 to a conservative. And I'll confess that while much of my life has been tilting at the windmills of government intervention in the economy, I find myself less passionate about those issues. And careful listeners will have noticed this trend over the years on Econ Talk. You and I have discussed this some in our conversation about crony capitalism and in other episodes. And I've also confessed that despite the rising size of government over our lifetime, things are pretty good in America, at least in terms of material well-being and so on, for a large portion of the population. But, you know, somewhere deep down, I still have a deep skepticism of centralized power, a belief that economic freedom is essential to human flourishing.
2:11 Speaker 00 Looking back at the presidential election we just went through in 2024, fans of economic freedom, what might be called free market economics, had no home in 2024, or for quite a while before that, not in the Democratic Party, not in the Republican Party. Both sides are unhappy with immigration, eager to shore up the border. Both sides are happy to impose tariffs. The so-called libertarian wing of the Republican Party has been completely amputated by Trump. In the old days, most Republicans paid lip service to market principles. They didn't always or often ever do anything that would be called free market, but at least they would defend the ideal.
2:54 Speaker 00 Those days seem long gone. Candidates who talk about the power of markets, economic freedom, have very little traction with the electorate these days. And yet, and yet, weirdly, inexplicably, it feels to me like the most libertarian moment of my lifetime. First, we have Malay in Argentina, not an American, but he's doing great, seems to be doing great anyway. He's the most libertarian national candidate who succeeded anywhere in my lifetime, at least so far. We'll see what he ends up being, but he seems to have taken a chainsaw to government agencies and to spending.
3:37 Speaker 00 He is an incredibly articulate defender of economic principles related to free markets. And even though I said that Trump doesn't seem to have much of a libertarian streak, since the election, there are elements of this moment that are, dare I say, libertarian. First, there's a full-throated defense of free speech from many, many players, and a deep suspicion of the deep state that is a fundamentally libertarian urge, a suspicion of government power. Then there is the Department of Government Efficiency, which I hope we'll be talking about. There is serious talk, just talk for now, but there is serious talk of eliminating government agencies.
4:21 Speaker 00 There's serious talk of slashing spending. On my ex account just now, five minutes before we recorded this, Elon Musk tweeted a photograph of the government's spending bill that's about, I think it's about to pass to keep the government going. And he says something like, "Well, here's a picture of pork." This is unusual. There's a focus on the deficit. Suddenly that it's an urgent issue, something that no one on either side of the aisle in the election had any interest in discussing. What is going on? Now, you and I, being men of the world, being economists, are always going to be skeptical of what people say versus what they end up doing.
5:06 Speaker 00 But I'm kind of surprised, well, I'm very surprised, at the current rhetoric coming out of Elon Musk, Vivek Ramaswamy, Trump and others. Am I imagining this? What are your thoughts?
5:22 Speaker 01 A bunch of shocking things have happened. In the Middle East, the collapse of Syria. In Argentina, the rise and continued popularity of Javier Melé. And then in the U.S., the, for many people, unexpected, not just victory, but dominance of what you might call the Trump coalition, have put them in a position to be able to try to do things. Now, I've been a libertarian since 2004. And by being libertarian, I mean big L libertarian. I have been active in the Libertarian Party since then.
6:07 Speaker 01 We probably would want to distinguish between big L Libertarian Party people, small L libertarians, who kind of identify, and then classical liberals, which are a much larger group. But all of those people are skeptical of government. Now, it seems to me that a big problem that libertarianism has had is that it's torn between two impulses. One is to celebrate the, if not perfection, at least magnificence of markets. And the other is to point out the difficulty and in fact danger of relying on the state to accomplish things that people want to accomplish. I'm much more in the second group.
6:50 Speaker 01 And the coming up, as I have in the public choice approach to political science and economics, I've always been much more comfortable with what, and I've, we've talked about this on previous podcasts, the, uh, the pretty pig approach, that is, there is, we look at one set of processes, market processes, and we've talked about their imperfections. There's market failures, there's these problems, there's inequality, we should rely on the state. Well, wait, uh, we would want to say something about the ability of the state to carry out those functions. And there's, there's an original libertarian impulse in
7:33 Speaker 01 the American constitution, or at least the original version of the American constitution, what the constitution started out as saying, which seemed to be just a model of limited government. And by limited government, what they meant was there will be specifically enumerated powers that the federal government will be able to exercise. That's it. Only the powers that we are listing. And there were a bunch of restrictions on what the state could do. So my concern, and I say this all the time, but people won't heed it, is to me, the most important political principle is never make a sword so powerful
8:16 Speaker 01 and sharp that you don't want to see it wielded by your worst enemy right after the next election. And everyone forgets that. What they want is a powerful state to accomplish what they envision that a powerful state at the, under the control of a good person they approve of, will accomplish all of these things. All of the constitutional impediments, all of this argle bargle, all of the red tape, politics, the worst thing is politics. So they all hate politics. One of the reasons libertarians like markets is they all hate politics. But when it comes down to it, almost all of us are susceptible. To this siren song of, well, we can control the sword.
9:01 Speaker 01 We can control the ring of power. And we will, we will, we will use it. And for just a day or two, we will make things right. And then, sure, we'll revert to the, the state being weak. But for now, we need a powerful state. Everyone thinks that is the problem. I always feel like a lone voice saying, wait, stop, don't. Which is what Willy Wonka said when the fat kid was going to jump in the chocolate. Wait, stop, don't. But he didn't say it very loud. The kid jumped in the chocolate anyway. I say it loudly, people create the sword anyway. And so I'm worried that what we're, what we're on the verge of now. It's tempting to say, what we'll do is endow a powerful agency.
9:45 Speaker 01 The, the, the Doge will be able, the, the Department of Government Efficiency. We will suspend all of the usual rules. They will look through all of the different government activities. And with this enormously powerful, sharp sword, they will cut out just those things that the government shouldn't be doing. And then we'll start over, except with a much smaller, leaner, less powerful government, and all will be well.
10:12 Speaker 00 I have to reference one of my favorite episodes of Econ Talk, which I think was back in 2012 with Robert Frank. We had an actual debate. It was not a conversation. We had been asked by National Public Radio to talk about infrastructure. They ended up using about 10 minutes of our back and forth, but we recorded about an hour. And NPR gave us permission to release the entire hour as an Econ Talk episode. And although I prefer conversation to debate, in this exceptional case, partly because of the relationship I have with Bob, that we respect each other, and, and it was in an educational vein, it was more of a debate than a, than a conversation, much more combative,
10:57 Speaker 00 and a little more entertaining, maybe, than the average episode. We'll put a link up to that. You might want to go back and listen to it, because it's very relevant for this moment. What Bob wanted at that point was to improve infrastructure in the United States, feeling that we had done a terrible job. I pointed out, "We've spent a huge amount of money on it." And he pointed out, "Well, that's, yeah, it doesn't get spent very well because the government messes things up." And we wouldn't let the government... Politics, politics. Yeah, and we wouldn't let the government allocate this money in this better world. We'd have a committee of experts, and they would just actually make a list of the most important pieces of infrastructure: crucial bridges, highways, subways, you name it, high-speed rail. And instead of it going to the places with the most political power, we'd go to where
11:42 Speaker 00 it was most needed, or that was most good for the world, or the economy, or the American people. And I mocked that politely, more or less, and you can go back and listen to it. But we're in the exact same moment. Here's this idea now coming from the right, from the Republicans, that, "Yeah, if we can just avoid all these nasty political processes that gave us these bloated agencies, well, we could just actually do some good in the world." And my first thought, and I'm curious if it's yours, and it seems very ironclad, this first
12:20 Speaker 00 thought, "Well, that's all nice, but there are all these rules, and you can't cut..." I'll take an example, my favorite. You know, Social Security spends a huge amount of money, and so does Medicare, taking care of old people. Many of those old people have a lot of money, except they're not means-tested. Exactly. So obviously, it would make sense to means-test Social Security, and retirement, and also healthcare. And the government would save an enormous amount of money. The deficit could come way down, and it would have important ramifications for the next 10 years. Yet somehow, the political process doesn't think that's a good idea. It doesn't result in... There's no thinking.
13:04 Speaker 00 That result does not emerge from the political process. And so if Mr. Musk or Mr. Ramaswamy with their giant shears cut through the cordial knot of politics, try to do so, well, they're going to be stymied by filibuster and voting. And it's just not going to happen. Now, what are your thoughts? So that's my first thought is that talk is cheap. They'll never get this done. It'll end up being a silly little thing where they kill off some NSF study of snail darter reproductive habits and save $18 million. And that'll be it. There'll be nothing grand or important that comes out of the Department of Government
13:49 Speaker 00 Efficiency, because you can't just add a department. You've got to go through the normal processes of budgets and allocations and spending. And this whole thing's a fantasy. Well, you're in a political science department. Am I right or wrong?
14:04 Speaker 01 Are you saying that we know more about fantasies than most departments? You're probably right. Yes. I prefer the fantasy identification department. It's in Ecclesiastes, I don't remember the Hebrew word, but it's in Ecclesiastes that there's nothing new under the sun. So this was a big debate in the teens and early 1920s. And I actually have tried to make a point saying a lot of the observations of what we now think of a public choice actually come from the Cambridge School of Economics, where, and we did this in a previous podcast, where it's really important to recognize
14:45 Speaker 01 that the concerns about insulation from politics were crucial to achieving good policy. So it's not true that people on the left don't understand the problem with democracy. They understood it 30 years before the public choice people on the right started to work in that direction. And Ludwig von Mises, in his book on...
15:10 Speaker 01 Bureaucracy and on socialism make the really important observation that bureaucracy is the sine qua non. It is the essential form of organization for the territorial extensive state. And the idea that we're going to reform bureaucracy, we're going to make it more efficient. We're going to go through the budget and cut wasteful spending is just nonsense. You either want the state to do this or you don't. If you want the state to do it, then you want bureaucracy to carry it out. So the question is not can we go through their budgets? The question is, what are the things that the government should be doing? If it's doing, and this is Tyler Cowen's claim really, about state capacity libertarianism.
15:55 Speaker 01 There are some things the state should be doing. We're going to have to argue and decide what those things are. If the state should be doing that thing, it should be carrying it out in a way that is well-funded, that has experts, that has employees that are dedicated to that purpose. The state should not be doing it. We need to get rid of the entire agency. So on the question about Doge, the problem is, um, there are, well, there's two dimensions of problems that are kind of separate. One is that the budgets and the enabling statutes of these agencies were passed by Congress. They cannot be cut by some, forgive me, bureaucrat, even if that bureaucrat's name is Elon Musk.
16:39 Speaker 01 He's still just a damn bureaucrat who works for a new department called the Department of Government Efficiency. So one bureaucrat can't look and say, you know, we should get rid of this department. And everybody will say, yes, thank you for revealing that, and we'll get rid of the department. It's there because of a statute. It would have to be passed by Congress, and it is the nature of these departments that they create. Quite a few winners that have very concentrated benefits. They will rise up, immediate pop-up lobbyists against getting rid of the agency. The other thing is, there's a bunch of statutes. There's a bunch of things. You may not like them, but there's a bunch of things that these agencies do. And so the the rule is that if you have one lawyer, they're not very busy. If you have two lawyers, they have more business than they can handle.
17:22 Speaker 01 The the usual rule about bureaucracy is that the larger they get, the busier they are because they have more rules and regulations to enforce. And so there's a bunch of statutes. People say we should get rid of the Department of Education. The Department of Education administers just an enormous number of regulations that are we we have to do in order to spend the money that the Department of Education spends. We can't cut that back. We'd have to get rid of it entirely, in which case we also would have to get rid of the statutes that they enforce and the regulations that they use, or we're going to recognize that we're not going to accomplish very much. So the the two dimensions, I said a bunch of things there.
18:03 Speaker 01 The two dimensions are, first, you can't get rid of the agency. Second, there's a whole, there's a whole forest of regulations that they enforce that unless those statutes also, in addition, hundreds of things are withdrawn, you can't get rid of the agency. And so my favorite of these is the IRS. We'll get rid of the Internal Revenue Service. The reason the Internal Revenue Service is there is that we have this gigantically complicated tax code. Getting rid of the IRS will not change anything about the gigantically complicated tax code. Now, if what you want to do is have a flat tax with two rates and no deductions, then we can get rid of the IRS. But the IRS would, like Mark said, it would wither away. We wouldn't need it.
18:48 Speaker 01 It would disappear. And so the the the the idea that we can just go through the budget and cut it suffers from those two problems. First, we'd have to get rid of the entire agency because that's how bureaucracies work. That's what governments do. And von Mises noticed this in the 20s and argued it very clearly. The second thing is this forest of statutes and regulations we would also have to get rid of. I I just think it's a nonstarter. I think it's a complete waste of time and it's just a public relations stop.
19:18 Speaker 00 Okay, I want to come back to that in a second, but I want to say something first about the Department of Education.
19:25 Speaker 00 Some Americans understand, many do not, but some Americans understand that the Department of Education is a relative, at the federal level, is a relatively small dispenser of funds. It is an important dispenser of some regulations, but in general, the organization of education in the United States at the K through 12 level, the public education system, is a local system. So Trump, at some point, tweeted a bunch of goals he wanted for the Department of Education. Stop doing this DEI thing, do more of this, I don't know what it was, doesn't matter.
20:09 Speaker 00 He wanted education in America to have certain characteristics it doesn't have now. And among the other things he wanted to do was to eliminate the Department of Education. And I suggested that it's going to be difficult to get the 50-state, 3 million municipality level public education system to do X, whatever X is, if you don't have a federal organization to impose it. It's just not going to happen. So there is a inconsistency there. We may disagree, reasonable people can disagree about what trade-offs are worth enduring
20:51 Speaker 00 or things worth giving up if you keep it or don't keep it, but you can't do all that. It's not, it's not, not realistic. I think the only challenge I would have to your claim that it's just PR is the following. You and I did a really wonderful conversation, mostly you, not me, on enforcing the obedience to the unenforceable. And it was a conversation about norms. And I've become increasingly interested in the fact, it seems to me, that norms decay over time in the face of temptation.
21:32 Speaker 00 So the United States political system has a bunch of rules, checks and balances, the role of Congress, the role of the federal court, the power of the Constitution. They have changed dramatically over time. And much of what has changed is not the letter of the law, but how the law is enforced, how people feel about it. And the most obvious example of this, to me, is the increase in the executive power of the executive of the President of the United States. And there are a lot of things presidents do now that would have been considered unacceptable 50 years ago, 25 years ago, certainly 100 years ago.
22:16 Speaker 00 One of my favorite presidents, Grover Cleveland, at one point was asked to give money to farmers to help them after a drought. He said something like, "I'd love to. Where is it so I can do that in the Constitution? It doesn't. So raise the money through charity or do something else." That attitude is not acceptable anymore. And the norm of a stay near lane, as a, no matter what institution you're part of, has sort of degraded and eroded over time. So even though I am skeptical of the true desire and especially the ability of what we're talking about, the people are talking about, to achieve what they claim they want
23:00 Speaker 00 to achieve, I wonder if I'm underestimating them. I wonder if it might be possible to elude and evade some of those restrictions in place that keep change from happening. You know, the United States is famously a country where radical change is difficult. The checks and balances have this cost. Change is hard. They have this advantage. Change is hard. It leads to a certain level of stability. You don't have large swings in policy, even when you have a landslide, like when a president wins 49.7% of the vote, which I think is what the incoming president won.
23:43 Speaker 00 You know, that landslide degraded over the course of the evening as votes came in from California. He did win. He does have... Something of a popular mandate, but I would say it's quite thin. And yet it's being treated as if it's this chainsaw is being put in his hands by the American people to do a bunch of things he did not campaign on. And yet, I wonder if he might actually achieve some of these things because there is a willingness of different pieces of this puzzle to stand aside and not hold up their part of the bargain of what their obligations are. Let me say one more thing. I apologize for rambling and going on so long.
24:28 Speaker 00 The administrative state, the imposition of regulations by non-elected officials at their discretion, has grown over time. And again, the reason I feel like this is something of a libertarian moment is that all of a sudden, people are talking, at least in the Republican Party, that the administrative state is out of control. Now, you're suggesting they won't be able to do anything about it. I wonder, I'm a little more, dare I say it, optimistic. Your thoughts?
25:00 Speaker 01 Stafford Beer famously said that any system is designed to produce the outcomes that it actually produces. And so, the concept of equilibrium is important here. The reason we have the system of government we have and not some others, there's a set of political forces that have resulted in this. It's not an accident. And so, there's a bunch of interests that have, are benefiting, probably not net, that is, if we could get rid of it, the overall system would be better, but many individuals would be harmed and they're not going to be compensated because of the costs of getting rid of these agencies are going to be concentrated, the benefits are wide, but there's going
25:44 Speaker 01 to be a big increase in growth. In that, an article I recently wrote about changes in the Constitution. I said that if we were serious, there's two things that we should be doing. And we need to have a copy of maybe Milton Friedman's book, Free to Choose, and the US Constitution, open to the page where the 10th Amendment is. And there's two questions we should be asking of every government activity. The first is, is this an activity the state should even be involved in? Not because markets are perfect, but because states are bad. States do things badly, they do them expensively. There's a lot of red tape, it's slow, and it diverts resources from other parts of the society.
26:26 Speaker 01 So if this is not, and in the case, the burden of proof would have to be on whoever wants to say, yes, we should do it, not, we should do it because we are doing it. Let's assume we should not be doing it, and you'd have to show it. So is this something the state should even be doing? Second, we look at the 10th Amendment, and the 10th Amendment, if I may quote it, is, "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states respectively, or to the people." So there's a set of things that the federal government gets to do. Everything else belongs to the state. And so this is federalism, this is the issue of federalism. There's, it's astonishing that there's a Department of Education.
27:10 Speaker 01 You said that's mostly in the states. According to the Constitution, it is entirely in the states. There is nothing in the US Constitution about having a centralized system of education. And so this education, maybe it's a public good, maybe this is something that government should be involved in. Department of Education fails the second test, which is the 10th Amendment. This is not a federal activity. The Department of Education should be entirely eliminated, not cut, not look at its budget. The way to get rid of it is just to excise it and get rid of it. And if we cannot do that, then we probably cannot do any of the more difficult ones,
27:51 Speaker 01 where actually this is clearly a federal government activity. So the other one that I would, that I have argued for, is the Department of Commerce. And I mentioned, again, it's something that I wrote about cutting. The Department of Commerce, if you look at their website... They say that we touch every American every day. This is non-consensual touching. I imagine I go to the doctor and I have a doll and the doctor says, well, show me on the doll. Where did the Department of Commerce touch you? Because it's too embarrassing to say. But I don't want to be touched by the Department of Commerce. This is not, they have 13 different bureaus.
28:34 Speaker 01 They have scientists who are doing research on all sorts of activity to improve the productivity of investment. That's not a government activity. So the two that I would lead with, and so my test is how long is it before we at least ask, after January 20th, after the inauguration, how many months, or I would say years or decades, is, because I'm a skeptic, is it before we say, we've got to get rid of the Department of Commerce, the Department of Education? That's the low hanging fruit. My prediction is never, the over/under is never. And so I don't think they're, I don't think they're serious because that's where you would start if you were serious.
29:18 Speaker 01 You have a copy of free to choose, copy of the Constitution, and it has to satisfy both of those two things. This should be something government should be involved in, and it should be involved in it at the federal level. And I just, there's no way that's going to happen.
29:35 Speaker 00 Well, this could be interesting to see. I don't think we're going to abolish the IRS. I don't know.
29:41 Speaker 01 That's a, we have a complicated tax code. We should not, that, you raise the important, I'm wiping my arms for those that are listening. You raise the important point. Starting with the IRS, it is deeply unpopular. It is unpopular because the tax code that the Congress has passed is so complicated and in many cases aggressively punishing people that work, that don't rely on lawyers to create artificial structures that allow them to pay less. But we have to have the IRS. We don't have to have the Department of Commerce or the Department of Education.
30:20 Speaker 00 Okay, so I want to, I want to give you a counter example to your skepticism and see if you, if this is the exception that proves the rule for you.
30:32 Speaker 00 To summarize your view, and to be honest, it's my view too, but I'm caught up in the excitement of the moment.
30:41 Speaker 00 I would summarize your view as saying the following.
30:46 Speaker 00 Political forces are very powerful. They impede change, even when it's for the best. And it would be foolish and unrealistic to expect those things to go away.
31:01 Speaker 00 And therefore, very little is actually going to happen. Before we recorded this, I called this the impulse we're talking about here, the Thomas Friedman impulse, because Friedman once wrote, I found it deeply offensive, he said, "You know, if only for a day, we could be like China, the United States. If the United States could be like China for a day, where you didn't have all these democracies..."
31:24 Speaker 01 With him in charge. Not with Xi in charge, but with Thomas Friedman in charge. So not really like China, but otherwise like China, and with Thomas Friedman in charge.
31:34 Speaker 00 And if we could just get rid of these checks and balances and these annoying institutions of a constitutional republic, we could get so much done. And it only needed for a day, though. We just do the big, low-hanging fruit, the big, important things. And as you say, of course, he has himself or someone equally wise and good in mind. But every once in a while, we do something like this. Here's the exception that proves the rule, maybe. I suspect you know more about this than I do.
32:08 Speaker 00 When the Cold War ended, the United States found itself with all kinds of bells and whistles that were no longer necessary. One of them was, we had a lot of military bases that were no longer necessary. And a military base is very much like the kind of political example we're talking about. The benefits are very concentrated, the costs are dispersed, so it's really hard to close a base. The people who live there, work there, benefit from it, yell a lot. The people who would benefit from the closing don't even know what's happening. They tend to stay quiet, and the political process keeps the base open. So at some point, and I don't know how this happened, maybe you do, those people say, "Well, this is silly.
32:53 Speaker 00 We've got to close some of them, and we can't just close this one over here, because Senator so-and-so will scream on behalf of..." His or her constituents, so we'll have a commission. The commission will look across all of them. This is akin to the infrastructure example of Bob Frank. And they'll close the least needed ones. And it'll be painful for those locations, but we'll spread them around geographically. And I think that actually happened. And I'm asking the version of this that is maybe somewhat interesting, or maybe not, is that the United States office of sudden spends a lot of money and has a really big national debt and a really big deficit.
33:38 Speaker 00 And it's true that nothing bad has happened so far, which is why that issue gets almost no political traction. But even most people recognize that that's not a good strategy over time to say that there are no budget constraints for the federal government. And so maybe there would come a moment where we'd have to do a commission on base closings kind of thing to get the deficit or the debt under control. And I feel like, is it possible that the Department of Government Efficiency, which is a really Orwellian name, by the way, you really couldn't name it any better, because it's only going to get rid of inefficient things, not kidding.
34:21 Speaker 00 Efficient things, we might even spend more on by definition. It's the Department of Government Efficiency. Really probably should have called it the Department of Government Inefficiency, but doggy. But anyway, what do you think about this question of a commission to override the things you're talking about? And that maybe the deficit and the national debt could create that kind of serious moment?
34:49 Speaker 01 The Base Closing Commission was created because of the problem of time inconsistency. Time inconsistency for economists is that we recognize that we might have different incentives at different points in time. So we would say, you know, we should get rid of some bases. And then when it's proposed that the base in my district is one of the ones to be closed, I'm going to say, wait, not that district. You can't have meant that. And so on the cover of the Constitutional Political Economy Journal is Odysseus bound to the mast. Because Odysseus recognized that he had the problem of time inconsistency. So at one point, he says, you know, I would like to hear the sirens and not die.
35:33 Speaker 01 But if he is not.
35:35 Speaker 00 Explain who the sirens are.
35:37 Speaker 01 Well, the sirens in this case are deficits. But the sirens were, they lived on an island surrounded by big rocks. Waves are constantly pounding against it, but their song was so seductive that people wanted to draw near to hear it. They would either have their ships broken on the rocks or they would swim and then die because they would sit there and listen until they starve to death. So the goddess Kirkie in the Odyssey tells Odysseus, if you want to listen, you can, but make sure that you do two things.
36:17 Speaker 01 First, have your men stop up their ears with cotton and wax. And second, command your men to do two things. First, to tie you to the mast. And second, when you order them to untie you, have them bind you all the more tightly. And so the question is, could Odysseus give his men an order to disobey his future orders? Because that's what the base commission was. The US Congress said, we're going to create a commission. And that commission is going to be beyond the power of politics. Because later, we're going to thrash around and try to untie ourselves and go to where
36:59 Speaker 01 the seductive song of the sirens we can hear. But when we say, wait, no, you can't close those, they are impervious. The base closing commission will close them, even if we don't want them to close it then, because we recognize in advance that we need to close some bases. We're going to accept the outcome, even though we know that we're going to dislike the outcome when it actually comes down. What I want is to close all the bases except the one in my district. And so we'll have a collective solution to this. I think the difference was, there actually, there also was the 1986 tax change where there was a compromise where a bunch of different.
37:42 Speaker 01 Deductions were gotten rid of and tax rates were lowered all in the same omnibus bill. So if you can put a bunch of things together, you can probably solve this problem. To my knowledge, the Department of Government Efficiency has not worked on that line. That is, we'll create a commission beyond politics that will be able to say, close this department, cut this part of the budget, because members of Congress are not going to be willing to give that kind of blank check to things that are likely to be unpopular among their constituents. Base closing, yes, that's a, we all recognize we need to do it. It's fairly limited and it's kind of a one-time thing.
38:24 Speaker 01 Getting rid of the entire agencies and giving a agency closing commission, the power to do that, I think is something that Congress is not willing to do. The other thing is that there was a spirit of compromise and shared purpose in the 1980s that Congress really has not had since about 1994.
38:49 Speaker 00 Yeah.
38:50 Speaker 01 So somewhere in 1994, Newt Gingrich turned out to be a genius for political organization, but probably was damaging to the norms of the organization where you had to at least pretend that what you were doing was for the good of the country. Now it's okay if you're just doing it for the harm of the other party. And so in terms of getting rid of the unenforceable law, the Congress no longer, you don't have to say, I'm doing this because it's good for the country. You can just say, I want to smite that evil other party. Yeah, that's right. That's what you're gonna do.
39:30 Speaker 00 I'm gonna digress here for a minute, using the power of the host, free of checks and balances, to remark that this is the 50th anniversary of the release of what I think is the funniest movie of modern times, Young Frankenstein. We recently lost Terry Garr, one of the stars of that movie. And your remark about time inconsistency reminds me of when Gene Wilder goes into the chamber where the monster is and he tells Marty Feldman and Terry Garr, "No matter
40:12 Speaker 00 how much I beg, no matter how I plead, do not open this door." And he goes in, closes the door. I think he stumbles, wakes up the monster in an unplanned way. The monster gets up and roars, and Gene Wilder races to the door and says, "Open this door." And Terry Garr and Marty Feldman look at their fingernails and whistle and do exactly as they were told. They ignore him. And mayhem ensues. It includes the great Settigiv moment shortly after that. I want to try to come back to a question I asked a minute ago in a different way.
40:57 Speaker 00 The Department of Government Efficiency is a name. It's not a building. There's no building. It has no power.
41:04 Speaker 01 Not yet. Not yet. It's coming. I'm sure it'll be a big building with thousands of employees.
41:09 Speaker 00 But it has no building. It has no authority. There's a certain comic theatrical element to this moment that you are highlighting, that this is theater. The thing that pushes me in the opposite direction again is the president. President Trump does not, I would say, fully appreciate the complex system of checks and balances embodied in the American system. Kind of focused on power. He recently won a settlement
41:51 Speaker 00 from ABC News for $15 million for defamation, and he's gone and he's gone and, you know, launched a bunch of other threats and suits about other news organizations he doesn't like. And a number of media people have kowtowed to him. Some were very upset about the $15 million settlement, that ABC should have fought it.
42:20 Speaker 00 And this comes back to my point about executive authority that is, I would say, somewhat run amok, and your point about the sword. He's got a big sword, and he's not ashamed to use it. He doesn't care about norms and the dignity of his office. And he likes to win. And by the way, he's pulled into his orbit somebody else who likes to win, Elon Musk. Elon Musk is a very competitive, just as an aside, he's like in the top 10 of the world in something called, was it Diablo? And like, he's running three companies and he's internationally in the top 10 of some video game.
43:05 Speaker 00 He likes to win. And he's not going to be so eager to just slink off into the sunset the way you're suspecting he will. I just wonder if it's possible that the normal constraints of government may be off the table. I find this very frightening, by the way. I don't find this exciting, because as we both would agree, this will not be, the elimination of the Department of Education, say, which I might, in many moments of my life, think was probably more or less a good thing. That probably won't be the only thing the sword is used for, and it won't just be used for cutting.
43:48 Speaker 00 It's going to be used for all kinds of interventions in daily life. I think there's, I call this a libertarian moment, that's probably the wrong word. We're in a much more Caesarian, much less constrained moment. It does appear that certain libertarian impulses are prowling around. Silicon Valley in general has been empowered by this victory of President Trump and is excited clearly about cryptocurrency getting a better day in court and other things. And the price of Bitcoin reflects that.
44:31 Speaker 00 I know I've got many listeners who have invested in Bitcoin because of the episodes we've done in the past. I'm sure you're feeling good about that right now. But there's going to be some, I think we're in for a rocky ride. That's my thought. What do you think?
44:49 Speaker 01 You started it out by saying I didn't want to quarrel with you then, but I'll quarrel with you now, something about a full-throated defense of free speech. Yeah, yeah. I'm maybe on X, I'm not so sure that I see anything like that for Trump. One of the problems that I think libertarians have to have with the present moment is that libertarians are principled in worrying about the power of the state, even if the power might be used in ways they happen to agree with. And that's a very difficult thing to force yourself to stick with, because that's obedience to the unenforceable. There's this rule, and if we could expand the power of the state, it would be used for good.
45:34 Speaker 01 No, shouldn't do that, because if we do, it might be used for bad, even though right now it would be used for good. And so libertarians, it's very tempting to think that the enemy of my enemy is my friend. So suppose there's somebody who just doesn't like some of the things that government is doing, and wants to use this sword to smite their enemies. Well, it would make government smaller, and therefore I, as a libertarian, am going to be in favor of it, said no libertarian ever, no real libertarian, in the sense that I want to give government the power to hurt other parts of the government that that person wielding the sword happens not to like, and I'll say, good, let's do that, because I happen to agree with smaller government. That's not the same thing.
46:19 Speaker 01 And so I think that Elon Musk does like to win. He hates to wait around. He has the attention span of a gnat. And so when it turns out that you can't even make any progress against this schmoo, this giant mushroom, mushroom, marshmallow, that you're punching at, and it just rolls around, he'll go do something else. So the, yes, he likes to win, and when it turns out that it takes more than 10 minutes just to say, okay, do this, he's gone. And I don't know that Trump is any different. Trump doesn't like, Trump really doesn't like people who disagree with him.
46:59 Speaker 01 And he, yesterday, he wrote on his social media account that sometimes reproduced on Twitter, he had the largest mandate in 129 years.
47:15 Speaker 01 I have actually, usually I can figure out what the heck he's talking about. I have no idea what that means. It wasn't the largest popular vote. It wasn't the largest win in the Electoral College. What he might mean is it's the largest total vote, but that can't be right either, given the increase in the population. But his claim is, I have the largest mandate in the last 129 years, therefore, both the House and the Senate have to do what I say. So he's just eliminating the fact that Article One creates a separate branch of government. And I admit, you could get things done if you did that, just as if Thomas Friedman were in charge of the Chinese government. But I think those are
47:57 Speaker 01 both terrible ideas. And in fact, if compared to Donald Trump not having to worry about Congress, I almost would prefer Thomas Friedman being in charge of the Chinese government.
48:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, 129 years ago is roughly 1896. I don't remember that being the heyday of mandates. I don't remember. Who won the 1896 election?
48:20 Speaker 01 William McKinley defeated William Jennings Bryan. He got 73% of the Electoral College vote. And it was a pretty big victory. It wasn't as big a victory as Reagan had in 1984. So I don't know what, again, I don't know what the difference is. But Donald Trump posted this on Truth Social yesterday. The, "I won the biggest mandate in 129 years. I will make my appointment of very qualified people," all in caps, "in January when I am
48:58 Speaker 01 sworn in." And so his claim is that the Congress, the Republican Senate, should just immediately accept all of his appointments without doing advice and consent. And so what his claim is, that he, not even the Republicans, should be scrutinizing his appointments. And this is presumably what people mean when they say, "We should concentrate more power." Power in the office of the presidency. I talked to a lot of young, they call themselves national conservatives and they're interested in a doctrine of executive power. And their theory is that it's a thousand year rife. They will never lose again.
49:40 Speaker 01 And this executive will always be a Republican. That would be really surprising if that were true. So I think I've said this before on the show also.
49:51 Speaker 00 Go ahead.
49:51 Speaker 01 But it was the, after both the 2016 election and the more recent one, I had lefty Duke faculty friends come into my office, close the door and say, you know, I was looking in the Federalist Papers. There's some good stuff in there. Yeah, yeah, there is. And two weeks ago, when your boy was president, there was good stuff. Well, I'm not so worried about it when our guy is in charge. You're completely missing the point. The point is the Federalist Papers are you will not always be in charge. And you only have two choices. One is we're going to have a really powerful president and just accept the fact that sometimes it will be held
50:32 Speaker 01 by the wrong person. Or we'll have a relatively weak president, which means that we will limit the thing, we have to actually have consensus. Got to go through the Congress, you got to persuade people, you can't use the giant flaming sword.
50:45 Speaker 00 Yeah, the thing you're forgetting, Mike, is that when you have the correct viewpoint,
50:50 Speaker 00 you can stay in office forever because everyone's going to agree with you. If you've, and you see a lot of evidence for that. No, nowhere, nowhere. You see, evidence for that, nowhere.
51:02 Speaker 01 I, but it is absolutely the core belief. Both of those things are true at the same time. That is the core belief of people on both sides. And there's no empirical evidence for it.
51:11 Speaker 00 Yeah. And although I think they would, if you ask them, there's, if you pointed that out to them, what they will often say is, well, sure, in the past, because people were misinformed and miseducated. And they didn't understand that what I'm advocating for now is obviously really good and can't be argued with. There's no arguments on the other side that are, that are legitimate, or viable, or credible. So now that we've come to this enlightenment, everything's going to be smooth sailing from here on in.
51:44 Speaker 01 It is frustrating. To me, the task of the libertarian, and we've talked about this also a bit, the difficulty with the conservative coalition, the fusionist coalition that probably was best embodied by Ronald Reagan, who was fiercely opposed to the Soviet Union, was at least in principle in favor of rhetorical shrinkage of government, reduction in taxes. So government's not the solution, government is the problem. That's some pretty libertarian rhetoric. And it's not about the perfection of markets. So it's the sort of libertarian rhetoric I actually admire, that there are problems with government.
52:29 Speaker 01 There should be a presumption against saying, let's have the state do something about this. Because the state is not going to be as good at this as you can imagine. You can see here in the background, there's my unicorn. And the unicorn, to me, is the symbol of people's imagination of how this time is going to be different. My argument is so persuasive that it will all work. The difficulty that I think we have with the fusionist coalition of conservatives and libertarians is that libertarians, without conservatives to say, wait, we need to worry about tradition and morality, libertarians become a free radical.
53:13 Speaker 01 They start to say, anything that you want to do, if it's not illegal, it is moral. And conservatives say, no, we need to worry about morality. Now conservatives, without libertarians, are a problem because conservatives fall prey to this desire to use power to achieve their means. So libertarians and conservatives actually need each other. They're a much more effective, durable coalition. I think the split of fusionism in the US has resulted in an enormous increase in pure conservatism. A lot of libertarians have kind of stepped back.
53:51 Speaker 01 It is interesting that a lot of libertarian sentiment is now being expressed by the current administration. And we haven't really talked about Javier Millay. He is explicitly libertarian in the sense that he is advocating for market principles and is doing pretty well in Argentina. I hope that you are right, that this is a kind of libertarian moment in the sense that we're going to see an emphasis on reduction of the size and scope of government. What I worry about is that instead we're going to see is an increase in government power so as to smite people that the administration disagrees with.
54:34 Speaker 00 Okay, I'm gonna make, I'm gonna make my prediction now. This, we're recording this at the middle of December. We expect it to be released in the middle of January, right before the inauguration of the new administration. And predictions aren't interesting, really. I'm gonna make one anyway. So I'm sympathetic-
55:01 Speaker 01 To listeners, they will be.
55:02 Speaker 00 Yeah, maybe.
55:03 Speaker 01 People are wanting you to make a prediction. They're looking forward to it.
55:06 Speaker 00 Oh, they can't wait. I'm gonna suggest something a little different. I have to say intellectually, I agree with you. Everything in my, every bone in my body agrees with you. But those bones have been mispredicting things now for a while. So I'm a little worried that, that my natural impulses, which are equilibrium-ish like yours, that say that what really matters isn't who's in charge, but the incentives they face. That intuition has not been so reliable lately.
55:45 Speaker 00 So while I am sympathetic to your view that nothing significant will get accomplished in, in terms of the Department of Government or efficiency and the size of government, I, I am, I, I hold some probability that, that I'll be wrong about that and that you will be wrong about that. Here's what I'm more confident about, and I'll let you react to this and, and bring us home.
56:16 Speaker 00 In the last 10, 15 years, traditional economic issues have been subsumed by other kinds of issues. The rise of Trump within the Republican Party is a tribute to this phenomenon that cultural issues are dwarfing, so-called pocketbook issues. I don't think it's the economy stupid anymore. I think the worries, for example, about immigration are not about the fact that they might take away jobs from low-skill workers. It's more about whether immigrants will change the culture and fabric of American life.
56:59 Speaker 00 Some people think they'll change it for the better. Some people think it'll be for the worse. But the fundamental issue here is not material. It's cultural. It's about a sense of identity. It's about a sense of belonging. And what's happening all over the world, not just in America, is that these cultural issues, for reasons I don't fully understand, we'll devote another episode or 10 to it in the future, Mike, these cultural and ethical, excuse me, these cultural and identity issues are at the forefront. And I think that the pendulum is swinging very strongly in a different direction than it has been swinging for a while.
57:42 Speaker 00 I think Trump's success, not his landslide, not his mandate of 129 years and counting, but his success is a tribute to his ability to be an effective politician, to recognize that that pendulum is swinging. He's causing it, some of it, but he's also as much an effect and the result of these changes. And so the...
58:13 Speaker 00 The salience of certain cultural issues in this last election are what will endure. Not the size of the deficit, not the tariffs, because I don't think he's going to pass large tariffs across the board. I don't think he's going to eliminate the income tax or replace it with a national tariff, which is what he's floated that idea. But I do think he may, and it's not just him, that this moment, when we, four years from now, in 2028, when I am old and gray and full of sleep, and I hope perhaps still hosting Econ Talk, and you still are willing to be my companion in this enterprise, I
58:58 Speaker 00 think we'll look back on this moment, and it will seem to be more about cultural aspects of the moment and less about the economic policy aspects. That's my guess. What do you think of that?
59:13 Speaker 01 I think big changes almost always seem impossible in prospect and inevitable in retrospect. And so there's no way any of this is going to change. I'm reminded of, "In the Sun Also Rises," I think you've quoted this before, Ernest Hemingway, Bill says, "How did you go bankrupt?" And Mike responds two ways, gradually and then suddenly. So you're...
59:44 Speaker 00 I've never quoted that, but that's a great line.
59:47 Speaker 01 It is a great line, and that's the way bankruptcy works.
59:52 Speaker 00 It's been a long time.
59:53 Speaker 01 We have a big deficit, "Gosh, well, it's not so good. Maybe we should do something about that, but tomorrow." And then all of a sudden, "Oh, whoa, that was quick." And so the change happens. The US budget deficit is increasing in ways that would simply have been impossible. I have a graduate student who is now finished named Cameron Tilly, who has a paper that he calls "The Old Time Religion." And the mystery is to explain, why is it that enormous budget deficits didn't happen long ago in the US?
1:00:24 Speaker 00 It's a puzzle.
1:00:24 Speaker 01 The question's not why they're happening now. They had the capacity to do this. If I can use either money or tax cuts to buy votes, why wouldn't I do that? That's in the self-interest of politicians. For a long time, it was because people felt, well, it's just wrong. We shouldn't do that. And so there was...
1:00:41 Speaker 00 Obedience to the unenforceable.
1:00:43 Speaker 01 Obedience to the unenforceable. But then, suddenly, it's gone. And so, the point that you raise about change, I think, as I said, in prospect, big changes always seem impossible. It can't. But then, sometimes, it does. And afterwards, we're trained economists. We can come up with reasons why it was inevitable. Here's the reasons why it happened. But in fact, it was something that may have been pretty hard to predict. It will be interesting, four years from now, to look back and talk about the reasons why, by then, we will say, well, sure, the change was inevitable. We understand why it happened. Or was there not
1:01:23 Speaker 01 any of the kind of change that we had hoped for? I think that your claim about the pendulum is, another way to say it, is dialectic. By the time you think that all of the forces of cultural change are so deeply embedded in this society that we have moved in a wokest direction, the response is to say, no, we don't want that. And it basically gets wiped out by a tsunami of response. I think what we look at now, if we look at things that were just taken for granted in 2014 or 2022 about identitarian politics, it now seems...
1:02:05 Speaker 01 Could anybody really have believed that? Could they have said those things? The Democrats, I think, are reassessing a fair number of their initiatives that had to do with culture. It seems to me that the economy is a big part of the explanation at the more fundamental sense that people have a... They feel precarious. They the the the employment rate is pretty high. Income is going up. Inflation is going down, but they feel a sense of exposure. And one of the things that always is going to appeal to people who are worried about
1:02:46 Speaker 01 being exposed to economic forces beyond their control is to control labor, which is immigration, and to control the imports of products that compete with things that I make, and that's tariffs. And so regardless of the fact that those things might be expensive, it's going to appeal to me because I have more of a sense of control. So the Trump in happening upon those, maybe it was luck, maybe it was cunning, maybe it was strategy, but it happened slowly and then suddenly happened gradually and then suddenly. And now, of course, that was the way that it worked. But it is it's not obvious that in the absence of Trump, the Republicans would have found someone else to do that. So the the the figure of Donald Trump is someone who's going to be looked back on
1:03:30 Speaker 01 as an important figure in American history, whether we attach a positive or negative valence, with any luck, we'll know more about by 2028.
1:03:38 Speaker 00 My guest today has been Mike Munger. Mike, thanks for being part of Econ Talk.
1:03:45 Speaker 01 A pleasure as always, Russ.
1:03:54 Speaker 00 This is Econ Talk, part of the Library of Economics and Liberty. For more Econ Talk, go to EconTalk.org, where you can also comment on today's podcast and find links and readings related to today's conversation. The sound engineer for Econ Talk is Rich Goyette. I'm your host, Russ Roberts. Thanks for listening. Talk to you on Monday.
Previous Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch) Next Weep, Shudder, Die: The Secret of Opera Revealed (with Dana Gioia) Page updated November 7, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated