Pod Insights EconTalk Who Needs Miracles? On Nature and the Miraculous (with Alan Lightman) About this episode How can we cultivate a sense of awe in our lives? Easy, says physicist and author Alan Lightman: Pay more attention. When we take the time to examine the world around us, from shooting stars to soap bubbles to everything in between, we can feel a sense of wonder and appreciation akin to spirituality. And the best part is, you can take your scientific worldview with you on your awe-inducing journey. Join Lightman and EconTalk's Russ Roberts as they discover that discovering the science behind things can be a truly miraculous experience.
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Welcome to Econ Talk, Conversations for the Curious, part of the Library of Economics and Liberty. I'm your host, Russ Roberts of Shalem College in Jerusalem and Stanford University's Hoover Institution. Go to econTalk.org where you can subscribe, comment on this episode, and find links and other information related to today's conversation. You'll also find our archives with every episode we've done going back to 2006. Our email address is [email protected] . We'd love to hear from you. Today is September 24, 2024, and my guest is physicist and author Alan Lightman. This
0:44 Speaker 00 is Alan's third appearance on Econ Talk. He was last here in April 2020, talking about stardust meaning religion and science. His latest book and the topic for today's discussion is "The Miraculous from the Material: Understanding the Wonders of Nature." Alan, welcome back to Econ Talk.
1:04 Speaker 01 Nice to be back on your show, Russ.
1:06 Speaker 00 Now, you write that you don't believe in miracles, but you do believe in the miraculous, and that's in your title, "The Miraculous from the Material." It's a lovely title. Explain that difference for you, between miracles and miraculous.
1:20 Speaker 01 Well, for me, a miracle is something that contradicts the laws of nature as we understand them. Generally, people who talk about miracles refer to the intervention of God in the physical world, or some supernatural being, the intervention into the physical world. And of course, the word supernatural by itself already means beyond the natural, or beyond anything that human beings can explain. So that's what I mean by a miracle,
2:01 Speaker 01 and I don't believe in miracles. But by the miraculous, I mean the experience of awe, the beauty that we see in the world, the tremendous order.
2:23 Speaker 01 And in particular visually extraordinary phenomena, which is what I talk about in the book. And I feel that I, and most of us are, are open to these, to experiencing these extraordinary phenomena. And that's what I mean by the miraculous. So I think that we can have a scientific worldview, which means that we believe that
3:03 Speaker 01 the world is made out of, it follows natural law, but we can still be appreciative and open to these beautiful phenomena.
3:14 Speaker 00 And this book is a set of short explanations and observations about such beautiful visual phenomena. I think everybody has their own list. This is yours presumably. And at one point, I can't remember which, and there are things like rainbows, flowers, shooting stars, et cetera. At one point you mentioned how, I think it was spider webs, which is another chapter. You talked about how your, all of your children or grandchildren are, will stop and examine a spider web. And I recently, we did an episode on owls and I mentioned how my granddaughter loves owls.
3:56 Speaker 00 And I tried to get all of my children, and now my granddaughter, to be in awe of the natural world. On its own terms, they were all raised with some level of Jewishness as well, religious belief, but I felt it was important to give them just that transcendent appreciation of beauty. And just I'm curious what your thoughts are as a parent, grandparent, as...
4:29 Speaker 00 How you did that, and by the way, none of my kids are scientists. None of them went into, one of them studied science, but none of them became scientists, at least not yet. And I wouldn't say that was my goal. I don't have a goal that my granddaughter become an ornithologist or an expert on owls. But I'm curious what your thoughts are on that as a parent and grandparent.
4:50 Speaker 01 Well, I think that most children, from my own limited experience, do have an awe and an appreciation of the natural world. So I think as a parent, and I've got four grandparents, four grandchildren as well, I think that I just want to encourage that. And I want them, my children and grandchildren, to spend time in nature and just to pay attention. And I think that the awe is natural, but we need to pay attention.
5:35 Speaker 01 And we don't really pay attention as much in the world today as we used to because of the way that everything has been digitized. We all have our smartphones and are looking at those instead of looking at the trees and the sky and the water. And also, the pace of the world has gotten so fast, driven by the speed of communication, that we don't take the time to just pay attention. And I think when we pay attention, the awe will come, but we need to make time to pay attention.
6:14 Speaker 00 Now, some would argue that the rise of science in the last couple centuries has reduced the amount of awe. Things that were before considered, as you say, supernatural or religious, divine, now some of the, some would argue that the magic has been dispelled. Because now we understand why these things happen, at least at some level, I would stress. But you argue the opposite in the book in a number of places, so explain that.
6:52 Speaker 01 Well, I think that you can still find awe in a natural phenomenon like a rainbow or a volcano or lightning or a spider web, even if you understand the science behind it. I understand how Saturn forms its rings, and I encourage everybody to get a good pair of binoculars or a small telescope and look at the rings of Saturn.
7:29 Speaker 01 And I understand how those rings form by gravitational pull and angular momentum. But every time I look at the rings of Saturn, I'm just blown away by the beauty of them and the perfection. So I don't think that understanding, in this case, scientific understanding is incompatible with awe and appreciation of beauty. I do agree with you that science over the last couple of centuries has given explanations
8:08 Speaker 01 for many phenomena that we didn't previously understand, but we still have an emotional reaction to these things. When I go outside on a clear night and look at the stars, I know how far away some of them are. I know that stars are suns, like our sun, but it doesn't reduce the magnificent, the majesty of that view of a night sky for me. That's an emotional reaction, and I think, you know, our emotional reactions or our whole set of emotions come from a very ancient part of the brain, the amygdala. I'm probably mispronouncing it.
8:53 Speaker 01 And that's a very ancient, primitive part of the brain, and we still react.
9:01 Speaker 01 With that ancient part of our brain to the beauty that we see around us, even if we have another part of the brain that has read up on the latest theories of diffraction and astronomy, that primitive part of our brain, which is the seat of our emotions, is still active. And of course, I'm very, very glad that it is.
9:28 Speaker 00 Yeah, I don't, for me, I think the knowledge actually usually enhances the awe. I mean, if you think of the stars, I live in Jerusalem, not a very industrial city, but there's sufficient light pollution that there's only a handful of stars that are visible on a winter night. If I head, you know, a couple hours south into the desert here, you get an extraordinary view of the Milky Way. So I like that when I'm looking at the skies here in Jerusalem, I know there's a richer tapestry to be enjoyed. And when
10:11 Speaker 00 I see that tapestry, the knowledge that they're not all equally far from me is, I find, so mind blowing, that even when we look at a constellation, which looks like it's representing something, when you realize that they're not actually near each other often, maybe almost ever, I think there's a handful, but most of them are very far apart. It's an illusion that they look like they're close to each other. To me, that just, it's like going from 2D to 3D, even of course, we know it's 3D. So for me, it makes it better for me.
10:52 Speaker 01 Well, I agree with you that understanding and knowledge has a beauty of its own.
10:57 Speaker 00 Yeah.
11:01 Speaker 00 And you write in the book very nicely about
11:05 Speaker 00 being aware of that as human beings is quite extraordinary. Maybe we'll come back to that. Let me ask a more philosophical question.
11:17 Speaker 00 Are there limits to what we can understand about the physical world, the material?
11:25 Speaker 00 Obviously, we made tremendous progress over those centuries we're talking about. Of course, we don't know why things are the way they are. We kind of have a side of us that wants to know, I think.
11:41 Speaker 00 But understanding the physical processes and the laws that produce these phenomena is an extraordinary achievement in and of itself of the human mind, which, as you point out, is just this weird little set of neurons firing in a three-pound package, a crazy idea that that would lead to understanding the past, that we can't observe it directly at all, or at least doesn't feel like we can. Are there limits to what we can understand, or do you think what we will understand?
12:11 Speaker 01 Well, I think when you talk about understanding, we need to distinguish between the physical world and maybe you could call it the moral or ethical world. There certainly is or boundaries to the province of science, and there are questions, important questions, that don't lie within science, like, does God exist, or would we be happier if we lived to be 1,000 years old, or is it ethical to kill an enemy soldier in time of war? Those are all very important questions, but I think they lie outside of science.
12:53 Speaker 01 So we'll put those questions aside and just talk about the physical world and ask the question, are there limits to what science can know about the physical world?
13:05 Speaker 01 And I don't think that there are any limits in principle. I view science as a long project of getting better and better approximations to the way the natural world works. And we don't have complete knowledge of how the world works physically, but we have very, very good approximations, and I think that our approximations will get better and better. There's another aspect of that question, and that is whether science is the best tool for understanding certain physical phenomena.
13:47 Speaker 01 And, of course, let's take our feeling of appreciation for nature, or our awe at looking up at a night sky, or our falling in love. So all of those experiences are mental sensations. And I do believe, and I think that most scientists agree with me, that all mental sensations are ultimately based in the physical neurons of our brain, and the chemical and electrical exchanges between them.
14:27 Speaker 01 So I think that all of those experiences that I mentioned, like falling in love, are ultimately rooted in the physical brain. But even if you wired up my brain to a vast computer that recorded all of the electrical activity in the 100 billion neurons in my brain, and you put all of that out on a chart, it still wouldn't...
15:02 Speaker 01 Convey or represent what I feel when I look up at the night sky and feel part of it. That feeling that I have, even though I believe that that feeling is ultimately rooted in the material brain. Science is just not a good tool for capturing that feeling. That is, the data of all of those neurons and what they're doing doesn't really capture the sensation and the feeling that I have.
15:38 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think the philosophical term is qualia, which is a really pretentious way, maybe, just to say feelings, but...
15:46 Speaker 01 Right, qualia, yes, I know about that term.
15:49 Speaker 00 But the puzzle for me is, why would we not expect science to unlock that? At one point, you mentioned the emergent phenomenon of the brain and consciousness, which we talk about every once in a while on this program without much progress. But in going beyond what I just said, do you not think there will be a, quote, "big enough computer," a computing version of the brain that would allow us to predict who you'd fall in love with, or which night sky would make you more rapturous, et cetera?
16:33 Speaker 00 Do you think it's beyond our understanding? Is it a computing challenge, or is it a philosophical barrier?
16:40 Speaker 01 Well, it depends on who you talk to. I think that you, and I did talk to a neuroscientist at MIT named Robert Decimone about just this question, about whether...
16:59 Speaker 01 A computer and a neuroscientist working together could eventually predict who we would fall in love with. And what he said was, it's a question of probability, that right now we're at a level where a neuroscientist working with AI could probably, if they did enough interviews with you and examined your brain, they could probably say, well, there's a 70% chance you'll fall in love with Mary and a 30% chance you'll fall with Eileen. And he said that those probabilities will probably get higher and higher as the technology and as the neuroscience advances.
17:43 Speaker 01 So I think that in principle that you might be able to make such predictions with high probability. But still, there's the question, does the computer capture the qualia? Does the computer capture the feeling of being in love? And there was a great philosopher named Thomas Nagel.
18:09 Speaker 00 Sure.
18:10 Speaker 01 Who wrote a book, What Does It Feel Like to Be a Bat?
18:13 Speaker 00 It's an essay. Yeah, it's an article.
18:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, an essay. And of course, he argues that in principle, we can never really know what it feels like to be another organism. I mean, I don't know exactly what it feels like to be you, Russ Roberts. I can look at your expressions and hear what you have to say, and I can sort of compare that to my knowledge of how, with the expressions that I make and the things that I say and conclude that you probably are feeling things that I'm feeling or that I can understand. But I don't know for sure what you're feeling.
19:00 Speaker 01 And I don't know what my wife is feeling, for sure. I certainly hope that she's, most of the time, she's happy with me and not unhappy with me.
19:13 Speaker 01 So I think that's.
19:16 Speaker 01 I mean, I guess I agree with Thomas Nagel. One very interesting question that has come up a lot recently, and certainly since the advent of Chat GPT and the realization that that computers are getting pretty smart, is a question of whether a computer can ever be conscious.
19:36 Speaker 00 Sure.
19:37 Speaker 01 And of course, you have to define what you mean by consciousness, which is, of course, the fundamental mental sensation. And my view, and I think the view of many AI experts, is that any finite list of attributes of consciousness that you can write down, like being able to recognize yourself in a mirror, self-awareness, being able to plan for the future, any limited list of manifestations of consciousness you can make, that we will someday, maybe 10 years away or 20 years away, have a computer that will check all the boxes of manifestations of consciousness.
20:22 Speaker 01 But that's not the same as saying, is the computer really conscious? And to answer that question, you would have to know what it feels like to be a computer.
20:35 Speaker 01 And, you know, maybe 100 years from now, we'll all have silicon chips in our brains that make us part computer and part machine. And then we may start knowing what it feels like to be a computer, but we certainly don't know now.
20:56 Speaker 00 Yeah, I was in a, my first driverless car recently was picked up by a driverless
21:05 Speaker 00 car in San Francisco, which has these on the street. And, you know, my joke I've used here in the past is I wonder if it has any regrets that it's not a vacuum, electric automated vacuum cleaner, a Roomba. You know, does it sit long for to be something, some other kind of computer machine, generated machine?
21:34 Speaker 00 It's hard to imagine. You know, I was thinking about your love example. Most of us would have trouble remotely defining what it means to be in love. In its earliest manifestations, I would say it has a physical correspondence to... I would sometimes get a stomach ache thinking about a person and missing her. And I think as you sit longer with one person, there's a different set of physical and, of course, emotional reactions. And how would you begin to quantify... I mean, it's just, I don't know, it seems to be beyond
22:16 Speaker 00 the... some of it seems beyond the purview of science.
22:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, I would agree with that.
22:24 Speaker 00 Let me ask you about physics. You have PhD in physics. I don't know what your dissertation was on, but usually it's something specialized. I'm just curious, given the enormously wide range of phenomena in this book, how many of the explanations came effortlessly to you versus having to do research? Some of the smartest people I've ever met are physicists. They're not just smart, though. They know about things, which that's two different things. And if I say, "Why is this such and such a way?", they usually have some idea, and it's kind of extraordinary.
23:09 Speaker 00 How's that work for you in this book?
23:11 Speaker 01 Well, the book has all kinds of scientific explanations. Some of them come from the field of biology, some from chemistry, some from physics. And there were, I don't know what fraction of chapters come from the world of physics, but the physics, I was able to write the explanations and the understandings from my own knowledge. There were fields that I was not very familiar with, like...
23:51 Speaker 01 Weather and
23:58 Speaker 01 what makes the colors of a Mandarin fish.
24:06 Speaker 01 Which is chemistry and biology. And for those, I had to do some research. And even when I did the research, I didn't completely trust myself in fields that weren't my own and I would, you know, talk to experts
24:23 Speaker 01 in that area. One of the great privileges of living in the Boston Cambridge area, which is where I live, is that there are plenty of experts nearby in almost every subject. And I have the privilege of knowing some of them. So I can pick up the phone and ask someone, you know, what what are the reasons why the Mandarin fish has these colors and so on?
24:52 Speaker 01 So, of course, if you're a scientist, you have a feeling for all of the sciences. You know, you understand logical arguments, you understand quantitative arguments, but you may not know the details and fields other than your own. And I take a very humble approach to this, that that I can learn from a lot of different people. And of course, writing a book, and writing a book, the things that you learn, and I know you've written some books yourself, the things you learn in the research is one of the joys and pleasures of writing the book.
25:28 Speaker 00 For sure. I was gonna say, my dad was a very curious man and he was not an academic. He would occasionally write people in the Boston Cambridge area, say, for information, and many of them would write back, which is really nice. And then he would tell me they're on his staff, that they were part of people he could consult. And I would just add that the people you're talking about, when you say the experts, they're actual experts. They're people who actually do know about these scientific phenomena. I'm curious if writing the book made you more curious. Did it start to? Were the things you put in the book that you didn't intend to because something grabbed your eye?
26:08 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah. It definitely made me more curious and more interested and, of course, more aware that there are zillions of extraordinary phenomena out there, only a small fraction of I understand. The book started, what started off the book is, I'm a jogger and I was running by a field that I often run by, and it was early in the morning. I think it was probably in the fall. And there was a beautiful mist hanging over the field that went up maybe about six feet or something like that. This layer, this six-foot layer of mist hanging over the field.
26:52 Speaker 01 And I'd seen such mists before and I knew that as it got warmer and the sun came out that they would dissipate. And I began thinking about why mists form. And I realized that I didn't understand all of it. I had some guesses and I, but I didn't know for sure all the details and what form, what makes a mist form. And so that's what started the book off. It was my own curiosity.
27:27 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's like my wife asked me why hotels are so expensive in New York. I got a pretty good idea, but why they've gotten more expensive as Airbnb has basically been eliminated from New York? Is it because hotels were going to be built, would have been built, but because of Airbnb they weren't and now that Airbnb is gone, they're, I don't know. So, yeah, I've got, I'm, of course, semi-joking because the knowledge that economics brings to the world is limited compared to, say, physics, but I'll take what I can get. Tell us what ball lightning is.
28:10 Speaker 00 I'd never heard of that and it happened to you once. Explain what that is.
28:15 Speaker 01 Well, that's a good example because we don't really fully understand what ball lightning is, but what causes it. But the phenomenon itself occurs usually during a thunderstorm and...
28:38 Speaker 01 A shining ball forms that is something like, you know, maybe two feet or three feet in diameter and moves very quickly. And my own experience with it was that one summer I was standing on the second floor deck of my house and the thunderstorm was just letting up. And suddenly this shining ball came at me. It went by me and into the house and exploded with a bang.
29:19 Speaker 01 I mean, I think it knocked out some electrical appliances. And it moved very quickly. The entire phenomena, from the time I first saw this ball to the time it exploded, was probably only about three seconds. And so there are various theories about what it is. It's certainly some kind of electricity that is, you probably have the lightning and the thunderstorm probably ionizes an isolated region of air. That is, it strips the electrons off the atoms. That's what ionization is.
30:01 Speaker 01 And it's electrically charged. But we don't really know much more than that about it. It's a rare phenomenon, but it's really extraordinary.
30:16 Speaker 00 In the movie version, either being Alien or God talking to you to get your attention, I expect that the bang was extremely loud. Is that correct?
30:32 Speaker 01 It wasn't extremely loud. It was loud.
30:44 Speaker 01 I guess, you know, an interesting case was I had, I think I had written something about it. And there was a legal case in the state of Tennessee that involved ball lightning and someone had had property damage. And one of the lawyers in the case got in touch with me and asked me to describe what it was. And so the fact that a lawyer that I didn't know would call me up and ask me to be a witness, so to speak, suggested to me that this is a very, very rare phenomenon.
31:26 Speaker 00 But the reason I ask is that I've never been struck by lightning, but I've heard it strike, quote, nearby, nearby meaning maybe 30 yards away. It's really loud.
31:45 Speaker 01 Yeah.
31:46 Speaker 00 And I'm curious, one, you didn't write about this. One, why is it loud? And secondly, when it fried your appliances, did it leave, did the ball lightning leave any other mark, physical manifestation in your house?
32:08 Speaker 01 No.
32:09 Speaker 00 Like scar, like burn marks or?
32:10 Speaker 01 No, it didn't. It didn't leave anything. It didn't leave anything like that.
32:14 Speaker 00 Were you alone?
32:16 Speaker 01 I was alone.
32:17 Speaker 00 Did you yell? Do you remember?
32:21 Speaker 01 I'm pretty sure that my wife was in the house and I think I did yell.
32:25 Speaker 00 But she heard the, either the bang or the yell or both?
32:30 Speaker 01 She, she, yeah, she heard something. She, she either heard it or saw it because she, she was another spectator and confirmed my experience. I mean, I thought, you know, maybe I imagined the whole thing, but.
32:45 Speaker 00 Sure. And one of the conceits of.
32:54 Speaker 00 I'm blanking. Oh, Encounters of the, I can't even remember the name of it now. The Spielberg, I think it's Spielberg film.
33:01 Speaker 01 Uh, Encounters of the Third Kind?
33:04 Speaker 00 Is that what it is? I can't even remember the name now. But I think one of the great charms of that movie is that if you actually did see aliens, people would not treat you kindly. And I think it part, it could have been a comedy. I'm sure there have been some comedies like it, but, uh, part of that movie is the, is, is watching how frustrating and unbearable it would be to see something extraordinary that no one believed you. And what you just described, a ball of, of light coming through the sky and almost hitting you and going
33:47 Speaker 00 into the house. Um, I'm glad your wife heard the noise. That's all I'm gonna say.
33:53 Speaker 01 Right. Yeah. Well, I, I, I hear you and I understand what you're saying.
33:59 Speaker 00 It's, it's Close Encounters of the Third Kind. That's the title. Sorry.
34:02 Speaker 01 Yeah, Close Encounters of the Third Kind. But, but, um, you know, there are a lot of people that claim to have seen UFOs and other kinds of supernatural phenomena. Of course, UFO is not supernatural, but there are people that, that say that they saw supernatural events. And science requires that, that phenomena be repeatable in order to be believable. I mean, there are certain exceptions to that, like the, the, the origin of our universe happened only once. And yet, science still believes it because there's a lot of, of
34:46 Speaker 01 evidence and a lot of fingerprints of that event. Uh, but the method of science is that, that something should be reproducible. Um, it should be witnessed by more than one person and so on. Um, that's just the way that science works. And, uh, it's a very conservative process of science. Uh, we, we need a lot of evidence to believe something.
35:19 Speaker 01 I think they're both pluses and minuses to that approach, but on the whole, science has done very well for us civilized people. And it's brought us, you know, antibiotics and all kinds of cell phones and all the other parts of our modern world has been brought to us by science and technology.
35:47 Speaker 00 Do you have a thought on why it's so loud? Lightning when it strikes? Or when a lightning, a ball, piece of ball lightning ricochets off your dining room wall?
36:00 Speaker 01 Well, it... Of course, thunder... I mean, lightning is associated with thunder. And thunder, I'm pretty sure, is when there's a region of space that... where there's a pressure wave and it's first evacuated from air and then the air rushes back in. And that's what makes the sound.
36:39 Speaker 01 I mean, after all, sound is just vibrating molecules of air. That's what sound is. So it has something to do with removing the air from a region and then having it rush back in.
37:01 Speaker 00 And of course, we know, sound travels slower than air, than light, so it's...
37:11 Speaker 01 Right.
37:12 Speaker 00 There's a delay there.
37:14 Speaker 01 We see, yes, we see the lightning bolt first and then hear the sound.
37:17 Speaker 00 I mean, does every, does every lightning bolt have thunder? Sometimes we just don't hear it?
37:21 Speaker 01 No, I don't think so. I mean, I'm not an expert on lightning, but I do have a chapter of it in the book. But I don't think that every lightning bolt has thunder associated with it. And of course, static electricity.
37:43 Speaker 01 Which is related to lightning, an all electrical phenomenon, doesn't have any sound at all associated with it.
37:51 Speaker 00 A couple places in the book, you talk about the role of color in nature, and of course, as human beings, we like, for whatever reason, another mystery, we like color, and we like a mandarin fish, and if you haven't seen one, folks, you should buy Alan's book, or you could cheat and Google image it, but animals generally tend to specialize in either being colorful or not colorful.
38:18 Speaker 01 Right.
38:19 Speaker 00 And there's a just so story afterwards to try to understand those two differences. But those stories make sense, and, but one piece I struggled with, and I know this, but I don't understand it, some animals use color to signal that they're dangerous, because they're poisonous. You talk about frogs, the mandarin fish is an example, because general color doesn't make sense. There's a mating advantage sometimes, but in general, color's costly, because you're easily seen, and that means your predators can see you. How is it possible for a predator to learn that you're dangerous?
39:02 Speaker 00 Because if I eat you, and I die.
39:05 Speaker 01 Then I'm dead.
39:06 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's problem number one, and I also have very little, if I'm a fish, it's kind of, it's not that many, there's schools of fish, but there's not that many fish schools where baby fish can learn that mandarin fish are poisonous, and you should stay away. How does that work?
39:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, there are two ways it could work, and probably both of them operate. One is that if you're a predator, and you take a small bite out of a mandarin fish, let's just say, and you get some poison that makes you very sick, but doesn't kill you, then you would know to stay away from fish that look like that in the future. The other mechanism that probably also operates is that, as a matter of natural selection...
40:08 Speaker 01 That if your ancestor fish,
40:17 Speaker 01 well, it would have to be part of the same as the first example. That if you,
40:25 Speaker 01 if you were a predator of a Mandarin fish and took a small bite that that made you sick, but didn't kill you,
40:35 Speaker 01 then
40:38 Speaker 01 the descendants of yours,
40:42 Speaker 01 which had genes that
40:49 Speaker 01 that recognized the Mandarin fish as being dangerous, that those fish would survive, that those predators would survive. And the ones that that didn't have the genetic makeup
41:03 Speaker 01 to be wary of this particular colorful fish would not survive. So I think that that that natural selection operates. But I also think that probably even without going, you know, several generations and and and taking into account Darwinian evolution, that there are probably some predators who have had bad experiences with Mandarin fish and eating, you know, getting a little bit of poison, but not enough to kill them.
41:35 Speaker 00 And of course, that would allow other color, other fish to become colorful, imitating the poisonous ones and free riding on their.
41:42 Speaker 01 Exactly.
41:43 Speaker 00 If it works that way.
41:44 Speaker 01 Their adaptation, they would adapt to that, yeah.
41:47 Speaker 00 And then they could use it for mating or whatever. Um, yeah. Let's, um, move to some of the my favorite things in the book that I learned. And I'm going to ask you some follow up questions.
42:00 Speaker 00 I never thought about it. Uh, Mount Everest is the highest mountain on the face of the earth. It's 29,000 plus feet. Uh, I was shocked to learn it couldn't be much higher. Explain.
42:15 Speaker 00 There could never be a 80,000-foot mountain on the earth. And there are higher mountains than Everest on Mars. Why is that?
42:25 Speaker 01 Well, I think the reason is related to why glaciers can move. That is, as the mountain gets higher and higher,
42:37 Speaker 01 there's more and more pressure at the bottom of the mountain. And at some point, there's so much pressure, because there's more pressure because there's more weight as the mountain gets higher. And at some point, the pressure at the bottom can liquefy the ground underneath it.
43:04 Speaker 01 And then the mountain is not standing on a solid foundation anymore. And that liquid can escape and limit the height of the mountain because you've taken away part of the base of the mountain. So it has to do with the amount of
43:31 Speaker 01 gravity, the weight of the mountain exerts a pressure. Of course, the weight is related to gravity.
43:42 Speaker 01 The pressure at the base of the mountain
43:46 Speaker 01 basically melts the bottom of the mountain when it gets above a certain height. And planets with lower gravity and therefore less pressure at the base can have taller mountains.
44:08 Speaker 00 Presuming there's a submision force in the upthrust over time. It's not like the mountain tries to be harder or people try to build a bigger one.
44:17 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, right.
44:21 Speaker 00 Hummingbirds, when wings flap 1,200 times per minute, that's really fast. And they do it in a way that you describe in the book, a sort of semicircular oscillation. It's not constant. I mean, it's not the same every time. It reminds me a little bit of treading water, the sort of weird movement, which would be hard to describe, that you do with your arms to stay in place. I have a memory that most animals, other than humans, live for roughly the same number of heartbeats.
45:00 Speaker 01 Heartbeats.
45:01 Speaker 00 Meaning their hearts wear out after pretty much the same number of beats. So I assume hummingbirds don't live very long. Is that correct? Do you know?
45:10 Speaker 01 I don't know the answer to that question. It's a good question. My guess is, no, they don't live very long. They also have a very high rate of metabolism. I mean, to supply the enormous energy needs to flap 1,200 times a minute. And I think that's also a limit to their lifespan. The higher the metabolism we have, the more that we're taxing the body. And the parts just wear out.
45:53 Speaker 00 Yeah. You also point out, they get really warm because they're flapping their arms really hard, their wings.
46:01 Speaker 01 Right, right. Yeah, that's sort of pretty obvious. The movement creates heat.
46:08 Speaker 00 And so they have to dissipate it.
46:11 Speaker 01 They have to dissipate it, right. And so their bodies are designed to dissipate heat efficiently.
46:23 Speaker 01 It's sort of the same reason why camels have most of the fat in their bodies in a hump. So that the rest of their bodies can be thin, the skin can be thin and can dissipate heat easily because camels, and this was not a chapter of the book, but camels which live in hot places need to be able to dissipate heat easily and efficiently.
47:02 Speaker 00 Presumably, they don't pant, which is the other way that some dogs
47:06 Speaker 01 Right, yes.
47:07 Speaker 00 ...release heat.
47:08 Speaker 01 Exactly, right, exactly right. I've never seen a panting camel, but that would be another way to keep cool.
47:19 Speaker 00 I was stunned to read that there were about nine million lightning strikes per day on our earth. That seems implausible, but I'm going to take it as approximately true. It's obviously not a census. It's not a precise number. Longtime joke on the program. If you said nine million, three hundred fifty seven thousand, six hundred and forty, I probably would find it even more plausible, but...
47:49 Speaker 01 I wouldn't say that.
47:50 Speaker 00 I know you wouldn't because you're a serious person, unlike many economists. Inside joke for listeners. But how do we know that? And is a strike meaning it lands? It hits the earth?
48:06 Speaker 01 No, I think that that just means that they're visible.
48:09 Speaker 00 Okay.
48:10 Speaker 01 Nine million strikes are visible. Lightning bolts are visible. And I think most places on earth have weather stations that record these things. But even if you don't have a weather station in every hundred square miles of the earth, you can still look at the places where you do very good recording statistics and you can extrapolate from that to other parts of the earth. So that's probably the way that that number was computed.
48:44 Speaker 00 That's very cool.
48:48 Speaker 00 Saturn has 146 moons.
48:54 Speaker 00 How many, if any, are as big as ours? Do you know? If some are bigger, how big? What's like a... What's the biggest moon in the solar... in our solar system? Is it ours?
49:07 Speaker 00 Do you know? And why does Saturn have so many?
49:10 Speaker 01 No, ours is not the largest.
49:12 Speaker 00 Why does Saturn have so many?
49:15 Speaker 01 Well, it... It's probably related, although I don't know for sure, to the reason why it has rings, although the total mass in the rings is not... is very little. But, uh... It comes down to the formation of planets, uh, which was, uh, the condensation of material out of a vast revolving gas cloud uh, around the sun, uh, when our solar system first formed. And there were lots of fragments in that gas cloud.
49:59 Speaker 01 And there are other, uh, objects that broke up. There were collisions between different, uh, fragments. And, um, I don't know exactly why Saturn has so many moons, but I know that...
50:17 Speaker 01 that the conditions around each planet were a little bit different.
50:28 Speaker 01 And it was probably just an accident of the conditions
50:34 Speaker 01 around Saturn. It's probably not unrelated to the fact that Saturn has the rings, uh, but I... which also came from debris at the time that, uh...
50:49 Speaker 01 that the solar system was formed.
50:54 Speaker 01 Uh, I do know that our moon is not the largest moon in the solar system.
51:03 Speaker 01 And whether or not you call something a moon or a planet is somewhat arbitrary. I think we usually define moons as smaller bodies than planets that are orbiting things that we call planets. And of course, if a planet gets large enough, then it becomes a star. I mean, if a mass becomes large enough, then the temperatures at its center are high enough to start nuclear reactions, which is the energy source of stars.
51:43 Speaker 01 So Jupiter, of course, is the largest planet in our solar system. And if Jupiter were, say, 10 times the mass that it is, it could have been a star.
51:57 Speaker 00 I refrain from asking whether it ever has any disappointment about that. But I actually want to ask a semi-serious question along those lines before I forget. At one point, you write, you're talking about looking up at 100 billion stars. I think you're looking at the Milky Way. "Most of them," is a quote now, "most of them with their own solar systems." And almost certainly, some of those solar systems were inhabited by living beings, probably some of them smarter than us. "Because of the vast distances of space, we will probably never be in contact with
52:39 Speaker 00 those other beings, yet we are fellow spectators in this strange place of a universe we find ourselves in. We, intelligent and living beings, constituting only a small fraction of the total mass of the universe, are the only means by which the universe can observe itself, the only means by which the universe has self-awareness." Close quote. Some people think that everything has some level of consciousness. That paragraph suggests to me that you don't agree with that. Am I right?
53:17 Speaker 01 Well...
53:20 Speaker 00 I approve my Jupiter remark.
53:23 Speaker 01 Yes, right. Consciousness is almost certainly a graded phenomenon. It's not an all or nothing phenomenon. So I think crows and dolphins have a fairly high level of consciousness, although probably not as high as human beings. We know that they can recognize themselves in mirrors. We know that crows play with each other, or they exhibit activity that looks very much like our play.
53:53 Speaker 01 But I think as you go down the ladder of the animal kingdom and you get to smaller and smaller brains,
54:04 Speaker 01 that the mental capabilities decrease. And I think at some point, and where you draw the line is probably somewhat arbitrary, but at some point, that all of the mental activity that we associated with consciousness doesn't exist. I don't think an amoeba could be conscious in any meaningful sense. I also do not think that inanimate matter like rocks are conscious. I don't think they do any thinking at all.
54:40 Speaker 01 So it's a graded phenomenon.
54:41 Speaker 00 You're smiling when you say that, although there are people who think otherwise, right?
54:47 Speaker 01 Oh, I know there are people who think otherwise.
54:52 Speaker 01 But
54:55 Speaker 01 from our
54:58 Speaker 01 from everything in neuroscience,
55:03 Speaker 01 the mind and the brain are the same thing. And it's just a question of how many neurons you've got and how many connections there are between the neurons. It's not the absolute number of neurons that leads to higher brain activity and experiences like consciousness. It's also the number of connections between them, which we call synapses.
55:30 Speaker 01 So.
55:33 Speaker 01 I'm sure that people who have pets, like particularly dogs, that they feel like that those dogs are really in tune with them emotionally. And so there's certainly some level of consciousness there. But you really have to define what you mean by consciousness. And I think there are many layers of levels, many levels of consciousness.
55:59 Speaker 00 But what about the universe as a whole? Or, you know, a lot of people wax poetic about how the internet has made the earth conscious or us conscious, whatever that means, that we have some emergent level of, quote, "understanding", crowd source, whatever you want to, I don't know what you call it. Some crowdsourced level of awareness, knowledge, insight. Do you believe in any of that?
56:24 Speaker 01 So if I can rephrase your question, are you asking whether a group of intelligent beings can have sort of a group consciousness? And I think that's a matter of semantics. I mean, you could say that everything that human beings have created, all of our art and science and our civilization and our cities and buildings, that that is a group activity. And really, you can interpret that as one mega being, one mega consciousness.
57:08 Speaker 01 And you can do that if you want. But I think that each of us human beings has a very strong sense of being a separate entity, an independent entity.
57:27 Speaker 01 There's a boundary between me and the lamp on my table, and we're not the same thing, and I'm separate from it. And I don't hear the thoughts of other people in my brain, although that could change in fifty or a hundred years. So we do have such a strong sense of being independent beings that I think that we are independent beings in any meaningful sense. And any group consciousness that you attribute to a group of human beings
58:08 Speaker 01 is a metaphor, or an interpretation, or a philosophical statement.
58:19 Speaker 00 Yeah, I would describe it as a form of romance. We like to belong, human beings, and there's something romantic, poetic, whatever you want to describe it, spiritual, about the idea that we're connected to the lamp, or the sunset, or, you know, you and I are talking. We've never met. We're both born in Memphis, Tennessee. We both lived in the Boston area. We have this connection. I've read Einstein's Dreams, which is one of your earliest books, which is wonderful, recommended to listeners. So I connect to you in a certain way. But, you know, I'm gonna die, and you're gonna die,
59:04 Speaker 00 and that connection will be severed, presumably. And it might even be severed when we hang up the Zoom call, in any real sense. But I don't like that idea. I think part of the appeal of religion, and other forms of romance, true or not, is that they speak to this urge for belonging that we have.
59:25 Speaker 01 Yes.
59:28 Speaker 01 I agree with everything you said. I had forgotten that you and I were both born in Memphis, Tennessee.
59:35 Speaker 01 But I think that our feeling of belonging and need to belong, and certain other feelings that we have, including our appreciation of beauty, I think that they, that those feelings were hardwired into us through natural selection. If you go back a couple of million years ago, when our species was emerging, Homo, I don't know whether that's a genus, or I think that's a genus.
1:00:15 Speaker 01 I was never that good with zoological categorizations. When we lived in caves, and I think we know from archaeology that usually there were 15 or 20 people to a cave, something like that, that we depended on each other for survival. You know, the hunters went out and gathered food, and the others stayed in the cave and kept the fire going and took care of the children and so on. We were a highly interdependent community in those early days. And if one of us got separated from the group, you know, went out on a walk from the cave
1:01:00 Speaker 01 and couldn't find their way back or something, it was a quick death. And so, there was, the sense of being connected to other people and needing other people was really important as a survival strategy. So I think that that need was built into our brains as a survival strategy. Now, that may deromanticize the wonderful feeling of being connected to other people and being connected to nature.
1:01:47 Speaker 01 So I don't, I think it is a wonderful feeling and it's something that I honor and treasure. But I do think that it has a scientific or an evolutionary explanation. Like many of the things that we experience and the ways that we relate to the world and the thing, even the things that we value had an evolutionary origin. But we're animals. And, you know, we're magnificent animals. We've created art and science and philosophy and even economics.
1:02:32 Speaker 01 But in the end, we're animals. That's what Charles Darwin told us. And it doesn't make us any less magnificent to say that we're connected to chimpanzees and dolphins and rose.
1:02:47 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think the reason you forgot I was from Memphis is I don't have any accent from my birthplace. I lived there a year, but my parents grew up there. And so when they would be in Boston, where we lived for almost a decade, they would lose a lot of their accent. I hear it in your voice. It's still there. But when they would go home to Memphis or talk on the phone to someone from Memphis, it would get stronger. I assume that's true for you too.
1:03:23 Speaker 01 Thanks.
1:03:24 Speaker 00 I'm sure there's an evolutionary explanation for it as well. But I want to close with an observation. It's not a coherent thought, and so I'm not going to try to make it a question, but I'm going to let you just respond to it. You used a common metaphor that, of course, you didn't mean literally. When we talked about creation, you said, "The fingerprints of the creation are still present." And I couldn't help but think about the Sistine Chapel and the ceiling where Michelangelo imagines God.
1:04:02 Speaker 00 Animating human beings with a fingertip. It's a magnificent thing. And as you alluded to briefly in our conversation and in the book, humans have created some really extraordinary, beautiful things through intention. The Sistine Chapel is one of my top 10 probably, the ceiling of it. And we don't like, I don't know, maybe you feel differently, but as human beings, and whether this is, you can think of this as either evolutionary or divine, we like causation a lot.
1:04:41 Speaker 00 We like the idea that there's fingerprints, there's things that hint at the origins of things. And it's just interesting how compelling that is. And I know you didn't mean that that way. And I don't believe that God has a hand. I don't even think, I don't even know if Michelangelo thought God had a hand, but he wanted to show something causal there. Anyway, just any thoughts on that?
1:05:12 Speaker 01 Well, we desire order.
1:05:15 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:05:16 Speaker 01 And I think that's at the root of what you're talking about, that we don't want to live, I mean, the universe is strange enough as it is. And we shudder at the thought that things can happen randomly and accidentally without cause and effect relations. It just means, you know, anything could happen. You know, you could start floating up in the air, or the books on your bookshelf could start coming out at any moment, or the sun could turn into a pumpkin. You know, we want, because the universe is as strange as it is, we would like there
1:06:01 Speaker 01 to be some explanation, some reason, some cause and effect relations for everything.
1:06:11 Speaker 01 That we see. And that was really part of the motivation of a famous book written 2,000 years ago by the Roman poet Lucretius. Who wrote a book called The Nature of Things. In which he suggested the atomic process of that everything is made of atoms. That obey cause and effect relations. Everything is material. And part of the motivation was to diminish the power of the gods to perform acts at
1:06:52 Speaker 01 random and upon whimsy. And that was one of the motivations for his proposing the material atomic hypothesis underlying all phenomena. To diminish the power of the gods. I mean, he still believed in the gods, but he thought that they should stay in their place and let us human beings conduct our lives as we would like to.
1:07:24 Speaker 00 But we do like order and at the same time, as you point out in the book, you want some kind of unpredictability. You don't like the idea that we would literally know everything about what's coming next.
1:07:43 Speaker 01 Yes. Well, that's, that's an interesting, you're right, and that's another interesting facet of our human minds. I think it's related to the fact that, and my wife is a painter and she always talks to me about what makes a good painting. And a totally symmetrical painting is not as interesting as a painting that has a little bit of asymmetry or a painting that has a little dot of red paint over in the right hand corner. Something that breaks the perfect symmetry.
1:08:23 Speaker 01 So it is an interesting aspect of the human mind and the human psyche that although we like most things to be orderly and predictable.
1:08:35 Speaker 01 And symmetric, do we also like a little bit of unpredictability? And if you read a novel, and the actions of characters are completely predictable, the novel is not as interesting to you. It's always nice to have a few surprises.
1:09:00 Speaker 00 Sure. My guest today has been Alan Lightman. His book is The Miraculous From the Material. Alan, thanks for being part of Econ Talk.
1:09:15 Speaker 01 Well, thank you, Russ, for inviting me again to be part of your very stimulating program.
1:09:29 Speaker 00 This is Econ Talk, part of the Library of Economics and Liberty. For more Econ Talk, go to econTalk.org, where you can also comment on today's podcast and find links and readings related to today's conversation. The sound engineer for Econ Talk is Rich Goyette. I'm your host, Russ Roberts. Thanks for listening. Talk to you on Monday.
Next Terrorism, Israel, and Dreams of Peace (with Haviv Rettig Gur) Page updated November 7, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated