Pod Insights Decoder Why the TikTok ban won't solve the US's online privacy problems About this episode Today, we’re talking about the brand-new TikTok ban — and how years of Congressional inaction on a federal privacy law helped lead us to this moment of apparent national panic about algorithmic social media.
This is a thorny discussion, and to help break it all down, I invited Verge senior policy reporter Lauren Feiner on the show. Lauren has been closely covering efforts to ban TikTok for years now, and she’s also watched Congress fail to pass meaningful privacy regulation for even longer. We’ll go over how we got here, what this means for both TikTok and efforts to pass new privacy legislation, and what might happen next.
Links:
Biden signs TikTok ‘ban’ bill into law — The Verge
TikTok ban: all the news on attempts to ban the video platform — The Verge
Anyone want to buy TikTok? — Vergecast
Congress takes on TikTok, privacy, and AI — Vergecast
Tiktok vows to fight 'unconstitutional' US ban — BBC
‘Thunder Run’: Behind lawmakers’ secretive push to pass the TikTok bill — NYT
On TikTok, resignation and frustration after potential ban of app — NYT
Lawmakers unveil new bipartisan digital privacy bill after years of impasse — The Verge
A real privacy law? House lawmakers are optimistic this time — The Verge
Congress is trying to stop discriminatory algorithms again — The Verge
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt and was edited by Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Companies shouldn't have to choose between speed and control. Amex Corporate connects cards with flexible spending controls and real-time visibility to help teams adapt faster. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is Amex Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:24 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
0:33 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
0:41 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
0:56 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, we're talking about the TikTok ban, quote unquote, the TikTok ban, the bill that will force TikTok to either sell itself or shut down in the United States. And we're going to talk about how years of congressional inaction on a federal privacy law helped lead us to this moment of apparent national panic about algorithmic social media generally and TikTok specifically. The law that Joe Biden signed that would force TikTok to either sell itself or shut down arrived with an almost shocking suddenness. The House of Representatives passed their version of the TikTok ban last weekend by stuffing it into a foreign aid package for Israel and Ukraine. That particular tactic of jamming, sometimes totally unrelated, legislation into a time-sensitive, so-called must-pass bill is
1:41 Speaker 03 often the quickest way, or these days, the only way, to get something in front of both chambers of Congress and signed into law. And the strategy worked. Last Tuesday, the Senate, which did not want to stall yet more aid to oversee US allies, voted to approve the foreign aid package. And President Biden signed it into law Wednesday morning, an achievement that both sides of the aisle hailed as a victory. But the fight over TikTok is just beginning. This new bill kept intact the compromise that TikTok parent company ByteDance could avoid a US ban by selling itself to another entity. But ByteDance's response to the bill is that it's a ban, no matter what anyone says, and that it will fight the US government in the court system. That fight could get drawn out and ugly. The TikTok drama is framed around China,
2:24 Speaker 03 but when you drill down, it really has a lot to do with privacy law, or more specifically, the fact that the United States doesn't have one. Most of the concerns around TikTok are around its stewardship of personal data. What is the company doing with all of our data? And what ultimately is TikTok's true relationship to the Chinese government? On top of that, there's debate around something called algorithmic transparency. Why does TikTok show us what it does? And does that make the platform ripe for things like election interference, influence operations, or other risks to democracy? At any point, Congress could turn its attention from banning one single app and pass federal privacy legislation or an algorithmic transparency law. Both of these ideas have been debated for years. There are even options. A federal privacy framework now has real momentum for the first time in a long time
3:09 Speaker 03 in the form of something called the American Privacy Rights Act, or APRA. But the TikTok ban could complicate those efforts. And Congress has a lot of incentive to drag its feet during an election year. This is a messy, complicated discussion that goes back years with lots of players and lots of drama. So to help break it down, I invited Verge senior policy reporter Lauren Feiner. Lauren has been closely covering the effort to ban TikTok for years now, and she's also watched Congress fail to pass meaningful privacy regulation for even longer. We're going to go over how we got here, what this means for TikTok, and efforts to pass new privacy legislation, and what might happen next. All right, the TikTok ban and privacy law in the United States. Here we go.
3:59 Speaker 03 Lauren Feiner, welcome to Decoder.
4:00 Speaker 04 Thanks for having me.
4:01 Speaker 03 There is a lot to talk about. We started talking about this episode thinking we were going to talk about privacy legislation and the renewed momentum to pass a privacy bill. And then the United States government went and banned TikTok along the way today, like earlier today. Joe Biden signed the bill that would force TikTok to sell, divest itself, or shut down. What is going on there? What happened last weekend to make this move so much faster? What does this bill actually say? What's the status of things?
4:28 Speaker 04 Yeah, it definitely feels like everything in the tech policy world just turned upside down in the past week. Basically, what happened is both chambers of Congress managed to pass this bill as part of a broader foreign aid package that would effectively ban TikTok unless its China-based parent company ByteDance manages to sell it within a year. Saturday, we got the House vote. Yesterday, we got the Senate vote. And then this morning, Biden signed it into law.
5:00 Speaker 03 Talk about the politics of this for one second. The House had passed a sort of straight up and down version of this ban a while ago. And it went nowhere in the Senate. Biden said, I'll sign it if it hits my desk. Then they extended the timeline where they had to divest it or sell it to a year, right? It's nine months plus three months of discretionary time for whoever is president if there's momentum. What changed about the politics of it? Because the thing that really gets me is they passed a TikTok ban today and none of them talked about it. Joe Biden, his signing statement for the bill was all about aid to Ukraine and Israel and Gaza. Nothing about TikTok. No one seems to be focused on it. It's just like a thing they did in the background. What's going on with the politics of this?
5:39 Speaker 04 Back when the House passed the TikTok legislation as a standalone bill, I mean, that was the headline, right? Because that was the one piece of legislation that was on the table, kind of on its own essentially, for an up or down vote. And it passed pretty overwhelmingly in the House. Then it went over to the Senate. And over there, some senators were really for this legislation and some were, you know, a little bit more noncommittal. So it seemed like, you know, maybe this is just going to stall out. Maybe they'll just take a lot of time going through the legislative process and everyone will forget about it. And then the election will happen and it'll be way in the rearview mirror. But instead, what happened was
6:22 Speaker 04 The House decided to bundle this legislation with a foreign aid package. So that's money to allies that a lot of lawmakers really want to send. And so it really incentivized Congress to pass this bill because it was just one piece of this enormous package of legislation. And because of that, and because they extended the timeline for divestment to something that was more palatable to more lawmakers, it was able to pretty much sail through.
6:53 Speaker 03 You've been a Capitol Hill reporter for a long time. You know that Congress is wheeling and dealing at all times. For the person who isn't so much in the machinations of Congress, is this fair play? Is this a thing that is normal? Or is this banning TikTok is unpopular, but providing aid to Ukraine and Israel is popular? So we're just going to slide it in under the table?
7:12 Speaker 04 Packaging bills together in this way is pretty common. Basically, there's two ways essentially that a bill can make it into law. And one way is the first way they tried to do it with TikTok, which was pass a standalone bill, have it go through both chambers on its own, and then have the president sign it. That's one way to do it. But obviously, there's a lot of moving parts in there. It's pretty easy to just throw sand in the gears of any kind of step in that process. So, you know, we don't really see so many bills passing that way. What we often see is bills packaged together with some must pass piece of legislation. So, you know, you'll hear about this a lot of the times around the National Defense Authorization
7:57 Speaker 04 Act, or, you know, some must pass budget bill, or something to keep the government running. And lawmakers will just stuff other pieces of legislation in there so that it all moves together. Because then it becomes more of a calculus of, you know, are we going to fight over each individual piece of legislation in here? And which pieces of legislation do we really care about? Would we really not want to see become law? And those are the ones that are really going to be at the top of the list for negotiation.
8:27 Speaker 03 So it's a must pass bill, like it's layered into it. They kind of avoid the political fallout, but there's already fallout, right? Like TikTok is out there. The CEO of TikTok, Chew, is on the app saying, we're going to fight this. We're going to file a lawsuit. They're trampling your rights. Do lawmakers seem phased by any of this?
8:42 Speaker 04 Not really. I think that's the simple answer. We heard Senator Mark Warner, who leads the Senate Intelligence Committee on the floor yesterday, saying like, look, you know, we know a lot of young Americans really like this app and we're not trying to ban it. We want to have a different ownership structure because we think there are national security issues. And that's in the line from a lot of lawmakers who really do say that they are looking for a different ownership structure that they think will be in the interest of US national security. Now, you know, TikTok is saying that's not the case. And certainly there've been some lawmakers who whose rhetoric kind of goes beyond that.
9:25 Speaker 04 And obviously that's what TikTok is pointing to. And they're making this an issue about free speech and free expression on their platform.
9:35 Speaker 03 Let's talk about the actual mechanics of the bill then. TikTok, again, they're saying this is a ban. Listen to the lawmakers. They're saying it's a ban. Make no mistake, it's a ban. It's kind of up to them, right? I mean, the choices in front of them are sell the thing or shut it down. Like they have to choose. What does the bill actually do? What is the mechanism by which it will ban TikTok if that is the outcome?
9:54 Speaker 04 TikTok's parent company, ByteDance, would have this period of up to 12 months to divest TikTok in order to allow it to keep operating in the US. Otherwise, basically, how this ban would take effect is that essentially app stores would not be able to distribute or, you know, update the app. So, you know, maybe you'll still have the app on your phone for a little bit if ByteDance chooses not to sell and, you know, the app is actually banned. But, you know, it's eventually not going to update. It's not going to really work after some period of time.
10:31 Speaker 03 So the regulation is not pointed specifically at ByteDance. It's pointed at the app stores?
10:36 Speaker 04 Pretty much, yeah.
10:38 Speaker 03 How do Apple and Google feel about this?
10:40 Speaker 04 I haven't really seen much from them. You know, I think they're probably just going to keep out of it. If the government tells them you have to do this, then I think they're going to follow. But yeah, ultimately, it's somewhat ByteDance's decision if they want to sell. And then, you know, if this bill is upheld, then yeah, the App Store companies are going to have to follow the law.
11:03 Speaker 03 I feel like we've been in the circus before, you know, the Trump years. There was a rumor that a Trump rally was sparsely attended because of a TikTok prank. No one knows that was true, but then the follow on rumor was that Trump heard this. He got all mad on his plane, coming home from the sparsely attended rally and said, I'm banning TikTok. And then there was a furious rush where Microsoft was going to buy it, or maybe Walmart was going to buy it. And Oracle did Project Texas, where they store the data, and maybe Oracle would buy it in the end. What's different between that time and this time?
11:30 Speaker 04 I think there were basically two differences in terms of the substance. You know, one difference is just the mechanism that they chose to use to carry out this, this kind of idea of getting TikTok to either change its ownership structure or face a ban. You know, the Trump administration was doing it under essentially just another statute. And then the second thing was the Trump administration was doing it through the executive branch. And in some ways, that's kind of inherently weaker than going through Congress. You know, courts are much more likely to uphold congressional action than executive action. You know, so I think that was something that just was a more inherent weakness in that version.
12:13 Speaker 03 Does TikTok have to sell to a US-based company? Oracle, Microsoft, Apple, whoever?
12:19 Speaker 04 That's not a requirement. It's basically just they can't be owned by another company that's controlled by a foreign adversary. So they can't really sell to like, you know, a Russian company, for example. But, you know, they could sell to a European company, they could sell to a lot of different companies. But, you know, realistically, I think it's a decent bet that there's a lot of US companies that would be the ones able to, you know, actually carry out this deal.
12:47 Speaker 03 ByteDance has obviously put out a response. They say they're going to sue. Is there a substance there? Do we know how they're actually going to respond? Or is it just sort of smoke and fire right now?
12:55 Speaker 04 I mean, I would take them at their word that they're going to present a legal challenge. This is an existential threat, so I don't see why they wouldn't. I think, you know, it remains to be seen what way they choose to go after that. But I think the ones that seem likely are they'll probably raise First Amendment issues with the law saying that, you know, their own First Amendment rights are being violated and, you know, those are our, if it's users that engage on the platform. And they also might say, this is a bill of attainder. This is a piece of legislation that's targeting and singling us out as one company, rather than, you know, a broad law that's applied to many companies. And the law does name ByteDance and TikTok.
13:39 Speaker 03 It sure does.
13:41 Speaker 04 But in theory, it could apply to other similarly situated companies in the future.
13:46 Speaker 03 So I want to come back to TikTok. We'll talk about what happens next and who I buy and all that sort of thing. But inside of this is a big question about what evidence lawmakers saw of something bad happening with TikTok and it's a sensible Chinese control. Other bad things that can happen on social media platforms. Basically, what scared them into banning TikTok? And I think the main thing is that there's an app like TikTok that became dominant in the United States. We have no federal restrictions on data collection or privacy or algorithmic recommendations for a variety of reasons. We don't have those things. And so those policy problems just run into each other. We've been talking about both those policy problems for years. We've been yelling at Mark Zuckerberg and Jack Dorsey until they turned into
14:29 Speaker 03 weird statues and then Zuck like emerged from the statue as some sort of MMA fighter. None of that's fixed because we banned TikTok, right?
14:36 Speaker 04 That's right. Yeah. I mean, it really, I think by design in a way, it really deals with this one, you know, singular issue of TikTok's ownership by a China-based parent company. You know, it's really not getting into everything else and all the other issues there are in the tech space. It's really dealing with this one discrete problem.
14:57 Speaker 03 Is there any sense on the Hill that, okay, we solved the TikTok problem? That was the big bad. That's China brainwashing all the kids. Now we should come back to privacy and we should come back to algorithmic transparency and all the other stuff we've been talking about.
15:11 Speaker 04 I think there is somewhat of that sense. You know, I don't know if it's, you know, one thing leads directly to the other. But I think we are seeing a rise of privacy being back on the table, which, you know, we haven't seen for a long time. And I think in a sense, it would certainly strengthen lawmakers' arguments with the public, perhaps, that, you know, we really are tackling all these different aspects of technology that we're concerned about and not just, you know, singling out one company.
15:39 Speaker 03 To me personally, the big danger of TikTok is the absolute opaque nature of its algorithm. I don't know why TikTok Shop is suddenly trying to sell me off-brand DeWalt batteries, but it's trying to sell me that every single day. And it will not rest until I burn my house down. There's also a lot of concerns about privacy, but data brokers in this country are running rampant. Like, if you want to steal a bunch of Americans' personal information, you can just do it. Like, that seems like a problem that is not specific to TikTok. And the algorithmic transparency issue is specific to TikTok, but obviously it spreads across all the other platforms. It feels like we're pretty close on a privacy bill for the first time in a long time. Tell us about the state of privacy law right now and then tell us what's happening with a potential bill.
16:20 Speaker 04 Privacy seemed to be an issue that had, you know, just kind of simmered out for a while. You know, back in 2022, this became a big thing all of a sudden because there was a new bipartisan framework that was supported by a bunch of really important lawmakers in the House and Senate that seemed like, you know, a big push for comprehensive privacy legislation. And then that kind of petered out. Then we get to this period where, you know, we're talking about TikTok. We're talking about all these things that are not privacy. And then suddenly we get a new privacy bill that's not yet a full bill. It's a discussion draft from Senate Commerce Committee Chair Maria Cantwell
17:01 Speaker 04 and House Energy and Commerce Committee Chair Kathy McMorris Rogers. And they worked together to create this new comprehensive privacy bill that's really promising because of these two chairs leading it. And in particular, Chair Cantwell had been the one who didn't sign on to the earlier version of comprehensive privacy reform. So to have her on this legislation really indicates maybe we could go somewhere.
17:32 Speaker 03 There's realistic momentum on a privacy bill. It might actually happen, which has not seemed realistic for a long time. To set the stage, what's the current framework of privacy law in the United States?
17:44 Speaker 04 Right now, we really just have a patchwork of legislation. There are certain like specialized privacy laws like HIPAA that everyone's familiar with for health data.
17:55 Speaker 03 Are they familiar with it?
17:58 Speaker 04 In broad strokes. And then you have just like a series of state laws that are attempting to step in where the federal government hasn't to provide more general privacy laws for people's online information. But there's really no national framework for just general data privacy. So that's really the state of where things are in the US today.
18:19 Speaker 03 One thing I always think about is terms of service agreements. I lead a sparkling social life, constantly thinking about terms of service agreements. That's where people kind of expect the privacy action to be, right? You're going to sign up for Instagram and Instagram is going to have a privacy policy. And that means something or doesn't mean something. But there's nothing like uniformly regulating any platform's privacy policy. There's just all these sort of random state laws that are weaker and stronger in some places than others.
18:50 Speaker 04 Yeah, pretty much. I mean, I think a lot of times those privacy laws, you know, I would really think of them as like protecting the business from legal liability and just kind of covering the ground on, you know, what sort of things they collect and trying to provide some level of information to the consumer. But, you know, I think we all know that no one really reads those privacy policies or those terms of service. People really just click through and that's something that regulators have contemplated cracking down on more as well.
19:17 Speaker 03 There are privacy bills in some of the states. I think it's 15 states have privacy bills. Are those effective? Do we see that people in some states have their privacy better protected than people in other states?
19:27 Speaker 04 I think a lot of these laws are relatively new. They are providing more privacy rights than have ever existed for Americans before. So, you know, I think there's just a lot more that people in those states are entitled to when it comes to their data. And I think even more importantly, maybe, it's actually pushing Congress to really take this more seriously because the more and more states that are passing their own privacy laws, the more businesses that have to comply with them are saying, all right, well, you know, we'll really get on board with the national law because this is just really difficult to comply with.
20:03 Speaker 03 That's one piece of the political puzzle that I think is underappreciated, that as you get 50 different laws in 50 different states, it just becomes harder to do business across the country. Is that providing any real momentum to the federal bill? Are these companies lobbying for a federal bill to avoid that outcome or are they just dealing with it?
20:23 Speaker 04 No, I think that's absolutely what's happening. California was an early mover here. It used to be, you know, we're only really talking about California and their privacy law. Now, you know, we have 15 states with their own privacy laws that companies are having to deal with. That's a much different landscape than we've seen in the past and I think is starting to, you know, form this reality that lawmakers have kind of known was coming for a long time but wasn't as tangible. There's just this huge patchwork of laws that businesses have to comply with and they are hearing from businesses that this is really difficult, especially for smaller and lesser resourced businesses.
21:01 Speaker 03 Yeah, and I think everybody wants to see some smaller companies compete with the big companies and reducing their compliance costs just seems like part of the picture. One more question about this. The states have really been leading the way on internet regulation for the past several years now because Congress is so paralyzed, because attacking big tech is a winner for any politician at any level. There are a lot of laws now about regulating the internet in various states, in various directions, at various levels of efficacy. Overall, is that providing pressure on Congress to act? Like, is this dynamic playing out more systematically? That, okay, there's a weird patchwork of laws. We need a federal law to come in and preempt them all so we can continue running our businesses.
21:45 Speaker 03 Is that happening in all of the cases or just in privacy?
21:50 Speaker 04 I think we see it most in privacy because this discussion has been around for a long time and we've seen states really take up the issue of privacy for a while now. But I think we're starting to see it in other areas, too. You know, other states are contemplating how to deal with AI and deep fakes. States are thinking about, you know, even TikTok. We've seen, you know, Montana move forward with a version of a TikTok ban. So I think we are seeing some version of pressure, but nothing has risen to the level of pressure from the states as much as privacy, just because of how long it's been around and how much we are seeing tangible laws around it.
22:32 Speaker 03 We need to take a quick break. When we're back, Laura and I talk about the new proposed federal privacy bill, what it does and what might happen next.
22:43 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bullspend and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
22:52 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
23:00 Speaker 01 Cut the bullspend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
23:13 Speaker 05 College football is back. So Hilton called in me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
23:43 Speaker 06 Propel Fitness Water with Gatorade Electrolytes, zero sugar and vitamins. Propel hydrates better than water to help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you? Propel with Gatorade Electrolytes.
24:01 Speaker 03 We're back with Verge senior policy reporter Lauren Finer discussing Congress's latest attempt at a federal privacy law and what's different this time around.
24:09 Speaker 03 So let's talk about this bill. There is a bill in Congress with some momentum and some cosponsors, one of which is important to understand and talk about. It's the American Privacy Rights Act. APRA rolls right off the tongue. What is in the American Privacy Rights Act?
24:25 Speaker 04 This bill is still a discussion draft, so that means it wasn't yet formally introduced. But essentially, it was authored by Senator Maria Cantwell, who is the Chair of the Senate Commerce Committee, and Congresswoman Kathy McMorris Rogers, who leads the House Energy and Commerce Committee. Basically, there's a few different things that this bill would do. Overall, one of the big things it would do is kind of focus on having large companies minimize the data they collect in the first place. So rather than this, you know, other framework that you might hear about sometimes called notice and consent, where it's more about, you know, having consumers just read a notice and consent to having their data collected, they're really trying to emphasize that companies
25:09 Speaker 04 should really only collect data when it's really necessary to what they're doing. So that by itself would kind of lower the amount of data that's collected on consumers in the first place. And then it would give consumers the ability to correct or export their data. They'd be able to opt out of targeted advertising and out of algorithms for important life decisions. So things like whether they get certain employment or housing, things like that, that could have, you know, important implications on like civil liberties. And it also would importantly give individuals a right to sue if they think that their rights are being violated, but also give companies the chance to correct any information or missteps
25:54 Speaker 04 before that happens.
25:56 Speaker 03 So this is the list of things. Every privacy bill has sort of looked like this. We should lower the amount of data. We should give people more controls. We should let you opt out of various kinds of algorithms, especially for things like housing and insurance and education where the bias in the algorithms is just very easy to show over and over again, and we want those things to be as equitable as possible. Why is this bill the one that seems like it has momentum?
26:23 Speaker 04 You know, first, it's worth rewinding a little bit back to 2022 when we had another bill that rolls off the tongue, the ADPPA, which was the American Data Privacy and Protection Act. And that bill was a pretty popular bipartisan framework. It was introduced by the leaders of the House Energy and Commerce Committee at the time and the Republican ranking member on the Senate Commerce Committee at the time. And that bill was, you know, pretty similar in a lot of ways and, you know, would do a lot of the same things that the APRA would do. What's different here is, you know, a little bit about how the preemption of state laws works and how the private right of action or the ability of
27:07 Speaker 04 individuals to sue would work. But I think one of the key things that's different is who's leading the bill. And, you know, Senator Maria Cantwell, who's the head of the Senate Commerce Committee, that is the Committee of Jurisdiction here, kind of stood in the way of the ADPPA before. And so it's really significant that she is leading the charge on this particular proposal.
27:30 Speaker 03 So if people are not familiar with Maria Cantwell, she's a Democrat from Washington. She is the chair of the Senate Commerce Committee. Why did she stand in the way of the previous bill?
27:40 Speaker 04 Senator Cantwell would basically say that she felt like the enforcement mechanisms weren't strong enough in the ADPPA. She really was pushing for a strong privacy bill. But I think, you know, a lot of people who have worked on this were a little bit confused about, you know, what exactly it was that was keeping her from this because, you know, any bipartisan bill, I think we all know, is going to end up being a compromise. And we're working from a place where there's zero national privacy standard. And states are continuing to move forward even more quickly with their own state privacy laws. So I think it was kind of confusing for some advocates in this space, why she was standing in the way. But, you know, she would point to things like enforcement mechanisms and preemption
28:24 Speaker 04 as areas that she thought could be strengthened.
28:26 Speaker 03 You've been covering Congress for a long time. You've got a powerful committee chair who says, I need better enforcement provisions in this bill if I'm going to let it through. I know you all want it, but here's the concern that I'm saying out, better enforcement provisions. Why didn't they just add better enforcement provisions?
28:43 Speaker 04 I think sometimes behind the scenes, there's different negotiations that happen and, you know, different leaders will have different sticking points where they put their foot down and say, we don't want this to happen, whether that's, you know, because of lobbying by companies, whether that's because of some, you know, deeply held belief about a certain aspect of law. I'm not quite sure why they didn't just add that in, but I would imagine that there were some other lawmakers who maybe wouldn't have been on board with that if they were to change some of that at the time. That kind of fell apart and now you kind of have this new coalition trying to form around this other framework.
29:21 Speaker 03 So does the new bill, the APRA, does it have the enforcement provisions that Cantwell wants?
29:28 Speaker 04 It does. So it would basically let consumers sue for their data rights in a shorter timeframe than the ADPPA would have allowed. You know, it does have kind of a mechanism to keep this from being, from companies from being sued just like over and over and over again because it lets the companies cure whatever misstep they might have made or that they're being accused of before the lawsuit actually goes through. But it also really empowers users to sue for their data rights and, you know, would grant them really significant ability to seek damages.
30:02 Speaker 03 There are some concerns about this bill though, right? The EFF has a long list of things it would want changed. Some privacy advocates are saying, look, the state bills are actually stronger. We should see how those play out. Are those concerns real? Are they illusory? Is it people trying to get too much from an already sort of compromise process?
30:20 Speaker 04 With any bipartisan compromise, it's not, not everyone's going to get what they want. So I think that's kind of what you see with this bill. You know, some privacy advocates seem pretty supportive of it, but maybe want a few tweaks here and there. Some are a little bit less supportive, but I think overall, we're seeing positive reaction to the idea that a national privacy law is back on the table.
30:43 Speaker 03 So it's back on the table. We have to do how a bill becomes a law now because you said it hasn't been formally introduced. It's been publicized. It has to get formally introduced. I'm sure there's a series of votes. Other lawmakers have to support it, including House Republicans, who are charitably described as a bit chaotic right now. They do have the majority, though. Walk us through that process. How likely is any of that to happen at every stage?
31:07 Speaker 04 You know, even though this is a discussion draft at this point, I think we can feel pretty confident that it will begin to move pretty quickly through the legislative process, given that both the authors of this bill lead their respective committees in the House and Senate and therefore can set the agenda and say when a bill comes to a vote in their committee. We just saw a legislative hearing earlier this week that included the privacy discussion draft in the House. Once the lawmakers decide to introduce the bill, they can pretty quickly move forward with hearings and voting on the bill itself to pass it along. At that point, then it's up to the leaders in the House and Senate to bring it to the floor,
31:49 Speaker 04 assuming that it passes the committee level. That can be a little bit up in the air because there's a lot of different things that are lobbying for floor time. So, you know, maybe it ends up in a must-pass package that kind of ushers it through. Maybe House and Senate leaders decide that it's a priority to put these bills on the floor, given that they're bipartisan nature. But that's really probably one of the bigger questions is what happens once it leaves the committee level.
32:17 Speaker 03 Is there support from the White House that we've heard? Would Joe Biden sign a bill like this if it hit his desk?
32:22 Speaker 04 I don't think we've seen explicit statements about that yet, but I think privacy is something that would generally align with some of the principles that the Biden administration has talked about before. You know, we know they're concerned about AI and kids' online safety and, you know, privacy is kind of seen as an underpinning of a lot of the things that people are concerned about with those things as well.
32:47 Speaker 03 Let's get real for one second. We might not have a House Speaker by May 1st, right? I mean, the Republicans are in pure, open, internal warfare over some of the aid packages for Ukraine and Israel. It's also an election year. This is kind of a political risk to pass a big privacy bill that will enable new lawsuits. Is this politically realistic this year?
33:11 Speaker 04 Look, I've been covering tech policy for about five years. Privacy has always been a discussion since I've been covering it and probably well before. And we have not gotten a national privacy law. So I would not hold my breath that this is going to pass this year, no matter what lawmakers are saying. But, you know, there are some promising signs and, you know, who is actually sponsoring this legislation? The political will around it and the fact that, you know, it's something that generally both sides want. Maybe there is some pathway for this to make it through. But again, like I said, I wouldn't necessarily hold my breath for it.
33:52 Speaker 03 Let me ask you about sort of the other side of the tech policy world. We know lawmakers have some interest. We know that there's some cautious enthusiasm for this bill. What is the tech industry saying? Because they spend a lot of money lobbying. They have probably killed some of these bills along the way. Is the vibe on this one from the Googles and Facebooks of the world positive, negative, neutral? What's the situation?
34:14 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think we're seeing kind of a mixed reaction, I guess. I think Microsoft came out in support of the proposal.
34:23 Speaker 03 Microsoft never met a proposed regulation it doesn't like. I just want to say that for the audience. They are probably the sharpest lobbyists out there right now.
34:30 Speaker 04 Yes, that's definitely true. Then, you know, you see like NetChoice, which is a big group that represents a lot of the social media companies. They kind of say like, this is like a good start, but there's a long way to go. They say it fails to create a true national standard and doesn't cover all data collectors equally. So I think we're going to see a mixed bag of reactions here. And, you know, I think as things get closer to introduction and passage through the committee or otherwise, we might see some of these statements, you know, more tailored to the key issues that arise.
35:06 Speaker 03 I keep thinking about the ads that Meta ran on a bunch of publications for years that just said, "Facebook welcomes regulation."
35:14 Speaker 03 Those ads were basically to preempt regulation, like Facebook welcomes regulation and that got a bunch of people to go talk to Facebook and then nothing happened. And it seemed like Facebook got what it wanted, which is to be able to say, we welcome regulation without ever being regulated. Is this when the clock hits zero on that strategy? Like, you can only say you welcome regulation for so long until you have to actually welcome the regulation?
35:39 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean, I think that's a strategy that we see kind of over and over with legislation that impacts business. A lot of tech companies have come to realize it's better to get out ahead and say, we support regulation. And here are the kinds of regulations that we support, because they don't want to end up with a bill that they don't like coming down to a vote. So I think a lot of tech companies have gotten a little bit more wise and mature about, you know, we have to be involved in this process from the get go, or there's still going to be regulation made about us that we didn't participate in. So that also means that once regulation actually comes to the table, they can take out their red pen and say, you know, yeah, like, we like this, this, this, but not this, this, this, and kind of throw some sand in the gears.
36:24 Speaker 03 Has a federal privacy law just been in the machine for long enough that this bill or some version of this bill has gone through that process and is more realistic? I'm contrasting this to antitrust right now, where any antitrust effort is met with the most furious gnashing of teeth possible. Like, there isn't some middle ground over there. And maybe that's just going to take a long time to figure it out. But on privacy, it feels like, yeah, there's a middle ground. Like, we've been talking about it enough that there are some solutions that everybody agrees on now.
36:59 Speaker 04 That's probably a good way to think about it. One thing that I think is sometimes important to remember is that lawmakers, they sit on a lot of different committees. You know, it can be easy for someone who's more of like a subject matter expert to be like, you know, doesn't every member of Congress know about this? But really, it's just, you know, members of these committees that are, you know, in the weeds on this, week to week or month to month. And, you know, other members of Congress are working on other things and not as in the weeds. So I think Privacy is maybe something that has permeated out of the committee at this point a little bit more because I think there's just a more general awareness about it. We're aware of these state laws. We're aware of, you know, online data privacy generally.
37:40 Speaker 04 Antitrust is a little bit of a wonkier topic that takes a little bit more understanding and, you know, studying from lawmakers to grasp and understand the nuances of. But yeah, I think that's probably fair to think of it that way, that maybe this has been around long enough that lawmakers at least have a general idea of some key discussions here.
38:02 Speaker 03 We have to take another quick break. When we're back, Lauren and I get into how the TikTok ban plays into the latest privacy push.
38:12 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard, but not the pipeline? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
38:22 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
38:29 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
38:43 Speaker 05 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
39:12 Speaker 06 Propel Fitness Water. With Gatorade electrolytes, zero sugar, and vitamins, Propel hydrates better than water to help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you? Propel with Gatorade Electrolytes.
39:31 Speaker 03 We're back with Verge senior policy reporter Lauren Feiner to discuss how the TikTok ban might affect bills around privacy and algorithmic transparency. If you look at a privacy bill as one component of the set of problems with TikTok, this bill might address that component, right? We don't know what TikTok is doing with our data. We want people to be in more control of it. We certainly want to know where that data is going. Here's a bill like this will let people sue TikTok if something goes awry and they'll have more control. The other part of it is like the big systemic question of the internet right now, which is what are these algorithms doing to us? And there's not a lot regulating that or even requiring the companies to be transparent about that. Is there any action over there?
40:15 Speaker 03 Because that feels like the other part of the system that everyone is constantly talking about, whether the platforms are owned by American companies or Chinese companies.
40:22 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's definitely another big part of the issue. I think there is a bill out there called the Algorithmic Justice and Online Platform Transparency Act that would, you know, try to provide more transparency around algorithms and how, you know, content is amplified. But, you know, right now, we don't really have a lot of insight into why certain things are pushed and others aren't. That's really kind of within a company's own discretion. And I think there's also, you know, a push in Congress to give researchers more access to information that maybe it's fair for a company not to want, just the general public to have access to for its own business reasons, but would be helpful for researchers to be
41:07 Speaker 04 able to access so that we can understand more about how these things work and the impact that they have on us.
41:12 Speaker 03 Are those bills anywhere close to reality? Chart them against the privacy bill. The privacy bill is at 75%. I'm not even sure if it's at 75. Let's say it's at 75. Where are the algorithmic justice bills?
41:27 Speaker 04 I think they are at certainly a lower level, but I could see them being packaged together with something like a privacy bill. If they're attached to a larger piece of legislation and they move together, I think, you know, that could kind of like quickly change. It's hard to say because these aren't as sweeping proposals necessarily as a privacy bill that might be given, you know, time on the floor on its own. But they could be kind of like pinned on to that and we could see them move more quickly.
41:58 Speaker 03 Let's end where we started. The Senate has passed the foreign aid bill. It has the TikTok ban, quote unquote, in it. What happens next? Who might actually buy TikTok? And is that going to get totally sidetracked by a lawsuit?
42:12 Speaker 04 That is one of the next big questions right now. The companies that come to mind initially are companies like Meta and Google that they're have their own kind of versions of TikTok competitors of these short form videos, like reels and shorts. But anyone who's been at least loosely following antitrust in the past years would probably know that that would be a really big uphill battle to usher through a deal like that through the FTC or DOJ to have these big social media companies buy another enormous social media company that was kind of like the one of the only new upstarts to challenge their power. So that seems unlikely.
42:54 Speaker 04 We did see that former Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin was interested in putting together an investor group to buy the company. So maybe that's one option. Maybe there's going to be other groups that we don't know about yet that come out and say, you know, we're willing to do this. I think another question is, what will there be for sale? You know, China would have to approve if the algorithm were for sale because that's essentially, you know, a high technology export. But could By Dance potentially sell its brand, its content, its user base, perhaps? But that would be worth a lot less than selling it with the algorithm. So I think that remains a really big question.
43:35 Speaker 03 Alongside all this is TikTok's promise to go to the courts. They're threatening to make some sort of First Amendment argument. I just keep coming back to the the sort of core mechanism of the ban here or the bill, which is that it regulates Apple and Google. Can TikTok even go and say, look, they regulated Apple and Google and kicked us off the store? Now we have a First Amendment problem. What does that argument look like?
43:54 Speaker 04 My understanding is that they'd basically be arguing that, you know, the government is trying to get rid of TikTok and in doing so, they're limiting TikTok's own First Amendment rights and they're also limiting the First Amendment rights of its users that will no longer have this space for expression. And it seems like that's an argument that the courts could take seriously, but I think what will happen here is that it has to be weighed against the national security concerns that the government is saying it's seeing. And a lot of the times, courts really, you know, they don't want to be in the business of determining what's a national security issue. So I think that's going to be a really difficult thing for the courts to weigh, and that's really the key issue here.
44:37 Speaker 03 It does strike me that should we allow a foreign power, any amount of control over an algorithm is persuasive, is what the government will say loudly and often. But it does seem like TikTok has fought off some of these bans in Montana and other states, where the states are like, get out of here, and TikTok has won, or at least fought them to a draw.
44:57 Speaker 04 I think that's definitely significant, but on the other hand, I think there's a difference between a state legislature doing something like this and the US Congress doing it. We're talking about an issue of national security that's within kind of Congress and the federal government's purview. So I think these are kind of different things. And, you know, for Montana to enact a ban that is supposed to only impact people in that state, that's really tricky. To do it across the US is kind of an entirely different matter.
45:31 Speaker 03 Do you think this sort of noisy sale process and whatever lawsuits happen and whatever young people get mad about during the election cycle will increase or decrease the momentum for privacy bills and other kinds of tech regulation?
45:44 Speaker 04 At this point, it makes sense for lawmakers to look at privacy after passing this legislation. You know, if they've been saying this whole time that yes, privacy is an issue that we see with TikTok and with other technology companies and, you know, we don't have a national privacy law on the books and we want to change that. So I think nothing has really changed about that in particular. The bill that they passed is very narrowly targeted at this one issue that they see. And I think that still leaves a lot of other tech policy issues on the table for them to tackle.
46:19 Speaker 03 All right, Lauren, it has been a rocket ride in tech policy. I think we're going to spend a year having you come on the show and tell us what's going on. And then on top of it, there's a net neutrality bill about to pass. So I suspect we're going to be hearing from you quite a lot here on Decoder. Thanks for coming on.
46:33 Speaker 04 Thanks for having me.
46:37 Speaker 03 Thanks again to Lauren for joining us on Decoder. We hope you enjoyed it. If you have thoughts about this episode or what you'd like to hear more of on these new Decoder explainers, you can email us at [email protected] . We really do read all the emails and we love the feedback. You can also hit me up directly on Threads. I'm at reckless1280. Hilariously, we have a TikTok. It's at DecoderPod. It's a lot of fun. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt. It was edited by Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. We'll see you next time.
47:55 Speaker 07 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing in wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash apple watch series 12.
Previous Discord CEO Jason Citron makes the case for a smaller, more private internet Next Mercedes-Benz CEO Ola Källenius explains why EVs are still the future — but Apple's next-gen CarPlay isn't Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated