Pod Insights Decoder Why the tech industry can’t crack the smart home About this episode Today, we’re going to talk about the smart home — one of the oldest, most important, and most challenging dreams in the history of the tech industry. The idea of your house responding to you and your family, and generally being as automated and as smart as your phone or your laptop, has inspired generations of technologists. But after decades of promises, it’s all still pretty messy. Because the big problem with the smart home has been blindingly obvious for a very long time: interoperability.
Yet there are some promising developments out there that might make it a little better. To help sort it all out, I invited Verge smart home reviewer Jen Tuohy, who is one of the most influential reporters on the smart home beat today. Jen and I break down how Matter, the open source standard, is trying to fix these issues, but there is still a lot of work to do.
Links:
Matter is now racing ahead, but the platforms are holding it back — The Verge
2023 in the smart home: Matter’s broken promises — The Verge
Smart home hubs: what they are and why you need one — The Verge
My smart kitchen: the good, the bad, and the future — The Verge
How bad business broke the smart home — The Verge
The smart home is finally getting out of your phone and into your home — The Verge
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt and was edited by Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. This is AMEX Corporate, a single platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Flexible controls for when priorities shift, support around the clock, all backed by American Express, so you can stay focused on what matters most. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:35 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard, but not the pipeline? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
0:44 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
0:51 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:06 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, we're going to talk about one of the oldest, most important, and most challenging dreams in the history of the tech industry: the smart home. The idea of your house responding to you and your family and generally being as automated and as smart as your phone or your laptop has inspired generations of technologists. But after decades of promises, it's all still pretty messy. I have a lot of smart home gear in my house, and I'll be blunt. None of it really works well unless you want to spend a lot of time and effort custom designing your own setup or paying someone else a lot of money to do it for you. And even then, it can be kind of hit or miss. But there are some promising developments out there that might make it a little better,
1:51 Speaker 03 one from big tech and another from the open source indie community. To help sort it all out, I'm talking to Verge smart home reviewer Jen Tuohy, who is one of the most influential reporters on the smart home beat today. Now, the big problem with the smart home has been blindingly obvious for a very long time: its interoperability. Different smart home gadgets from different companies just don't work very well together, and they don't all work with your phone or the voice assistant in your house in the same way. That means you either have to lock yourself into one company's ecosystem like Apple or Google, or you're going to spend a bunch of time figuring out ways to force things to work together. The good news is that the big tech companies like Amazon, Apple, Google, and Samsung know this is a problem, and they've put out a standard called Matter, which launched in 2022.
2:36 Speaker 03 At its heart, Matter is supposed to be like HDMI or USB or Wi-Fi for the smart home, a way for different device types to talk to each other, no matter what platform you use to control your smart home. But new kinds of devices have been added to Matter in a painfully slow way, and the platform owners like Apple and Google have been dragging their feet on supporting whatever new device types do get added to Matter. Matter has been around for two years, and as you'll hear Jen say, not much has really changed because of it. That said, things are moving. This week marks the launch of Matter 1.3, which adds a bunch of new device types and capabilities to the standard. Ideally, that pushes the platform owners to expand their support for Matter, and things get a little bit more seamless and easy to use.
3:20 Speaker 03 Jen and I ran down all the things that Matter can do now and what it still needs to do to solve some of the problems that still persist. But here's the thing, that's what's happening on the big tech side of the house. There's a really long-running debate in all of computing about whether letting big platform owners run software for you is better than running software yourself on a server in your home. And there's an open question as to whether consumers want or need a computer like that in their home that controls basically everything so that they can troubleshoot their own smart homes. And there's a lot of movement on that side of things as well. A number of open-source hobbyist projects have sprung up to fill in gaps in the platforms that Amazon and Google and Apple offer their customers, and some of those projects are going from hobbyist status to full-fledged products.
4:04 Speaker 03 You'll hear Jen and I talk a lot about Home Assistant, which is open-source smart home control software that has now launched a foundation focused on privacy and security, so it can try to grow even bigger and offer a counterbalance to the big tech version of the smart home. Home Assistant also has a new hub called the Home Assistant Green, which is supposed to sit in your house and connect to everything else. There's a lot of other projects focused on local control and privacy that are kind of bringing us back to those DIY roots of the smart home. And I gotta say, the more I mess with my own smart home setup, the more I think that maybe turning your house into a computer should require you to build your own system so you can fix it when it breaks. Or at least that's what I tell myself when everything breaks in the house. Okay, the state of the smart home. Here we go.
5:00 Speaker 03 Jen Tuohy, welcome to Decoder.
5:01 Speaker 04 Hello, Neelai. I'm very happy to be here. Thank you for having me.
5:04 Speaker 03 I'm very excited about this episode. I think our producers are very worried about it. Because when you and I get going, talking about smart homes, all hell breaks loose. And then everyone spends a lot of money, and then things only slightly work. But I think we can solve it today. That's our goal for this episode.
5:19 Speaker 04 Solving the smart home. We can do it in 30 minutes.
5:22 Speaker 03 So there's two things that really made me want to talk to you about it. Obviously, you've been covering the space for a long time. You know all the players, you know all the people. The idea has been pretty simple for a very long time. Your house should be full of sensors and various products in your house should be able to take action for you, react to those sensors. You open the door, the heat turns on, the lights are on, the shades move. That idea has been around since the 50s. It's a very old idea. And we've been stumbling towards it for quite some time. I think with the advent of mobile phones and cheap ARM processors and Android, like now there's like a million products that can do this stuff for you in your house.
6:03 Speaker 03 But it still doesn't quite work. Can you describe just the current state of smart home technology?
6:09 Speaker 04 Yeah, so today, what the smart home does really well is solve a singular problem that you might have. So like you go and buy a smart device to make sure you can shut your garage door remotely or turn your lights on and off with a voice command. If you have something you want to do in your home, smart home technology can help solve that. That's what it does really well. The smart home has succeeded in these single use case solutions. What it's not doing well yet, and where most potential is, is that integration, where things work together. I'm not saying it never works. There are, you know, motion sensors to turn on your lights, great experience. There's lots of different elements, like, you know, you can have geofencing
6:52 Speaker 04 so that as you drive up to your house, your lights turn on, your door unlocks. Those types of things work, but you have to have the right devices, you have to have the right system. You have to do a fair amount to set it up. So yeah, those kind of magical moments, those experiences that we think about when we think about a smart home, a home that reacts to us intelligently, those are still hard to do. That symbiosis, that whole intelligent home still feels far away or hard to get to. I mean, you can do it, but you will be spending a lot of time.
7:27 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's not even necessarily money. It's time. We both have these, you have a vastly more confusing smart home situation than I do because you are our smart home reviewer, but it's not money. Like you can spend a lot of money and it won't work. It's you have to spend the time making it all work together. And that seems like the core problem, right? The smart part of the smart home still is very reliant on some individual homeowner doing a system integration, right? And like making all the stuff work together. Whereas the sort of I moved the light switch to be a button on my phone is well unsolved.
8:04 Speaker 04 Right. Yes. And you can spend a lot of money and pay someone to do it all for you. You know, that's another world. But it's interesting because you can see from those examples, like the high end professionally installed systems, that it is possible to have all of this work seamlessly together, but with round the clock IT support and well trained people. I think one of the other big problems, even in those scenarios of the smart home today, is that it doesn't work for everyone in the smart home. I'm my home's sysadmin. I'm sure you're your home's sysadmin. My husband and my children could tell you some stories about how much they dislike living in a smart home. But then there are benefits, you know, that they miss when we're traveling. Like, oh, my son isn't very good
8:48 Speaker 04 at using light switches and he's never used a key.
8:52 Speaker 03 Incredible. My son isn't very good at using light switches is one of the most verge outcomes I can possibly think of. It's very.
9:02 Speaker 04 So but yes, you know, not everyone understands smart homes unless you know, everyone's on board, it can get really complicated for anyone living in the home.
9:11 Speaker 03 Your home starts to have a user interface like in a very real way. You have to know how to use your house.
9:18 Speaker 04 Very much so, yes.
9:19 Speaker 03 So this gets to kind of the heart of the problem, right? The idea is anyone should be able to use the house. A small idea with massive implications, but that kind of means like all the devices should show up on everybody's phones. However, the phones wish to express home control. All of your voice assistants should be able to talk to all the things. So you can just tell Siri or Alexa or Google Assistant to do something and it should happen. The user interface of your house should be expressed everywhere that user interfaces are expressed. The same way that I don't know Netflix works on every device that you might have, or you can open Google Docs on any device with a browser and it just works. None of that seems to work in the house yet. There is a standard that we cover quite a bit that
10:01 Speaker 03 you cover quite a bit called Matter. They just had a new release. That was supposed to fix it, but it just seems like it's very incremental progress. What is going on with Matter?
10:11 Speaker 04 So Matter is a connectivity standard that's designed to make our smart devices work better together. Like, right now, the problem, as I've expressed, is, you know, it's confusing, it's complicated, it requires a lot of time. I often get these comments, well, why would you need a smart light where you can just go flip the switch? Everything works well, but the smart home can make it better. The smart home can make things easier. There's a lot of advantages around like energy management, security, safety, convenience, comfort, all the stuff. But right now, the communication between devices is really poor. The interoperability is a real struggle. Matter is designed to create one common communication thread so that everything can work together. Alongside Matter, there's also something
10:55 Speaker 04 called Thread. And along with Wi-Fi and Ethernet, Thread is the main protocol that Matter runs on. So Thread is a wireless protocol that was specifically built for smart home devices that use low power and low bandwidth, like sensors, smart locks, lights. It's similar to Zigbee and Z-Wave protocols, but it's IP-based, and it doesn't need a central hub or bridge for communication, because Thread devices can talk directly to each other. Thread does need a Thread border router though to talk to the cloud and to other networks. The first Matter spec launched in 2022. It's been two years, which is not a huge amount of time in the scheme of things.
11:37 Speaker 04 But everyone has really been wanting, like needing a standard like this because the smart home is just so fractured and confusing and complicated right now. I've been following it very closely and it feels like it's just not moved forward. But this new release 1.3, which was just announced yesterday, adds about five or six new device types. So Matter now really covers most of the categories that you'd want in your home, except for cameras and security systems. But they've added ovens, extractor hoods, cooktops, dryers. And that's in addition to thermostats, blinds, robot vacuums, refrigerators, freezers, locks, thermostats, pretty much all the appliances in your home.
12:22 Speaker 04 Plus, there's also a robust energy management addition to this spec, which will open up a lot of really interesting use cases. And water management for things like leak detection, freeze detection, rain detection. So there's a lot here and I think it's going to be a really interesting shift for Matter. The problem is this is an industry standard and it's been developed by all the companies that create smart home devices and smart home platforms led by Apple, Google, Amazon, Samsung. And it's just kind of sat there, like nothing has happened for the last two years. Apple has not added any of the new device types from 1.2 to the Home app. Who knows when they'll get to 1.3?
13:06 Speaker 04 Amazon and Google have similarly been dragging their feet. None of the new device types from 1.2 are supported. Samsung has been a little more proactive, but for example, none of them support robot vacuums in Matter yet. So we're waiting for the platforms to step up and say, okay, we created this standard. Now we're actually going to let you use it. Because right now they're dragging their feet and I don't know why.
13:33 Speaker 03 We need to take a quick break. When we're back, Jen and I dive into why smart home standards have not been as effective as HDMI or Bluetooth.
13:44 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
13:53 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
14:01 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
14:15 Speaker 05 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up require compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.
14:40 Speaker 06 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
15:13 Speaker 03 We're back with Verge's smart home reviewer Jen Tuohy to talk more about Matter and what has made existing smart home standards so lackluster. We cover a lot of standards here at The Verge. They are invisible. They are undercover generally. They are usually dominated by rich companies doing politics with each other.
15:33 Speaker 03 HDMI is a standard. HDMI is a surprisingly political standard and it just plugs Roku's into TVs. It's still surprisingly political. Bluetooth, maybe the most political standard of them all. Matter feels like it hasn't even gotten to the politics stage because no one's adopted it. And my theory is that no one's going to switch from an iPhone to an Android phone because it supports robot vacuums when you can just open the robot vacuum app, right? No one's switching from Android to an iPhone because the home app on the iPhone supports range hoods now. Like, there's not competitive pressure on that. And I'm wondering if you see that in your reporting, that this is a great idea and everyone knows that in theory, there should be a USB for home stuff,
16:16 Speaker 03 you know, or a Wi-Fi for home stuff, this big standard that everyone agrees on, that no one messes with too much, that everyone can trust, and that is a great idea in theory. And then the reality is, there's not actually any competitive pressure to use it because no one's switching because of it. No consumer actually can see it or care about it.
16:33 Speaker 04 I think you're right. In my world, the people I talk to are all super excited about it and they see this as the future, but I feel like the next levels up in their companies are really not that interested. I think there was a push where all of these companies thought, okay, Matter is something we need to do because it will help grow the smart home and that will help our bottom line in whichever way we're involved in the smart home. But ultimately, the competitive pressure hasn't arrived because the smart home still is a very niche space. I think what is going to change, and I think what's probably going to help push the platforms towards making and adopting these changes, is the introduction of appliances.
17:17 Speaker 04 We're going from smart lights and sensors to dishwashers, washing machines, ovens, cooktops.
17:24 Speaker 04 You know, big appliances, HVAC systems that are in everyone's homes and that those manufacturers are actually going to push connectivity because actually it benefits them significantly. It makes it a lot easier for things like service and repair. And then there's also the data side. I do think we're going to see a push. Once a lot of the big companies start producing devices. It's a chicken and egg situation. You know, once there are Matter devices out there, we will see the platforms moving more quickly to adopt support because there'll be more pressure. But we're in a moment of stasis right now and consumer pressure is important there, too. I think we need to say, this is what we want. We need to push for it because we don't want to rely solely on the cloud to
18:08 Speaker 04 run our homes. This is one of the biggest arguments I see against the smart home today is the cloud is great, but it can't be the only way your device connects to your home. Matter helps resolve that problem because it's a local protocol. So even if the company goes out of business, you're still going to be able to control your smart devices using the platforms that are compatible with Matter.
18:31 Speaker 03 Yeah, we just bought a new LG washer and dryer, which does not have Matter. They're supposed to by now, but they don't. And first of all, they are just always talking to the network. I don't know what they're doing. They're just banging away, just sending packets left and right. I don't know why. Some of those packets are notifications to me that the washer is done, which is not useful and I need to turn them off. But even when I want to control them back, my phone doesn't actually talk to it. It bounces up to LG's cloud and then back down to my house, which just seems inherently silly to me. And you're saying Matter would make my phone talk directly to that appliance?
19:07 Speaker 04 Exactly. Yes. Because it would all work on your local network. Although just to make things more complicated, and because this is about standards and there's always politics and standards, there is a competing standard, the Home Connectivity Alliance, which is all appliance manufacturers, and that's all cloud based. They say that there's tandem harmony between the two standards, but for the consumers, Matter, I think, is the one that I would champion because Matter will help you have more control over your devices locally and subsequently more control over your data and also reassure you that your devices are going to continue to work in the way you're expecting them to and not have a negative change or degradation over time.
19:52 Speaker 04 This is one of the reasons I think we've really struggled to see the smart home take off is because of this confusion and this concern. And this is where, you know, a standard like Matter, and you said it earlier, you know, it is a Wi-Fi for the smart home, it's a Bluetooth for the smart home. That's exactly what it is. And that is what ultimately the Connectivity Standards Alliance, which oversees Matter, is trying to accomplish. Matter isn't or shouldn't be the story. Matter is the connective tissue, the interoperability. But this is something that we really need to make the smart home work. We're now in a position where I really think it's up to the platforms and the manufacturers to step up and say, okay, we decided to do this. We're going to follow through.
20:37 Speaker 03 Well, the good news is we're in OS launch season, right? Apple is going to announce new versions of iOS shortly at WWDC. Google is going to have I/O, where we're going to see Android in the next few weeks. So hopefully there's some movement there.
20:52 Speaker 03 There's another piece of the puzzle I want to focus on for just a second. It's where the smart home software actually lives. A lot of the big companies seem to think there should be some point of centralization. For Apple, it's HomeKit. For Samsung, it's Smart Things. Google has Google Home. But ultimately, the smarts have to happen somewhere. Someone has to write some code to tell your devices how to operate and interact. That code needs to live somewhere, it needs to run somewhere. Someone has to fix it when it breaks. Someone has to issue security updates. We're basically saying there should be a server somewhere, running your house. Maybe that server is more abstract, it's running in the cloud. Maybe it's more distributed, it's running on all the devices in your house. That's sort of how Apple's HomeKit works. But maybe it should just be a server, a computer, in your basement that's running the code that operates your smart home.
21:37 Speaker 03 There's a lot of different ways to handle it, and all of these approaches are out in the market. But the big platforms have not done a good job of making it clear where all the software is running and why their competing visions for how that software is organized or structured.
21:50 Speaker 04 When we go back to the beginning of the smart home with the original like SmartThings and the Revolve Hub and Wink, this was when, you know, we all started to sort of take the smart home, the DIY smart home, take some interest in it. And that was all hub-based. So we had these little white boxes with multiple radios in, but for some reason, we could never have one little white box with all the radios in. There was always one missing. You know, you could still never have everything talk to each other. And then so the hubs went away because the big platforms came in and were like, hmm, we don't need to do this with hubs. We can do this all in the cloud and we can make all these devices talk to each other. And interesting factoid, Samsung bought SmartThings, Google bought Revolve,
22:34 Speaker 04 Amazon launched Alexa and Apple launched HomeKit, all in the same year. So that all happened in 2014. So that was the beginning of this new smart home, the DIY smart home. And what happened then is, you know, wow, this is so much easier. Consumers don't have to buy this little hub. You can just use your phone to control everything. But then the lag and the control issues and not everything working with each other and it all became something of a confusing mess. And that's how we sort of ended up with Matter coming in to kind of fix it all and bring us back to the idea of a hub, which is essentially what Matter is doing, but in a different name. Because the word smart home hub became
23:17 Speaker 04 like a dirty word. No one wants hubs because they're expensive and confusing.
23:22 Speaker 03 So I disagree with you in a small way, right? Which is, if I could just buy a smart home product for my basement, that was an actual product with an interface and it's where everything connected to, then I could log into it and open it and see it. And when it broke, I could unplug it and plug it back in. I think that would be good, right? Like, I think it would conceptually be simpler than these weird, it's half on your phone, half on your Alexa. Like, where's the computer is like a real question. I think most people don't know the answer to in the concept of the smart home. And now, right, there's this project called Home Assistant that you've been covering. They're going from kind of
24:03 Speaker 03 a hobbyist group to being more of a real foundation. They are selling a product like this called the Home Assistant Green. It seems like there's some real action there.
24:13 Speaker 04 Yes, for sure. And so, yeah, we're coming back to hubs, essentially is what's happening. There is a problem with hubs. I agree with you that having one computer running your smart home sounds like the ideal, but the problem is when that computer dies, your home dies. So that is a bit of a failure point. And this is one of the areas of Matter and Thread that is trying to solve that issue where you have multiple devices in your home that are all essentially running the computer. Matter controllers and Thread border routers, but we're not at a point yet where you can reliably run your home with Matter controllers and Thread border routers for a number of reasons that I have
24:54 Speaker 04 written extensively about. Politics probably being one of them. I think Matter will get there, and I think Thread will get there. But right now, that's leaving a big sort of open space for new platforms to come in and say, look, we have a solution that's going to work for you right now, today, and will work with Matter and Thread in the future. Because I get emails constantly from readers saying, you know, I want to set up a smart home, or I'm moving to a smart home, or I want to expand my smart home. Do I have to wait for Matt to be here and be ready before I can do anything? And no one wants to tell someone, you can't buy any gadgets. I mean, that's just not something
25:34 Speaker 04 that we do. There are solutions today that mean you can use your smart home and devices today, but be set up for the future when Matter finally gets his act together. And that's where Home Assistant, and as you mentioned, the Home Assistant Green, really comes in. So Home Assistant is a smart home platform like Apple Home or Google Home. And what's exciting about it is it's open source, and it also has a very strong focus on local control and privacy. But traditionally, Home Assistant has been complicated to get started with. You need to run a Home Assistant server on a Raspberry Pi or a variety of hardware options. And while you can still do that, now there's actually an easier solution.
26:16 Speaker 04 You can pick up a Home Assistant Green, which they're about to start selling on Amazon for $99, which is a big shift for the company. And the Green is a one-stop-shop for Home Assistant. It's a smart home hub that comes with the OS pre-installed, just making it easier to set up and get running. Home Assistant is an open-source, community-driven Smart home platform that really made its name because it's one of the few systems that everything works with, but not everything works very well. Which is always one of these issues with the smart home because of this interoperability problem. So Home Assistant just launched the Open Home Foundation, which is a way of separating its business model from its ethics and ideals. So the Open Home Foundation
27:00 Speaker 04 is actually an organisation that is consumer advocate in the smart home. It's looking to try and help push forward better smart home products that work locally in your home. So you don't have the issues that we were talking about earlier about cloud control. They have a lot of really interesting lofty ideals, but the device itself, the Home Assistant Green and the Home Assistant platform is a very powerful smart home platform, probably a little too powerful for most people. And it can be really complicated to set up devices in Home Assistant. But with these updates to Matter, I think we'll see Home Assistant shift more into the mainstream because it will be easier to set up devices in Home Assistant than it is today. And Home Assistant will become a Matter controller. And you
27:45 Speaker 04 need a Matter controller from the platform you want to use in order to set up and control Matter devices. I know that's a lot of Matter and a lot of control, but basically, a Matter controller is like a hub. They just didn't want to call it a hub. There are other platforms that are also doing this. Akara, which is a smart home company that a lot of listeners might be familiar with. They make sensors and cameras and smart lights, very inexpensive. They've worked with Apple Home for years. And Akara has just released last week its own Matter controller slash Threadbort router. So you don't necessarily have to use Apple Home or Amazon Alexa or Google Home or Samsung SmartThings because this open source Matter
28:28 Speaker 04 smart home standard, anyone can use. You don't have to be one of the big tech companies. So all of these platforms, whether it's Home Assistant or Habitat or Homebridge, they're all using a single hub to control and communicate with your devices. So we're definitely seeing a shift back toward the hub idea, especially because of local control and the security and privacy it offers you versus relying entirely on the cloud.
28:55 Speaker 03 We need to take another quick break. When we're back, Jen and I get into what the future of the smart home might look like.
29:06 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard, but not the pipeline? That's bullspend, and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
29:15 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
29:22 Speaker 01 Cut the bullspend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
29:37 Speaker 05 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up. Required compatibility and availability varies. 18 plus.
30:02 Speaker 06 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition, even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 and 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
30:35 Speaker 03 We're back with Verge's smart home reviewer Jen Tuohy to talk about where the smart home is headed next.
30:42 Speaker 03 So we've talked about Matter, how it's changed recently, but how much further it still needs to go. And we've touched on this pendulum swing between hubs and giving consumers more control over what their smart home looks like and how these devices should actually talk to each other. Home Assistant is one version of this. It's a fascinating project because of that foundation you mentioned, and because it started as this hobbyist project that's now evolved into something much more legitimate and stable. You said maybe it's a little too powerful. I think that is a reflection of the fact that it was built by enthusiasts for enthusiasts. Like, it can just do everything. It is a computer, and you can program it. You can program your smart home like a computer if you use Home Assistant. I know people who spend their weekends just writing code for their Home Assistant setups.
31:24 Speaker 04 Yes.
31:24 Speaker 03 And that's great.
31:25 Speaker 04 For those people, that's like a wonderful way.
31:30 Speaker 03 I have been that person, and we'll get to why I'm no longer that person in a second. But the Open Home Foundation, which is going to run Home Assistant, they just started. And their mission statement is very idealistic, right? The mission statement, I'm just going to quote, is to fight against surveillance capitalism and offer a counterbalance to big tech influence in the smart home by focusing on privacy, choice, and sustainability for smart home users. How does that square with also when you buy whatever cheap cloud-connected gadget? We will control it because the goal is to control everything, right? Like, there's a real tension there that the platform might respect to you, but all this hardware you're deploying around your house might just talk to the network for no reason.
32:13 Speaker 04 So actually, what's also quite new for Home Assistant is it also has a works with program, which is something you might be familiar with if you've ever bought any smart home device that says works with Alexa or works with Google. Basically, it's saying this device will work with your platform well, and we have guaranteed that this will work on your platform. But Home Assistant uniquely is saying that it will not allow any device that only relies on the cloud to carry its works with label. So it will work with Home Assistant, even if it works through the cloud, it has to have a local connection to get that label. It can work via the cloud, but it also has to have a local control element.
32:56 Speaker 04 Because, yeah, you're right, there's a tension there that these devices have the potential, if they're sitting in our homes, to, as I mentioned before, you know, stop working, not work the way you expect them to, change the way they work. What it's doing, though, is it's putting the onus on the user. So if you choose to put a device in your home that is reliant on the cloud, you need to understand the risk there. What Matter and what Home Assistant does today is all works locally. Every device that works with Matter is a local device, except for, you know, if you choose to opt for a device that talks to the cloud. Talking to the cloud is not a bad thing, I just want to make that clear.
33:40 Speaker 04 There are lots of benefits of talking to the cloud, but unfortunately, there are also downsides. You just have to be aware. It's hard for the consumer to sort of understand what they're taking on every time you buy a device like that. But then you get the advantages, like for instance, when my smart thermostat knows it's going to be really cold tomorrow and it starts heating up earlier to keep me warmer. It's a struggle, I agree. It's going to take a while to work through this because right now, it's very much a hobbyist platform. And as it tries to appeal to a larger audience, there's going to be some tension.
34:13 Speaker 03 One of the reasons that I moved away from Home Assistant to another kind of community project called Home Bridge was that, you know, my wife, my child, they look at their phones, they look at their iOS devices. And so if you want to expose the control of the smart home to them, it had better be on their phone. That's where it is. And that's just the reality of the situation. If there's not a tile and control center on my wife's phone, she is not going to use it. And once that, once, once I came to that realization about seven years into our marriage, I was like, okay, I'm gonna, I'm just going to accept this. I was like, okay, I'm just going to move everything to HomeKit. I'm going to move everything to Apple's platform. And Home Bridge, another community project, just lets you do that, right?
34:57 Speaker 03 It's just middleware, it sits in your house. I always call it a Tamagotchi because it's finicky and you gotta, you gotta feed it every couple of days. But it's basically a little Linux computer running on Raspberry Pi. And it just bridges everything into the tiles in Control Center. And that feels like, one, like I gave up, like I turned my back on this idea of this like brilliant smart home running this custom platform in basement. But two, it also feels like a very important reality for everyone. We'll just end where we started, which is you saying this has to be for everyone in the house. And if it's not in that default interface on whatever phone you have, or it's not on the, you know, easily accessible from your Alexa screen or your Google Home screen, you
35:39 Speaker 03 know, your hub devices there, your smart displays, it might just go ignored. And that feels like the hardest part of this, right, is to, to make that interface so pervasive. It's the promise, but at the end of the day, it is, does seem still pretty gated by what the big platforms are going to allow you to do.
35:58 Speaker 04 Very much so, yes. And the big platforms are definitely going for the, you know, the widest common denominator. They're not interested in really appealing to the hobbyists and the enthusiasts, which is where I think platforms like Home Assistant and Homebridge will always have a place. And for the tech enthusiasts, they really do offer a lot that you, you just cannot get with the main four platforms. Samsung SmartThings, to some extent, has more control.
36:26 Speaker 03 SmartThings is, by the way, I just need to say this very clearly. SmartThings is some of the most chaotic software I've ever used in my entire life.
36:32 Speaker 04 Is that because you're trying to use it with the TV?
36:35 Speaker 03 Yeah. It's, I have Frame TVs, they're, but SmartThings is like a web-based platform, and sometimes you open the app and it just doesn't show up.
36:43 Speaker 04 Yeah.
36:44 Speaker 03 That's weird.
36:45 Speaker 04 It's downloading drivers as it goes.
36:47 Speaker 03 It's just a deeply weird platform. Yeah.
36:50 Speaker 04 Well, and because it, it did what Home Assistant is trying to do 10 years ago, which is moved from being a open source hobbyist enthusiast community to a mainstream platform. It had the power of Samsung behind it to do that. It still has some really great deep dive tools and automations you can do, but then you also just can't get it to turn your TV on, which you should do. I agree. But yes, ultimately, I think what I've been seeing is a shift of the big smart home platforms towards the local control, because that's what Matter is bringing. So I think that these hubs, like Home Assistant and Homebridge and Habitat and Homie's, another
37:31 Speaker 04 one, and Akara, I think they're actually providing almost a roadmap for where I think we'll end up seeing the big platforms going, because everyone will need a Matter controller to control Matter devices. And I think those Matter controllers, which right now are things like your Apple TV and your Google Nest hubs, I think we're going to see those devices get more powerful. And be able to do more in your home and actually become hubs again. They started out by not being hubs and I think eventually we're going to go full circle and they're going to become our smart home hubs and we'll have multiple of them in the home so that when one fails, our smart homes will still work and we will all love our smart homes eventually.
38:13 Speaker 03 I feel like this big question of I'm going to turn my house to a computer, but I don't quite know where that computer is or who's running it or who's responsible for managing it. There are some attempts at solutions here, right? You have the platforms on the major smartphones and from Amazon. You have things like Home Assistant, you have these protocols that are developing like Matter. But without solving that first problem, just making it conceptually easy to understand what is happening. It feels like there's going to be a roadblock to mass adoption for quite a while. Is the industry working on that? Do you see that in your reporting or is it just one foot in front of the other?
38:53 Speaker 04 No, I do not think the industry is working on that. But I do think they should be. I think right now they are in this one foot in front of the other stage because there's this push to make people understand the benefits of the smart home. I don't think there has been anywhere near enough attention paid to explaining to people how it's actually working in your home and how you can control it. Because troubleshooting the smart home right now, Matter, Thread, HomeKit, any of them is impossible. And the idea behind it, I think, is to try and make it user friendly and easy so that you don't have to worry about being a sysadmin for your house. But it also means that when it breaks, you're stuck and then you just throw up your hands and say, I'm done. I'm getting dumb lights and, you know, a key again.
39:38 Speaker 04 So we need more transparency around that. People aren't stupid. People want to know what they're doing. People are, you know, are used to computers and phones and understanding how these devices work. So yes, I agree, we need much more transparency there. We need the tools to be able to. You know, control, understand how the computers in our homes are working. But ultimately, if we get to the point where you actually make this all work seamlessly, work locally, so not relying on the cloud, we shouldn't be running into those problems as much. And then we shouldn't have to worry. Just as, just as seamless as Bluetooth and Wi-Fi is today, the smart home will be one day.
40:16 Speaker 03 All right. We'll have you back when that happens. You let me know. Jen, thanks so much for coming to Decoder. This is great.
40:21 Speaker 04 We could keep talking about this for many more hours, I'm sure. But thank you so much for having me.
40:29 Speaker 03 Thanks again to Jen Tuohy for joining us on Decoder. As you can tell, I love talking to Jen about smart home stuff. I hope you enjoyed it as much as I did. If you have thoughts about this episode or what you'd like to hear more of on Decoder, you can email us at [email protected] . We really do read all the emails. You can also hit me up directly on Threads. I'm at @backless128. We have a TikTok. Check it out. It's at DecoderPod. It's a lot of fun for as long as it lasts. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Kate Cox-Nick Statt. It was edited by Kelly Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. We'll see you next time.
41:13 Speaker 07 Fall savings are happening now at The Home Depot. Save up to $500 on select appliances. Plus, enjoy free delivery when you spend $998 or more. From prepping to cooking to cleaning up, Frigidaire has you covered. The custom Flex Temp drawer switches from fridge to freezer. With more than 15 cooking modes, including stone baked pizza mode, you can enjoy restaurant quality pizza in as little as two minutes. Then clean up with the Frigidaire dishwasher, featuring the industry's fastest normal wash cycle. Shop fall savings now at The Home Depot. Off of August 21st, US and DC. Store online for details.
41:43 Speaker 08 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing in a wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple's conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash Apple Watch Series 12.
Previous Polestar CEO Thomas Ingenlath on life after Volvo and weathering the EV slowdown Next Why Adobe CEO Shantanu Narayen is confident we'll all adapt to AI Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated