Pod Insights Decoder Why Nintendo sued a Switch emulator out of existence About this episode Hello, and welcome to Decoder. This is David Pierce, editor-at-large at The Verge and co-host of The Vergecast, subbing in for Nilay, who’s out on vacation. Regular Decoder programming returns next week. In the meantime, we have an exciting episode for you today all about video game emulation, which, as it turns out, is a whole lot more complicated than it seems.
Gaming emulation made headlines recently because one of the most widely used programs for emulating the Nintendo Switch, a platform called Yuzu, was effectively sued out of existence. There’s a whole lot going on here, from the history of game emulation to the copyright precedents of emulators to how the threat of game piracy still looms large in the industry. To break down this topic, I brought Verge Senior Editor and resident emulation expert Sean Hollister on the show. Let’s get into it.
Links:
Nintendo sues Switch emulator Yuzu — The Verge
Nintendo Switch emulator Yuzu will fold and pay $2.4M to settle its lawsuit — The Verge
Steve Jobs announcing a PlayStation emulator for the Mac — YouTube
Fans freak out as Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom leaks two weeks early — Kotaku
Tears of the Kingdom Was Pirated 1 Million Times, Nintendo Claims — Kotaku
The solid legal theory behind Nintendo’s new emulator takedown effort — Ars Technica
How Nintendo’s destruction of Yuzu is rocking the emulator world — The Verge
How strong is Nintendo’s legal case against Switch-emulator Yuzu? — Ars Technica
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt and was edited by Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 7,522 words · 10 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. AMX Corporate connects cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammxcorporate. Terms apply.
0:23 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out. In. Dashboard. Confessions.
0:32 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand", when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
0:40 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
0:55 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I am not Neelai Patel, though this is his show about big ideas and other problems. My name is David Pearce, and I am the editor-at-large at The Verge and the co-host of The Vergecast. I'm subbing in for Neelai today, who is out on vacation, I think in Mexico somewhere. Regular Decoder programming will be back next week. But in the meantime, we have an exciting episode for you today, and it's all about software emulation. In particular, we're talking about the emulation of video games, which, as it turns out, is a whole lot more complicated than it seems. Emulation in general is an old and well-established concept in computing. It's part of the way that Apple was able to reverse-engineer Microsoft's Office File formats decades ago in order to make them work inside of Apple's own workplace apps,
1:39 Speaker 03 like Pages and Keynote. It's also how computer makers decades ago figured out how to make software that worked across platforms. In the gaming world too, emulation has been around for decades. But it made headlines recently because one of the most widely-used programs for emulating the Nintendo Switch, a platform called Yuzu, was effectively sued out of existence thanks to a devastating legal complaint from, you guessed it, Nintendo. In one sense, it was a classic copyright infringement complaint from a company known for aggressively protecting its intellectual property. But Nintendo accused the anonymous creators of Yuzu, a mysterious entity known as Tropic Haze LLC, of, quote, "facilitating piracy at a colossal scale." Within just a few days,
2:24 Speaker 03 the group settled with Nintendo for millions of dollars, and Yuzu folded completely. There's a whole lot going on here, from the history of game emulation to the copyright precedence of emulators, to the way that the threat of game piracy still looms large in the industry. To break down this topic, I brought on Verge's senior editor and resident emulation expert, Sean Hollister. Sean and I get into what emulators actually are and how they work. We break down why the idea of playing a video game on hardware it wasn't designed for has been a lifelong mission for enthusiasts, and why that might as well be the end of the world for companies like Nintendo and Sony. You'll hear Sean explain why Yuzu was such a big deal, and why it broke a kind of unwritten
3:07 Speaker 03 rule in the game industry around emulating modern-day hardware to play newly released, or in some cases, even unreleased, video games. We also talk about the DMCA. Yes, that's right, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, because this is Decoder, after all, and Neelai's not here, but we have to do it for him, anyway. The DMCA actually plays a huge role in this story, and you'll be fascinated to learn that it does, in fact, protect some video game emulation, even though it's also the law that console makers have used since the 90s to go after the emulation community. Consumers and companies have been waging this battle over what they can and can't do with the hardware and software they buy since the beginning of the tech industry. And video games are a big part of that story.
3:51 Speaker 03 But this recent fight about Yuzu feels new, and it has the potential to change the emulation industry for years to come. Okay, Yuzu and the state of video game emulation. Here we go.
4:14 Speaker 03 Sean Hollister, welcome to Decoder. Thanks for having me. It's so fun to get to do this with you. This is very exciting. We're here to talk about emulators, which is kind of a big, messy, complicated space. But let's just maybe define a few terms here at the beginning, just to set up what we're talking about. What is a game emulator, just at the broadest possible level?
4:37 Speaker 04 The broadest possible level, it's a piece of software that allows you to run a game, an app, a program as if you were on another piece of hardware. So you're on a PC and you want your PC to play games like it's a Nintendo Switch or a Super Nintendo or PlayStation or any of these game consoles. Or maybe you're on a MacBook and you want your MacBook to play a Windows application. You can use emulators or translation layers to tell your computer that it's actually some other piece of hardware.
5:12 Speaker 03 So by that definition, it seems like emulators, A, have kind of been around forever. And B, are about much more than just video games. Again, at this big level, we're going to talk a lot about games on this episode. But I think it's actually important that emulators are this like foundational technology to how computers work in a lot of ways, right?
5:33 Speaker 04 Absolutely. Emulators fundamentally underpin a lot of what we do day to day. But in the video game space, which we're talking about a bunch today, it's been an argument for a very long time that you should be able to develop a brand new program for your Super Nintendo or your PlayStation that can run on a computer for purposes of figuring out how software works and preserving software and just learning how these systems are built. And so a lot of emulation folks are like, this is, this is an important right that we need to maintain, even if at the end of the day, what a lot of people do is they just pirate Nintendo Switch games and play them.
6:17 Speaker 03 In the gaming space specifically, I've only really come around to the emulation community recently as retro gaming and kind of all of the like nostalgia of the early NES and N64 games have come back. And I confess, I have had moments where I have wanted to play N64 games on non-N64s and have looked into this space. Has emulation been a part of the video game industry for a long time? Or is it really growing now because there is so much nostalgia for that kind of early generation of gaming?
6:48 Speaker 04 So we're in a bit of what I would call like an emulation fever pitch right now because we do have not only so many gamers wanting to play their games on their iPhone, but we also have the companies themselves, the Nintendos, the Sonys of the world, using emulation to allow you to play their older games again on newer consoles. They want to sell you a new copy of Crash Bandicoot and The Legend of Dragoon. And so they use emulation themselves in their Nintendo Switch Online, or some of the games you'll find on the PlayStation Store. And this is a virtuous cycle where not only can you potentially get a little bit of pirate or hacker fame, or computer building fame by building an emulator, you might also get
7:33 Speaker 04 a job in the industry based on what you're learning there.
7:36 Speaker 03 So that's an emulator. And emulators play ROMs. What is a ROM? And where do they come from?
7:43 Speaker 04 ROM stands for read-only memory. But what it basically is, is it's an encapsulated file that contains all the parts of the game. If you take a ROM, that is basically the container with the game in it, and you stick that into an emulator and it plays. ROM is a generic way to refer to these games that can be distributed as files.
8:04 Speaker 03 Where do they come from typically? How does one find a ROM? Purely hypothetically, not that I'm asking.
8:09 Speaker 04 Purely hypothetically. If you were to do it quote-unquote "properly," and when I say "properly," I do not know for a fact that this is legal, and it's a question that I want to answer. Properly, you would dump it from your own system. You would have Nintendo Wii with the Homebrew channel on it, and a hard drive plugged into the back with a USB cable. You'd stick in your own copy of a disk that you actually own and bought and plan to keep around and do not, aren't going to return to GameStop for a refund. You'd stick it in there. It would pull the ROM or ISO off there, and you'd have it on a hard drive. Then you could stick it into your emulator and shift it that way. Also, purely hypothetically, you could probably find them in various parts of the internet.
8:54 Speaker 03 So Sean, very important question. Are emulators legal?
8:57 Speaker 04 Yes.
8:58 Speaker 03 Are we sure?
8:58 Speaker 04 Maybe.
8:59 Speaker 03 Okay.
8:59 Speaker 04 Kind of, possibly.
9:01 Speaker 03 Cool.
9:01 Speaker 04 Sorta. The idea of an emulator is absolutely legal. It's gone through the courts. There have been several cases where not only has it been deemed legal by at least an appeals court level to create an emulator, fundamentally a program that is emulating another piece of hardware for purposes of interoperability with other software, yada, yada, jargon. Not only is it legal to do that, it's legal to do that for a profit.
9:28 Speaker 03 Sean makes a really good point here. You could theoretically sell an emulator for the PlayStation. And some companies like Blem and Connectix did just that back in the 90s. There's even a clip of Steve Jobs and Phil Schiller demoing the Connectix Virtual Game Station on the Mac at an Apple conference in 1999.
9:45 Speaker 05 At Macworld today, Connectix is introducing the Virtual Game Station. It is software that they're gonna sell for $49 that turns your Mac into a Sony PlayStation. It plays a few hundred. It plays a few hundred of the Sony PlayStation games today. And I'd like to ask Phil to come back and give us a quick demo.
10:10 Speaker 03 Things didn't really end well for the Virtual Game Station. Sony sued Connectix, but eventually Connectix did win on appeal. Emulation enthusiasts actually cite that case as one of the major legal precedents establishing a fair use argument for emulators. But right after that, Connectix turned around and sold the rights to its software to Sony, which then shut it down after a few months. So it's important to note that emulators like that were and are legal. But as video game hardware became more sophisticated over time, that legality became a little murkier. Here's Sean explaining why.
10:44 Speaker 04 The question is... What happens when technological protections come into play? What happens when the Digital Millennium Copyright Act says, "Well, maybe you can make an emulator, but in order to actually get any of the pieces you would need to play games on that emulator, you would have to break copyright law."
11:07 Speaker 03 So it's not building the emulator that's illegal. It's doing what you have to do to get the emulator to talk to the game, potentially.
11:16 Speaker 04 Where this comes down is to is encryption, really. Video game consoles and handhelds have gotten increasingly sophisticated over the years, not just in terms of how much they can do, but how much copyright protection the companies try to throw on top of that. With a Super Nintendo, you could dump the cartridge. You could take the files, basically, that are on the cartridge and copy them to a PC. You could do this with Game Boy Advance, too. It's not just ancient Super Nintendo. Anything that relied on a very simple cartridge, you just copy those files over, you drop those files in the emulator, and they would run. Then we got to BIOSs. Okay, so your Sony PlayStation,
11:59 Speaker 04 your PS2, your PS3, and certain other systems would also have a set of instructions for how they run at a hardware level, but it's made of software, and it's a copyrighted piece of software. Nintendo coded that BIOS. Sony coded that BIOS. You can't run this emulator without a copy of software that you don't have. Unless, like one emulator developer did for the PSP, you don't actually use the BIOS at all. You emulate the BIOS, too. You emulate the underlying hardware.
12:35 Speaker 03 Let's just take a second here to break down what a BIOS is. It stands for Basic Input Output System. And in simple terms, you can think of it like the instruction manual for a computer. In the context of a video game console, the BIOS is what tells the piece of game hardware how to run a piece of game software. Courts have found that the underlying code there is in fact proprietary and can in fact be copyrighted. But without getting too in the weeds here, there are fair use exceptions where a BIOS can be used as a reference to reverse engineer a custom BIOS of your own, which is what happened in some of the copyright cases that Sony brought against companies like Connectix that we mentioned earlier. This is a really murky part of the legal debate over emulation and reverse engineering. And as you'll hear Sean explain,
13:20 Speaker 03 a lot of emulator makers just don't want to cross a line that might invite a lawsuit, especially as video game hardware has only gotten more locked down and the software that runs it more complicated and more encrypted over the years.
13:35 Speaker 04 What many emulators would say for a long time is, "We are a..." And this is a term I've heard thrown around. I don't know if they said this. "We are a bring-your-own BIOS emulator. Here's the emulator. You can use it. It's not going to do much without a BIOS. Go ahead and dump the BIOS from your own system if you can, or more likely you'll pirate that off the internet."
13:56 Speaker 03 Right, implicit in that is, "We are going to close our eyes for 10 minutes, and then you're going to have a BIOS, and we're not going to ask any questions about it."
14:03 Speaker 04 Exactly. And this was, from what I can gather, completely tolerated by the video game industry. Emulators are legal, BIOS probably not, but can we go after the emulator folks for a BIOS? Nah. Could we go after the users and pirates? Maybe. But we're not going to bother, because that's like trying to enforce, you know, every download of an MP3 back in the day. You're not going to do that.
14:27 Speaker 03 Yeah, that doesn't go well for anybody.
14:30 Speaker 03 We have to take a quick break. When we get back, Sean and I get into what happened to Yuzu and how it's totally upended the game emulation community. We'll be right back.
14:41 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bullspend. And marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
14:51 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
14:58 Speaker 01 Cut the bullspend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
15:12 Speaker 06 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
15:41 Speaker 07 Propel Fitness Water. With Gatorade Electrolytes, zero sugar and vitamins. Propel hydrates better than water. To help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you? Propel with Gatorade Electrolytes.
15:59 Speaker 03 We're back with Verge's senior editor, Sean Hollister, to talk about what happened to Nintendo Switch emulator Yuzu and what it means for the future of game emulation. So this is all good ground setting, which brings us to today and brings us to Yuzu. Tell me about Yuzu.
16:17 Speaker 04 So Yuzu was the leading Nintendo Switch emulator. And I can't tell you off the top of my head why it was the leading Nintendo Switch emulator, but there was this moment where not only did we have Nintendo Switch games playable on PCs, but people realized that they could take this one emulator and they create forks of it to play Switch games on their iPhone. They could put Switch games on their Steam Deck. They could put them on these handheld gaming PCs. And not only could they do that, they could do that at a higher level of performance, more FPS, higher resolution than they could on the Switch itself. It's been a case for a long, long time that emulation was considered a bit of a brute force way of playing games on Mother Horde,
17:00 Speaker 04 that you would need brute force levels of computing from your processor in order to do that. So maybe in 2000, 2002, that timeframe, you've got your Nintendo GameCube able to play that graphical level of games. It takes years after that before PC chips can do enough brute force to play those games well. But the Nintendo Switch, those games can play better on a Steam Deck than they do on the Nintendo Switch.
17:26 Speaker 03 Because the Switch is just like a, it's a bunch of smartphone chips, right?
17:29 Speaker 04 It is, and they can do it within its own lifespan. The emulation community, they're saying, hey, you can play this game that Nintendo just released, Legend of Zelda, Tears of the Kingdom, you can play it on day one, or maybe even before it comes out, if you got a leaked copy of the game or something, on our system, and it's better than it is on Switch. So the question is, why do you buy a Nintendo Switch if you could theoretically get this game and play it on your Steam Deck or on your PC, and it looks better there?
18:01 Speaker 03 In the course of this, what actually happened to Yuzu?
18:04 Speaker 04 Yuzu was sued out of existence. Nintendo came at them with an actual legal complaint that alleged that Yuzu was facilitating piracy at a colossal scale, said they broke like five different layers of encryption, and told them they wanted their domain name and all of their assets and social media accounts, and that was it.
18:22 Speaker 03 Did Yuzu fight this at all?
18:25 Speaker 04 Not in the least. Yuzu had to pay $2.4 million to Nintendo and agreed not to work on any emulation against Nintendo ever again. We don't know who Tropic Haze LLC, the company behind Yuzu, actually is. It could be one guy in his basement who said, I don't want anybody to know that it's one guy in the basement, and therefore I'm just going to drop the whole project like a stone because I don't want it revealed who I am. It could be that simple. Or it could be a lot of people making a bunch of money off of this thing. We don't really know. Statutory damages add up to a lot. And so maybe they settled for 2.4 million and will go away forever because that was
19:08 Speaker 04 easier than however many ridiculous millions it might have been if they'd tried to fight.
19:15 Speaker 03 How unique a story is that? When I think of emulation, I think of, like you were saying a minute ago, ways to play kind of generations old games. But it seems like what you just described, Yuzu being, is going to raise the hackles of basically anyone in the gaming industry paying attention. Is this a new thing that Yuzu managed to do that other emulators had not pulled off in quite the same way? Or has this been happening forever?
19:42 Speaker 04 So Yuzu is not unique in that it's emulating the Nintendo Switch and allowing you to play it on other systems, but it became the most popular very quickly. It was forked a number of times, ported to other systems. It got everywhere, to the point where Nintendo pointed out that when people were downloading copies of pirated games off the web, some of these games would mention that they were designed to be played on Yuzu. These files were, you know, hint, hint, wink, wink, maybe you should play these in your Yuzu emulator.
20:16 Speaker 03 So Yuzu, from what I can tell, broke this kind of unspoken agreement or détente in the gaming industry where all the emulators were kind of tacitly allowed to exist because they weren't really getting in the way and they were mostly letting people who continued to buy games play the old games that they had probably bought. And Nintendo and the other companies just kind of agreed to be cool about it because it wasn't really worth pursuing anyway. And Yuzu broke this dam. Why do you think Yuzu was the one that broke this dam and actually riled up Nintendo to the point where it threatened to sue Yuzu completely out of existence?
20:59 Speaker 04 It's gotta be Zelda. I mean, in addition to the ability to play all these Nintendo Switch games on your handhelds, Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom in particular, Nintendo alleged that it was pirated a million times before it came out and that some of those files, the file names or something, suggested that it was designed to be used with Yuzu, the emulator. And while I don't know that for a fact, that, you know, that it was actually Yuzu that did that, I do know that on day one, people were playing copies of Tears of the Kingdom and Yuzu using guides that had been prepared in advance using those pirated copies of the game.
21:40 Speaker 03 And if ever you were going to do something that got Nintendo's attention in a big way, doing that on launch day of Tears of the Kingdom is probably the quickest way to do it.
21:49 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah.
21:50 Speaker 03 Why do you think over the years Nintendo has not pursued some of this stuff more aggressively?
21:57 Speaker 04 I think at the end of the day, it's a crazy balancing act that Nintendo has to do because Nintendo profits from emulation in small ways that add up over time. And they profit from having an active, interested fan community that is so devoted to their intellectual property that they're willing to develop an entire game or spend all of their waking hours pouring their sweat, blood, and tears into an emulator that'll play, you know, Wind Waker 20% better than it did on a GameCube, but maybe at 4K resolution. I don't know. They want to have that devoted fan community. Back in the day, there were periods of time where companies would shut down, you know, any project at the slightest
22:42 Speaker 04 provocation. And that hasn't been the case with Nintendo in recent years. They wait until something has so much critical mass that they can't ignore it anymore. Not only did a bunch of fans spend time making this, I don't know, Portal 64 demake for the Nintendo 64 emulators of Valve's Portal, but they're about to release it or something like that. They're going to make a big splash by doing this thing that is probably illegal right under Nintendo's nose. It's getting a lot of press. It's finally maybe in a place where it will cut into Nintendo's profits or where Nintendo will have this responsibility to shareholders. Yeah, you got to protect your IP. Otherwise, maybe it's not going to be
23:24 Speaker 04 worth anything at the end of the day. And Yuzu most definitely had that critical mass. People were talking, making YouTube video after YouTube video about how to get your Nintendo games running on the Steam Deck, how to get your Switch games running there. Valve, in a video that they edited after the fact, had Yuzu as one of the little icons in its Steam Deck promo video. Valve did not leave that up for very long.
23:52 Speaker 03 I guess, to some extent, the case for allowing these emulators to exist is that you let the people who love your products most continue to find ways to engage with them. And the case for taking them down is that you let the people who love your products most continue to engage with them, right? If I'm boiling it all the way down, that's kind of the tension, right?
24:14 Speaker 04 I think that's exactly right. There is another, I don't know how powerful this incentive is to let the emulation community keep going, but Nintendo and Sony and the rest, they do learn something from those developing emulators, too. They hire from the emulation community to develop their own in-house emulators that let you play your old Game Boy Advance games on your Nintendo Switch, or play your PlayStation 1 games on your PS5. We know that they hire from those communities and that they learn things about how hardware works. If somebody figures out how to make Switch games run way better than Nintendo can make them run themselves, that's valuable knowledge for those companies
24:59 Speaker 04 to imbibe. And so they do.
25:01 Speaker 03 The other case that seems like it's important in this context is Dolphin, which was a few years ago. And I think one of the things I'm trying to figure out in this whole process is where this line is for a company like Nintendo to go from allowing these communities to exist on the internet versus causing them huge amounts of trouble. And I feel like Dolphin explored one version of that line. Can you explain what happened there?
25:27 Speaker 04 Dolphin is the most popular GameCube and Wii emulator. It came out in the early 2000s and it does both of those Nintendo consoles. The Dolphin case is really interesting for two reasons. One reason is that it did not get served with a legal complaint. It did not get sent a DMCA takedown. This was very much the result of Nintendo legal being approached with an "is this okay for this emulator to appear on the Steam Store?" Valve wanted to know if this was kosher. And apparently Valve reached out to Nintendo's legal team. And what do you think Nintendo's legal team is going to say if you come to them and ask,
26:12 Speaker 04 is emulation okay? I think they're probably going to try to shut that down. And so Dolphin wound up not being able to bring Dolphin to Steam, very specifically to Valve's Steam PC game digital distribution platform, because Valve asked Nintendo and Nintendo said, nope. And then Valve said, nope, probably we're not going to bother doing this. At the end of the day, a platform, whether it be Valve with Steam or whether it be GitHub hosting, or GitLab, I should say, hosting files for emulators, as it did for a few of the clones of Yuzu, after Yuzu got sued out of existence by Nintendo.
26:54 Speaker 04 The platform has no responsibility to keep up anything that they don't want, that they don't want to fight for. The platform, they can, at the slightest provocation, at the slightest hint from Nintendo or any other company, that they might have any kind of legal threat coming at any point in the future, they can say, bye, we don't need you. If it's an application that might ever be used for piracy, there's even less incentive for them to defend. There is a whole process. If Valve did want to defend against a DMCA takedown request, there's a whole process. They can say, Dolphin, you can give us a counter notice to the DMCA.
27:38 Speaker 04 You can reveal where your developers live. You can agree that you were served with this notice. And then you can fight it. We'll take that back to Nintendo and say, Nintendo, do you really want to go after us for this? And that allows Valve to be protected from the Nintendo lawsuit, theoretically.
27:58 Speaker 03 In the Yuzu case, though, this was not about a platform or a partner or something. This was about Yuzu specifically, right?
28:07 Speaker 04 In both of these cases, there was no DMCA takedown. This was never a DMCA takedown issue. It was a DMCA issue.
28:17 Speaker 03 We have to take another quick break. And when we get back, Sean and I are going to break down what the DMCA is and why this copyright law is so important in the context of video game emulation.
28:28 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
28:38 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
28:45 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
28:59 Speaker 06 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
29:28 Speaker 07 Propel Fitness Water. With Gatorade Electrolytes, zero sugar and vitamins. Propel hydrates better than water to help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you? Propel with Gatorade Electrolytes.
29:47 Speaker 03 We're back with Verge senior editor Sean Hollister to explain the DMCA and how it's played a central role in the game industry's copyright disputes.
29:56 Speaker 03 So what is the law we're talking about here? You've been to the DMCA a few times. Is the DMCA, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, what we're looking at when we talk about this stuff?
30:06 Speaker 04 Absolutely. So, Digital Millennium Copyright Act has all kinds of statutes in it. But the two that we talk about most are DMCA 512, which has to do with DMCA takedowns. That's the idea that a platform can protect itself from lawsuits by saying, "We didn't upload this thing. We took it down as soon as we saw it because of our notice," or whatever.
30:26 Speaker 03 That's when you go to YouTube and the video has gone 512.
30:29 Speaker 04 Yes, 512. But then there's DMCA 1201. And that is about circumvention of technological protection measures. That's the statute that has not been litigated in regards to emulators. There haven't been any cases where we've said, "Oh, yeah. It's okay," or "It's not okay," for somebody to break
30:55 Speaker 04 Encryption, break technological protection measures, go around them, sidestep them while trying to play a game. So DMCA 1201 says, and I quote, "No person shall manufacture, import, offer to the public, provide, or otherwise traffic in any technology, product, service, device, component, or part thereof," that is, here's the important part, "primarily designed or produced for the purpose of circumventing a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title." Primarily designed to circumvent technological protection measures.
31:30 Speaker 03 Actually, while we're, while we're reading laws to each other, can I read you the very beginning of 1201, which I actually think is sort of fascinating? It just says, "No person shall circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title." And I have had this sentence stuck in my head for a long time because Cory Doctorow, who is an author and activist and was on Decoder a while ago, it was a really good episode, everybody should listen to it. He described it to me one time as basically saying, "It doesn't matter what's on the other side of the lock. The fact that it has a lock means breaking the lock is illegal. And as soon as I put a lock on something, you can't break it. It doesn't matter what's on the other side." And he was deeply enraged by the way that that was set up.
32:12 Speaker 03 But I feel like that goes to what you're talking about, where we've come to, the conversation is, it's in some ways not about the games or the emulators, it's about these encryption keys. And it seems like increasingly people want to focus on the locks, because we don't have to talk about anything else, because DMCA 1201 says, "If you break the lock, whatever you did it in service of, it doesn't matter. It's illegal."
32:35 Speaker 04 Yeah. It is such a powerful and frustrating law for anyone in this space, or any, or people at home who just want to fix their own shit. You know, "I want to fix my own gadgets." And DMCA 1201 is telling me that if they have software locks on them, I cannot break those locks. When it comes to the locks, there are two things to think about with regards to emulators. One is that every three years, the Library of Congress decides that
33:06 Speaker 04 You can pick a few of these locks for a limited amount of time. There are exceptions to the DMCA 1201 that are set by the copyright office. Maybe these three years, you can work on your John Deere tractor, or whatever it is. Maybe these three years, we will allow this kind of software to exist in libraries. The other thing, though, to draw your attention to that, primarily designed for the purpose of circumventing encryption, this is the thing that comes up time and again when the emulation community is trying to argue that DMCA 1201 does not apply to them. Yuzu and every other emulator developer wants to say, "We are not primarily designed to break encryption."
33:50 Speaker 03 What do they say they're primarily for?
33:52 Speaker 04 I don't think they say they're primarily designed for anything. Now that I think about it. Because they can't say that 99% of people are going to play homebrew games on this, or public domain games, particularly for the Nintendo Switch, where there will not be any public domain games. It is relatively new console from 2017.
34:08 Speaker 03 I will say, I've heard people say things about game preservation and accessibility and that kind of thing, and I find those arguments convincing as far as they go. But again, to your point, many more people just want to play Mario than are worried about the cultural history of video games.
34:25 Speaker 04 They are. They really are. I wouldn't say that it's a shame, because enough people are, and I think will be, interested in the preservation of video games, that eventually we'll get to somewhere where we are preserving them more thoroughly, I hope. I hope we don't lose too many things before that happens along the way. But with Yuzu, Nintendo argued that it was primarily designed to circumvent, that it was primarily designed for piracy. And when Yuzu flipped, it agreed, whoever is at Tropicase LLC, agreed that Yuzu was primarily designed.
35:02 Speaker 04 To circumvent these technological protections and they apologized for the piracy. And that is not a precedent, it's a settlement. So it's not a legal precedent. It's not like every emulator is now crippled by the idea that it's been decided that one of them is primarily designed to circumvent technological protections. But Nintendo got one of them to roll over real easy and say the thing that no other emulator developer would admit.
35:28 Speaker 03 And it seems like that, Yuzu just taking the hit and agreeing to the settlement, has really spooked the rest of the emulator world.
35:35 Speaker 04 Absolutely. We don't know how long it'll spook them. There's optimism that this is just a moment where everybody's, you know, we're all gonna watch our backs, we're gonna be careful. But, yes, a bunch of developers just outright quit the scene. They're like, we're done with emulation, this is too hot now. This precedent from Nintendo that we all now know, the emulation community all now knows, gamers all now know, that Nintendo could come down at any moment. And you probably wouldn't be able to do much about it. Because they have that argument in their back pocket. Who knows if Nintendo would win such a lawsuit if any emulator developer decided to actually fight it?
36:18 Speaker 04 But they can definitely get into court. They can get heard on the back of DMCI 1201, which means that any emulator developer would need to lawyer up and no emulator developer has the money to lawyer up.
36:31 Speaker 03 Have we seen this happen in court at all? Is there any legal precedent for how a case like that might go? If somebody decided to fight it all the way to the end?
36:41 Speaker 04 On 1201 with emulators, no. I've been told that there is no precedent where anybody's gone into court with an emulator and fought.
36:52 Speaker 04 Even a little bit, much less all the way to the end. But we do know that Nintendo has come down with criminal charges on those who sell mod chips, which is another way to get into the Nintendo console. They've come down on ROM sites and mod chip sellers very hard in the past. Gary Bowser, who of course has the same last name as the famous Nintendo character and of Nintendo America's current president. He was sentenced to 40 months in prison. And I think he only served maybe 14 of them, but it changed his life because he was selling a physical circumvention device to allow people to hack into their Nintendo switches and possibly play pirated games on them.
37:38 Speaker 03 It seems like there are two main assumptions people could be making now, right? On the one hand, it might seem like we've entered an era where companies like Nintendo are just simply going to be more aggressive and litigious. On the other, there could be a chance that Yuzu was a target because it very specifically got too big and was leaking games. And then, once the dust settles, everything can go back to business as usual otherwise? Is the community feeling one of those more than the other?
38:07 Speaker 04 I want to say it's kind of neither of those.
38:10 Speaker 03 Okay.
38:11 Speaker 04 On the one hand, yes, the threat is absolutely out there. Nintendo could do this at any moment. There's the, maybe if we get quieter, Nintendo will go away and let things be the way they were. But there's also this sense that maybe things will never go back to being the way that they were because now every console will have encryption, maybe many layers of it, and that the threat of the DMCA 1201 will now hang over every emulator going forward.
38:43 Speaker 04 Nintendo has not just shown that they can make an emulator developer run rollover. They have shown how to make an emulator developer rollover. And the how is you protect your console better. You add more layers of technological protection measures. And then more emulator developers will think twice about doing that.
39:03 Speaker 03 Do you think that arms race is just gonna move the emulator community out more and more? I mean, on the one hand, you've described a pretty real technical arms race that is hard for hobbyists to keep winning. On the other hand, you've described a legal arms race that is really hard for hobbyists to keep winning, especially next to deep pocketed lawyers at these gaming companies. To some extent, it sounds like maybe the only plausible thing for a lot of people to do is just kind of throw up their hands and give up and find something else to do.
39:39 Speaker 04 I think that many will think twice about jumping headfirst into emulation. But there's also this undercurrent of fuck Nintendo that also pushed a number of forks of Yuzu to exist. There's this sense that, gosh Nintendo, we bought these games. We are dumping them from our own switches using the copies that we bought. They play better in an emulator. If Nintendo isn't going to, you know, at least make these games play their best and give us powerful hardware to run them on, we should have the legal right to do this thing. And people who believe that they have the legal right to do a thing and don't actually have the legal right to do a thing often will use emulation and other technologies
40:24 Speaker 04 as a form of protest. And so I imagine we'll see protesters keep popping up. I don't know.
40:31 Speaker 03 It seems like there would be an opening there for the gaming companies to, if not extend an olive branch, then at least sort of solve the problem. If you go back to the music piracy example, that got really messy and really ugly and really bad. And then we got music streaming, which was essentially the product people wanted all along, and it worked and in large ways killed the piracy industry. Do you think there's a path there for emulation to go sort of full legit in that way?
41:04 Speaker 04 I don't think so. I've heard it from a few developers as well. I don't ever see that happening because unlike music, the quality matters so much and it changes so much over time. You know, if you have a master recording of a particular piece of music, that's the best that recording is ever going to be, right? It just gets worse from there as it gets down sampled. But with a game, we all know that if they sit on a game for a long time, they can make it look better. They can remaster the game, they can re-release the game, they can sell it once again to people and make another
41:45 Speaker 04 chunk of money on it, or, you know, have it prop up their subscription service as Nintendo does with Nintendo Switch Online. And if it can use these emulated games to get people paying monthly for Nintendo Switch Online, I don't think it would ever choose to distribute individual ROMs instead, particularly when those could potentially be copied and create another cycle of piracy.
42:09 Speaker 03 Thanks again to Sean for taking the time to speak with me, and thank you for tuning in. I hope you enjoyed it, and don't worry, Nilay's back next week. If you have big ideas on what the Decoder team should cover or who they should have on the show, they really do want to hear your feedback. You can email them all at [email protected] . They really do read every email. Or hit up Nilay directly on Threads. Nilay is @Reckless1280. There's also a TikTok. Check it out. @DecoderPod on TikTok. It's a lot of fun. Decoder is a production of The Verge and is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt and was edited by Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. See you next time.
42:54 Speaker 08 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing in a wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash Apple Watch Series 12.
43:24 Speaker 09 I work here. You know, that thing you have to wake up for every day? I know, I've made things a little difficult in the past. Okay, a lot difficult. But I got some help from UKG. And finally, I understand. Now I'm making work, work better. I've even got AI agents helping me find new ways to help you, your people, and your business. Because when work works, everything works. UKG, HR, Pay, and Workforce Management.
Previous Mailchimp CEO Rania Succar on culture, acquisitions, and how big 'small business' really is Next Why Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince is the internet’s unlikely defender Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated