Pod Insights Decoder What happened to the metaverse? About this episode This week I’m talking to Matthew Ball, who was last on the show in 2022 to talk about his book “The Metaverse: How it Will Revolutionize Everything.” It’s 2024 and it’s safe to say that has not happened yet. But Matt’s still on the case — in fact he just released an almost complete update of the book, now with the much more sober title, “Building the Spatial Internet.”
Matt and I talked a lot about where the previous metaverse hype cycle landed us, and what there is to learn from these boom and bust waves. We talked about the Apple Vision Pro quite a bit; if you read or watched my review when it came out, you’ll know I think the Vision Pro is almost an end point for one set of technologies. I wanted to know if Matt felt the same and what needs to happen to make all of this more mainstream and accessible.
Links:
Fully revised and updated edition to the “The Metaverse” | W. W. Norton
Apple Vision Pro review: magic, until it’s not | The Verge
Apple’s Vision Pro: five months later | Vergecast
Is the metaverse going to suck? A conversation with Matthew Ball | Decoder
Interviewing Meta CTO Andrew Bosworth on the Metaverse, VR/AR, AI | Matthew Ball
Interviewing Epic CEO Tim Sweeney and author Neal Stephenson | Matthew Ball
An Interview with Matthew Ball about Vision Pro and the state of gaming | Stratechery
Tim Sweeney explains how the metaverse might actually work | The Verge
Fortnite is winning the metaverse | The Verge
Is the Metaverse Just Marketing? | NYT
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Our producers are Kate Cox and Nick Statt. Our editor is Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Give you and your team more time to focus on the work that matters. This is AMEX Corporate, one intelligent platform for company spending. With smart expense management to help capture details, categorize spend, and streamline expense submission and approval, there's less manual work for your team and greater visibility and control for you. Built to simplify, designed to scale. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:30 Speaker 01 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition, even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 and 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
1:02 Speaker 02 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Eli Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. This week, I'm talking to Matthew Ball, who was last on the show in 2022, to talk about his book, The Metaverse: How It Will Revolutionize Everything. It's 2024 now, and it's safe to say that that has not yet happened. But Matt's still on the case. In fact, he just released an almost complete update of the book now with a much more sober title, Building the Spatial Internet. Matt and I talked a lot about where the previous metaverse hype cycle landed us and what there is to learn from these boom and bust waves in technology. We also talked quite a bit about the Apple Vision Pro as sort of a marker or a symbol of where the metaverse is now and where it has yet to go. If you read or watched my Vision Pro review in The Verge when it came out, you know that
1:47 Speaker 02 I think the Vision Pro is sort of an endpoint for one set of technologies. And I wanted to know if Matt felt the same way, and what needs to happen to make all of this much more mainstream and accessible. It's tempting to think that the metaverse just fizzled out after the huge explosion of hype that came after Facebook renamed itself to Meta, hype which the lackluster Quest Pro and messy Horizon platform couldn't really live up to, and hype which eventually feels like it got totally washed away by the arrival of generative AI. But Matt's point is that the metaverse didn't just disappear. The major players like Meta, Fortnite Maker, Epic Games and Roblox, they're all still plugging away at it, albeit gradually. While Meta and Apple go head to head on hardware, the gaming companies whose engines make the 3D internet come to life
2:31 Speaker 02 are still working on some of the core technical ideas, all while contending with an industry-wide downturn that's led to waves of layoffs, not to mention a pretty stark lack of consumer enthusiasm in the whole metaverse concept, combined with some intense backlash to both crypto and AI. Matt and I got into all of that and more, and he made the case for why the ideas that power what we think of as the metaverse today are a lot bigger than just buzzwords and futurist predictions. He's optimistic that we're still on a path towards a new spatial internet. The progress is being made, and booms and busts are just part of the directory from where we are now to where we might be in the future. Okay, The Metaverse with Matthew Ball. Here we go.
3:20 Speaker 02 Matthew Ball, you are the CEO and managing partner of Apillion and author of the book The Metaverse: Building the Spatial Internet, which is a different title for a book that we already talked about. Welcome to Decoder.
3:30 Speaker 03 Glad to be back.
3:31 Speaker 02 You were last on the show in 2022. The book did have a different title. It was a much more expansive title. It was The Metaverse and How It Will Revolutionize Everything. You changed the title. It's a little smaller. Tell me about that. What's going on with this book?
3:44 Speaker 03 So the book is a comprehensive update, revision, expansion to that 2022 title. It's about 70% net new in content, 40% longer. And so though the subtitle might seem smaller, the book itself is actually a lot more expansive, artificial intelligence being one of those categories. But I'll tell you, I never really loved the subtitle. It was actually very off-piste for me stylistically. So I did use this book as an opportunity to change that, just like I updated and improved a lot of the original text.
4:12 Speaker 02 The first time I read the book, and then as I was reading the new version, it feels like a textbook in a good way. If you don't know anything, you can read this book and sort of understand your thinking about the metaverse. There's a bunch of definitions in it which are important. The definitions all build on each other. Is that how you're thinking of this? Is the way a textbook gets revised over time, you're going to keep revising this book over time?
4:32 Speaker 03 The goal was very much to detail all of the technologies, the trends, the behaviors, and the key quandaries that are going to affect the development of the metaverse, the spatial internet, the 3D internet, what have you. I did not want to advocate for any individual philosophy, business model, technology, or even theory. Of course, a reader can nevertheless understand where I'm kind of tipping my hat and the version of the metaverse that I would most like. But the goal was to take a more factual basis and explain to readers how we got here, where we might need to go, so that whether or not you are a content marketer, a entrepreneur, a large company executive, you could understand these trends holistically and then make your bets accordingly.
5:14 Speaker 02 You say tip your hand. The title kind of tips your hand, right? You have a definition of the metaverse. It's the spatial internet. It's the 3D internet. I think you call it several times. It kind of is the one you think about where you exist in a video game with other people right now is the closest I think we have to it. And that environment persists. You can take actions in it. You can like pay money in it. You can do all that stuff. Is that still your working model of it? That was certainly the working model when we talked two years ago.
5:37 Speaker 03 That's quite right. I finished the original book in truly the last few pages where I get a little bit more speculative. And I make the argument that by the end of the decade, many people are likely to acknowledge that the internet that we experience today, that being 2022, had changed. It had become more immersive, more embodied, more experiential, more 3D. But I also say that it's unlikely that we use the term metaverse at that point. In fact, it's unlikely that we used any of the terms save for the word internet and perhaps the 3D internet. The one flaw, or foundational flaw with the metaverse, beyond its association with dystopian literature, beyond its association with a specific company, and beyond that perhaps
6:19 Speaker 03 failed projects in both crypto and VR, is the fact that it is very much perceived as an end state, right? The metaverse is a fully realized experience. And that makes understanding our trajectory from whenever to there really hard.
6:34 Speaker 03 And so the goal here was actually to separate away from an end state and to instead talk about the minor contributions, the major accelerants and the overall pathway to getting there. Whether we call that spatial or immersive, it's kind of immaterial.
6:50 Speaker 02 In the two years since you wrote the first version of the book and you were on the show, what are the minor iterative steps and what do you think are the major accelerants?
6:57 Speaker 03 Well, I think there are three areas that have exceeded expectations and I like to highlight that blockchain is 15 years old. HMDs or head mounted displays are roughly 70 year technology and then artificial intelligence is variably dated at around 70 or in some instances 100 years old. In each of those areas, it feels like the last two and a half years have actually felt more like decades of acceleration. Artificial intelligence is a super clear example. When you take a look at head mounted displays, the introduction of the Vision Pro, though it hasn't changed the world as we know it today, it's a brilliant case study because it shows you what perhaps the most technically capable, most brand savvy and most accomplished tech pioneer has and has not been able to
7:39 Speaker 03 achieve with the device category or the form factor. And then blockchains, essentially 70% of all money going into that technology has gone in since that book was published. Probably 95% of total transactions, nearly all users. And of course, we crashed from a peak market cap of 3 trillion down to 800 billion. We nearly reclaimed that high a few months ago. During that time, we had countless failures of technology, of products of entrepreneurs. And so those three areas, though again, between 15 and 100 years each, have changed quite comprehensively. And so actually bringing users through, not just to understand that new history, but to place it within new context and to better understand
8:22 Speaker 03 and acknowledge what the problems are, felt like one of the most important updates to the book.
8:29 Speaker 02 Let's start with the Vision Pro because it's the flashiest thing that probably listeners understand it the most is the most different thing. I spent a lot of time with it. I reviewed it. My read of it, it feels like it echoes yours, right? Like here's the best we can do. It's nowhere near good enough. There's a part of me that says, and I put this in my review. That maybe camera-based pass-through on screens in front of your eyes, maybe we should just admit to ourselves, this is a dead end. And we have to build some other kind of technology to make this work. Are you seeing the Vision Pro that way? Or do you see iterative steps from this Vision Pro to something that enables more of the metaverse that you have been thinking about?
9:08 Speaker 03 So I think you and I are largely aligned. In fact, your review is quoted quite extensively in the book itself, because I thought it was particularly insightful in that same regard. And I mean that earnestly. I think of it in a few different ways. First and foremost, I think it is important to recognize that while we don't know how much Apple has spent building this device, we have some semblance of an idea. Since Mike Rockwell, who led the development of the Vision Pro, began his group in 2015, Apple has spent roughly $135 billion on total R and D. They don't have product P and Ls. They probably couldn't even tell you the answer. How much did they spend? The investments in...
9:48 Speaker 02 I feel like Tim Cook knows the answer. I know Apple likes to say this about itself. I'm confident Tim Cook knows the answer.
9:53 Speaker 03 Well, I'm sure he can tell you in some vague sense, but my point is just extricating silicon development for the Vision Pro from the rest of their line is difficult. But the point is, Tim Cook proudly said, "This is our most advanced device ever. It's the most sophisticated piece of consumer hardware ever produced." He said 5,000-plus R and D patents went into the device specifically, not the broader corpus of work that might include the Vision Pro 2, optical AR glasses, but just the Vision Pro. That's about 25% of all patents they've filed since 2015. And so no matter how you allocate that $135 billion, you're getting to tens of billions of spend, not identical to Meta,
10:36 Speaker 03 which has also spent on marketing, on content, on device subsidies. But that is to say, we now have two companies that have spent tens of billions of dollars, have slightly different stylistic interface, product optimization and trade-off choices. And we feel like both of those devices are far away from being mainstream. When you go back to that initial announcement, I remember Jay Peters, or perhaps Alex Heath, had that leak from Mark trying to reassure his staff. And he said, "We actually find this reassuring, because the worst thing that could have happened was that Apple had discovered something we hadn't." And instead, he felt reassured that there was no new science. So the reason why I say this is...
11:17 Speaker 03 You go back 15 years ago, it was consensus in big tech that this was going to be a solvable problem by the end of the decade. Not just that we could produce the device we wanted, but that we would have and hundreds of millions of consumers would have embraced it. 15 years later, companies like Meta haven't even shipped their optical AR display. The introduction of the Vision Pro is simultaneously an affirmation that the era of HMDs is here, yet a reminder that it's very far off for the average person. I'm a little bit more optimistic as to whether or not the Vision Pro has us on the right path, partly because I think when you separate all of the constituent parts, you can see the progress. Our devices have roughly the same battery life, roughly the same price point, roughly the same weight as they did seven or eight years ago,
12:02 Speaker 03 but they have four times the sensors, three times the screen resolution, three to four times the frame rate. They're capable of doing far more. They have spatial audio and so on and so forth. But I would say that we have certainly learned that that day that 10, 15 years ago, we imagined would already be here is still probably 10 to 15 years away.
12:23 Speaker 02 So the data point here that I haven't think of a lot is inside of Meta. You actually just talked to Meta CTO Andrew Bosworth, who is sharp on the Metaverse and the amount of money he's spending. They restructured, right? They said, okay, look, the Quest and the headsets are going to go in this division. The glasses, the Meta Ray-Ban sunglasses, that is a great product. It's finding its own product market fit. We're going to put all of our effort there. And they're moving away from the Metaverse ideas that prompted the name change into what you might call augmented reality with the Ray-Ban glasses, which are basically just a voice assistant in some headphones and a camera and sunglasses. And that's where the consumers are. Do you see
13:06 Speaker 02 that as evidence that this is actually getting more refined or that 15-year roadmap has another 15 years to go?
13:12 Speaker 03 I'm interested by your perspective there because I would disagree with the characterization. Now, the tough part about that is that organizational changes are opaque. They're partly for PR and optics, and they're never really going to explain how the priorities have changed. What we know is that Vishal Shah, who was in charge of essentially the software and experiences layer for Quest devices, now also runs the hardware. And now both of those divisions report directly to Boz, who runs all of Reality Labs. That seems like an elevation of the software side of the company. The AR glasses themselves, as I understand them, still report within the Metaverse Division, still report up through the rest of that team. It does seem that the artificial intelligence layer is coming from another part of the business,
13:54 Speaker 03 but the implementation for that audio assistant is still going through the Reality Labs group. The more important point that I would argue is if you go back to 2021, when Mark changed the name of the company, he was quite clear in both the hype videos that they released, as well as his own talking points, that AR, mixed reality, traditional 2D interfaces and VR were inextricably linked core and parts of the Metaverse, and that there was no starting or ending line between those experiences. The downside of that was the only device you could buy from them at the time was virtual reality. The only thing that you could really experience of their Metaverse group was virtual reality.
14:36 Speaker 03 And therefore, every demo that they had was a virtual reality. That has had this lingering effect where people say the Metaverse is virtual reality. Even Neil Stephenson, who largely adhered to that when he wrote Snow Crash in 1992, has publicly separated himself from that idea. But there's still a lingering perception.
14:56 Speaker 02 We're seeing more and more of that, right? That some of these companies are actively trying to distance themselves from VR, or at least the idea that they only do VR. We see that with Meta and the Ray-Ban glasses, and to some extent with the Apple Vision Pro. Apple only talks about it as a mixed-reality device with pass-through that lets you stay in your environment. That's been the big bet in Silicon Valley for a long time. We're going to get to actual augmented reality. We're going to layer digital information over the world you're in. My killer app for that is just please help me with faces and names. I will spend any amount of money on a device that would help me with faces and names. But that's, you know, to do that, you have to build a worldwide facial recognition database. There are some costs along the way. Is that part of your metaverse definition? This more traditional augmented reality that everyone's been talking about for so long?
15:41 Speaker 03 Yeah, and this gets to the idea of the 3D internet, right? It's where we get into the ideas of persistent digital twins, the idea that the way in which you've actually solved for self-driving vehicles at level five at scale with improved accident rates is to build persistent, essentially UGC-contributed simulations. We know, in fact, that that's a significant part of Tesla's roadmap and part of the robotaxi plan. They are today building a persistent, live, Unreal Engine-based simulation of San Francisco, and their idea is essentially that every single part of their self-driving car network, including privately-owned vehicles, would be transmitting LiDAR-infrared radar scans
16:25 Speaker 03 to build that 3D representation. And not only would that be used to aid the driving cars themselves, it would become essential infrastructure for the city, for emergency services, for ads and what have you. That's an important part. And if you rewind three years ago, Jensen Huang took a lot of flak for making the argument that the metaverse was eventually going to be half of world GDP, which still sounds fantastical and is in excess of even my expectations for it. But his perception there was actually the same, right? That the fundamental processes of the modern economy would be running through industrial-grade 3D simulations, which in his perspective was the metaverse, rather than just a consumer-leisure VR headset experience.
17:11 Speaker 02 We need to take a quick break. We'll be right back.
17:53 Speaker 04 When you need to build up your team to handle the growing chaos at work, use Indeed sponsored jobs. It gives your job post the boost it needs to be seen and helps reach people with the right skills, certifications and more. Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com/podcast. That's indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.
18:23 Speaker 05 Low energy, unfocused, foggy? You might be dehydrated. Gatorade Zero powders have been scientifically designed to help improve hydration balance in the body with a clinically proven electrolyte blend and no artificial colors or flavors. Great tasting hydration, no matter where you're going. Shop now online or at retailers nationwide. Gatorade hydrates better than water. Is it in you? Symptoms noted are signs of mild to moderate dehydration. Consult a healthcare professional if symptoms persist.
18:56 Speaker 02 We're back with Metaverse author Matthew Ball to discuss whether the tech we have today is at all suited to actually building the 3D internet.
19:05 Speaker 02 I feel like you're a good person to talk about these ideas with because one of the things that I'm really challenged with the Vision Pro, with AI as it exists today, with digital twins as they exist today, the whole thing, is the process by which we get from the products and services we have today and the technologies we use to make those products and services and where we might want to go is one, not linear. And then right now, it feels to me like I'm not even sure that the core technologies we're using are the ones that enable the next step that everyone wants. So I'll just use AI as an example. I'm really unsure that LLM technology is the thing that can build the AI systems that everyone's actually selling, right? We've invented a language model and maybe it will never actually reason.
19:49 Speaker 02 And maybe we don't want to live in a video game where the AI models are fully hallucinating without any sense of what the player is doing. Do you see that gap, right? I mean, that's kind of what your book is about, is that this is going to happen in fits and starts. But right now, there's a lot of emphasis on one or two core technologies that might not be able to take the pressure of the expectations.
20:10 Speaker 03 What you are highlighting, the perception that transformers solve important use cases today that are much better than the solutions we had a few years ago, but don't scale. Has actually become increasingly consensus over the last six to eight months. Yan Le Cun, who runs the AI division at Meta is particularly clear about that. He tells researchers starting their careers, don't focus on L L Ms. John Karmic is perhaps my favorite example. John was one of the co-founders of Id Software. He's considered the godfather of 3D graphics. Later, he became the CTO of Oculus VR in 2014 and left Meta in late 2022. He started his own AGI startup.
20:53 Speaker 03 And he has made this argument that he believes that all of today's technologies are incapable of getting to AGI. And he says, all of the pioneers have been distracted by what he calls multi-billion dollar off ramps. And he doesn't besmirch anyone from doing that, but he just says, you're never going to get there. If every time you see a multi-billion dollar TAM, you pursue it. He has instead made the argument that he believes that actually many of the fundamental premises around AGI from the 70s and 80s and 90s are actually a better pathway. It's just that they were technologically impossible at the time due to multiple different constraints, whether that was edge computing networks,
21:34 Speaker 03 bandwidth capacity, or just the scarce and poor availability of GPUs at the time. And so part of the point of the book is to talk about the end state of the metaverse. Chapter five is not just a definition of the metaverse, it's the full spec metaverse. The book itself is designed to tell you how we start to get to that end state, but then to detail the many different uncertainties. But I will say very conclusively that as critical as AI is to building the metaverse and despite the many ways in which today's transformer models, multimodal L L Ms, can accelerate that path, most believe that very different systems and fundamental architecture is going to be required.
22:15 Speaker 02 You said full spec metaverse. Very quickly, tell people what you mean by that.
22:19 Speaker 03 So what I'm attempting to do is to define the metaverse, not just by saying a 3D internet, but to describe the expansive vision that when Mark Zuckerberg talks about this as a multi-decade transformation, when Jensen Huang talks about a multi-decade transformation, Tim Sweeney, what are they actually describing? I use a variety of different modifiers. And the reason why I say this is if you say, "What's the internet?", it's the TCP IP or Internet Protocol Suite. And so actually, defining the internet technically is not a very good way to explain to the average person what the internet is. Instead, we want to talk about the internet being a consistent, cohesive, comprehensive
22:57 Speaker 03 way of exchanging data across 110,000 autonomous networks, 4 billion-plus applications, 150 million different servers, and billions of end-users and devices. But what we don't do in that description of the internet is talk about scale, talk about experiences, talk about applications, talk about hardware. And so I have a full-spec version of the metaverse that basically says it's a massively scaled and persistent 3D network that can essentially be experienced or co-experienced by everyone simultaneously at some sort of rendering requirement that we consider as basic visual fidelity comparable to the real world, and where we can interoperate
23:42 Speaker 03 and maintain various forms of data: our identity, our payments, our objects, our history. And that's an effort to set up that end state so that we can then walk back to what we lack today, and then talk about the technological point solutions, problems, and hypotheses for closing those gaps.
24:01 Speaker 02 So let me just come at that again from the lens of here's what we have today.
24:04 Speaker 03 Yeah.
24:04 Speaker 02 The Vision Pro, we'll just use that, it's easy. Apple doesn't want it to have fully immersive environments, even though those are the most compelling apps inside the Vision Pro. The idea of it is that you will stay in your environment, that you will pass through information. It's not building a simulation or environment, just passing through camera information. There's some amount of AR involved in there. It's actually not a lot, which I think is surprising for that product, given Apple's enormous investment in AR over the years. Is that the kind of step you're thinking of? Or is it more immersive, more VR-ish?
24:37 Speaker 03 It's not more immersive and more VR-ish. I think, again, this is why I talk about the Internet Protocol Suite is we're experiencing the Internet constantly. We're not actively logging on to it. It's running sidewalks. It's running security badges in our office. It's the way that our OnStar guide in a GM vehicle is identifying that a crash has happened and then alerting the authorities. We think of it as this, again, comprehensive, coherent and consistent network for the ubiquitous exchange of data across all forms of different applications, devices and intelligence systems, upgrading that to 3D. Now, naturally, when we talk about 3D and we talk about that end state vision where
25:17 Speaker 03 you have more consumer applications, more time, more people, more often engaged in these immersive environments, it is sensible that having a more 3D native interface is important. And you can see that, right? We have a billion people a month engaging in a 3D real-time environment through Roblox, Fortnite, Call of Duty and so forth. But if you haven't grown up with controllers in hands, if you're not familiar with dual analog sticks, it's hard. And even if you have, there are fundamental limitations to what you can do in those environments because button mapping is finite and the precision of all of those inputs is still mediocre. And so we naturally assume that if you want to fully leverage 3D environments in the
26:01 Speaker 03 classroom, in healthcare, in design, that you require full immersion into that environment. You need full digital dexterity and that in order to get older generations and more use cases in, you just require those devices. Doesn't require VR, but it at least involves some form of eye-based device.
26:22 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's very visual. But that's kind of what I'm getting at, right? You've got to put something over your eyes. You've got to put something on your head. And that seems like where all of these plans kind of fall down because that technology is the one that has hit the clearest, I wouldn't say dead end, but the clearest stall, right? This is the best we can do and it's still very complicated and very expensive and pretty fiddly. And then the utility doesn't overcome the fiddliness.
26:48 Speaker 03 I'm totally with you. I mean, look, I would say about the Vision Pro, it is clear that it is a remarkably crafted device that can perform some tasks far better than any other device. And yet, I think that those few things that it does better are far short of the things that it does worse. And at the end of the day, the big challenge for any of these head-mounted displays, be it AR glasses or VR, MR, XR goggles, is that the smartphone's big advantage is it was probably your and my second computer alongside a PC. For most people on Earth, it was their first computer and thus also their first access pathway to the Internet. But for everyone today, an HMD will be their fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh, eighth computer.
27:33 Speaker 03 And right now, those devices are very far from replacing your need to carry your smartphone or iPad or PC to and from work and out shopping. And the few instances in which it does one of those tasks better, it's not good enough to replace any of those devices, and it's not good enough to warrant being held in your bag.
27:53 Speaker 02 Yeah, I guess the comparison is really apt here, right? We're going to give you a second computer in the United States, and many in mobile generally around the world, we're going to give you your first computer that is an excellent general-purpose computer. I think that it was the CEO of BlackBerry who said, "We didn't realize they weren't competing with us, they were competing with your laptop." And so you've got, now you've got this excellent general-purpose computer that's going to eat everything else. What you are describing is the actual reverse, right? We keep taking shots at a general-purpose spatial computer, whether it's the Quest 3 or the Vision Pro or whatever else it is, and the general case is too hard, so we take even more expensive shots at like a vertical, and those might be working. But it's hard to see how you go from the very, like, targeted, vertical, expensive,
28:37 Speaker 02 to the general, like, cheaper mass market.
28:40 Speaker 03 I think that's where you get to the new Horizon OS strategy, where...
28:45 Speaker 02 That's Meta's OS for the Quest.
28:47 Speaker 03 Correct. And they've just opened it up to various partners. You know, in my interview with Boaz, the CTO at Meta and head of Reality Labs, he talks about the fact that there are currently three different challenges facing XR devices. And unfortunately, they're a vicious cycle. One is the price, the second is the content, and the third is the form factor. And all three of those things affect one another, right? If you want to improve the form factor, that typically means it's lighter and more comfortable, that typically means it's less powerful, and that's going to impede the content. On top of that, the more skews you have on form factor, the harder it is for any content developer to make something. One of the fundamental premises that Apple had was that they can build a remarkable device that will enrich the content ecosystem.
29:31 Speaker 03 But if you're Disney, as an example, right now, you can make something much, much better that is just for the Vision Pro, but the Vision Pro probably has 200,000 total unit sales and the Quest has 20, 25 million. And so the trade off means that you probably want to build to the largest common denominator, not to the top end of the market, but that means you're not building pioneering content that is going to best demonstrate the Vision Pro and drive further adoption. But the premise of the Horizon strategy seems to be that general purpose device, for the reasons I mentioned earlier, is elusive. And so let's instead do an ecosystem where if Logitech wants to come out with a $150 device that is super light, that is only built on cloud, or is designed to be tethered
30:16 Speaker 03 to an Xbox or PlayStation, only uses controllers and therefore doesn't need external cameras for hand tracking, that that will best advance the ecosystem. If a surgeon wants to build an enterprise version using the Quest hardware, they are never going to need hand tracking. It's not precise and reliable enough. So let's again shift that off. That seems like it might be the best bet and would say that let's build the supply chains, let's build the software, let's build a highly fragmented ecosystem of software applications, but collectively share the R and D, collectively push adoption, and maybe 15, 10 years from now, we can start to converge into the mythical device that we hope for.
30:59 Speaker 02 And Meta, of course, will be the operating system vendor who takes fees from everyone. It's a good strategy. It's played out in various ways over time.
31:07 Speaker 03 It's just very counterintuitive now. And I would argue that like, that is probably one of the challenges of the Vision Pro today. As I mentioned, the Hollywood use case. Well, the reality is, putting aside that it's $3,500, and I like to remind individuals that in most developed markets, the sales tax on a Vision Pro exceeds the price to purchase a Quest 3. That's how large the price gap is. It is a way over featured device if what you want to do is review dailies in Hollywood.
31:36 Speaker 02 We have to take another quick break. We'll be right back.
31:46 Speaker 01 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 and 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
32:17 Speaker 04 When you need to build up your team to handle the growing chaos at work, use Indeed sponsored jobs. It gives your job post the boost it needs to be seen and helps reach people with the right skills, certifications and more. Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com/podcast. That's indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.
32:47 Speaker 05 Low energy, unfocused, foggy? You might be dehydrated. Gatorade Zero powders have been scientifically designed to help improve hydration balance in the body. With a clinically proven electrolyte blend and no artificial colors or flavors, great tasting hydration, no matter where you're going. Shop now online or at retailers nationwide. Gatorade: Hydrates Better Than Water. Is it in you? Symptoms noted are signs of mild to moderate dehydration. Consult a healthcare professional if symptoms persist.
33:20 Speaker 02 We're back with Metaverse author Matthew Ball to talk about interoperability in gaming and what needs to happen on the software side to bring us closer to the metaverse.
33:28 Speaker 02 The place where the metaverse might be most accessible to most people today is in games. Disney just gave Epic $1.5 billion in February to grow Fortnite, to grow all the stuff that Epic is doing to participate more there with IP relationships. You talked about Roblox. Roblox is huge. The key piece of your definition of the metaverse or 3D computing is that these things will have to interoperate.
33:54 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
33:54 Speaker 02 Right? You don't want to hand over your world to Disney and Epic and then have a totally different identity in Roblox. Or maybe, maybe some people do. But to build the kind of economy you're talking about, the kind of experiences that you're talking about, you definitely need some interoperability. Is there any hope of that coming? Because it doesn't feel like these companies are incentivized to do it yet.
34:14 Speaker 03 So I love this question. It's actually one of the more important reasons for the book update, which is, over the last two and a half years, I think most people came away saying, that was a bubble. I certainly haven't seen the quote unquote revolution that I was promised. Meta's name change doesn't seem to have changed their trajectory. Now AI is at the forefront. And of course, blockchains have come and gone. As a result, like, I wouldn't begrudge people for saying, like, hasn't this been proven? Isn't it dead, duly rejected by consumers? The goal of this book is really to talk about the arc and progress of those technologies. And I think that those very high level narratives have actually led to us overlooking the very important progress to getting to that end state, interoperability
34:58 Speaker 03 being one such example. Through regulatory action, most of all, but separate from that, actually new technology and investments at the platforms, we are seeing that progress. Apple, in concert with Disney and Pixar, as well as their arch nemesis Epic, Epic's own competitor in Unity, Microsoft and Meta, have established what Jensen Huang has called the HTML of the metaverse, OUSD, as a file format for sharing and exchanging 3D information. Epic is now pioneering a programming language for the metaverse called Verse, that various parties have attached to, that includes transaction-based memory for the exchange
35:41 Speaker 03 of virtual goods. The Disney announcement alongside their Lego partnership is clearly oriented towards off-platform exchange of not just
35:50 Speaker 03 World but user entitlements. Disney said that very clearly. They're like, we will operate, sell and merchandise separate from the Epic team. Even Roblox has started increasingly open sourcing a number of their different technologies. And Apple, for all of its prohibitions on the iPhone, and despite its protestations against regulators worldwide, the Vision Pro is actually their most open device in quite some time. They support open rendering standards such as WebXR and OpenXR. And if you can believe it, they're now allowing enterprises with raw camera access feed. Even on the iPhone, a developer does not have raw access to what the consumer sees through their smartphones,
36:31 Speaker 03 but they get to do so and then exchange, share and locally store that information on or when using the Vision Pro. And so the answer is, look, over two and a half years, there's a real cap on how much progress you can see in interoperation. You see more technological improvements and commitments to openness than you are likely to see actual commercial agreements. And the amount of actual products deployed is going to be fewer still. But I do think that there's been a great amount of interoperation since.
36:59 Speaker 02 Let's take the Disney example. It's simple, it's understandable. Disney sells a lot of merchandise. They sell a lot of toys and t-shirts and princess. I just went to Disney World. We bought all the stuff. The idea that I can buy that stuff in Fortnite and it won't just go to Roblox when I decide to play Roblox, right? That I can buy these digital goods in one environment and they don't appear in the other one right now. That's the status quo.
37:21 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
37:22 Speaker 02 The turn is I buy them in Fortnite and I have the same stuff in Roblox. Like, that's the first, to my mind, the first easy consumer term. There's a bunch of technologies that may or may not enable that. The blockchain is supposed to enable that. Who knows if it will? But those are the kinds of technologies that might enable that stuff. Wanting to do it is a different problem. Do you see any desire to want to do that? Because Disney is giving the money to Epic. You have to assume they're going to want to see the return from their investment in Epic versus, okay, now you can also buy the stuff in Roblox.
37:54 Speaker 03 So there's a few different things there. I think one that is perhaps understated, because the data is really opaque, is that we are starting to see a cap on how much individual users are willing to spend on cosmetics, partly because of what you would call the repeat purchase problem, right? Like, how many times are you actually going to buy a Spider-Man skin? Right? Like, it was very new five or six years ago. You got excited. You could be in Spider-Man Avatar with your own backpack. But once you've purchased it nine different times in PUBG, in Call of Duty, in Fortnite, your inclination to purchase it again goes down. And we're starting to see that. There was a report out the other day that's showing that Epic is actually making fewer skins now than they ever did before with an increased reliance on third-party IP integrations.
38:38 Speaker 03 And despite that fact, sales are going down. And so there definitely is an intent to open that up under the belief that if the utility of a purchase increases, that the willingness to spend will go up and that more purchases will be, will occur. I will tell you first and foremost, there are actually very few people who believe in the metaverse idea, who believe that this is the leading use case. At the end of the day, like, great, you can be Peely the banana in more environments, but it's not clear how important that is. At the end of the day, though, that is actually where we see a lot of the progress being made.
39:12 Speaker 02 Gaming is where most people are experiencing sort of 3D internet. The gaming industry is also in turmoil.
39:17 Speaker 03 Yeah.
39:18 Speaker 02 There's more players playing, there's more money flowing through the system, and there's more game studios going out of business. Is that just an industry shifting towards, okay, all of the experiences are going to happen in a handful of games or environments versus what we've been doing for years, which is lots and lots of new games?
39:36 Speaker 03 The challenges that the gaming industry are facing are manifold, and that's why we're seeing such turmoil. It's not just interest rates. It's not just capitalism run amok. It is a reflection of several years of accelerated growth, followed by several years in which revenues have actually declined at a point in time in which the cost of labor has gone up, a reflection of both justified increases in individual compensation, an improvement in work-life balance, a shift towards unionization. But it's unfortunately been in parallel to a pullback in consumer spending. It's remarkable to imagine that among every single major media category...
40:12 Speaker 03 Gaming is the only one that has contracted since the pandemic. Not stabilized at its prior levels, but it's contracted. And that has had pretty significant consequences that are also in contrast to what everyone expected. There's not a single forecast you can find from 21, 22, 2023 that didn't suggest that the industry was going to have grown tens of billions by now that it did not. And unfortunately, that has bled down right to the bottom. But at the end of the day, what you're tipping your hat at is also true. Which is, like any increasingly saturated or mature channel, a few platforms are increasingly powerful in every measure. Revenue, profit, the developer scale, the profitable developer scale, the predictability and thus safety of incremental investments.
40:56 Speaker 03 And their share of time, data and consumer spend. And that has made it very hard for all other games to compete. I think one reason to be optimistic, actually, for inter-operation, especially from Epic and Roblox. Is that by opening up, they're actually reducing some of the barriers to third parties to compete. Right? One of the challenges, if you're an independent game developer, is you want to bring an entire friend network over to your new game. And then you want to somehow convince them that even though they've only spent five minutes playing your game, they should buy a Spider-Man outfit. And they have to hope that they were even able to convince Marvel to give them a Spider-Man license. And so the hope would be actually, from the Epic perspective, which is a platform, not a content company.
41:40 Speaker 03 Though Epic, Fortnite, UEFN, like Roblox and Minecraft are becoming larger, more dominant. There's more user lock-in of entitlements and spend and time and player networks. And avatars that actually opening up will start to refertilize the rest of the gaming industry.
41:56 Speaker 02 Where do you think this all goes next? You, you, obviously, you've updated the book. You've been talking about both big changes and minor incremental changes. I assume we'll have you back in another year or two to talk about the next version of the book. What are the things you're looking for next as markers of progress towards the metaverse?
42:11 Speaker 03 I think the big commercial deal or interoperation between the big platforms is the most important. I think the interesting thing is if you take a look at 2015 to 2017, it's inextricably linked with the success of the metaverse in 2021, 2022. It's no coincidence that Satya Nadella, that Tencent, Roblox, Unity, Epic, and Facebook all started talking about the metaverse at the same time. And that's because a number of different things that happened between 2015 and 2018 all matured. iPads became capable of running real AAA video games. We had the rise of battle royals, a genre that has long been contemplated,
42:50 Speaker 03 but had only recently become possible with consumer-grade GPUs and with servers able to manage that synchronization. We had the simultaneous rise of microtransactions and battle passes. And then, most importantly, the floodgates on cross-platform blew open in 2018, strengthening this network effects of all gaming systems that shifted over. And three years later, we had a gaming world, a digital environment that was very different than we had. The challenge of that question now is very few people actually expected that Cambrian explosion to happen. And actually, now, to your point on gaming, most of those tailwinds have expired. Like, there's no new games that are going to shift to cross-platform.
43:33 Speaker 03 Battle passes don't seem to be lifting revenues anymore. Mobile is no longer growing. Social gaming has essentially reached all of its addressable market. There was a hope that virtual reality, that Web 3 gaming, that the metaverse would be that next growth engine. It hasn't happened yet. I think there's a plausible case for generative AI, which faces its own legal and ethical barriers. But I don't know what that next big explosive moment's going to be.
44:00 Speaker 02 Yeah. Well, we're gonna have to have you back when it happens. Let us know. Matt, thanks so much for joining the show.
44:05 Speaker 03 Thanks for having me.
44:10 Speaker 02 Thanks again to Matthew Ball for joining us on Decoder. His newly updated and revised book, The Metaverse: Building the Spatial Internet, is out next week on July 23. Your thoughts about this episode, or really, anything about Decoder. You can email us at [email protected] . We really do read all the emails. You can all see me up directly on Threads. I'm at reckless1280. And we have a TikTok. Check it out. It's @decoderpod. It's a lot of fun. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. And if you really like the show, hit us with that five-star review. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Our producers are Kate Cox and Nick Statt. Our editor is Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. See you next time.
44:49 Speaker 06 Looking for a simple way to thank your clients or recognize employees for a job well done? A Starbucks card is more than a gift. It's a pick-me-up, a break in their day, and a reminder that you appreciate them. Whether you're shopping for digital or physical cards in bulk, Starbucks cards are the perfect gift to brighten anyone's day. Share the joy of coffee and connection when you give the gift of Starbucks. Shop Starbucks cards in bulk now at starbuckscardb2b.com.
45:16 Speaker 07 Mr. Monopoly here. Miss me? Monopoly is back at McDonald's with millions of prizes: a 2027 Jeep Cherokee, a Carnival Cruise vacation, gift cards from DoorDash, and Best Buy. Feel free in the McDonald's app. Get your bag.
45:34 Speaker 08 No purchase necessary. 50 U.S. and D.C. Age 18+. See playatmcd.com for rules and playatmcd.com/amoe for info on playing without purchase by mail by November 2. Chance card game ends November 8. Game ends November 22, 2026. See rules for prize details. Monopoly is a registered trademark of Hasbro.
Previous Biden’s top tech advisor on why AI safety is a “today problem” Next Rivian CEO RJ Scaringe says too many carmakers are copying Tesla Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated