Pod Insights Decoder Underunderstood: Why is This Sheriff Arresting Fire TV Sellers? About this episode An 88-year-old is being charged with a felony after selling ‘jailbroke firesticks’ at a Florida flea market. Why?
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 7,222 words · 19 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. This is AMEX Corporate, a single platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Flexible controls for when priorities shift, support around the clock, all backed by American Express, so you can stay focused on what matters most. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:36 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.
1:01 Speaker 02 Hey, everybody. It's Neelai from Decoder. We've got a little treat on the feed for you today. A few weeks ago, I was a guest on a show called Under Understood. That's a podcast hosted by some of my favorite former Verge staffers, where they explore strange corners of tech and culture. They had me on to talk about a truly strange story, where a sheriff in Florida held a full-on press conference after busting a bunch of older folks selling jailbroken Fire TV sticks in a flea market. It is really something. The story goes in all kinds of directions, and I thought the Decoder audience would enjoy it quite a bit. So we're gonna run it in the feed. Check it out and enjoy.
1:44 Speaker 03 This is Under Understood.
1:48 Speaker 04 Hey, everybody.
1:49 Speaker 02 Hello, Billy.
1:49 Speaker 05 Hi, Billy. Hey, Billy. Regina.
1:55 Speaker 05 Sorry.
1:56 Speaker 04 It's OK. I don't take it personally whatsoever.
1:59 Speaker 05 Good.
2:00 Speaker 02 OK, now I do. Just based on how you said that.
2:03 Speaker 05 Should we start over?
2:04 Speaker 02 No, that was fine.
2:06 Speaker 04 So I want to play you all a press conference.
2:11 Speaker 05 Ooh.
2:11 Speaker 04 And this took place at the tail end of 2020.
2:16 Speaker 06 Merry Christmas, everyone. It's time for our daily briefing. As I told you, we were going to bring you several different press releases this week of Christmas cheer that we've provided for those who violate the law.
2:32 Speaker 07 What?
2:33 Speaker 05 What? What? I'm sorry, huh?
2:35 Speaker 04 So that's Grady Judd. Have any of you encountered this guy?
2:39 Speaker 07 No.
2:40 Speaker 05 Have I encountered Sheriff Grady Judd just in my day to day life?
2:44 Speaker 04 In your day to day life, you probably wouldn't encounter him unless you live in Polk County, Florida, where he's the sheriff and where he's conducting this press conference from.
2:55 Speaker 05 Okay.
2:56 Speaker 06 So we thought we would start with our investigation that began in the month of October as a result of a concerned citizen that came to us and said, you know, I think they're doing illegal stuff out at that international flea market.
3:17 Speaker 04 Any guesses? Any guesses on the illegal stuff they're doing out at that international flea market?
3:22 Speaker 05 Tax evasion?
3:23 Speaker 04 Well, I think that's basically just a given at any flea market.
3:27 Speaker 07 Are they selling pot?
3:28 Speaker 04 No.
3:29 Speaker 07 Are they selling a drug of some sort?
3:31 Speaker 04 No, at least that's not what he's here to talk about.
3:34 Speaker 05 Are they selling like food and they're not supposed to sell food?
3:37 Speaker 04 It's not food.
3:38 Speaker 07 Hmm.
3:40 Speaker 04 All right, I'll keep playing.
3:41 Speaker 06 And we said, like what? And they said, like, no monthly fees for television that the rest of us are having to pay for?
3:50 Speaker 07 What?
3:51 Speaker 06 Something's got to be wrong with that.
3:53 Speaker 07 Is this about Cody boxes?
3:55 Speaker 04 Uh, great question. You, well, let me just keep playing.
4:00 Speaker 07 Okay.
4:01 Speaker 06 We started an undercover investigation, and here's what we found out. You can see the fire sticks. All four of the people we arrested admitted they were jail-broke fire sticks.
4:17 Speaker 05 Oh, my God.
4:18 Speaker 06 That's your clue. Jail-broke fire sticks.
4:23 Speaker 06 A jailbroke fire stick was sold between eighty and a hundred and seven dollars by these four folks that I'll introduce to you in a minute.
4:32 Speaker 08 My god.
4:33 Speaker 06 A regular fire stick sells for between twenty-five and forty dollars.
4:39 Speaker 08 He's holding up a picture of the Fire TV Stick 4K.
4:44 Speaker 04 Yes.
4:44 Speaker 08 This is the, it's like an Amazon set-top box?
4:50 Speaker 04 Yes.
4:51 Speaker 08 Okay, I like only sort of know what this is, so explain for me.
4:55 Speaker 04 Okay, a fire stick, or an Amazon Fire TV Stick, as it's officially called, is, it's like a Roku. You know, it's a smart device that you plug into your TV so you can watch Netflix, or play games, or whatever.
5:10 Speaker 08 Got it.
5:11 Speaker 04 And they run a version of Android, so they're relatively easy to customize with software beyond what's available in Amazon's App Store. Much easier to customize than, say, an Apple TV, or a Roku. And Sheriff Judd is calling these devices, quote, "jailbroke."
5:31 Speaker 08 Isn't jailbreak for iPhones, and for Android, it's something else? Yeah, I always thought jailbroke was an iPhone thing, yeah.
5:39 Speaker 07 I think it's like a more generic term now.
5:42 Speaker 08 Rooted.
5:43 Speaker 07 Rooted, yeah.
5:44 Speaker 04 Yeah, it, as a term, it was first popularized in reference to exploits that allow people to install unauthorized software on Apple iPhones. And that started way back, like, when there wasn't even an official way to add third-party apps. I did it for many years.
5:59 Speaker 07 Same.
6:00 Speaker 08 As did I, yeah.
6:01 Speaker 04 Generally, you're right, on Android devices, which again, the Fire Stick is an Android device, the equivalent process would be called rooting.
6:10 Speaker 08 Gotcha, Sheriff.
6:12 Speaker 04 Gotcha! Throw it out of the court.
6:15 Speaker 08 You idiot.
6:17 Speaker 04 But, but it's also worth noting that the Fire Stick, like many Android devices, doesn't actually require root access to install unauthorized apps. You literally just flip a switch in the settings, and you can install apps directly without having to go to the App Store.
6:34 Speaker 07 What's the county sheriff doing getting involved in this?
6:38 Speaker 04 Well, uh, I guess we'll find out. Let me keep playing it here.
6:41 Speaker 06 We did search warrants, and we took all of these fire sticks last Saturday.
6:46 Speaker 08 Close-up of the fire stick.
6:47 Speaker 06 After making our fourth buy.
6:49 Speaker 08 Actually, close-up of the fire stick poster.
6:52 Speaker 06 And on each of the times that we made a purchase of this illegal product from the sellers, they all admitted that this is how you avoid paying communication services fees. They weren't that technical. They said, this is how you get free TV.
7:12 Speaker 04 Which, hold on, those are two very different things. He's saying they admitted
7:16 Speaker 07 Yeah.
7:16 Speaker 04 to something very specific and then he's like, well, they weren't that technical. They just said, this is how you get free TV.
7:21 Speaker 06 You must understand that here's how it works. If you're in possession of one of these firesticks and you're streaming content, you're committing a misdemeanor.
7:34 Speaker 05 Hmm, what?
7:35 Speaker 06 So let me put that in Polk County vernacular. Every time you turn that TV on
7:40 Speaker 07 Oh.
7:41 Speaker 06 to a channel or a station or Hulu or Netflix that you're supposed to pay for, and you're not paying for it.
7:48 Speaker 05 What? No.
7:49 Speaker 06 You've committed a misdemeanor.
7:51 Speaker 07 I don't think you can watch Hulu on this for free.
7:53 Speaker 05 Right, no.
7:54 Speaker 04 Well, you could prob- they could probably install an app that gives you access to links for streaming Hulu shows on the internet.
8:02 Speaker 05 Right, but it's not Hulu. Like, it doesn't come preloaded with a Hulu subscription.
8:08 Speaker 04 Yeah, he doesn't really seem to understand how it works.
8:10 Speaker 07 This stuff is really frustrating.
8:13 Speaker 05 Yeah, it really is.
8:16 Speaker 04 Let me keep playing here.
8:17 Speaker 06 Now, here's my Christmas present to you. To save you potentially problems down the road, unplug it. Just unplug it. I would give it to the garbage man for Christmas, broken up in pieces, because you don't want to be committing a misdemeanor.
8:34 Speaker 07 Wait, is this what he meant about Christmas cheer for people committing crimes?
8:37 Speaker 05 This is like Oprah.
8:39 Speaker 04 Yes, this is his definition of Christmas cheer.
8:41 Speaker 05 You get a broken firestick and you get a broken firestick and you get a broken firestick. Nothing about this is Christmas cheer.
8:49 Speaker 06 But sale of these firesticks.
8:54 Speaker 06 Or felonies. Oh.
8:55 Speaker 08 Oh, no. What's a felony?
8:56 Speaker 04 He's claiming that if you sell it, that's a felony.
8:58 Speaker 08 Oh.
8:59 Speaker 06 Every time you sell a fire stick that's jailbroke, it's a felony.
9:07 Speaker 06 And the key to it is you jailbreak it for personal gain and then you turn around and resell it.
9:13 Speaker 08 What?
9:13 Speaker 04 So the sheriff, he's, he's making a lot of definitive statements here, right? He's claiming that
9:18 Speaker 08 Yeah.
9:19 Speaker 04 the devices are, quote, illegal products. He's claiming that using them is a misdemeanor. He's claiming that selling them is a felony. And he has not yet clarified what he means by a jailbroke fire stick. Or what the advertised claims of, quote, free TV actually mean in practice. Which seems important to me.
9:41 Speaker 06 So let's meet some of the folks. The entrepreneurs. That were committing a felony every time they sold one of these fire sticks.
9:51 Speaker 08 Have these people been convicted?
9:52 Speaker 04 No, at this point, they had not. I'm going to beep out
9:55 Speaker 08 Mm hmm.
9:56 Speaker 04 these people's names.
9:57 Speaker 08 Okay.
9:57 Speaker 04 Because they have not been
10:00 Speaker 08 They haven't been convicted.
10:00 Speaker 04 They have not been convicted of a crime.
10:02 Speaker 06 So how about [BLEEP]? She's 59. And we, in conversation, said, well, how did you get into this? She said, well, originally I bought a jailbroke fire stick. And I had some problems with it, so I took it back. And they wanted too much to repair it. So I went online to figure out how to break my own fire stick.
10:25 Speaker 08 That's amazing.
10:26 Speaker 06 And that's how I got into the business. And from there, she started selling them to the public. So even if you buy a legal fire stick. And go online and figure out how to jailbreak it. The first time you download content, you're committing a crime. Is that true? Think about that.
10:44 Speaker 08 It does, that depends on the content.
10:47 Speaker 06 Or [BLEEP] is probably one of the more technologically savvy of the group.
10:54 Speaker 04 This woman is 71 years old.
10:57 Speaker 08 Oh, I'm impressed.
10:59 Speaker 06 But being the all purpose service kind of lady she is. If you take her your legal fire stick. She'll break it for $50.
11:11 Speaker 06 But she would also coach and counsel you. She recommends that you get a VPN so that the internet provider can't see just how much traffic you have and how much theft you're conducting.
11:24 Speaker 08 Oh my gosh, I love this lady.
11:26 Speaker 04 Again, not to overly nerdsplay and everything to the sheriff here, but that is another objectively incorrect detail. A VPN does not prevent your internet service provider from seeing, quote, "how much traffic you have." That statement doesn't even make sense, even if he was trying to say how much traffic you're doing on the internet. That's also not true. If you're using a VPN, they can still tell the amount of traffic you're doing. Yeah.
11:52 Speaker 08 But they can't see what content and sites.
11:55 Speaker 04 It just further obscures it. Anyway, back to Sheriff Judd.
11:59 Speaker 06 She has a storefront. There are [BLEEP] candles and more.
12:03 Speaker 08 Ah, and more.
12:05 Speaker 06 And more is the fire sticks. I would say that her candle business and more kind of went up in smoke on Saturday.
12:14 Speaker 04 Oh my god.
12:15 Speaker 08 Dude.
12:16 Speaker 06 And then there's [BLEEP]. He's 34. He also jailbreaks his own fire sticks and he shows you how to load and do this over the internet. He's the only one with a criminal history. Then there's [BLEEP].
12:37 Speaker 04 This last person is 88 years old. Oh my god. This is an 88-year-old man.
12:42 Speaker 08 That's amazing.
12:43 Speaker 04 Right. This 88-year-old, like the others, was arrested, taken to jail, and now the sheriff, Sheriff Grady Judd, in this press conference, is showing their mug shots. He's mocking them. He's making fun of their signs. And he's saying that they all committed a felony offense.
13:05 Speaker 06 So we charged him, as we did the others, with one count of unauthorized reception of communications, which is a felony of the third degree.
13:13 Speaker 08 One count of unauthorized communications receptions.
13:19 Speaker 04 Yes, so the law that they claim these individuals violated is a Florida law.
13:26 Speaker 08 Mm hmm.
13:27 Speaker 04 And this section is titled unauthorized reception of communication services, semicolon penalties. We'll dive into the exact text of it. But in general, here's what I want to find out. There's sort of this cloud of mystery surrounding this story because the local news in Florida, they basically just paraphrased the sheriff. They covered it one way. If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. And in this case, it's also a crime. And then, as you can imagine, Reddit and other parts of the internet, once they caught on to this story, they reacted in a completely different way. And hearing what that sheriff had to say, it's like nothing, nothing he said made sense. What I want to unpack is,
14:12 Speaker 04 is it illegal to use a quote unquote jailbroke fire stick? And also, what prompted these arrests? Like, what's the deal with Sheriff Grady Judd?
14:24 Speaker 08 Oh, man. I like that.
14:26 Speaker 07 Love to talk Floridian sheriffs.
14:28 Speaker 08 Right?
14:30 Speaker 06 I have a Christmas tip. Just don't violate the law this next year and you'll have a lot less complicated life. You see, we won't bother you at all. But the investigation's not over. It's just beginning. That's another Christmas present from me to you.
14:48 Speaker 08 This man doesn't understand Christmas presents.
14:51 Speaker 05 These are not good Christmas presents.
15:02 Speaker 07 After the break, Billy tries to figure out what's actually broken here.
15:17 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration blog, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.
15:42 Speaker 09 This episode is brought to you by Nordstrom. For 125 years, Nordstrom has been part of your story. The stylist who found the perfect outfit for your big interview. The first pair of walking shoes for your one-year-old. The tomato soup you shared with your sister at the cafe. These are the moments that make Nordstrom Nordstrom. Big or small, we're here for all of it. Celebrating 125 years with new moments still ad. Discover it all in Nordstrom stores and at nordstrom.com.
16:13 Speaker 04 Hello. Hey.
16:14 Speaker 08 Hey, Billy.
16:15 Speaker 04 Welcome back.
16:16 Speaker 08 Thanks.
16:17 Speaker 04 We have a lot to get through, so I'm just gonna jump right in.
16:21 Speaker 08 Amazing.
16:23 Speaker 04 So the first thing I want to do is contextualize everything that we're navigating here. So I called the first person that I could think of. Hi, Neelai.
16:35 Speaker 02 Hey, Billy.
16:35 Speaker 08 Oh, my gosh.
16:36 Speaker 02 I'm very excited to be on the show. You need to know a lot about something very obscure to really make an impact on the show. And I'm happy that I finally, finally have that corner of my brain of value to you.
16:48 Speaker 08 It's the perfect crossover.
16:50 Speaker 04 Neelai Patel is editor in chief of The Verge, where we all used to work. He's also hosted the podcast Decoder. And one thing that I learned from Neelai is to overly disclose everything when reporting. So I feel like I should disclose that we all worked under Neelai in some capacity at some point. But Neelai has a deep and sort of personal understanding of how copyright law works on the internet. And that's why I wanted to talk to him.
17:19 Speaker 02 I went to college to be a doctor, like every good Indian kid does. And about midway through college, I was deeply radicalized by Napster.
17:31 Speaker 10 Most of us head out to a music store to buy CDs, but not Mike Chesworth.
17:35 Speaker 02 I've been using Napster for about a year.
17:37 Speaker 10 He goes to Napster.com to get all the music he wants, and he doesn't pay for it.
17:42 Speaker 02 My college campus actually blocked access to Napster. And this made me very much want to become a lawyer, and not only a lawyer, but specifically a copyright lawyer.
17:50 Speaker 04 And so Neelai does what I think is a very funny form of rebellion. He says, "I'm not going to be a doctor, I'm gonna be a lawyer."
17:59 Speaker 02 So I ran off to law school, became a lawyer. I had, I would say, like a two-year, brief, unremarkable career as a copyright attorney. I worked for a tiny firm in Chicago, and a big part of the practice that the woman who started the firm set up was defending kids who had been sued by the record industry for using Kazaa.
18:17 Speaker 11 Many Americans use programs like Kazaa to download music, and the recording industry claims this costs them millions in lost revenue.
18:27 Speaker 03 I can't believe this happened.
18:28 Speaker 04 You can't believe that Neelai was like this punk rock Kazaa attorney?
18:33 Speaker 03 No, that I can believe. I can't believe record companies sued kids for using Kazaa.
18:38 Speaker 04 Oh, okay. So anyway, that is who Neelai would represent. He would go to the federal courthouse in Chicago. Their client would be there, there would be a lawyer from the record industry.
18:50 Speaker 02 And we would just lose. Like, all those cases settled, because at the end of the day, they had done it, and they had used Kazaa, and copyright infringement is legal. And there wasn't really a way around it unless one of these kids had a million dollars in 10 years to fight some novel theory of the law to the Supreme Court. So they were all gonna lose.
19:10 Speaker 04 So Neelai gets a bit disillusioned with the day-to-day realities of being a lawyer.
19:15 Speaker 02 Fast forward to now in The Editor-in-Chief of The Verge, where I feel like all we talk about, the bottom of every story is a copyright law story. Because everything that happens on the internet requires making a copy of something.
19:30 Speaker 04 So I sent Neelai the video of Sheriff Grady Judd to get his take. Had you seen this, by the way?
19:37 Speaker 02 I had not, and I watched this video. And I, I can't, I laughed so hard. These, these dudes are, the, the police there are in so far over their head. This is like the silliest podunk police force doesn't understand what they're talking about situation I, I've ever seen in regards to the internet.
19:59 Speaker 07 And he's seen a lot.
20:00 Speaker 02 Nice.
20:01 Speaker 04 It's important to point out here that all of the cases of internet piracy that Neelai dealt with back when he was a lawyer, none of those people were being arrested or taken to jail by the cops. But that doesn't mean that criminal copyright infringement doesn't exist.
20:18 Speaker 02 Criminal copyright infringement is a real thing that happens. And if you are running a factory to pirate DVDs, it is possible that you will get arrested for that and you'll be subject to criminal copyright violation. The guy on the street selling the bootleg DVDs rarely gets prosecuted. And there's a really important reason for that, that is squarely at the heart of this situation, which is copyright law is a federal law.
20:49 Speaker 02 The federal copyright law supersedes, overcomes, replaces any state level copyright law. So it is wholly a federal offense. So criminal copyright infringement is investigated by the FBI and prosecuted by the Department of Justice, not by the local cops and not prosecuted by the state level or local level authorities.
21:14 Speaker 04 Huh. So this is all to just kind of set the scene. Regardless, local authorities don't enforce copyright law, as Neelai is saying, and they certainly can't arrest you for it or take you to jail for it.
21:28 Speaker 07 Wait, so why did the county sheriff arrest these people in Florida then?
21:32 Speaker 04 What they're doing here in Polk County is referencing a state law. It's Florida statute 812.15.
21:42 Speaker 07 Why is this a Florida law if federal law in copyright matters always supersedes state law?
21:51 Speaker 08 Yeah.
21:52 Speaker 07 Like, why would you write the law in Florida at all if you know that it's going to be superseded by? Or is it if the federal one goes away?
21:58 Speaker 04 It's because it's not copyright law.
22:00 Speaker 07 Oh. Oh, right, because you said this is about unauthorized reception of communications.
22:08 Speaker 04 Which is an important point.
22:10 Speaker 07 So if you're ripping off the cable company, basically.
22:13 Speaker 08 This is just a law to protect cable companies.
22:16 Speaker 04 Yeah.
22:19 Speaker 02 You will note that they are not alleging copyright infringement anywhere. This statute in Florida was written so that if you hijack like the cable system, the local police can come and get you because that's a very local crime. There's no copyright law in here.
22:40 Speaker 04 We can actually tell pretty precisely what the devices in question do because the police department posted the undercover footage from the flea market.
22:50 Speaker 12 Do you have one hooked up that we can see the movies? No, okay, let's show you just sex.
22:54 Speaker 04 And in it, the individuals arrested demonstrate the features.
22:58 Speaker 13 But this one here, like that app, is MobDro. That's for live TV. Okay.
23:03 Speaker 04 So I went through the footage and here is every app they show, as far as I can tell. MobDro, Sofa TV, Cinema HD V2, FreeFlix TV, Watched, Strix, and the Media Center app, Cody with the plugins Numbers and Exodus Redux.
23:23 Speaker 07 These definitely sound like the types of things you would download to like jailbreak your phone in 2010.
23:28 Speaker 04 Or like bands that would perform at a NASCAR race.
23:32 Speaker 07 Sure.
23:32 Speaker 04 Strix, MobDro, Exodus Redux.
23:37 Speaker 04 All of these apps essentially do the same thing. They aggregate links to stream unauthorized copies of movies and TV shows, or in some cases, like with the MobDro app, live TV channels. They let you watch live TV channels. So essentially, all of these apps, what they do is they just make low-level piracy a little more user-friendly.
23:59 Speaker 02 Yeah.
23:59 Speaker 04 And that seems to be a completely different offense than what is outlined in the law cited in the official press release.
24:07 Speaker 02 The law that they're charging these people under, the sheriff, the local sheriff in Florida is charging these people under, is a law about a cable service or another communications service provider. Well, who is that cable operator? Who is that communications service provider?
24:25 Speaker 04 So to answer that question, we have to dive a little deeper into the law, and we have to dive a little deeper into the police records. So Neelai emphasized to me that he is not a practicing attorney and that he's not super familiar with Florida law. I couldn't get any of the lawyers representing the accused individuals in this case to talk to me. The cases are ongoing. So I talked to a lawyer in Florida who normally defends users accused of sharing copyrighted material on BitTorrent.
24:53 Speaker 14 Nice. My name is Cynthia Conlin, and I am an attorney in Orlando, Florida.
25:01 Speaker 04 Now, again, Cynthia is only dealing with civil cases in her work, but here's what interested me. In addition to the BitTorrent stuff, she also represents clients who receive Dish Network channels without proper authorization, which is something like, I think, it sounds a lot closer to what is described in the Florida law than what we talked about happening on these fire sticks.
25:29 Speaker 14 Typically, an end user will purchase a box or some sort of hardware, and they will buy what's called an IKS passcode.
25:43 Speaker 14 To be able to access a service that is intercepting Dish Network Satellite Service.
25:52 Speaker 04 And Cynthia even said that a lot of this activity, like with the fire sticks, is initiated by sales at flea markets.
26:01 Speaker 03 Hmm.
26:02 Speaker 04 But despite the similarities here, Cynthia had never personally encountered this particular law in Florida with any of her cases before.
26:13 Speaker 03 Oh, I assumed that's what she was talking about this whole time.
26:16 Speaker 04 No. And beyond that, she had never heard of anyone being arrested for any kind of offense like this whatsoever.
26:24 Speaker 14 I've never seen it before, not before this incident.
26:29 Speaker 04 So like any good lawyer, Cynthia starts going through the text of the law.
26:34 Speaker 14 When I printed out the statute, it takes up five pages. It's kind of long.
26:40 Speaker 04 And she ends up sending me all of these detailed notes. She notices that the law had been tweaked over time, the language has changed. She sends me a PDF where I can see what text has been added and what text has been removed. And we could get into all of those specifics, but Cynthia noticed something else that is super important that the police didn't include in their public analysis of the statute that sort of reshapes how we need to look at the entire thing.
27:11 Speaker 14 I dug a little bit deeper into the statute. So subsection 12, which is the last section, second to last section, deals with multi-purpose devices, which would be a fire stick. And it says specifically, "A person that manufactures, produces, designs, sells, distributes, licenses, or develops a multi-purpose device shall not be in violation of this section unless that person acts knowingly and with an intent to defraud a communication service provider." But then it adds also, "The multi-purpose device..."
27:54 Speaker 14 Either A is manufactured, developed, assembled, produced, designed, distributed, sold, or licensed for the primary purpose of committing a violation. Or it would have only a limited commercially significant purpose or use other than the commission of violation of this section. Or if it is marketed by that person, um, with that person's knowledge for the purpose of committing any violation of this section.
28:23 Speaker 08 Hmm.
28:24 Speaker 04 What this basically leaves us with are the questions of, one, are these devices successfully defrauding a cable operator or communication service? Are they actually doing that? And, not or, and, are they being sold explicitly for that purpose? Are the sellers advertising them as being able to defraud a cable operator? And do they understand that that's what they're doing?
28:51 Speaker 03 I think it goes back to Neelai's question, who's the operator?
28:56 Speaker 04 Exactly.
28:58 Speaker 14 It looks like from reviewing the police reports in the files that they're being accused of intercepting the Spectrum Charter Communications Cable Service.
29:12 Speaker 04 Oh.
29:13 Speaker 14 That's what the police reports refer to.
29:16 Speaker 04 So I have copies of the police affidavits. They're all basically the same, but right now I'm looking at the one for the 88-year-old man. I should mention, by the way, that I reached out to request an audio interview from Sheriff Grady Judd, and they told me because the cases are ongoing that I just have to go off of what is already publicly available. So that's what we're gonna do. It's worth noting that the written part of this document is riddled with errors. They spell the word statute incorrectly. Nice. They wrote it as statue. Anyway.
29:51 Speaker 04 In the affidavit, it says, quote, "Each individual fire stick was taken to a secure location within the Polk County Sheriff's Office, and was analyzed, confirming access to these cable channels, such as Fox News, without a monthly or annual subscription fee. The cable channels being accessed on the fire stick are cable channels that are not over-the-air cable channels."
30:18 Speaker 07 Well, those aren't a thing.
30:19 Speaker 04 Right, exactly. That's not even a thing. Then it says, "Contact was made with Bruce Asbury, who is a Director of Enterprise Communications with Spectrum Charter Communications. Asbury provided a sworn recorded statement, detailing how the jailbroken fire sticks are unlawful. Asbury advised cable channels being received on devices are typically negotiated with a telecommunications conglomerate. Any reception of these channels, without negotiation, is considered," and I believe they meant to say "considered," "unlawful in reference to the below-listed state statue." Spelled S-T-A-T-U-E. Yeah, I don't know what a Florida state statue would be.
31:03 Speaker 04 Like Dan Marino? I don't know. And then they list the statute that we talked about. But there are a few things that are interesting about this. First, I looked up the guy from Spectrum, Bruce Asbury, because I wanted to interview him. And I wasn't able to reach him for comment. But check out his LinkedIn page. Scroll down and let me know if you notice anything that stands out.
31:29 Speaker 05 Deputy Sheriff, Polk County Sheriff's Office.
31:32 Speaker 07 No way.
31:32 Speaker 05 Florida. What? May 1996 to May 2001.
31:37 Speaker 04 Yeah, so...
31:38 Speaker 05 Five years and one month.
31:40 Speaker 04 Alumnus of the Polk County Sheriff's Office.
31:43 Speaker 05 Uh huh.
31:44 Speaker 04 And there appears to be no proof that channels available in MobDro, which was the app capable of playing live TV streams, even originate from Spectrum or Charter Communications.
31:58 Speaker 08 Mm-hmm.
31:59 Speaker 04 On MobDro's official website, it says that MobDro is, quote, "A tool that constantly looks for free video streams available on the web and makes them accessible." So a seller can't even reasonably guarantee that any specific channel from any specific source will be available on MobDro at any given time. But even if you could twist these circumstances into claiming that these individuals defrauded Spectrum, which is sort of attempted in the police affidavit, it would actually also be reasonable to conclude that these sellers didn't see themselves as deliberately defrauding anything.
32:37 Speaker 04 So if you'll remember, Sheriff Grady Judd, basically, he basically admits that his office is projecting the specific element of intent onto the people that they arrested.
32:50 Speaker 06 They all admitted that this is how you avoid paying communication services fees. They weren't that technical. They said, "This is how you get free TV."
33:03 Speaker 04 So it's possible that these accused individuals simply just saw this as a way to get free TV. They probably realized, like, yeah, this is in some kind of gray area, but they didn't see themselves as defrauding Spectrum. And the 88-year-old man at his booth, he also appears to be selling TV antennas, which, you know, of course, are a free alternative to cable TV.
33:26 Speaker 07 Love them.
33:28 Speaker 04 So, you know, are they knowingly, willingly defrauding Spectrum?
33:35 Speaker 04 It seems like perhaps they are not.
33:38 Speaker 14 You have to have intent to defraud. That's one reason that it would probably be more difficult for them to be found liable in a criminal arena.
33:49 Speaker 04 And keep in mind, the intent to defraud is not enough on its own to qualify as a violation. The device has to actually be capable of defrauding Charter Spectrum.
34:02 Speaker 02 When you stream something, you're making a copy of it on your local device. And there's actually an enormous amount of case law about those, what they're called ephemeral copies. And eventually, the copyright law was amended to say ephemeral copies are legit. But when you stream something, you make a copy onto your computer, your computing device. You copy it into the RAM of whatever, your fire stick. Okay, well, under a pretty narrow reading of the law, you hit the button, you play it, there it is, there's copyright infringement. You were not allowed to make that copy. And now you're fully in the realm of federal law enforcement. And so they're, all the moralizing, all of the vocabulary about jailbreak, all that
34:44 Speaker 02 is to kind of hide the fact that the state level law that they're relying on here doesn't really apply to anyone's conduct.
34:53 Speaker 03 We've phrased the central question of this podcast as, was this activity technically illegal? But my question would be, who cares?
35:03 Speaker 04 Right. Well, right.
35:04 Speaker 03 This is a five-page statute that does one thing, which is protect cable providers' business.
35:11 Speaker 04 Right.
35:12 Speaker 03 So my interpretation of this is cable providers did a really good job of getting local police departments to spend public resources to protect their profits and bust senior citizens for making little amounts of dollars at the flea market. And it just seems like a giant waste of time, and I think it's bullshit. Yeah.
35:32 Speaker 04 Yeah.
35:32 Speaker 03 They were able to turn to this cookie cutter, protect the cable providers' law, and then they were able to write this sloppy report and pat themselves on the back. And meanwhile...
35:45 Speaker 03 Like, what have they done to benefit the community that they're supposed to serve?
35:50 Speaker 07 Well, and why did it happen in the first place? It sounds like they were looking for, what, a press moment?
35:55 Speaker 03 The sheriff is definitely looking for a press moment. This is a 100% Twitter sheriff here that we're working with.
36:02 Speaker 07 Was that the motivation behind the whole thing?
36:04 Speaker 03 I think their motivation is to do easy stuff that they can do press conferences about. And whether it's, you know, people selling what seems to be an illegal device that you can use a scary word like jailbreak to describe. Or if it's, I just checked, they're busting people for violating provisions of the CARES Act for like, collecting too much welfare, basically. Booked a bunch of people who were supposedly fraudulently getting food stamps. Like, that's the business they're in. They're like, who's, who's like, absolutely clinging to the edge of the cliff and we can stomp on their fingers so that they fall off?
36:41 Speaker 02 This is where like, you run into just the real equity and justice problems of our criminal justice system. Who are we talking about here? We're talking to a bunch of older people, some of whom appear to be immigrants. There's a reason they're picking on these folks. Like, there are marks. They're probably not making a lot of money. Like, if you look at the signs he's showing off in the videos, they're not like, beautifully designed. It's a bunch of Sharpies on cardboard, right?
37:04 Speaker 04 Neil, I obviously is not off base with these remarks here. The Polk County Sheriff's Office has a history of being selective and opportunistic with their targets. In 2017, during Hurricane Irma, Sheriff Grady Judd tweeted that his department would be patrolling the county hurricane shelters, looking for people with outstanding warrants. And he would bring them to jail.
37:34 Speaker 14 I'm trying to choose my words wisely.
37:40 Speaker 14 Polk County has, has had certain reputations in their law enforcement of marginalized groups.
37:47 Speaker 02 It comes right back to why our criminal justice system does not often lead to equitable outcomes. And here's one where it's like, why do you spend all this time doing stings on fire sticks? Like, aren't there other crimes in Florida?
38:01 Speaker 04 No, I don't think so. Not in Florida.
38:06 Speaker 04 As I said earlier, the Polk County Sheriff's Office denied my request for an interview. So I couldn't ask Sheriff Grady Judd if there are other crimes in Florida. But of course, there are. And those crimes also allegedly include ones coming from inside his own department.
38:26 Speaker 15 And breaking news now, a Polk County deputy in big trouble tonight.
38:30 Speaker 16 Sheriff Grady Judd just wrapped up a press conference explaining that he had to arrest one of his own for threats related to the violence in Washington DC. Of course he did.
38:40 Speaker 04 Sheriff Grady Judd strongly denounced this, of course. But to critics of the sheriff, it's not exactly surprising to hear that one of his deputies advocated for swift, violent action against a perceived threat. The sheriff regularly defends proactive use of deadly force, not only among his deputies, but among the citizens of Polk County as well.
39:06 Speaker 06 If you're not afraid of a gun, get one. The message from Polk County's top cop, crystal clear. Become proficient. Get a concealed firearms license and carry it. And if you need to shoot somebody, shoot them a lot.
39:20 Speaker 03 What is he talking about? What prompted these comments?
39:24 Speaker 04 This was just in general. It was in response to general threats, active shooters and stuff, they said. But this next clip is what he said during the Black Lives Matter protests in the summer of 2020.
39:35 Speaker 06 But we have received information in social media that some of the criminals were going to take their criminal conduct into the neighborhoods. I would tell them, if you value your life, you probably shouldn't do that in Polk County. Because the people of Polk County like guns. They have guns. I encourage them to own guns. And they're going to be in their homes tonight with their guns loaded. And if you try to break into their homes to steal, to set fires, I'm highly recommending they blow you back out of the house with their guns.
40:22 Speaker 04 Sheriff Grady Judd seems to think that the world is pretty black and white. That the law is easy to understand.
40:30 Speaker 06 I have a Christmas tip. Just don't violate the law this next year and you'll have a lot less complicated life. You see, we won't bother you at all.
40:41 Speaker 04 He thinks that there's good people and bad people.
40:44 Speaker 06 I truly believe that the only thing that stops a bad man with a gun is a good man with a gun.
40:50 Speaker 04 And he believes that, you know, he's the good guy in charge of the good guy squad.
40:55 Speaker 06 Let me make one thing abundantly clear. You can't police a society if you don't first police yourself.
41:02 Speaker 04 And he, you know, he believes that his good guy squad should have a zero tolerance policy for crime, whether it's something that's within their jurisdiction or not.
41:14 Speaker 06 Ladies and gentlemen, the bottom line is whether it's stealing from a store, stealing from your neighbor, or stealing from a internet provider, when you are stealing intellectual property, you are violating the law.
41:33 Speaker 04 And that got me to wondering, he has such a hard stance on this stuff. Has Sheriff Grady Judd ever done anything that is a clear violation of intellectual property law? So I went through his YouTube page with Neelai. Are you seeing this now?
41:51 Speaker 06 Yeah.
41:52 Speaker 04 Let's see, where is it? Okay. So he did around, towards the beginning of the pandemic, started reading children's books on YouTube?
42:00 Speaker 06 Yeah. Hello, I'm Sheriff Grady Judd.
42:03 Speaker 04 You can just watch a little of this.
42:04 Speaker 06 Decided to be with you today to read one of my favorite books. Oh, The Places You'll Go. I enjoy it. Okay, I'm gonna point out the exact second.
42:14 Speaker 02 He commits copyright infringement. You ready?
42:17 Speaker 04 Okay, I'm ready.
42:18 Speaker 02 Congratulations. There it is. He committed copyright infringement. The end. Okay, super obvious. Yeah, you are not allowed to publicly perform copyrighted works without a license. There's no way that he went to the publisher of this book, or the Seuss estate, and got a license to publicly perform this work.
42:38 Speaker 04 And he's, he goes through the whole book and has had, has the scans of the pages up on the screen and stuff. Like, it's very...
42:46 Speaker 02 Incredible.
42:48 Speaker 03 That's very funny. Wait, this is on his YouTube channel?
42:51 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean, he's a prolific poster.
42:55 Speaker 04 So, I emailed the Polk County Sheriff's Office about this.
42:58 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm.
42:59 Speaker 04 I said, "Hi, quick question. Did the Polk County Sheriff's Office receive a license to perform 'Oh, The Places You'll Go' on YouTube?"
43:05 Speaker 03 Oh my, you are such a brat.
43:09 Speaker 04 So I asked them if they received a license to perform it. And Scott Wilder, their Director of Communications, responded...
43:18 Speaker 03 I can't believe they responded to you.
43:20 Speaker 04 He said, "Billy, no, we did not receive a license to read the book."
43:29 Speaker 04 That was the whole email.
43:30 Speaker 03 Entire email. No, thank you.
43:31 Speaker 04 So then I responded, "Was this an oversight, or does the Polk County Sheriff's Office believe it has a justifiable exemption from the relevant federal copyright law that prohibits this behavior?"
43:41 Speaker 03 Did they respond?
43:43 Speaker 04 Yes.
43:45 Speaker 04 So, he's claiming that what they're doing qualifies as fair use, which is a limitation on exclusive rights. But when I had talked to Neelai about this previously, he said there are plenty of fair use arguments for performing a reading of a book that's protected under copyright, but that this, a sheriff doing it on YouTube in full, with full scans on the screen, isn't one that would hold up particularly well against a motivated copyright holder.
44:11 Speaker 02 If you're a teacher in a library, there's some case law that says, "Okay, this is fine." You're the local sheriff just reading a book on YouTube? Yeah, you're definitely performing the work to the public without a license. Like, this is straight up, direct copyright infringement. And the reason that Dr. Seuss is the worst target is that...
44:30 Speaker 02 Dr. Seuss's publishers are notoriously litigious. In December, they just won a major lawsuit about a book called "Oh, The Places You'll Boldly Go," which is a mashup of "Oh, The Places You'll Go" and Star Trek.
44:48 Speaker 04 Did they try to claim that it was parody or something like that?
44:51 Speaker 02 They said it was fair use. I can send you this link, it's a New York Times article. The creators, this is the judge, Margaret McCoon. "The creators thought their Star Trek primer would be pretty well protected by parody, but acknowledged that, quote, 'people in black robes may disagree,' the judge wrote in the opinion. Indeed, we do." They just got smacked. So, yeah, I mean, you are not allowed to just pick up a copyrighted book and read it on YouTube without a license, like, absolutely not. And the Seuss estate is not shy. This is hilarious to me.
45:26 Speaker 04 My point here is that issues of intellectual property are complicated, that things are not so black and white. Do I personally care that Sheriff Grady Judd read this book on YouTube? No, I do not, of course not. I think it's fine. In fact, I had someone read "Oh, The Places You'll Go" at my wedding. So technically, we should both live in constant fear of Seuss Enterprises.
46:00 Speaker 05 Thanks for listening. Underunderstood is Regina Delay, Billy Disney, John Laga Marcino, and me, Adrianne Jeffries.
46:07 Speaker 07 A big thank you to Neil I for helping us get to the bottom of this story and also letting us present it to you here in the Decoder feed.
46:17 Speaker 05 If you like the show, you can subscribe to us wherever you are currently listening to it. Just search "Underunderstood," it's one word, and the art is an upside-down smiley face.
46:27 Speaker 07 You can also find us at our website, underunderstood.com. We have all the episodes there, plus additional show notes, more information, the works. It's a website, you know what that is.
46:40 Speaker 05 Stay safe and don't break the law. Merry Christmas.
46:49 Speaker 04 Joke's on Neelai because we actually own the copyright to this episode and we are going to immediately file a DMCA takedown request.
46:59 Speaker 07 Don't tell them we said that.
47:07 Speaker 17 Everyone's got a hard question about AI: your job, your kids, where it's going. Anthropic was built to surface those questions and share what it finds along the way because there's hope in hard questions. Ask yours at claud.ai/spotify and keep thinking. That's claud.ai/spotify.
47:31 Speaker 18 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing in a wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash apple watch series 12.
Previous Meet Austin Russell, the 25-year-old billionaire building the future of self-driving cars Next How Twitter is building its future, with Kayvon Beykpour Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated