Pod Insights Decoder The mystery of Biden’s deadlocked FCC About this episode The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is currently short a commissioner, and the Biden Administration and Senate Democrats just can't seem to get that seat filled despite having nominated an amazingly qualified person. Her name is Gigi Sohn. The inability to get Gigi confirmed at the FCC has left the commission deadlocked with two Democrats and two Republicans. That means the commission in charge of regulating all telecom in the United States, including how you get your internet service, is unable to get much done. The Biden administration can't accomplish some of its biggest policy priorities like rural broadband and restoring net neutrality. President Biden first nominated Gigi Sohn to the FCC over a year ago, but the full Senate vote to confirm her just hasn't happened. We’ve been digging into the story for a few months now, trying to figure out what's going on here, and we found a simple but really frustrating answer…
Links:
Gigi Sohn Author Profile - The Verge
Comcast trying to “torpedo” Biden FCC pick Gigi Sohn, advocacy group says
The Slime Machine Targeting Dozens of Biden Nominees
Attempted acquisition of Tribune Media by Sinclair Broadcast Group
The Vergecast: Net neutrality was repealed a year ago. Gigi Sohn explains what’s happened since
Confirmation Hearing for FCC and Commerce Department Nominees
Biden signs $280 billion CHIPS and Science Act
Biden Signs Bill to Help Veterans Exposed to Toxic Burn Pits
With the Inflation Reduction Act, the US brings climate goals within reach
Federal Communications Commission v. Pacifica Foundation
Federal Communications Commission v. Pacifica Foundation
A Media Censor for the FCC?
Hyperpartisan Gigi Sohn Doesn’t Belong at the FCC
Gigi Sohn and the Police
Gigi Sohn Facebook Tweet
Tech antitrust pioneer Lina Khan will officially lead the FTC
Confirmation Hearing For FCC Nominee
FCC Commissioner Jessica Rosenworcel on staying connected during a pandemic
Transcript:
https://www.theverge.com/e/23201559
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was written and reported by Jackie McDermott.
It was produced by Creighton DeSimone and Jackie McDermott and it was edited by Callie Wright. Additional mixing by Andrew Marino.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our Editorial Director is Brooke Minters and our Executive Director is Eleanor Donovan.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 7,177 words · 23 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 When it comes to your business, you want cards and tools you can trust. Amex Corporate helps put you in control. Set custom spend parameters to help fit your business needs and quickly issue unlimited corporate cash back cards. All backed by best-in-class fraud protection and the powerful backing of American Express. Get started at go.amex slash Amex Corporate. Terms apply.
0:28 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Michelob Ultra. Good times mean competitions between you and your friends, like seeing who can throw some pigskin the farthest or rush the field the fastest. Winner gets an ultra. Because it's not just a superior-like beer, it's also giving fans superior access to their favorite sporting events. Superior is worth playing for. Visit michelobultra.com/superioraccess to enter. Enjoy responsibly. Copyright 2026 Anheuser-Busch InBev Michelob Ultra Beer, St. Louis, Missouri.
0:57 Speaker 02 Before we start, here's a list of people and organizations we reached out to about this episode of Decoder who refused to talk to us. Fox News. Comcast. The Fraternal Order of Police. Former FCC Chair Ajit Pai. Democratic Senators Joe Manchin and Kirsten Sinema. Republican Senator Roy Blunt. The Biden Administration. Verizon. The former Speaker of the Arizona House Republican Kirk Adams. Former Democratic US Senator Heidi Heitkamp. FCC Chair Jessica Rosenworson. And FCC nominee Gigi Sohn. It's a wild one. Here we go.
1:33 Speaker 02 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, we're just talking about a problem. And that problem is the Federal Communications Commission, or the FCC. It's currently short a commissioner. And the Biden Administration and Senate Democrats just can't seem to get that seat filled, despite having nominated an amazingly qualified person. Her name is Gigi Sohn. The inability to get Gigi confirmed at the FCC has left the commission deadlocked, with two Democrats and two Republicans.
2:07 Speaker 02 That means the commission in charge of regulating all telecom in the United States, including how you get your internet service, is unable to get much done. And the Biden administration can't accomplish some of its biggest policy priorities, like rural broadband and restoring net neutrality. President Biden first nominated Gigi Sohn to the FCC over a year ago, but the full Senate vote to confirm her just hasn't happened. We've been digging into the story for a few months now, trying to figure out what's going on here. And we found a simple, really frustrating answer.
2:39 Speaker 03 It's corruption. I mean, we can call it a lot of things, but what we're witnessing is just ordinary corruption.
2:45 Speaker 02 That was Carl Bodie. Carl's a veteran telecom reporter. I've known him forever, and he's one of many people we talked to for this story. We're doing something a little different with this episode of Decoder. You're going to hear from a bunch of in-the-know people about what happened to Gigi Sohn's FCC nomination and why it matters. This story has some strange crisscross alliances, behemoth bad actors, shady politicking, and even some good old fashioned family drama. But most of all, it reveals a lot about the huge problems plaguing politics and policy in the United States today.
3:15 Speaker 03 I've covered the telecom sector for, I think, 22 years, and I've never seen anything quite as shady as this.
3:20 Speaker 02 Okay. The fight over Gigi Sohn's nomination to the FCC and why it matters. Here we go.
3:40 Speaker 02 This story ends up revealing corruption, but it starts with good old fashioned confusion.
3:45 Speaker 03 It makes no sense that this has been so contracted of a nomination process.
3:51 Speaker 02 That's Carl Bodie again. He's talking about Gigi Sohn.
3:53 Speaker 03 The thing that's funny to me is that she's, if you talk to anybody in telecom policy, on both sides of the aisle, she's extremely popular. You know, she's well qualified. We've seen people appointed to the FCC that have a tiny, tiny fraction of the experience.
4:07 Speaker 02 I agree with Carl, and that's why I started tracking this story. I've interviewed Gigi before, and she's even written for The Verge in the past, always about making internet service better and cheaper for regular people. So I've been baffled as to why someone like Gigi Sohn couldn't get confirmed to the FCC. Gigi was nominated to the FCC over a year ago, and throughout her career, she's been popular with just about everyone. She's known as an incredibly talented telecom regulator who's been willing to work across the aisle.
4:36 Speaker 04 Thank you Chair Cantwell, Member Wicker, members of the committee. I'm honored to be nominated by President Biden and to be considered by this committee for a seat on the Federal Communications Commission.
4:46 Speaker 02 Here's Gigi talking about her background at her first confirmation hearing in December 2021.
4:50 Speaker 04 The radio was always on in my family kitchen, where reports from the front lines of the Vietnam War, Watergate, and other critical events of the 60s and 70s resonated. It was there that I learned the power of communications networks to inform public discourse and promote democratic values. My love of local broadcasting, and especially radio, led me to Boston University, where I studied communications law and policy. After school and private practice, I started what has been an over 30-year career as a public interest lawyer, advocating for policies that ensure that modern communications networks are available to everyone, regardless of who they are or where they live.
5:31 Speaker 02 Gigi is a lawyer by training. She's currently a fellow at Georgetown Law and the Benton Institute for Broadband and Society. She co-founded and ran Public Knowledge, an organization that advocates for consumers in the telecom industry. I've talked with lots of folks from Public Knowledge over the years. You've heard some of them on this show. Given that the FCC is supposed to advocate for consumers, she seemed like a natural choice to be a commissioner. Plus, she's worked at the FCC before. She advised former Chairman Tom Wheeler during the Obama administration, when the FCC adopted its strongest-ever net neutrality rules.
6:01 Speaker 05 Here's the thing, when you talk to people about Gigi, if you were talking to them, Republicans, Democrats, a year ago, maybe a little over a year ago, everyone loved her.
6:11 Speaker 02 That was McKenna Kelly. She's a politics reporter on The Verge team. Telecom lawyer David Goodfriend said something similar.
6:17 Speaker 06 Thousands of people have actually reached out to their members of Congress to say, "We need you to confirm Gigi's own."
6:25 Speaker 02 And so did Craig Aaron. Craig is the co-CEO of Free Press, which advocates for competition in media and an open internet. Here's some of what he had to say about Gigi.
6:34 Speaker 07 She's, you know, been a consistent advocate for what's right, time and time again, and also been someone who's shown she can work with just about anybody, across the political spectrum, public interest, corporate interest, you name it, to get good things done. That's the kind of person you need at an agency like the FCC.
6:54 Speaker 02 One more person expressed his support for Gigi.
6:56 Speaker 07 Hey, Chris? Hi, can you hear me?
6:59 Speaker 02 Chris Ruddy, the CEO of Newsmax. Yep. Conservative cable network Newsmax is a vocal supporter of Gigi's nomination.
7:06 Speaker 08 I have strongly supported her nomination. I've known her for some time. I think she's a person of integrity. We probably disagree on a lot of issues. In fact, I know we disagree on any number of big issues. She would probably identify herself as liberal, I think, maybe progressive, and I would say I'm conservative. Am I going to agree with her on every issue? No, but I do think the fact that every major big company, all the big conglomerates don't like her suggests that maybe she's on a path that's at least going to look a little bit more out for the consumer and the little guy and gal, so to speak.
7:45 Speaker 02 You'll hear more from Chris Ruddy later. Okay, if this many people on both sides of the aisle love Gigi, why can't she get confirmed to the FCC? When we first started looking at this story earlier this year, it seemed like the Biden administration and its slim Democratic majority in the Senate just couldn't get this done, because at the time, it really couldn't get much of anything done. A lot of the Democrats' biggest policy priorities were stalling out. Then, around the summer, things changed.
8:13 Speaker 09 ...where there appears to be a breakthrough on President Biden's economic agenda. President Biden signed the $280 billion CHIPS and Science Act into law today.
8:22 Speaker 02 A flurry of big legislation passed.
8:24 Speaker 10 You've got the CHIPS Act the President signed today, the PACT Act, which he'll sign here tomorrow, and then by the end of the week, the Inflation Reduction Act.
8:32 Speaker 02 The usual holdouts like Senators Manchin and Sinema got on board, and the Dems were getting things done.
8:37 Speaker 11 The biggest US investment ever to help fight climate change passing the House, the Inflation Reduction Act, now headed to the President's desk.
8:45 Speaker 02 But there was still no movement on Gigi. It's around this time that we finally got to the bottom of why.
8:50 Speaker 06 Gigi's son is a manifestation of a much bigger tug of war going on right now between a very small number of extremely powerful corporate interests and the public interest.
9:06 Speaker 02 That's David Goodfriend, the telecom lawyer again. David previously worked at the FCC and he's also known Gigi for a long time.
9:13 Speaker 06 There are really two companies that have been literally financing a campaign to stop a Senate from confirming Gigi's own. And those two companies are Rupert Murdoch's 21st Century Fox and Comcast. Those two companies have paid for lobbyists to actively court swing votes in the Senate against Gigi's own.
9:41 Speaker 02 We promised crisscrossed alliances, and here they are. Rupert Murdoch, who controls Fox News and the Wall Street Journal parent company News Corp, is on the same side as the Roberts family and Comcast, which owns MSNBC. These are not your usual allies. It's bizarre that Comcast and the Fox News machine have teamed up to obstruct Gigi. And David Goodfriend told us that Comcast is lobbying against her in two politically critical states.
10:07 Speaker 06 Comcast hired a lobbyist in West Virginia who used to serve as chief of staff to Senator Manchin, back when Senator Manchin was governor. Senator Manchin has not said, one way or the other, which way he intends to vote. And that's because his former chief of staff was hired by Comcast to lobby him against Gigi.
10:31 Speaker 02 The same thing happened in Arizona, home of centrist Democratic Senator Kirsten Sinema.
10:36 Speaker 06 Back in January, Comcast hired a lobbyist in Arizona named Kirk Adams of Concilium Consulting. And Adams filed a lobbying disclosure, which, of course, is required to do. And it listed on his very own disclosure that he expects to work on FCC nominations. He then quickly recanted that and replaced it with telecommunications policy. Well, Comcast refused to comment, but I think the article in Ars Technica points out that this was pretty clearly an attempt by Comcast to swing. Senator Kristin Sinema's vote against Gigi Seun.
11:20 Speaker 06 So they've done it in Arizona, they've done it in West Virginia, and they're hoping that they can stave off enough Democratic votes in the Senate to stop her from being confirmed.
11:33 Speaker 02 By the way, this is where I should disclose that Comcast's NBCU division is a minority investor in the Verge's parent company Vox Media, which we disclose all the time. Now you know. Anyway, while Comcast was busy lobbying politicians, Fox News and The Wall Street Journal, which are both owned by Rupert Murdoch, were actively running negative stories about Gigi. Carl Bodie told us about this, too.
11:53 Speaker 03 All of the Fox property's been very active in pushing things, ideas, false ideas like Seun hates the police, she'd be bad for rural America, she wants to censor conservatives, she's bad for media diversity. I mean, none of these are supported by any facts that you can find if you've spent 30 minutes objectively researching her record.
12:13 Speaker 02 Here are just a couple Fox News segments about Gigi. You'll hear one Fox anchor talking to Ted Cruz and another Fox guest referencing the CCP, the Chinese Communist Party.
12:24 Speaker 12 So what do you think of this woman, Gigi? The name sounds a little funky and the glasses make me think twice, but she seems like she has a radical agenda. Now she's in charge of this place?
12:34 Speaker 13 Yeah, look, she hates Fox News. She has been vocal and partisan a long time. Looking up the word hack in the dictionary, Gigi Seun's photos should be right next to it. She wants to pull the broadcast license of this network. Gigi Seun will turn the FCC into the CCP. This is a bridge even Pyongyang wouldn't go over.
12:55 Speaker 02 Part of the argument on Fox News is that if Gigi is added to the FCC, she'll somehow censor Fox. But there's no evidence that she has any plans to do that at all. And even if she wanted to, it's not like she could, because that's not a power the FCC has. In fact, the more likely outcome is the opposite, that she would encourage Fox to say whatever they want.
13:15 Speaker 14 Gigi is pretty infamously in favor of free expression online?
13:22 Speaker 14 And the FCC has no control over that?
13:25 Speaker 02 That's Catherine Trendacosta from the Electronic Frontier Foundation.
13:28 Speaker 14 That's not really its job, especially when it comes to telecommunications. Like, the FCC doesn't tell phone companies that if you make a lewd phone call, they have to cut you off of phone service. That's the same bucket that the internet is under, right? So like, none of that is related to anything. The FCC is not involved in deciding what speech is or is not allowed on the internet, at least.
14:00 Speaker 02 There's a long and complicated tangent we could go down here, but basically, the Supreme Court has held that since the public owns the airwaves of the United States, the government can regulate broadcast speech to make sure it's in the public interest. That's where you get the FCC doing things like indecency complaints, the seven dirty words, and fines for Justin Timberlake and Janet Jackson at the Super Bowl. Traditional broadcast networks like ABC and CBS are using the public's airwaves, and the government can tell them what's allowed and what's not. But cable networks like Fox and internet companies like Google and Facebook don't broadcast on public airwaves. So there's really no legal basis for the FCC to regulate what happens there.
14:34 Speaker 14 TV and the radio, those are public airwaves that the FCC has granted people permission to use, and so they have certain rules about that, because anyone could listen and it's a public space. However, as we all know, like, if you're on cable, those rules don't apply because that's not a public airwave that has been licensed out. So it's basically that, right? It's the difference between something that is a publicly owned airwave and something that is privately owned.
15:06 Speaker 02 Despite that reality, Fox News is out there saying, "Watch out for a Democratic FCC commissioner, she'll censor your speech." And the smear campaign has extended across the rest of Rupert Murdoch's media properties. We did reach out to News Corp, the parent company of The Wall Street Journal, and in an email, News Corp chief communications officer Jim Kennedy denied a coordinated attack. He told us, "The Wall Street Journal and its editorial board speak for themselves. News Corp did not lobby for or against the nomination." Despite this denial of a coordinated attack against Gigi Sohn, The Wall Street Journal and Fox News are still attacking her.
15:41 Speaker 07 There's a lot of like, "Oh, my God," you know, pearl clutching over stray tweets.
15:46 Speaker 02 That's Craig Aaron again.
15:47 Speaker 07 What you see is a lot of quotes taken out of context, a lot of, you know, essentially front groups, like organizations that take a lot of money from big telecom and big cable interests, coming out with push polls.
16:02 Speaker 02 A push poll is a poll with very suggestive questions that basically trick people into agreeing with anything you want.
16:07 Speaker 07 Like, "Oh, I think the police are very concerned because Gigi once said something about encryption," or, you know, sort of questioning her stance on rural America and like parsing quotes out of context. And suddenly you see it in an ad, and then it's on the Wall Street Journal editorial page, and then it pops up over here. And then, all of a sudden, a lot of people who literally live to take company money to smear people on their behalf start raising their hand and trying out and saying, "Oh, I could also say mean things about this candidate." And you start to get this noise floor that, you know, then reaches policymakers and decision makers.
16:42 Speaker 02 Craig mentioned a Wall Street Journal op-ed, but there have been several journal opinion pieces, including one by the editorial board, with headlines like, "A Media Censor for the FCC? Hyperpartisan Gigi Sohn Doesn't Belong at the FCC." And, my favorite, "Gigi Sohn and the Police: Democratic Senators Are at Risk If They Vote for Biden's Progressive FCC Nominee." The police thing is something else, by the way. The Fraternal Order of Police published a press release about a poll it commissioned, claiming that, "When shown messaging about Gigi Sohn's past actions, such as 'Gigi Sohn has publicly supported defunding the police,' what they mean here is liking tweets, 61% of registered voters indicate they are less likely to support Ms. Sohn's nomination."
17:24 Speaker 02 We asked for more information about the specific questions on this poll, but the Fraternal Order of Police declined to comment. Another thing that's added fuel to the Gigi is anti-police fire is that she's also on the board of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, or EFF. You've already heard from the EFF's Katherine Trenacosta. The EFF opposes tech companies turning user information over to the police, and I don't know, the police don't like that very much. But what Senate Republicans have really grabbed onto are the tweets Craig mentioned. In 2020, Gigi tweeted, "For all of my concerns about Facebook, I believe that Fox News has had the most negative impact on our democracy. It's state-sponsored propaganda with few, if any, opposing viewpoints." Where's the hearing about that?
18:07 Speaker 02 Gigi was asked about that one at her first confirmation hearing by Missouri Senator Roy Blunt, a Republican.
18:12 Speaker 15 I've got a list of comments here about Fox News. Are you biased against them?
18:17 Speaker 04 So you're referring to my tweets that are now pretty famous. I understand they're concerning to some, and anyone who knows me knows I'm pretty direct, but they were made in my role as a public interest advocate. They were made in the context, and I think context is very important, context of hearings, hearings and media reports. Maybe the tone was a little sharper, maybe I should have dulled it a little bit, but again, it was part of my job essentially as a public interest advocate.
18:50 Speaker 15 And do you think they're the only news agency that is state-sponsored propaganda?
18:58 Speaker 04 Let me--
18:59 Speaker 15 That's your quote, by the way.
19:01 Speaker 04 Yeah, I know it's my quote, yeah. I just wanted to complete my thought. My opinions as a public interest advocate will have no bearing on how I behave as a policymaker if I'm confirmed.
19:16 Speaker 02 Another shady actor joining Comcast and the Murdochs on the anti-Gigi team was the American Accountability Foundation. The AAF is a whole other tangent we could go down. Jane Meyer did great reporting on them in The New Yorker, which we'll link to in the show notes. But basically, they're a totally mysterious dark money group. No one knows where their funding comes from, but their sole explicit purpose is to smear and obstruct Biden nominees. They come up with wild narratives, especially about lesser-known nominees, and push them until they catch on with conservatives. You might have seen that Marjorie Taylor Greene made the baseless accusation that then-Supreme Court nominee Katanji Brown Jackson had been lenient on sex offenders
20:00 Speaker 02 during her time as a US District Court Judge. She even called her "pro-pedophile." Well, it was the AAF that started peddling that story. And Gigi is on the AAF's hit list, too. Actually, she's on the front page of the AAF smear website, BidenNomns.com. So while all of this external shadiness was going on to make noise about Gigi's nomination, a bunch of procedural stuff was happening inside the Senate chambers. Lots of boxes need to be checked for a nominee to be confirmed to the FCC. First, the president nominates someone. President Biden took office in January 2021, and he moved quickly on some progressive nominations, like the appointment of Lina Khan to the Federal Trade Commission. But he didn't move on the open FCC slot. So by the time he first nominated Gigi in October
20:45 Speaker 02 of 2021, the telecom-driven propaganda machine had had plenty of time to gear up, bracing itself to obstruct the confirmation. The Senate Commerce Committee held Gigi's first confirmation hearing in December 2021. You've already heard some clips from it. At these hearings, different senators on the committee interview the nominee, and then the committee votes on the nominee. If they vote yes, the nomination goes to the Senate floor, where a majority of all US senators have to vote yes to get the nominee confirmed. But likely because of all of the lobbying in opposition to Gigi, the committee failed to advance her nomination to the floor for a confirmation vote, and her nomination expired. So then Biden had to renominate Gigi in January of this year, and she had a second confirmation
21:28 Speaker 02 hearing in February. As you might have imagined, the Republicans came out swinging in this one.
21:34 Speaker 16 I don't even know where to begin here. I, too, am very... Disturbed, Hassan, on your tweets.
21:41 Speaker 13 If you're trying to force the hand of the agency of the lawmaking body of the federal government by doing that which only Congress can do, how is that constitutional?
21:50 Speaker 16 Damn, that's, that's way out there, right? I mean, you think most Republicans are racist and white supremacists? And I've got to say, Ms. Seun, the timing of the settlement stinks. I don't see how you can be unbiased. Seems to me you have conflicts everywhere, and that makes your impartiality, not to mention your judgment, I think you have very big issues with judgment, given your previous tweets.
22:20 Speaker 02 That was Senators Dan Sullivan, Mike Lee, and Ted Cruz, by the way. Eventually, despite all of this, Gigi won the committee's vote, and her nomination went to the Senate floor. But there still hasn't been a floor vote to confirm her to the FCC, even though she was nominated over a year ago. So why didn't the Biden administration push for a floor vote that would have led to Gigi's confirmation? Well, they chose not to, at least not publicly. McKenna Kelly actually asked Senator Schumer at this earlier this month.
22:50 Speaker 05 What is happening with Gigi Seun? Should we expect her to be confirmed?
22:54 Speaker 17 What's happened? Well, they're, you know, right, right now, the administration is working on getting the votes for her. They're not there yet, but they're pushing hard to get the votes.
23:06 Speaker 02 Here's Carl Bodie.
23:08 Speaker 03 From what I understand, there were some concerns that the nomination of Gigi Seun early on would have conflicted with their efforts to pass the infrastructure bill. I think they were concerned that any controversy around the nomination of a progressive reformer might cause some additional ripples in efforts to get the votes lined up for infrastructure. I'm not sure that's necessarily true, but that's what I understand some of the advisor thinking was that went into the delay.
23:33 Speaker 02 So it sounds like passing that flurry of legislation was prioritized over Gigi's nomination, but we're not really sure. There was some noise that a vote might happen before the Senate's Fourth of July recess, but now it's November, and the midterms are in just a few days.
23:48 Speaker 03 Comcast was really active in states where Democrats were vulnerable in the midterms.
23:53 Speaker 02 Carl told us that Comcast and other members of Gigi's opposition have specifically targeted Democrats in red or purple states who are worried about getting reelected, spooking those vulnerable Democrats from supporting Gigi. So that's how Republicans and big telecom ground things to a halt. And there was some help from Democrats along the way.
24:12 Speaker 03 I've seen, you know, like Heidi Heitkamp. She's a former Democratic senator who I think is running a little PAC that I think the telecom industry is feeding, spreading the idea that so and is really bad for rural America. So it's bipartisan. I think it's a little heavier on the right wing side since they pretty much have a unified blockade against her nomination, but it is bipartisan. The whole Heidi Heitkamp project is basically suggesting that she's terrible for rural America, which again is not based, I don't care how far you have to dig, it's not based on anything close to fact.
24:45 Speaker 02 Here's the thing, though. Yes, the opposition to Gigi comes from both sides, but so does the support. Gigi has long worked with right wing news networks that compete with Fox News to make cable systems like Comcast more competitive. She worked with Charles Herring, the president of Right Wing OAN, to get his other channel, Well TV, onto big cable systems by filing complaints against them. And she worked with Newsmax CEO Chris Ruddy to oppose the merger of Sinclair Broadcasting with the Tribune Media Group, which would have consolidated broadcasting to 73% of US households. These are competition concerns, not speech regulations. So when Gigi was first nominated, Newsmax CEO Chris Ruddy offered his support for her
25:30 Speaker 02 nomination. You heard from him at the top. A reminder, Newsmax is one of the most conservative news outlets in the country. Here's more from our conversation with him.
25:39 Speaker 08 A few years back, I opposed the merger of Sinclair Television Stations with Tribune, which would have created a massive television channel, a station, a network that reached 80% and had control over the market of 80% of US television homes.
25:56 Speaker 02 That stat is actually closer to 73%, but you know.
25:59 Speaker 08 I opposed it and she opposed it. And so I think where you find, where we find common interest, I tend to support even Democrats that do those, do the issues that I care about.
26:11 Speaker 02 There's been a lot of commentary about Gigi in particular that says she is in support of speech regulations. It seems like you're more worried about competition issues. Are you at all worried about her speech or her tweets, I suppose?
26:24 Speaker 08 I'm actually worried about speech issues, but I don't think that she's ever called for closing down any conservative or any other media that I'm aware of. You know, the criticism of Gigi is that she once said during the issues after the election, I think, in a tweet suggested there should be hearings about Fox News. Okay, and I think that she said it was Trump TV or something or other. Well, conservatives have said similar things about CNN and they've called CNN, the Clinton News Network at one point, I remember, or state-run TV or whatever it is. So, you know, it's political rhetoric. She never, ever called for deplatform.
27:06 Speaker 08 I know that when I had the issue after the election, people were calling for Newsmax to be deplatformed. We strongly, vigorously had to defend ourselves and she was sympathetic to the view that, even though she didn't agree with us, that we should have the right to be able to broadcast and exist on the internet cable and OTT streaming platforms.
27:26 Speaker 02 Where do you think the opposition to Gigi's confirmation comes from?
27:29 Speaker 08 Well, I think a lot of it is that she's been fairly progressive activist, so it's an easy target for Fox in this very highly polarized world. She's also been a very strong supporter of net neutrality. Now, I don't personally like the idea of regulating the internet, that the government should regulate the internet, but I do believe that it should be an open platform and I do like the basic concepts behind net neutrality, which is that no company can squelch or limit other players on the internet in their access and broadband access. And we've seen it happen on the internet where Newsmax is being limited or algorithms
28:09 Speaker 08 have been used against us by places like Facebook and Twitter and other places. And so it's very concerning to me that some major broadband provider could start squelching access to the Newsmax stream. Now, we're not aware of that happening, but I think protections need to be in place. And so I'm basically in favor of a concept that's similar to net neutrality, but it became such a highly polarized issue, net neutrality.
28:37 Speaker 02 Yeah.
28:38 Speaker 08 I think conservatives actually should support it, but liberals were the ones to sort of back the idea. Again, not the full regulatory concept behind it, but a robust idea that everybody should have access to the internet and it should be like a utility.
28:52 Speaker 02 The other player here is Fox News, which really opposes Sone's nomination. Do you think that they're pushing against her because they don't want you to compete with them on Comcast and other cable networks?
29:03 Speaker 08 You know, the cable industry is a bit of a racket and the big broadcast companies are part of the racket and they benefit it. The people that get screwed are the consumers, the cable customers. And so the way the racket works is if you own a lot of television stations that a local cable company needs, your ABC, CBS, NBC, Fox affiliates, they basically have you over a barrel because if they don't give you your channel, people are going to go to another cable system, right? The Foxes really milk the system and they've been a big beneficiary and they just want to keep that system going. As a side benefit, they also reduce the potential of Newsmax.
29:43 Speaker 08 Everybody's so afraid of Fox, they will seek to destroy you personally if you go against them. And so a lot of people just are quiet about it.
29:53 Speaker 02 Have you talked to anyone in the Biden administration or Senator Schumer about Gigi's nomination and where it stands? Have you pushed for it?
30:02 Speaker 08 I wouldn't discuss like who I personally have chatted with or what particular agency. I can tell you that I have talked to both Democrats and Republicans, but we still support Gigi Sohn for the FCC Commission.
30:23 Speaker 02 So Ruddy and Newsmax continue to support Gigi Sohn's nomination, but something weird is going on at their big competitor, another far-right news channel, OAN. OAN President Charles Herring released a statement supporting Gigi in December of 2021, laying out reasons very similar to Chris Ruddy. But then his dad, OAN CEO Robert Herring, rebuked his son for endorsing her on the OAN airwaves. Here's some bits from that broadcast, but let me set them up for you. First, an OAN anchor calls Gigi "an enemy of the First Amendment." Then reporter Pearson Sharp interviews Robert Herring. Here's some of that conversation.
31:01 Speaker 18 Sohn is one of the most extreme leftists anywhere in Washington. In fact, she's not just a radical leftist, she's a Marxist who has absolutely no regard for free speech or the Constitution. Gigi is an enemy of the free press. Where do you stand on her nomination? Do you or does One America News support Gigi Sohn's nomination?
31:25 Speaker 19 Well, this is why I had to come on. My son came out and supported her, but the company itself is not supporting him. And at that point, I had to come out and explain that there is no way this company would ever support her and no way I'll ever let it happen. How my son decided he wanted to, I don't know. I think that because we worked with her for, not really worked with her, but we've known her since about 2003 or 2004. And she's never done anything for us. My son's out there saying that we support the company, but there is no way. She shouldn't be anywhere near the FCC as far as I'm concerned.
32:06 Speaker 18 Now, I know that you personally reached out to Fox News to offer your support, didn't you?
32:11 Speaker 19 I did. I called a couple of people over there that are very high and told them, "I'm sorry," and that we'll try and straighten it out and that we should never have backed her.
32:21 Speaker 02 That's a lot of grovelling to Fox News. I mean, wow.
32:31 Speaker 02 So we've talked about who's opposed Gigi and how. But why? Why has big telecom gone to such lengths to oppose Gigi's nomination? David Goodfriend explained to us.
32:42 Speaker 06 Rupert Murdoch and Brian Roberts.
32:44 Speaker 02 Brian Roberts is the CEO of Comcast.
32:46 Speaker 06 Are determined not to let the Senate confirm Gigi. Why is that? It all comes down to their business. Comcast is in the broadband business and they don't want the government telling them what to do. So they don't like net neutrality. In fact, they've really campaigned against net neutrality. The Obama administration put in place the strongest rules ever to preserve an open internet. And Comcast went to war. And the manifestation of that war is their determination not to have Gigi's home confirmed in the Senate. What about Rupert Murdoch? Well, he wants to buy more properties. He doesn't like a lot of attention to which broadcast stations he owns or which streaming
33:31 Speaker 06 services he owns. And yet, Gigi Sohn has been very clear that she thinks there should be limits on the amount of concentration in media worship. So these two billionaires have decided they're trying to stop Gigi Sohn.
33:45 Speaker 02 Carl said something similar, mentioning that telecom wants to prevent the FCC from getting an active and engaged commissioner like the FTC got with Lena Kahn.
33:53 Speaker 03 So I think there's a real aversion amongst these telecom giants. They really don't want, you know, a progressive reformer in there who's willing to shake things up in any degree. They enjoyed pretty much a captured FCC for four years under Trump, and now they've enjoyed an FCC for another two years that basically lacks the voting majority to do anything remotely controversial or anything that the public has demanded that their representatives do. So it's corruption. I mean, we can call it a lot of things, but what we're witnessing is just ordinary corruption. It gets justified and dressed up as something more intellectually complicated, but it is just corruption.
34:30 Speaker 02 Verge policy reporter McKenna Kelly reiterated this as well.
34:32 Speaker 05 What they really care about the most, right, is why you keep it two to two is because if Biden has made it clear that he wants to restore net neutrality, and you can't do that unless there's three Democratic commissioners, you know, at the agency.
34:45 Speaker 02 McKenna also gave us another example of the kind of problems that arise when the FCC is at a stalemate and largely unable to take action against big telecom.
34:54 Speaker 05 The Biden administration struck a deal with a bunch of telecoms, Comcast, Verizon, AT&T, to basically either lower their lowest broadband plans or make them cheaper, you know, so low-income families would have better access to the internet. And that had nothing to do with the FCC, really. I mean, it's the Affordable Connectivity Program that was passed through Congress, of course, but it was just deals that they struck with these companies, and it was just a private market solution.
35:21 Speaker 02 One of the things that really struck me about those deals is that immediately thereafter, Verizon increased its rates.
35:27 Speaker 05 Right.
35:28 Speaker 02 So they got money from the government, and then they increased their rates for their other subscribers. And it seems like that's the sort of thing a functional FCC would be in charge of, but at two to two, it seems like they can't really do much of anything. We asked AT&T for our comment. Here's what the company had to say. "We have long supported an open internet and any suggestion otherwise is wrong. We have not taken a position on Gigi Sohn's nomination, have not asked any third-party organization to take a position, and have not funded any campaigns against her nomination."
35:59 Speaker 02 So with the FCC in its current state, big telecom isn't really being regulated. And that's by big telecom's design, as we've heard. But there are other consequences of this weakened FCC. One is that the FCC isn't at full strength to improve access to the internet in rural and underprivileged areas. Craig Aaron from Free Press emphasized how the need to close the digital divide became even more urgent when the pandemic hit.
36:23 Speaker 07 The Federal Communications Commission is the place that sets the rules for how these companies are going to operate, whether they can rip you off, what your choices are going to be. Is there going to be real competition? The FCC has a big role to play. It actually has a lot of power over shaping the kind of internet we're going to have. Is it just going to be Facebook? Is it just going to be dominated by a few players? Or are we actually going to get back to talking about a kind of, you know, big, open pipes that make anything possible? That is the promise, the original promise of the internet.
36:51 Speaker 02 In fact, the current chair of the FCC herself, Jessica Rosenmussel, talked to us about this on the Vergecast during the pandemic.
36:59 Speaker 20 I think we need a nationwide plan for addressing the digital divide. As a nation, we need a policy that addresses how we're going to connect all of us and what are the plans we want in place to make sure it happens.
37:11 Speaker 02 So what's going to happen to Gigi Sohn's confirmation into the FCC? There are three possible outcomes here. The most likely scenario is the vote will happen in the lame duck period, between November and January, when new senators have been elected but haven't yet taken office. Several other FCC commissioners, Simmington, Carr, Tate, and Adelstein, were confirmed during the lame duck period. So it's very possible this will happen. Another outcome is that a floor vote on Gigi happens next year with the new Senate. The third possible outcome is that Gigi never gets a vote. The Biden administration gives up and puts forth a new nominee who's more amenable to big telecom. Karl Bodie told us he's worried that might happen. But David Goodfriend offered us the silver lining.
37:53 Speaker 06 Well, in some ways, it's a very sad commentary on the outsized influence of a few multi-billion-dollar companies on our politics and our public policy. But on the other hand...
38:10 Speaker 06 I've really felt inspired by the amount of support that Gigi is getting because it's very rare that you see such a diverse coalition on anything right now. I mean, think about it. Newsmax, one of the most conservative news outlets in the United States, supports her. The Communications Workers of America, a labor union, supports her. And thousands and thousands of individual Americans have gone out of their way to tell their senators, we support her, we like her. When's the last time you found an issue like that in today's Washington? It's rare. So it's inspiring to see how much support there really is for her. And I think she'll be confirmed because she's shown that she has the metal for it.
38:53 Speaker 02 Look, I don't know what's going to happen with Gigi's nomination. Obviously, it's too late to get it done before the midterms. They're just a few days away. But I do know that if no one fills the seat at the FCC at all, there will be no meaningful change to net neutrality, no push to close the digital divide, no emphasis on creating more competition for broadband access. There'll just be a lot of nothing. I also know that Americans pay more money for slower broadband than just about every other country in the world because we have utterly failed to regulate our ISPs. And that is a big problem.
39:44 Speaker 02 You heard at the top of the show that a lot of people and companies wouldn't comment for this episode, but I do want to thank the many people who did. So thanks to Craig Aaron, Carl Bodie, Ernesto Falcone, David Goodfriend, Greg Geis, McKenna Kelly, Chris Ruddy, and Catherine Trenacosta. And thank you for listening to Decoder. I'd love to hear what you think of the show and honestly, this new episode format. You can email us at [email protected] or hit me up directly. I'm at Reckless on Twitter. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. If you really like Decoder, hit us with that five-star review. And if you tweet about this episode, I will almost certainly retweet you. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode is written and reported by Jackie McDermott. It was produced by Creighton DeSimone and Jackie McDermott. It was edited by Callie
40:27 Speaker 02 Wright with additional mixing by Andrew Marino. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our editorial director is Brooke Minter, and our executive director is Eleanor Donovan. We'll see you next time.
40:40 Speaker 21 Fall savings are happening now at The Home Depot. Save up to $500 on select appliances. Plus, enjoy free delivery when you spend $998 or more. From prepping to cooking to cleaning up, Frigidaire has you covered. The custom Flex Temp drawer switches from fridge to freezer. With more than 15 cooking modes, including stone baked pizza mode, you can enjoy restaurant-quality pizza in as little as two minutes. Then clean up with the Frigidaire Dishwasher, featuring the industry's fastest normal wash cycle. Shop fall savings now at The Home Depot. Offer valid through October 21st. U.S. only. See store online for details.
41:11 Speaker 22 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing and wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash apple watch series 12.
Previous Why Amazon VP Steve Boom just made the entire music catalog free with Prime Next Why Figma is selling to Adobe for $20 billion, with CEO Dylan Field Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated