Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Why nonprofits should think more like tech companies About this episode Stanford lecturer Kathleen Kelly Janus talks with Recode's Kara Swisher about her book, "Social Startup Success: How the Best Nonprofits Launch, Scale Up and Make a Difference." In this episode: (01:17) Janus's background and what social entrepreneurship is; (05:26) What works and what doesn't; (08:36) For-profits and nonprofits; (13:11) What nonprofits have to do to get ahead; (18:40) New forms of fundraising and leadership; (22:35) The power of storytelling; (29:13) Where philanthropy is going; (35:07) Examples of innovative philanthropy; (39:16) Explosions of fundraising online
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 I'm Ina Garten and each week on Happy Hour, I invite new and old friends for a drink and a fun conversation at my kitchen table in New York City. On this week's episode, I'm joined by Nathan Lane. We talk about his critically acclaimed run in Death of a Salesman, taking his dog to therapy, and winning an Emmy for Only Murders in the Building. New episodes of Happy Hour are available every Wednesday. You can watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get your podcasts. Cheers.
0:37 Speaker 01 How much have you spent on your pet's medical care this year? Maybe more than your own?
0:42 Speaker 02 25 years ago, it was very rare to hear of a pet having an MRI. Now it's kind of standard if a pet presents with an issue. Big corporations and private equity have seen all of this and have rushed into the sector.
1:00 Speaker 01 Why your vet bill is so high? That's this week on Explain It to Me. Listen to new episodes Sundays wherever you get your podcasts.
1:12 Speaker 03 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, the editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as someone who would be a reportrepreneur, but I hate that term. Sorry, Jessica, listen. But in my spare time, I talk tech and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today in the red chair is Kathleen Kelly Janis, a lecturer at Stanford University's Program on Social Entrepreneurship. She's also the author of the book Social Startup Success: How the Best Nonprofits Launch, Scale Up, and Make a Difference. Oh, it's so nice to be talking about social things. Kathleen, welcome to Recode Decode.
1:42 Speaker 04 Thanks for having me, Kara.
1:43 Speaker 03 It's been an ugly period of time in startup land, I think. But here, we're going to talk about what you're doing. Give me a little bit of your background. Now, I want to know how you got to writing about this social entrepreneurship because Stanford has a very big program in that. There's lots of, there's a lot of really interesting things going on there.
1:57 Speaker 04 Huge program. So I was raised in a small town. I was raised in Napa. My grandparents moved there when it was prune country, long before it was wine country. I was raised in a family where we were Irish Catholic and it was... Our duty to give back to the community. So oftentimes you would find my sisters and me tagging along with my parents giving back at soup kitchens. And my parents sat on dozens of nonprofit boards over the years. And so the conversations at our dinner table didn't just revolve around the people in our community that didn't have enough to eat, but the nonprofits themselves and how they really struggled to survive and thrive. So I've always had this real passion for giving back, particularly to nonprofits.
2:40 Speaker 04 And so when I was a young lawyer in San Francisco, I looked for ways to get involved, didn't find them, and ended up co-founding my own nonprofit, Spark, which engages young professionals in giving back to gender equality issues.
2:54 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm.
2:55 Speaker 04 And Spark was amazing. We had a ton of momentum. We had a ton of buzz. And just when we hit our stride, we hit this wall. We couldn't get the capital that we needed to grow the organization. And so many years later, when I began teaching social entrepreneurship at Stanford, I became really curious, well, who are the organizations that are scaling this wall? And what were they doing that we weren't doing at Spark?
3:18 Speaker 03 So talk about the idea of what a social entrepreneur is. So, because that's, explain what Stanford has. Stanford has a lot of programs. I know Lauren Dresen's involved in it. There's a whole bunch of people involved in it. Explain that for people.
3:28 Speaker 04 So, social entrepreneurship is a new form of creating social change. It used to be about checkbook charity, about, let's say, Bill Drayton, the godfather of social entrepreneurship, says it's no longer about just giving a man a fish, or even teaching a man a fish. We need to revolutionize the fishing industry. And that's exactly what social entrepreneurs do. They're thinking about how you can solve the underlying problems of, say, homelessness. So you don't have to just give a man a bed, that you can prevent homelessness from happening in the first place.
4:02 Speaker 03 And at Stanford, they do, there's a degree in it, correct?
4:05 Speaker 04 There are dozens of social entrepreneurship classes at Stanford. And that's really exciting, because I'm seeing in my students, it's not just, you know, a certain type of student who's going to go in the nonprofit sector. It's computer science majors, it's engineering majors. There is a passion and an interest of young people to get involved in social causes like never before.
4:25 Speaker 03 So when you're talking about that concept, I want to get to your book in a second about some, but one of the things that I think a lot of people feel are lacking are that interest in social issues and sort of all the... Coming home to roost right now in these hearings that have been going on and about the responsibility of companies like Facebook and Google and others. Why is that shifting? Because it didn't seem like there was a whole lot of that before in startups, that they did not think of anything but growth, growth, growth. Social issues were very low on the totem pole, if there at all, or they were relegated to a status that never got fixed.
4:54 Speaker 04 I think young people are taking it. We're seeing an incredible generational shift where now 55% of millennials say that a company's social cause work was a really important factor in deciding whether to go for work for a company. And so companies have no choice but to get involved in social cause work if they want to hire and retain great talent.
5:16 Speaker 03 And how does that work here, you know, in Silicon Valley? I want to get to your book in a second, but like when you're trying to get companies to get that, you don't want it forced upon them, presumably?
5:26 Speaker 04 No, I think it has to come from companies themselves. It has to come from the passion and interest of the founders, of the employees, and every company is going to have a social cause program that's going to look a different way. But what I will say is that the sooner that you can integrate social cause work into the fabric of a company's culture, the more effective it's going to be, and ultimately the more fulfilling it's going to be for the employees as well.
5:57 Speaker 03 So let's talk about the ones that have worked, because every company, there's been Google out of work, there have been all kinds of things in the tech sector, and we're going to focus just on the tech sector, but talk a little bit about what's worked and what hasn't worked.
6:07 Speaker 04 So I'll tell you an interesting story. So I went on this book tour, my book came out in January, and I happened to be speaking at Google and Facebook the same week. And it happened to be that I was speaking at Facebook the day that the Cambridge Analytica news broke. And so I, you know, I saw it on CNN that morning, and I go in and the executive who was showing around said, "I'm so sorry, the cafeteria is in disarray, you know, we have this, we had this all hands on meeting for this external thing that's going on." And I said, "Oh, really? That external thing that I saw on CNN this morning?"
6:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, how you ruined democracy.
6:45 Speaker 04 And so it was so interesting, you know, speaking at Facebook and hearing the passion of those employees who were looking for ways to get involved in social causes. And Mark Zuckerberg made a really interesting decision early on in Facebook that his philanthropy would be separate. And so the philanthropy arm of Facebook is the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative, which is doing incredible work. I have a lot of respect for Priscilla Chan and Mark Zuckerberg. They've been very committed to a lot of great social causes. But they're selling themselves short by not harnessing this incredible passion that their employees have. And so when I heard questions from the employees at Facebook, it was like, I'm just going to be here for a couple of years until I can go start my own thing.
7:28 Speaker 04 Because they were looking to get involved elsewhere, because they weren't finding that support internally. Shift to Google, where I spoke that same week, where, you know, the .org work has been integrated into the company from very early on. And there is a commitment to giving their engineers and their employees time to work on social cause work. The questions were very different, and the opportunities to give back were so different. So for example, when the fires happened in Northern California, Google employees came to the table and said, you know, we realize that it's really hard for people to get information about where these fires are. We think we can use our mapping tools to make that information available. And they did, and it was critical to support those regions.
8:12 Speaker 04 And so that's the kind of change that companies can make for good if they allow their employees the opportunity to give back as a part of their job.
8:24 Speaker 03 Does every company have to have these, though? I mean, it seems like a doerigurs thing that companies have them. Now, I know Airbnb has one. They all seem to have launched those kind of things.
8:34 Speaker 04 They don't have to, but if they're going to want to survive in today's hiring economy, I think it's going to be necessary. The next generation is Gen Z. Gen Z is even more committed. 60% of teens say that they want their work to have an impact in the world. So, again, It's also, it's employees and it's consumers. Consumers are also demanding products from companies that are values-based. So I think it's a really exciting time for philanthropy and to be involved in social.
9:07 Speaker 03 So I'm going to go to the nonprofits themselves in a second, but I wanted to stick with companies for a minute. I just interviewed Rose Mercario from Patagonia, for example. That's a heavy values-based company, even to the detriment of their own business, which seems to have gotten better the more committed they are to values, to certain values they have around, whether it's suing the federal government over different things, over parklands and things like that, or being very strident against the government, against Trump particularly, or whatever, or saying, "Don't buy our stuff, recycle it," and things like that. It seems to have worked rather well for them.
9:42 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think Patagonia is a great example of a company that has been incredibly, not only impactful through the way that they're doing business, but also have shown that it can be good for business, too. They've seen an incredible revival of their company.
9:56 Speaker 03 All right, so talk a little bit about nonprofits themselves. When you're talking about, you know, social startup success, how have nonprofits changed? Because when I was in Silicon Valley a couple of years ago, many years ago, I remember going to something, it was right near Kleiner Perkins, and they were helping nonprofits become more technical and do better. And it was sort of a hopeless cause, because most of these nonprofits were stuck in some age that just doesn't exist anymore. Talk about the way nonprofits have moved.
10:24 Speaker 04 Nonprofits are struggling.
10:26 Speaker 03 Yeah.
10:26 Speaker 04 So my research showed that this wall that we hit at Spark, getting past $500,000 in revenue, is a real thing. That 2/3 of nonprofits in the United States are $500,000 in revenue and below. And they are on this treadmill to constantly fundraise for payroll the next month when they should be focused on their impact. I mean, imagine if we expected that of CEOs, right? Like... We're going to make you spend, nonprofits who responded to my survey said that they spent 75% of their time on fundraising. Companies would never get anything done. Right. And so we're basically expecting nonprofits to solve some of the hardest issues
11:07 Speaker 04 of our time, like climate change and increasing inequality, with one hand tied behind their back. And so my book, Social Startup Success, is all about trying to figure out, well, what are the strategies that nonprofits are using to get ahead? Like, testing and innovation, measuring impact, fundraising more creatively, developing better ways of telling the story, so that we can teach the next generation of nonprofits and the last generation of nonprofits how to be more effective. These strategies are teachable, and the problem is that we're not teaching them.
11:41 Speaker 03 Okay. We're here talking with Kathleen Kelly Janus. She's the author of Social Startup Success. When we get back, I want to hear more about the tips that you use to create better nonprofits.
11:52 Speaker 05 What if we told, dude, there was one thing you could eat to reduce your risk of death by about a quarter?
11:58 Speaker 06 Interested? And what if we added that this magical substance can dramatically lower your cholesterol, improve your mood, and keep your weight stable?
12:06 Speaker 05 No, it's not protein. It's actually fiber, the least sexy, most overlooked nutrient of all.
12:13 Speaker 06 But what is fiber? How could one nutrient do all those amazing things? And how can you get enough? Is a powder you stir into some water going to do it for you?
12:21 Speaker 05 All that, plus the strange tale of the gorilla poop-obsessed father of cornflakes in the latest episode of Gastropod. Find Gastropod and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
12:35 Speaker 03 We're here with Kathleen Kelly Janus. She's the author of Social Startup Success. She's also a lecturer at Stanford University. Talk a little bit about your, the second part of your book is how they scale. You're talking to them in nonprofits launch, scale, and make a difference. You're using tech terms to do that. Talk a little bit about what nonprofits have to do.
12:53 Speaker 04 Well, in my research, I found that it wasn't just charisma or a great idea that allowed a nonprofit to get ahead or not. I went out and I surveyed hundreds of nonprofit leaders. I sat down with 100 social entrepreneurs with their staff and asked them what the key was to their success. And it turns out that it's these five strategies that I talk about in the book, testing and innovation, measuring impact, collective leadership, fundraising, experimentation, and storytelling that allow organizations to lay the foundation for success.
13:32 Speaker 03 So go through the first one.
13:33 Speaker 04 So testing and innovation.
13:35 Speaker 03 Which you don't think of when you think of startups, really.
13:38 Speaker 04 No, and yet that is the essence of philanthropy and nonprofits, to test small ideas so that we can use government to scale them for good. And the problem is that a lot of nonprofits get stuck on their individual solution and don't really take the time to investigate whether they are solving the problem in the most effective way. So the organizations that continue to be innovative as they grow are the ones that are able to ensure that they're having the most impact.
14:10 Speaker 03 Right. So what else? So testing, like what?
14:14 Speaker 04 So.
14:15 Speaker 03 Give me an example.
14:16 Speaker 04 So an example would be Beth Schmidt, who founded Wishbone.
14:20 Speaker 03 And what did they do?
14:21 Speaker 04 It's a crowdfunding platform for low-income kids to get involved in extracurricular activities. And so when she was teaching in a low-income school in Los Angeles, she realized that her kids didn't have these opportunities to follow their passions. She didn't go out and just start a nonprofit. She took the time to really identify what is the problem and how can I help with my solution. And so she assigned a paper asking them to write about their passions. And she photocopied that paper, sent it out to her friends and family and said, would you give these kids money to follow their passions over the summer? And she got back thousands of dollars in the mail. So she really figured out how to tweak the engine before she began to run it.
15:05 Speaker 04 So doing things like figuring out how to get better scholarship money so that the cost would be lower, how to engage the kids in the fundraising themselves so that they could get that skill. And this is really drawing on a lot of the lean startup principles that we see in the Silicon Valley, the minimum viable product, figuring out how to test, measure, build. And by drawing on some of these Silicon Valley practices, she was able to scale this organization to be a multimillion dollar organization that has served thousands of students across the country.
15:37 Speaker 03 All right, so testing and innovation before. Next one.
15:40 Speaker 04 Measuring impact is really critical.
15:42 Speaker 03 Which they don't do.
15:44 Speaker 04 No, I mean, this is something that really defines the next generation of nonprofits, this real rigor towards data. And I thought when I first learned this that, well, that makes sense. These are the ones that are able to go out and talk to donors and say, here's what impact we're having, and then they get funded. But it's not that at all, that they want to know that they are having the most impact that they can possibly have. So the problem is, it's really hard to do that. Seventy-five percent of nonprofits say they collect data. Only 6% of them feel like they know how to use it well.
16:16 Speaker 03 Right, right.
16:17 Speaker 04 So we need to do a better job of supporting nonprofits to be more rigorous with their data, to know how to use that data that they're collecting so that they can figure out how to do better.
16:26 Speaker 03 So give me an example, someone who's done that well.
16:28 Speaker 04 One organization that has done this well is Braven, an organization that helps college students who are from low-income backgrounds learn soft skills like networking and resume building. When they had their first cohort of freshmen, they needed to know whether they were having an impact early on. They couldn't wait four years to see if these students were graduating. So they tested proxies, like, were those kids going to class as a proxy for whether they would ultimately graduate? They asked their mentors if they would recommend them for jobs as a proxy for whether they would ultimately get a job. And by using this data to show that they were on track toward... Towards graduating their students at faster rates and getting them jobs at faster rates.
17:13 Speaker 04 They were then ultimately able to tweak their program so that they could be as effective as possible and grow the program by getting the confidence of the donors that they needed to get to that next level.
17:23 Speaker 03 Okay. And is it an anathema towards data or is it just not an ability or not thinking of it properly?
17:29 Speaker 04 I think-
17:30 Speaker 03 Because all tech companies use their data. I mean, that's how everybody differentiates themselves.
17:35 Speaker 04 I think the challenge is that nonprofit leaders go into this work because they care about the causes, not because they're data scientists. And I think, you know, as someone personally who's a little bit of a dataphobe, I can relate to that. And I think what nonprofits have to realize is that it doesn't have to be this big complicated thing. You can just figure out the two or three things that matter, like Braven did, and go after them rigorously. And also leverage the help of tech companies and data scientists who do know what they're doing. This is something that nonprofits have also been doing well.
18:09 Speaker 03 Yeah, they have recently. All right, what else?
18:11 Speaker 04 So also fundraising experimentation. This is a really important piece of it, and particularly developing ways of generating earned income. This is, again, another signature component of the new nonprofit. It's not just about-
18:24 Speaker 03 So the old way was?
18:25 Speaker 04 Checkbook charity. You know, take donations and give services and then come back in the year and get your donation renewed.
18:34 Speaker 03 Have a party.
18:36 Speaker 04 That's not, yeah, the gala. That's not very sustainable. And so organizations like Hot Bread Kitchen in New York, which are using bread recipes from low-income women to help both train them to go into jobs in the food industry and then sell the bread to sustain the organization itself, are finding ways to bring in earned income. Hot Bread Kitchen has a cafe. They do wholesale to Whole Foods and JetBlue, and they have an incubator for small businesses from the food industry. This is really exciting that these organizations are able to survive beyond just philanthropic dollars.
19:17 Speaker 03 Because fundraising is, besides the hand-to-mouth aspect of checkbook, which you're talking about doing it every year, this is a way to diversify your business, presumably, which is a business, right?
19:27 Speaker 04 Absolutely, absolutely. I think what we have to be careful about is recognizing that not all causes are going to be amenable to earned income. You know, there's not a huge business.
19:37 Speaker 03 It's not a t-shirt business.
19:38 Speaker 04 Yeah.
19:38 Speaker 03 A lot of T-shirts.
19:39 Speaker 04 Yeah. You know, racial justice issues, human rights. You know, people aren't going to be paying for their human rights if they can't afford the bus to get to the courthouse in the first place.
19:48 Speaker 03 Right, right.
19:49 Speaker 04 So philanthropy is not dead, but where organizations can bring in earned income, it can be very useful.
19:55 Speaker 03 Okay, what else?
19:56 Speaker 04 The other strategy that these organizations use is collective leadership. So they're flipping this, the traditional hierarchy of the CEO being on top.
20:07 Speaker 03 Right.
20:08 Speaker 04 And putting their staff up front. In the book, I talk about Jim Nordstrom, who did this famously at Nordstrom, the Nordstrom Way. He talked about how customers should be first, and the people who are closest to those customers, the salespeople on the floor, are the people who have the most control over the outcome.
20:26 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm.
20:27 Speaker 04 And so nonprofit leaders also realize that they cannot do it all themselves. And although we are in this world where we revere our leaders, like we equate Facebook with Mark Zuckerberg, we equate microfinance with Mohammed Yunus, that actually the best nonprofits tap into the talents of their entire staff to leverage their talents and to keep them engaged.
20:56 Speaker 03 How do you get a company, a nonprofit, to do that? Because usually, they like their charismatic founder.
21:01 Speaker 04 Well...
21:02 Speaker 03 Sometimes it turns out to be bad, like every fourth one.
21:05 Speaker 04 I think the problem is usually we like the charismatic founder. And so whether it's donors or media, you know, we all want to hear from the founder because it makes a great story. And so the best organizations figure out how to use "we" language, not "I" language, how to make everybody a part of the social cause and the movement, not just the...
21:31 Speaker 03 Give me a good example of that, too.
21:32 Speaker 04 So Charles Best from Donors Choose, which is...
21:35 Speaker 03 Yeah, he's great.
21:36 Speaker 04 Yes, an incredible crowdfunding platform.
21:38 Speaker 03 I'm starting with crowdfunding for teachers.
21:40 Speaker 04 For teachers, so teachers can put their projects up on the site and fundraise to get them funded. Charles Best always brings it back to the teachers. He always brings it back to the staff and the leaders. And he understands his role as the face and the voice of the organization. But he never misses an opportunity to give credit to others. And that is the beauty of collaborative leadership.
22:04 Speaker 03 Okay, and the last one, storytelling.
22:06 Speaker 04 Storytelling, yeah. So I think we all have this tendency to think that, you know, someone who gives a great TED Talk, a great political speech, gets up there and they're just such a natural. And when I went out and talked with these leaders, it's not natural at all. It comes from a lot of practice. And they realize that you cannot build a movement if you can't tell a good story. So for example, Nadine Burk Harris, who founded the Center for Youth Wellness, had the opportunity to give a TED Talk about ACES. This was the talk of her life because she realized she could shift the conversation if she could make this go viral. And so she talks about how at the end of six months preparing for this speech, her husband literally could have given the speech for her
22:49 Speaker 04 because she had given it so many times across the dining room table. So that is a level of commitment that we see in storytelling. And it's not just for founders. It's also for staff or your board members who can be incredible champions for your cause. Everybody needs the tools to be a brand ambassador for an organization. And the onus is on the nonprofit organizations to put those tools.
23:15 Speaker 03 Have they used social media tools and other things to do that? I mean, you were talking about TED Talk, which not many people get to do. What are some other techniques that people?
23:23 Speaker 04 So I tested for social media in my original survey because I was really curious if there would be a correlation between the organizations that were emphasizing a social media play and organizations that weren't. And there wasn't. I do think social media is a place that can have-
23:40 Speaker 03 Or technology tools.
23:41 Speaker 04 Oh, of course, technology tools. I mean, we heard from Dave and Charlotte Willner, the power of Facebook to allow-
23:50 Speaker 03 This was a couple you can explain.
23:51 Speaker 04 Yeah, the couple who wanted to raise $1,500 on Facebook for ACES. Yeah, and to help-
24:00 Speaker 04 Bring families back together who were being separated at the border and, you know, within one week raised $20 million. And that is the power of technology and social media to help social causes. And that is allowing philanthropy to take shapes and forms that we've never seen before. That's very exciting. It is not the only way to have a cause go viral. The Center for Youth Wellness, for example, uses Google Analytics to see how they've changed the conversation by seeing how many times people are Googling aces. And, you know, Nadine Burkharis was talking about how Oprah had on 60 Minutes this talk about aces and she didn't feature Nadine.
24:43 Speaker 04 And we were all like, wait a second, you should have been on Oprah. And she said, no, no, no, no, no. That's impact. When other people are using your story and not attributing it to you, you have changed the conversation. And so I think it's that egolessness that is, makes, makes organizations and leaders so powerful.
25:03 Speaker 03 Have organizations embraced this stuff? Or, we're going to talk about that next, but where philanthropy is going. But how hard is it to get an organization off, like a nonprofit organization off? Because they do represent to me, besides healthcare, the slowest moving change agents around.
25:18 Speaker 04 It's really hard. And it goes back to the fact that donors are not investing in nonprofits to give them the tools they need to make a difference. So 80% of nonprofits in this, of philanthropy in this country is restricted. So that means that those donations have to go to certain programs. Let's say if it's a reading program, it can only go to the reading program. It can't go to what donors might call overhead expenses. We would never go into a restaurant and say, I'll pay for the food, but definitely not paying for the plate, or the chef's time to prepare it, or, you know, the electricity to keep the lights on. And yet we do that with nonprofits all the time.
26:03 Speaker 04 Somehow we feel entitled to restrict our donations to the part that feels good, like teaching a kid to read, but not all of the components that go into...
26:13 Speaker 03 Well, that's probably because many have abused it. Like, there's been, like, you report after report of them using all the money for their own overhead.
26:19 Speaker 04 I think those reports got sensationalized. But all of these strategies that we talk about in social startup success... That's overhead. That's capacity building. That's investing in nonprofit leaders to do the work on the social causes that we care about. And so there's a great TED Talk by Dan Poulter where he talks about the overhead myth and how we do need to invest in overhead because that's all the R and D and the marketing that gets companies off the ground.
26:47 Speaker 03 Right.
26:47 Speaker 04 We need the same kind of investment in social causes.
26:51 Speaker 03 Okay. We're here with Kathleen Kelly Janus. She's the author of Social Startup Success. When we get back, we're going to talk about where philanthropy is going in the future and how it will be changed going forward and where it is, actually, how people, how much giving people are doing. We're talking with Kathleen Kelly Janus. She's the author of Social Startup Success. She's also a lecturer at Stanford University. I want to finish up talking about where philanthropy is going. You know, a lot of, there's a lot of money here. For example, a lot of different entrepreneurs have started their own philanthropies. Mark Zuckerberg, obviously, Pierre Omidyar and his wife Pam, obviously, Bill Gates and his wife also have started that, Melinda Gates. And they're doing some really astonishing things. Is that the way philanthropy is going to go in the future? What's happened?
27:36 Speaker 03 What's changed? Because that's where much of the money is in philanthropy. Maybe I'm wrong, but it seems like some of the most exciting ones are out of tech right now.
27:44 Speaker 04 It's a very exciting time in philanthropy. So about 2% of our country's GDP goes to philanthropy, about $340 billion. And so this is a huge investment that big foundations like Omidyar, Gates, and others are making in social causes. And they're doing it in new ways. They're investing in this very kind of social innovation that we're talking about, new ideas that are being applied to social causes that are allowing for scale like we've never seen. And so that's all really exciting. What I think is challenging as new donors think about ways to make a difference, a couple of things.
28:29 Speaker 04 One is that we forget about the poverty in our own backyard. We are living in a valley of billionaires and yet one in six children goes to school hungry.
28:41 Speaker 03 In the San Francisco area.
28:42 Speaker 04 Every day. Yeah. There's a great report, The Giving Code by Alexis McCleod, sorry, Alexis Cortez Colwell and Heather McCleod Grant, which talks about this poverty paradox that we're seeing in the Silicon Valley and how A lot of the philanthropy that's happening is going to higher institutions.
29:02 Speaker 03 Africa, too.
29:04 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, there's a story that they tell where this donor spent, was making an incredible contribution, a $10 million gift to a nonprofit. He spent a year trying to negotiate what the terms of the gift would be and finally, ultimately, gave the gift. He was at his Harvard reunion with a bunch of guys and, you know, had planned to give a certain amount, but saw what everybody else was giving and, you know, by the end of the night, he made a $25 million gift on the spot.
29:32 Speaker 03 To Harvard.
29:33 Speaker 04 To Harvard. Where there's a lot of poor people.
29:36 Speaker 03 Because they need the money.
29:39 Speaker 04 So, you know, I think that there is this scrutiny of nonprofits that we don't see in higher education institutions and other places where people contribute their money. And I think that people need to take it upon themselves to understand how they can give back to people in our community who are suffering as well. And I think they need to do that by ensuring that they are educating themselves and learning from those who have gone before them. Sean Parker, a couple of years ago, came out with this piece in the Wall Street Journal talking about how he-
30:17 Speaker 03 This is the Napster founder and he was an early Facebook investor?
30:19 Speaker 04 Yep, how he wanted to hack philanthropy.
30:22 Speaker 03 Yeah, I remember.
30:24 Speaker 04 You know, which is exciting, I'm all for, you know-
30:27 Speaker 03 Sean has a lot to say.
30:28 Speaker 04 Thinking about new ways to approach philanthropy, but let's not forget that there are people who have been on the ground with their sleeves rolled up, trying to tackle these issues for decades. And what can we learn from them and improve on in order to really make an impact in these social causes that we care about?
30:49 Speaker 03 Yeah, I forgot that hacking, they love to talk about stuff like that. They have to first declare it broken so they can fix it, right? Yeah, is that irritating?
30:57 Speaker 04 Well, I think that, you know, I'm in the education business.
31:00 Speaker 03 It's irritating to me.
31:01 Speaker 04 So I try and keep it positive.
31:02 Speaker 03 Oh, do you? I find it deeply irritating. But are there some hacks that, I mean, there are some hacks, you're talking about hacks here in your book, correct?
31:10 Speaker 04 Absolutely. I mean, it's-
31:12 Speaker 03 Because there are antiquated ways we've done philanthropy in the past.
31:15 Speaker 04 Absolutely. And I think that there's a lot of old school nonprofits out there that need to renovate. They need to, they need to clean house and think about doing new, taking new approaches like measuring the impact of their work more rigorously so they can figure out what's working and what's not and get better at what they do. But this isn't rocket science. The strategies that I talk about in this book are not new. They're just what the best organizations are doing.
31:47 Speaker 03 Where do you imagine philanthropy is going in the future?
31:50 Speaker 04 You know, I'm really hopeful about the next phase of giving. I really believe that we are living in a golden age of philanthropy where there are more ways to give back than ever before. I mean, we see this with ordinary citizens giving back, like the, the Rises fundraiser on Facebook. We see this with people who are giving their time, their, they don't, people don't just want to write a check and be done. They want to roll up their sleeves and get involved in the nonprofits that they care about. This is what's happening in the Rises fundraiser.
32:25 Speaker 03 People going down.
32:27 Speaker 04 People are saying, yeah, no, it's, I don't want to just write a check. What, now what can I do? And so, we need all hands on deck to solve these really pressing social problems that we're facing, like climate change, like increasing wealth inequality. And so, I think the fact that more people want to get involved is really exciting and we need to educate the next generation so that when they do graduate from college, they are ready to hit the ground running and they don't have to waste their time-
32:59 Speaker 03 Figuring-
32:59 Speaker 04 -learning these very basic skills like fundraising and measuring impact on the job.
33:03 Speaker 03 Right, absolutely. And if you had to pick out a philanthropy that's doing it in a really innovative way, what would you pick? Name, give me two or three stories of that.
33:11 Speaker 04 I'm a huge fan of Tipping Point.
33:13 Speaker 03 Okay.
33:13 Speaker 04 I know that you've had Daniel Lurie, the founder, on the show. When I went out and I asked organizations, "Who is your favorite funder and why?" Tipping Point came up most often because of the fact that they give multi-year grants, that nonprofits don't have to worry about whether they're going to get funded next year. And it leads to a more honest conversation. I mean, this is a big problem in the sector. There's no incentive to talk about failure when you have to get funded. And yet, anyone from the tech sector knows that failure's a critical part-
33:47 Speaker 03 Yeah, they like to celebrate.
33:48 Speaker 04 -learning and getting better and doing better work. And so it allows them more transparency and it allows Tipping Point to then come in and help the organizations figure out how to solve the challenges that are happening.
33:59 Speaker 03 Tipping Point gives money to organizations. They're a funder of philanthropies.
34:04 Speaker 04 They are. And they're supporting anti-poverty work in the Bay Area.
34:09 Speaker 03 Yeah, they're also doing that, homelessness, anti-homelessness.
34:12 Speaker 04 Yeah, and so it's the multi-year grants. It's the capacity building. It's investing in all these strategies that I talk about in social startup success, like management training, fundraising, storytelling. They bring in a media coach, yeah, to help their nonprofits. Because media coaching shouldn't be something that's just relegated to companies. I mean, this is something that nonprofits arguably need just as much. And so by investing in the nonprofits that they support, I think that ultimately, they're able to show better results. And I hope that Tipping Point will be a model that other philanthropies will learn from and individual donors as well.
34:54 Speaker 03 What else?
34:55 Speaker 04 I am a huge fan of organizations that are thinking about how to invest in not just organizations themselves, but in, say, initiatives like Chan Zuckerberg is doing incredible work with-
35:16 Speaker 04 Their hospital, sorry, their preschool that Chan, Priscilla Chan has led in looking at adverse childhood experiences and how they can bring their talents from the foundation to bear in this preschool that is helping kids recover from adverse childhood experiences. I'm also a huge fan of the Emerson Collective. I think that Lorraine Powell Jobs has done a fantastic job of not just investing in the causes that she cares about, but using her voice and realizing that her voice on immigration issues is going to be equally
35:58 Speaker 04 as powerful as any money that she can give to nonprofit organizations. So you will see her in the halls of Congress advocating for immigration reform legislation. And that is a really important role that philanthropists, big and small, can-
36:15 Speaker 03 She also does a lot of artistic and social media things that have, it's a really interesting thing. They did a Carne Arenas, the VR experience. They funded that, what it's like to be an immigrant, which I thought was very moving.
36:27 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
36:28 Speaker 03 They did this art, this photography project that got very viral, where they put pictures of all the immigrants in front of like Mitch McConnell's office, like giant photographs of immigrants.
36:39 Speaker 04 Amazing.
36:40 Speaker 03 Just to see who they are. And I thought that was, everyone's like, oh, it's a waste of time. I'm like, no, it's not. It's a visual representation, so people can't look away.
36:46 Speaker 04 And that can be sometimes the most powerful way to change hearts and minds. Jeff Skoll has done this through participant media where he, you know, made waves with The Inconvenient Truth, the film that he funded on climate change and-
37:01 Speaker 03 This is an eBay founder.
37:02 Speaker 04 Yep. And so thinking about film as a way to change the conversation can also be a really important contribution to social causes.
37:13 Speaker 03 Absolutely. Lastly, are we gonna, like, when you think about what happened with the Facebook thing with races, is that the way big funding is gonna happen from now in these moments of boom? It happened in Haiti, it happens, you know, on Twitter or wherever. Is that the way fundraising is gonna go in the future, where there'll be just these big, large- Explosions of fundraising or not?
37:36 Speaker 04 I think it is going to be one big part of the way that fundraising happens. And I think that's really exciting. I think one thing we saw with-
37:45 Speaker 03 Like this guy in Alexander Gillum in just political fundraising. He was using a single app that really got, it was really interesting. It was just-
37:52 Speaker 04 Well, I think Obama and his presidential campaign really showed that, you know, a $5 contribution when brought together with, you know, millions of other $5 contributions can actually make a big difference. And that is an equalizing of philanthropy that we're seeing that is really exciting because it's giving ordinary citizens the feeling that they can give back. I remember being a young professional saddled with student loan debt and feeling like I would stretch myself to make, you know, a $100 donation and it would be a drop in the bucket. But now people can really see and touch and feel the impact of their contributions through these large donations.
38:36 Speaker 03 It also feels like a game. Like it feels like a, like, let's get the number. It's just interesting. I've noticed like a ton of them now.
38:42 Speaker 04 Well, all game of five. Philanthropy any day if it helps social causes, let's go.
38:47 Speaker 03 So again, this is, to get, to, for these philanthropies to start doing this, they have to start thinking more innovatively. That's essentially what you're saying.
38:56 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
38:57 Speaker 03 They have to think innovatively in how they're gonna put their messaging out, how they're gonna put their, how they're gonna create their organization and how to invest in their organization essentially.
39:06 Speaker 04 Yeah, absolutely. But it also means that we need to be supporting nonprofits so that they can integrate some of this innovation into their work.
39:16 Speaker 03 Great. Thank you so much. This is Kathleen Kelly Janis. She's the author of Social Startup Success. We've been talking about philanthropies and where they're going. The book is available everywhere, correct? Absolutely. Absolutely. Thank you so much. It was great talking to you. Thanks, Kara. If you enjoyed the interview as much as I did, be sure to subscribe and leave us a review on Apple Podcasts. You can also find more episodes of Recode Decode on Spotify, Google Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. If you didn't like the interview, well, you're just a mean person. Or you just want to say hi, tweet at me. I'm at Kara Swisher on Twitter. Now that you're done with this, go check out the latest episode of Recode Media. You can find that show wherever you found this one. Thank you for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. Thanks to our editor, Joel Robby, and our producer, Eric Johnson. I'll be back here on Saturday. Tune in then.
Previous Recode Decode: Sally Yates Next Recode Decode: Milk Bar CEO Christina Tosi Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated