Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Whistleblower Aid CEO John Tye About this episode John Napier Tye, the founder and CEO of Whistleblower Aid, talks with Recode's Kara Swisher about how his non-profit law firm helps people seeking to legally expose corruption in the government and at private companies. It recently worked with a whistleblower at MIT, connecting them with New Yorker reporter Ronan Farrow to discuss the university's cover-up of funding that had come from convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein; Tye also discusses the US official who reported President Trump's phone call with the president of Ukraine, the Edward Snowden leaks in 2013, and how whistleblowers can protect themselves from criticism and retribution. Plus: Will we always need whistleblowers?
Featuring:
John Napier Tye, founder and CEO of Whistleblower Aid (@wbaidlaw)
Hosts:
Kara Swisher (@karaswisher), Recode co-founder and editor-at-large
More to explore:
Subscribe for free to Pivot, Kara’s podcast with NYU Professor Scott Galloway that offer sharp, unfiltered insights into the biggest stories in tech, business, and politics.
About Recode by Vox:
Recode by Vox helps you understand how tech is changing the world — and changing us.
Follow Us:
Newsletter: Recode Daily
Twitter: @Recode and @voxdotcom
... But enough about us
We are conducting an audience survey to better serve you. It takes no more than five minutes, and it really helps out the show. Please take our survey here.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. This is AMEX Corporate, a single platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Flexible controls for when priorities shift, support around the clock, all backed by American Express, so you can stay focused on what matters most. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:37 Speaker 01 You could try to find the perfect coffee-to-water ratio. Or you could press a button. With Keurig, each K-cup pod is precision-measured for a perfectly delicious cup. No effort, no grind, no math required. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
1:00 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as someone who tried to buy a whistle on Pennsylvania Avenue the other day, but how weird, they're all sold out. But in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today in the red chair is John Napier-Ty, the founder and CEO of the nonprofit law firm Whistleblower Aid. Its clients are all government employees and private sector workers who want to report violations of the law by their employers without breaking the law themselves. John previously worked at the State Department, leading the Internet Freedom Section. John, welcome to Recode Decode.
1:35 Speaker 03 Wonderful, thanks for having me.
1:36 Speaker 02 Thanks for coming. Let me just start, I want you all to explain what you all do at Whistleblower Aid in much more detail. But what's gotten you in the news lately was the MIT situation.
1:46 Speaker 03 That's right.
1:47 Speaker 02 So can you explain what you all did in that? I've written about it in The New York Times, I've talked, I know Joey Ezeo very well. Talk about what happened there, because Ronan Farrow ended up using your material or your whistle.
1:59 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's right. So Ethan Zuckerman.
2:01 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
2:02 Speaker 03 Who was a professor there and is leaving now. He basically got in touch with me. We use, you know, special apps for security and everything. And he said, I have someone I want to send to you. So Signe got in touch and we had-
2:15 Speaker 02 Explain who that was.
2:16 Speaker 03 Signe Swenson is the whistleblower in the MIT case. So she had formerly been a development officer at MIT Media Lab. And she was very uncomfortable with what she saw there, really for several years, especially related to Jeffrey Epstein, some other things as well. And she happened to have a whole stack of emails, basically all of her emails from her time there, where, once you review the emails, it's very clear that there's a deliberate effort to cover up the relationship to Epstein. And some really creepy stuff where they brought Epstein into the lab. So try to picture this. Epstein is inside a glass-paneled room, meeting with Ito and other male professors.
3:01 Speaker 03 And meanwhile, Epstein's air-quote assistants, as they were called, these young Russian women, were outside, dressed like models. And the female staffers are going through the trashcans, looking for notes about whether or not they're there voluntarily, can you help us, kind of thing.
3:17 Speaker 02 Right.
3:18 Speaker 03 That was happening at MIT Media Lab. And Signe, obviously, was not happy.
3:22 Speaker 02 So let's talk a little bit about, I want to go into that case in detail, but let's talk about what you guys do. So what you did is you helped her do this legally.
3:30 Speaker 03 Yep.
3:30 Speaker 02 And it's really important in this internet age with emails and who owns these emails and things like that. I want to get through that. But explain how whistleblower aid started. And you yourself-
3:39 Speaker 03 Yeah, I was a whistleblower.
3:41 Speaker 02 Right.
3:41 Speaker 03 So our motto is, "Report government and corporate lawbreaking without breaking the law." So we're definitely trying to distinguish ourselves from people who do break the law. And really, that's meant to attract more disclosures. You're not going to have high-level intelligence officers come to a group like WikiLeaks.
3:58 Speaker 02 Right.
3:59 Speaker 03 I mean, for obvious reasons. So I worked at the State Department. I was under both Secretary Clinton, Secretary John Kerry. I was in the Internet Freedom, basically, section of the Human Rights Bureau. And was part of all of the open internet initiatives around the Arab Spring and other things, resolutions at the Human Rights Council, and then the Snowden leaks happened. And I was actually not surprised by the Snowden leaks.
4:24 Speaker 02 The Snowden leaks were Edward Snowden, who worked for the NSA.
4:27 Speaker 03 Yeah. And, you know, I had been, for a couple of years at that point, thinking, wow, when is this stuff going to come out? It's so huge. I mean, what the US government is doing is so huge. I wasn't personally read into those programs. I had no need to know.
4:40 Speaker 02 This is Prism and some of the others, which were speaking, they were spying on internet companies and the American people, by extension.
4:47 Speaker 03 Yeah. I would say that they were collaborating with internet companies to spy on the American people.
4:53 Speaker 02 Yes, yes, yes, both, both, both. I think the internet companies despised how much they were spying. That's where they were.
4:59 Speaker 03 Yeah. So the Snowden disclosures happened, and obviously that was front-page news every day for months.
5:04 Speaker 02 Did you think it was going to come out? You weren't read into this, but how were you aware of that?
5:07 Speaker 03 I was, you know, let me say, the intelligence I was reading, I was like, wow, the US government has some serious capabilities here.
5:18 Speaker 02 Right.
5:19 Speaker 03 And so it was pretty clear that we're collecting a lot of stuff.
5:23 Speaker 02 Right.
5:24 Speaker 03 And I would have conversations, kind of after meetings with people, like, you know, trying to get some hints about what was going on. So it was pretty clear, I wasn't surprised.
5:32 Speaker 02 Any intelligent person could see that.
5:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah. So I was part of that diplomatic response, and as you may remember, there was a lot of anger from Germany, from Brazil.
5:43 Speaker 02 Yes, because of emails.
5:44 Speaker 03 From others, you know, hacking Angela Merkel's cellphone, others, I mean, including Human Rights Watch and other groups in Geneva, you know, so there was a vast scale of hacking that we're familiar with.
5:57 Speaker 02 And the State Department's own emails, their assessments of different foreign leaders and different things like that.
6:01 Speaker 03 Yep. So, yeah, so I was part of that response. We dealt with resolutions in the General Assembly at the UN, the Human Rights Council in Geneva, and then I had two briefings with the NSA at a top-secret level. I won't go into those details, obviously, but most of it is now I can talk about.
6:22 Speaker 03 And basically learned that even for the whole year after the Snowden disclosures, there hadn't been a single article about the main legal authority that the NSA is using to collect Americans' data, and that's an executive order called 1233.
6:33 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
6:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, and so it's not a statute, it was never passed by Congress, there's no oversight, basically no oversight from Congress, and Dianne Feinstein said as much, on the record. And so, this is a, basically, the president says, under the Constitution, he has the authority to do this, and they're basically using this loophole where now that we have the cloud and the internet, Americans' data is stored in dozens of countries around the world. Before the internet, it may, there was a geographical boundary distinction between what the NSA could do inside our borders and outside our borders, which made sense, because most Americans' data was inside our borders, it had higher privacy protections.
7:13 Speaker 02 So those are in file cabinets, or wherever they are.
7:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, but now, Americans' data is everywhere. Dozens of countries, all the Google data centers, and that's treated by the NSA as foreign person data by default, because it's stored outside the United States. And so, this is a huge loophole that the NSA is going, collecting, sucking up all this stuff, with some safeguards, I will say, but probably not enough.
7:36 Speaker 02 Right.
7:37 Speaker 03 And then, sharing it with other US intelligence agencies, using it to seed criminal investigations and prosecutions, in a way that I certainly don't think is permissible under the Fourth Amendment.
7:48 Speaker 02 Right, so they're using this because we've become this global communications system, which has been helpful to a lot of people, that our global communications are everywhere, and therefore, they have much more ability to get it, get at it, for lots of reasons.
8:00 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:01 Speaker 02 So this was going on, and what happened to you?
8:03 Speaker 03 So, there were several things. President Obama gave a speech, this would have been early 2014, gave a speech about reforms to intelligence practices. I had worked before that speech to get some changes to the praxis under 1233, which had really gotten lost in the whole shuffle.
8:24 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
8:25 Speaker 03 Failed to do so, there was no mention in that speech, and at that point decided, it's time to become a whistleblower, had no intention of going to prison or fleeing the country, so hired a lawyer. And his name is Mark Said, he's my partner now with whistleblower aide.
8:38 Speaker 02 You're not a lawyer, correct?
8:40 Speaker 03 No, I am, yeah.
8:41 Speaker 02 Oh, you are, okay.
8:42 Speaker 03 Yeah, I'm a lawyer as well.
8:43 Speaker 02 So you hired your own lawyer?
8:44 Speaker 03 I hired my own lawyer. You never represent yourself.
8:46 Speaker 02 No, I know your rule for a client, I know that one. So you did this, and you wanted to whistleblow on what, precisely, this was happening?
8:53 Speaker 03 Well, that the NSA is breaking the Fourth Amendment. It's collecting all of this Americans' data, basically most of what you put on the Internet, not inside the United States, but in these cloud servers around the world. It's not even telling Congress that it's doing this, and it's writing its own rules in secret for how to handle this information, and that's, you know, constitutional law.
9:13 Speaker 02 So tell us what happened.
9:14 Speaker 03 Mark was great. We first met with the inspector general for the State Department.
9:20 Speaker 02 Each agency, just so you know, has an inspector general.
9:23 Speaker 03 Yeah.
9:24 Speaker 02 To look at problems within the departments.
9:27 Speaker 03 And they kind of raised their eyes and said, wow, yeah, this is something, but, you know, we're not the ones running these programs, you know, you need to talk to the NSA inspector general. So in my la-- I was quitting my job for other reasons, I actually loved my time at the State Department, but got another job. And my last week before I quit, I met with State Inspector General, I met with staff from the House and the Senate Intelligence Committees. And then, a couple of weeks later, after I had left government, met with NSA Inspector General staff. And then ended up, so that went well, and then, within a month or so, I had submitted an article for pre-publication review. So the way this works is, whenever you get a security clearance, you have to sign all
10:11 Speaker 03 these NDAs and things, saying, anytime you write about your work, especially if it relates to classified material, you have to submit it for review. They get to, you know, redact things.
10:20 Speaker 02 Same thing with speeches and everything else, which is what got Michael Flynn into one of the many things that got him into trouble.
10:26 Speaker 03 Yeah. Yeah, so that actually went well, and I was able to-- Publish most everything in op-ed in the Washington Post. There's a couple interesting things here. One is, you know, the mechanisms to protect whistleblowers are not sufficient, but they're actually more powerful than many people understand. And what's classified changes from moment to moment, I mean, based on the decisions of senior leadership. I was basically able to get some things declassified through this process that were classified when I started the process. Like, they didn't want to take it to court and have me file a First Amendment lawsuit, so they just declassified it and let me publish it.
11:03 Speaker 02 Right.
11:04 Speaker 03 So I didn't break any laws. I went through the process and showed that this process can be used to push the boundaries of what Americans can learn about how our data is being treated.
11:12 Speaker 02 So, the idea of a whistleblower, this idea is to do whistleblowing in a way, again, that doesn't break the law.
11:19 Speaker 03 Yeah.
11:20 Speaker 02 And to make it clear for people, I know a lot of people who follow it do understand this, it is perfectly legal to whistleblow.
11:27 Speaker 03 Yes.
11:28 Speaker 02 But it's thought of, because of just the word, it's a really interesting and weighted word, as perhaps not, because of what's happened just recently with Ukraine, they're saying this bad whistleblower, like, it's bad to do that. Explain why it isn't.
11:40 Speaker 03 So, I think of it as, there's two concepts, whistleblowing and leaking. These are overlapping circles in a Venn diagram.
11:48 Speaker 02 They are, especially in Washington, right.
11:49 Speaker 03 Yeah. So, blowing the whistle is defined as reporting violation of a law, rule, regulation, ethical violations.
11:56 Speaker 02 Company policy.
11:57 Speaker 03 Even lying in public would be a reason to blow the whistle, right? So, you are reporting some kind of misconduct. Now, that's clearly protected within bounds, and obviously, as you get into classified information, it becomes very, very touchy. But in general, that's not only legal, it's legally protected and valuable. Leaking is sharing information that you are not authorized to share. Now, typically, that's used with respect to classified information, so if you leak classified information, you can and often will go to prison. So, again, these are overlapping circles of the Venn diagram. So you could have someone who is both a whistleblower and a leaker.
12:40 Speaker 03 You could have someone who is a whistleblower but is not a leaker. So if you have unclassified evidence that a US agency or a company is breaking the law, you know, you're not leaking classified information when you come forward with that, right? I mean, Cygni is an example of that. She was a whistleblower without, you know, leaking, doing anything illegal. You could, you could also leak information without being a whistleblower. So, I mean, there are millions, tens of millions of classified documents, classified by the US government, and most of those, some of those probably do show evidence of law breaking by the US government, but probably 99% don't. And if you leak any of those 99%, then you're leaking classified information, you'll go to prison, but you're not actually a whistleblower because you're not showing any kind of misconduct.
13:24 Speaker 02 And then there's just leaking by companies, information or problems within a company or things like that, which is just simply leaking.
13:33 Speaker 03 Yeah, although, yeah, it's not illegal.
13:35 Speaker 02 That's how I do my jobs.
13:36 Speaker 03 It's not typically legal. It's not typically illegal.
13:39 Speaker 02 I'm memo and things like that. I did a lot of them on Uber, a lot of memos, a lot of memos they didn't want out, but I got my hands on them and that's different.
13:46 Speaker 03 And then the lawyers, you know, would want to look at any kind of NDAs that people had signed and try to help avoid any kind of issues there.
13:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, of course, right. So you decide, so you were there and you had this experience, which was good in terms of putting this stuff out for relative.
14:00 Speaker 03 It was, it was good. I mean, a couple of things. First of all, I'm very lucky. I was a lawyer. I knew how to put my concerns into a legal argument. I knew enough to hire a lawyer, actually, and, you know, I had a bunch of friends who were lawyers and just started talking to them and found Mark. I had the money to pay Mark. I mean, one of the things here is until we launched, there's basically no free capacity, legal capacity to help whistleblowers. So we're, we're pretty much it now, which obviously I'm very proud of, very happy with. But I was lucky that I could pay, you know, a lawyer and a lot of people can't because, I mean, I paid $13,000 to two lawyers. And just was able to write that check and not everyone can do that.
14:44 Speaker 02 Right. And so the concept is to allow people with very important concerns about how our government and private companies are behaving to get out without, without being in trouble themselves, which is often the case. Now, a lot of times when people leak, it's also, they also get in different kinds of trouble that aren't necessarily being arrested, but being fired, retribution, all kinds of things. I'm thinking of the Google walkout people who talk publicly about stuff there that several of whom are alleging that Google's come down on. But let's focus on this. So you started Whistleblower Aid and it's funded by who?
15:17 Speaker 03 Well, we, we don't have much money. Honestly, it's been mostly me and my family that's funded it. And we do have some, you know, online donors.
15:27 Speaker 02 So why do you think this is important to do now, then?
15:28 Speaker 03 Well, I, I think like a lot of people have been concerned about protecting a democratic form of governance, small d, protecting the rule of law, worried about accountability. And, and so it just seemed like this was the time. I had been through this myself. I was well positioned to do it. There was a huge need there. Yeah.
15:52 Speaker 02 Okay. We're here with John Napier-Tai. He's the founder and CEO of Whistleblower Aid. When we get back, we're going to talk about some of the cases they've been involved in, including the MIT one. We're going to take a quick break now. We'll be back after this.
17:01 Speaker 02 We're here with John Napier-Tai, the founder and CEO of Whistleblower Aid. It's based in Washington, and it helps whistleblowers legally blow the whistle, essentially. So, talk a little bit, so the case, the MIT case, which you've talked about, is she had emails. She had emails. Why was that not problematic as an employee? You know, I know a lot of tech people, when they download emails, they download any documents, these companies are watching them carefully about what they take and what they don't take. An email, of course, is so full and rich with information these days, because it's the way people communicate. She was concerned and didn't feel she had a way to get it out there, but she had the email trail that proved her case.
17:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, I would start by saying, every case is very context-specific, so I can't, it's hard to make generalizations.
17:52 Speaker 02 Sure.
17:53 Speaker 03 So, some people have signed documents that make it a problem for them to share emails.
17:59 Speaker 02 These are NDA documents.
18:00 Speaker 03 NDA documents, I mean, any kind of security policies for the tech system. I mean, certainly, it would be a mistake to hack into your employer's system without appropriate access. You could definitely be prosecuted for that.
18:11 Speaker 02 Right, but these NDAs are pernicious, as far as I can tell. They're overreaching and pernicious.
18:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, and often unenforceable. And, so, it comes down, as a legal judgment, you explain to the client, "Well, you signed this thing, and you might be violating this thing, but that's up to you to decide, and we can help you if, you know, how you want to do, but there's a good chance that this wasn't a legal binding contract to begin with." You won't ever know until you get to
18:39 Speaker 02 A court.
18:40 Speaker 03 A court, which hopefully doesn't happen. And there's all kinds of things you can do to mitigate it along the way. I mean, especially if you're currently working at a company, showing that you've gone through your chain of command, or other things are sort of laying the groundwork for you to be on stronger ground later on. So, we help people walk through that. For instance, me going to the IGs.
19:03 Speaker 03 I knew that the IGs did not brawl back the NSA's.
19:06 Speaker 02 Yeah.
19:07 Speaker 03 Collection.
19:08 Speaker 02 Really?
19:09 Speaker 03 Yeah.
19:10 Speaker 02 I'm surprised.
19:11 Speaker 03 But we knew that we had to do that so that I was.
19:16 Speaker 02 You showed that you were strong.
19:17 Speaker 03 Yeah, I showed I was doing the right way. And so, you know, that's a lot of what we do for people is we help them walk this path. And everyone is different, but how to insulate themselves from blowback.
19:27 Speaker 02 From blowback. So in this case, let's go over MIT and then I want to go over some of your other cases.
19:31 Speaker 03 Yeah.
19:32 Speaker 02 In MIT's case, she was concerned and she called you.
19:37 Speaker 03 Yeah.
19:38 Speaker 02 And what, talk about that. She had emails. Did she have an NDA?
19:43 Speaker 03 Look, you know, she, there had been policies in effect at the time she worked there, but they were no longer in effect and she, they had still given her access to these emails. They'd never cut it off. So, you know, in that case, there wasn't really an issue.
19:59 Speaker 02 There wasn't an issue. And then when you're getting them, how do you decide where to leak them and how to do that? Because Ronan Farrow, who wrote the story for New Yorker, said he worked with you all in this way.
20:09 Speaker 03 Yeah.
20:10 Speaker 02 So explain that process with a journalist.
20:11 Speaker 03 Well, we would be very careful about thinking about who is the right person to tell this story. I mean, Ronan clearly has a strong track record on this stuff, but there's other stories that aren't necessarily up his alley. And, you know, some of our litigation we'll get to, you know, it's, we just, a couple of weeks ago, won a reprisal case against the CIA. That is significant, it's very significant, actually, but it's not something that Ronan would probably write up.
20:41 Speaker 02 Right. But this one, when you saw this one, when you were talking about, because all these stories are different, I get that, that concept, but in this case, how did you look at it? That this was happening there and needed to get out? In the old days, she might have gone to a reporter directly, for example.
20:55 Speaker 03 Yeah, so I I've been, you know, it it's a pretty tight group. And there's a lot of effort to control the information flow, obviously to protect the clients, to protect the disclosures. So we implement a huge amount of security. We give our clients all special devices that are all specially set up and encrypted and use, et cetera, et cetera. And we had actually gone through that process with Ronan several months ago for a different matter. So Ronan was already on to our secure kind of system, and so that made it easier to talk to him. Yeah.
21:31 Speaker 02 And these secure systems you need to use because because you do, because people are following the track. And obviously Ronan had experience with that with Harvey Weinstein, because he was being investigated by some Israeli group and so he was.
21:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, that was the thing that we worked with him on in his reporting. It'll be in his book coming out next month. Basically, this company, Black Cube, was hired, which is Israeli private intelligence firm, was hired by Harvey Weinstein to go after both the women accusing him of rape and the journalists recording this, including Ronan. And we have helped a former subcontractor of Black Cube become a whistleblower with respect to the Southern District of New York.
22:13 Speaker 02 I'm going to get off on a tangent here, actually. Talk about that, protecting yourself from a technological point of view. Why is it so important? And what do you do today to do that? What are the various methods? I know they're different in different cases.
22:25 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah. So the threat model is is is pretty extreme for us, because especially with some of our CIA clients, I mean, these are current US intelligence officers handling the most top secret things. And so our clients are targeted by Russian intelligence and Chinese intelligence, which means that my communications with my clients will be targeted by those groups. Now, obviously, the rule, they would be operating illegally, but they definitely do it. Then there's, you know, the FBI and the CIA, which run their own counterintelligence investigations. And, you know, there are, there are legal protections in place and I, I wouldn't say they're universally ignored. I would say that a lot of these decisions about who to investigate
23:10 Speaker 03 and which tactics to use happen in secret. There's no, there's never reported to Congress or to a judge. And anyone who's at that level with, with, with such a compartmented clearance, you know, there's, some of these programs have like five people who, who know what's going on, right?
23:25 Speaker 02 Right.
23:25 Speaker 03 And so they can vary. If, if it leaks out, they, they already know who the five people are and they just go search everything they've ever done. So, you know, we have to credibly be able to recommend our systems to people in that position. Now, we don't want them to tell us classified stuff. We don't accept classified information, but to give them legal advice. And even just using an encrypted app or asking a lawyer for advice can be, can be enough to trigger a counterintelligence investigation against intelligence officers.
23:52 Speaker 02 Right. Just even talking to you.
23:53 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:53 Speaker 02 So what, how robust are these systems that, that are, exist commercially for people? Like WhatsApp?
24:00 Speaker 03 So.
24:01 Speaker 02 Encrypted apples, encrypted.
24:02 Speaker 03 The only, the, the only way to reach us, you have to install Tor Browser.
24:06 Speaker 02 Right.
24:07 Speaker 03 And then.
24:07 Speaker 02 That's, explain that, explain that.
24:09 Speaker 03 So, okay.
24:09 Speaker 02 This is a browser that.
24:10 Speaker 03 So, you know, like Internet Explorer, Firefox, or whatever, Chrome. This is a special browser called Tor Browser that was actually initially funded by US government. Now it's a, it's its own nonprofit. And it is a way to access a whole bunch of hidden sites, pejoratively called the dark web.
24:30 Speaker 02 Right.
24:30 Speaker 03 So there's definitely some illegal things that happen on there, but it's also the main, the main tool used by human rights and democracy activists and repressive regimes all over the world.
24:38 Speaker 02 It's a bad name for all the bad stuff.
24:39 Speaker 03 Yeah. So.
24:41 Speaker 02 And it does have bad stuff. Let's be clear.
24:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, there is some bad stuff on there, for sure.
24:45 Speaker 02 People use it for bad reasons.
24:46 Speaker 03 Yeah. But we have a good website on Tor.
24:49 Speaker 02 Okay.
24:50 Speaker 03 Which is, you can basically send us a message at our special site called Secure Drop, created by Freedom of the Press Foundation, which does a great job, or, you know, they, they've managed it. And basically, this is the sort of state-of-the-art online communication security platform. It'll take you five extra minutes compared to sending an email, but it's so much more secure. So that's what we do. That's the only way to reach us. And yeah, I mean, I'm not going to go into the details, but I will say, everyone who works for us has a special device that with special VPNs and special... We've created anonymous numbers and aliases. I mean, it's quite elaborate.
25:28 Speaker 02 Right.
25:29 Speaker 03 There's a 40-page single-spaced security policy you have to sign.
25:31 Speaker 02 Right. What it is, is you create different... It can be anything from going to China and buying an Android device and then never signing on to anything and then throwing it out afterwards to using WhatsApp, to using Signal, to using...
25:44 Speaker 03 We recommend Signal is what we use.
25:45 Speaker 02 Yeah. What's the other one? I'm probably blanking. Signal? The other one's owned by countries I'm like nervous about. I forget.
25:51 Speaker 03 I think you're thinking of Telegram. I wouldn't use that.
25:53 Speaker 02 Telegram, yeah, exactly. It's from Russia. And then, obviously, there's VPNs, which are... Which we can protect your browsing or whatever you're doing. Again, lots of them are owned by questionable companies.
26:04 Speaker 03 Yeah.
26:05 Speaker 02 Which ones do you recommend?
26:07 Speaker 03 We recommend Malvad VPN.
26:08 Speaker 02 Malvad?
26:09 Speaker 03 Yeah.
26:10 Speaker 02 I don't know that one. Wow. There's a couple. And again, this is a way to mask your movement on the Internet, which is becoming increasingly difficult.
26:19 Speaker 03 Yeah. And we do a lot in person. Like, we have air-gapped machines and printers that we use to create documents, and then we only print them on the air-gapped printer, so it... There's no way for that data to hit the Internet and get stolen.
26:36 Speaker 02 Right.
26:37 Speaker 03 And then we have a burn bucket, and we burn up all the papers.
26:38 Speaker 02 Right, right.
26:39 Speaker 03 Like, once a week.
26:40 Speaker 02 Right. So, paperwork.
26:42 Speaker 03 Yeah.
26:43 Speaker 02 Or you eat it, or something like that.
26:44 Speaker 03 Yeah.
26:45 Speaker 02 So, there's all these... Because what has happened is, we've been introduced to a lot of technological wonders that let us communicate, but they track us everywhere we go. And I think people don't realize how tracked and censored and camered this whole country is. We'll get into that. Not just this country. I mean, obviously, China, we talk about all the time, but this country is the same thing. And so each of these whistleblowers get in touch with you in these various technological ways to protect from the internet. Talk a little bit about some of the other cases. You had the MIT case, which she was giving emails, which she had rights to, I guess, or they had let her.
27:16 Speaker 03 Yeah.
27:17 Speaker 02 And then released it to a reporter, very traditional. The guy got fired.
27:20 Speaker 03 And had to resign from the New York Times and MacArthur Foundation.
27:25 Speaker 02 Yes, exactly. Exactly. And the president of MIT is under a lot of pressure also, because more emails have come to pass that they knew about it. Of course, everyone, they always know about it. So, not always, but it's a shocking amount how much they knew about it before stuff. Talk about some other cases, some key cases that you would think are really important.
27:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, so our very first case was two CIA officers, Andrew Bakai and Jonathan Kaplan, whose names are in public now, been reported. They had evidence that the presidential nominee in the Senate for the inspector general of the CIA, a guy named Christopher Sharpley, had been committing, investigating misconduct, lying to Congress, retaliating against people, other things. So after that came out, Sharpley had to resign, his nomination, and he had been acting, he left as acting. We just, last week, for Andrew, won a formal ruling that the CIA had committed unlawful reprisal against him. So we're obviously very proud of that.
28:26 Speaker 02 Yes, right here.
28:27 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:28 Speaker 02 So what happens is sometimes when people whistleblow, they may have a great victory, but then what comes next is critically important.
28:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah.
28:35 Speaker 02 And in this case, they were trying to push him out. But if you're in the CIA and you suddenly whistleblow on people...
28:41 Speaker 03 Yeah, and it was a classic thing where they accused him of fake security violations.
28:46 Speaker 02 Right.
28:47 Speaker 03 So because the executive branch has basically unilateral authority on security clearances and security matters, they just say, oh, they come up with a pretextual reason and said, oh, his clearance is suspended, we can't trust him. And then he couldn't work, so he was on leave for months, maybe a year, and then finally just quit and started his own law firm, so.
29:07 Speaker 02 So now you won this reprisal case.
29:10 Speaker 03 Yeah.
29:10 Speaker 02 And where does it go from here for him? He unveiled this, this person didn't get?
29:14 Speaker 03 We're gonna keep pushing and, you know, see what kind of result we can get from the CIA. He's gone on to an illustrious career, actually. He's now the lead lawyer for the intelligence whistleblower you've been reading about in the New York Times.
29:28 Speaker 02 Right, and then, give me another example of case, this Homeland Agency security? Or the Department of Housing?
29:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, yeah, okay, a few things. Department of Homeland Security, there's a presidential nominee in the Senate right now named William Bryan. Bryan is currently acting undersecretary at DHS. He had been at Department of Energy, and while he was there, he was the point person for energy policy towards the country of Ukraine. This was back in 2013, 14, 15. One of his colleagues who became our client, basically was really upset and freaked out that it seemed like he was not pursuing American interests, that he was basically cultivating relationships with oligarchs and their staff to advance his private energy consulting business.
30:19 Speaker 03 He wrote a report that validated this coal monopoly by this guy Rinat Akhmatov in Ukraine. So, my client, Bob Ivey, came to me, maybe a year ago, over, just over a year ago, and we filed a couple of, you know, we filed a disclosure with the US Office of Special Counsel and a reprisal complaint. And so just last week, that, the US Office of Special Counsel referred that disclosure to Secretary Perry, Secretary of Energy, for further investigation, saying that they had found a significant likelihood of misconduct by Bryan.
31:00 Speaker 03 So, we're obviously hoping he is not confirmed, and that he is forced out of government, because he should be, and we are well along the way of getting a good job result for our client, who's still at DOE.
31:14 Speaker 02 And so he has to be there at the same time that this is all happening?
31:17 Speaker 03 Yeah, he's there, yeah, he's there, yeah.
31:19 Speaker 02 Okay.
31:19 Speaker 03 But he's, we're finding a good niche for him, so.
31:21 Speaker 02 So it's the ability for someone to point out, this is, they're saying there's substantial likelihood that this, he's correct, right?
31:29 Speaker 03 Yeah.
31:29 Speaker 02 Essentially, and then the next step for this is what?
31:33 Speaker 03 Well, obviously, we're all concerned about stopping the nomination of William Bryan to serve in this position of trust. I would say that's the main thing, because we're very close to signing a favorable settlement on Bob's job.
31:48 Speaker 02 But the goal is to get the bad actor out. That's what the goal of every whistleblower is. All right, talk about this housing agency chief.
31:57 Speaker 03 Okay. Our client, Simone Grimes, is a wonderful person. She had evidence that the former head of the Federal Housing Finance Agency, a guy named Mel Watt, who had been a Democratic congressman, committed both pay discrimination and pretty egregious sexual harassment. She had him on tape saying things like, "Let's discuss our sexual attraction." I'm paraphrasing here, so don't quote me, but things like, "Let's discuss our sexual attraction alone at my vacation house this weekend."
32:27 Speaker 02 Yeah.
32:28 Speaker 03 That kind of thing.
32:29 Speaker 02 That's a line.
32:30 Speaker 03 And her pay discrimination complaint was contingent on that discussion, kind of thing. So, pretty egregious. The reason most people haven't heard of it is there was actually an eight-hour hearing in the House of Representatives last year. But the reason, and in most worlds, that would probably be a front-page news story. This is Senate confirmed officials saying these things on tape. That hearing was literally simultaneous with the Kavanaugh hearing happening on the other side of the Capitol Building. So, obviously, the media covered that.
33:02 Speaker 02 Lucky Mel Watt.
33:03 Speaker 03 Yeah, lucky Mel Watt. This story didn't get nearly the coverage it deserved for that reason. I won't speak out of turn here, but I will say that we did a lot of advocacy for Simone. We even had a billboard, a mobile billboard on the back of a flatbed truck driving in circles around the FHFA office for like, three or four weeks, saying, basically saying, "Fire Mel Watt."
33:27 Speaker 02 Right, exactly. And so, these are all different. You pointed out, these are all very differences. When we get back, I want to talk a little bit about where whistleblowing is going in the modern age. Obviously, you have to protect the whistleblowers, but at the same time, the massive amount of email, the massive amount of texts, the massive amount of things, does create an opportunity and a problem at the same time. I'm thinking of what's happening with the Ukraine this week, and I want to get into that. And then also, a lot of these companies, the amount of information they have on people and who should protect this, so that people are able to do these things in a way that's legal. We're here with John Napier-Tai. He's the founder and CEO of Whistleblower Aid. We're going to take a quick break now, and we'll be right back.
34:07 Speaker 04 It's me, the
34:12 Speaker 04 We don't need the jingle twice.
34:15 Speaker 04 Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights, and rental cars.
34:24 Speaker 04 Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app.
34:30 Speaker 04 Fine. No one deals more deals than Please stop. Touche. Priceline.
34:38 Speaker 05 How about a latte?
34:39 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
34:40 Speaker 05 Vanilla?
34:40 Speaker 01 Caramel?
34:41 Speaker 05 Blueberry?
34:42 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor, or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup Pod varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee. No effort, no grind, no settlement.
34:59 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
35:04 Speaker 02 We're here with John Napier-Tai. He's a lawyer and a former State Department official, who is the founder and CEO of Whistleblower Aid, which helps whistleblowers of all kinds whistleblow legally. So let's first talk about what's happening this week in the Ukraine. This is a whistleblower.
35:19 Speaker 03 It is.
35:19 Speaker 02 So explain for the people what's happening.
35:23 Speaker 03 Well, my colleagues at Whistleblower Aid, two members of our legal team, are this person's lawyers.
35:29 Speaker 02 That's right.
35:29 Speaker 03 Andrew Bakai and Mark Sade.
35:34 Speaker 03 Broadly speaking, a US official, I can't really go into details. A US official had what they considered an urgent concern, which is a legal term of art, that related to communications with a foreign government, and brought that concern to the inspector general of the intelligence
35:56 Speaker 02 Which is the first step, right.
35:58 Speaker 03 It can be the first step. It's not necessary. There's actually a lot of options, but it's a typical first step. That inspector general found that this met the legal standard to be a, quote, "urgent concern." But nevertheless...
36:13 Speaker 03 The Director of National Intelligence refused to turn that urgent concern over to Congress.
36:18 Speaker 02 Which is supposed to go to Congress.
36:19 Speaker 03 Yes, yeah.
36:20 Speaker 02 So it had previously.
36:22 Speaker 03 Well, it's a confusing situation. There's basically some imperfections or ambiguities in the law here where if the IG had found it was not an urgent concern, then the whistleblower would have a clear path to go to Congress.
36:39 Speaker 02 I see.
36:40 Speaker 03 But it was never contemplated by the people who wrote the statute that something that did constitute an urgent concern would not be permitted to go to Congress.
36:48 Speaker 02 Right.
36:49 Speaker 03 And that's where we find ourselves today.
36:51 Speaker 02 They love to slip through these laws, don't they?
36:53 Speaker 03 Yeah.
36:54 Speaker 02 So you're representing him and what?
36:55 Speaker 03 I am not representing him. My colleagues.
36:57 Speaker 02 Your colleagues are.
36:58 Speaker 03 Yeah.
36:59 Speaker 02 So right now, since you cannot talk about this, is what's been reported and the President has said it, is that first he pretended he knew the whistleblower, which he hopefully does not know who that is, but that he was a Democrat at some point, all kinds of things, making, trying to fudge the situation really expertly, which is, they do very well. But basically, he said he did have this conversation, has to do with the Ukraine again, and that he had, he's essentially admitted, and his lawyer has admitted, that they were trying to get the Ukraine to investigate Joe Biden, his political rival. There's some allegations that they withheld aid because of that to the Ukraine in order to do something for private political impact that would aid President Trump. At the very same time, I just did an interview with the head of the FEC, the Federal Election
37:44 Speaker 02 Commission. There's no way to pursue this because there's not a core at the Federal Election Commission. So it's kind of a perfect storm of possible corruption, alleged corruption. So what happens now with this whistleblower? What occurs? Is this a standoff between essentially the White House and Congress again?
38:04 Speaker 02 You're choosing your words carefully.
38:05 Speaker 03 Well, I can't really talk about this case, I'm sorry.
38:08 Speaker 02 All right, okay.
38:08 Speaker 03 Yeah.
38:09 Speaker 02 Talk about the, but this idea is that people continue to whistleblow in these...
38:14 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, so, one of the sort of hypotheses when we started whistleblower aid is that sort of the way that the world is moving, the structure of government and economies is whistleblowers are becoming systematically more important every day that goes by.
38:32 Speaker 02 Right.
38:33 Speaker 03 And the reason for that is, is that, you know, 50 years ago, if you think about the biggest threats to, you know, democracy and governance, it was things like segregation or, you know, like things where there's clear laws on the books and everyone knows what these laws are and we need to overthrow, you know, overturn these laws. So much of the threats, you know, threats to democracy today are hidden and covert and it's about the control of information, the misuse of information, and that's true, obviously, in all these tech companies, all these government agencies. And so, as that happens, as threats to democracy are contingent on the control of information, the value of whistleblowers is going up every single day.
39:13 Speaker 02 Right.
39:14 Speaker 03 And the threats to whistleblowers for retaliation and for people to find out who they are. So, you know, I would say we, we are trying to fill that gap and there is, I would say we're only scratching the surface. You know, there are so, there are a lot of cases that we've gotten in and that we've just had to say no on because we don't have enough people and lawyers and stuff. My point is that the demand for this is, if you look nationally and globally, it's basically infinite.
39:42 Speaker 02 Right, infinite.
39:43 Speaker 03 Yeah. I mean, think of all of the, here's, when we have the money and the staff, I want to expand into things like criminal justice. I was a legal aid lawyer in Louisiana. You know, there's staff in those police forces in New Orleans and those parishes down there, the district attorneys, who have a lot of evidence that these law enforcement officers are breaking the law, railroading innocent people, whatever it is. And they should, we should represent those people and start disbaring these lawyers. I mean...
40:15 Speaker 02 So talking about that idea that here, there's never been a bigger need because the information is covert and the ability to track these people has never been stronger. And at the same time, the ability for whistleblowers to have their, the people that are whistleblowing on their behavior tracked is also never been better. Everyone's in emails. I'm thinking of like, I was talking this morning because some of the governments, the government is investing, different governments are investing all the tech companies. And the only thing I'm thinking about is, oh, the emails. Like, you know, it's the Hillary Clinton joke, but boy, are there going to be a lot of, is there going to be a lot of good evidence that will be, look bad.
40:53 Speaker 03 Yeah.
40:54 Speaker 02 If correctly assembled.
40:55 Speaker 03 Yeah. I mean, that's, so when whistleblowers come and ask me for advice, my first piece of advice is always talk to a lawyer first before you do anything else. But then the very second piece of advice is secure the evidence. And typically, that's not forwarding emails to journalists, it's printing them off because you don't want to create a record of forwarding to anyone.
41:14 Speaker 02 Right, right.
41:15 Speaker 03 Or even on a secure device, it's difficult. You wouldn't do this for classified information, but you know, you can take photos with your secure device of the screen so that there's no evidence even of printing.
41:27 Speaker 02 Right.
41:28 Speaker 03 You know, things like that. So you're looking to preserve the evidence without creating a trail that leads back to you.
41:35 Speaker 02 Right. And talk about the secure device. I always tell people to take a picture of it, but not on a phone that's attached to the internet, or just a camera.
41:42 Speaker 03 I would buy a new phone.
41:43 Speaker 02 Right.
41:44 Speaker 03 Or an iPod, actually. But the iPod is cheap and small and it has, you know, it doesn't connect to 4G, 3G, but it connects to Wi-Fi, so.
41:51 Speaker 02 Right, so you can then be able to send it, or keep it, or move it somewhere else.
41:55 Speaker 03 Yeah. Get a new, don't use your personal device.
41:58 Speaker 02 Right.
41:59 Speaker 03 Definitely not a work device for any of this.
42:01 Speaker 02 Right, no. People do use work devices. I was always fascinated when they would send me memos, like, don't do that. Just a picture of it's fine, and on a device that isn't owned by your company, and possibly a camera. Just send me a camera picture at this number and stuff like that. So, but there's never been more information available at the same time because the government and these companies are generating enormous amounts of proof of behavior.
42:26 Speaker 02 I mean, like, look at MIT. I mean, this is astonishing. I couldn't believe those emails, that they didn't know that they could possibly be discovered at some point or downloaded by people.
42:35 Speaker 03 Don't send emails that you don't want in The New Yorker.
42:40 Speaker 02 Were you surprised by those emails? I was like, wow, you don't even have to try to prove what they're doing. They gave them nicknames, they didn't.
42:47 Speaker 03 Yeah. You know, I'm not especially surprised. I mean, you know, it seems pretty straightforward. They wanted Epstein's money, they didn't want to associate with him.
42:59 Speaker 02 Right. It was astonishing. And then the second part is this Melwatt thing, is the recordings. Look at what happened to Roger Ailes, look at what happened to...
43:05 Speaker 03 Yeah.
43:06 Speaker 02 How do you treat those? Because anyone with a cellphone...
43:09 Speaker 03 Well, again, it's very sensitive. I mean, again, talk to a lawyer before you do anything, because in some states, it's illegal to record someone without their knowledge and consent. So, like, we don't want to get people in trouble here, and, you know, so that's why the advice is always, talk to a lawyer first.
43:26 Speaker 02 But in general, people just are doing it, in any case, correct? And then releasing it, or having it in their back pocket, or something else?
43:34 Speaker 03 Yeah. I mean, this is the world.
43:39 Speaker 02 This is the world.
43:40 Speaker 03 And, you know, I will, let me say, I'll be interested to see, as the Epstein story develops, what kind of evidence Epstein was collecting on his friends.
43:50 Speaker 02 Oh, absolutely. I'm just, I'm waiting for that shoe to drop. I'm hoping people with subpoena power can get that.
43:56 Speaker 03 I obviously don't have any personal knowledge.
43:58 Speaker 02 No, but you'd have to assume that this was, this is the thing. So, you've got cameras, you've got, you've got to make sure that when you're taking pictures or doing else, that you're doing it legally, correct? Or not within a state, or taping someone. Although, sometimes it hardly matters if you can use it for leverage, obviously.
44:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, you don't want to also blackmail people into doing what you want either.
44:20 Speaker 02 No, not blackmail. I mean, it's. No, just have it.
44:21 Speaker 03 Yeah, again, the only thing I can say, the only piece of advice you won't regret is talking to a lawyer. If you start taking, if you walk into your work and start taking pictures of sensitive things, you could get in trouble, you could get sued. Depending on what it is, you could be prosecuted, so.
44:36 Speaker 02 Can I ask you, what states are looser on this kind of stuff? California would be my guess, or?
44:41 Speaker 03 You know, I don't know, although I do know that Massachusetts is a one-party state.
44:48 Speaker 02 Meaning?
44:49 Speaker 03 Excuse me, excuse me, I got it wrong. Massachusetts is a two-party state. Both parties have to consent to a recording, whereas D.C. is a one-party jurisdiction.
44:58 Speaker 02 Right, and New York, I think, is a one-party.
45:00 Speaker 03 Not sure.
45:01 Speaker 02 From what I understand. So that's one, that's taping. The other is photographs. The other is sensors, people following you around and knowing where you are. When you have your whistleblowers, it's got to be a concern.
45:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, we've met with former, you know, intelligence officers to train us on how to have meetings without being followed and all the rest of it.
45:23 Speaker 02 So how do you do that?
45:25 Speaker 03 Don't bring any devices with you.
45:26 Speaker 02 Yeah.
45:27 Speaker 03 Take multiple forms of transportation, learn to look around without looking like you're looking around.
45:32 Speaker 02 So the old school.
45:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, the old school.
45:35 Speaker 02 It's so funny, I just had an interview with an election official, they're like, "Paper, paper is the technology of the future."
45:41 Speaker 03 Yeah.
45:41 Speaker 02 So not having these. So can we finish up talking sort of about the impact of tech on all of this? Because, again, as I said, in one, some ways it makes your job easier, and others, it creates a situation where whistleblowers have never been more at risk.
45:54 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, yeah, technology, I mean, you have made a wonderful career out of this. There are so many different implications in every aspect of our lives. You know, it does typically create a stronger chain of evidence for misconduct. So that's, I mean, that's the first insight. And it, you know, as I advise clients on how to avoid retaliation, we are obviously thinking about the technological angle and how these technologies could be creating a trail to the client that we want to avoid.
46:32 Speaker 02 So going through, to finish up, if you're going to be a whistleblower, the things you need to do are?
46:39 Speaker 03 Talk to a lawyer.
46:40 Speaker 02 Talk to a lawyer.
46:41 Speaker 03 Secure the evidence, ideally either print it off or buy a new device and take photos. But again, I don't want to give blanket advice.
46:48 Speaker 02 Sure.
46:48 Speaker 03 You wouldn't do that with, in a skiff.
46:50 Speaker 02 No.
46:50 Speaker 03 With classified information.
46:51 Speaker 02 Of course not, no.
46:52 Speaker 03 And then use clean new devices unrelated to you bought in cash and use the Signal app.
46:59 Speaker 02 And then go through the systems that you work in, like an inspector general system.
47:06 Speaker 03 Again, yeah, I mean, that would typically be a way that we would, an option we'd consider. But, you know, every case is different and some clients really want to put their name on things. Others really don't. I mean, we have a State Department client who we use, whose identity we have kept secret, who had evidence, you know, that Secretary, former Secretary Rex Tillerson had violated the Child Soldiers Protection Act and reclassify, basically unclassified Burma and Iraq and Afghanistan is not using child soldiers, even though they were. And we were able to keep this person's identity a secret, basically because of how we did it. We were smart. We were like, well, we filed it with the IG, we went to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, and then they, they're the ones who shared it with the reporter.
47:51 Speaker 03 So it was, it was never directly from the client.
47:53 Speaker 02 I see. So in this modern age, when we're thinking about what a whistleblower is, do you, you're saying there never been more important, correct?
48:02 Speaker 03 That's my view.
48:03 Speaker 02 That they've never been more important.
48:06 Speaker 02 Will that change? Is there any system that you can imagine where AI or technology could monitor misbehavior in a better way than having to rely on the bravery of people coming forward where their jobs are at risk? And then, secondly, when you're thinking about the concept of retaliation, protecting and proving that people are being retaliating. And so I'm thinking of like tech, right now, Google, for example, the walkout, people feel like they're under retaliation, but it's often never provable. Do you imagine technology being able to do that someday or not at all? It just relies on people?
48:41 Speaker 03 Well, the idea of AI monitoring everyone for misconduct is a little creepy to me.
48:49 Speaker 03 So, you know, I would say I'm a sort of techno skeptic on a lot of these things. We obviously use it, but I, I wouldn't say I'm a huge fan of. More surveillance. So, you know, I think this is a, it's a cat and mouse game. People are going to try to commit misconduct if they think they can get away with it and it'll help them. And then other people will try to uncover that. I mean, this is sort of a universal human theme here. Obviously, it is changing with technology, but I don't think, I mean, anyone who writes the AI systems will know the workarounds and the hacks.
49:26 Speaker 02 Right, exactly. And do you, do you imagine people are getting braver, that they feel that when things are gone awry, they want to say, see something, say something?
49:36 Speaker 03 You know, we've seen a real renaissance of whistleblowing over the last 10 years, and it started, you know, so people like Chelsea Manning and Edward Snowden have, I would say, a contested legacy, and some people hate them and some people love them. But certainly, they've brought it more into the public eye and made people realize that this is a crucial way for holding the government and these corporations accountable. So, yeah, I think, I would say I'm seeing, certainly, we're seeing an uptick in inquiries. And then the question is, can we bring these disclosures to light without letting these people get hurt?
50:14 Speaker 02 And last question, one of the big things in Silicon Valley is NDAs. People have them all over the place. Should you not sign an NDA?
50:21 Speaker 03 Talk to a lawyer. I mean, every case is different. I can't give you advice. And a lot of companies just won't hire you if you don't sign it. So, you know, but it's unclear whether it's enforceable, so.
50:33 Speaker 02 Did you have a point of view on them?
50:34 Speaker 03 There is, you know, this gets actually back to our sort of philosophy here. I mean, unlike WikiLeaks, we do agree that the government, there is a legitimate scope of secrecy for US government, at least some secrets, right? And so, we're not 100% transparency, declassify everything, publish everything. No, like some things, you know, there were human rights activists named in some of the Manning cables who had to leave their countries and come to the United States and leave their family.
51:01 Speaker 02 Yeah.
51:02 Speaker 03 Their careers behind.
51:02 Speaker 02 It can be indiscriminate.
51:03 Speaker 03 Yeah, and so there are real privacy costs to mass leaks that we recognize, and that makes every case complicated and different. There can be a place for secrecy for certain types of secrets, especially protecting, you know, people's privacy. But figuring out where to draw that line, I would say, is what the whole society is struggling with that.
51:24 Speaker 02 Absolutely. Wait till we get censored, each of us.
51:27 Speaker 03 Oh, God.
51:29 Speaker 02 I know, right? Anyway, John, thank you for doing the work you do. But one of the key things is get a lawyer. Get a lawyer, right?
51:35 Speaker 03 Yes.
51:35 Speaker 02 Get a lawyer. Anyway, John, thanks for coming on the show. You can follow me on Twitter at Kara Swisher. My executive producer, Erica Anderson, is at Erica America. My producer, Eric Johnson, is at HeyHeyESJ. John, where can people find you and whistleblower aid online?
51:48 Speaker 03 Whistlebloweraid.org and on Twitter at WBAIDLaw. WBAIDLaw.
51:56 Speaker 02 Yeah, and you can read some of their cases. Their most prominent one recently has been the situation at MIT where they got a whistleblower to work with a journalist and had quite a lot of results for that. If you liked this episode, we'd really appreciate it if you shared it with a friend. And make sure to check out our other podcasts, Recode Media, Pivot, and Land of the Giants. Just search for them in your podcasting app of choice. Thanks also to our editor, Joel Robby. Thanks for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. I'll be back here on Friday. Tune in then.
53:03 Speaker 06 20th Century Studios presents Whale Fall. The most incredible survival thriller of the year. I need the whale, help me! In theaters Friday. To survive the unthinkable, do the impossible. You're gonna become so dangerous that the predators can't help but let you go. Austin Abrams. I'm going home! Josh Brodel. Survivor, survivor. Whale Fall. Rated PG-13. Maybe inappropriate for children under 13. In theaters Friday. Get tickets now.
Previous Recode Decode: Hermitage Capital CEO Bill Browder Next Recode Decode: Senator Mark Warner Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated