Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Twitter legal boss Vijaya Gadde About this episode Twitter general counsel Vijaya Gadde talks about social media and the law, Walt Mossberg and Kara go back and forth on Apple's fall lineup and Kara gives the ABCs of aging in Silicon Valley.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Today's sponsor is Audible.com, which has more than 180,000 audiobooks and spoken word audio products. Get a free audiobook of your choice at audible.com/decode.
0:13 Speaker 01 Recode Radio presents Recode Decode, hosted by Kara Swisher.
0:17 Speaker 00 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, Executive Editor of Recode, and you're listening to Recode Decode. You may know me as the Women's Issues Advisor to the Donald Trump campaign, but in my spare time, I also do some tech reporting. The tech industry is strange, just like the Donald, and it is everywhere, just like Trump. But here, we talk about what makes tech so weird, interesting, and important. We leave Donald Trump to the rest of America. Today's guest in the red chair is Twitter's top lawyer, Vijaya Gadi. Gadi has battled in courtrooms across the globe to keep Twitter online, leading one of Silicon Valley's most impressive legal teams. She is also deeply involved in Twitter's efforts to crack down on online harassment,
1:00 Speaker 00 and she helped roll out some of the service's major safety changes from this spring. Welcome, Vijaya.
1:06 Speaker 02 Thank you, Kara.
1:07 Speaker 00 Thanks for coming. There's a lot going on at Twitter. Just at the top, we're not going to be talking about the CEO search, correct? And you're not the CEO today, correct?
1:14 Speaker 02 That is correct. And I'm the person who always tells everyone they can't comment on this.
1:17 Speaker 00 Yes, the lawyer. That's what I figured. I'm not going to get a thing out of you. Let me just tell you, lawyers are tough. Some lawyers are tough, not all of them, but I know you are. But let's talk about tough. Like, you just, we're going to talk about a range of things. Online harassment, all kinds of things. And Twitter's been very much out front around the NSA and things like that. But let's talk about the transparency report that just came out, which you were involved in. So give us, we're going to talk a little bit about your history in a second, but let's talk about the news, what you guys released this week.
1:42 Speaker 02 Sure. What we released is our biannual transparency report, and we started this process back in 2012. I believe this is our seventh transparency report. And the information we put in there is all about the requests that we get from governments to either access information about our users, who they are, or asking us to take content down off of the platform for various reasons. And we go into a lot of detail in that report because we think it's an important public service, not necessarily for every individual. But in terms of the landscape of the Internet and how governments are relating to what's going on.
2:15 Speaker 00 And how do you assess it? Talk about this year's things and why you think it's important. I mean, obviously Twitter's been much further out there than others and much more opposing these government requests and has been stronger in that area. Why has Twitter been like that, first of all, which is laudable because some of the bigger companies have a lot more legal firepower, money to spend on it. And then, secondly, what's unusual this year as compared to other years?
2:38 Speaker 02 Actually, to kick off on a last point, I don't think there's anything unusual this year. I think what you're seeing is a steady increase in how the government is attempting to either shut down particular conversations or access information about users. So that's been a consistent theme and what this year's report shows is that that's only increasing in scope. This really started for us as a company very early on. We've had this philosophy or core belief about protecting and defending our users' voice and that's what we're showing in the transparency report. And that started very early on with our founders, Jack and Ev, as well as our first general counsel, Alexander McGillery, AMAC as he's known. And they have this strong belief in fighting for these rights for our users because that
3:21 Speaker 02 is what's powering the platform at the end of the day, is the ability to speak out.
3:24 Speaker 00 So why is the government increasing? What are they looking for? What is, from your perspective?
3:28 Speaker 02 I think the government is increasing, one, because they're catching up to technology. They're understanding that more and more people are using technology and that they need to keep up and understand what's being said and that's part of what's going on around the world. You see countries actually increasing over time. So it's this constant pace of technology and the governments are catching up to it.
3:47 Speaker 00 Where do they cross the line? I mean, is there, is any requests? Is there an argument to be made for? I mean, I interviewed President Obama last year and he was saying, "Look, the first plane that goes down because of an email I don't have is, I don't know what to say. We have to have these abilities."
3:59 Speaker 02 This is an incredibly complicated area, obviously. We cooperate with law enforcement as long as they're following the proper legal process. But even in our report, you can see that we do push back on certain types of requests and it's not because we're not wanting to be cooperative or not for any other reason. It is because we want to make sure that we're upholding the same standards of due process and civil rights across the platform.
4:20 Speaker 00 What do you push back on?
4:21 Speaker 02 We push back on over broad requests. We'll push back on things that haven't followed the proper process, a subpoena versus a warrant in some cases. So it depends on the case. It's really hard to be very specific. But we push back in all sorts of cases. We push back because we often want to give the user himself or herself the notice that the government is requesting their information. And oftentimes, the government doesn't want us to do that. A really famous case of this was back during Occupy Wall Street. Malcolm Harris was one of the many protesters, and the New York District Attorney wanted information about Harris, a lot of information. And they didn't, in our opinion, follow through on the right process, a search warrant. Rather, they issued a subpoena, which doesn't go through the
5:04 Speaker 02 same process. And we tried to fight. We tried to push back. We wanted Harris to be able to fight, to be able to protect his information. And the government did not let him fight. And we tried to fight, but we were eventually forced to turn over that information.
5:18 Speaker 00 And in terms, in doing the fight, is it a pointless fight? Or do you feel like, you know, you're a lawyer, and obviously, you know, you watch TV shows where lawyers are always fighting for justice. And sometimes, they're not.
5:27 Speaker 02 Don't believe everything you see.
5:28 Speaker 00 No, I don't believe anything. I know. But I still like How to Get Away with Murder. You're not going to stop me from.
5:32 Speaker 02 Okay, great. I also watch legal shows. So even though I know that they're not.
5:36 Speaker 00 She's a couple crazy on that show. I highly recommend it, by the way.
5:38 Speaker 02 I don't think we take pointless fights. I think we take fights, or we stand up and push back, where we think that there's an important principle involved. So we're not going to win every single one of them. We have a case against the US government, the Department of Justice, and the FBI right now, around our transparency report, to be able to share more information about national security.
5:57 Speaker 00 And explain that. What do you want to do that they don't want you to do?
6:00 Speaker 02 We want to be very granular about our disclosure, in terms of the types of requests we're seeing from the government, whether they're national security requests or other types of requests. And right now, that information may be only disclosed in a certain aggregate forms, and we want to be incredibly granular.
6:13 Speaker 00 And why are they opposing that? I mean, they spend all this time on Hillary Clinton's email, you know, and they just let her write emails from any old account. And here, they're being very particular. Is it just that they're overly broad, or do they?
6:24 Speaker 02 Well, they think the formats that they've agreed to are sufficient for disclosure purposes. You should really talk to them. And they believe that there's some security benefit in not disclosing how and when, what types of requests they're making for service providers.
6:41 Speaker 00 What's the overall trend here in the United States versus the world? I mean, where are there more egregious examples? Is the US egregious?
6:47 Speaker 02 In terms of numbers, the US is the most, but we're also a US company.
6:51 Speaker 00 Both state and local and federal?
6:53 Speaker 02 Yes, all of that. So we've received most of our requests from the US, but we're a US company. We're used here. We have a lot of users here. So it's not surprising that we would get more requests from the US government. But you're seeing a slow uptick around the world, I'd say.
7:08 Speaker 00 And where, for what countries, for example, are being particularly aggressive?
7:12 Speaker 02 Well, it's funny, because you can look at our report, and you can see where the sharpest increase is. And it can be around political events or elections. So it's very dependent, you know, quarter to quarter or year to year. You know, recently, we've obviously seen a lot of reports from Turkey.
7:30 Speaker 00 Right.
7:30 Speaker 02 And you can see a lot of disclosure.
7:32 Speaker 00 Or you are not beloved. Twitter is not beloved. Well, by some people, they're beloved.
7:35 Speaker 02 I think that we're used, very importantly, in the country, and I think that's what's important to us.
7:41 Speaker 00 And what is the government doing there? Can you explain what happened in Turkey?
7:44 Speaker 02 Well, about a year ago, I guess last March, we were blocked for a short period of time.
7:49 Speaker 00 By the president, is that right?
7:51 Speaker 02 By the government, by the courts.
7:53 Speaker 00 Right.
7:54 Speaker 02 Because there were a number of tweets with some allegations of political corruption that we felt were important, and we weren't in a position to take down.
8:07 Speaker 00 Take down.
8:07 Speaker 02 Because of the system, the process, et cetera, that happened. And we eventually got a lot of support from Turkish citizens and civil rights groups, and they actually filed a constitutional case as well as ours. And the constitutional court ruled that it was basically unconstitutional under Turkish law for the government to block us for this. It was an extreme measure. And so we've been in an ongoing dialogue with the government, and we put Back in a lot of court orders, some of which are overturned, not as many as we'd like, but we've also complied with a number of court orders there in keeping with Turkish law.
8:42 Speaker 00 What about in China? What about there? You don't operate in China, but you have Chinese citizens using.
8:46 Speaker 02 We are currently blocked in China. That being said, I believe there are probably some citizens who have access to the platform just based on what I've seen through other mechanisms.
8:55 Speaker 00 So that's How do you move into a country like that? Or is that just, forget it, we're not going in there?
8:59 Speaker 02 Well, you've seen companies like LinkedIn who've been able to do it. But they've made a fair number of compromises to be able to do so.
9:06 Speaker 00 Yeah, a fair number. I think you're being kind.
9:08 Speaker 02 I think you, what we have said, and I think what we continue to believe is that we are unwilling to make the compromises needed to be in that market today.
9:19 Speaker 00 And do you ever imagine, or do you think the government has to change before that happens?
9:24 Speaker 02 I don't know about the government needing to change, but I think there are other avenues that are open to us, and we're seeing some of this. We have a large export business on our ads platform in China. We also have a number of developers in China who use our developer tools. So we do feel that that's a market that's available to us, or we're just pursuing it in a different way.
9:41 Speaker 00 But not North Korea anytime soon?
9:43 Speaker 02 Well, I'm not sure that the internet market is as
9:47 Speaker 00 Robust there.
9:48 Speaker 02 Yes, exactly.
9:49 Speaker 00 What do you imagine? I want to get into how you got into this in a second, but what do you imagine is the most troubling thing that could happen with all these requests? When, you know, government has, we've seen all this NSA stuff and what they're spying on and how they're tapping into things. What are you most troubled by as a lawyer and as a citizen, really?
10:07 Speaker 02 I think the robust exchange of information around the world is so critical to everything that happens. And it is a very American point of view, I'm an American educated person, so I appreciate that not all countries feel the same way and different countries approach it differently. But we restarted here and we have this fundamental belief in the power of Twitter and the power of the exchange of information around the world. And I think if the government doesn't follow appropriate processes, or they try to stop those conversations from happening, what you're doing is stifling that free exchange of information. And I think that's incredibly dangerous.
10:44 Speaker 00 How did you get into this? You were, give me your background, just, just a little bit. You don't have to go back to kindergarten.
10:48 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. It's gonna sound a little, um, discongruous, I think, but, um, I actually spent about a decade of my career here in Silicon Valley, uh, at Wilson Sonsini, representing tech companies, mostly in IPOs and mergers and acquisitions. Um, I mentioned-
11:01 Speaker 00 Sort of boring stuff.
11:02 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly. And I did hostile takeovers for a really long time, too.
11:05 Speaker 00 Nice, nice, well done.
11:06 Speaker 02 Um, but, um, I was friends with AMAC, who is our former general counsel here at Twitter, and, um, always admired him and the work that he was doing at Google before he came to Twitter, and also what he, um, started here. And I also had this really unique perspective because my father-in-law is Egyptian, lived in Egypt, uh, lived in Cairo, and, uh, is still the biggest, uh, user of Twitter that I know, and-
11:29 Speaker 00 In Egypt?
11:30 Speaker 02 In Egypt. Um, he lives there about half-time, and he was there during, uh, the revolutions and the protests in Tahrir Square. And the, the, the time that I found it just phenomenal, and the power of this platform became so apparent to me, was back in 2010, when he was sending us tweets from Tahrir Square, from, you know, pictures of what was happening. And I was like, this is amazing. This entire movement started because people were able to connect with each other around a common interest. And not only are they thousands and thousands of people there, but they're able to share what's going on directly with the entire world, without any mediation, and without journalists, and they're able to express exactly what they feel and what they're trying to achieve. And
12:13 Speaker 02 that power was, is really something that I think is, is relatively new, and it, it really felt to me like-
12:20 Speaker 00 It resonated with you.
12:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely.
12:22 Speaker 00 And, and you, so you said, "Screw the IPOs, I'm gonna be doing something with a little more substance there."
12:26 Speaker 02 Yeah, well, it took me a couple of years to actually get a job at Twitter, but, um, it was something that was-
12:30 Speaker 00 Was that where you aimed to work, or did you?
12:32 Speaker 02 No, I really wanted to. I, I remember having, uh, lunch with, uh, AMAC a couple of times, and asking him if there were any opportunities available, and I was very excited when one finally came up.
12:42 Speaker 00 And you, had you specialized in these kind of areas, which are sort of First Amendment issues there?
12:47 Speaker 02 Not at all. And in fact, I have a phenomenal team that supports me. And they are really the ones that push on these issues. So my job is to help them.
12:56 Speaker 00 What do you do all day? What is your...
12:58 Speaker 02 I often ask myself that same question. I spend a lot of time in meetings.
13:02 Speaker 00 Right.
13:03 Speaker 02 I think. And a lot of time planning for the team, unblocking issues, making sure that the leadership team and my team are communicating well, so that we're focused on the right things.
13:13 Speaker 00 So you could also kind of contracts, obviously. That's sort of the block and tackle of what you're doing. These government requests and keeping those correct. And the other is safety and online harassment.
13:23 Speaker 02 That's right.
13:25 Speaker 00 Do you... Is there anything to be... We've had Reddit people here, we've had others who've talked about this issue quite a bit. Is it never going to be fixed? Do you feel like... You've put in all kinds of things. Twitter got criticized for not doing enough. I think around the Robin Williams suicide, there was a lot of talk about what happened. And you acted, but still, it's sort of can be a real cesspool out there in a lot of ways.
13:47 Speaker 02 I think that's right. I think, you know, fundamentally, the internet is often a reflection of what the real world is like. And some of that is really amazing, and some of that is not so great. I think for us, a lot of our criticisms stemmed from not acting fast enough or not acting with enough success. Meaning we weren't stopping things from happening. We were very reactive. We made a lot of changes, I would say, in the last year.
14:14 Speaker 00 Do you think you were too reactive? Did it not occur to you that this would hurt, or is it just, this was just a prominent person?
14:19 Speaker 02 In that particular case, I think there was a lot of confusion on what was actually going on. So, and I don't want to comment on specific cases, but I think that it's not that we had this belief in the platform and the power of the platform, and we tried to tinker with it very little in the early days. And I think we reacted to reports of abuse, but we weren't doing anything proactively to either educate users or make it more difficult to abuse someone. And so what we've done over the last year is really drastically changed how the product works, our enforcement mechanisms, how quickly we react. And those are the things we focused on. And we've changed our policies, actually, because of a lot of... Feedback from our users.
14:58 Speaker 00 All right, we're going to get into talking about that in a second, but first, an ad from our sponsor. If you're always on the go like myself and don't have time to sit down and read, audible.com is a great source to be able to catch up on the latest bestsellers. Listen to it while on the road or at the gym. Audible.com is a leading provider of premium digital spoken audio information and entertainment on the Internet. Audible content includes more than 180,000 audiobooks and spoken word audio products. It carries audiobooks in every genre imaginable, business classics, history, and self-development. Audible is offering our listeners a free audiobook of your choice and a free 30-day trial membership. I availed myself to it, and I'm listening to Ken Follet's Fall of Giants that I'm listening
15:41 Speaker 00 to as I walk up and down Market Street in San Francisco. Just go to audible.com/decode and choose from over 180,000 audio programs, download a title free, and start listening. It's that easy. Go to audible.com/decode. That's audible.com/decode and get started today. We're here with Vijaya Gadeh. Did I get that right?
16:02 Speaker 02 Yes, you did.
16:03 Speaker 00 Thank you. And we're talking about a range of issues around Twitter. She's Twitter's top lawyer and deals with all kinds of issues, from basic contracts to government requests to shut down information, and also online harassment, which has become a big issue and doesn't seem to ever go away. Twitter has tried to fix the situation. We're going to talk about that, but it's also been criticized for not acting enough. It's sort of the world's great marketplaces of voices, and in that case, there's a lot of bad voices and bad actors, and it can degenerate and sort of be a reflection of humanity. I'm of the opinion that Twitter doesn't hurt people, people hurt people, and yet, these tools make it a lot easier.
16:46 Speaker 00 Let's talk about the solutions, because I think you can't change humanity and sort of the vile things they say. And there is anonymous, for example. On Facebook, you can't be anonymous. It's very hard to do so. Is that a problem? Let's start with that to begin, because on Twitter, you can have all kinds of crazy names, and nobody quite knows who you are.
17:04 Speaker 02 Well, it's certainly one of the things that can exist. ...disaster bait a situation and people can hide behind the veil of anonymity to say terrible things. And, you know, one of the things that I've been really focused on, and I wrote an op-ed in the Washington Post a couple of months back that really focused on this, is that at some point, the abuse becomes so bad that it begins silencing other people. And while we've historically not mediated and gotten involved, we've taken the position and we believe that we need to create an environment where people can speak freely, but that there is a line over which we will not allow you to cross. And we're doing a number of things on the product and the policy side to prevent that.
17:45 Speaker 00 So let's talk about those. Let's talk about the product side.
17:47 Speaker 02 So on the product side...
17:48 Speaker 00 First of all, do you ever imagine Twitter not anonymous, real names?
17:52 Speaker 02 I have a hard time imagining that. And there's the date that it's funny, because I do think, you know, in many cases, Twitter is the place for your online identity. It is the place where so many people, whether it's government officials or celebrities or business leaders, choose to speak and put their views out to the rest of the world. But it also serves this other use case, which is to allow those who don't have a voice to speak up and without fear of retaliation.
18:19 Speaker 00 You know, celebrities tend to get in trouble if they go too far, except for Donald Trump in a weird way. But really, seriously, you know, one guy who's doing the, one of the late night shows, he said a bunch of things on Twitter and it's late, it comes to haunt him later.
18:32 Speaker 02 Well, it's a public platform. You know, you could say the same thing on the evening news and it might come to haunt you later.
18:40 Speaker 00 That would be Brian Williams, yes. But the anonymous, so you don't think there should be anonymous, or do you...
18:46 Speaker 02 No, I think it's a very important part of the mission of the platform, which is to allow any voice to speak up. And there are many places in the world, or many topics, even in a place like the United States, that people would have a fear of speaking out about. And it's really important that we enable those voices to be heard as well as the...
19:05 Speaker 00 So you're sheltering the discomfited rather than...
19:09 Speaker 00 You know, afflicting the obnoxious kind of thing.
19:12 Speaker 02 We have a philosophical point of view that anonymous speech can be very powerful. We have the opposite reality that it can also be used for things that like abuse and harassment. So it's a balance and that's the balance that we're continually striking every day and we can continue to iterate on that.
19:30 Speaker 00 I think you should not have anonymous, that's my feeling. But we'll go on. I think it does breed more trouble than it's worth, but I get your point if you're in a certain country and you can't speak and don't have an outlet. Gay issues used to be like that.
19:43 Speaker 02 Or even here, when you talk about diversity issues in tech or in a number of issues, you might be afraid to speak in your own voice, but you want to make a point.
19:51 Speaker 00 Right.
19:51 Speaker 02 So I think that that's valuable even here, every day.
19:54 Speaker 00 So let's talk about the product changes. What, give me some examples of what's going on.
19:57 Speaker 02 So we've done some really simple things such as just make it easy to report, one-click reporting in many instances. The other thing that we've done is changed how we react to reports that we get. For example, we will force users to delete tweets that are seeing, that are violating our policies. And it's sort of an education process. We have to go through and delete every tweet that's been found to be in violation of our policies. And it forces them to really take a moment to think this is wrong, this violates the policy. And you're not allowed back to access your account unless you go through those steps. We also have a number of things.
20:34 Speaker 00 Who does that? What team does that there?
20:35 Speaker 02 We have a global team, our services team, customer service team.
20:41 Speaker 00 And they read them and determine?
20:42 Speaker 02 That's right. We have a policy team that reports into my organization and they write the global policies for all this type of content. And then we have a team that enforces the policies.
20:52 Speaker 00 So some, those are very gray areas though, in a lot of times. I mean Reddit had that issue is that it was okay to have certain words, but they were all offensive. Like even the what we, you could say, you couldn't say you'd kill someone, but you could talk about attacking someone for their race or something like that.
21:07 Speaker 02 So there's certainly an area of greatness to our, any company's policies, I think, in this. But you can be pretty specific. And this is one of the changes we've made actually is because we used to have a policy. That's the only thing that was prohibited was a direct threat of violence.
21:23 Speaker 00 Right.
21:23 Speaker 02 And what we found was a lot of people were getting indirect threats of violence.
21:26 Speaker 00 Right.
21:27 Speaker 02 That were incredibly intimidating. And we took the feedback from our users that our policy didn't go far enough. So we made the change. But you're right. It requires our agents to have a lot of context to really understand the policies before they can make a decision. And we take this incredibly seriously.
21:44 Speaker 00 Can you give an example of that? Is it like one particular thing? Was it just a racial comment or?
21:50 Speaker 02 I mean, a great example is the rape train is coming your way.
21:54 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
21:55 Speaker 02 Is that a threat?
21:56 Speaker 00 Yes, it is.
21:57 Speaker 02 I agree.
21:58 Speaker 00 Yeah.
21:58 Speaker 02 But I'm not sure that it would have been a...
22:00 Speaker 00 You're also an idiot for saying it. Not you in particular.
22:03 Speaker 02 But something like that, like in the old days, may not have been captured by a direct threat of violence against you. But now we're like, clearly, this is meant to intimidate and harass, and it's violent. It is abusive, and we're going to take action on it.
22:15 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm. So and what else do they do to stop this?
22:18 Speaker 02 Oh, so we're also limiting the spread of this information. So we will not show certain types of tweets and app mentions. You know, we've enhanced the ability for people to block. The functionality is much better.
22:30 Speaker 00 Yeah, it is. I block a lot of people.
22:32 Speaker 02 We've allowed people to, you know, share block lists. So for example, if you are an activist and, you know, you and the people that in your community have the same people that are always harassing you or you don't want to hear from, you can share your block list with other people, which is great. We also enhanced the ability to mute people that you just don't want to listen to. So we've done a bunch of things in the product to enhance the user controls around what you see and when you see it.
22:59 Speaker 00 Talking of the bigger issue of online harassment, and then I want to finish with talking about content, troubles around content. Because we had an interesting discussion about content around the world being blocked in a lot of ways, real good content. Is there, when you look at a Reddit, for example, and you can't necessarily, but it's a bigger trend, like what do you do in this space where you want to allow freedom of expression at the same time? You know, it doesn't happen, and the news has a gated quality. I can kick people out of my site. I have, we block people. I remember someone coming on and saying vile things about one of our reporters in the comment section, I just blocked them. And they said, "You can't do that." I go, "Get your own website." I said, "F-word." Website. And I, it was really interesting, because they thought they could say whatever they wanted.
23:44 Speaker 00 And I said, "No, you really actually can't, because it's my party here, and you need to leave my house." So it was, you know, I had certain, news people have certain control over that. How do you, you all don't want to have that control, or don't want to serve that purpose, yet increasingly you'll get drawn into it.
23:57 Speaker 02 I actually think we do have that control, and that's what you've seen us do. I think Twitter is taking a stand against online abuse. And we can control that on our platform, and we're being much more aggressive. So similar to you, that is exactly what we're doing when we suspend someone from the platform, and we prevent them from signing up.
24:14 Speaker 00 Do you imagine it's going to get worse as we move into other platforms of VR? All kinds of ways where people can really interact. I mean, a VR Twitter would be really interesting.
24:23 Speaker 02 It would be really interesting. I don't know that it'll get worse. I think it's just always going to be there. This is a problem in the real world, it is a problem online. What you often see is organized campaigns that are across multi-platforms. It's, you know, a lot of Gamergate was across multi-platforms. It wasn't just one platform.
24:40 Speaker 00 Yeah, the Twitter was the center of it.
24:42 Speaker 02 Twitter, Reddit, there was a number of places that it was happening. And I do think that there's a number of, a lot of that's happening on private platforms as well, you're just not seeing it. We've always had the privilege of being a largely public platform, so you can see everything that's going on, and that's both good. You see the good stuff, as well as the bad stuff.
25:00 Speaker 00 Do you think Reddit's doing enough?
25:03 Speaker 02 You know, I don't, I'm not sure. I'm not as close to their kind of day-to-day things, so I wouldn't want to comment on that.
25:09 Speaker 00 Okay. I would imagine, I personally think they never do enough there. I think they just allow a lot of cesspool behavior to go on, and I'm not sure why. I mean, I get the larger First Amendment issues, but at some point it becomes a question of social, you know, kindness, or something like that. So let's finish up about content around the world. Is it at risk? Do you think that content is at risk? As you move, you know, as a lawyer, you see blocking of content, blocking of information. You know, we all promote more information everywhere, especially good information in news. Do you see that as a big issue going forward?
25:41 Speaker 02 I think it's an issue that we should always be vigilant about, because if people stop fighting for these things, that's when you slide into a place where information is not flowing freely. And I think it's one of the things I'm most proud of, is the work that my team has done about withholding. Where we are forced to withhold content, we only withhold it in a particular country that has given us that legal order to do so. And then we publish the court order for the world to see, so they can see exactly what governments are acting and what they're trying to suppress.
26:13 Speaker 00 Can you give me an example of that?
26:14 Speaker 02 So we publish all of our court orders, for example...
26:18 Speaker 00 No, quarters, I mean something that they wanted to block a piece of content.
26:20 Speaker 02 Well, I mean, it happens all the time. Even in countries like France and Germany, there'll be a lot of things that are considered violations of European hate speech laws. And that wouldn't be violations of US law, for example. Or in particular countries around demonstrations or protests, that type of information, if you don't have a permit to protest, you're not allowed to hold a protest. So that type of information will be asked to be blocked as well.
26:50 Speaker 00 And do you, do you see a contraction around the world as the government becomes, governments become smarter of it? There's not going to be a world view of this. I mean, on the, for example, it's the right to be forgotten. Where do you come down on that?
27:03 Speaker 02 I think it's incredibly challenging. I think that that is a really tough position. I understand that there are cultural norms that are different around the world, but I think it's a very challenging issue because it is information and I believe that it should flow freely.
27:18 Speaker 00 Yeah, I don't think there's any right to be forgotten. That's my feeling.
27:21 Speaker 02 I'm not sure, you know, the interesting thing about that decision is it's not that you really have a right to be forgotten, it's just in certain places.
27:28 Speaker 00 Right.
27:29 Speaker 02 You have a right to be forgotten.
27:31 Speaker 00 In France, say, or Germany.
27:32 Speaker 02 Well, not just that, but you know, you have a right to be forgotten from a search engine, but not necessarily.
27:37 Speaker 00 From Twitter.
27:38 Speaker 02 You know, and in the online world, you don't have a right to be, or, sorry, the offline world, you don't have a right to be forgotten.
27:43 Speaker 00 Right, exactly.
27:44 Speaker 02 So, I'm not sure what's being achieved by this.
27:48 Speaker 00 The last question, what's the most interesting legal issue right now on the internet, right now, that really, even if it's not a Twitter issue, what is something that really, is it labor issues, like the New York Times story that just came out, what is the, what do you think that one of the most interesting issues?
28:02 Speaker 02 Well, I think contingent workforce issues are really, really interesting. We have a new world with a sharing economy and a lot of the people that are participating in different services, like Uber, Postmates, et cetera, are they employees, are they not employees, what kind of protections do they have? I think it's a fascinating issue that will really impact how these companies continue to operate and how employees and service providers are treated.
28:31 Speaker 00 Great. Last question, very last question, if you weren't a lawyer, what would you do? Would you still be working in the internet space?
28:37 Speaker 02 Absolutely. I think the one thing I've seen is the ability for technology to impact every corner of the world and I just love that and it's the reason I love Twitter, because it has an impact in people's lives every single day.
28:50 Speaker 00 Great. Thank you so much for coming.
28:52 Speaker 02 Thank you. I'm very honored to be here.
28:54 Speaker 00 Yes, well, you look great in the red chair. Thanks for coming on, Vijaya Gade. You're almost as nice as Adam Bain, but that's impossible. Up next, a special Too Embarrassed to Ask with Walt Mossberg, where we talk about Apple's big autumn announcement and what will be coming. Stay tuned.
29:15 Speaker 00 Today's Too Embarrassed to Ask is brought to you by Audible.com, which has more than 180,000 audiobooks and spoken word audio products. Get a free audiobook of your choice at audible.com/decode and start listening. So today on Too Embarrassed to Ask, we're going to be talking about what Apple is going to be doing in the fall at their special event. A new iPad, Apple TV. For this week's Too Embarrassed to Ask, Walt Mossberg is here to help us make sense of whatever Apple has planned. Welcome, Walt.
29:46 Speaker 03 Glad to be here, Kara.
29:48 Speaker 00 All right, you're here in the studio. It's very exciting.
29:50 Speaker 03 It's very exciting, right here in the studio.
29:51 Speaker 00 Right here in the studio. So one of the things, this is not, you usually talk about products and how things are used, but people are very excited possibly about what's going to come out of Apple. And they have events twice a year and introduce different things. And they have a big event in the fall.
30:04 Speaker 03 Yeah, we think it's September 9.
30:06 Speaker 00 Right. And it tends to introduce things, it tends to be around the iPhone and things like that.
30:12 Speaker 03 It is around the iPhone, absolutely, definitely. That we know.
30:15 Speaker 00 Right. So talk a little bit about these events and why they're such a big deal still.
30:19 Speaker 03 Okay, so I'll start with the iPhone cycle, if that's of interest to people. So some people call it a tick-tock cycle. So they bring out kind of a big deal new iPhone every other year. And the intervening years, their pattern has been to bring out one that is labeled usually S. So it might be six, and I understand they've confirmed none of this. But they, people expect there to be a 6S and a 6 Plus S. They have a couple of ideas of new features on it. One is this thing called Force Touch, which they've already put into the Apple Watch and into some Macs, which is a way to press the screen in a hard way and get a bunch of shortcuts.
31:02 Speaker 03 Also, a lot of rumors about faster LTE performance, stuff like that. So that's kind of table stakes in the speculation. Beyond that, I've been told by sources at Apple that I should think of this as a big event. Bigger than just these iPhones.
31:20 Speaker 00 These upgrades.
31:21 Speaker 03 So big that they're actually trying to work hard to figure out how to make it a plausible length.
31:28 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
31:29 Speaker 03 And that implies to me a couple of things. First of all, it's been a long time since they revamped Apple TV. Our own Peter Kafka has reported that he expects they'll probably have a new Apple TV device with a new user interface, new remote, new capabilities, but not necessarily the streaming network that they have been looking to get from the media companies.
31:51 Speaker 00 Which they've been negotiating rather loudly in Hollywood.
31:53 Speaker 03 Very loudly, and, you know, the media companies have a lot of control, so it's just hard to do. But it's not hard for them to do a new Apple TV. And some speculation is that this new Apple TV could also be used as kind of a hub for Internet of Things and other things. I mean, it can, it'll, it could have Siri in it, it could run apps, it could be a radical revision of the Apple TV. In addition, everybody knows, or everybody has speculated, and I think, I really believe this, they're working on a kind of more business-oriented version of the iPod, of the iPad, sorry.
32:30 Speaker 00 iPad Pro, correct?
32:31 Speaker 03 iPad Pro, iPad Pro, who knows what they'll actually name it. And it's like, suppose they could have a 12 or 13-inch screen, a stylus.
32:40 Speaker 00 So aimed at business people.
32:42 Speaker 03 Aimed at business people. And as part of, you remember, Tim Cook has an initiative with IBM to try to write a whole bunch of business apps for the iPad. I think this is his way of goosing falling iPad sales. Generally, iPads have been announced on a different schedule than iPhones, but there's some feeling that maybe that he'll pull that out at this meeting.
33:02 Speaker 00 Right.
33:03 Speaker 03 Plus, they have upgrades, which they announced in the spring, to their operating systems.
33:09 Speaker 00 Right.
33:10 Speaker 03 And I think that's the general parameter.
33:11 Speaker 00 But it won't be a big new device like the Apple Watch, which was the last device.
33:13 Speaker 03 No, I don't think there's going to be a big new category like the Apple Watch.
33:16 Speaker 00 Will there be upgrades to the Apple Watch?
33:18 Speaker 03 I don't think there'll be a hardware upgrade. They did announce in the spring the 2.0 version of the operating system, which is desperately needed because it should allow third-party apps to write directly to the watch.
33:33 Speaker 00 Right.
33:33 Speaker 03 And not have to kind of pull the stuff up from the phone to the watch.
33:37 Speaker 00 Right, which is a problem. How are you liking your watch, by the way?
33:39 Speaker 03 I like it, but I use it for about three or four things, and I'd be interested in using it for more things if it was faster.
33:44 Speaker 00 Right.
33:45 Speaker 03 At getting the deal.
33:45 Speaker 00 But it's still on your wrist?
33:46 Speaker 03 It is, and just so everybody knows, I paid for it.
33:50 Speaker 00 Okay, God, of course you did. All right, we're gonna ask some questions from readers. Graham Kissinger asks, "Any chance Apple offers a phone smaller than the iPhone 6?" Going back to the iPhone 5 or 4.
34:01 Speaker 03 Well, this is an interesting question. I've actually lately had several people, including my wife, tell me they were not interested in the iPhone 6, because they really like the smaller, older size of the iPhone. And I had one person, who is a colleague of ours, tell me she actually feels like she's gotten some kind of, you know, injury from the bigger size. But I don't believe they'll bring out a new phone. I should point out that the iPhone 5 is on sale, as they typically do, for $100 less, and it's only a 4-inch screen.
34:35 Speaker 00 Right.
34:36 Speaker 03 I don't know what'll happen with that when they bring out the new ones.
34:40 Speaker 00 Possibly giving it up.
34:41 Speaker 03 It might. Well, typically, that one then goes to sort of a zero price. It becomes a giveaway one.
34:47 Speaker 00 Right.
34:47 Speaker 03 But it would still be available.
34:48 Speaker 00 Right, but they won't be making or improving it?
34:50 Speaker 03 I doubt it. I'd be really surprised.
34:52 Speaker 00 All right, Carlos, M.C.S.E., "Will Apple finally drop the 16-gigabyte option?"
34:58 Speaker 03 Yeah, he's referring to the base memory on the phone. I don't know for sure, but I wouldn't be stunned. A lot of the other phone guys have done this. And now that
35:09 Speaker 00 Because it's too small for...
35:10 Speaker 03 Phone subsidies aren't so common anymore. They don't have to worry about fitting into $199, so...
35:18 Speaker 03 You know, maybe they'll, maybe they'll just start at thirty-two.
35:23 Speaker 00 But that amount is pretty much inadequate to what people are doing, correct?
35:25 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, I always buy, I don't know about you, but I always buy much more than the base memory.
35:30 Speaker 00 Okay, say Bastian, when will we see Apple TV four, which you just referred to?
35:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, you're gonna see it, I'm almost certain you're gonna see it September ninth.
35:38 Speaker 00 Okay. John Christensen, do you think they will market the new Apple TV as the center of your home, et cetera, or just release it like past models, which they haven't really integrated?
35:48 Speaker 03 No, I think they will market it as more than just TV. It will run apps, and I think, you know, they have HomeKit. It's a wireless box sitting in, you know, your living room or wherever you have at your bedroom, and there's no reason why they couldn't build other functions into it.
36:05 Speaker 00 But they haven't, they really haven't, like, gotten into that idea. They've talked about it, the idea of sort of the central nervous system, but they haven't. I don't think about them.
36:12 Speaker 03 You're right, but the, but a new redesigned Apple TV, remember, they've sold twenty-five or thirty million of them.
36:18 Speaker 00 Yeah, I just, but I just have it next to my Roku, and I don't consider it anything special.
36:22 Speaker 03 Yeah, but you wouldn't have to do anything with it necessarily, it would just, it would just, it's connected to your Wi-Fi network, so all of a sudden, some other sensor or thing you're using in your house, like, I don't know, light bulbs that go on and off.
36:34 Speaker 00 I just thought by now I'd have Apple everything, like, Apple lights, Apple, I just don't, it just doesn't.
36:39 Speaker 03 I don't think they're gonna make Apple lights, but I think they're licensing people to be HomeKit compatible, and Apple TV may play a part in that.
36:45 Speaker 00 Yeah, I just thought they'd be bigger in my living room and home, but they aren't.
36:49 Speaker 03 I, I, I feel so bad for you, Karen.
36:50 Speaker 00 I know, it's terrible, that's okay, I don't need a giant corporation running my house. Sudip Mishra, odds of the iPad Plus, what happens to the iPhone six price, cut by a hundred dollars would hurt margins?
37:01 Speaker 03 Yeah, this, the last part, we already talked about the iPad Plus. Cut by a hundred dollars would hurt margins, yes and no. They, they tend to cut last year's phone by a hundred dollars, that's been their pattern. I have no reason to think they won't. But remember, the margins also depend on the cost of goods. They've sold a bazillion iPhone sixes. The price of the components is significantly less than it was when they introduced it last year. So if they cut it by a hundred dollars, it might not hurt the margin on it at all.
37:33 Speaker 00 And they'd sell more, and they'd sell more of them.
37:35 Speaker 03 And they sell more, yeah.
37:36 Speaker 00 Right. Do you think, this is from Hot Chocolate, I don't know who that is.
37:39 Speaker 03 I love questions from Hot Chocolate.
37:41 Speaker 00 Do you think iPad's Air Mini refresh will be skipped at this event in order to focus on the speculated iPad Pro?
37:48 Speaker 03 I have no idea. I have no idea. I don't know.
37:52 Speaker 00 How are those small iPads doing? How are they?
37:54 Speaker 03 I...
37:55 Speaker 00 It seems like you have either the big phone or your laptop or the larger...
37:58 Speaker 03 Yeah, obviously, the iPad Mini is probably the iPad that has been hit the most by the big iPhone that you love to carry around. I still use my iPad Mini because I did not buy the big iPhone. But, like I say, my sources suggest there's a lot at this event, so maybe there will be an iPad.
38:17 Speaker 00 So what else? Is there anything else you can reveal to us, Mossberg? What are your sources suggest?
38:20 Speaker 03 I don't think they're going to have an Apple car at the event.
38:22 Speaker 00 Okay. All right. When is that coming?
38:25 Speaker 03 I don't think they're going to make a car.
38:26 Speaker 00 You don't? What are they going to do?
38:28 Speaker 03 No, I have, I mean, I think, I think some people, some important people at Apple, like Johnny Ive, wanted to work on a car. That's a long way from them deciding they want to be in a regulated business. Even Google with the self-driving cars, and you know this, their concept isn't that you'll, everybody will own one of the self-driving cars. It's really more of a fleet kind of a thing. You know, summon it.
38:50 Speaker 00 Well, isn't it the idea that they need growth elsewhere, beyond search or beyond phones? That this, these are...
38:55 Speaker 03 Yes, but I'm thinking of the product itself. I mean, I, I, I, Apple doesn't strike me as a company that really wants to get into a regulated business where people could be killed on the highway and all this kind of stuff.
39:06 Speaker 00 Right. I'd like a gold car, though.
39:08 Speaker 03 Yes. Well, I'll, I'll pass that on to them.
39:10 Speaker 00 Gold is best. Yes, you do. You please.
39:13 Speaker 03 Right after this podcast, I'll call them and tell them.
39:14 Speaker 00 So you will be attending this event, correct?
39:15 Speaker 03 I will be attending it. And Recode will be attending it. And our sisters at the Verge will be attending.
39:20 Speaker 00 But you are the Verge now, Walt. Now, let's just say that Walt Mossberg will be writing for the Verge. When do you start?
39:24 Speaker 03 I'll be writing column for the Verge, starting at the end of this month. And that column for Recode lovers will also appear in Recode.
39:32 Speaker 00 Absolutely.
39:33 Speaker 03 And I'll still be involved in the Code conferences and in these wonderful podcasts, but I'll be doing podcasts at the Verge as well.
39:40 Speaker 00 Right.
39:41 Speaker 03 And so you'll be able to find me everywhere.
39:44 Speaker 00 Well, how can we miss you if you won't go away? Thanks, Walt. Thanks a lot. And now, on Enough Said, a commentary from me on getting old. Google's real alphabet: I is for innovation, and also irrelevant. Like a lot of places, it's hard to be old in Silicon Valley. That's because it's always been an environment where the young eats its old rather than vice versa right from the start. Shockly begat Fairchild, begat Intel, and so on and so forth, a biblical lesson that has been iterated throughout the tech sector since. Silicon Valley's power elite will deny this age insecurity up and down, of course. But like Hollywood actors heading to a Botox session to save off the inevitable, there
40:27 Speaker 00 is always a sense of needing to refresh into the new, new thing to slow the digital guillotine hanging above all their efforts. Which in many ways is a bit of what's going on over at Google and its odd name change to Alphabet. The name itself is even younger than young, harkening back to nursery school, even that sing-song that we all learn to memorize it: A, B, C, D, E, F, G. To say it is primary is an understatement, and that is perhaps what Google is going for here. In his blog post on the subject, "Google, Excuse Me, Alphabet CEO Larry Page noted, 'We like the name Alphabet because it means a collection of letters that represents language, one of humanity's most important innovations, and is the core of how we index with Google
41:12 Speaker 00 Search. We also like that it means 'alpha-bet.' Alpha is an investment, return above benchmark, which we strive for.'" While well said, this is just the kind of banal Silicon Valley bromide that means a whole lot less than it says. You get a lot of that here in the center of innovation, and it is wearisome. And perplexing, because Google should be justifiably proud of just how innovative it has remained since it was founded around the beginning of this century, which I call the olden days. Despite its massive growth in power, revenue, employees, and overall influence, the search giant has remained more nimble than any other company in tech.
41:52 Speaker 00 Google Glass, loon balloons, contact lenses that test for diabetes, giant solar kites, and who knows what else they're brewing up? I have a bet that they're working on an invisibility cloak and also a time machine. Who knows? But it's very exciting. In fact, aging probably shouldn't be so much a worry anywhere in Silicon Valley, given that most powerful companies are run by these same ever-aging executives, and most of the money funding the startups is controlled by another cadre of mature, almost always former dudes. Nonetheless, these same men all long for one thing, remaining as it was in the beginning, was then and ever shall be, is the prime directive, which is to say, always and forever, retaining
42:34 Speaker 00 the ethos and spirit of a startup, that they are still wearing cheap hoodies instead of expensive cashmere, that they're having to get by on nothing when they now have everything. In other words, to start from the beginning again, where ABC's meant you were just learning how to spell, rather than having to change your name, and in this case, the best-known name in the world, to stop from what is inevitable, which is that you will eventually be upended, as you yourself once upended, that you will grow old and you will be replaced, as the iPhone 6 will someday be an iPhone 7. This is the life you chose to always change. There's an old saying, that everything is always on the way to being something else,
43:16 Speaker 00 and realizing that, maybe, is not such a bad thing. This has been Recode Decode with Kara Swisher. Thanks for tuning in. We'll be back next week.
43:27 Speaker 01 This has been Recode Decode, hosted by Kara Swisher. For more hard-hitting interviews with insiders from the worlds of tech, media, and politics, subscribe to Recode Replay on iTunes. Featuring candid conversations with leading voices like Snapchat CEO Evan Spiegel, Uber founder Travis Kalanick, reality star Kim Kardashian, Shark Tank host Mark Cuban, and presidential candidate Hillary Clinton, President Obama, and more. They're all on Recode Replay. Thanks for tuning in.
Previous Recode Decode: Investor Chris Sacca Next Recode Decode: Ex-Googler Erica Baker Page updated October 18, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated