Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: The inside story of the Cambridge Analytica scandal About this episode Cambridge Analytica’s former business development director Brittany Kaiser talks with Recode’s Kara Swisher about her new book TARGETED: The Cambridge Analytica Whistleblower's Inside Story of How Big Data, Trump, and Facebook Broke Democracy and How It Can Happen Again. Kaiser talks about how she first observed the dangers of social media while working on Barack Obama's 2008 campaign, why she mistakenly believed Cambridge Analytica was using technology as a force for good, and what happened when she decided to turn on the company and testify about its abuses in the UK Parliament. She also deconstructs Facebook's excuses for the scandal and its slow response, and predicts that 2020 could be "exponentially worse" than 2016 for election interference.
Featuring:
Brittany Kaiser, author of TARGETED: The Cambridge Analytica Whistleblower's Inside Story of How Big Data, Trump, and Facebook Broke Democracy and How It Can Happen Again.
Hosts:
Kara Swisher (@karaswisher), Recode co-founder and editor-at-large
More to explore:
Listen to Kara's interview with the creators of The Great Hack, a Netflix documentary about Cambridge Analytica, including former COO Julian Wheatland.
Read Vox's Alissa Wilkinson's review of The Great Hack.
Subscribe for free to Reset, Recode's new podcast that explores why — and how — tech is changing everything.
About Recode by Vox:
Recode by Vox helps you understand how tech is changing the world — and changing us.
Follow Us:
Newsletter: Recode Daily
Twitter: @Recode and @voxdotcom
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 11,072 words · 7 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Company spend can be complicated. Managing it shouldn't be. Amex Corporate connects cards, expenses, and payments all in one place. That's less time managing work and more time doing work that matters. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is Amex Corporate. Get started at go.amex slash Amex Corporate. Terms apply.
0:30 Speaker 01 You could try to find a perfect coffee to water ratio. Or you could press a button. With Keurig, each K-cup pod is precision measured for a perfectly delicious cup. No effort, no grind, no math required. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
0:53 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as someone who'd be happy to host Mark Zuckerberg and Tucker Carlson for dinner. I have a thing or two I'd like to say to both of them, but in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today in the red chair is Brittany Kaiser, the former Development Director of Cambridge Analytica. She later testified about the company's misuse of Facebook data in the British Parliament and was one of the stars of the Netflix documentary, The Great Hack. She's about to release a new book called Targeted: The Cambridge Analytica Whistleblower's Inside Story of How Big Data, Trump, and Facebook Broke Democracy and How It Can Happen Again. That's a big title. Brittany, welcome to Recode Decode.
1:33 Speaker 03 Thank you so much.
1:34 Speaker 02 There's a lot of words in there, Brittany. A lot of bad words together, all mashed up together.
1:38 Speaker 03 There's a lot of important things to say at this point in time, so I had to try to fit it all in.
1:43 Speaker 02 It's perfect timing. Of course, right in the middle of the Ukraine mess and everything else that's been going on, but there's always something going on, actually. But the repercussions of what happened at Facebook and Cambridge Analytica just last and continue to have repercussion, you know, reverberations of repercussions throughout. So let's talk a little bit about your background, so people get a sense. I did a panel for the documentary, The Great Hack, which does explain you quite a bit. I recommend people watching it. It's a really interesting and unusual portrayal of you. I want to talk about that in a minute, but give people the background of how you came to become Development Director, because you have an unusual path. You started off in politics, working for... Obama, correct? Is that correct, or before that?
2:20 Speaker 03 Yeah, so I was actually studying to be a human rights lawyer when I left my degree in order to go work for Barack Obama. So during the prime-
2:31 Speaker 02 Where are you from? You're from-
2:32 Speaker 03 I'm from Chicago.
2:33 Speaker 02 Chicago, right.
2:33 Speaker 03 So I've known about Barack Obama since I was quite young. And I had volunteered for the DNC many years before that on first Howard Dean's campaign and then John Kerry's, and continued to follow what was going on. And in 2004, I attended the DNC. And that's where I first met Barack Obama, and he actually invited me to volunteer on his senatorial campaign, which I did. And continued to keep eyes on him until he announced that he was going to run for president. And I left my degree when I got an internship to go back to Chicago to work for him.
3:07 Speaker 02 All right, so you, what was the political bug that got you? What, you were working on generalized things? Or was data and social media your biggest focus?
3:17 Speaker 03 Actually, it was environmental policy that I was most interested in from a very young age. Barack was giving a speech about how him and Senator Dick Durbin were trying to stop British Petroleum from dumping into the streams and waterways that fed into Lake Michigan. And that's what the rally was about on Boston Harbor when I first met him. So that's what originally motivated me to be interested in his candidacy. And from there forward, I started to get much more involved in human rights activism. Maybe it comes from a Jewish background where we learned about genocide and crimes against humanity so intensely growing up. But that became a very big interest of mine of how to use foreign policy in order to protect people and prevent war.
3:57 Speaker 02 All right, so you go to the Obama campaign. Talk about what you did there.
4:01 Speaker 03 So I joined in spring of 2007, so quite early, when the new media team was about five people. And that's when we were first starting to create social media accounts for Barack Obama to start testing the waters on how we could use these new platforms to start communicating with voters. So on my first day, I was actually asked to create a Facebook page for Barack Obama. And we started doing very rudimentary things to collect data.
4:29 Speaker 02 Right.
4:29 Speaker 03 Which was to- Post different messages and also see how people were reacting. What issues were they writing in to ask about? Was it healthcare? Was it the environment, foreign policy? And we could start to keep basic Excel sheets to find out what actually motivated people to care about Barack's candidacy or about politics in general. And that way, we started to develop targeted messaging. So we know if this person ever writes into us again, they care about healthcare policy, and we're always going to make sure to keep them updated on what the campaign is up to.
4:59 Speaker 02 Or send the messages that way. But it was sort of artisanal. This is artisanal data if you're keeping an Excel spreadsheet.
5:05 Speaker 03 Yeah, it was very basic in the beginning. It was only later in the campaign when we started to do more advanced work with algorithms, such as when we noticed that there were so many people that would write into us during a presidential debate, we decided to build a platform where people could text in their questions. And depending on the words used in those texts, it would categorize the text under a certain policy. And we would have different teams. Okay, here's the healthcare team and the foreign policy team. And we'd be live responding to all of their questions. And again, that was a basic algorithm that was being used, but that's when we started to use predictive analytics.
5:42 Speaker 02 And what was your, did you have a background in data? No, you just started making Facebook pages.
5:47 Speaker 03 Yeah, I had worked in digital in high school. On our high school newspaper, I was the head of photography and led the transition from film photography to digital. And was quite advanced in working with Adobe products. But that was the most I had really done was digital design and editing.
6:05 Speaker 02 They just had put a young person on this stuff? Is that really?
6:07 Speaker 03 Well, learned pretty quickly.
6:09 Speaker 02 Yeah. All right, so you were doing this for them and then, and worked for them for quite a while. And you had a great regard for President Obama during this time. I mean, if the documentary is correct, you had quite a, like, it was your candidate.
6:22 Speaker 03 Yes, very much so.
6:23 Speaker 02 All right, so you were doing this, and explain what happened. You didn't go to the White House. You didn't go, why not?
6:29 Speaker 03 No, I actually applied to do an abroad program in Hong Kong. And at the time, I was very interested in human rights in China. So I wanted to move there very badly. I'd taken Mandarin for many years. And the opportunity to go work in the White House first, to go work on human rights in China and to further my Chinese language skills.
6:52 Speaker 03 It was a no-brainer for me.
6:53 Speaker 02 All right, but part of the documentary was talking about you being disappointed with the Obama campaign in some way. Is that correct?
7:00 Speaker 03 No, not disappointed in the Obama campaign. It was more, I had a very difficult time while doing some of that work. Most days, I actually ended up crying at work because of the incitement of racial hatred that we would get on our Facebook page, on our YouTube.
7:17 Speaker 02 So you saw that early?
7:18 Speaker 03 Yeah, and it was very tumultuous. And trying to track and trace where that misinformation was coming from was very difficult at the time. Was it coming from opposing Democrats? Was it coming from the Republicans? Was it coming from advocacy groups? And trying to manage that and police it and even develop internally our own debate about whether censorship or free speech was correct on social media just made it a very emotionally difficult job to have.
7:47 Speaker 02 Right. And so this, and this was early days where people were really manipulating. And did you see signs? This was so early, I guess you wouldn't have seen signs of Russian involvement or anything like that. Or it was just bots? Or you saw the power of Facebook?
7:59 Speaker 03 I saw the power.
8:00 Speaker 02 To be manipulated.
8:01 Speaker 03 I saw the power of people being able to hide behind kind of a digital divide and therefore be able to speak their mind in a way that they never would in person. And the development of fake accounts was not so, not such a big thing in the very beginning. I wouldn't say there were even really bots. This was not too long after you didn't any longer have to have a college email.
8:24 Speaker 02 College, yes.
8:25 Speaker 03 In order to get on Facebook. So it wasn't really bots and fake accounts that were the problem. It was people, for the first time, feeling like they could say whatever they wanted, whenever they wanted, to whomever they wanted, without any repercussions. And unfortunately, there were quite a few people that took that very far. And part of my job was actually to report people to the FBI when they threatened violence on Senator Obama.
8:46 Speaker 02 And so you wanted to get out of that. You wanted to, there wasn't a disgruntlement with the Obama administration or anything else to move, you went, you were going to Hong Kong?
8:56 Speaker 03 Yeah, this was a very early decision when he had only, kind of before he even won. I was told that if he does win, people who were early on in the campaign, you know, were going to get the first offers of jobs for the communications team in the White House and in other government departments, which most of my colleagues decided to take up. But I really thought... I needed to move on and do something different.
9:19 Speaker 02 So talk about what you did then, how you got to Cambridge Analytica.
9:23 Speaker 03 So I spent very many years working in human rights activism. I really learned all about that, which is such a contemporary conversation right now. When I went to Hong Kong, I got there and I met a big group of different human rights activists that at the time were fighting against something called Article 8, that the Chinese government was trying to pass, which would mean that the Chinese government would get a full veto of any decisions made in the Hong Kong Parliament. So, as you could imagine, there were very big protests that I was very actively involved in. I also got involved with a group of people who are helping smuggle North Korean refugees into safety. So refugees that ended up in China, where they were going to be sent back to North Korea,
10:07 Speaker 03 we would try to find a way to get them behind embassy walls. Sometimes even they would be dropped through helicopters behind embassy walls so that they would be safe with whatever country that happened to be, you know, Vietnam or what have you, so China couldn't send them back. And that was really moving for me. I got involved with a Brussels-based NGO called Human Rights Without Frontiers, and they gave me accreditation to the European Parliament and the United Nations in order to undertake NGO lobbying. So I spent my year in Hong Kong and went back to the University of Edinburgh where I was doing my master's degree. And I would travel to Geneva and to Brussels all of the time in order to talk about human
10:51 Speaker 03 rights in China and human rights in North Korea and try to keep that on the top of the political debate.
10:57 Speaker 02 So Cambridge Analytica.
10:59 Speaker 03 Right. So many years and degrees and jobs at NGOs like Amnesty International and United Nations. I'm writing my PhD on preventive diplomacy, which means using the power of ambassadors and heads of state in order to prevent war, violent crime, crimes against humanity before they happen.
11:22 Speaker 03 And I get to chapter three and it ends up being all about how you can use big data sets in order to predict war before it happens. So you can get real time valuable information to decision makers so that they can intervene more quickly. And nobody at my law school could teach me about predictive analytics. So at the time, I was still trying to pitch for a side work to do social media for anybody that was working in elections or even charity campaigns. And I was introduced at a meeting where I was hoping to pitch for social media work to Alexander Nix.
11:58 Speaker 02 The CEO.
12:00 Speaker 03 Exactly. And because it was a meeting with people who were going to have elections upcoming in their country, I got to hear his entire pitch about everything that he did at his company. At the time, he told us that his biggest project was on the defense side where he had a team of people that were using predictive analytics in order to find people who were vulnerable to being recruited into ISIS online. And to reach out to those usually young people, 18 to 35, and convince them to stay at home with their families instead of sneaking themselves into Syria. I thought, wow, I mean, these are some incredible data scientists. I'd love to meet them. I'd love to learn what they do. This sounds perfect for my PhD.
12:45 Speaker 03 And I started exploring a relationship with the SCL Group.
12:49 Speaker 02 And so, did you have any sense that there was any problems or you just wanted to be in on it? Because you shifted really dramatically in your mentality, I guess. That was what was so curious about the thing. I was like, who are you? Like, why did you do that if you had this background in democratic politics and then in human rights to go to this, which was sort of like a...
13:13 Speaker 02 Digital arms dealer, I don't know how else to put it. You know, did you think of it that way?
13:17 Speaker 03 No, that's not how it was pitched to me.
13:19 Speaker 02 Okay, all right. Well, pitched to you and what you can see they're doing is, are often different things.
13:24 Speaker 03 Yeah, very much so.
13:25 Speaker 02 But you're just too smart enough, so.
13:26 Speaker 03 On the outside, it seemed like a group of people who are trying to make the world a better place using technology. The first time I went in for a meeting at the SCL Group's office, I got introduced to somebody who had been specifically working in preventive diplomacy for 10 years for the Commonwealth Secretariat, someone that had been the Director of Operations for the International Rescue Committee, somebody else that was a human rights lawyer that had worked with the European Commission, and they were all working on sometimes defense projects, but also social projects. So how you could use research and data analysis in order to figure out, for instance, how to get people to use new healthcare facilities instead of traditional medicine doctors and what have you.
14:10 Speaker 02 I remember their pitch. I was at dinner next to next, and I thought it was a lot of bullshit, actually, interestingly enough. But one of the things that there was, but a lot of that predictive analysis was happening at the time. Google, remember they were going to predict what movies that were going to work?
14:21 Speaker 03 Right.
14:22 Speaker 02 Or what TV shows? There was all kinds of stuff like that, but a lot of it was sort of not adequate, I would say. It didn't come through in the same way. Had you studied that?
14:32 Speaker 03 I had never studied predictive analytics before.
14:35 Speaker 02 But you would hope that you, I'm not saying that all of it was, but it's sort of a big sell, that we can make, change people's minds, I mean, which propaganda has been doing for centuries, right?
14:43 Speaker 03 Well, I suppose it's actually a very commonly held belief and concept in humanitarian operations. It's called behavior change campaigns.
14:52 Speaker 02 Sure.
14:53 Speaker 03 And they're used very prolifically. And there's usually RFPs and project manager positions, always advertised through United Nations websites, all about being part of behavior change campaigning. But it's all supposed to be shifting things towards
15:07 Speaker 02 The good.
15:08 Speaker 03 Quote unquote, what they consider to be good. And I always saw it as inherently good and something not to be questioned.
15:15 Speaker 02 Right.
15:16 Speaker 03 So when I'm presented with a company that is doing this scientifically in a way where you can measure your impact and measure the change in people's actions and perceptions. I thought, hey.
15:26 Speaker 02 And the only reason I'm asking is because you had been part of the Obama campaign where this was, you saw the ugly side of it. It never occurred to you there could be ugly sides to doing this kind of stuff?
15:36 Speaker 03 Well, I suppose I saw the ugly side of individuals that were able to hide behind social media in order to let out the worst in themselves. I didn't think about companies that could possibly be doing that with paid messaging, because at the time, there wasn't any paid messaging. So I had never really experienced anything like that.
15:55 Speaker 02 So talk about your development there. So you decided to work with them.
15:58 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm. So eventually, I decided to work with them.
16:01 Speaker 02 So you leave behind all this other stuff.
16:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, at the time, I was writing my-
16:04 Speaker 02 This was your world-changing thing.
16:05 Speaker 03 Yeah, I was writing my PhD, so my goal was to really finish my doctorate and then continue on with my human rights work. And this was an opportunity to earn a bit of money while I was researching and actually be able to write the crux of my PhD, which is that it's possible to give real-time, accurate information to decision-makers so that they can prevent more. Right? But without getting really deep into big data and analytics, I wouldn't be able to prove my thesis. So I got involved with the campaign, originally just to do social projects and international elections, because I'm very interested in politics.
16:44 Speaker 02 Yeah.
16:45 Speaker 03 And that seemed great for the first few months that I was there, only to find out that the way that that particular company operated in different countries and the people that they interacted with were not always as above-board as I would have expected. I was definitely in over my head and-
17:04 Speaker 02 How old were you at this time?
17:05 Speaker 03 Twenty-six.
17:06 Speaker 02 Okay, all right. In over your head, how?
17:09 Speaker 03 In over my head in terms of negotiating millions of dollars' worth of contracts with business people and governments at that age.
17:19 Speaker 02 What was your pitch?
17:20 Speaker 03 With a technology that I didn't fully understand yet.
17:23 Speaker 02 Right. Did you, make you worry about this company that it was doing this?
17:26 Speaker 03 Not initially.
17:27 Speaker 02 Not initially?
17:28 Speaker 03 Not initially. I just thought, well, if I'm going to be working in predictive analytics alongside my PhD-
17:35 Speaker 03 You know, running around Asia and Africa as someone so young. Maybe I need to learn a bit more, or maybe I should go home and do it from home.
17:44 Speaker 02 Right.
17:44 Speaker 03 So eventually, there ended up being an opportunity to go back to America and still work for the company. And so I started to explore that.
17:54 Speaker 02 And so, explain to people what you did, what you, these deals that you did. Because you were in these meetings, you were, you seemed to travel with Nix a lot and develop business. And that was, he seemed to be on sort of a demented course to sign up deals. I mean, again, I recall meeting him so many times, and he was always on some deal or the next.
18:14 Speaker 03 Yes.
18:14 Speaker 02 And selling, selling, selling. He was a big salesperson.
18:17 Speaker 03 Definitely. Sales before operations, unfortunately.
18:20 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, I was, I thought that at the time. You know, I was like, oh, you're going to solve, I think I made a joke, I think, oh, you're solving cancer, good for you. Good luck with that, with that endeavor. But, talk about that, what you were doing, what you were, what was your pitch to clients? And what was the actual, things that actually worked?
18:35 Speaker 03 So, usually what, we'd be meeting people that either had an election or a campaign to do. In the beginning, I pitched quite a lot of nonprofits and charities that were trying to find new donors. So, we would show them exactly what we did in strategic communication, so how we did qualitative and quantitative research, and would be able to also take their proprietary data that they already had about their supporters, if it's political, or their donors, if it's for charities. And we would be able to make a suite of models specifically for them, in order to identify the people that care most about their issues.
19:13 Speaker 02 Right.
19:13 Speaker 03 That are most likely to vote or take action, most likely to donate.
19:16 Speaker 02 Target.
19:16 Speaker 03 Right? And explain to them the whole micro-targeting process for communications, and how we would measure results.
19:24 Speaker 02 Right.
19:24 Speaker 03 Right? And so, we would figure out what that organization or individual was actually trying to achieve, how much data they had or didn't have, what internal capacity they had to carry out a campaign, and then we would put together A proposal for exactly what we were going to do with them. Sometimes they had half the things that we were proposing already in-house. So we would just figure out how we were going to work with their team in order to slot in and provide extra value or measurement as part of the campaign.
19:53 Speaker 02 All right, and this is especially around digital, digital and all data that they would crunch and it would come out in a perfect answer, correct, essentially.
20:02 Speaker 03 Well, at least a more informed answer.
20:03 Speaker 02 A more informed answer. And also, you could use it to manipulate, in terms of manipulate. Had that, was that one of your pitches, to, we're going to help you win this election with targeted data that might not have been on the up and up?
20:15 Speaker 03 Well, again, it's, in politics, you're going to have campaigns that are positive. And unfortunately, since the Obama campaign, I've realized most people engage in negative campaigning.
20:26 Speaker 02 Right.
20:27 Speaker 03 So you're going to promote your candidate and you're going to not promote the others.
20:31 Speaker 02 Right.
20:32 Speaker 03 However, that happens to be. And as normal as that might seem in politics today, it can get really dark.
20:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, very quickly. I mean, engagement is enrage, right? I mean, if you think about it, like, that's how you do it. Did you feel that this was a problem when you were doing this? Or was it just sort of a melange of different clients that were, some of which were more dubious than others?
20:53 Speaker 03 Well, I only took part in the beginning of helping design it and meet the client and get them excited about it. And then Alexander would send a team to whatever country and have me move on and keep on doing pitches.
21:05 Speaker 02 So selling, selling, selling. So you're saying sales over operations. What did you mean by that?
21:08 Speaker 03 He prioritized sales.
21:10 Speaker 02 Right.
21:11 Speaker 03 Throughout my time there, it was very obvious that if he could sell something, then he would figure out a way for the company to do it.
21:17 Speaker 02 Do you think you were delivering actual products or more promises of products?
21:23 Speaker 03 I definitely think there was strong delivery in most of the campaigns that I sold, especially the commercial campaigns. We did really well and would usually get a new contract, you know, selling summer dresses or shoes or whatever it is. But the political stuff is...
21:39 Speaker 02 So it wasn't all summer dresses and shoes, when it moved to the political stuff?
21:42 Speaker 03 When it moved to the political stuff, that's where you could see really serious engagement, really serious results. But... With most campaigns, we wouldn't get shown how that was done.
21:55 Speaker 02 Okay, so did you ever worry about any of this? And the next thing I want to talk about that, when did the worm turn for you? Did you ever, did you think about it?
22:03 Speaker 03 I, I mean.
22:05 Speaker 02 The only reason I'm asking, I think the CFO, the same thing. I had no idea. Like, everyone had no idea at this place? Or was it just?
22:13 Speaker 03 No, I suppose it's not that, not that people had no idea. It's just that most people had no idea how bad it actually was. Unless you saw end to end what was going on. Just seeing one advertisement here and there, or hearing that a campaign is going really well, or not going really well, and the client's upset. Piecing all of those things together into, here's actually all of the campaigns that were put out. Look at what all of these advertisements actually say. Look at what they were intended to do. And look at what good or harm that caused.
22:48 Speaker 02 So you all, each individually, didn't see the whole chain of offerings, essentially?
22:54 Speaker 03 No.
22:54 Speaker 02 So you.
22:55 Speaker 03 We were very siloed.
22:56 Speaker 02 Siloed, so you, but you were quite close with Nix himself. Did you worry about his, the promises he was making, just in certain cases? Were there any meetings that they, that you were like, we can't do that?
23:07 Speaker 03 Well, he would usually promise that we could do things a bit faster.
23:10 Speaker 02 Right.
23:11 Speaker 03 And maybe a bit better than we actually could. So, because I had spent a very long time in law school, before I got there, I had a habit of calling our lawyers to ask if we could do certain things, or not do certain things, before I would propose them. And every now and then, I would get yelled at very badly when one of the lawyer's invoices would cross Alexander's desk. And he would say, "Why were you calling them?" And funnily enough, it's actually Giuliani's law firm. So it seems a lot more.
23:42 Speaker 02 Whatever it is.
23:43 Speaker 03 Yeah. Seems a lot different, looking back on it, than it was at the time. But I was seeking their advice to make sure that whatever I was promising a client I could do, I could legally do in that country.
23:53 Speaker 02 Right.
23:53 Speaker 03 And I would get told that. We had enough expertise in-house. If the data scientists told me we could do it, then I could and I should stop creating invoices.
24:03 Speaker 02 All right. So we're going to get back, we're going to talk about what happened with Cambridge Analytica itself. Some people think it's a tempest in a teapot. Other people think it's absolutely the example of the kind of abuse that started online and continues to do that. We're here with Brittany Kaiser, whose new book is called "Targeted: The Cambridge Analytica Whistleblower's Inside Story of How Big Data, Trump, and Facebook Broke Democracy and How It Can Happen Again." We're going to take a quick break now. We'll be back after this.
24:27 Speaker 04 It's me, the We don't need the jingle twice. Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights, and rental cars. Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app. Fine. No one deals more deals than Please stop. Touche. Priceline.
24:59 Speaker 05 How about a latte?
25:00 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
25:01 Speaker 05 Vanilla?
25:02 Speaker 01 Caramel?
25:03 Speaker 05 Blueberry?
25:04 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup pie varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee. No effort, no grind, no settling. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
25:24 Speaker 02 We're here with Brittany Kaiser. Her new book is called "Targeted." It's about the Cambridge Analytica scandal. Talk a little bit about that. You're calling yourself a whistleblower. Now whistleblowers are in the news these days, and you're an identified whistleblower. Why do you think you're a whistleblower? What do you imagine that you have done?
25:43 Speaker 03 So being a whistleblower means that you're able to provide information that is for the public good, that is original and useful.
25:53 Speaker 03 I've spent the past almost two years of my life doing that.
25:57 Speaker 02 Talking to parliament and other government organizations.
26:02 Speaker 03 I've worked with over 12 different investigations around the world, let alone the amount of journalists and academic researchers that have relied on me for both on and off the record information.
26:13 Speaker 02 Okay, talk about the Cambridge Analytica thing, because that was at the center of it to begin with.
26:17 Speaker 03 Yeah, so I originally started working with The Guardian last March in 2018, specifically to provide documents around Facebook and Brexit that I knew that I had. This is before I realized that I actually had access to my entire work computer. I thought I just had some specific emails that were still saved on my phone. So I talked to Paul Hilder, the activist that I was friends with at the time, and said, "Okay, I'm seeing some things in the news that I actually have more evidence about.
26:55 Speaker 03 You know, what do you think I should do? Because some of the news that I'm seeing is not actually accurate. It's not what happened. And I think I have a lot of information that would be useful." And so he was more than kind and said, "You know, I don't think you should let other people tell this story. What are you going to do about it? Do you want to tell your own story?" And he connected me with Paul Lewis, who at the time was bureau chief of The Guardian in San Francisco and had been writing a lot recently. You know, there had been the expose with Sandy Perikelos out of Facebook. And he talked about the wider problems in the data industry in the same way that I saw them.
27:38 Speaker 02 So tell him how you see them. What did you see having happened?
27:42 Speaker 03 What I saw was that Cambridge Analytica was one very bad example of how easy it is for data to be abused, that over the past decade or more, our data has been... Collected in a way that we have not been fully transparent about. And that data has been collected and sold all over the world to be used for whatever people want to use it for, without the knowledge of the individuals that produce that.
28:12 Speaker 02 Which is what you were selling at Cambridge Analytica itself. So, explain what they did that got them in trouble with Facebook, for people who don't know.
28:20 Speaker 03 Right. So, for people that don't understand what happened there, there was a program at Facebook for about five years where you could be a developer on their platform, and you would get access to their data feed, an API that is now known as the Friends API. And when you developed an app on that, it meant that when somebody consented to use that app, they were consenting for their data to be shared with the developer. But unfortunately with this API-
28:50 Speaker 02 These third-party developers.
28:51 Speaker 03 Exactly. A third-party developer that had paid Facebook for the opportunity to develop. You would get access to the individuals that then used that app, but also all of their friends. And there's no legal construct in the world that allows one adult to consent on behalf of another able-bodied adult.
29:10 Speaker 02 Well, it's called Facebook or Instagram, but go ahead.
29:12 Speaker 03 Right. And so, this API allowed at least 40,000 developers to have access to, if they had the reach, to all of the personal data of everybody on Facebook. And Cambridge Analytica was working with a developer that made one of these apps. And this app had just enough money put behind it that they were able to have over 30,000 people engage with that application, and therefore had the data of probably most people on Facebook that were relevant to Cambridge at the time.
29:47 Speaker 02 Right. And they were using it to target people in elections. Correct.
29:51 Speaker 03 Yes.
29:51 Speaker 02 Did you object to them doing this? Why do you think it's a bad example, from your perspective?
29:56 Speaker 03 Oh, I mean, a very bad example in terms of
29:59 Speaker 02 Of abuse, yeah.
30:00 Speaker 03 in terms of the range of how
30:02 Speaker 02 I think it's very typical of what happens with your data. I think we just don't uncover it. But explain why you think this is a bad example.
30:08 Speaker 03 I think it's a bad example because most advertisers around the world that probably have used the same data set and might even still be using this data set, they are probably not using divisive rhetoric in order to run their campaigns.
30:24 Speaker 02 Sure.
30:25 Speaker 03 So if they're selling cars, they're selling cars. They're probably not going to create incitement of racial hatred or violence while undertaking their communications campaign. So although data might be abused in some ways, it doesn't actually open up to a litany of other offenses, which I think Cambridge Analytica was probably involved in.
30:47 Speaker 02 Right, to use it. And so when you started to decide to do something like that, do you think it's been overblown? I'm just, Facebook pushed that out a lot, that it's been overblown and that this was a rogue operation by something that they shut down. I was at the meeting where he opened it up to third parties, and I remember thinking, this is going to be a problem. Because I knew some of the third parties. I was like, they don't seem very, they seem somewhat sketchy. Some of them are going to go out of business. What happens to data?
31:16 Speaker 03 Right, so it would be very convenient for Mark to say that, of course, that there is one rogue actor. Unfortunately, it was Facebook's negligent policies that allowed anybody to take advantage of this data. And unfortunately, that was not the only weakness of Facebook. And most of the weaknesses that were shown through this scandal and through the continued proliferation of this conversation in the news, I think are putting pressure on companies, not just Facebook, but anybody else who has been lax about their data protection policies, to realize that this isn't going to go away. People are not going to stop caring that they've been exploited and manipulated, and that
32:00 Speaker 03 until these problems are fixed, we're not going to give up on it.
32:03 Speaker 02 So we're going to talk about that in the next session, but when you say these problems are fixed, do you think that Cambridge Analytica actually did anything wrong, or just took advantage of the system as it was?
32:12 Speaker 03 I think Cambridge took advantage of the system as it was, just like any of the other developers on Facebook, but then used that data in order to take advantage of Facebook tools that Unfortunately, so had massive discord within the United States and in other countries. It wasn't just Cambridge. There were other organizations involved. But I was there a month after the election when we got shown two days of what they did in the campaign and in the Super PAC. And a lot of the content that I saw was absolutely horrific.
32:46 Speaker 02 So what did you think at the time? What did you think you were doing?
32:49 Speaker 03 Well, I wasn't on the Trump campaign or on the Super PAC. And we weren't allowed to know what they were doing on a day-to-day basis.
32:57 Speaker 02 But they were bragging about it afterwards.
32:59 Speaker 03 Well, a month afterwards, we did an official debrief. It was two whole days of them actually showing us, here's the full methodology of what we did, the research we did, how we collected data, how we built the database, how we deployed it. This is all of the briefings that we would give on a daily and weekly basis. Here's how it was used to plan everything from where Trump was going to do speeches and rallies to how we were going to communicate with people on social media, to door-knocking and the whole shebang, right?
33:28 Speaker 02 Which Brad Parsiel was involved with.
33:31 Speaker 03 Of course, yeah. He was overseeing it in his San Antonio office. But his office was filled with Cambridge Analytica employees. And so they presented to us everything that was done in the campaign. And then in DC, David Bossie, our friend from Citizens United, was running the "Defeat Crooked Hillary" Super PAC, which, thank God, the Federal Elections Commission did not allow that to be the actual name. But they tried to register it. It was called the "Make America Number One" Super PAC. And they ran the "Defeat Crooked Hillary" campaign, which was 100% negative. It was all negative campaigning, nothing else. And some of the content from the campaign and the Super PAC.
34:14 Speaker 02 So what did you think?
34:15 Speaker 03 I didn't expect it to be that bad.
34:17 Speaker 02 Right. And so was that willful ignorance on your part and the part of other employees there?
34:23 Speaker 03 Well, we weren't allowed to see what they were doing on a day-to-day basis. It's the firewall laws. So unless we saw a piece of paper coming out of the printer, we weren't on any emails, in any meetings.
34:34 Speaker 02 So what did you feel after this happened?
34:38 Speaker 03 Shock and shame that I could have been there throughout that entire process and not known.
34:46 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
34:47 Speaker 03 And kind of, I don't know, I suppose, very confused that this was all done targeting people, using data, and they had no idea why they were seeing this misinformation on their newsfeed. This misinformation came onto their newsfeed because they were shown to be persuadable, they were shown to probably be neurotic and easily motivated by emotional fear-based messaging. And that's above and beyond a normal political campaign and what they would do.
35:19 Speaker 02 Is it now?
35:20 Speaker 03 That's what I am here to talk about because maybe it's not. Maybe a lot more people are taking advantage of these tools because it's so easy to take advantage of these tools.
35:32 Speaker 02 I'm of the belief they're architected that way. It's a gun. It's a gun. It's a gun. It's a gun. And everyone's surprised that it shoots a bullet, you know?
35:41 Speaker 03 Yeah.
35:42 Speaker 02 They pretend it's not a gun, but it's a gun.
35:43 Speaker 03 Nobody should be surprised anymore.
35:45 Speaker 02 Yeah, nobody should be surprised. So what did you do at this time when you found out about this?
35:49 Speaker 03 So, we spent quite-
35:54 Speaker 02 Here's Nick's excited about what they've done. I remember that victory lap that they took.
36:00 Speaker 03 Yeah. We spent about, I don't know, we only had a couple of days after that to kind of digest the information and to start dealing with what was going to happen going forward. We were supposed to completely stop all political work altogether and translate our Trump victory into a commercial enterprise. So somehow we were supposed to explain Trump in a way that would allow people to, you know, sell toothpaste in cars.
36:33 Speaker 02 Right. Saying, "We did it. We did this."
36:36 Speaker 03 We did this.
36:37 Speaker 02 Right.
36:38 Speaker 03 And when they had shown us that debrief, there was a huge confrontation between me and some other people in the New York office that were supposed to be doing commercial work and the people who had just undertaken the Trump campaign and Super PAC work of- How are we supposed to use any of this? All of this material is so offensive. We don't actually understand how to translate this. If you guys just showed us, you know, impact numbers, people that went to the polls, okay, great. But everything you've just shown us is kind of horrific. There's no way that anybody running a company is going to actually buy this. This doesn't make any sense whatsoever.
37:19 Speaker 03 So after spending quite a while being more than offended and trying to figure out what to do, I actually moved to Mexico.
37:31 Speaker 03 At the time, I wasn't in a place to be able to quit my job, unfortunately. I wish I could have been. And so I decided to go open a new office where I wouldn't have to work with Alexander or with anyone that had worked on the Trump campaign. And I could start my own business within their umbrella. So I actually still had financial support from them, even though it was quite small, and just get away from all of that.
37:57 Speaker 02 And when did you leave? You stayed there for...
38:00 Speaker 03 I left a couple of days after that presentation.
38:03 Speaker 02 Right, from Mexico. But you were still with the company?
38:06 Speaker 03 I was still with the company.
38:06 Speaker 02 Why not leave the company?
38:09 Speaker 03 Maybe I should have applied for other jobs then. But I wasn't financially stable. My dad had just had brain surgery.
38:20 Speaker 03 It wasn't a thought that came to my mind.
38:23 Speaker 02 Did you understand the gravity of what the company had done?
38:29 Speaker 03 I suppose I did. But, well, I guess I suppose I didn't. I was shocked that Donald Trump had actually won because I was told the entire time that he wasn't ever going to win and that this was all a commercial exercise. So the idea that...
38:46 Speaker 02 Trump is a commercial exercise?
38:48 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's actually how the conversation started with us and Donald Trump, that he was going to run for president.
38:56 Speaker 02 And create a TV show.
38:57 Speaker 03 And that it would be a perfect opportunity for him to test his messaging and find his audience. So I just never thought that he was actually going to win. And it took a long time to kind of process that that had happened.
39:10 Speaker 02 So you eventually left the company?
39:12 Speaker 03 I did, yeah.
39:13 Speaker 02 Yeah. What was that like?
39:16 Speaker 03 That was a massive confrontation between me and Alexander, actually. So I had spent a long time trying to get the company to make more ethical decisions. I'd gotten in a fight with him over my office registering to work in elections when he actually wanted to put it through a commercial company and hide the fact that we were doing political work. He wanted our data scientists to be the people making decisions about data compliance instead of lawyers, et cetera and so forth. And that built up to the point where I finally told him to go fuck himself in a meeting and left.
40:01 Speaker 02 And that was your last to never come back? And by this time, had he gotten caught on tape making ridiculous bragging or anything like that? But they were still dining out on the Trump victory, essentially.
40:12 Speaker 03 Still dining out on the Trump victory for a long time. And it continued to become more and more offensive, given that I was living in Mexico and working with my friends there and developing great relationships with companies and the government. And I was really excited about the work that I was doing.
40:30 Speaker 02 Which was commercial work?
40:32 Speaker 03 Mostly commercial, but some political as well for candidates that I believed in. And I believed that I was actually going to have an opportunity to use these tools for what they should be used for.
40:45 Speaker 02 Right. All right. So when the Cambridge Analytica thing broke, what did you think? They got caught having abused this platform.
40:52 Speaker 03 Yeah, so when I first saw the Facebook story break in the news, I thought, huh. I have an email where my chief data scientist promises Facebook that he deleted this data in January 2016.
41:11 Speaker 02 Right.
41:12 Speaker 03 So they still had it.
41:13 Speaker 02 Right.
41:14 Speaker 03 Huh. I wonder what else went wrong if I'm to...
41:20 Speaker 03 Actually reflect upon everything that happened to me.
41:24 Speaker 02 So the chief data scientist promised Facebook, so Facebook is off the hook in that way. Do you think they are?
41:29 Speaker 03 No, because I don't think an email from a data scientist that is using this data for commercial purposes and political purposes, that an email saying, yes, we deleted everything, is a legitimate interaction.
41:44 Speaker 02 I would agree.
41:45 Speaker 03 Over a data protection violation that vast.
41:48 Speaker 02 Yeah.
41:49 Speaker 03 Why was there no contract? Why was there no forensic analysis of the database?
41:54 Speaker 02 Right.
41:54 Speaker 03 Why was there no temporary banning of Cambridge on their actual, you know, commercial relationship with Facebook? The email ends with the chief policy officer of Facebook signing off, basically thanking Dr. Alex Taylor and signing her name, Ally, instead of Allison, as, you know, a show of friendly, a show of friendliness to say, you know, oh, this is all cleared up.
42:24 Speaker 02 Yeah.
42:24 Speaker 03 Everything's okay.
42:26 Speaker 02 So no follow-up, no enforcement of their rules.
42:29 Speaker 03 Zero enforcement.
42:29 Speaker 02 Zero enforcement. And was that known within Cambridge Analytica? They're not going to do anything. We can just plunder this data as much as we want?
42:36 Speaker 03 No, because when this came up in 2015, at first, the entire company froze and was terrified about breaking a relationship with Facebook.
42:48 Speaker 02 Right.
42:49 Speaker 03 And so the entire company was very well aware of, we were meant to tread carefully and apparently, one of the data sets we had, we weren't supposed to have, so we were going to delete it. It was a very big deal.
43:01 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
43:01 Speaker 03 And handled, as far as I knew, very sensitively and very seriously.
43:05 Speaker 02 Right, right. But the enforcement by Facebook was lax.
43:08 Speaker 03 The enforcement by Facebook was nonexistent.
43:11 Speaker 02 All right. When we get back, we're going to talk about that and what we need to do going into this next election. And what do you think the repercussions of this, what happened at Cambridge Analytica and elsewhere, are? We're here with Brittany Kaiser. Her book is called Targeted: The Cambridge Analytica Whistleblower's Inside Story of How Big Data, Trump, and Facebook Broke Democracy and How It Can Happen Again.
43:31 Speaker 04 It's me, the
43:36 Speaker 04 We don't need the jingle twice.
43:39 Speaker 04 Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights, and rental cars.
43:47 Speaker 04 Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app. Fine. No one deals more deals than Please stop. Touche. Priceline.
44:01 Speaker 05 How about a latte?
44:02 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
44:03 Speaker 05 Vanilla?
44:04 Speaker 01 Caramel?
44:05 Speaker 05 Blueberry?
44:06 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor, or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup pie varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee.
44:18 Speaker 01 No effort, no grind, no settling.
44:23 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
44:28 Speaker 02 We're here with Brittany Kaiser. She's the author of Targeted. It's a new book about the inside story of the Cambridge Analytica scandal. There's another one out by Chris Wiley, who is in the technical part of that. He was also a whistleblower. It's interesting. How do you look at that book? You're coming out at the same time, but you're talking about similar issues from different viewpoints.
44:46 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, I think the more information that's out there, the better, as long as it's accurate. Unfortunately, the few pages that I've seen of his is not accurate.
44:56 Speaker 02 What's not accurate about it?
44:58 Speaker 03 I've only seen the parts that he wrote about me because people have sent me photos of them.
45:01 Speaker 02 So what is not accurate?
45:02 Speaker 03 I was told that it says in the book that I was Director of Operations of the Leave EU Campaign for Brexit, even though we were, at the time, an unpaid consultant. There was no official title or involvement whatsoever. And there's quite a few things in there that say that I consulted to Julian Assange's legal team.
45:28 Speaker 03 Never happened. I did pro bono work for a human rights law firm that also represented him, but.
45:35 Speaker 02 Well, he's trying to say you were knee deep in it, presumably.
45:38 Speaker 03 Yeah, exactly. So it's just unfortunately a bit of misinformation in there. But, you know, he could have asked me and I could have given him the accurate information.
45:49 Speaker 02 Sure, sure. But in terms of what you both were doing, we're trying to unveil the same thing, which is abuse of data.
45:55 Speaker 03 Of course, and I totally support him in doing that.
45:58 Speaker 02 Right.
45:58 Speaker 03 100%. I actually, in fact, wish that more whistleblowers would come out of companies that have abused data so that we can right this wrong faster than we are right now.
46:07 Speaker 02 So you're saying Facebook is nonexistent, destroyed democracy, meaning not just with the American election, but that's had repercussions even today, right now, we're seeing in Syria and other places, but also repercussions across the globe. What do you imagine if Facebook had done nothing, what should they have been doing at this time? Understanding their power or what?
46:30 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, being a little bit more open about the fact that they were not prepared to make the changes that they needed to make to keep people safe. If you think about some of the basic things that they did wrong, okay, let's start with basic know your customer, anti-money laundering, identification of individuals who are purchasing political advertising on Facebook. So you have to be an American or an American registered organization with the FEC in order to buy political ads. Now somehow Facebook allowed people with a Russian credit card from a Russian bank to pay in rubles from Russia for political advertising.
47:15 Speaker 03 Now that's something that inherently in the platform should not be allowed, that shouldn't be a loophole. There's an easy technology fix for that. If you're a $500 billion company, that is a quick fix for a very small budget.
47:28 Speaker 02 Who they're doing business with. Right, all right.
47:31 Speaker 03 100%.
47:32 Speaker 02 The other is enforcement of data that's used by third parties, which they have sort of clamped down on.
47:37 Speaker 03 Well, by clamping down, they told everybody, you're not allowed to use our data anymore. Have they actually gone to those 40,000 developers?
47:45 Speaker 02 And gotten it back.
47:46 Speaker 03 And to the millions of companies that that data was then sold on to and. Made them delete it?
47:51 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
47:51 Speaker 03 No.
47:52 Speaker 02 No.
47:52 Speaker 03 Not that I know of. I think we'd know.
47:54 Speaker 02 Right.
47:55 Speaker 03 If they were doing something like that. And kudos to them if they are.
47:58 Speaker 02 And what else?
48:00 Speaker 03 What else? Well, it's really-
48:03 Speaker 02 Abuse of the system by foreign malcontents and governments aiming at messing up the system.
48:09 Speaker 03 Of course. And unfortunately, I've seen Mark Zuckerberg go on television and say that he doesn't have the ability to measure hate speech. Now, this is a huge problem considering hate speech and misinformation on his platforms caused a genocide in Myanmar besides violence and hatred around the world when it goes completely unchecked. Now, I have worked for very many organizations that have been using very basic data in order to measure hate speech. The International Criminal Court has interns doing it. The United Nations, many departments do it. Big NGOs do it all the time. Amnesty International certainly helps do that.
48:50 Speaker 03 How is a company that is worth that much money lacking in all abilities to measure hate speech when this is an easy investment into some data scientists and data engineers that can start solving this problem with psychologists and experts? It's not a huge investment to stop people from killing each other because they're using your platform.
49:12 Speaker 02 So what would be the reason for doing it? They say they're working on all these things. Of course, it's late. It's rather late in the game to have, having done this. Secondly, they continue down roads of not taking things down. The Nancy Pelosi video and explaining or labeling things, the recent re-announcement of something they were already doing, which was allowing politicians to lie in ads, but then delete any links that are lies, which was sort of confusing on some level.
49:37 Speaker 03 Very confusing.
49:37 Speaker 02 How do you assess how they think of things now?
49:41 Speaker 03 I think that the direct, there's a direct contrast in trying to say that they are upholding free speech. And being a publisher and being held liable for nothing. Absolutely nothing. Now, I've spoken to a lot of executives from big news organizations who are livid that one of the biggest publishing platforms in the world is not held liable for what they allow people to publish. Now, we've heard all of Facebook's excuses for why they don't fall under these laws, but I don't really understand how they themselves can continue to purport that when the amount
50:25 Speaker 03 of crimes and violence and death that has come out of that has gone completely unchecked. You know, just if you hold your mouse over an image and you all of a sudden see a tag that it's a political ad, or that video or image has been manipulated. Is that enough to stop people from believing in its content and seeing it anyway? And there are these essential questions. You know, I'm not someone that is going to claim that censorship is 100% the right answer, but there has to be some better policing and management of content because you can be sure if the New York Times or the Washington Post published even a small percentage of
51:07 Speaker 03 what goes through Facebook, the entire executive board would be in jail.
51:11 Speaker 02 Right. So why doesn't that happen? From what you're... You worked with them. What was your impression of Facebook people when you worked with them?
51:18 Speaker 03 Well, I actually didn't have that much individual interaction with Facebook. Sometimes they would visit the office in order to show my digital buying team, in order to sell new tools to them, show them how to use the new stuff that they had. But in general, I didn't have a day-to-day interaction with Facebook. Some of my friends have in the past. Some of the people that I worked with had their direct relationships with Facebook, and it was very much a buyer-seller relationship. You know, if we were willing to buy something from them, they were willing to do anything to let us do that.
51:52 Speaker 02 All right. And so what should happen then? Here you are, a company that's unchecked by any regulatory agency, although they're trying in Europe, they're trying all... And you've testified in front of the things. What do you imagine is going to happen? And what has to happen for it not to happen next? As you talk about it, how it can... Happen again. Explain how it can happen again and then what needs to be done about it.
52:12 Speaker 03 It can happen again for quite a few reasons. One, I would say that this election is going to be even more contentious than the last one. Someone that's trying to stay in power, from all of my former work and research about what goes on in politics around the world, someone trying to stay in power wields as much use of tools as they possibly can.
52:34 Speaker 02 Especially with the walls coming in.
52:36 Speaker 03 They pull up all the, yeah, they pull out all the stops. And so, any of the tools and the hatred and the violence that came out of the last election is sure to be exponentially worse this time, because there aren't, there aren't really any tools to stop that from happening. And so, where I really hope that regulators and legislators are going to concentrate are on solving multiple problems at once. It's not going to be one law. You know, it's not, it's not just monopoly legislation that's going to help, it's not just data protection legislation, it's not just, you know, further definitions and policing of hate speech and voter suppression. It's going to have to be all of those.
53:18 Speaker 03 Unfortunately, the good and the bad thing about cutting-edge technology is that it moves a lot faster than the law does. That's a good thing, when technology is doing things that better humanity. It's a really bad thing when it goes completely unchecked for so many years that now there are all these problems that we never foresaw. And I'm not going to say that all of this is Facebook's fault. A lot of these were problems that nobody predicted could have possibly happened. But the fact is, we have identified a lot of problems right now. And if the proper investment is not happening via Facebook to actually solve these problems and we're not seeing the results of that, then unfortunately, I think we've given them quite a lot of time to prove that they're making a difference. And they haven't proved anything to me.
54:03 Speaker 03 They certainly haven't proven anything to other people I know that have left Facebook. I don't know if you ever have spoken to Yala Eisenstahl?
54:11 Speaker 03 So after her six months of head of elections integrity, she was told no, no, and no to everything she suggested as a cybersecurity and intelligence expert on how to protect people ahead of elections. So if they're going to say no and not invest in the changes that we need to see, then unfortunately, they need to be legislated and regulated.
54:29 Speaker 02 So what would you do? I hear you have Elizabeth Warren. I mean, well, Mark is having dinner with, I don't know, Tucker Carlson. It's a joke, but he was. He's snarking about Elizabeth Warren in meetings, not having meetings with her.
54:41 Speaker 03 Right.
54:42 Speaker 02 He did put a post out, so it was a little self-aggrandizing and self-righteous. Oh, I meet with lots of people and it's important to talk to people. I was like, listen, Ellen of social media, you didn't have dinner with Elizabeth Warren, as far as I can tell, or that I know about.
54:55 Speaker 03 No, because she's an existential threat, apparently, to his company.
54:58 Speaker 02 Yes, exactly. So what should be the legislation, then, from your perspective?
55:01 Speaker 03 So there's a number of things. Number one, in terms of my viewpoint, is the way that they handle data. Right now, there is no transparency into what you're actually agreeing to by using Facebook, all of the different places they're collecting data from you, how they're using it, and if there is any way for people to have knowledge into that. So the transparency and consent mechanisms need to change completely. Next would be the policing of what is actually published on Facebook. And there's going to be a lot of people who love the right to free speech that are going to be terrified at some of the things I'm going to say. But I'm sorry, incitement of racial hatred and violence is not OK.
55:44 Speaker 03 And we need to find a way to make sure that language and content that is insightful of that doesn't have a place on Facebook and doesn't have a place anywhere where you can pay to put that in front of people. We need to find ways to do that. It's not just going to be a law, it's going to be a technology solution, to be honest. But with that amount of money and that amount of data scientists and engineers, it should be easier for Facebook to fix. I just don't have any proof that they're trying to fix it. And then there needs to be... Relationships between our actual laws, not just data protection laws, but electoral laws and what is allowed in the Facebook platform. As I said, you shouldn't be able to log in from another country and purchase in another
56:29 Speaker 03 currency political ads in America when it's illegal for you to do so. There should be checks and balances.
56:35 Speaker 02 The FEC will never catch it. It will never catch all of it, really.
56:38 Speaker 03 That's the problem.
56:39 Speaker 02 I mean, right now, they don't even have enough people to have a quorum. That's another issue. So what do you think the chances are of this happening?
56:48 Speaker 03 Well, there's quite a lot of good legislation that's currently sitting, waiting to be considered. Actually, my favorite that I didn't talk about yet is Elizabeth Warren's law, the Corporate Executive Accountability Act, which means that instead of civil fines, if a company through negligence allows a massive data leak or to be hacked, then that will be a criminal penalty. So people like Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sandberg would be in jail by now. And I think that is so incredibly important because executives from big tech are so completely removed from the consequences of how people use their platforms or how people abuse their platforms.
57:29 Speaker 03 And so the idea that you can get away with a small fine as opposed to actually having criminal liability, I think, will change the incentive structure quite a lot for people to take data protection very seriously.
57:41 Speaker 02 Right.
57:42 Speaker 03 And it's not saying if you just happen to get hacked, you should go to jail. No. It's saying through negligence, like with Equifax and Facebook. Equifax had over 300 security certificates expire before they were hacked. They didn't implement over 8,500 updates to their software systems. That's a problem.
57:59 Speaker 02 It's negligence.
58:00 Speaker 03 You know, it's complete negligence.
58:01 Speaker 02 To jail.
58:02 Speaker 03 It's through negligence, then you would receive criminal liabilities.
58:05 Speaker 02 So did you ever think about working for Elizabeth Warren?
58:08 Speaker 03 I mean, I'd love to sit down with her, of course. She's amazing.
58:12 Speaker 02 Do you think you lost your way? That movie really showed you sort of wandering around in suitcases, rolling through airports.
58:19 Speaker 03 Yeah.
58:20 Speaker 02 Felt a lot like that.
58:21 Speaker 03 Yeah.
58:21 Speaker 02 Oddly, in a Thai pool. I don't know why you were doing that.
58:25 Speaker 03 Yeah, I got distracted and let the wrong priorities take over my decision-making, unfortunately. But it's never too late to do the right thing.
58:35 Speaker 02 What do you do now? What do you do now for...
58:37 Speaker 03 So I run two different nonprofits. One of them is completely new. It's the Own Your Data Foundation.
58:44 Speaker 02 I see you're wearing a necklace that says that.
58:45 Speaker 03 Yes. So we work on digital literacy training. We're starting first in schools. So we're teaching teachers and parents how to implement digital literacy education for kids. So that's everything from understanding your data rights to how to behave with empathy online, how to know how to protect yourself, basic cybersecurity protocols, which I think should really be part of every computer lesson that kids go through. You shouldn't know how to type without understanding what typing words into a software program means. So that's one side. And then I also co-founded a year and a half ago the Digital Asset Trade Association, DATA.
59:28 Speaker 03 We are a 501(c)(6), so a lobbying nonprofit. And we help legislators connect with technologists so that they can create common sense legislation in technology.
59:40 Speaker 02 How much do you think there's going to be common sense regulation?
59:44 Speaker 03 Well, I think, right now, a lot of the laws have come from a need that has been shown. And I think it's very important for technologists, and very important for ethical technologists, to be in direct conversation with Congress, because we're at a very sensitive time right now, where if technology is over-legislated and over-regulated...
1:00:06 Speaker 02 Right.
1:00:06 Speaker 03 Then we're going to stifle innovation and just send companies to other countries. And that's not what we want to do. What we want to do is find a balance of being able to protect people and also protect entrepreneurship, because data and technology can solve a lot of the world's problems. And that's how I got into this mess in the first place, by hoping that that's all it could do.
1:00:26 Speaker 02 All right. Do you think Facebook is ethical?
1:00:29 Speaker 03 Right now, no.
1:00:31 Speaker 02 Can it be?
1:00:32 Speaker 03 Yes, it definitely can be. I mean, I'm still on Facebook. I don't want Facebook to cease to exist. I just want them to stop abusing people. I understand why it was first created and, you know, connecting people should inherently be good. It's still possible for that to happen, but really serious steps need to be taken. And I think we've given them more than enough time to make those decisions, and I haven't seen it yet.
1:00:57 Speaker 02 All right, Brittany, that's great. Thank you so much. Good luck with your book. It is called Targeted: Cambridge Analytica whistleblowers' insight story of how big data, Trump, and Facebook broke democracy and how it can happen again. Let's hope it does not, but we have to do something about it, not just hope.
1:01:11 Speaker 03 Agreed.
1:01:12 Speaker 02 Anyway, thank you for coming on the show. You can follow me on Twitter at Kara Swisher. My executive producer, Eric Anderson, is at EricaAmerica. My producer, Eric Johnson, is at HeyHeyESJ. Brittany, where can people find you online on these organizations?
1:01:23 Speaker 03 Right, so if you go to LinkedIn.com/OwnYourData and Facebook.com/OwnYourData, also OwnYourData.Foundation.
1:01:33 Speaker 02 Okay, and you're getting funding from various tech groups? What?
1:01:37 Speaker 03 Yep, we... Most of my work has been pro bono. Actually, nearly all of it has been pro bono. So we just founded this foundation so that hopefully we can work with tech companies who want to be a part of solving these problems.
1:01:49 Speaker 02 Okay. If you liked this episode, we'd really appreciate it if you shared it with a friend. And make sure to check out our new podcast, Reset. Just search for it in your podcasting app of choice. Thanks also to our editor, Joel Robb. Thanks for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. I'll be back here on Friday. Tune in then.
1:02:43 Speaker 06 20th Century Studios presents Whale Fall. The most incredible survival thriller of the year. I need the whale! Help me! In theaters Friday. To survive the unthinkable, do the impossible. You're gonna become so dangerous that the predators can't help but let you go. Austin Abrams. I'm going home! Josh Brodel. Survivor, survivor. Whale Fall. Rated PG-13. Maybe inappropriate for children under 13. In theaters Friday. Get tickets now.
Previous Recode Decode: Rosetta Stone President Matt Hulett Next Recode Decode: Ken Burns Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated