Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Senator Amy Klobuchar About this episode Amy Klobuchar, the senior U. S. Senator from Minnesota who is running for the Democratic Party's nomination in the 2020 presidential race, talks with Recode's Kara Swisher in front of a live audience at South by Southwest.
In this episode: The infamous comb incident; why Klobuchar thinks she can win; big pharma and big tech; why Klobuchar is aiming for the center while her fellow Democrats are pulling left; what she learned from studying Hillary Clinton's 2016 loss; the crowded Democratic field; the need for urgent action on climate change; Elizabeth Warren's proposal to break up the tech companies and Klobuchar's own agenda for tech; should Facebook and Google be broken up?; the prospects of a federal data privacy bill; does Klobuchar trust tech companies?; do they like her?; Paul Manafort's initial prison sentence; the Mueller Report; President's Trump's coziness with Vladimir Putin and his attacks on the press; impeachment; Rep. Ilhan Omar's comments on Israel; and what politicians Klobuchar looks up to.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 12,102 words · 8 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Companies shouldn't have to choose between speed and control. Amex Corporate connects cards with flexible spending controls and real-time visibility to help teams adapt faster. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is Amex Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:26 Speaker 01 You could try to find the perfect coffee to water ratio. Or you could press a button. With Keurig, each K-cup pod is precision measured for a perfectly delicious cup. No effort, no grind, no math required.
0:43 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
0:49 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, the editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as someone who would never eat salad with a comb, for goodness sake. I eat it with a brush. But in my spare time, I talk tech. And you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today, we're going to play a live interview I did recently with Amy Klobuchar, the senior United States senator from Minnesota. But as you might have heard, she's trying to get a new job, president of the United States. We spoke at South by Southwest in Austin, Texas. Let's take a listen.
1:25 Speaker 02 Well, welcome here. I'm so excited to kick this off. Senator Klobuchar, I usually just beat up tech executives, so this is going to be good. Like Mark Zuckerberg? With Mark Zuckerberg, yeah. Okay. But he's too easy. I'm ready. All right. So I asked, I met with Senator Klobuchar backstage, and we're talking about a bunch of things. And I asked her if she wanted to start with the comb or end with the comb. So we're going to start with the comb. I have to, I have to. I'm not a political reporter. Some of this, I have a son who is voting in the next election. And I asked him about it, and he said, "That's the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard as a topic." My other son, who's 13, said, "What kind of salad was it?" And other people are varying things.
2:09 Speaker 02 So what was your reaction to that story in The New York Times?
2:13 Speaker 03 Well, first of all, hello, everyone. Before I get to the com, it is great to be in Austin. I love this town. I actually, a few times ago when I was here, I got to rent a bicycle and by myself rode around for three hours and got lost. And it was just this incredible experience. So it's really good to be back and good to be here with you. I figure if I can make it through an announcement in the blizzard, in my permanent snow globe, I can make it through our interview. So, of course, no one feels good when they read a story like that. And as I have said, I have high expectations for myself, I have high expectations for
2:53 Speaker 03 the people that work with me, and most importantly, I have high expectations for our country. And for me, that story was about me, the comb story, was me sort of doing a mom thing. I didn't have a fork, I used a comb, to eat a salad, very briefly, on a plane, in a MyGuy ver move. And as I look back at my time in the Senate, I know a few things. I know that I can be tough on people, sometimes too tough, that I can push them too hard, that I can always do better. But I also know that we have incredible people that have worked with me.
3:35 Speaker 03 I wouldn't have been able to pull off what we found out last week, that I was ranked number one of any Democrat in the Senate by Vandermilch on 15 metrics for getting things done in the United States Senate. And I couldn't have done that without staff. And we've also had so many people that have gone on to do incredible things, including a Saul that I just happened to see in the second row, who was my scheduler for three years in Washington, who's now doing great work in the nonprofit sector. And so you move on, you make sure that you have the right staff around you all the time to do a good job, and that's what I'm going to do now in this campaign.
4:17 Speaker 03 It's a fishbowl, you'll be able to watch us and see how I work with our staff, and that's what I'm going to do as president.
4:23 Speaker 02 Why do you think this is the thing they focused on with you? There are a lot of shitty bosses all over the place, I've had a number of them. Why do you think this is what has stuck here? Is it sexist, people have brought that other people have written that it's not sexist, it goes on and on, what do you imagine?
4:40 Speaker 03 You know, I'm not going to go there, and I imagine that other candidates are going to be asked the same thing at some point, and there'll be stories. I was kind of right out with my candidacy, I thought that was really important. If you haven't noticed, I have a little less name ID than a few of the other candidates, and maybe that was why I was right out there right away. But whatever it is, I just can't waste my time analyzing it, because these stakes are too high, and I care too much. That's why I announced my candidacy in the middle of a blizzard by that Mississippi River, because I wanted to make the point that it is time to cross the river of our divides,
5:21 Speaker 03 to stop spending every day looking at the latest tweet and the latest attack, and walk over that sturdy bridge that is our democracy to a new plateau in our politics, to a new ground in our politics. And to me, which is why it's so cool we're here in Austin, is to take on the challenges that are before us, because this is a city that has taken on challenges, that has walked right into the digital world and developed new businesses and new ideas, that is on the cutting edge when it comes to culture and music, and understands that America...
5:59 Speaker 03 America isn't just on the coasts, right? That America, just like Minnesota, is in the heartland of this country and in the heart of Texas.
6:08 Speaker 02 Well, OK. Austin's really nice, the barbecue's great. But what, I want to understand, though, why you, when these things do degenerate, because it is part of the broader culture now, the, how stories pop up like this, they go through their cycles, there's been dozens of them for each of the candidates. What does that say about our political culture now? Because it is a twitchy culture. We have a person who's running this country, who I think is probably the most epic troller of all time on Twitter. How do you?
6:38 Speaker 03 He called me "snow woman."
6:39 Speaker 02 Yes.
6:40 Speaker 03 I like that name, actually.
6:41 Speaker 02 OK.
6:42 Speaker 03 I embraced it.
6:43 Speaker 02 That was, it could have gone so many other ways. How do you imagine that to be? I mean, you say that, "We want to cross the digital, we want to get along, can't we all get..." But life is not a Coca-Cola commercial.
6:54 Speaker 03 It's not just, "Can we get along?" No, no, no, I don't think we think we're all going to get along. I think what we think we can do is have, in the words of my friend John McCain, the last thing he did when I saw him alive on his ranch was to point to some words in his book, which said, "There is nothing more liberating than fighting for a cause larger than yourself."
7:12 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
7:13 Speaker 03 Well, America is that cause right now. And when I see the corrosive divide, instead of trying to find ways to bring us together in times of crisis, he finds ways to bring us apart. This is Donald Trump, every single day. And so that is the number-one thing on people's mind. The second one is to make sure we have someone in the White House that is willing to rise to the challenges of the day, whether they're climate change, whether there's how we handle privacy legislation, immigration reform, something so important in Texas, so important for our economy, something that he doesn't talk about enough, how we handle income inequality. These are the challenges of our day, and because we are spending all of our time being
7:54 Speaker 03 governed by chaos, he is not governing by opportunity, and I want to govern with opportunity.
8:01 Speaker 02 When you think about doing that, what is your path to winning in that way? How do you look at your path? Because first of all, there's the money path, the raising of the inordinate amounts of money. There's the noise of social media. There's the divide. What is your path? Lay it out for us.
8:21 Speaker 03 Well, I start with how I have won every single election that I've ever run in. And that is by going not just where it's comfortable, but where it's uncomfortable. Texas is a great example here, by the way. Look at those congressional races you won in this state, right? That people did not expect that you could win. And if you didn't have candidates that came up and ran in areas that were unexpected, we wouldn't have those seats. So that's what I've done in my own state. And I have won in three U.S. Senate elections, every single congressional district, every single time, including Michelle Bachmann's, okay? And that is in a purple state. And that is in a state that Donald Trump nearly won,
9:06 Speaker 03 which includes winning, he won, a bunch of rural counties that I then went on to win two years later. And that is because I think when you talk to people in rural areas, you quickly find out that rural poverty for kids is just as bad as it can be in urban areas. You quickly find out that they feel like there are people in urban areas that think that their food just lands on their plate and don't understand the hard work that goes into it. So there are rural hospital issues that are so unique. There are rural broadband issues. And that's why, as president, one of the things, as we talk about tech here, which I think should unite our country, is that, yes, we can be as good as Iceland, okay? We can get broadband...
9:49 Speaker 02 Is that your campaign slogan? Yes, we can be as good as Iceland.
9:52 Speaker 03 I don't think that would really work in the warmer parts of the United States. But the idea is that we should be able to get rural broadband out to every household broadband out by 2022. There is no reason that we can't do that.
10:06 Speaker 02 But your platform, the key platform that you talked about when you were in the snow. Pharma prices, tech, what else?
10:16 Speaker 03 I talked about the idea that we need to have people's back, that everyone matters in this country. And for too long, yes, we want to move to universal health care. And I have ideas for that. But the pharma issue has been neglected, really, under any administration in the last 20 years. They actually think they own Washington. Well, they don't own me. From the very beginning, since the day I got there, I have led bills that have been focused on bringing pharmaceutical prices down. To me, that means more competition. In Minnesota, we can see Canada from our porch. And that means we see these less expensive drugs all the time. So if you were to bring in safer drugs from places like Canada, that's a bill I had with
11:01 Speaker 03 Senator McCain, and now Senator Grassley has agreed to take his place, you could bring down prices. If you stopped the pernicious policy called pay-for-delay, where Big Pharma pays off generics to keep their products off the market, think about how anti-competitive that is. You save 2.9 billion for customers in just a few years. Medicare, allow, unleash that bargaining power of 43 million seniors, and lift the ban on negotiating prices. Those are all pro-consumer issues. Those are all ways to deal with competition and to bring back what I think is a strong system, the capitalist system.
11:43 Speaker 03 But you're not going to have entrepreneurship, like we're seeing in this town, if you allow big companies to buy out other companies and to completely dominate a marketplace. Then you lose competition. It was Adam Smith that said, as much as he loved capitalism, he said that he fears that power of monopolies. Well, that's what's happening right now.
12:04 Speaker 02 Pharma doesn't own you, but it owns Washington. How do you then do anything about it?
12:09 Speaker 03 Well, because it's starting to be such a big political issue that politicians get scared, right?
12:15 Speaker 03 So politicians get scared when there's a crisis, like when we had the financial crisis and then we had to act. Well, you don't want to wait until you get to that moment of a crisis. But right now, the voters clearly said, we don't like what's happening when it comes to farmer prices. Ads were run on it. People who had been too much in their pockets were in trouble and it was used against them. So you are reaching this pinnacle of a political moment where you could actually get action and you've got to seize that moment. And that moment is now and that moment will be when I'm President of the United States.
12:48 Speaker 02 We're going to take a quick break now. We'll be back after this with Senator Amy Klobuchar.
12:55 Speaker 04 It's me, the
12:59 Speaker 04 We don't need the jingle twice. Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights and rental cars.
13:10 Speaker 04 Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app. Fine. No one deals more deals than Please stop. Touche.
13:23 Speaker 04 Priceline.
13:24 Speaker 05 How about a latte?
13:25 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
13:26 Speaker 05 Vanilla?
13:27 Speaker 01 Caramel?
13:27 Speaker 05 Blueberry?
13:28 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup Pod varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee. No effort, no grind, no settling. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
13:51 Speaker 02 When you think about this idea of big, this idea of large companies, we're going to get to tech in a minute. One of the things that you are also doing is sort of the idea that you're in the middle. You're in the middle of the country. You have a more, some people think it's too compromised. There's a lot of pull to the left in the Democratic Party. Talk a little bit about that issue because I think it's, it's hard to resist what's happening within the Democratic Party itself.
14:17 Speaker 03 What I see as our real election model, and that was 2018, when, yes, there's differences in our party. I think that's healthy, that we're not all lockstep. And we certainly are at a moment in time where we need new ideas in our party. So you can have new ideas from the left, from the middle, from the right, but you've got to be open to new ideas. And that's, by the way, how you always get compromised and how you get things done. If you just shut out new ideas, then you're never going to get to a different place in our politics. So I saw in 2018 that people united behind candidates. Yes, there were a few well-known primaries, but in the end, people united behind the candidates. And we elected people like Laura Kelly in Kansas, Democratic governor, who beat Kris Kobach,
15:02 Speaker 03 that people didn't think was possible. In my neighboring state of Wisconsin, we elected a new governor who beat Scott Walker. That happened. And we also elected some exciting new liberal candidates to Congress all over the country. So we have people of all different stripes. The important thing is, we realized that there was a cause greater than ourselves, whatever our individual differences are, and put some new people in, who now can be that check and balance on the Trump administration.
15:33 Speaker 02 So when you have a campaign, and the Trump campaign is going to be sort of scorched earth, it looks like it from this...
15:38 Speaker 03 Really?
15:39 Speaker 02 Yes, I know. Shocking.
15:43 Speaker 02 How do you then push back against that? As a compromised candidate, I'm going to be reasonable. I mean, you tried to do that in the Kavanaugh hearings. You kept your... when he was yelling at you about beer...
15:56 Speaker 03 I wasn't going to go down into that swamp with him, no.
15:59 Speaker 02 You have to possibly go down into that swamp? But even though there, you were lauded for that.
16:04 Speaker 03 You have to pick your moments. And I would say, one of the things that we learned out of 2016, and Hillary Clinton would have been a great president. She had great ideas. She had a great policy platform. But no one had run against someone like Trump before. So this is across the board, not just... Her campaign, everyone didn't know what to do. And it seemed to me that by going down every rabbit hole, that we lost our optimistic economic agenda for America, that we regained, we had cases to make in 2018 that were really important. Don't kick people off their health insurance for pre-existing conditions. So part of this is staying on the issues that matter to you and making sure he doesn't mess around with you.
16:48 Speaker 03 The second thing is, you pick your battles with him, right? You don't go after every single tweet he does. When he called me the Snow Woman, I thought, well, this isn't bad, so let it sit out there for a while. And then I finally said, and something I will do effectively is use humor. I finally said, you know what? I'd like to see how your hair would fare in a blizzard.
17:09 Speaker 02 Yeah.
17:11 Speaker 03 Mr. Umbrella Man. So I think you have to-
17:15 Speaker 02 Is that your nickname for him? Mr. Umbrella Man?
17:17 Speaker 03 No, I just made that up right now.
17:18 Speaker 02 Okay, good.
17:19 Speaker 03 It's not really, it's not like a focus group moment.
17:23 Speaker 02 Yeah.
17:23 Speaker 03 But I, you know, I think that you have to, you have to pick your moments, you have to use humor, and you have to have a different approach to him than we've had before. But when he says things that are racist, when he says things that are anti-immigrant, that are meant to FOMA and hate, yes, you call him on it, but you never lose track of your goal, which is to bring this country together.
17:48 Speaker 02 So in doing that, because a lot of people do the tit-for-tat with him, and they get drawn into his agenda. I think that's absolutely right, that they do.
17:54 Speaker 03 He wants to get on every news cycle. When you have something rolling, like you're decided to announce in the middle of a permanent snow globe, you know, then he wants to get in there. And so you have to decide, how are you going to deal with it, that moment?
18:06 Speaker 02 What did you learn? You were talking about the sort of going down every rabbit hole in the Clinton campaign. What did you learn from that, as you studied that?
18:14 Speaker 03 Well, I learned that, being in a Midwestern heartland state, I learned that there were people, and this is Hillary was so strong on the farm bill and things like that. But I learned that there were people that weren't hearing that, that they felt left out, that they felt that our party, not just her, was not speaking for them. And that is why I've always had this mantra, that you go where it's not just comfortable, you go where it's uncomfortable, you meet people where they are, and you listen to them. And you don't always agree with them. You stand your ground, but you have got to hear them out.
18:49 Speaker 02 So in that, in that sort of middle position, which I think, would you call yourself?
18:53 Speaker 03 By the way, could I use one example, like guns?
18:55 Speaker 02 Right.
18:56 Speaker 03 I come from a prosecutor background. I've always believed that you have to have sensible gun safety legislation. I know we're in Texas right now, which isn't that different than Minnesota when it comes to hunting. So I look at every single proposal in front of me, and I have an F rating for the NRA, let me make this clear. I look at every single proposal before me and I say, does this hurt my uncle Dick in the deer stand? Okay? And when I met your son with his Cabela's shirt telling me that he had shot a boar, that was cool. I started talking to him about that because that's what I look at it. And then I point out that the vast majority of Americans, and even many, many gun owners, believe that we can have universal background checks, right?
19:39 Speaker 03 So you have to make the argument, which doesn't diss all of hunting, a quality of life issue for my, people in my state, but makes the safety argument. Because I sat across from Donald Trump and literally took track. Nine times at that gun meeting we had, I was there because I was leading the gun safety legislation, the school safety legislation with Senator Hatch, and also had a domestic violence bill. Nine times, he said he wanted universal background checks. And the next day, he met with the gun lobby and never got it done.
20:11 Speaker 02 Right.
20:12 Speaker 03 That's wrong.
20:13 Speaker 02 Right. All right. So one of the ideas is getting, being in the centrists. With Biden entering the picture, and you had Sherrod Brown coming out, how do you, he's more of that kind of candidate, like you are more of a centrist. How do you manage, you know, the 412 people running for the Democratic Party?
20:31 Speaker 03 Okay, that, I'm sorry, Kair, that's a bit of an exaggeration. There are a number of great candidates. No, there really are. And I always like to jokingly say, may the best woman win. But...
20:46 Speaker 03 No litmus test, many of them would be good. But I think that competition is good. Barack Obama has told this to people, maybe not publicly, but I've heard he's told a lot of people.
20:58 Speaker 02 Did you have one of those meetings with him?
20:59 Speaker 03 Yes, I did.
21:00 Speaker 02 Okay.
21:01 Speaker 03 He was in a really good mood.
21:02 Speaker 02 All right, okay.
21:03 Speaker 03 He's really happy.
21:04 Speaker 02 Well, why not?
21:04 Speaker 03 And he was really happy about Michelle's book tour, and how well she's doing, and how she's filling stadiums, and that this is her moment. And it was just really quite beautiful to hear him talk about it. But I think that he has always said that competition is good. And I believe that, that you need a competition of ideas, especially now when we've been so stultified by not moving forward of the challenges in front of us. And also, that you want to hear different voices, and from different people in the country. And I am proud to be Heartland candidate. I think you want to hear from the Midwest.
21:40 Speaker 02 All right, in that thing, the idea that, why should you, this was a question I got from Peter, why should we elect a candidate who says, no, that's not possible to do everything progressives want?
21:50 Speaker 03 Because I'm being honest. And I think you want, I think you want honesty. And you can have legitimate differences on how you get places. You know, I want to get to universal health care, and I want to do it with a public option. I think you could do that immediately. That was something that Barack Obama wanted to do with the Affordable Care Act, by expanding Medicaid, or expanding Medicare. I think that we need to move quickly on climate change, which is really the challenge of our time. When you look at the rising sea levels, when you watch that video of that dad driving his young daughter and singing songs to her through that lapping wildfire in Northern California,
22:35 Speaker 03 and you think of people watching that and realizing, that could happen to me. These are things going on all over our country right now. And that's why, as president, I would rejoin the International Climate Change Agreement on day one.
22:48 Speaker 03 Bring back the clean power rules. Bring back the gas mileage standards. Introduce legislation to finally do something on building codes. This is the challenge of our day.
22:59 Speaker 02 That's rolling back what they rolled back. What about Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's Green New Deal? She's here looking for tacos right now, apparently, according to the internets. How do you look at that? Because that's quite...
23:14 Speaker 03 I'm a cosponsor of that. It is a resolution, and I liked to get on that. Why? Not because I thought we could get everything done in 10 years, but because I thought that it harnessed this energy right now to say, "Let's stop admiring this problem and do something about it." Right? That's what that is. And I'm looking forward to seeing Mitch McConnell trying to use that against America, because America believes in science, and they know we have to move on this. They know it's not going to be one-size-fits-all, that we're going to have to use renewable energy, and maybe solar works some places, and wind works other places, and hydro works some places,
23:55 Speaker 03 and we've got to do more with energy efficiency and electric cars and other things. But they know we have to do something. The debate on whether it's happening is over. The debate on how we handle it and how quickly we respond, and whether we're going to be alone against the rest of the world or work with the rest of the world is happening now.
24:14 Speaker 02 But that's precisely what they're doing. They're attacking Ocasio-Cortez personally, which they're doing a lot. She's become their favorite. It's not working particularly well, but...
24:23 Speaker 03 No, not very well. She's good at responding.
24:25 Speaker 02 Yeah. But they are doing that right now. They're around the billionaire stuff, around the taxing, around the Green New Deal, around a lot of these issues.
24:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's what they do. But my point is, America is on our side, and we need to, just as we did in 2018, we need to unite. There's going to be some differences on the policies and how you get there, but we can't just diss the young people who want to do something on this. I know, because I have one of them, my daughter.
24:52 Speaker 02 All right. So I want to finish up with this presidential thing. What's the topic?
24:56 Speaker 03 Yeah, let's just finish it.
24:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, no, President. No, I'm going to get to tech. I want to talk about tech.
25:00 Speaker 03 Yeah, we got to.
25:01 Speaker 02 We got to talk about it. What's the topic you want to avoid on the campaign trail, aside from hair care issues?
25:06 Speaker 03 Oh, get out of here. Let's see, I want to avoid a constant attacks on what label are you, where do you, you know, how are you different? And I want us to, in a really good way, and maybe this is a Pollyanna, just be able to discuss policy differences. I'm looking forward to those debates. And the gotcha every single day on things that are differentiating people or something they said about each other, I think is going to be one of the hazards that we're going to have to deal with. Because you get asked every day, "Well, what do you think about this person's policy?" And then you say, "Well, I agree with this part, but not that part." Or, "I agree with this." And then that can be exploded into, "Oh, they hate each other."
25:51 Speaker 03 You know, I just hope we can get beyond that as a nation. There was times in our country, we mentioned antitrust, where we had big debates about big issues. And that's what we need to do right now. And I have faith in my colleagues who are running for office that we'll be able to do that well.
26:07 Speaker 02 All right, so reasonableness is what you're looking for?
26:10 Speaker 03 Reasonableness in how we treat each other. Because we have one goal, and that is to win the White House.
26:17 Speaker 02 All right. So you, um, let's get to tech. You introduced a bill last year on social media privacy. You did the Honest Ads Act, all kinds of things. Elizabeth, three days ago, you talked about re-upping the investigation, the FTC investigation into Google's dominance in search. Not many people heard that. I did. I heard when you said it. But then Elizabeth Warren came out with this astonishing proposal. And I think most people in tech are sort of vomiting in their Allbirds.
26:47 Speaker 03 Oh, that is, that's really appealing.
26:50 Speaker 02 Yeah, I know, it's not. They're going to get someone to clean them. So, um, so they, so they're very, it was, it was really went far, kind of thing. Talk, we're at first to the Elizabeth Warren proposal, and then talk a little bit about your issues around big tech.
27:06 Speaker 03 Well, you know, there is merit in, and I want to look at the whole proposal, in the fact that she's talking about that you have to look at the anti-competitive aspects of this. We all know that. And the way I have ...approached it is this way. Number one, privacy. For so long, these companies have said, "We got your backs." Well, that's just not true. And they've somehow equated a free and open Internet, which we all support, net neutrality, this idea that you should be able to, everyone should have access to it. That's true, but that doesn't mean that we just say, "Okay, so just take all my data and I trust you. I'm a commodity to you. You make money off of me." So, the first thing we do is privacy legislation.
27:48 Speaker 03 I have a bipartisan bill to do that with notice of breach and those kinds of things. The second thing is to look at the consumer pieces of this in terms of how much they are making off of us, basically. Because the problem is that we just thought, "Oh, we can just put our stuff on there and it's fine," but they're making money off of us. So, one big idea I think we need to discuss, in addition to privacy and making sure that the election ads are out there, is looking at, and that's why I'm asking this here, because I want to get your feedback later, is maybe there's a way we could actually tax when they use data, when they use us, and we're their commodity, and we're not getting anything out of it, right?
28:32 Speaker 03 Well, maybe then we could tax them, so the money goes back to us, when they are exchanging that data, right? When they sell our data to someone else, well, maybe they're going to have to tell us so we can put some kind of a tax on it, just like we do with other businesses. If you go on a truck, if you send stuff on rail, you have to pay for the roads and you have to pay for the rail. And maybe there's some way we can do that with large sets of data, when they use it or when they sell it. That is one idea that I want to put out there today. Because otherwise, we're just like, we're just being used, right? And this isn't about taxing ourselves. It's about doing this in a way that wouldn't limit innovation. Maybe you would do it with larger platforms, not startups.
29:17 Speaker 03 Maybe there's some way. But we should be looking at something like that, because these days that we think that they can just make money off of us and we don't get anything out of it, I don't think that's And then the last thing I would add, which you know about, is just antitrust laws, which go way beyond tech. And those are my ideas to supercharge the agencies. And this would get it, I think, some of the stuff Elizabeth's trying to get at a different way, which is to give them the resources by putting a fee on the mega deals. This is not on consumers. This is on the big companies that are merging, sometimes billion-dollar, trillion-dollar companies, so that they have to pay more, so that then that is used to fund FTC, Justice
30:02 Speaker 03 Department, so they can be more as, and an even playing field, and as sophisticated as the tycoons that are making these deals. That will allow them to do the, thank you, one person. That will, that will allow them to do the investigation, so they can better look at what's going on. So you can look what happened when they did the AT&T breakup, right? That was a big thing, but costs went down for long distance.
30:26 Speaker 02 And lots of innovations.
30:27 Speaker 03 We're trying to replicate that in a much more complicated, sophisticated scenario. And the last thing would be to change the standard. So, on the big deals, that they have the burden to show, the companies have the burden to show in a merger, that they do not materially reduce, I would change the standard, materially reduce competition. Because otherwise, you've got, you know, Google Maps buys Waze, and I don't think most consumers know that, right? Well, they bought Waze, so we all love Waze, super cool, right? Well, now they own it, all right? And you have these things going on, online travel. When you go to all those sites to get a deal, 93% of them are owned by two companies.
31:09 Speaker 03 They have different names, but they're all owned by the same companies. This is what brought Teddy Roosevelt into the White House, right? He ran on breaking up the trust and making sure that he preserved a capitalist system. Woodrow Wilson actually had an antitrust campaign song. Okay, no one laughed? So sad. But actually, it's true, because people saw this as a way of guaranteeing competition, lowering prices, and increasing innovation.
31:37 Speaker 02 All right, so antitrust, you're, the idea of changing antitrust. First, let's talk about specific companies. Should Facebook or Google be broken up? And how?
31:48 Speaker 03 If they are at a point where you have, there's competition.
31:52 Speaker 02 I'm asking you, are they?
31:54 Speaker 03 I would want to have it investigated. That is how I do things, okay? I don't just come in and say.
31:59 Speaker 02 Well, there's been a lot of, there was investigations.
32:02 Speaker 03 I would think that you go in there and we just have not had adequate investigation, which is why I called for that from the FTC. You go in there and you figure out what are the anti-competitive, um, the major anti-competitive problems, and then you come up with a plan to break up or to move something out if there's a piece of it that is anti-competitive. The other way you can do it, especially under the bill that I just introduced, you can strengthen, and I'm going to introduce a third one, you can strengthen the review going backwards after a merger has occurred. And one of the things I'm worried about with the potential that you're going to integrate Facebook and Instagram and WhatsApp is that then it's going to be impossible to untangle it.
32:45 Speaker 02 That's why they did it.
32:46 Speaker 03 To use the antitrust laws to do it. So that's another argument for.
32:49 Speaker 02 You realize that's why they did it. That's one of the reasons.
32:51 Speaker 03 Exactly. So that is why I think you have to have adequately funded government agencies with a president in charge who just doesn't use antitrust as a weapon, right? Oh, I don't like CNN, so let me get involved. Really bad. Instead, you see it as one of the governing principles for assuring that we have a capitalist system, and that is that we don't have all this monopoly consolidation that's squeezing out new competitors and new market entrants.
33:19 Speaker 02 All right, so antitrust regulation. It also has to change the idea of antitrust, correct? The House Subcommittee just hired Lena Kahn, which, who has some new ideas about antitrust. You're aware. How does that, because competitive harm is hard to prove here. Everybody loves Amazon. They deliver on time and they're never wrong, like that kind of, like, everybody likes it.
33:39 Speaker 03 Oh, you're saying this to the home state of Target?
33:41 Speaker 02 I understand that.
33:42 Speaker 03 Which, by the way, went up yet last year? Because they started some innovative things, like you can go and pick your stuff up right in the parking lot, to give a little pitch.
33:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, but they, I mean, look, they missed a lot of turns. A lot of retailers missed a lot of these turns. But here you have the idea of competitive, consumer harm.
34:00 Speaker 03 Right. By the way, you want competition, right? You want this innovation that Amazon brought into the market. You just don't want them controlling everything under them. That's a monopsony. And/or the Whole Foods is another example of that. You want to have the ability of a government that's a countermeasure to go in and investigate and figure out, hey, is this one so bad for competition in shutting things out like we did in the long-distance market, like they did back over a century ago with rail and all kinds of industries and the Pullman strike in Chicago. You want to be able to have pushback so that you guarantee that you're not stifling the innovation, but innovation is there. That is always how we have worked in America.
34:41 Speaker 03 And sadly, because of conservative courts that have gone so conservative, including the two new nominees, Kavanaugh and Gorsuch, that are even more conservative on antitrust than who we've got there, you've got to do something legislatively and through the agencies to change this.
34:56 Speaker 02 How likely do you think that is to happen, the idea of it? Because Republicans have their beefs with tech, too. It's largely around whether...
35:04 Speaker 03 Right. And so, by the way, that creates some likeliness, right? That creates likeliness that you can move on antitrust. A number of my colleagues on the Republican side have talked to me about that idea of increasing the fees on the mega-merchants. That's not on the taxpayers' backs. Drop in the bucket for them so you can beef up the agencies so they can better do these investigations. That's something they are open to. We just have to set it at the right price. So I would say that first. I think the public is going to get more and more aware of this issue because of the presidential debates and what's happening. I'm coming out with a book on this, actually, on antitrust. I've been looking at this for the last two years. And I think that you're going to be able to have a better discussion of this framed
35:48 Speaker 03 in a way around things like pharmaceutical prices, data privacy, that's going to make it more bite-sized and more doable for an election.
35:56 Speaker 02 All right. Privacy bill. Should be the lowest rung to jump over. Why? There's a privacy bill in California that's coming into form, which some people feel doesn't have enough teeth. There's one in Europe that has a lot of teeth. I'm going to bring Marguerite Vestager tomorrow, who runs the Competition Bureau at the EU. You have that happening over there. You've got California. There's different state things. But the federal government has not passed a privacy bill, ever.
36:24 Speaker 03 I know, it's pathetic. We had a hearing on this. And some of the witnesses were saying, "Oh, we hate this patchwork that's coming up through the states. We hate the industry. We hate that California." And I finally said, "You know what? Why do you think the states are doing that? Because you have lobbied against any federal privacy legislation for years. And so now the time has come. Senator Kennedy and I have a bill, Kennedy of Louisiana, that would, Republican, that would allow for 72-hour notice of breach, something that Zuckerberg said he was open to when he came before Congress, that would make clear that you have to, that you can
37:01 Speaker 03 opt out of this data sharing, and then also make very clear that it has to be in plain language. So, those things would go a long way. There's other things we can do, but we cannot keep going without privacy legislation.
37:17 Speaker 02 But what has been the gatekeeper to having this happen? Is the lobbying against it?
37:20 Speaker 03 It has been lobbying and making this, people are scared that it's going to look like they're regulating the Internet. And I think we have, you know, we blew past that when Russia was paying in rubles for ads in our last election. That's over. We have got to look at, and one more pitch of the bill that I want to pass the most immediately is the Honest Ads Act. We have 12 Republicans on it now in the House, and it simply says, "When you spend a bunch of money on Internet ads, like everyone's doing right now, 1.4 billion in 2016, forecast to go to 3 to 4 billion dollars in the next election, you have to have the same rules in place that the other media companies have.
38:00 Speaker 03 Newspaper, radio, TV, they have disclaimers for issue ads and candidate ads that says who pays for them." And then you have to disclose them. So the other candidates in the press can see where you're running. One of the funniest arguments that the companies used on me, well, they go, well, it's too hard for us to do that, to figure out what a federal issue ad is. That's what the standard is. And I said, really, okay, so my radio station in Thief River Falls, Minnesota, can figure that out? I think that you guys can. So what has happened since then is that Facebook and Twitter are both now supporting the bill. As you know, in the last election, which was helpful, they undertook voluntary measures
38:43 Speaker 03 to put up their own archives, which was very, very helpful. But we need to have the law in place so that everyone's doing the same thing. And we do not put ourselves at risk of foreign governments, again, buying ads in our elections.
38:58 Speaker 02 Do you trust these tech companies?
39:00 Speaker 03 No, no, I don't. I mean, I like that they are incredibly successful for America. I like that they employ so many people. I like that they brought in new ideas and new innovations. But I don't like that they've been saying, "Trust us" for so long, and we did it. I think we have to have, as we've always had in this country, we have now always just embraced business and let them run the show. We have said, "We love business. We want to have them employ people. This is part of why we're great as America." But we always have a check and balance. The biggest goal of government in my life, and I said this when I was a newly minted
39:42 Speaker 03 county attorney, was protecting people's safety. Well, right now, they did not protect our safety, not the safety of our privacy, not the safety of our national security. And I would also add, our government has to learn a little bit of the Austin way here, okay? We have to upgrade our cybersecurity, right? And one of the things that I put in with Senator Thune of South Dakota, I always work hard to make sure we got bipartisan support on big things like this. The idea is you give people a tour of duty, two years in Washington from the private sector, and our people then can take a tour of duty with the companies. And it is a way of bringing some high-tech expertise into the government.
40:27 Speaker 03 We're not like China and Russia. We can't requisition people and say, "You're going to go work in a warehouse and troll us for five years." Okay, we can't do that because it's America. But what we can do is create incentives to get the best of the best into our government and the best of our best in our government to learn in the private sector.
40:44 Speaker 02 That's been a difficult thing, though. That's still, it still remains a very difficult because it's, they make more money working in other places.
40:50 Speaker 03 Yeah, I know, but we found a way to do this in this bill.
40:53 Speaker 02 All right. So when we're talking about the idea of China, one of the things, I did a recent podcast with Mark Zuckerberg, and one of his arguments of why we should continue to trust them is that the choice is what's going on in China, which is essentially a surveillance economy. They're, they're doing all kinds of things like facial recognition, social scoring, all kinds of things where you can see it going in any country. It's like a, it's an episode of Black Mirror. And one of the things I've, when I talk to tech people, is I said, "Imagine your creation is an episode of Black Mirror, then don't do it." Like, if it, if it becomes that, like, imagine what could happen, which I think is excellent advice. But one of his arguments was, "Well, China gets to do all these things and they're going
41:35 Speaker 02 to collect more data, have better AI, have better robotics, the government's running it." And his argument was essentially, "It's Xi or me." And I don't like the choice at all. I don't like either of them. You know, I like him better than Xi, but, you know, it's not, it's kind of a low bar. So when they, when they do make that argument, though, in that argument, there's a very cogent thing is that tech has been innovative, has created jobs. How do you keep innovation and at the same time? Throttle some of this behavior, which is careless at best and malevolent at worst.
42:07 Speaker 03 Right, and you're always going to get those arguments that you are going to, you know, stop everything from innovation. That's why I like the idea of doing it through FTC, antitrust, of moving it and putting some very basic privacy rules in place that will save us from where we are right now. But this idea that we're just going to do nothing, which they were saying as recently as a year ago, right?
42:32 Speaker 02 They're saying it today, but not loudly.
42:34 Speaker 03 Free Cambridge Analytica, they're saying it in different ways. It's just not right. This is not how our country has been run. I go back to even the colonists in the Boston Tea Party. That was about taxation without representation, but was also about that the colonists didn't want to have to buy tea and sell their tea to the East Indian Tea Company, to one monopoly, right? It literally is part of the founding of our country that we wanted to have entrepreneurs. Many of the pilgrims and others came over here because they didn't want to have people telling them what they had to do. They had this independent spirit of innovation. And that is what we have to kind of call back when we deal with tech in the modern day,
43:16 Speaker 03 that we have to suspend belief and say, okay, you guys are really cool, and I know what you do is super complicated, and there's a bunch of people in Washington that can ask dumb questions and don't understand what it is. Okay, we understand all that's going on, but you can't then say, well, let's disarm, and we're not going to do anything to create a counterbalance. Small companies, I cannot tell you the number of innovative companies that come to me and say, this isn't right, we want to get into this market. So there's actually a market outcry, and there's some really smart people that can help us get to the point, including in this town, where we can regain that balance. So we can have these successful companies, but we make sure that we're opening up the market so that new people can compete.
43:58 Speaker 02 I have two more questions on tech. One, should Facebook, Google, Amazon be allowed to buy anything large? At all right now?
44:06 Speaker 03 That is where I get very concerned and why I want to put these merger standards in place and why I want to be president because I think we've got to look carefully at all of these deals. And you just, if you look at them through a analysis that includes the standards that I want to put in place, which will at least look at monopsonies, which is sort of do you control things under you as one of the standards, and also changes that burden, then you're going to be able to get a much better answer to that question.
44:34 Speaker 02 And Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which gives them broad immunity, which has, I think, led directly to this sloppiness of the platforms in terms of not managing them properly. Should that be changed so that they have some, they remove immunity?
44:48 Speaker 03 Right. It is something else that we should definitely look at as we look at how we can create more accountability. That is our goal. We do not want to destroy these companies, right? But what we want to do is to put more accountability in place, and we have been failing at that effort, and that's why we need all of your help to get to a better place.
45:08 Speaker 02 Does tech like you? Do you get, do you?
45:10 Speaker 03 Well, they did not like that, which I thought was so crazy. They did not like, right out of the start, they complained about the Honest Ads Act. How can you complain about something called the Honest Ads Act? But they did not like that, and that really made me mad, honestly. They did not like the privacy legislation. I keep trying to push them, and I think the fact that I've been outspoken makes them not like me. However, there are, and by the way, this, if you haven't learned in the news, running for president shouldn't be a likability contest. But let me tell you what the other thing they did like, and that is that they employ a very diverse workforce, right?
45:53 Speaker 03 So they like that I've been out front since the day I got to the Senate on immigration reform, right? That I believe that Dreamers should stay in America, that I believe that you should have a path to citizen for our immigrant workforce, and that you should not put these mean-spirited caps on refugees, right? Because they have a workforce that is diverse.
46:15 Speaker 02 Oh, wait, I'm gonna push back on that. They do not have a workforce.
46:18 Speaker 03 Okay, no, but I would get to. They don't have a workforce at the top that is diverse.
46:21 Speaker 02 Yeah.
46:21 Speaker 03 They have a, that is a very good point. Thank you. They have a, they have a workforce that they need to come in.
46:28 Speaker 02 Right.
46:28 Speaker 03 That is diverse. And they recruit people at levels of their company that is diverse. Thank you for correcting me.
46:35 Speaker 02 Right.
46:36 Speaker 03 But they have a real trouble at the top, right? As we do in many areas of our country.
46:41 Speaker 02 Right.
46:41 Speaker 03 But what they want is they want to have employees. They have, I think Apple was telling me they have like 300 Dreamers that work there. So that is a true fact. I'm not just talking about social media platforms. So they have employees that they want to be able to have and keep. So they've appreciated that I've been outspoken on that issue. They've appreciated that I've been outspoken. I head up the Diversifying Tech Caucus with Tim Scott. They've appreciated that I'm willing to listen on business ideas and trying to do what we can during the downturn. I was a supporter of President Obama's stimulus. I was a supporter of being smart and moving on affordable health care.
47:26 Speaker 03 Businesses, not just tech, appreciate that I'm willing to take on pharma prices. That is not a left versus right issue. All businesses care about that because it's an expense of doing business that shouldn't be that expensive. So I have worked with businesses extensively, but I don't think that means that you have to suck up to them every step of the way.
47:47 Speaker 02 Yeah, they do have a lot of money. And you are running for president, in case you're, no, you need a lot of money to do that.
47:53 Speaker 03 But I'm not taking PAC, corporate PAC money.
47:55 Speaker 02 We're gonna take another break now. We'll return to this conversation with Senator Amy Klobuchar after this.
48:10 Speaker 04 Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights, and rental cars.
48:19 Speaker 04 Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app.
48:25 Speaker 04 Fine. No one deals more deals than... Please stop. Touche. Priceline.
48:32 Speaker 05 How about a latte?
48:33 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
48:35 Speaker 05 Vanilla?
48:35 Speaker 01 Caramel?
48:36 Speaker 05 Blueberry?
48:37 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor, or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup pie varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee.
48:49 Speaker 01 No effort, no grind, no settling.
48:54 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
48:59 Speaker 02 So let's do some in-the-news stuff while we're finished up. We've got 15 more minutes. Manafort handed a 47-month sentence well below federal guidelines of 19 to 24 years. Your reaction?
49:12 Speaker 03 That was appalling to me. I had a job where I was the chief prosecutor for the biggest county in our state. I had about 400 people that worked for me. And we would try every day. We had sentencing guidelines. Minnesota notoriously, and I remember looking at what Austin was doing in Travis County at the time, also was doing a lot with working with the community. This is years and years ago. And we worked really hard to use drug courts a lot and to try to be fair in our sentencing. We were not perfect. I tried to do things to improve things. But one of the things that I realized was that we weren't doing enough with white-collar
49:52 Speaker 03 cases and that crimes in the boardroom were not being treated as seriously as crimes on the street corner. That you could go out and create a crime with a computer that cost people millions of dollars and you got a lesser sentence than you did if you broke into someone's house with a crowbar. And that's wrong. And when I saw that Manafort sentence that day, I did my tweet on the couch I was watching. I just thought, wow. Because he deviated from those sentences and then sentencing guidelines and then added to putting salt on the wound by saying, "The judge said about Manafort, he led a blameless life until then." And that just wasn't true. And so, let me just, my reaction to this.
50:36 Speaker 03 When we took on white collar crime, I get to have one story here. One of my big cases was a judge that we put in jail. He had stolen hundreds of thousands of dollars from a disabled woman. A woman that literally, in her adult years, lived in a world of dolls and toys. And he had taken over this, basically, a trust for her from his client, who had died. And then he became a judge, and they let him keep doing it. Well, what he was doing was putting on the trust document that he was buying things, like a bed for her, and he was buying fancy artwork for his house. He was a judge on the second court, biggest court in Minnesota. And when we took the case on, literally, no one believed it. We did all this investigation. We had to do a search warrant on his chambers.
51:21 Speaker 03 Anyway, we had him cold on the evidence. And then there was a sentencing. And we asked for the guideline sentence, which I think was three, four years for that crime at the time. And I was in the courtroom, and it was filled with all his friends from his church, from his courtroom. And there was no one there to make that case for justice. And we had no idea what the judge was going to do. And all of a sudden, in the middle of this day-long sentencing hearing, where literally the former Miss America testified for him, true story. In the middle of this thing, these two African-American guys walked in. And they were the only two African-Americans in the courtroom, besides the court reporter. And I saw them sitting there, and they were kind of nodding their head, agreeing with our witnesses.
52:05 Speaker 03 Then there was a break, and they walked out. And I was sitting in the hallway, and they looked at me, and they go, you know, we were upstairs for a drug court case that we had, and we heard about the judge getting sentenced because it makes us mad. And we came in here, and we have somewhere to go, but, man, sitting in there, we think you need us in there. And I'm like, I do need you in there. And they sat there through that entire sentencing hearing. And for me, they were there to say, you can't have two systems of justice, one for the rich and powerful, and one for everyone else. And in the end...
52:41 Speaker 03 In the end, we got the sentence that we asked for, and that judge went to jail. But I'll never forget those two guys. Because when I heard that Manafort sentence, and by the way, it's not over. There's going to be a new judge, right, in the coming weeks on other charges, and it may all be taken care of that way. But you just can't treat people differently, not just based on race, but also based on the types of crimes that they commit.
53:06 Speaker 02 Right.
53:06 Speaker 03 That's wrong.
53:07 Speaker 02 All right. Mueller report, should it be released?
53:10 Speaker 03 Yes. That was... Remember, at the core of this is a foreign country trying to influence our election. And when people use that word meddling, never use that. That is what I do when I call my daughter on a Saturday night and ask her what she's doing, okay? This was, this was an actual attack on our elections. And so, that's what Mueller is investigating, and I think the country has to see this. I'm hoping that when you see all the gory facts, it's going to help us to, one, understand what went on, that's most important, but, two, maybe it'll compel my colleagues to immediately put in place that Honest Ads Act and do more than Senator Langford and
53:55 Speaker 03 I already did, which was get 360 million to the states for shoring up election equipment, but actually pass our Secure Elections Act to have backup paper ballots. What is so outrageous about that, right? So, that's why they have to see the report. I question Barr on that. He was all squiggly, you know, well...
54:14 Speaker 02 Squiggly?
54:15 Speaker 03 Squiggly, yeah, well, you don't want to call the Attorney General that, I guess, but he was, he wouldn't really commit to making it public. This is going to be his moment. I hope I'm wrong. I didn't vote for him because of that, but I hope that he comes through. I hope that he makes that whole report public, because America deserves to see it.
54:33 Speaker 02 All right. Putin, just go ahead.
54:35 Speaker 03 Putin?
54:36 Speaker 02 Putin, just go ahead.
54:37 Speaker 03 Is this like, uh, Lightning Rod? What about Putin? Okay, well, you look at what he's done, it's not just the elections, right? This is like bringing down a plane, right? This is like killing innocent people. Uh, this is a dictator. And when Donald Trump went and sat next to him and embraced his views of what happened over his own intelligence... That was so wrong. You don't show strength that way. You show weakness. And that is why I continue to support NATO. It's why I went with Senator McCain. One of the last trips before he got sick, where we stood with the President of Ukraine on the front line on New Year's Eve to make the point that America stands with our allies.
55:19 Speaker 03 And it's why we went to Lithuania and Latvia and Georgia, because we won. And Estonia, don't forget Estonia, because we wanted to make that point. So I think it's, we are at a moment where Congress, actually, because of how Donald Trump is cozying up to Kim Jong-un or the Crown Prince in Saudi Arabia after they murder a journalist for an American newspaper, we're at the point where Congress must stand up and make clear that we are, stand with our allies for democracy. We stand against these acts of dictators and these murders, and that we stand with sanctions, that we are
56:03 Speaker 03 someone, are a country that has always been a beacon of democracy. And one last thing I will add, since I brought up Saudi Arabia and the Khashoggi murder, is that we stand up for the First Amendment while we have a president in the White House that tweets whatever he wants in the morning, but doesn't respect the amendment that allows him to do it.
56:24 Speaker 02 On that, we have two more things. His attacks on the press. I don't love talking about the press, but these attacks are really quite an astonishing thing to happen from the President of the United States. How do you look at it?
56:34 Speaker 03 I didn't hear it, because you know, the clap.
56:35 Speaker 02 Attacks on the press. What do you, Matt, when he does them?
56:37 Speaker 03 Attacks on the press, yes.
56:38 Speaker 02 And at the same time, calling them all up himself.
56:41 Speaker 03 Okay, so, as I said, I'm a journalist daughter. My dad spent his entire life in journalism, starting with AP, where he got to actually call the 1960 election for John F. Kennedy, Minnesota, Illinois, California, where the three states out. And he went from a hardscrabble mining town to interview everyone from Chicago Bears coach Mike Ditka to...
57:07 Speaker 03 Ronald Reagan to Ginger Rogers. And so if I wasn't for the First Amendment, my dad would never talk to me again. So no matter what the press does, as long as they are doing their constitutional duty, I think it's very important that you not attack the press. You can disagree with them. You can defend yourself. You can make arguments on the other side. But we must allow access in a free democracy. To me, that is one of the most evil things that's going on right now because it doesn't feel like it because the press is so strong and because you don't always agree with every story they wrote, really. But because of that, you don't then turn around and start trying to use the wheels
57:52 Speaker 03 of government like it appears the president did from the news reports last week in going after CNN. You can't use your power to go after the press. And that's why I've always asked every Attorney General nominee about not sending journalists to jail. Neither former Attorney General Sessions or Barr would really answer that question. And I'm now following up in writing, which I found disturbing. But we must stand up for the First Amendment.
58:19 Speaker 02 All right, impeachment.
58:20 Speaker 03 Okay. This is like the Kara lightning round. Okay, so, and I think you're going to hear this from other senators that you may have raced this stage. We are in a different position in the Senate.
58:35 Speaker 02 Yes, I get that.
58:36 Speaker 03 We are the jury. And so I never comment on evidence. I didn't as a prosecutor before the case came before me. So we will see what comes out of the Mueller report. We will see what comes out of the House. And then it's our constitutional duty to look at evidence and make a decision. So I never weigh in on what is impeachable or what should be impeachable just because that is our profound constitutional duty.
58:58 Speaker 02 All right, that's fair. Representative Omar.
59:02 Speaker 02 I want to talk about political pressure, political influence in this country that says it's okay to push for allegiance to a foreign country. So, to be fair, what did you think of that? She's from Minnesota.
59:12 Speaker 03 Yeah, I did not agree with what the representative said there because I believe you can be true to your country and advocate for another country, whether it is Israel or Canada or Ethiopia. There are many Americans that feel strongly that they love their own country, but they advocate for, maybe it's the country of their own ancestry, or maybe it is another country that they care a lot about. So, I didn't like what she said there. But what I do believe is that the president has ignited, in his own way, a string of things against other people, right?
59:57 Speaker 03 It is everything from we see antisemitism on the rise to anti-Muslim rhetoric on the rise. And I try to go back home and look at how we've handled some of this. We have the biggest Somali population in the country. And, in fact, Ilhan Omar is a refugee herself, and she is in a unique position to advocate for refugees from Somalia, and I hope you'll see this, and the fact that the president has put what I consider to be unfair caps on refugees to talk about those issues. Because one of the things, my favorite stories about our state, because we have a strong
1:00:38 Speaker 03 Jewish population, and we also have a major Muslim population. And one of my best stories was when the Jewish Community Center got a bomb threat, and not just the staff there, but the young kids that had been in a swimming pool, senior citizens in an exercise class, were wandering around outside of that community center in the cold because they had to immediately leave, and they finally found some warehouse to be in. When they got back, the first call they had gotten in their messages from the Islamic ...asking if they needed a place to meet. We have happy Ramadan signs in front of all of our churches, not all of them, but
1:01:21 Speaker 03 a big part of our churches and our religious community. During the Super Bowl, we staged a football game between faith leaders with one of our more prominent rabbis, a woman, throwing a pass to an Imam. And we have tried, it went viral, over and over again to try to bridge that gap. And what I don't like is when rhetoric, no matter who it comes from, but who I see it primarily coming from is the president, doesn't try to fix things, but tries to make things worse. And our goal is should be to see the populations in our country as not diminishing America. They are America.
1:02:00 Speaker 02 So, my last question. Who do you, if you had to pick a politician you would be most like, who do you think it is? From the past.
1:02:12 Speaker 03 Wow. It is hard for me to pick one politician, but my mentor has been, and I wouldn't say I'd want to be quite like him, is Walter Mondale. He's a really good guy. But in the modern day, I'm trying to think who it would be.
1:02:30 Speaker 02 You can do a dead one.
1:02:31 Speaker 03 I don't know, we've had so many. I really don't have one person that I look at.
1:02:34 Speaker 02 Who is the person you look up to? Who is the person you look up to?
1:02:38 Speaker 03 Well, I have always looked up to some of the women that came before me that were incredible, that were mentors to me, like Olympia Snow and Barbara Mikulski, the dean of the Women Senators, who were so strong and taught me so many things, like Barbara Mikulski would, she's so short, she would stand on...
1:03:00 Speaker 02 Don't insult short people.
1:03:01 Speaker 03 Yeah. She would stand on a couch and she would literally say... Square your shoulders, put your lipstick on, and get ready for a revolution. I'd be like, what revolution? Whatever we're gonna go vote on. And so, they were incredible. But I do want to mention one person. And by the way, I think when you look at, as David Brooks said, "You don't know what you got till it's gone." One great president was Barack Obama, but let's keep going. So, I did want to mention, one president I got to meet recently was Jimmy Carter. And I've met him a few times, and I got to go to Plains to see him. And he is 95 years old, and he was giving me advice on how he ran his campaign in the 70s.
1:03:43 Speaker 03 And it was just incredible, serving me with Rosalind Pimento cheese sandwiches. And he then sent me an email the next day, at 95, signed JC. Also, the initials for Jesus Christ, as you know.
1:03:58 Speaker 02 I got that, I got that.
1:04:00 Speaker 03 But I was just, I was, that was an amazing thing. But I think I told you this back in the green room. I had visited, when I did the Atlanta, the Democratic Dinner for Georgia, I told Jimmy Carter this, the Carter Presidential Library, looking for Mondale memorabilia a few years ago, like, where's Joan's dress? And on the wall were these words from Walter Mondale, looking back at the four years, which weren't perfect. And as you know, they lost their reelection. But there was one thing that is important to cherish from that time. Mondale looked back at that time, and he said these simple words. I wrote them down, put them in my purse, didn't think they were relevant until Donald Trump won. Those words were, "We told the truth, we obeyed the law, we kept the peace."
1:04:45 Speaker 03 I think that is the minimum that you should expect from a president of the United States. And that is that they try to keep the peace, and they tell the truth, and they obey the law. And that is what I will do as your president.
1:04:58 Speaker 02 All right. Thank you. Amy Klobuchar.
1:05:03 Speaker 02 Thanks again to Senator Amy Klobuchar for joining me onstage and to South by Southwest for letting us share the audio with you. And thanks to you all for listening. You can find more episodes of Recode Decode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. And please tell a friend about this show. If you're in the Washington, DC area, I'm doing a live podcast taping on April 2 at the Studio Theater focusing on AI and self-driving cars. To learn more, just go to events.recode.net/ai. You can also follow me on Twitter at Kara Swisher. Now that you're done with this, go check out our other podcasts, Recode Media and Pivot. You can find those shows wherever you found this one. Thank you for listening to this episode of Recode Decode, and thanks
1:05:48 Speaker 02 to our editor Joel Robbie and our producer Eric Johnson. I'll be back here on Monday. Tune in then.
1:05:59 Speaker 06 In this life, you can't win.
1:06:01 Speaker 07 When the world gets you down.
1:06:02 Speaker 06 No!
1:06:02 Speaker 07 Escape to Pluto TV.
1:06:04 Speaker 06 This is objectively fantastic.
1:06:06 Speaker 07 Relax into the movies and shows you already know and love, all for free.
1:06:10 Speaker 06 Shwing!
1:06:10 Speaker 07 Even our news is uplifting.
1:06:12 Speaker 04 You stay classy, San Diego.
1:06:14 Speaker 07 Watch School of Rock, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy, The X-Files, Wayne's World, and so much more.
1:06:19 Speaker 05 We're not worthy!
1:06:21 Speaker 07 The best things on TV really are free. You just have to know where to look. Escape to Pluto TV. Stream now, pay never.
Previous Recode Decode: Kathy Griffin Next Recode Decode: Margrethe Vestager, European Commissioner for Competition (Live at SXSW 2019) Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated