Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Sen. Chuck Schumer About this episode Chuck Schumer, the senior U. S. Senator from New York, talks with Recode’s Kara Swisher and Democratic strategist Hilary Rosen about a range of tech-related issues, including immigration, net neutrality and Russian election meddling. He hopes to enlist tech companies like Netflix in the fight to bring net neutrality back after it was overturned by the FCC last year. Schumer also talks about his “sympathetic” attitude to the tech giants, saying the world would be a worse place overall if Amazon were not in it, even though “there’s lots of problems” with its impact on retail. Plus: Why the senior Democrat is optimistic about the midterm elections later this year.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Today's show is sponsored by Synchrony. Because ambitions live everywhere, Synchrony has the payments tools and technologies, promotional financing, and retail insights to help you achieve whatever you're working forward to. Learn more at synchronyfinancial.com. Recode Radio presents Recode Decode, coming to you from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, Executive Editor of Recode. You may know me as the creator of the popular Facebook page 100% American Patriot News, definitely not from Russia, but don't look too closely. But in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode, a podcast about tech and media's key players, big ideas, and how they're changing the world we live in. You can find more episodes of Recode Decode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Play Music,
0:43 Speaker 00 or wherever you listen to podcasts, or just visit recode.net/podcast for more. Today, I'm joined once again by Democratic strategist Hillary Rosen, who, regular listeners may remember, co-hosted a month of political episodes with me last year. One of the people we wanted to talk to you back then was Senator Chuck Schumer. He's the Senate Minority Leader and the senior United States Senator from New York, obviously. And he's joining us today from Washington, DC, for a shorter Recode Decode, but we're thrilled to have him. Senator, welcome to Recode Decode.
1:14 Speaker 01 Kara, great to be with you. I'm looking forward to it.
1:17 Speaker 00 We have so much to talk about. We could talk for hours, I'm guessing, but let's go right into it. So you've been in the Senate for 20 years now, and the leader for one. I'd just like to know what the biggest difference, you know, you're in an administration that's quite active, too, so why don't you talk a little bit about that?
1:31 Speaker 01 Okay, well, I'll tell you a story. I like stories. Abe Lincoln said, "The best thing a politician can do is tell stories." So it's election night, 8:00 PM. I see the exit polls of college-educated women, North Carolina and Florida, the first two states to close, and I go, "Oh, boy." I call up Hillary's chief pollster, strategist, a guy named Bennison. He says, "Don't worry, our firewall in Wisconsin and Pennsylvania and Michigan can't be broken. There's no way Trump wins." Of course, he won. And the next morning, just by way of reference, Paul Ryan called me up, the Republican Speaker, and I just happened to ask him, "Well, did this come as a surprise to you, Paul?"
2:13 Speaker 01 And he told me this story. I hadn't told him the 8 p.m. story. He said, "I called up our chief pollster at 6:30. He said, 'Sorry, Paul. Feingold's gonna be your new Democratic Senator in Wisconsin. Schumer's gonna be Majority Leader. Hillary's gonna be President.'" Okay. I am distraught. My wife is distraught. My big daughter is most distraught because she had worked in the Hillary campaign and had her job picked out in the White House. I taught them the old Sherrell song. Some of you will remember this. Mama said there'd be days like this. And I moped around in my house for two days. I'm not a moper.
2:51 Speaker 00 As did the rest of the country.
2:52 Speaker 01 The third day, I had an epiphany, almost a message from the heavens. It went like this. "Chuck, stop moping. If Hillary had been President, your job would be easier, it would be more fun, and you'd get some good things done. That's why you're there. But with Trump as President and you as Minority Leader, your job is much more important." And that has fueled me the whole way through. This is the hardest job I've ever had, much harder than just being Senator, particularly with Trump as President. I worry more in this job. I wake up in the morning and I have three or four things I'm always worried about. I'm not a worrier. I never used to worry. But I love it more than any job I've had because what we're doing is so vital and so important to saving America.
3:35 Speaker 00 So how is your frenemy relationship going right now? I mean, you were down with immigration and sort of up with dreamers and down with dreamers and goes back and forth quite a bit. Where is it right now? How do you characterize it?
3:47 Speaker 01 Well, you know...
3:48 Speaker 00 I can't tell what's happening there.
3:50 Speaker 01 He likes to talk to me. He calls me up, but I'm right in his face. He said to me when we were debating immigration, "Everyone loves the wall." I said, "Mr. President, 35% of the people like the wall. That's your base. If you keep just appealing to your base, you'll never be reelected and you won't be a good President." I've said to him, I said to him time and time again, "You've campaigned when you ran as a populist." And against both the Democratic and Republican establishments, but you've embraced the hard right. The hard right is so far away from not only where the American people are, but even most Republicans, you're going to be an abject failure as president. You ought to change. I talked to him like that, and he keeps calling me back.
4:31 Speaker 00 Do you sense you're one of the few who actually does? Talk to him that way?
4:34 Speaker 01 I think I am one of the few. Most of the people around Trump seem to be in the sycophant mold. That's not quite my nature.
4:41 Speaker 00 All right, let's ask about Dreamers, though. Where are they now? You were getting along with them. You had that lovely, I don't know, lunch or whatever it was, dinner. And this was supposed to be the easy one, and it hasn't passed, obviously.
4:53 Speaker 01 You know...
4:54 Speaker 00 And that's a concern here. Immigration issues are a major concern in technology and the technology sector.
4:58 Speaker 01 Of course, of course. Well, we need immigration in tech. You know, I'll tell you an interesting thing. When McCain and I did the 2013 immigration bill, which passed the Senate with 68 votes, but the Tea Party stopped it in the House. Boehner was afraid to bring it up, even though it would have passed. But we put on the legislation where, of course, there was a path to citizenship for the 11 million, but we also said that any foreigner who studies STEM—science, technology, engineering, or math—and gets an MA or PhD at one of our universities gets a green card stapled to his or her diploma. That would have been such a shot in the arm for tech. And still today, I've nurtured and helped the New York tech industry, which now doesn't need much nurturing.
5:43 Speaker 01 We're number two after California. But when I ask them what their complaints are, it's still getting talent and how many people from overseas want to come here and can't. So with Trump, in answer to your question, he just—I said afterwards, negotiating with him is like negotiating with Jell-O. I try, when I'm a negotiate—when I'm negotiating, to put myself in the other person's shoes. And I knew Trump wanted his wall. I hated the wall. But I felt so, we all felt so desperate to help the plight of the Dreamers, that we were willing to give him not the cutbacks on legal immigration, which involve humanity, and not interior enforcement, and not sanctuary cities, which would hurt lives,
6:26 Speaker 01 but this physical structure of the wall, which I believe never would have been built. To build the wall in the 60 miles that he first wanted to, you needed 982 eminent domain cases. Anyway, we gave him what he wanted. But he couldn't take yes for an answer. We sat at the table, myself, I insisted it just be his chief of staff, Kelly, my chief of staff, Mike Lynch, him and me. I didn't want Miller there, or Cotton, or anybody else, these anti-immigration people. And we really, basically, we didn't shake hands on a deal, but we said, "This is the parameters of a deal. We think we can both accept it." Immediately, he talks to Miller and Cotton and adds all these unacceptable things. And you can't negotiate with him. Because it's like Jell-O.
7:09 Speaker 00 So what happens now, then? Where are the Dreamers? Where is immigration? You know, this is wending through the courts and everything else. What happens?
7:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, we meet regularly with the Dreamers and the other groups that have been with us through the battles on immigration. And we are first, the first thing we're doing, is urging Trump to simply extend the date. You know, he caused all this problem. He's, you know, he's out there saying, "Democrat." He created the deadline. He can lift it tomorrow. We've said that to him. If he doesn't, we will then have to see in this omnibus bill that comes up March 25th, if we can get something in that's positive for Dreamers and extends the deadline. The problem has been Paul Ryan, not so much the Senate, although some, and you saw the vote in the Senate, even on our bipartisan bill, that, but Ryan has been very negative here.
8:01 Speaker 01 But he's feeling the heat from two places. One, the deportation, the breaking up of families, just the total nastiness of this administration to Dreamers is hurting, is just an issue that strikes the heart cords of America. But second, he's got 30 or 40 So-called moderate Republicans in suburban districts. And those districts are putting heat on those people to say, do something. Now, in the past, unfortunately, when the hard right, the Freedom Caucus says, jump, Ryan says, how high? And that's what's tied us in a knot. But maybe he'll feel the pressure this time.
8:40 Speaker 00 We're going to take a quick break now for a word from our sponsors. We'll be back in a minute with Senator Chuck Schumer. Today's show is brought to you by Betterment. It's tax season, which means it's a great time to think about your finances as a whole. Are you ready for the deadlines coming your way? Are you saving as much on taxes as possible? And are there any accounts that could be working harder for you? Maybe you have an old 401K sitting around. High fees on that account can drain your savings. According to an independent study, rolling over into a Betterment IRA can mean 60% lower fees. Betterment is a modern solution to an age-old problem: how to save for better retirement. Investing involves risk, but the licensed experts at Betterment will help you develop a personalized plan to make sure you have the retirement you deserve.
9:25 Speaker 00 Find out today if you're on track to hit your saving and investing goals. And when you need it, Betterment has the tools and guidance to help you get on track. Recode Decode listeners, you can get up to one year managed free. For more information, visit betterment.com/decode. That's betterment.com/decode. I'd also like to tell you about one of our other podcasts, Recode Media with Peter Kafka. Peter, who'd you talk to this week?
9:50 Speaker 02 Hey, Kara. Yes, who I talked to this week. I will tell you, I talked to Graham Yost. He is a veteran screenwriter, wrote Speed, wrote one of my favorite TV series of all time, Justified, and he has a new series out on Amazon called Sneaky Pete. I think it's their most popular series, he told us. He knows how to tell a story. You know why? Because he's a professional screenwriter, so it's a good conversation. You will enjoy it.
10:09 Speaker 00 Sounds great, Peter. You can find Recode Media on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Play Music, or wherever you listen to podcasts.
10:18 Speaker 03 There's such unanimity among Californians and in the tech community and maybe on the coasts to support the Dreamers and to support some immigration bill. But, so there was this perception after the budget at the end of last year that maybe Democrats didn't use all the leverage that you had to try and do something. Do you think that's because the politics of immigration aren't really the same way that Californians or tech industry perceives it?
10:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, that's certainly true, Hillary, but I remind people, we're playing with a pair of fours. We have a Republican president, a Republican senate, a Republican house, led by a Republican party that is the most anti-immigrant we have ever seen in the history of America. So, we can pressure as best we can, but we really don't hold the cards. And, you know, Democrats hate to shut down the government. We hate it. We like government. We're not like the Republicans. The only time we've ever done it has been for Dreamers. We put the issue on the table. We came real close in the bipartisan vote where he got a piece of the wall, which I think would never be built.
11:29 Speaker 01 We got a really good bill on Dreamers, not just 700,000, but close to 2 million citizenship for them. And then Trump lobbied against it, the Republicans backed off. So at some point, we're gonna have to go back at it again, and we will. But we gotta call our shots, because we can't just pound our hand on the table and say, "It's gonna get done."
11:50 Speaker 03 Yep.
11:51 Speaker 01 And one reminder, if all of those who support Dreamers, Dreamers themselves, the Hispanic community, and all those who support it, if we take back the majority in House and Senate, it'll get done like that.
12:02 Speaker 03 All right, so you've got this pair of fours you're carrying around. Net neutrality, explain what you want to do here and why you think you could be successful. This is another issue that's, you know, Ajit Pai runs the FCC.
12:15 Speaker 01 Well, first, yep, I feel really strongly about net neutrality, like I like building highways. The 21st century, the net is our highways. And if we were, as a country... To have tolls everywhere and say, "Rich people could use the highways and poor people couldn't, middle-class people couldn't, startup businesses couldn't. We never would have gotten to the place we have here, as it's such a strong economy." Well, it's the same exact thing with the net. And I really resent these ISPs. I talked to them. You know, they came in and made the case. I felt more strongly for net neutrality after they came in than before, because it's clear. They want to maximize their profits by squeezing people who don't have much power and exceeding to people who do.
13:00 Speaker 01 So we feel very strongly about this, and this unites our caucus, from the most liberal to the most moderate. The advantage we have here, which we didn't have in immigration, is, since it was done by regulation by Pai, who I think is a horror as head of the FCC— I'm not supposed to use such a strong word, let me strike that and say— Horror? —a very bad leader as the head of the FCC. We're allowed to bring to the floor, within 60 days of them passing this regulation, a motion to overturn it, and it only takes 51 votes. We now have all 49 of our Democrats—we're 49 since Doug Jones from Alabama joined us— and one Republican, Susan Collins.
13:44 Speaker 01 So we're at 50. We get one more Republican to support our, what's called CRA, Congressional Resolution Act, to overturn Pai's regulation on net neutrality. It passes. And so, we are urging strongly our friends throughout America to email, write, call, picket, protest. Their senators, particularly their Republican senators, if they're in such a state, and say, "Support the CRA to restore net neutrality. Support restoring net neutrality." We should—you know, I remember SOPA and PIPA, and we had millions of people.
14:26 Speaker 01 Emailing and protesting and it we succeeded in beating it. We can do the same thing here, so we're trying to arouse the community.
14:35 Speaker 00 Are you working with the big tech companies to do that? Are you working with the big larger and who are you working with?
14:39 Speaker 01 Yes, we're working with the big tech companies, the little tech companies. I was on the phone today with the head of the Internet Association, asking him to get his all of his membership, which goes all the way from the biggest tech companies to the others. I put in a call to someone I know, Reed Hastings. You know Netflix users will pay a lot more money if this happens and they might get slower service too. So I'd love Netflix to anytime you subscribe to just have a little, you know, a little chyron there and say, write your senator, don't be charged more for your movies. So we need to get all of our tech providers, big and little. I spoke to Fred Wilson today, you know, who's one of the funders of tech in New York and
15:23 Speaker 01 he's trying to get, we're trying to get the whole tech community to rally the way they did with SOPA and PIPA. And folks, a lot of it depends on the employees in these companies. If they tell their leaders in their companies, please get on board here, that's going to help too.
15:36 Speaker 03 I think one of the reasons this becomes different than SOPA and PIPA is that there really are customers on both sides of the equation here, right? And so when you look at Netflix or Amazon or YouTube, they they take up, you know, 75 to 80% of all the bandwidth on the on the internet and then these telephone companies feel like they're subsidizing those businesses. But both of them charge customers, right?
16:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, look, I don't care.
16:05 Speaker 03 Netflix charges customers more anyway, right?
16:07 Speaker 01 And it's not the fight between Netflix.
16:08 Speaker 03 It's sort of money versus money.
16:09 Speaker 01 It's I want to be for the people, for the average person. And this is going to cost them more because because Netflix will reduce their prices, but the cable companies and the ISPs will raise their prices.
16:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, and also Netflix did do a deal with Comcast, so a lot of people felt like they backed off the fight after they got there.
16:29 Speaker 01 Well, it's and it's not just Netflix. It's a whole bunch of companies that should do this.
16:34 Speaker 03 Do you think if you got 51 senators that that would lead to compromise legislation? Or do you just see it as just a fight at the FCC?
16:41 Speaker 01 I'd like to keep fighting. I am very leery with Republican-controlled House and Senate of legislation this year. Again, if we get back to majority, I'd like to do good legislation and force Trump to sign it. And I'd make one more point here. Related to this and everything else, the MO of our Republican colleagues, I'm sorry to sound a partisan here, but these are the facts, they always side with the big interests over the average people. And that's certainly true here in net neutrality. Average folks will pay more, new startup companies, Fred Wilson, who I talked to, who's funded a lot of the startups in New York, they're petrified because their larger competitors will get better rates than they do.
17:23 Speaker 01 And if you're a new company, a new startup, that's going to kill you. So they're trying, they are siding with the big special interests, surprise, surprise. And we're trying to help the average people. The good news here is because this was a regulation that was passed in the last six months, we have the ability on our own with a couple of Republican votes to overturn it. Then we'll have to go to the House. But I think if we get people to rise up with, the way they did with SOPA, PIPA, there were two sides there too. There were the, there were the companies, the content providers, and you know, the tech community on one side versus the other. But if they get people, if we get people to rise up, we can have the same positive result.
18:08 Speaker 01 A lot of Republicans on SOPA and PIPA who never wanted to side with average folks were forced to.
18:13 Speaker 00 So can you walk us through when you, when it passes, what happened? If it passes, you get that extra senator, is there anyone you're targeting? And then what happens?
18:20 Speaker 01 Well, we're targeting everybody right now because if we get the kind, it's just starting. We have 60 days from last Thursday. So we have a long time. And we're going to have days of action where we build things up. There's a discharge petition, that's a technical thing. And I just had a meeting of seven or eight senators, Senator Markey, Senator Wyden, Senator Cantwell, people who've been very involved in this issue. We've divided up the heads of the big companies and calling them, we've developed, we're going to do, I'm going to do calls with every New York college newspaper to get them to write about it. We're just starting to rally here and, hey Kara, you got me on your show.
19:04 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's true, that's true. Fair point.
19:06 Speaker 03 And so you think the politics of this work for Democrats?
19:09 Speaker 01 Absolutely. Let me, here, I want to say something interesting here, it's a little broader, but it's related. Our secret weapon. To win back the House and Senate, we got a few, but one of the top ones, probably the top one, is the millennials, the 18 to 35. These are the people who know tech the best. They're gonna be the largest voting cohort this year. I'm a baby boomer. I was born in 1950. My children are the millennials. They're 28 and 32. They're the largest voting cohort. They're overwhelmingly Democratic, all of a sudden. Four reasons I want to mention, okay? And this is very nice. It gives me help. One, we're willing, we're, they think Democrats, oh, let me tell you, Hillary only won millennials by plus seven. In the New
19:53 Speaker 01 Jersey governor race, millennials went by 41 points for the Democratic candidate, in Virginia, 38, and in Alabama, where we won that Senate race, the millennials and the African-American women were our two secret weapons, and we won by 20 points. Millennials in Ala-F Alabama. So, this is a big deal. Why are the millennials so for us? Four reasons in ascending order of importance, and this gives you, gonna give you faith in America. Fourth, college. They want, um, uh, help with all the burden of all these student loans they have. Third, environment, green. These folks are very green. Second, freedom. Net neutrality, decriminalization, legalization of marijuana, the freedom to do what you
20:38 Speaker 01 want, and net neutrality is way up on that list because it gives people freedom to pursue things on the internet without too much cost. But the number one reason, bigger even than net neutrality, and bigger than all the others, is this, and this one came as a surprise to me, the others are sort of intuitive. The younger people hate the bigotry, the smell of discrimination that's coming out of Trump and the Republicans, the anti-women, anti-black, anti-LGBT, anti-Hispanic, anti-immigrant, anti-Muslim. And I thought about it after I learned this, and, very interesting. My wedding, 1980, to my wife.
21:18 Speaker 01 Not a person of color was at our wedding. There were probably gay people, but we didn't know they were gay. They wouldn't tell us in those days. My daughter's wedding, a year and a half ago, was like the United Nations. Not because she was picking and choosing. That's who she went to elementary school with, high school with, college with, works with, has friends with. And what we've learned, Kara, this is so interesting. On the coasts, they would call it bigotry. In the middle of the country, even high school educated kids, women more than men, because they're more sensitive to discrimination, would say, "We don't like the way they're dividing us."
21:50 Speaker 00 Right.
21:51 Speaker 01 And when you think about it, almost every group of friends has a black, has a gay, has women. And when Trump picks on them, and the Republicans pick on them, they tell their friends, "I don't like this." And neither do their white male friends.
22:03 Speaker 00 True.
22:04 Speaker 01 So this is our future.
22:05 Speaker 00 So that's the Netflix and chill tweet.
22:07 Speaker 01 Yeah.
22:08 Speaker 00 That you're, you know...
22:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, that was Netflix and chill, yes.
22:11 Speaker 00 We're gonna get some Netflix and chill and maybe...
22:13 Speaker 01 I didn't know, I wanna tell, confess. I didn't know what chill...
22:16 Speaker 00 You did not know.
22:17 Speaker 01 I knew what chill meant in my generation, which means the opposite of what Netflix and chill means today.
22:22 Speaker 00 In the Me Too moment, let's not go down that road. I'm gonna go down, we could talk about Me Too in a second. I wanna touch on a couple of things.
22:28 Speaker 01 I have a great Me Too story, okay?
22:30 Speaker 00 Oh, all right, go ahead.
22:31 Speaker 01 I've been an advocate of Me Too.
22:32 Speaker 00 But I wanna get to guns, midterm elections, and face the Russian bots.
22:35 Speaker 01 Okay, we will, we will. When Me Too came out, my mom, I haven't told this publicly yet, but I'm gonna do it here. She's 89, okay?
22:43 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
22:44 Speaker 01 She told me, just in October, the following story, after Me Too started. She was 17 years old, it was 1945. She was on the diving board at a camp where she was a counselor. And as parent of one of the kids at the camp, who was a big deal in her neighborhood, he owned jewelry stores, I'm gonna leave out his name even though he's dead now, he grabs her from behind and pushes her into him. She says, "What are you doing, Joe?" She jumps off the diving board, okay? She goes into the changing room, which is an open coed changing room. He comes behind her, takes down the straps of her bathing suit and says, "Turn around, Selma," and she turns around, he's naked.
23:25 Speaker 01 She runs out of the, uh, room, out of the, uh, changing room and goes back up. And she tells, this is the part that really was amazing to me, even worse, or, or as bad as the, the previous part. She told her mother, she told her father, she told her grandma, who she was close to. They said, "Don't tell anyone, they're gonna blame you."
23:49 Speaker 00 Yeah.
23:50 Speaker 01 That was in 1945. Just about every woman-
23:54 Speaker 00 Very common.
23:55 Speaker 01 -has had stories like this, or a friend who has stories like this. And I tried to explain this to my male, um, friends, colleagues, that men just don't understand it because they've never experienced this, but so many women have. And it took the Me Too movement for my mother to tell me this story, uh, whatever it is, 44 years later.
24:17 Speaker 00 God bless her and her voice.
24:18 Speaker 01 Isn't that amazing?
24:19 Speaker 00 Yeah. Yeah, it's not, not surprising to women, I think.
24:23 Speaker 01 Right.
24:24 Speaker 00 I think these, everybody has a story, especially in tech, everywhere, every, every sector. There's not a sector of the US economy that hasn't affected, at work especially, um, and everywhere in their personal lives. We're gonna take another break for a word from our sponsors. We'll return to Hillary Rosen and my conversation with Senator Chuck Schumer after this. You know Katie Couric as the renowned author, journalist, and even guest on this show, Recode Decode. You also know her as a badass, but did you also know that she has her own podcast? It's called Katie Couric, easy to remember. It features candid, unscripted conversations with the biggest names in news, politics, and popular culture. She goes beyond the soundbites to reveal how we got there and what's really going on. It's all unexpected, unconventional, and unbuttoned up, just like Katie Couric is.
25:09 Speaker 00 For people who do not know her, you should listen to this podcast. Listen and subscribe on Stitcher or wherever you get your podcasts.
25:17 Speaker 00 Today's show is brought to you by Synchrony. Ambition lives everywhere. Synchrony believes your ambition isn't something you just look forward to. It's what you work forward to. That's why they partner with businesses to help provide the payment tools and technologies, promotional financing, and retail insights they need. Every day at over 350,000 partner locations, Synchrony helps people and businesses fulfill their unique ambitions, big and small, for themselves and their communities. Because at the end of the day, when customers succeed, businesses succeed. And when we all work together, we can achieve more than we can alone. The only question is, what are you working forward to? Learn more at synchronyfinancial.com. I want to get to regulation of big tech, because one of the things people feel that
26:00 Speaker 00 tech has, especially social media, has become weaponized and coarsened our culture. Obviously, Donald Trump is really talented at Twitter, whether you like it or not. But he's good at it. But a lot of people feel that there needs to be regulation of big tech on lots of issues, from tech addiction to fake news, antitrust, advertising, and transparency. Democrats, which used to be the supporters of tech, are now much more negative on it. Do you feel that way? Or do you feel that the regulation's necessary?
26:30 Speaker 01 I think it's a very difficult question. First, let me say this. The people who most want to undo tech is the hard right. Donald Trump and the hard right do not like anything stated against them. They all watch Fox News, which is totally biased. And anytime there's groups that can talk against them, agglomerate against them, they don't like it. The left is mad at tech too, for reasons, but it's not the same. I have no doubt that the hard right and Trump would like to undo tech as much as they could, even though he uses Twitter. Now, a broader issue. So tech is, for a decade, tech was a great, great thing.
27:14 Speaker 01 It allowed people to agglomerate. It allowed people who had no power, who didn't own a newspaper, who didn't own a TV station, who didn't have a megaphone, to get together and have power. We would not have the guns movement. I have some optimism on guns, but only because online, we're gonna have, you know, right now, they're plant, how did, they have five million people they hope to get in Washington on the 24th, you know, on the anti, you know, the end of the, against the internet.
27:40 Speaker 03 The march, the gun march.
27:41 Speaker 01 Wouldn't have happened without the net, and without a big, broad, powerful internet. That's true on immigration, that's true on the issues. We Democrats represent average folks. Tech gives us the advantage. We don't have a Fox News. We don't have Rush Limbaugh, who gets 20 million people a day. It's our antidote. So I am sympathetic. Now, because it's so open and so free, lots of dark forces have taken advantage. And I certainly think tech has to modulate itself. I mean, one easy example for us in politics, all ads should have to be made public. Who's paying for the ads when they're political ads? Just like you have to do on television or radio. And I don't know why big tech resists that.
28:23 Speaker 03 The Warner Klobuchar.
28:24 Speaker 01 It's the Warner Klobuchar legislation. And there are probably other changes, but I think you have to be careful. Government regulation of speech is a frightening thing, and often has a bigger downside than upside. So I approach the issue with care, maybe more so than some of my colleagues who would have similar politics to me.
28:44 Speaker 03 So some of the, um, uh, regulation of tech in the FCC net neutrality order ended up going over to the FTC. What they said was the FTC should be more active in antitrust and in consumer protection. And now, uh, the Senate is going to...
29:00 Speaker 01 Consumer protection, I'm all for. That's a different issue than regulating speech. That's the worry I have here. And we probably, given tech is so new, we probably have to look at it, but we ought to approach it with caution.
29:11 Speaker 03 So do you think the FTC should do more on...
29:14 Speaker 01 I'd have to study it a little more. I'd, um, any Trump-appointed agency, I'm dubious of.
29:21 Speaker 00 So what about the responsibility of tech? I mean, Facebook, Twitter, others being used by Russia. How do you, you know, and Hillary Clinton, we interviewed her last year at the Code Conference, talked a lot about this, a lot of people made fun of her at the time.
29:34 Speaker 01 Yes.
29:35 Speaker 00 How do you come down right now and what should these tech companies do?
29:38 Speaker 01 I think they should do more on their own, for sure. That's the antidote to government regulation and also the antidote to a lot of this stuff. Now, you know, they've had some successes. Facebook took off 50,000 fake accounts before the French election and it was relatively free. And I've talked to the leaders of Facebook, Twitter, Google about this. And I've told them, make efforts to figure out how to deal with this issue without doing too much impinging on free speech, or so, or the government's going to come in and change you and that will not be good. I think they get it and their first big test will be the 2018 elections. I don't think the Trump administration will do a thing.
30:22 Speaker 01 The amount the Trump administration is doing against Russia is appallingly zero, almost.
30:27 Speaker 00 Right.
30:28 Speaker 01 So it's up to tech to do more. And I do think they're making an effort, not only because it's the right thing to do, but because I think they know down the road their survival depends on it.
30:40 Speaker 00 So that is the test, then, is the midterms, that you think that nothing's going to happen in Congress or in regulation before the midterms?
30:47 Speaker 01 No, with these guys, no.
30:48 Speaker 00 And so tech is essentially on the hook to make sure the election feels fair.
30:53 Speaker 01 Yes, I think tech has to make sure, I mean, for instance, they should knock out all these fake accounts. They're already, I forgot the word, but downgrading things they think are fake, so it comes up less on your, on Twitter, less on your Facebook news feed, if they think, you know, if you got, the Russians, let's say they have 50 websites and they all do the same thing, and first they're talking about this and then an hour later they're all talking about that, that's suspect.
31:22 Speaker 00 Pretty good sign.
31:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's a pretty good sign. They should look in that, maybe they can't shut them down, but they can so downgrade them so it's only one rather than 50 people bouncing around the same message, that it goes way down on their list.
31:35 Speaker 00 Do you see Facebook as a media company?
31:39 Speaker 01 Well, it's everything. You know, Facebook's a very powerful force. I think overall it's been a very positive force. I think now people are taking advantage of the openness of the net. And Facebook has an obligation to try and deal with it. I think they, I've talked to them. I truly believe they want to. I truly believe they know that their future is at stake with this. I also believe it's a hard thing to do, and here's another thing I worry about. They tried to do a certain things in the past and the hard right went and criticized them. Because much of this, the left does very little of this. I mean, we don't use bots the way the Russians would, or the hard right people would. And we, meaning the left, not me. But, um, so I think when they do that, the hard right criticizes them.
32:24 Speaker 01 They're gonna have to be a little more immune to that criticism.
32:27 Speaker 00 Yeah.
32:28 Speaker 01 And go after the fake stuff and separate it from the legitimate stuff, even if it's, you know, a little bit crazy what legitimate people are saying and doing.
32:36 Speaker 00 But do you, when you, when you talk about this power, you're pretty kind to the tech companies. A lot of people are less.
32:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, I am more sympathetic because I think they're in a very difficult position. And I worry about government regulation.
32:49 Speaker 00 All right, but what about the power that they have and what's coming down the pike? Automation, robotics, AI, all these very important technologies could make them more powerful than ever, almost like nation-states themselves. Does that worry you at all?
33:03 Speaker 01 Well, it's something I'm concerned about, yes. Do I know what the consequences are, let alone the solutions? No.
33:10 Speaker 03 And to Kara's point, we've spent a lot of time talking about how companies, other than sort of online communications companies, but companies like Amazon, and what they're doing to communities and retail and the like.
33:22 Speaker 01 There's another one. Now, Amazon does great things for huge amounts of people. And they only have 3% to 4% of the retail market. Could it get, you know, greater? Yes. But again, I'd be careful. I'd be careful because they are creating cheaper, better competition. People get better goods, cheaper goods.
33:44 Speaker 01 I guess my feelings are a little more nuanced. Yes, they're big, but big can do good things as well as bad things. And you've got to separate the wheat from the chaff. Would the world be a better place or worse place if there were no Amazon right now? My guess is a worse place. And yet, there is a lot of problems, for sure.
34:03 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, but you don't see a Microsoft monopoly trial in any of the future of these companies? Or maybe?
34:10 Speaker 01 I thought when Microsoft was a big monopoly and I thought they were much more rapacious, I fought them. Back in the 90s, they didn't talk to me for 10 years.
34:20 Speaker 00 But you're not seeing that right now.
34:21 Speaker 01 I am not seeing the same thing. I go to my small tech companies and say, how does Google treat you in New York? And a lot of them say, you know, much more fairly than we would have thought.
34:30 Speaker 00 Not Yelp, not Yelp.
34:32 Speaker 01 No, Yelp, I've talked to Jeremy Stoppelman. He does not feel that way. I have.
34:37 Speaker 00 No, so just one more question for me.
34:38 Speaker 01 But Kara, it's more mixed. It's more mixed in terms of the.
34:41 Speaker 00 I agree with you, I agree with you. There's too many of them, there's lots of them. So I'm just curious, Hillary's going to ask you a question, I think, about where you see the midterm elections going and what you'll do if you're the majority leader. But I'd like to know, how do you involve yourself in tech? One of your daughters works in tech. Are you a techie? Would you call yourself that?
34:57 Speaker 01 No, I am, I loved, I am interested in it. I read every article about it, but I am not a techie. In fact, I'll tell you a funny story. I'm well-known for my flip phone. I don't have an iPhone. Because my chief of staff, Mike Lynch, in 2004 said, you know what? You know, someone's going to hack into this down the road. And you'll say on your phone, oh, Senator so-and-so, what a moron. And that'll be the end. So I use my cellphone. And I actually, maybe I'm old-fashioned.
35:33 Speaker 00 So you don't text either?
35:34 Speaker 01 I don't do texting. I get emails on my iPad. I get emails, but I don't text. I've never, I don't even know how to do it. I'm backward that way. But Putin is not listening in to me, Kara. He can't.
35:48 Speaker 00 No, you're not, you're not Snapchatting then, I'm guessing, right?
35:51 Speaker 01 Correct, correct.
35:52 Speaker 00 Correct, nothing, none of it. You could use Signal, you could, there's a thing called Signal.
35:56 Speaker 01 They will, they will figure out to capture your instantaneous Snapchats down the road or Signal or anything else.
36:04 Speaker 03 Communicate the old-fashioned way.
36:05 Speaker 01 Old-fashioned. I like people. I like to talk to people. I sit on an airplane. I ask the person sitting next to me their life's history. Wouldn't be the same if we did it online.
36:16 Speaker 00 Okay. All right. Hillary, why don't you ask the election question, then we'll let the senator go.
36:20 Speaker 03 Two quick questions. Lightning round, then. When does the presidential campaign start, by the way?
36:25 Speaker 01 It shouldn't start till 2019. And my attitude, "who, who, who?" people ask.
36:30 Speaker 03 Yeah.
36:30 Speaker 01 Let a thousand flowers bloom.
36:32 Speaker 03 Yeah.
36:32 Speaker 01 Let there be lots of candidates all over the lot and let them go through the crucible of the first year, year and a half. Now, the one thing I'd say is we shouldn't beat the daylights out of each other. We have a far greater enemy than Donald Trump. Politically speaking, he's the enemy.
36:47 Speaker 03 That's some advice Democrats are not yet taking from you.
36:50 Speaker 01 No, and I think the difference between a mainstream Democrat and a far-left Democrat is about 2% of the difference between either of them and Donald Trump. We have an emergency here. And we've got to keep our eye on what we have to do, which is beat Trump. Now, on 2018, you preempted your question. I think we can take back the House and the Senate. Why? The millennials I mentioned. Second, Democrats are getting much better. This is a tech issue. As we all know, Donald Trump did a better job on the social media than we did. We have learned to do it. We are getting advice from some of the biggest, the best, smartest people in tech.
37:32 Speaker 01 A lot of them are very comfortable. You know, they made money and they're working for us full-time. And in Alabama, our social media helped turn out millennials. Our social media and learning how to do turnout, especially in the African-American community, where the first time it wasn't a bunch of white guys telling the blacks how to turn out, but we had indigenous people running the whole show. So millennial turnout and African-American turnout was higher than in 2016, but also higher than 2008 and 12. So we're using social media really well. We're going to kick the pants off the Republicans on social media. And you also have swing voters. I'm going to conclude by giving you one little vignette here.
38:15 Speaker 01 So we looked at our five most Republican states where we have Democratic senators. Montana, North Dakota, Indiana, Missouri, West Virginia. We took out the people who always vote Republican, always vote Democrat, but looked at the broad middle, about 60%. And here was the key question. These are Republican states. Do you prefer a Republican senator who would help Donald Trump pass his agenda on jobs and the economy? That's his strong suit. Or a Democratic senator who will serve as a check and balance on Donald Trump whenever appropriate? 72% check and balance. 20% of the people who identified themselves as strong Trump supporters still want to check and balance. People want a check and balance on Trump.
38:56 Speaker 01 And we are now ahead on our polling in all 10 Senate races where Democrats are running in states that Trump carried. We're ahead in three of the challenger states. And I'll tell you this, if we take back the Senate, when I have the right to put things on the floor, we can stop Donald Trump from doing bad things and we can actually start doing some really good things. So it's a, it's an imperative.
39:21 Speaker 03 So even though voters generally like the tax cuts, they generally actually like a president who's fighting for them on trade, as sloppy as he's been this week, you think that the check and balance is the message?
39:37 Speaker 01 They are, people are, swing voters, suburban voters, women voters, people of color. But just lots of folks are worried about Trump and want a check and balance. Some of them like Trump but still want a check and balance. Many of them don't like Trump. And my prediction, now that his tax bill has been, you know, the first month he got a big boost on that tax bill. Why? They had just passed it. He had all these companies announcing bonuses and the stock market went way up. All three are gone. A, it's no longer just announced and Trump has screwed up on so many things between then and now. Second, people are realizing three things. One, that 80% of the benefits went to the wealthiest permanently while their benefits
40:21 Speaker 01 are smaller and temporary. Second, that there's a huge deficit. And third, they're using that deficit to cut healthcare, Medicare, Medicaid. We've done, you know, the Koch brothers with their huge money machine, put ads against McCaskill in Missouri and Donnelly in Indiana. The Senate super PAC answered back. They, on taxes, they put ads on taxes. We answered back with the answer I told you. We won the argument.
40:47 Speaker 03 Yep.
40:48 Speaker 01 The tax issue is not going to be the panacea the Republicans think it is.
40:52 Speaker 00 Can I ask one final question?
40:54 Speaker 01 You know what's a bigger issue to people? Healthcare costs than taxes. Healthcare costs.
40:59 Speaker 03 Right.
41:00 Speaker 00 And now Trump. But being anti Donald Trump, is that, does that work? Because it doesn't seem to. There's almost, you know, no matter what level he goes to.
41:07 Speaker 03 Well, does it? If you're a senator in a, in a state, I think Kara's asking, if you're a senator in a state, a Democrat in a state that Donald Trump won, are you running against Donald Trump?
41:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, you are in terms of check and balance and saying, when I disagree with Trump, I will fight him. When I agree with him, I'm not going to just go against him for its own sake.
41:25 Speaker 03 Yep.
41:26 Speaker 01 But in reference to the question that Kara asked, 2018 election with Trump at 40%, that's a huge advantage for us. But that doesn't mean we can't have our own positive program and we, we will be, we have some of it and we're going to have more. We just announced an infrastructure program, a trillion dollars of real jobs. You know what we did? We took the tax cuts on the rich, some of them, a trillion dollars worth and put it into infrastructure. What do people prefer? Tax cuts on the wealthiest people and biggest corporations or millions of middle-class jobs on infrastructure? We're going to, in that bill, we propose something that's going to really help us in rural areas. You know, in the 1930s, Franklin Roosevelt said every rural home should get electricity. It was a necessity.
42:08 Speaker 01 We say in the 21st century, every rural home should get broadband, you know.
42:13 Speaker 03 Right.
42:14 Speaker 01 High-speed internet. Right now, a third of all rural homes have almost none.
42:19 Speaker 00 Yep.
42:20 Speaker 01 We will propose it. We're proposing a job training program like the apprentice program in Germany where people can get good paying jobs after a company gets a tax incentive to train them. We realize that in 2016, Democrats did not focus positively enough on people. We are. But remember, fighting Trump is also going to be very important. You need both.
42:44 Speaker 00 Right. All right. Perfect. Senator Schumer, this has been great. I like all your stories and I wish you would tweet, honestly. You can't on your flip phone, but it would be nice.
42:53 Speaker 01 I've tried to make a deal with Donald Trump. You don't tweet, I won't tweet.
42:56 Speaker 00 Right. Yeah, he likes to tweet. He's tweeting, but he doesn't seem to do the same at taxes.
43:01 Speaker 01 Tweeting is doing him more harm than good.
43:03 Speaker 00 I don't know. I don't know. He's good at it, I'll tell you that.
43:06 Speaker 01 He's good. No, you see, you sound like Donald Trump. I tell him this. It's good for his 35%. It turns off 65%. We're upset because even 35% would go for him. But, you know, take your blessings.
43:20 Speaker 00 All right. Well, thank you so much. It was great talking to you and Hillary Rosen, who was also on as my co-host. Thank you so much and thank you for coming on the show. I'm sure we'll be talking a lot more.
43:29 Speaker 01 Hey, make sure you write and call, email your senators on net neutrality, audience.
43:33 Speaker 00 I've already done it. I've already done it.
43:35 Speaker 01 Good. Thank you.
43:36 Speaker 00 While I'm sitting here. All right. Thank you so much, Senator. Thanks again to Hillary Rosen for co-hosting this episode with me. Special thanks to Rachel London for recording Hillary and Senator Schumer in Washington. If you enjoyed the interview as much as I did, be sure to subscribe to the show. You can find all our past interviews in whatever app you use to listen to this or on our website, recode.net/podcasts. And if you have a minute, please leave us a review on Apple Podcasts. That helps other people find the show. Now that you're done with this, you should check out our other Recode Radio podcasts. On Recode Media with Peter Kafka, you'll hear no-nonsense interviews with some of the smartest people in media and entertainment. I also host Too Embarrassed to Ask along with Lauren Good of The Verge, where we answer all of your questions about consumer tech. And on Recode Replay, you can find audio from all of Recode's live events, including
44:21 Speaker 00 the Code Conference and Code Media. Thanks for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. Thanks to our editor, Joel Robby, and our producer, Eric Johnson. I'll be back here on Wednesday. Tune in then.
Previous Recode Decode: Facebook’s Sheryl Sandberg on techlash and #MeToo (Live) Next Recode Decode: Facebook co-founder Chris Hughes Page updated October 16, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated